Could Jon have warged into someone else and then have been glamored by Mel? Seemingly getting stabbed, seeming resurrected, but not really.

I’m pretty sure Voldemort put a curse on the castle when he was refused the job of running it.

Bennifer and the holy 100

What about Roose Bolton?

"A great friendship forged in orc butchery." As all the best friendships are.

Either way, the way they were outnumbered by the orcs, both Gimli and Legolas should have had higher numbers.

The wall of Helm's Deep was carrying Legolas hard and Saruman knew it. If we gave Gimli enough time he would have killed every orc in the castle.

I love ASOIAF, but we haven't had LOTR or Tolkien focused livestreams in about 4 months. It would be nice to have some soon. I appreciate everything you do!!

The thing I never really understood, was there looked to be thousands or orcs, yet if legolas and Gimli both slayed the most, you'd think their counts to be higher.

"The moral victory" 😬 eek. Gives me an unfortunate reminder of sooner extremely bad sportsmanship from the English cricket team and its fans. That's the only time I've heard the phrase used recently

I’ve always enjoyed your voice. I love how passionate you are about GoT ❤️

Thank you, Robert.

Great video!

We are never getting the winds of winter, you need to realize the truth and face the facts were never never never getting the ending to this.😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

Thanks IDG

The WOWinter is Done! He is working on A Dream of Spring you saps🧐

Love your stuff

The eagles, as well as the wizard and your videos, are never late nor early. They arrive when they are meant to.

N + A = J One day GRRM will bd like dam you giys really over thought it but guys..I told you..Nit one , not 2x several times. It was no red herring. Jon is Neds Son.

My Theory? There is no water on Namek because Robert Baratheon, Protector of the Realm and so fort drank it all. That caused the downfall of the greens.

So GRRM says Bran will be King but will he be a good King….???

Should have brought a Kleenex or more…..

I’m curious how Dany is going to control the Dothraki when they get to Westeros they just like to kill and will the north keep their independence and be 6+1 vs 7 …..??

I wonder if Jane Westerling would try to cause trouble for those who set up the Red Wedding by purposely / secretly getting pregnant while on the road.

I think the Maesters will go after the weirwood network as soon as they know it's "active'. Surprised they haven't gone for it already...

Wow, I love your videos. Hope you're feeling better. Lots of good wishes to you and Dan (the dog) from Brazil❣️

21:19 I found very interesting symbolic connection between some French acting school! I dont remember the name but Essentially you start off with a mask and the final phase is a clown nose! Which is said to be the hardest to embodie someone else. When Arya is serving drinks at the meeting the tiny variation of the changes to the peoples faces, are essentially phases in this schools syllabus! I recommend checking it out! I would also recommend researching Golden Chalice Roses! The lore behind it amongs native americans describes the story pretty well. I found one lore site that was way detailed years ago, but i havent been able to find it again. The sites i have find since have similar ties to the story! They do not fit as precisely though. The tyrell rose is golden and sounds similar growing all over walls and stuff, Arlon of Penny tree has a winged golden chalice as his sigil, joffery is poisioned from drinking from a golden chalice! Its very interesting! The one thing i found interesting speaking of flowers, I started researching the different flowers in the story because of Chett. He talks about spending an entire day looking for different flowers, and it didnt make sense to me. After looking into all these flowers it seems like Chett was bringing this girl flowers that would allow her to abort a child! So essentially she risk nothing sleeping with him, and hey shes already slept with everyone, so now she has no exuse in his mind. Or maybe even it was a requirement to bed her. This is why he gets so enraged and kills her, because she still wont sleep with him. So all the known flowers aside from many non existent flowers, the ones that do exist in the story and in our world are connected to contraception essentially abortive agents, bith in universe and out of universe lore. Anywho in the lore one of the flowers it gives people dreams and brings on strong northern winds. I am curious what you think about Chett being the one that buried the dragon glass cache! Its hard to catch because of the gape in when we get the information. But chett and his cronies weeks before the attack at the fist of the first men have cached food, weapons, and supplies. Chett panics when it begins to snow because he fears they wont find the caches! What are the chances someone else with a new Nights Watch cloak is burrying caches of things around the first around the time chett and his group are also doing this! Its very possible being maester Amons Steward that he heard Amon talk about dragon glass and found a cache of the stuff at castle black and brought it with! Maester Luwin has a bunch of dragon glass arrowheads. He gives some to Bran and Rickon. It doesnt really make sense that he do this besides to show us maesters have this, and to talk of the children and magic. Bran and Rickon dont have these later so it seems pointless they be given this. Chett seems much more likely to be the culprit!

Do you think Jon will dream after he’s resurrected??? Prolly not right, as he won’t need sleep…

I think Jon's name will turn out to be Jahearys

Allar Deem is the Hooded man

Could gold will be their crowns refer to their hair colour rather than kingship?

@IDGlive 3.5hrs on a sore throat 😳 thanks so much for your efforts, hope you have a good rest through the remainder of the week!!🍻

When this story is over I'd love to see it end with a private meeting of the new power structure, King and chief house lords etc being revealed to all be faceless men wearimg the faces of their respective counterparts. That would be a cool way to end it in a nefarious way.

I have so many thoughts about Jon's name but I think there is one option more likely than Aegon, which is Aemon after Aemon the Dragon Knight, who we hear about weirdly frequently and who was almost certainly one of Lyanna's favourite stories growing up. And of course the show couldnt use that since it didnt mention him and naming him after Maester Aemon wouldnt be plausible. Also, this is super important to me: Viserys IS NOT the male form of Visenya. The female form of Viserys is Viserra (a name used for one of Jaehaerys 1's daughters). And frankly I dont buy that Lyanna would know the male form of Visenya regardless of what it is.

Thank you, Robert. I needed a longer video to play when I do yoga. Incredibly relaxing 👌

Omg lol your face is so different than what I imagine while I’m drifting off to sleep….😂

Sad part is we are never getting the winds of winter. After everything I have put into this and nothing is every going to be finished.

Daario is Euron

Would be wild if Jon's issue is resolved through Dalla's POV... and if she dies, it could be via this chapter. Mel's already been used before so I can see her being the Wall's POV, but I also think GRRM will want to be careful about how much he directly deals with magic; having Mel as the POV complicates it somewhat, but anyone else makes it a lot easier. I too can't wait to see how some of the theories and logical character arcs get turned upside down a bit.

"Frey comeuppance" - did IDG just coin new fandom lingo? I'm here for it! 🥧

Craster is def in the Targaryen bloodline. He’s Bloodraven’s son. So are his 100 sons that are turned into The Others. Meaning so is Gilly and “Little Sam”

Robert, you're a scholar and a gentleman. Thank you for keeping the glass candles burning

AegonVibes, AegonVibes Bless my homeland forever

The Stark family sword, Ice, was made for a literal giant.

Sorry I missed this one! I watch now!

Nooooo, I thought I was on time! Nvm, I'll watch it now. Thank you, Robert!

Wacky Theory: Euron wrote the Pink Letter. Proof: 1. Euron is very versed in magic and can definitely of heard of the Azor Ahai prophecy. If Melisandre can see Jon Snow in the visions then it’s safe to say other magic users can as well. 2. Euron believes Jon is Azor Ahai, a rival that can stop him from mantling the title or someone that can stop his Dark Apotheosis into Godhood. 3. Euron learns about Jon through spying with Mormont’s Crow. 4. He simply writes the Pink letter or magically influences Ramsay to write it playing into all of Jon’s Insecurities. 5. Jon is killed, problem solved for Euron and now he is free to do whatever evil scheme he wants. This can probably be easily disproved by more knowledgeable Loremasters so let me know! :)

I tried the interesting nerd club. They certainly think they're funny.

Daenerys was certainly the Saruman in the TV shows Unless GRRM withheld information from HBO or intends to change the ending that’s probably where the books are going too.

Eldric Stoneskin is my favorite underrated ASOIAF KZbin theorist