About how much $$ did you spend in just the plants?

Love the video!!

With more co2 you also need more light for the plants to use it. If the light on the two tanks was the same, its not a good comparison. Also co2 should stop when the light is off.

Hi these maybe a stupid question can i ask the reason why you add fish food in the tank?

I've recently started using co2 after decades of aquarium keeping. I've found that it makes a huge difference in a tank with a gravel or sand substrate. The difference might be less noticeable in a tank with aquasoil or dirt substrate. I'm using an inexpensive DIY system on my 29 gallon but plan to add a pressurized system on a planned 70 gallon "dream" tank.

Your algae issue is from too much nutrients. Fish food plus fertiliser every day is too much.

3 male 1 female very unfair

Give honest answer about fertilizer. Which liquid fertilizer you used coz in whole video you secretly hide it.

The red sand on gunny sack that you sieve it's soft red lava rock sand is'nt? So what all the substrat that you used to on this tank? Black Red? I just so confused...😢

How your sp.red mini not growing faster than red cabomba? My lidwigia all var. Always grow up so fast! 🙄

I would say the rotala in the tank without co2 is turning red because of less algae so clearer water meaning more light.

Thanks for playing real music instead of the usual computer generated rubbish for deaf ears. Thanks again for displaying what can be achieved beyond any mainsteam way of thinking. And yep fish, snails and shrimp produce CO2 and minerals (by ways of bacterial breakdown) which can support survival of plants in this particular set-up. Gas exchange is bad for plants you are telling us here. But you are using a skimmer and a strong fan which agitate the water surface heavily whereby you kind of contradict yourself and your claim. I suppose you need to explain what exactly you mean by gas exchange.

Red plants won’t stay red in non co2 .. this is pure KZbin gimmick video.

Size of your tank?

What type of filter did you use?

That was beautiful to watch. Thank you.

Thanks for the video. It took a lot of effort to do this for us.

Great video for beginners like me. One question comes is, do we need a water heater to maintain a proper temperature? Please reply. Thanks a lot 👍🏻

Nanti tumbuh algae

Untuk pakan ikannya pakai apa ya kok cair...?

looks neat, but these animals like to dig in Soil...

I think the usage of ferts so quickly is the reason the algae came. The substrate has plenty of nutrients for weeks, mayby months. I would fert when i see the plants ask for it.

It's worth it if you have the means, time and money for CO2. But if not, just be diligent in maintaining and fertilizing your tank. It also depends on the types of plants you have. If you plan to keep a tank with high tech and carpeting plants, then you should use CO@, but if you plan on keeping the low tech route then it is not necessary.

It's making water brown... I'm running vermicompost tank for 4 months

Wow great video and I enjoyed the music as well. This gives me hope, as I'm planning on doing my first planted aquarium in the near future, but doing my research first and slowly accumulating the necessary items for it now. Thank you.

is this 5 gallon or 10?

Cut the co2 and all your plants will start to fall better not to get stuck buying co2

Snail name ?

Nice 👍 Video Very Informative ❤from Mumbai 🇮🇳

Back in the mid 70's as a teenager read aquarium magazines & books. now I like to get into the hobby again. but I need to update myself on these new tech aquarium stuff. no such thing as CO2 back then. we even leave water out 24hrs to get rid of chlorine. we used to take natural plants from Bronx River narrows that cut thru BX Zoo & they grow like crazy w/ invisible baby hitchhiking snails that shows up in a few weeks all of sudden. all natural

Hi, amazing video. What is the size of the tank? what is that broad leaf plant at the back on right?

How long do these red claw crab breed live in freshwater?

anjirr baru kepikiran aku trimakasih

Nope. These crabs need a burrowing substrate. You can't keep them on solid rocks only if you want them to live good lives.

Akuarium brp cm tu bg, pake mesin apa

What brand of sand is that?

What plants are used

TÜRKÇE İÇİN Teşeķür ederim.

Türkçe alt yazı için çok teşekkür ederim .Seni takip edip , beyenip paylaşacağım

TÜRKÇE ALT YAZI Koyarsan seni anlayıp paylaşıp izleyebilirim

I am using a similar undergravel filter, though my 10 gallon tower itank only needed two plates! I'm running one lift tube and a box filter for mechanical and chemical filter off one air pump. I hid the lift tube with Anubias, and the box filter with driftwood like you hid your powerhead.

Türkçe alt yazı kullandığın için seni anlayabildim ve abone oldum. Çok güzel açıklamalar Teşekkür ederim.

Mükemmel deneyim Ayrıca TÜRKÇE ALT YAZI Kullandığın içinde çok deşekkür.Seni anlayabildim .Abonen dum .

in all your tank using only diy fertilizer ?

A continuous CO2 test would provide information on how much CO2 is actually in the tank🥴

Nice, clear experimental setup. However, I have the feeling that practically no CO2 is flowing out of the diffuser?

How much time you use the Neo co2 how u stop that in rest time

Great to see crypt parva survives with sand only. Thank you very much for your sharing. I am going to setup the low tech one with only Anubias and Crypt parva. Actually fan takes some part of CO2 out of water.