If it was 1996 he would be like 101

Jack may have seen Jurassice Park

Uncle is the complete opposite of Reds personality and no scars on his face. Why do you all keep reaching when you know there’s nothing there?

Obesity is a modern day problem due to added sugar, processed foods, and other crap that back then they didn’t have access too. Back then people didn’t sit down on their asses as much and had to get up and work. They had to pick up the hay, feed the livestock, they physically had to move at times. And they didn’t eat all the time like we do back in those times.

One article even says he died in a car accident in 1953'.

He is Arthurs dad. After being law man he became criminal and was hanged

Obese people were very uncommon back then

The universe isn’t connected because in rdr New York exists and in gta it’s Libery City

I hope that Red Dead Redemption III explains that he died in the 20s

Chapter 2Horseshoe overlook The mission with uncle That's called uncle You can see a train and you see a dude go on the train and somehow it might be Gavin

My head cannon is that Jack died in 1992. He outlived the entirety of the Van der Linde gang. IDK why.

boy was able to watch Michael Jordan's 3peat !

ngl im all for the suicide theory, he just doesnt have anything to live for

I honestly hate this alternate universe thing. Not to mention what concerns the 3D and HD universes. Just say that everything takes place in the same universe and story. It's a much broader path of opportunities, even if there ends up being a side character in GTA 6 who has the last name Marston and is the most common guy in the game lmao.

I have never heard anyone be mad about the way John looks

He’s a made up character. He didn’t live up to any of those years lol. You guys and your fantasy head canons thinking of all these possibilities of how they lived their entire lives after lol

This is why we need a whole game (RDR3?) About Jack, after red dead 1

There is literally zero evidence for this theory. 99.9% of people who believe it have never even played Revolver, and base their opinion off shitty KZbin videos that did absolutely no research and probably didn’t even play the game themselves, yet act like they’re an authority in regards to RDR lore.

that would be so cool if this gang was based off of a true story!!

Regarding the Suicide theroy I can say that Jack likely would have learned to cope before the time he approached 20. He would have learned that even if those you care about aren't physically with you they are always with you spiritually. I have known people who have experienced this lesson and am grateful for the chance to know them. I have also witnessed the lesson firsthand which is quite a blessing to experience.

All is possible with the proper application and amount of lumbago.

I think he's the Devil. He tells John that he hopes his son grows up to be like him. That would insinuate the anti-Christ.

Landon Rickets in like the 1870's might be the way to go

He Joined WW1/WW2, became a pong master.

Nah my canon is he was depressed for the rest of his life, he finds a shack somewhere around strawberry. To suppress his sadness he is doing alot of literature. He writes his One-hit wonder called "Red Dead" and somewhere around the end of 1950s looking at the pictures of his family, beechers hope, and the gang

Eh, theres the pig farmer brother.

It was written by jack because in the epilogue he had an intrest into writing storys

I hate having a console instead of a pc

Jack's story is probably the saddest out of all of them because he's pretty much the last one to live out of everyone in the gang. He holds the most weight because he lived after everything that happened. Lost everyone he knew and ended up alone which possibly made him cold. It's either he found closure in killing Edgar Ross and moved on to try to better himself or he stood cold hearted and became a bounty hunter for a living. Either way it's pretty damn sad he ended up by himself. Maybe he was smart enough to leave that life behind and took into consideration that Arthur saved him and his parent's lives and arthur wanted them to live a great life and that stuck with a young Jack Marston. He remembers his sacrifice and went onto do way better in his life compared to what he grew up in. He learned from everyone else's mistakes and IF he didn't learn he'd be a fool.

I forgot who but someone said go burn the body cus she snitched

Coach Ryan could you do a video explaining unresolved conflicts leading to the breakup

Crazy Harry Potter reference

Most people would agree only because they are stupid. In the Red Dead universe all the states have their real, original names. In the GTA universe, California is called San Andreas by the 90's. An Easter Egg does not mean they are connected. People are just dumb. There are Easter Eggs of other games in games that are made by a different studio. It's called a homage

i hope there will be a RDR 4 or 5 where we can play young uncle and feel more bad-ass about him. We may not make fun of his lumbago anymore

If you look around Limpany, you can find Leviticus Cornwall Kerosene Oil Barrels (or whatever it’s called.) I’m not sure, but Cornwall could’ve did either a deal with Limpany, or burned down Limpany itself.

Imagine Jason is Jacks grandson. Jason Marston

In 3.5 games, red dead redemption undead nightmare

When he grows up he looks exactly the same

Jack could of been an old side character in Vice City

As i remember correctly the Bigfoot appearing in RDR1 is the same Bigfoot who franklin shot and killed in the strangers and freaks mission in GTA5.That even said the same dialogue as RDR1 bigfoot so yeah it is set in same universe

Its crazy how recent the wild west was jack grew up in the wild west and at the end of his life he could of witnessed the biggie and tupac beef

Uncle is Red Harlow 😂

I've always liked the idea of jack getting a full game of his own and imagining him being mentored by Red Harlow is awesome

If u all go inside the house or the store where Nigel is at the beginning u can find gavin in the bar drinking..unfortunaly I met Gavin before Nigel so i didnt helped him, but u can litterally choose to help Gavin or not..hope to help everyone with this mistery

Jack Marston was alive to hear “one” by Metallica

Dude first of all yo like that was phucking awesome bro excuse me u egar Ross 😮

When I played we never had that conversation, I did have it with captain Vincent

Red was 14 whene his parents died

What is this triage at dawn sounding background audio?

Noooooooooo😢