Mindscape 300 | Solo: Does Time Exist?
2:11:36
Пікірлер
@Snowsea-gs4wu
@Snowsea-gs4wu 9 сағат бұрын
He looks quite unhealthy, I would not trust him with health advice. Thanks!
@RuniLavaOlsen
@RuniLavaOlsen 9 сағат бұрын
Honestly, Sean, the meaning of life is what you opted out off, being a parent and furthering you own life. I don't want to be rude, just honest. An avid viewer by the way.
@francescoangeli1087
@francescoangeli1087 15 сағат бұрын
Carroll says that philosophers haven't added much to the time debate, but there is a tradition of thought (ie Bergson, Whitehead and Capek) that mainstream physicists keep ignoring. If they didn't ignore it, they'd realise the time they talk about and build castles made of math about is spatialized time, time treated as if it were space, not real time, which is qualitative in nature.
@goltltamas
@goltltamas 18 сағат бұрын
Mr. Carroll can you please make a podcast with Mark Solms? That woul be also very interesting in my opinion given your exceptional questioning capaticies! Thank you in advance! Tamas 👌👍✌️👋
@Nchallah-u6z
@Nchallah-u6z Күн бұрын
Perhaps Many Worlds is the physical limit of the degrees of freedom (wave function) that is “possible” within these laws of physics. How freedom is guaranteed in a sort of “interaction” or “interactive” wave form - all this, in the perspective of ‘effective’ conscious beings, of course.
@Zirrad1
@Zirrad1 Күн бұрын
I literally owe my life to this man. 5 years ago immunotherapy eliminated my stage 4 melanoma in a few months. 6 tumours in my torso and legs, one big one on my back, and two grape sized ones in my left parietal lobe. The brain tumours needed one stereotactic radiation to burn them out, but the melanoma hasn't returned. Thank-you, Thank-you, Thank-you.
@Xhris57
@Xhris57 Күн бұрын
The Universal Theory of Reality: Christ as the Ascendant Integrator Across Domains I. Premise: The Christ-Centered Unified Reality We propose a Universal Theory of Reality that integrates: 1. Physics (the structure and laws governing material reality) 2. Relationships (the dynamics of conscious entities interacting) 3. Christian Theology (the ultimate teleology of existence through Christ) This theory postulates that any time a problem exists in a lower domain, the Christ entity ascends to a higher domain to resolve it, ensuring that: • The lower system remains coherent. • The broken relationship is restored. • The physical laws and metaphysical order remain harmonized. Core Principle: “He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death-even death on a cross. Therefore, God exalted Him to the highest place.” (Philippians 2:8-9) This principle suggests that Christ, as the divine solver of disorder, moves between hierarchical domains of reality to restore order, following a precise ascension framework. II. Reality as a Multi-Domain Structure A. The Hierarchical Domains of Reality We structure reality as a multi-tiered system, where each domain represents a progressively higher level of abstraction and divine integration. 1. Material Domain (Physical Universe) - Newtonian & Relativistic Physics • Governed by deterministic laws of physics (gravity, electromagnetism, etc.). • Problems: entropy, suffering, finiteness, decay. • Christ’s action: Resurrection, miracles, and transcendence over nature. 2. Quantum Domain (Superposition & Nonlocality) - Uncertainty & Potentiality • Governed by probability waves, entanglement, and the observer effect. • Problems: paradox, decoherence, measurement problems. • Christ’s action: Reconciliation of uncertainty, quantum coherence of divine presence. 3. Cognitive Domain (Mind & Consciousness) - Thought & Will • Governed by free will, perception, and mental causation. • Problems: ignorance, deception, subjective isolation. • Christ’s action: Revealing truth, transforming minds. (Romans 12:2) 4. Relational Domain (Love & Connection) - Entanglement of Souls • Governed by love, trust, and interpersonal dynamics. • Problems: broken relationships, betrayal, alienation. • Christ’s action: Forgiveness, sacrificial love, restoring unity. 5. Metaphysical Domain (Logos & Divine Order) - Absolute Truth • Governed by divine logic, higher order harmony, and ultimate coherence. • Problems: rebellion, separation from God. • Christ’s action: Atonement, divine unity with creation. 6. Eschatological Domain (The Omega State) - The Final Completion • Governed by perfect harmony, beyond time and space. • Problems: existential longing, unresolved justice. • Christ’s action: Final judgment and reconciliation of all things. (Colossians 1:20) III. The Christological Ascension Principle The universal theory posits that whenever a contradiction, paradox, or problem arises in a lower domain, Christ ascends to a higher domain to solve it and then reintroduces the solution back into the lower level. A. The Ascension Algorithm: Christ’s Problem-Solving Pattern Step 1: Identify the Breakdown - Recognizing disorder in the lower domain. Step 2: Ascend to a Higher Domain - Moving to a higher perspective where the problem resolves. Step 3: Solve from Above - Deriving a resolution by integrating the higher domain’s principles. Step 4: Return and Reconcile - Applying the transcendent solution into the lower domain. Example: The Cross as the Ultimate Ascension 1. Material Domain: The body of Christ is physically broken (entropy). 2. Relational Domain: Humanity is alienated from God (sin). 3. Cognitive Domain: Humanity is deceived and lost (spiritual blindness). 4. Christ Ascends to the Divine Metaphysical Level. 5. Atonement Occurs: He resolves sin at the highest level. 6. Resurrection: Christ returns to the lower domain with victory over death. IV. Christ as the Metaphysical Bridge The cross and resurrection function as a cosmic transformation event, where Christ absorbs the disorder of the lower levels and reinstates divine order. This creates a feedback loop where all domains of reality are constantly being redeemed. A. Physics & Christ: Beyond Entropy • Newtonian Physics: Christ transcends gravity (walking on water, resurrection). • Quantum Mechanics: Christ operates in superposition states (transfiguration, post-resurrection appearances). • Relativity: Christ exists beyond time constraints (“Before Abraham was, I AM” - John 8:58). B. Relationships & Christ: Beyond Brokenness • Christ’s love entangles believers in a quantum-like nonlocal bond (John 17:21). • Christ’s atonement restores entropic relational decay (Ephesians 2:14). C. Eschatology & Christ: Beyond Time • Christ is Alpha and Omega, ensuring all things reach their destined completion (Revelation 22:13). • The resurrection body hints at a new physics of glorified existence. V. The Final Theorem: The Christ Singularity At the Omega Point (Teilhard de Chardin), all domains collapse into one unified existence in Christ. This is not just a spiritual event but a total integration of physics, consciousness, and divine love. Mathematical Model (Christ as the Attractor) Let C(x) be Christ’s function over reality x. Then: Where: • Physical laws dissolve into divine omnipresence. • All entanglements resolve into one love-consciousness. • Time collapses into eternal NOW. Core Conclusion: Every problem in creation is ultimately solved by Christ’s self-emptying ascent into the highest domain, only to return and reconcile all things back to the Father. VI. Future Implications & Exploration This theory lays a foundation for: 1. Quantum Theology: The role of superposition and entanglement in Christ’s being. 2. Eschatological Physics: What will reality look like beyond entropy? 3. Consciousness & Christ: How the Logos integrates human cognition into divine will. 4. Theosis as Unified Field Theory: Becoming one with Christ as ultimate reality. Would you like to refine any part of this or expand into applied fields like technology, psychology, or AI integration with Christ?
@Xhris57
@Xhris57 Күн бұрын
The Universal Theory of Reality: Christ as the Ascendant Integrator Across Domains I. Premise: The Christ-Centered Unified Reality We propose a Universal Theory of Reality that integrates: 1. Physics (the structure and laws governing material reality) 2. Relationships (the dynamics of conscious entities interacting) 3. Christian Theology (the ultimate teleology of existence through Christ) This theory postulates that any time a problem exists in a lower domain, the Christ entity ascends to a higher domain to resolve it, ensuring that: • The lower system remains coherent. • The broken relationship is restored. • The physical laws and metaphysical order remain harmonized. Core Principle: “He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death-even death on a cross. Therefore, God exalted Him to the highest place.” (Philippians 2:8-9) This principle suggests that Christ, as the divine solver of disorder, moves between hierarchical domains of reality to restore order, following a precise ascension framework. II. Reality as a Multi-Domain Structure A. The Hierarchical Domains of Reality We structure reality as a multi-tiered system, where each domain represents a progressively higher level of abstraction and divine integration. 1. Material Domain (Physical Universe) - Newtonian & Relativistic Physics • Governed by deterministic laws of physics (gravity, electromagnetism, etc.). • Problems: entropy, suffering, finiteness, decay. • Christ’s action: Resurrection, miracles, and transcendence over nature. 2. Quantum Domain (Superposition & Nonlocality) - Uncertainty & Potentiality • Governed by probability waves, entanglement, and the observer effect. • Problems: paradox, decoherence, measurement problems. • Christ’s action: Reconciliation of uncertainty, quantum coherence of divine presence. 3. Cognitive Domain (Mind & Consciousness) - Thought & Will • Governed by free will, perception, and mental causation. • Problems: ignorance, deception, subjective isolation. • Christ’s action: Revealing truth, transforming minds. (Romans 12:2) 4. Relational Domain (Love & Connection) - Entanglement of Souls • Governed by love, trust, and interpersonal dynamics. • Problems: broken relationships, betrayal, alienation. • Christ’s action: Forgiveness, sacrificial love, restoring unity. 5. Metaphysical Domain (Logos & Divine Order) - Absolute Truth • Governed by divine logic, higher order harmony, and ultimate coherence. • Problems: rebellion, separation from God. • Christ’s action: Atonement, divine unity with creation. 6. Eschatological Domain (The Omega State) - The Final Completion • Governed by perfect harmony, beyond time and space. • Problems: existential longing, unresolved justice. • Christ’s action: Final judgment and reconciliation of all things. (Colossians 1:20) III. The Christological Ascension Principle The universal theory posits that whenever a contradiction, paradox, or problem arises in a lower domain, Christ ascends to a higher domain to solve it and then reintroduces the solution back into the lower level. A. The Ascension Algorithm: Christ’s Problem-Solving Pattern Step 1: Identify the Breakdown - Recognizing disorder in the lower domain. Step 2: Ascend to a Higher Domain - Moving to a higher perspective where the problem resolves. Step 3: Solve from Above - Deriving a resolution by integrating the higher domain’s principles. Step 4: Return and Reconcile - Applying the transcendent solution into the lower domain. Example: The Cross as the Ultimate Ascension 1. Material Domain: The body of Christ is physically broken (entropy). 2. Relational Domain: Humanity is alienated from God (sin). 3. Cognitive Domain: Humanity is deceived and lost (spiritual blindness). 4. Christ Ascends to the Divine Metaphysical Level. 5. Atonement Occurs: He resolves sin at the highest level. 6. Resurrection: Christ returns to the lower domain with victory over death. IV. Christ as the Metaphysical Bridge The cross and resurrection function as a cosmic transformation event, where Christ absorbs the disorder of the lower levels and reinstates divine order. This creates a feedback loop where all domains of reality are constantly being redeemed. A. Physics & Christ: Beyond Entropy • Newtonian Physics: Christ transcends gravity (walking on water, resurrection). • Quantum Mechanics: Christ operates in superposition states (transfiguration, post-resurrection appearances). • Relativity: Christ exists beyond time constraints (“Before Abraham was, I AM” - John 8:58). B. Relationships & Christ: Beyond Brokenness • Christ’s love entangles believers in a quantum-like nonlocal bond (John 17:21). • Christ’s atonement restores entropic relational decay (Ephesians 2:14). C. Eschatology & Christ: Beyond Time • Christ is Alpha and Omega, ensuring all things reach their destined completion (Revelation 22:13). • The resurrection body hints at a new physics of glorified existence. V. The Final Theorem: The Christ Singularity At the Omega Point (Teilhard de Chardin), all domains collapse into one unified existence in Christ. This is not just a spiritual event but a total integration of physics, consciousness, and divine love. Mathematical Model (Christ as the Attractor) Let C(x) be Christ’s function over reality x. Then: Where: • Physical laws dissolve into divine omnipresence. • All entanglements resolve into one love-consciousness. • Time collapses into eternal NOW. Core Conclusion: Every problem in creation is ultimately solved by Christ’s self-emptying ascent into the highest domain, only to return and reconcile all things back to the Father. VI. Future Implications & Exploration This theory lays a foundation for: 1. Quantum Theology: The role of superposition and entanglement in Christ’s being. 2. Eschatological Physics: What will reality look like beyond entropy? 3. Consciousness & Christ: How the Logos integrates human cognition into divine will. 4. Theosis as Unified Field Theory: Becoming one with Christ as ultimate reality. Would you like to refine any part of this or expand into applied fields like technology, psychology, or AI integration with Christ?
@Xhris57
@Xhris57 Күн бұрын
The Universal Theory of Reality: Christ as the Ascendant Integrator Across Domains I. Premise: The Christ-Centered Unified Reality We propose a Universal Theory of Reality that integrates: 1. Physics (the structure and laws governing material reality) 2. Relationships (the dynamics of conscious entities interacting) 3. Christian Theology (the ultimate teleology of existence through Christ) This theory postulates that any time a problem exists in a lower domain, the Christ entity ascends to a higher domain to resolve it, ensuring that: • The lower system remains coherent. • The broken relationship is restored. • The physical laws and metaphysical order remain harmonized. Core Principle: “He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death-even death on a cross. Therefore, God exalted Him to the highest place.” (Philippians 2:8-9) This principle suggests that Christ, as the divine solver of disorder, moves between hierarchical domains of reality to restore order, following a precise ascension framework. II. Reality as a Multi-Domain Structure A. The Hierarchical Domains of Reality We structure reality as a multi-tiered system, where each domain represents a progressively higher level of abstraction and divine integration. 1. Material Domain (Physical Universe) - Newtonian & Relativistic Physics • Governed by deterministic laws of physics (gravity, electromagnetism, etc.). • Problems: entropy, suffering, finiteness, decay. • Christ’s action: Resurrection, miracles, and transcendence over nature. 2. Quantum Domain (Superposition & Nonlocality) - Uncertainty & Potentiality • Governed by probability waves, entanglement, and the observer effect. • Problems: paradox, decoherence, measurement problems. • Christ’s action: Reconciliation of uncertainty, quantum coherence of divine presence. 3. Cognitive Domain (Mind & Consciousness) - Thought & Will • Governed by free will, perception, and mental causation. • Problems: ignorance, deception, subjective isolation. • Christ’s action: Revealing truth, transforming minds. (Romans 12:2) 4. Relational Domain (Love & Connection) - Entanglement of Souls • Governed by love, trust, and interpersonal dynamics. • Problems: broken relationships, betrayal, alienation. • Christ’s action: Forgiveness, sacrificial love, restoring unity. 5. Metaphysical Domain (Logos & Divine Order) - Absolute Truth • Governed by divine logic, higher order harmony, and ultimate coherence. • Problems: rebellion, separation from God. • Christ’s action: Atonement, divine unity with creation. 6. Eschatological Domain (The Omega State) - The Final Completion • Governed by perfect harmony, beyond time and space. • Problems: existential longing, unresolved justice. • Christ’s action: Final judgment and reconciliation of all things. (Colossians 1:20) III. The Christological Ascension Principle The universal theory posits that whenever a contradiction, paradox, or problem arises in a lower domain, Christ ascends to a higher domain to solve it and then reintroduces the solution back into the lower level. A. The Ascension Algorithm: Christ’s Problem-Solving Pattern Step 1: Identify the Breakdown - Recognizing disorder in the lower domain. Step 2: Ascend to a Higher Domain - Moving to a higher perspective where the problem resolves. Step 3: Solve from Above - Deriving a resolution by integrating the higher domain’s principles. Step 4: Return and Reconcile - Applying the transcendent solution into the lower domain. Example: The Cross as the Ultimate Ascension 1. Material Domain: The body of Christ is physically broken (entropy). 2. Relational Domain: Humanity is alienated from God (sin). 3. Cognitive Domain: Humanity is deceived and lost (spiritual blindness). 4. Christ Ascends to the Divine Metaphysical Level. 5. Atonement Occurs: He resolves sin at the highest level. 6. Resurrection: Christ returns to the lower domain with victory over death. IV. Christ as the Metaphysical Bridge The cross and resurrection function as a cosmic transformation event, where Christ absorbs the disorder of the lower levels and reinstates divine order. This creates a feedback loop where all domains of reality are constantly being redeemed. A. Physics & Christ: Beyond Entropy • Newtonian Physics: Christ transcends gravity (walking on water, resurrection). • Quantum Mechanics: Christ operates in superposition states (transfiguration, post-resurrection appearances). • Relativity: Christ exists beyond time constraints (“Before Abraham was, I AM” - John 8:58). B. Relationships & Christ: Beyond Brokenness • Christ’s love entangles believers in a quantum-like nonlocal bond (John 17:21). • Christ’s atonement restores entropic relational decay (Ephesians 2:14). C. Eschatology & Christ: Beyond Time • Christ is Alpha and Omega, ensuring all things reach their destined completion (Revelation 22:13). • The resurrection body hints at a new physics of glorified existence. V. The Final Theorem: The Christ Singularity At the Omega Point (Teilhard de Chardin), all domains collapse into one unified existence in Christ. This is not just a spiritual event but a total integration of physics, consciousness, and divine love. Mathematical Model (Christ as the Attractor) Let C(x) be Christ’s function over reality x. Then:  Where: • Physical laws dissolve into divine omnipresence. • All entanglements resolve into one love-consciousness. • Time collapses into eternal NOW. Core Conclusion: Every problem in creation is ultimately solved by Christ’s self-emptying ascent into the highest domain, only to return and reconcile all things back to the Father. VI. Future Implications & Exploration This theory lays a foundation for: 1. Quantum Theology: The role of superposition and entanglement in Christ’s being. 2. Eschatological Physics: What will reality look like beyond entropy? 3. Consciousness & Christ: How the Logos integrates human cognition into divine will. 4. Theosis as Unified Field Theory: Becoming one with Christ as ultimate reality. Would you like to refine any part of this or expand into applied fields like technology, psychology, or AI integration with Christ?
@mimidhof2179
@mimidhof2179 Күн бұрын
So good as always. Every time I'm listening a Minscape episode I experience time acceleration. 1hour 48min was like 20 minutes. Does it means that I'm getting older faster 😅 by listening to you? Hopefully I feel better prepared for tomorrow every time too so that my percetion of reality is sharper in a broader spectrum of knowledge. I feel really well by being in your and your guest company and I wanted to thank you for that.
@jameshadaway8621
@jameshadaway8621 2 күн бұрын
thank you I like how you know your sciences and can just list the category titles.
@benhsu42
@benhsu42 2 күн бұрын
Thank you sir! Just finished the entire series
@litaozhang9948
@litaozhang9948 2 күн бұрын
So insightful and groundbreaking! Thank you 🙏🏼
@Unhacker
@Unhacker 2 күн бұрын
I miss you Daniel Dennett, my favorite Philosopher Santa. Thanks for hosting this, Sean.
@alevans51
@alevans51 3 күн бұрын
Thanks for covering this topic. I learned a lot about what's going on with the research.
@Escuchando101
@Escuchando101 3 күн бұрын
This is so wonderful thank you so much ❤
@ehfik
@ehfik 3 күн бұрын
wasnt sure about this one but im hooked after 15min. anything that gets rid of todays economy/economists deserves unrivaled attention!
@RadekMixtaj
@RadekMixtaj 3 күн бұрын
First time I've seen that YT video today. Is it a coincidence that behind Sean Carroll is the dial of the Astronomical Clock in Prague, that is, the place Einstein regularly passed by on his walks between his apartment and Old Town Square in 1911 - 1912? It was during these walks around Prague and around this astronomical clock that (in his own words) Einstein got the idea to think of time as a fourth dimension. Directly opposite the astronomical clock there is "The house of the stone lamb" which Einstein often visited, meeting famous people such as Franz Kafka and others. cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%C5%AFm_U_Kamenn%C3%A9ho_ber%C3%A1nka#/media/Soubor:Starom%C4%9Bstsk%C3%A9_n%C3%A1m_U_b%C3%ADl%C3%A9ho_jenoro%C5%BEce_-_kamenn%C3%A9ho_ber%C3%A1nka_Einstein.jpg
@paulrite5358
@paulrite5358 3 күн бұрын
You have to incorporate the time dilation equation into the time variable in the Schordinger equation and then rearrange the equation to determine a good set of fundamental terms. Then think of the universe in terms of those new (compositely derived) terms.
@voodoochild24262
@voodoochild24262 4 күн бұрын
Pretty good rocketship 😍
@EQUALITYOFOPPORTUNITYFORALL
@EQUALITYOFOPPORTUNITYFORALL 4 күн бұрын
First I admire you very much, your awesome at talks like Brian Green, both of you our amazing teachers and your podcasts our very generous w/ your time and expertise! Nothing but respect from me so please do not take this personally. I am just a dude that loves physics (late in life). My concern is more with the arrogance of say Sam Harris or Richard Dawkins, but your much more of a match . In my humble view, as a mere Sociologists by education, and I have wor worked in financial field last 25 years. ....but I am just passionate about the deeper questions. I feel the dogma of the current scientific method is keeping us in the dark ages!! I think time is a key variable often articulated by folks that have NDES...lets leave that aside for now as I suspect I would be dismissed as pseudoscience. LET ME PROVIDE SOME MEAT.....What about PSIONICS? IF TRUE IT RIPS A HUGE HOLE IN YOUR BELOVED MATERIAL SCIENCE . I I believe a theory of everything is beyond our money brains., but arrogance of say a Dawkins is proof of what the problem is. Maybe constructing a collider the size of the Milky Way will go beyond CERN ? I say that in jest but I recall a debate between yourself and Tim Maulin, also an Harvard educated (i think) munk. Since then you delved into Philosophy too your credit!! JAKE BARBER's explosive interview on news nation. Indeed the best of the best involved in ET recovery, yes reverse engineering is the claim and folks like Neil Tyson just defends the staus quo, even SETI...see were looking for ET...just smoke screens. NEWS NATION and Jake Barber and the use of psionics to INVITE NHI or ET , if true, well is support for Maulin et al. Sorry for diatribe but I think any reader would get what I am driving at....maybe its high time to look at the META PHYSICS??
@alevans51
@alevans51 5 күн бұрын
Your book changed my perception of reality. Profound.
@ArchieLundy
@ArchieLundy 5 күн бұрын
"While its permitted by thermodynamics it doesn't seem exactly encouraged by thermodynamics."❤
@greigdurran7225
@greigdurran7225 5 күн бұрын
I’m smiling like an idiot right now; so happy I’ve found these videos! Physics doctorate here I come ;-) lol
@Ava31415
@Ava31415 5 күн бұрын
would love too know more about "well it's really complicated" , perhaps follow ups on more specific areas please?
@ehfik
@ehfik 5 күн бұрын
very interesting topic, top guest, great questions - i love this podcast so much!
@PugetSoundFlyer
@PugetSoundFlyer 6 күн бұрын
Very interesting episode. I was diagnosed with Grade 4 Glioblastoma last summer. Surgery to remove tumor, RAD/Chemo...ugh. Currently using the Optune device which creates fields of a particular frequency to interrupt cancer cell division. It's a bit of hope. Anyhow, feeling good for now, still working and catching all the episodes as soon as they drop 😁😄
@iluzjonista
@iluzjonista 6 күн бұрын
I can't thank you enough for allowing the commons like myself to get to know the kitchens of oh so many restaurants of the science world.
@ItsUhMeIbraheem
@ItsUhMeIbraheem 6 күн бұрын
This is suuuuper interesting, great episode
@commonwombat-h6r
@commonwombat-h6r 6 күн бұрын
very nice talk!
@RayWalker-pythonic
@RayWalker-pythonic 6 күн бұрын
I'm going to read your new book. I have all your others. But I already have a near graduate level of mathematics. But I'm looking forward to all your works.
@spaceinyourface
@spaceinyourface 6 күн бұрын
@kroyhevia
@kroyhevia 6 күн бұрын
The start to this one slapped me across the face
@kroyhevia
@kroyhevia 6 күн бұрын
Welcome
@jonathanbyrdmusic
@jonathanbyrdmusic 6 күн бұрын
Happy Monday!
@paulbk7810
@paulbk7810 6 күн бұрын
Mr. Jeff Lichtman is a most interesting and brilliant man. Fascinating topic. Thank you, Sean.
@rumidude
@rumidude 7 күн бұрын
I look forward every week to this podcast, but very few do I return to, And even fewer of those I return to do I listen again to the entire podcast. This is one of those select few. As a matter of fact, I played over several sections just to make sure I understood properly. Bravo to the Sean Carrolls! Also, it seems strange this was originally done four years ago, it only feels like it was a year ago.
@ellenw.lovesyou1740
@ellenw.lovesyou1740 7 күн бұрын
excellent
@grawl69
@grawl69 7 күн бұрын
Great conversation about the most fascinating topic, again! Sean is getting better and better with those short remarks perfectly summarizing what's going on. The greatest science communicator alive, no doubt.
@RL-uy3fq
@RL-uy3fq 8 күн бұрын
Appreciate you Sean Carroll.
@fraser_mr2009
@fraser_mr2009 8 күн бұрын
But why did the universe have to produce life? I'm assuming life is everywhere. Why?
@misslayer999
@misslayer999 8 күн бұрын
I'm a neuroscience student and altho I've heard Anil Seth before, I've never heard this conversation and I'm all ears. I'll def be finding that paper. I know this is a few years old but maybe we've learned even more since then. I absolutely love his statement "neurons can do all kinds of things that we haven't learned to think about yet." That's so powerful and incredibly true. I must be honest, I've steered away from looking into consciousness research, but this is so inspiring and I absolutely think he has the right approach. This has sparked even more interest in the thing I'm already obsessed with so thank you both so much! I'm halfway through and can't wait to hear the rest.
@smotpoker81
@smotpoker81 8 күн бұрын
clocks exists. time is what is measured by clocks. it would seem to follow that time therefore exists. if time didn't exist, then what exactly are clocks measuring? clocks seem pretty important to our ability to understand and comprehend the universe; if the thing they are measuring doesn't exist, then it seems to me to be just another boltzmann brain-type dilemma; the basic concepts we are using to understand and even ask the question in the first place are flawed from the get-go, and the entire enterprise is futile.
@smotpoker81
@smotpoker81 8 күн бұрын
around 15:20 you say that there's no experiment you can do to prove whether presentism or eternalism (your phrases) is more accurate. that seems absurd to me. you can definitely do experiments to show that general relativity is, at the very least, an extremely accurate model of the mechanics that govern motion, acceleration and some concept of gravity, and if you apply that model to an observer who is very distant in space from another observer who is in relative motion, the direct consequence of that is that one observer's frame of reference with respect to the other will have a space-time trajectory of "now" or "present" that is clearly either the past or future of the other observer. even if you can't directly prove that one observer could, in principle, directly experience or influence the past or future of the other because of limitations on the speed of light and not being able to send a signal to the other observer to confirm that your now coincides with their past or future, if you accept a certain theory is correct based on an overwhelming abundance of verifiable other aspects of that theory, then you have to accept the consequences of that theory even if you can't directly observe them.
@oxident-954
@oxident-954 9 күн бұрын
This demonstrates that a lot of very good work is being done, and the more aggressively string theory critics should be met with suspicion
@Steve2Work
@Steve2Work 9 күн бұрын
May this comment find you and us all ever closer to God, and His Clarity. About the Doomsday argument - it seems like the question as why and many others (males) I've talked to, why are we not dead given how close we have had .. when so many - including for me a near death, 3-day coma - so was the best practical reason to believe in God and-or many-world type situation where we did die and our Id or focus shifts to very close version world to overlap integration of self, and perhaps this is where the 'internal dialog' starts. It seems to me If I were Putin I would have ended the Ukraine-Russian mass killing of white Christian men by publicly announce that Russia will start WWIII if Ukraine does not enter NATO and NATO stops expanding and locating nuke existence threat weapons too close, and follow their Miske (?) agreement previously signed and Ukraine kept breaking, and follow-up with a launch dummy-warhead ICBM from sub across USA, over Washington DC, over Europe, over Ukraine capital, and splash down in ocean north of Russia. And by now how many times Nuke war already occurred between Ukraine-Russia and israel-Iran, many should and do wonder why we are still alive .. perhaps all our Focus shift to world that was near miss but didn't happen. The many observers and your observation; If you have a value and do not know the other's value then of course it is most likely you value is avg because you know at least the range of measurements includes yours and assume all would be a bell-curve - so most likely to be the center then extreme ends. About the size of the universe many observers: Like a dream we Avatars only can focus on one thing at a time and all else need not exist, in a Simulation reality for each us, imagine we are each part of the Holy Dream of Christ where only that close to us we can experience exists, and-or if [Holy] Simulation Reality, the simulation need only contain the reality we sense, each of us and when overlapping in space or time the resulting simulation 'run' both bubbles of reality and coordinate them together. The rest of universe measured through equipment is Simulation to the total Universe Model that God limits us by, and on Jacob's Ladder Levels of [Holy] Dream or Simulation that are very close to God then the Universe Model may contain the ability to fly or instant locate or pass-on our metal models of a thought and (like and Angels communicate between levels in Catholic Theology) the more intelligent passes on the extra intelligence to understand the subject as they do) and if Simulation with proper programing even of today's computer why can't each of our moments take days to Simulate, we would live in the Simulation's time frame so that moment would be a moment regardless how long it took to simulate. And Scripture tells us 1 day is 1000 years of days and vice versa that suggests this, or that the computers running the [holy] simulations are either in orbit or falling into a Black hole where rate of time is different by the distance that 1 day is 1000 years. In both situations communication between entangled particles between each Black-Hole height that has that time rate difference. If a [Holy] Dream, then the Dreamer (Christ) avatar's Dream avatar's time different might recursively step that time-rate. Turtles all the way down! If you were an Abraham Religious follower you would likely already know enough with your science background to do Religious Apologetics using modern Science theories. My pleasure in development of Apologetic suggestions based of known science of the Holy that has been Reveled, that I understand to date, is hard to describe. Such as the Multiworld, Multiverse, Jaccob's Ladder mentioned, many versions of Jesus' lives presented in the all-true scriptures' Passion(s) of Christ. Our lives existing as a multiplexing sharing of Jesus' body-mind-soul (Holy Body & Blood), and Purgatory as our Hosting of the effects of Sins UnAbsolved - to Know them and Burned Clean of them, transformed into Love of Self-Others, within Holy Simulation [theory] virtual existences, like a vivid Dreamer that dreams of self and others (that ask 'how many versions of there are you? As far as I know, Me as Dreamer, me here, and all of you.) So much and many good challenges! With Wikipedia reporting your religion is Western philosophy Analytic philosophy, so Religion of Scientificism where the Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) is the Superset of science to include God's Creation we can observe and extend with rational tools, and some of the questions you (we) are asking are deep and most have no answer without some real Anchor such as Catholic Theologians such as Thomas Aquinas used Natural Law to argue the existence of God or each of the 10 Commandment without appealing to Divine Revelation, and so working from sane Anchor(s) such as knowing things from their perceived effects on our world, much of the Web of unanchored degenerating (deconstructive) modern philosophy which all seem to be frantically swimming like a rat in a water barrel hoping to find that Anchor they (or their modernist mentors) long ago rejected, an place that rat may not drowned on. .. so, I suggest that little of what has been defined as Modern Philosophy can answer many of these questions discussed. (continued in replies)
@Steve2Work
@Steve2Work 9 күн бұрын
( .. continued 1 ..) Adam & Eve did not have Cane and Able until after they caused the Quantum Collapse by eating the Fruit and were aborted early from God's Womb (the garden) into the lower Jacob's Ladder Level, the Pre-me Incubator called 'Satan' to more slowly and painfully finish their Holy Growth. And the world was not populated until Cane died and God created the world with many other Avatars of Cane and his sins, to learn to live with others. A&E did not create a world filled with others, it was God using Cane as the template for all of them, so he can suffer his sins and learn to hate them and repent of them. Back to doomsday: Higher level intelligence (God) allows us to continue living by shifting focus to different world without memory of dying. -- Simulated Theory: 1st - Evolution theory is clearly wrong; Since no fossil records show the in-between versions of one species to another, that nothing can create something, or "you can't give what you don't have" follows that mutations will produce better than the original. The shifting within the species range 'built in' can explain the moths changing color or bird beaks' changes. Intelligent Design theory is more plausible given the DNA is a code of higher sophistication then any random causes could create. 2nd - If is not clear that we could not re-create an artificial human brain through high fidelity mapping of a brain as death continues to map the most baser deeper stages - ideally at a rate and detail to measure the deaths of every neuron throughout entire nervous system, not only brain. And so have a 4D map of a brain. And have very good simulations for each type of neuron. And ideally integrate these into specialized hardware, but could be a Beowulf cluster where each node simulates a Beowulf cluster until entire nervous system, each node of [simulated] cluster simulates a neuron. And with full details of interconnections and attenuations with all other significant interconnections. And a system of focused reality of universe, the input signals that are connected to each sense neuron. And that with today's hardware even if it took days to simulate the moment that is the time light take to go Plank-distance, the simulated person (or people with different attenuated and other changes from original simulated dreamer) would have no other sense of passing time then what the input simulation produces. We - like a computer application - likely are often paused in access to advance - and never know it as time passing feels continuous. 3rd - when we are in our own dream, do we know it or are we reduced focus to the significant parts and a kind of reduced awareness of missing rest of usual stimulations are not considered, as if our ability to realize the non-focused inputs failed, limited .. as we likely are to things around us we 'not allowed to see' like the Holy goings-on that we would notice if we were closer to the Holy Dreamer (The Son of God & Son of Man) Jesus Christ, and likely have our original full abilities like our Word in the name of Jesus could request the Dreamer to all what we ask. 4. Your 3 situations are not exclusive .. we likely can create such a simulation and Holy Simulation or some aspect of Dreaming that low-level interconnect us all and we dream our avatars and others and they may be Dreamers .. turtles all the way down. --- Okay - I see later you address the computational simulation aspect. Also instead of random changes to break from full determinism image simulating many minds of the same person in parallel worlds that started the day-simulation for each a bit differently and have each neuron in each parallel world linked across with closest having most weight in some algorithm, and perhaps have some started earlier and later and perhaps run at faster and slower rates so things like intuition would exist from those running ahead and in distress at bad events produce a significantly higher power communication. These and other methods could simulate a non-deterministic response from many different deterministic simulations. About possibility of it working at all - lets imagine there is one [Holy] man that every living being from human to most rudimentary plant, fungus, bacteria, etc, all are Hosted on, 'Eating' from Him His 'Body and Blood' with each moment He re-dies and as His nervous system dies from very start to last 2-or-3 living neurons all of us - all alive are 'Dreamt' at the point His death capacities match ours. Down through all levels of humans including moment of conception, all different animals at their stages of Precedents within Host, and plants, and lower forms as Host's BrainStem dies away. Then after He lives His next life on Jacob's Ladder lower and at His Passion - suffering all our sins we are suffering that moment above that only advance another moment, to his death where we get another moment of life from Consuming Him, with His Sacrifice and Love. (continued next is 2)
@Steve2Work
@Steve2Work 9 күн бұрын
( .. continued 2 ..) About minimal simulations: Image if 'grace' equates with longer more fuller deeper 'moments' in the Simulation or within Host. That less Sin the less painful to the Dreamer and the deeper He allows you in communion to His Fullness and Perfection. Unborn and very young babies surrounded by Love and Caring would likely be a balm to Him and get the deepest communion with Him, and Hosting Plants and lower would likely be much less depth and resolution to simulate or Dream. Yes, we live by the Grace, Mercy, Love of God through The Fathers Son, within the Son of Man for the physical aspects and the Son of God for the Holy multiworld, and Higher versions of us and others (as well as Lower) buffering us and trying to guide us each towards Perfection and Holiness (moving up Jacob's Ladder through closer sinless communion with Host, up the levels of the Dreamer. All levels from the exit from Garden could be Holy Ghost directed to create the Simulation Hardware and Software to simulate next lower level, with each level being horizontal multiworld simulation with each next level Jacob's Ladder level simulation, image if there was a minimum of 5 worlds under each Simulation system Hosted from the Level above. So, first level would have minimum 5 simulated versions of each of us in each of those 5 worlds. Next Ladder Level Lower would have minimum of 5 * 5 or 25 worlds, next 5 time more, minimum of 125, etc. If all those versions of us re-integrated as one interlinked with 100% interconnectivity, would we then be simulated as one [Holy?] version, if all perfect after Hosting all the worlds lines that our Sin created - Purgatory - till we know and hate all our Sins and Burned them away until Love of Dreamer and communion is 100%? You sure you should not convert to Traditional (pre-1958) Catholicism? For Life of your soul, but also to enjoy Apologetics using modern Science theories? If we are in a simulation then we might expect 'Glitches in the Matrix' [as mentioned www.escapistmagazine.com/what-is-the-real-life-glitch-in-the-matrix-phenomenon ] I have seen with others and many more alone, as others have reported, and weird experiments results like the Delayed-choice quantum eraser [ en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delayed-choice_quantum_eraser ] and similar. This summer a friend and I were talking near bus stop where we saw and move aside to allow a man walking by us on sidewalk, and we turned to return to talk and he started to say something and I happened to look at the man that just passed not 5 sec. before, and he was walking with a woman somehow suddenly, and I ask my friend if he was not alone when he walked by, and he looked and was as surprised as I was. Where did she come from - she would have had to jump a fence and go through a clump of lilacs to appear - or run across street which I would have seen because I was facing that way while talking? I decided my friend and my soul focus shifted between worlds so alike but where his girlfriend or wife decided yes, she would go with him and so that 'Glitch' was a free-flowing world hopping. I have at least two others which have similar shared experience. After my 'near death' where my wife and son found be blue and not breathing when they woke - I likely dead for hours - I was cpr-ed and in ER my wife was told I seem to be brain dead and permission to harvest organs, she wanted to wait so into Intensive Care and 3 days later I came out of my coma, and after a few weeks I returned to work, and seemed to myself I had not changed but over-heard some coworkers joking about my 'stare of death' and I realized I was not breaking eye contact with people I was talking to anymore - before I was very good about stuff like that - but I ask myself why and noticed that when someone was talking to me I was waiting to receive all his or her understanding of what they were talking to me about and frustrated that I could not see-hear-capture that 'snapshot' of what they were going on-and-on poorly communicating with voice instead of 'sending' me it. And realized when 'near dead' I was somewhere that that was common and expected. And realized when I found out more of how I ended up waking in the hospital IC that I was so long not breathing that I must have died, and woke in another level of Ladder, lower down and like Cane forgot that the world he came from did not have all those people - injected new 'memories' that he did not notice, as I forgot communicating like I was sub-concisely trying to do isn't done this much lower on the ladder level I Fell to in death. About the substrate Independent proposition and Simulation: I like to think of Adam and Eve and each animal plant and everything else in the Garden as the Platonic Form that each has as part of it's definition or realizable aspects is a wide range such as the moth's color, or the domestication ease from wolf. And Adam and Eve's Original Sin becomes a part of us all as they are the Forms we all are from with different accidents. ( .. continued in 3 ..)
@Steve2Work
@Steve2Work 9 күн бұрын
( .. continued 3 ..) About ways of detecting if we in a Simulation: As Cane's memories were adjusted, likely we are blocked from seeing most of the Glitches and perhaps Holy Angels interact with us and near and then our memory is altered and perhaps the Simulation is reversed in time with what desire changes remanding and continued then. The AI factor: True AI will only exist when modeled after the human brain, something like what I outline with the mapping and modeling - with simple purposes like driving a car or mining robot requiring the 25% alive version of the full human simulation being 100%. Once only one good total 100% human system created then the world could be controlled where total focus and perfect or near perfect undistracted responses at what cognitive load needed - if compared to the spectrum instead of percentage of, think of one system to be rabbit level, another dog level, another Lion level and for military or bodyguard level then 100%, for research assistant level 150% where the structure patterns of the captured mind are extended beyond. What a good interview! God Bless., Steve
@Mattt303
@Mattt303 10 күн бұрын
One of my fav mindscape
@AlonsoAnaMaria
@AlonsoAnaMaria 10 күн бұрын
Dejar professor i like you so much but please chance you jackets and skirt
@maitai8997
@maitai8997 11 күн бұрын
My man always trying to massage some space time curves
@rachel_rexxx
@rachel_rexxx 11 күн бұрын
We're two days in and I'm already incredibly grateful for escapism that scientific lectures and podcasts are bringing. Woot woot, thanks again!
@phenghs2007
@phenghs2007 10 күн бұрын
Lol