My dogs can bury bones but they are not carrying out cultural funerary practices of humans. My cat used to leave diagonal scratches in my sofa but I don’t believe he thought he was creating art. The claims made by Berger have been intensely criticised by experts in the field. As a layperson who watched the Netflix documentary I wanted it to be true, but something told me it was suspect, so I have been researching all day. But I am glad I found this interesting channel and subscribed.
@worldofpaleoanthropology3 күн бұрын
Be sure to check out all my Rising Star coverage, from the early days, to the big announcements, pre Netflix fun, post Netflix Fall out, and space disaster! Not to mention those peers reviews! yikes!
@Steven-m2o5n6 күн бұрын
❤❤❤❤🤘🤘🤘🤘
@bluesmusicandwhatnot28456 күн бұрын
This is the first time I’ve ever seen the rear of the neurocranium/brain case. You cannot find a single photograph of the back of the skull and it’s been driving me nuts for years, so thank you for that. From what I can tell, it reminds me a lot of what the Saldanha cranium looks like in rear view. Also very similar to KNM-ES 11693.
@worldofpaleoanthropology5 күн бұрын
Glad to show it off! If you can send me your email at [email protected] I can send more images!
@100Llewis7 күн бұрын
I loved this episode! Good job!
@worldofpaleoanthropology7 күн бұрын
Thanks so much!
@pcerrato7 күн бұрын
Wondering where I can find the links to sites and books mentioned in this and other episodes. I love that you share these pointers but for some reason I'm not seeing the links in the descriptions either here in KZbin or in Overcast where I usually listen. Thanks, love love love y'all's work!
@sum_rye_hash_3218 күн бұрын
Great episode, cant wait to see this podcast keep growing :) Any plans to get special guests on the show? I think it would be neat to have someone pop on for a little bit to chat about a topic, like a specialist in radiometric dating or proteomics, so they can answer some questions and explain the process from their perspective. I also like seeing their reaction to what research is done with the results. Often they work in a lab processing dozens of samples so they don't always know what cool stuff their work results in. Looking forwards to more episodes this year though!
@worldofpaleoanthropology8 күн бұрын
We do in fact! Season four is going to be focusing on having guests on the show! Its going to be a blast!
@sum_rye_hash_3218 күн бұрын
@ great! Cant wait!
@APcaveman10 күн бұрын
The Michael Shermer of paleoanthropology.
@czarina778611 күн бұрын
I’m 65 and still have my childhood rocks and fossils. With many additions. Over decades.
@DreamerBooksAnIceAgeSaga11 күн бұрын
Hmmm....this gives me a whole new perspective on my various jars of rocks and shells. 🤔
@jamiegallier210611 күн бұрын
❤
@Nobody-il2fp11 күн бұрын
Merry Christmas
@worldofpaleoanthropology11 күн бұрын
Happy Holidays to you too!
@DreamerBooksAnIceAgeSaga11 күн бұрын
Happy Holidays!
@difficulthail51611 күн бұрын
Happy holidays!!
@tjwhite196311 күн бұрын
If the Rising Star team is sitting on further important discoveries, especially ones that would silence the critics, what's the hold up? Out with them, please!
@worldofpaleoanthropology11 күн бұрын
Or they don’t lol. And that’s why.
@tjwhite196310 күн бұрын
@worldofpaleoanthropology touché, M'sieur.
@MrW11YT12 күн бұрын
Ardipithecus ramidus couldhave still been evolving into Australopithecus anamensis at that time. But that fact they coexisted is really cool.
@jbaccanalia12 күн бұрын
If the oldest lamp is 22,000 years put Chauvet is is 35,000 years with comparable art to lascaux. Could you make the logical inference that they also had similar tech like an oil lamp? The thought of going all the way in there to do beautiful art with nothing but a burning stick is, well, kind off primitive.
@worldofpaleoanthropology12 күн бұрын
Yes, absolutely! That’s just the oldest found to date!
@dwainkitchel131612 күн бұрын
science is beginning to give us culture from our older cousins now...and yes George despite it lessening our all important selves...we learned from them too
@MTB21412 күн бұрын
May you post a link to the book? I’ve read Genevieve’s book and would love to read another. I’ve been reading more than a book a month since December 2020. I’d love to add another to my reading list.
@worldofpaleoanthropology11 күн бұрын
Reading is on of the best ways to learn - are you referring to George’s book? Didn’t forget the link? Sorry; trying to remember this episode!
@MTB21411 күн бұрын
@ yes George’s book.
@paintingtracey12 күн бұрын
Another fun one!
@worldofpaleoanthropology10 күн бұрын
Thanks! 🙏
@mkd407612 күн бұрын
Thanks! Have a great new year.
@worldofpaleoanthropology12 күн бұрын
Happy New Year to you too!
@paintingtracey12 күн бұрын
This was so much fun! Thanks:)
@worldofpaleoanthropology11 күн бұрын
I'm glad you enjoyed it!
@DreamerBooksAnIceAgeSaga12 күн бұрын
Thanks so much for a great episode!
@wendyhill475715 күн бұрын
Too much hand talking....makes me crazy to watch.
@worldofpaleoanthropology14 күн бұрын
Cool story bro
@prestonforayter258415 күн бұрын
Blondes sure had funny looking feet back then.😅
@WhiteRanger129817 күн бұрын
Yeah we have only about 6,500 fossils total and only a few rare full body ones. Comparing that to a worldwide population really isnt a whole lot. This dude we found was probably just a tank.
@worldofpaleoanthropology16 күн бұрын
Curious to know where that number came from? I’ve never heard of an estimation of all hominin fossil remains. I’d be curious to know the source for my own knowledge
@WhiteRanger129816 күн бұрын
@worldofpaleoanthropology The big brain of ai overview. Don't read too much into it. Regardless of whether it is 6,500 or 15k it's still pretty small compared to any existing population.
@worldofpaleoanthropology14 күн бұрын
@@WhiteRanger1298 So you threw out a random number. Got it.
@WhiteRanger129814 күн бұрын
@@worldofpaleoanthropology lol people like you are so annoying. No wonder your channel is so unpopular.
@cavemancaveman519018 күн бұрын
DOGGAMMIT Fire from mythology is a metaphor for language. THINK DOGGAMMIT Can destruction come about as a result of a word?
@paulfreeman2300020 күн бұрын
Thank you for sharing, great information, Subscribed and thumbs up. Upper Paleo Rocks Peace
@worldofpaleoanthropology20 күн бұрын
Thanks so much! Glad to have you! Plenty more to come!
@cavemancaveman519022 күн бұрын
OLD FART IN AN OLD HOUSE jk
@worldofpaleoanthropology22 күн бұрын
He might agree knowing him haha
@mpickett928323 күн бұрын
These just keep getting better! Your infectious enthusiasm make the topics all that much better.
@worldofpaleoanthropology22 күн бұрын
Thank you so much!
@Chris-6483223 күн бұрын
Oh yes, "transition" , but what a heck of specialist knowledge would be necessary to put the story together.
@sum_rye_hash_32123 күн бұрын
In regards to the mammoths on Wrangel island, from my understanding there is no evidence of humans hunting live mammoths on the island, it looks like some other disaster got to them. The only human interaction is collecting bones if i recall correctly. Also Genevieve, that show hunting permafrost finds would be amazing! There are other KZbinrs who do that to help find missing people from present-ish times. It might be worth looking into them for help, they have a large audience that would probably also be interested.
@sum_rye_hash_32124 күн бұрын
I'm glad to see this podcast growing, I've enjoyed the content you all cover for a long time. Its great to hear from people working in the field! One thing I would recommend is improvements to your audio setups. I watch a few different podcasts and channels that do interviews, and bad audio is a terrible plague lol. Can't wait to see how this podcast changes as it grows, glad to see Darren on board and looking forward to more nice visuals though!
@worldofpaleoanthropology23 күн бұрын
Thank you so much for the feedback, I'll keep the audio in mind!
@Ghost274324 күн бұрын
Love what you guys do! There's a half a dozen LINES OF INQUIRY you voiced in this episode that are 100% shared and voiced by the more scrupulous proponents of history's mysteries, or alt historians for lack of a better term... I think an open, earnest conversation with some would be more entertaining than debunking somebody's ancient alien theory. It would certainly be more productive. 😐😎
@DreamerBooksAnIceAgeSaga24 күн бұрын
Great episode-so many fascinating topics! Thank you!
@worldofpaleoanthropology24 күн бұрын
Glad you enjoyed it!
@dicksonwhitesides560724 күн бұрын
Love the podcast! Wonderful conversation guys!
@worldofpaleoanthropology24 күн бұрын
Thanks for listening
@Petal-Lavelle25 күн бұрын
What a wonderful episode. Thank you. If you could follow up on the use of psychotropic substances by our cave friends that would be awesome
@worldofpaleoanthropology25 күн бұрын
That’s a fun idea! We will have to visit in Season 4!
@worldofpaleoanthropology25 күн бұрын
Glad you enjoyed!
@Zoltan141225 күн бұрын
What do u think of spenoid flexion driving evolution?
@worldofpaleoanthropology25 күн бұрын
The sphenoid bone, a complex structure at the base of the skull, has played a significant role in the evolutionary development of the human cranium. Its intricate morphology and strategic position have influenced various aspects of cranial architecture, impacting both function and form. Structural Integration and Cranial Stability Positioned centrally, the sphenoid bone articulates with multiple cranial bones, contributing to the overall stability and integrity of the skull. This central “keystone” position has been crucial in the evolutionary transition from early tetrapods to modern humans, facilitating the accommodation of an expanding brain while maintaining structural coherence.  Facilitation of Sensory and Neural Functions The sphenoid bone houses several foramina and canals that allow the passage of critical neurovascular structures, including the optic canal for the optic nerve and the superior orbital fissure for nerves controlling eye movements. This configuration has been essential in the evolution of enhanced sensory capabilities, particularly vision, by providing protected pathways for nerves and vessels.  Adaptations in Cranial Morphogenesis Research into the morphogenesis of the sphenoid bone during human development suggests that its complex shape and development patterns have implications for craniofacial evolution. The bone’s development is closely linked with the overall morphology of the skull, influencing the spatial arrangement of cranial components and the accommodation of the brain and sensory organs.  Implications for Paleoanthropology In paleoanthropology, variations in the sphenoid bone among different hominin species provide insights into their phylogenetic relationships and functional adaptations. For instance, changes in the sphenoid’s structure can reflect dietary adaptations, respiratory functions, and even aspects of social behavior, as cranial base morphology influences vocal tract configuration. Understanding the evolutionary significance of the sphenoid bone offers a window into the complex interplay between structure and function that has shaped the human skull. Its development reflects broader evolutionary pressures and adaptations, highlighting the intricate pathways through which human cranial morphology has evolved.
@DorchesterMom27 күн бұрын
What an interesting moment in time we currently exist in - to see with increasing clarity backwards and forwards, to behold our very human selves for once, and with that insight shape the present to affect the latter? Yet, the past (as a non-scientist) fascinates me most. What ARE we but an amalgam of the survivors?
@worldofpaleoanthropology27 күн бұрын
I love it! Exactly! 👍
@RoundSomeStuffАй бұрын
From out of left field: Neanderthals are the people described in the mythological account of the Levant region, in the book of Genesis. They were Adam. Eve was the development of egoic consciousness and the desirer of wanting to understand the external world. However the Neanderthal brain could not support egoic consciousness in a wholesome manner. The Understanding fractured and their social system imploded in The Flood. The new mind is described as The Ark whereby ego is compartmentalised and limited being subject to Boundary, a concept Aspies just don't get.
@worldofpaleoanthropologyАй бұрын
Pure fantasy
@RoundSomeStuff29 күн бұрын
@worldofpaleoanthropology You would be aware that the test of a theory is not a rhetorical denial but a prediction from the theory which can be calibrated. At 25:15 you ask the question of when did Neanderthals begin to think abstractly about the world around them eg a rock as an object to be manipulated by their intelligence. You didn't really put up a default prior state but it would seem that an articulation would be 'rather than being subjectively experienced as a thing in itself. Your guest really doesn't answer. However the mythology gives you an answer: when Neanderthal consciousness turned away from the Tree of Life as the means to Understand the purpose of Life and made the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil the focus of how to Understand life on Earth. Everyone actually experiences this even today around age 7, the so called age of reason when it dawns on the seven year old that Self is a distinct locus of conscious awareness of events being experienced in Life, separate from parents, siblings, friends and school class acquaintances who are Other. Non-Aspie Self realises Other are OtherSelf, locii of separate domains each delimited by Boundary and Relationship is built to connect locii, a bridge across no-mans land which become the platform for interactions between Self and Other. However Aspie Self never develops this concept of Limited Self demarcated by Boundary, so has no concept of Boundary nor building Relationship using small talk and unspoken communication to keep things fluid, and all interactions are transactional. Non-Aspies recognise that Other has their own Understanding and one cannot Will to Act solely on Self's Understanding but compromise and consensus must be worked out with stakeholders with win-win as a goal. Aspies do not conceive of this multiplicity of Understanding so their Will to Act is fused to their own particular Understanding. Musk is an example as is Thunberg who has stated this is her secret power. This is the basis of the unyielding iron will exhibited by Margaret Thatcher, the Iron Lady. In their mind there is no multiplicity of Understanding just as there is none in the mind of infants. Everyone is on the same page they assume. In the dawn of human consciousness represented by mythological Adam this was true, the Tree of Life was that unified consciousness. Then around Neanderthal's age 7 that fractured but Neanderthals, as with Aspies, did not recognise this fracturing and eventually Neanderthal society imploded due to an inability to compromise and cooperate.
@xxthreedaysgrace2xx29 күн бұрын
@@RoundSomeStuff You keep up with that crazy juice lol
@RoundSomeStuffАй бұрын
The term neurotypical and neurodivergent are unhelpful. In looking at variation and typicality one is in the realm of statistical analysis and we have a mean for people with Aspies and a mean for non-Aspies and the difference between these two means describes the inter-group difference. Then comes intra-group variation which applies to each group. It is likely that the intra-group variation for Aspies is smaller than the intra-group variation of non-Aspies, meaning non-Aspies are the more neurodiverse group than Aspies.
@worldofpaleoanthropologyАй бұрын
Asperger’s is not even recognized anymore.
@RoundSomeStuffАй бұрын
@@worldofpaleoanthropology Well you don't say. Would an Aspie care what a bunch of Non Player Characters thought? By merging the two it confounds any analysis when conclusions are drawn. It was for ease of diagnosis and legal reasons.
@worldofpaleoanthropologyАй бұрын
@ It’s actually because the diagnostic criteria was set by a nazi exploring eugenics, but ok, believe what you will.
@DreamerBooksAnIceAgeSagaАй бұрын
I love hearing Baby World of Paleoanthropology in the background! :-)
@DreamerBooksAnIceAgeSagaАй бұрын
Woohoo! Can't wait!
@JUANORQUIOАй бұрын
WoW! That’s Tremendously Awesome! Have An Incredible Weekend! 🫶🏻🤩❤️✨
@ImOldGregggАй бұрын
There are some pretty big names in the Paleo-anthropology world that believe most Homo Erectus fossils found in the Indonesia and China area are Denisovans.
@worldofpaleoanthropologyАй бұрын
Such as? I’d like to hear these names lol, because I’ve literally never heard that.
@johnwinbergАй бұрын
Fascinating stuff. I'm jealous that I'm not there.
@worldofpaleoanthropologyАй бұрын
I know! I hope to visit one day! There are so many stunning archaeological sites around the world, as I was commenting with someone else this afternoon!