Did the Octopus Flux tariff not exist when this video was made? Because odds are most of the people advocating big battery installs are on that one, and the reason it makes sense is a large battery enables you to engage in arbitrage, for example based on the modelling I've had done the house I'll be renovating to a high standard of energy/thermal efficiency soon will have a maximum typical daily consumption of around 7-8kwh, so assuming I bought two of those Fogstar batteries for a 31kwh total capacity and using the Flux numbers for my region, the total cost to charge the battery to full every day during the early morning off-peak plus the standing charge would be £4.64 per day, while selling the unused ~23kwh back to the grid during the evening peak period would bring in £5.06. Let's say the battery lasts ten years without excessive degredation, that little daily excess would amount to just over ~£1.5k which should cover the install cost of the battery so call it £500 a year. That beats Standard in your calcs by a factor of three, and Track by almost double. It's a little above Go but remember that's a *no solar* install, just battery. With the 14.6p day rate Flux gives my area for export outside of peak times and given how cheap solar panels are these days, if the grid operator lets me put a decent size array on the property that should pay itself off fairly quickly and then anything produced by the solar is gravy that further offsets the battery cost.
@UpsideDownFork11 сағат бұрын
Yes, I have also considered flux. You should watch some of the videos on the Tim&Kat's green walk channel. He's done some more thorough analysis on flux and it's best use case.
@jfinnie7814 сағат бұрын
£8.5k?! That's more like it! :) Amazing VFM. Finger's crossed it is a good one for you. What's the weird thing under the numberplate? At first I thought it was an aftermarket rear park sensor, but that would seem madness on a car of this age.
@UpsideDownFork13 сағат бұрын
@@jfinnie78 it is a terrible afterthought by MG UK! Literally just a blanking plate. It will be gone shortly. 👍 Just back from the Jurassic coast and it's been excellent.
@asabriggs642616 сағат бұрын
£8500 is a bargain. Throw in a bit more for a compatible EV charger and you're Intelligent Octopus Go ready ...
@UpsideDownFork13 сағат бұрын
Watch this space!
@edc156918 сағат бұрын
Still absurdly expensive to deal with the image Tesla comes with.
@UpsideDownFork17 сағат бұрын
@@edc1569 very true 👍
@geoffreygriffiths472519 сағат бұрын
The issue is what is the likely long-term price of solar. Many thoughtful people think that power prices will become more volatile but generally lower in off peak periods. The battery option only becomes viable if you can spread your load to avoid peak hour periods. Investing in new kit has to be partly an act of faith. If you've got the cash and you think it will cut costs it's probably worth it. Your pay back calculation is good but doesn't make an allowance for inflation or power prices becoming more volatile. Grat video very informative.
@UpsideDownFork16 сағат бұрын
All very true. I have delved into some of those points in other videos on my channel 👍
@ashb8572Күн бұрын
Great video, I had a MG5 LR back in 2022. That version had mg pilot which was very good adaptive CC and lane centering. I noticed used car prices going up so bailed out of my pcp at near list value. I'm glad i did given the crash in prices. You got yourself a bargain. I decided to go back to a Prius phev as it better suited our familys use case 😊
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
@@ashb8572 thanks for the comment 👍
@chrisrowe22Күн бұрын
Nice video, or should I say pleasant! I enjoyed the change in presentation style from your Heat Pump/Solar Videos and look forward to seeing more. Welcome to the EV world. 4 years in for me and never going back!
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
@@chrisrowe22 thanks for the comment!
@jusiditКүн бұрын
Just the question I was asking myself. Wife wants a 2nd Tesla, but currently can't justify the price for a 3mile commute.
@barrywhite5899Күн бұрын
You need to sell more printer ink! Then you could justify it! What colour would you get , red blue or white! Or maybe get really exciting with a grey one!
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
@@jusidit give it a year and they'll be under £20k I'm sure 👍
@MrRushworm2 күн бұрын
What tariff are you going to go for to run your heat pump and charge the car in winter? This is the conundrum for me. Octopus intelligent go isn't compatible with every car or charger, plus the 18 hour peak pricing. Agile the cheap rates aren't guaranteed, again with a shorter peak. Tracker lacks an off-peak window for charging. So cosy?
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
I think I'm going to roll the dice and try and make agile work for us. I'm fortunate that we don't do that many miles and the car will often be sat on the drive during the off peak periods. We'll see if that gamble pays off for me.
@JOOI5252 күн бұрын
Should have added that on the non electric seat they have height adjustment, is that not available on the electric seats?
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
The electric seats are height adjustable but I'm on the lowest setting.
@edwardlamb2 күн бұрын
Had no idea the price of these was so low! You're right... they are so darn ugly, but I love the practicality. We have a 2012 Volvo V60 so this would be perfect for us as our first EV (though we are hoping to get something a bit smaller - only two kids and a small dog). Looking forward to seeing how you get on with it and the changes you make. Nice one!
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Thanks for the comment. The price did seal the deal.
@ChrisJakins2 күн бұрын
We just bought the same car. Really pleased with it. It just works. One thing that surprised me was the wipers when lifted collide with the bonnet and rub the paint off. It’s a minor issue I suppose. I think maybe the boot lip protection is aftermarket but a neat solution if you have a dog jumping in. Do wish I had tinted windows too. Great car though. I don’t mind its looks at all.
@brettfield8472 күн бұрын
On VW's they have a wiper maintenance position either in the settings on the infotainment or try switching the ignition on, then off and pull the wiper for one single wipe and the wipers stick at the top position. On Volkswagens that is...
@ChrisJakinsКүн бұрын
@@brettfield847 thanks that is interesting information! Maybe I should read the manual 🤔
@ChrisJakinsКүн бұрын
@@brettfield847 You are correct. Service mode position. You have to turn ignition on and off then push the wiper control stalk down. Never seen that before!
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Thanks for the comment. Good tip from the community on the wipers!
@geoffreycoan2 күн бұрын
Lot of car for a bargain price. Very nice
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
It sure is!
@rhiantaylor34462 күн бұрын
I bought a Zoe about a year ago and I am very happy with it but I am now wondering why I didn't look out for a MG5, I like estates but had assumed it would cost a lot more.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
I suspect the price on these has fallen a lot in the last year. I don't think you made a mistake by getting the Zoe.
@davefroman47002 күн бұрын
In 6-12 months the cost of these battery systems is likely to drop by another 30%. Simply because the cost of LFP cells is rapidly declining, as the industry scales up. CATL is saying their costs on LFP dropped by 50% in the last 6 months. As that filters down into the retail market, we will see prices fall.
@UpsideDownFork2 күн бұрын
Yes, I totally agree. We have already seen retail pricing fall considerably this year and will continue.
@Wildchild1210072 күн бұрын
My house is exactly the same in regards to facing rotation. I'm going for 7 panels on the front and 15 on the back. With a 10kw battery. All in £6999. Sounds to good to be true. But still research to do in company
@UpsideDownFork2 күн бұрын
That does sound too good to be true! Definitely do your research. I'm not sure how it's possible to do a system that cheap.
@Wildchild121007Күн бұрын
@@UpsideDownFork 17 x DAS Solar 445W N Type, Bifascial, TOPCon, Black Panels 1 x 8kW Fox Hybrid Inverter 1 x 10kWh Fox Battery Storage System 1 x Fox Battery Cables Set 1 x Management App 1 x Set of MC4 Connectors 1 x Pitched Roof Mounting Kit for 17 Panels 1 x Bird Proofing 2 x Isolators 1 x Set of Labels 1 x Full onsite installation and commissioning Price: £6,990.00
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
@@Wildchild121007 have you thoroughly researched that company?
@Wildchild121007Күн бұрын
@@UpsideDownFork can't find it anywhere, everyone beware. I'm not taking the chance
@CEUOTC2 күн бұрын
Great content buddy. I too have just jumped on a 72 plate MG5 FL LR Trophy and l am quite happy with the performance and think l bagged myself a bit of a bargain. Not to the same level you have :)
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Nice 👍
@middlesbrough1232 күн бұрын
Vaillant are a boiler manufacturer I do have confidence in their product but I wouldn’t put them above Daikin who have been in the ASHP business along time . Personally my rule of thumb would be if yiur on gas stick with gas . Install is higher maintenance cost will be higher and uncertain regarding what potential costs would be .
@UpsideDownFork2 күн бұрын
Thanks for your comment. Heat geek and the like seem to regard the Vaillant units as a step up from Daikin but as a layman I'm not to know.
@Carlos11802 күн бұрын
The prices you're getting are what I was paying a year ago in Northern Ireland! This year in July my 2016 BMW 330e went up from £348 to £606!! That was with my current insurer 1st Direct who I've been with for years because nobody else can match them on price. The price comparison sites were even more eye watering. The cheapest on them was £848!!! What is going on?!!!
@UpsideDownFork2 күн бұрын
Ouch! That is a very worrying trend!
@Carlos11802 күн бұрын
@@UpsideDownFork Hopefully it calms down a bit. I should have said, I loved your review. Nicely done. Also your last review of the MG5. It's a pleasure to listen to someone who really knows what they're talking about
@UpsideDownFork10 сағат бұрын
@@Carlos1180 Thanks for the feedback! I'm no motoring journalist or anything but I am the third generation in the motor trade. I've done just about anything and everything on a car and worked in almost all parts of the sector too.
@iKaGe012 күн бұрын
I actually really like the look of it. Especially vs the new version... But I like the look of the original Leaf. The 61kWh of this will be my next car. By next year, probably about 9-10k for it. You got the Exclusive too
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
I'm actually camping at the moment and another family has the LR version. It's been interesting to compare. They had theirs for over 2 years and are over the moon with it.
@iKaGe01Күн бұрын
@@UpsideDownFork Yeah it seems like the obvious step for us. Can't get it this year due to remortgaging but next year we'll be selling the Leaf which will hopefully get something for...and moving on to that
@derekpaisley6202 күн бұрын
So you will be considering a new tariff to compliment the house battery and car charging?
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
I'm going to play the agile game if I can. Watch this space.
@leslie196112 күн бұрын
Accelerator like an on/off switch? Which EVs are you referring to and why not mention them?
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Mustang mach-e is the worst offender. Teslas are also not great, even in their "chill" mode.
@karlwest4372 күн бұрын
An MG5 is the definition of sensible, and if that's what you want there's nothing wrong with it 😃
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Well said.
@briangriffiths12852 күн бұрын
And I bought the ZS new in 2020 for much the same reasons; very practical car with the VW feel to the cabin (replaced a Passat) and whilst it wasn't the bargain that the MG5 is now, it did get all the discounts at a time when there weren't second hand EVs about. And the Press panned them but as you have found there really isn't anything to hate about them.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Yeah, if you can see past the Chinese stigma then you can enjoy the value for money.
@ODD_JOB2 күн бұрын
I'm seriously looking at the mg5 ev estate. I look foward to your next video on the real world range test. thank you for the great video. and hopefully the charge time to 80% from home charging if available.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Stay tuned. Done some miles and some trips already and I'm impressed.
@M0j02 күн бұрын
Congratulations on your new car. Great amd very smart choice. Like you mentioned cannot be beaten in terms of features and practicality and price. Love it.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Thanks! 👍
@MikeGleesonazelectrics2 күн бұрын
Not sure what the black bar was for on the rear door but it just didnt look right. Comes off easy enough. The MG5 version 1 had a few minor issues but was a great workhorse and very cheap to run. At that price you cant go wrong.. I now have an mg4 se with no regrets as my retirement car.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Nicely done!
@stevechelt12 күн бұрын
Interesting video, I will watch out for updates. I've had an Ampera or the last 7 years and am looking to change soon, the two EVs on my shortlist are this or an Ioniq 38kwh. Both are not the best looking cars but I'm not too fussed on looks, in fact I quite like the slightly retro look of the MG5.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Good choice. I did really like the Ioniq 38kWh, but this just blew it away for practicality. If you don't need the extra space then it's definitely worthwhile thoroughly researching both.
@matthewwakeham22062 күн бұрын
I'd have one but I had a Volvo v40 (the old estate one) and I loved that car. It was just nice to be in and you could get loads of stuff in it. This is probably not as nice inside but an unassuming practical car for moving things and people about. No-ones going to steal it or 'accidentally' damage it in a car park and you probably aren't going to worry about minor battle scars anyway.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Good points. It's hard to beat a Volvo interior. Especially those seats! They know what matters most. The MG5 is a step down but it's probably not as bad as you might expect.
@izwizbiz34712 күн бұрын
If you use a VW spare wheel you should use the VW bolts, whilst the bolt pattern is the same, I think the countersink in the wheel is a different angle.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
That's an important point if people don't know what they're doing. Radius bolts are what I use for my Mercedes spare, I also need a spigot ring because of the smaller centre bore on the MG. The MG5 bolts are tapered. My previous 2 VAG cars also used the same tapered bolts as the MG. I used to run an alloy wheel business for my sins.
@JOOI5252 күн бұрын
We have the 62KWH excite without the 'toys'. Had it 15 months without issue. Only thing to watch for is the ,auto braking' on the collision avoidance system. Had it come on and catch me out, very aggressive....can be cancelled by pressing accelerator bizarrely. Love the car though, smooth. Average 4.25 mpk annually, upto 6 in summer and 3.5 in winter. Enjoy
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Nice, thanks for the comment!
@chrispenn7152 күн бұрын
The MG5 is a very sensible car. It looks a bit old fashioned, but it does the job for most people day to day and a great bargain. I have an MG4 and I'm happy with it. Cheap to run, reasonably comfortable and fast enough - but all EVs are kind of soul less to me. Cars are becoming about as exciting as washing machines, or fridges 😂. I get my fun from an older petrol car that I only use sparingly on sunny days....
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Very true.
@robinbennett59942 күн бұрын
Early reviews the MG5 called it 'quirky', with intrusive lane-assist, complex menus and a charge port flap that obscured the socket. The latter seems to have been fixed on yours, with the flap opening horizontally instead of vertically. Have you found anything that made you think MG isn't an experienced car designer? The big surprise for me (who has never driven an MG) was that someone coming from a Merc found a sub £10k Chinese EV good enough to buy. That's got to be a good sign for consumers, if not for some big European car brands...
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
I think you've got some crossed wires with the MG ZS electric. The quality of the interior is pretty much on par with a Mercedes A Class, it's not comparable in any way to an S Class or something like that but it's all very functional and practical for an every day car.
@andrewgage69422 күн бұрын
I don't dislike the MG range, obviously with a car of this budget price it's not going to be perfect, if I was in the market for an electric vehicle I would consider one of these. The technology is a bit much for an old fart like me, the screen on the dash, I probably wouldn't use it mainly because it would probably be too complicated for me, being short, the driver seat height would probably be fine for me. As most of my driving is motorway driving, I don't have access to off road parking so I wouldn't be able to charge at home, I work nights so even if I had access to off road parking, I wouldn't be able to take advantage of cheaper electric rates and the infrastructure in the area where I live is very poor, if I could afford to buy an electric vehicle, it still wouldn't be as cheap to run as my little diesel. That said, I think MG are producing some nice cars, even though they are way too expensive for someone like me, they are still cheaper than the competition
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
No off street parking is definitely a deal breaker for most. The dash display is actually very simple on this one. It defaults to just one big Speedo and if you don't press any buttons it just stays there. Another great practical design feature.
@_Dougaldog2 күн бұрын
Well done, and perfectly placed to spot a bargain , the MG5 looks to be the comfy sized family car. With your solar PV and all the other trimmings it should cost near nothing to run, a real bargain. I went for the MG4 a few weeks ago, more of a 'lady magnet' I thought; others may have recognised it better though with the words 'late mid life crisis' appearing frequently 🤔
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Absolutely. So far I've only charged it from the negative agile rates so I've been paid to charge it.
@jamesdaw1312 күн бұрын
I’ve also gone estate (admittedly different end of the spectrum with an ID7). If this was my budget, I’d be going for something like this.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
ID7 looks great! I'll be keenly watching for what happens to their pricing in 3 years time!
@jamesdaw131Күн бұрын
@@UpsideDownFork looking forward to it. Amazing lease deal came up and went for it. Don’t normally get new cars!
@ML-qk1px2 күн бұрын
Dealers didn’t like them either it would seem. My dad tried to get more information on these when they came out, but he said the salesmen at first were now where to be seen, and when they did didn’t know much about it.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Our local dealer was definitely geared up to sell us an MG4 or MG ZS but not so prepared for the MG5.
@carlarrowsmith2 күн бұрын
A great buy. Some would say the depreciation on Chinese cars is bad, but the best depreciation beater is to pay less in the first place as you have. Now you can have EV I would be interested on you take of the tariffs. Just moved from Octopus Intelligent Go to E.on Next Drive.
@SteveForth2 күн бұрын
You’ve got a bargain at that price, gutted I didn’t wait 18 months before buying mine now. Btw If you change the tires from the terrible oem ones you’ll get the grip you need on faster pull away and reduce the noise significantly.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Thanks. The car is presumably on it's second set of tyres as they are Michelin and I understand that wasn't a factory fit option. My presumption is that the chassis dynamics were calibrated with a petrol or diesel engine fitted which would shift the weight balance considerably compared to the EV version. There's only so much they can do with suspension to try and correct a chassis after the design phase. The low sling battery pack will have shifted the weight balance significantly.
@derekpaisley6202 күн бұрын
Well done!, same issue not much £ managed to bag a tesla model 3 long range for 15.8k loving it.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Nice one!
@SolAce-nw2hf2 күн бұрын
Great choice. At that price you really can't go wrong. I like physical buttons and a normal interface instead of driving a game console.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Well said!
@TheVedabuss2 күн бұрын
I bought mine 2.5yrs ago and so far 40k miles. Love going on trips with the dogs, range is great, ride is excellent. Some quirks..android rarely works, rear boot open warning only triggers after you are going 30mph (lol) and front lights at night about are really dim, so eat your carrots. Overall, love it, looks tatty but 5 yrs left on warranty and is a great dog truck..
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
I've adjusted the headlights already up to the maximum level I can and will fit some osram night breakers I think as I've had good experience with them in the past. I've also found that short, high quality USB cable are the way to go with android auto. Mine is working perfectly so far.
@TheVedabussКүн бұрын
@@UpsideDownFork I'll give that USB upgrade a go thx
@truebrit36702 күн бұрын
It's a very capable car. I do like the power available in sport mode. Ride is very good, not a rally car by any means but doesn't pretend to be. Infotainment is not great, but overall a very nice EV.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Totally agree
@petest39922 күн бұрын
Oi! I’ve been looking for that car for 6 months! How you get it for such a great price? I’d have snapped that up right away.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Keep your eyes peeled. I set up favourite searches and refreshed the pages every evening to check for any new listings. Then drove a hard bargain with the dealer.
@Burtis892 күн бұрын
The wheels and the ride height let the car down. They should have down a lower version with sporty aero and tasty wheels to appeal to a younger market
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
They are a little hamstrung on the height due to the battery fitment but I agree the wheels are appalling considering they were the only option.
@TheRonskiman2 күн бұрын
Interesting video, I didn't realise the tie up with VAG. I've no plans for an EV, but something like this would suit me if my 15 year old Tiguan gave up. A few years back I replaced the wheels on my Tiguan, it made it look like a lot newer car.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
You will certainly recognise some of the VAG parts bin I showed in the video then. My brother in law who had a passt and now has a t-roc feels very at home in the MG5. I've changed wheels on just about every car I've ever owned, so this is nothing new. Totally agree that just a set of wheels can transform a car.
@contact20012 күн бұрын
Can this do V2H? If not then I don’t understand that you didn’t go for one that is, like the Nissan Leaf for example. You do work from home, no?
@robinbennett59942 күн бұрын
The Leaf doesn't do V2H unless you buy a charger that's so rare it's almost mythical. A few people got them as part of a research project, but otherwise they're not available in the UK.
@_Dougaldog2 күн бұрын
The MG5 supports V2L (Vehicle to load @ 240v ac), so in an emergency could easily be used to power home at a nominal 2.2kWh, my MG4 could easily provide household power at 10kWh/day for six or seven days.
@AlanTov2 күн бұрын
Do any UK EV's have V2H? Quite a few have V2L...
@MikeGleesonazelectrics2 күн бұрын
@@AlanTovnah..
@JOOI5252 күн бұрын
I don't believe the Nissan leaf has liquid battery cooling which appears to result in increased battery degradation. Looked in detail about getting one, but space was an issue for us. Felt nicely put together but from memory do they have infotainment screen issues? Always liked them though.
@bamber1192 күн бұрын
I was looking at an older MG5 as my shortlist along with an ID3. I was looking at the exclusive(or is it premium?) as it had the panaramic roof but what put me off it was the lack of mobile remote features for charging but still a lovely looking car. The id3 I didn't like the short bonnet, and I ended up with my leaf. The only downside of the leaf is the foot hand brake, but I went for a n-connecta(tekna has electric brake I know.). I still like the look of the MG5 though and I think the bits you don't like are very small points and will do you until you can get the Tesla you wanted for under 25k.
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
Yes, the lack of app is a bit of an inconvenience. The newer MG5 resolves that and many other annoyances.
@stuartburns86572 күн бұрын
The MG EV range seem to be fairly well thought of from what I understand. Spare tyre a bonus these days too. Not personally ready for a EV yet, hanging on to our 2 diesels for another 4-5 years, lots of EV price carnage to come I believe 😊
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
👍
@adrianflower32302 күн бұрын
Great review thanks 👍 did you buy through trade or auction for it? I'd be tempted at £8500 but all the retail ones are around £11000
@UpsideDownForkКүн бұрын
This one was actually retail! I was so close to going down the auction route but didn't need to in the end.