Пікірлер
@jasongreif7867
@jasongreif7867 18 сағат бұрын
Before expanding make sure you have things operating the e and h lines are defunct and not usable
@jasongreif7867
@jasongreif7867 18 сағат бұрын
The bus is way fast and more reliable than light rail which is just sad Rtd joke is reason to drive
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 7 сағат бұрын
@@jasongreif7867 The current system is a sad state of affairs to be sure
@cyynthia1676
@cyynthia1676 Күн бұрын
How do i get there whats the address
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 19 сағат бұрын
@@cyynthia1676 Hammond Gateway Station, 4530 Sheffield Ave, Hammond, IN 46327
@Nerdy_dude
@Nerdy_dude 3 күн бұрын
Yeah NS is a jerk to Virginia Railways Express, Even though they use the line once a day.
@Kameezy
@Kameezy 3 күн бұрын
The automation segment is throwing me off. Automation would cost a ton of money. Plus installing glass for the automation system could be installed for a driver system. So it's just an extra cost. And do drivers really slow down the lines? How would driverless trains run more often? Due to less cost? After how many years? Oh, and you could not walk faster than that.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 3 күн бұрын
@@Kameezy Automating Line 1 in Paris cost €600 million, of which about 400 mil was the cost of new trains, which Chicago will need anyway. ~$200 million for an automation project is a bargain, and it has SO many benefits. Heating, cooling, noise reduction, safety, higher-speed and more-reliable trips, and reduced operating costs, which lead to higher frequencies and long-term efficiency within the agency. Automation is a no-brainer in 2024, especially for an agency struggling to find enough drivers to operate basic service.
@Kameezy
@Kameezy 2 күн бұрын
@@thehouseoftransit2719 Thank you for the more in depth explanation!
@ThornappleRiverRailSeries
@ThornappleRiverRailSeries 7 күн бұрын
The land to the north of the new station, including where the old tracks were, is earmarked for TOD. At some point, the ped crossings to the platform may be extended to the north also if needed to service the new TOD.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 6 күн бұрын
@@ThornappleRiverRailSeries always good to hear!
@michaelbaird2818
@michaelbaird2818 7 күн бұрын
This is a really funny and informative video for a channel with not even 3k subs.
@hawkeyetherailfan
@hawkeyetherailfan 16 күн бұрын
Terrible shame they didn't design the station better, they could have had an elevated structure over the main line that would abut against the branch line and have a direct entry facing the neighborhood to the north there. Maybe they have some grandiose plan for a better station once the tracks are cut over and removed so the land can be fully redeveloped, but if that is the case I don't think it's been mentioned. Still, my hope is that Amtrak can use the West Lake branch to reroute the Cardinal so it has a better entry route to Chicago. As the route it currently uses is very slow as it goes through many junctions on its way to Dyer, Dyer being where its current route meets the West Lake branch for those unfamiliar with the area. Thank you for the overview of the station, I don't get out that way very often and it's nice to see the changes.
@MrSleepy677
@MrSleepy677 17 күн бұрын
RIP old Hammond Station.
@MrCateagle
@MrCateagle 19 күн бұрын
I'm old enough to remember the original Hammond station that did not have much of a waiting room at all
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 19 күн бұрын
@@MrCateagle when did that close?
@MrCateagle
@MrCateagle 19 күн бұрын
@thehouseoftransit2719 I'm not totally certain. I know it was.open onto the Sixties but don't know beyond as ww moved out of the area.
@peoriavideosltd6822
@peoriavideosltd6822 9 күн бұрын
The old station closed around 1997 or so when the next station was built. It's crazy that one barely lasted 25 years!
@mirzaahmed6589
@mirzaahmed6589 23 күн бұрын
1950s? The practice has been around since the 1850s. You really don't know what you are talking about. There is less frequent service within the central city because cities have their own internal transit systems.
@Marion-p4j
@Marion-p4j 23 күн бұрын
Motto Washington state Come & visit us but dont stay Quote tina o neil American german teacher
@lars7935
@lars7935 25 күн бұрын
Express trains make perfect sense. Underserving core sections of the network does not.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 25 күн бұрын
Exactly, denser urban areas should have more service due to them being denser than the suburbs.
@lars7935
@lars7935 25 күн бұрын
@ There are however cases where expresses can skip some dense stations. That's however talking about service levels like Tokyos suburban lines not north american ones. Even local only stops on suburban lines in central Tokyo frequently see 12+ trains per hour per direction even outside of peak hour.
@apollotransit6711
@apollotransit6711 25 күн бұрын
Great video! It’s crazy to think how much untapped ridership there is across the dozens of other Metra stations in Chicago city limits
@history_leisure
@history_leisure 25 күн бұрын
Either trains are local within the city/adjacent or go express from the downtown core station(s) to the limits/adjacent in the peak-even if it’s only on 3 round trips weekdays only
@simonsv9449
@simonsv9449 25 күн бұрын
First
@KeyserTheRedBeard
@KeyserTheRedBeard Ай бұрын
Impressive video, The House of Transit. Looking forward to seeing your next upload from you. I clicked the thumbs up icon on your post. Keep up the awesome work. The insights into the new Hammond Gateway station were fascinating! What are your thoughts on how the West Lake Corridor will impact commuter patterns in the area once it's fully operational?
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@KeyserTheRedBeard happy to hear you enjoyed the video! Admittedly I’m not super familiar with the area, but given the spotty bus service in Northern Indiana as a whole I would imagine this will make commutes into central Chicago viable for many more people living near the line and beyond!
@dylanwinn3
@dylanwinn3 Ай бұрын
love the doors on both sides, all door boarding, internal bike racks, high-level platforms, and center-running bus lanes. hopefully they can put up some wires and convert it to trolley buses in the future, and actually deliver the promised 6 minute headways. does it have signal priority?
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@dylanwinn3 From what I can tell there actually isn’t signal priority, which is unusual because plenty of other Metro routes *do* have it in some form
@Eddie-wr2fh
@Eddie-wr2fh Ай бұрын
You've done something I've never seen anyone making a fantasy map do before which is link Hyde Park and Roslindale. Hyde Park is notoriously isolated (transit wise) from West Roxbury and Roslindale (it's literally impossible without going to Forest Hills (in Jamaica Plain) and then transferring. This is why I tend to favor the Orange Line branching with one branch terminating in West Roxbury and the other at Readville via Hyde Park, but I really appreciate the thought given to southwest Boston!
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
You bring up a valid point. I think with much better mainline rail service on the Providence/Stoughton/Franklin Lines Hyde Park can probably do just fine without an Orange Line extension.
@Max-ns8lc
@Max-ns8lc Ай бұрын
Is it a sin for them to put some at Newcastle and Renton? It’s literally right there. No light rail but a potential brt on 405.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@Max-ns8lc under construction as we speak!
@grahamturner2640
@grahamturner2640 Ай бұрын
I wonder why you added the Blueface song at the end.
@samblensdorf7384
@samblensdorf7384 Ай бұрын
Bring trains to lowell!!
@markstocker5121
@markstocker5121 Ай бұрын
Took the South Shore into Chicago for a day trip when visiting relatives on my mom's side of the family some thirty years ago or so. I think we left from the old Hammond station.
@ix830
@ix830 Ай бұрын
Its nice to see both the good and bad of the recent G Line launch. There are almost always early on problems but your video shows this is likely to be a big win for Seattle. I hope other cities are taking note.
@XOXFilmStudio
@XOXFilmStudio Ай бұрын
Northern Indiana is the GOAT at being so overly depressing aesthetically it makes me hate the fact I live anywhere near it (I live in central IL)
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@XOXFilmStudio agreed, hopefully this new train service will help stimulate more appealing development
@justinanderson181
@justinanderson181 Ай бұрын
Drove through Decatur Illinois and that blows nwi out of the water when it comes to being depressing. Might’ve been the most depressing town ive ever seen
@XOXFilmStudio
@XOXFilmStudio Ай бұрын
@justinanderson181 most areas of Illinois are just as depressing as NW Indiana. The area up by Galena is quite nice tho
@PixelatedLlama
@PixelatedLlama Ай бұрын
@@justinanderson181 Central & Southern Illinois are the worst.
@Daniel-hj8el
@Daniel-hj8el Ай бұрын
Can you make video of ideas of improving VRE aside or include VPRA authorities to improve VRE/ Amtrak services?
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@Daniel-hj8el Evan is from the DMV so that can probably be arranged
@JoeyLovesTrains
@JoeyLovesTrains Ай бұрын
Why not just put an elevator in the island platform and create an overpass…
@JoeyLovesTrains
@JoeyLovesTrains Ай бұрын
Wtf, I though all trains were gonna use the viaduct lol.. why did they make the connection so poor???
@history_leisure
@history_leisure Ай бұрын
TOD on top of the old station, also remove the grade crossing just over the state line (like they could have elevated both branches in the Hammond Gateway area and make some adjustments to the yard on the other side to make it work. At that point, it would just make sense to shuttle people from East Chicago to Kensington and force Metra to run more trains (probably to Blue Island-like you could fully double track to West Pullman with a flyover to help with traffic flow- not that it helps allow more room for Monon Corridor trains). Also South Shore trains should serve Kensington after RLX opens since there would be busses connecting the two or a less than 1/2mi walk (not that most people would transfer there inbound unless they lived in that part of Chicago, but would provide access to Indiana Universities and Amtrak at Dyer or Homewood vs Union Station
@NWIndianaElevators
@NWIndianaElevators Ай бұрын
6:17 claps hands lights behind them turns on LOL
@jeffreysmith85
@jeffreysmith85 Ай бұрын
Need an underpass
@jeffreysmith85
@jeffreysmith85 Ай бұрын
What a pain for a new station
@jon9103
@jon9103 Ай бұрын
First comes fown to semantics of how you define BRT. Using the federal definition, the G line definitely isn't the first.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@jon9103 yeah but their definition kinda sucks
@sjd3l4l59
@sjd3l4l59 Ай бұрын
Really fun video, bravo! Thoughts: -I like the Purple Main Line Express, I'm not sure why you think it would mess with the Red Line, which just glancing at the schedule has the room. -Or: through-run the Pink and Orange via Wells and Van Buren, offsetting the imbalance created by the Green. I imagine this wasn't considered because off-peak Inner Wells/VB would have little service, but Purple ought to run all-day anyway. This would have the most-balanced load of the options, AFAICT. -Or: make the Brownge permanent, at least during rush. If Brown alternated between Brown and Brownge, it would match the Orange frequency. -And/Or: this may be absolute insanity, but could the relay house on the west of the Wells Elevated (just south of Tower 18) be moved? If so, a third track could be added there which could serve as a left-turn lane for the Pink and add capacity to the Tower 18 crossing.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@sjd3l4l59 Red Line schedule has the room *today*, but running trains more frequently is definitely a bigger priority than making the Purple Line a full express. Truly express trips from Evanston can be made on Metra. There’s a lot you could do to adjust service on the loop, but I’d generally say keep it at what it’s best at: being a loop. Brownage means trains serve certain stations exclusively northbound and others exclusively southbound, which is inconvenient and confusing for riders
@sjd3l4l59
@sjd3l4l59 Ай бұрын
@@thehouseoftransit2719 Ah, sorry, I didn't specify I'm imagining an all-day Purple, which would precisely be about adding off-peak frequency/capacity to the Red corridor with available equipment, with two bonuses: (1) express service, (2) giving the mainline and Metra a direct connection. Have you ridden on the Brownge before? In my experience, people handled it decently well despite the fact that no one even knew that was a thing and it was unmapped and unmarked. But completely agree it's not an ideal solution, I really only mention it because the CTA has been doing this so long it's the minimum-change option. My concern with turning the Pink back to a Blue branch is that you'd be left with 10-minute peak headways for Ashland/Morgan/Clinton which are fairly important stops. In the Purple Express option, the stops losing service would be retaining 5-minute peak headways.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@sjd3l4l59 aye but removing Pink from the loop enables you to run the Green more frequently to make up for that lost service
@sjd3l4l59
@sjd3l4l59 Ай бұрын
@@thehouseoftransit2719Apologies for going on, but I know I was really surprised when I dug into it: the headline ridership numbers don't tell the real story. You need to split the two Green branches to properly compare to Pink, Orange, etc, and then the totals give Ashland/Morgan/Clinton entirely to the Green Line (those 3 stops alone are 8k daily). Lake St L west of Ashland (10k daily for 11 stops) is comparably weak to the Pink (12k daily for 11 stops). South L's ridership is just 6.5k daily over 11 stops. At the very least the CTA ought to keep the 10-minute headways all-day for the Green, and they should run clockface on the South L branches (each branch gets 24-minute headways mid-day, pretty much unusable without clockface), but AFAICT the Green has a weak case for peak frequency additions. Edit: forgot to include the branch stops in South L.
@craigcook9715
@craigcook9715 Ай бұрын
There's a mathematical reason why frequent bus services "clump". As passengers wait on service, one bus going by picks them up, and then for the next bus on the line, there's often no passengers to pick up. So the second bus in the line will catch up to the one before it, potentially several collecting in a "bus pack" as you termed it. I've seen that in many cities. Seven, however, does seem like a lot. See en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_bunching
@airik-vlogs
@airik-vlogs Ай бұрын
I literally live in Redmond and there are somany buses I have never seen
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@airik-vlogs excited for the upcoming Link extension??
@davidsucks922
@davidsucks922 Ай бұрын
I live right off this line (my building is in this video lol) but have yet to take it. Likely will next weekend as family will be in town and I'll be taking them to pike place and the waterfront! Exciting stuff. Personally, despite the hiccups, I'm glad it's up and running,and that they aren't pausing service to address the issues like the timing of the lights and height of the platforms, considering how much Seattle tends to drag their feet on transit related improvements. Next problem to deal with is drivers hopping in the bus lanes... the G buses should have ticketing cameras on them if they don't already
@cuppajoe2
@cuppajoe2 Ай бұрын
The G line is great. Yes, it could and should be rail, but this was WAY cheaper to build than a light rail or subway line. And it’s really efficient compared to regular city bus service. It’s also the only rapid transit that connects to the valley, which is nice.
@DSAhmed
@DSAhmed Ай бұрын
ended smoking? (at 1:12) no. Every ride you smell cigarettes, weed, pee, or a homeless person's B.O. Edit: Ok, i totally missed the sarcasm.
@DSAhmed
@DSAhmed Ай бұрын
Excluding NYC (at 00:22) because NYC is the only one on par with Europe and Asia, and the bar would be so big the others would look like nothing.
@maxwellsmith9988
@maxwellsmith9988 Ай бұрын
i think that the rapid bus idea of BRT of being specialized bus lines is better than the often purported idea of putting a BRT somewhere as a "bus metro" is not a good idea that being said this place looks fairly dense and should eventually get some rail transit.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@maxwellsmith9988 agreed, BRT is best as an upgraded bus and not a rail substitute!
@BobaBuwan
@BobaBuwan Ай бұрын
It’s so funny you mentioned Cleveland because Maynard, one of the founding builders of the city of Seattle is FROM CLEVELAND, OHIO!😂💀
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@BobaBuwan surely explains why he helped create such an incredible city
@tedbellWRV
@tedbellWRV Ай бұрын
I know headways and other stats are important to many young BRT users, but I have to challenge BRT proponents to account for modern issues (i.e. post-1990's thinking). 1) with over 1M being sold in the US per year, e-bikes are becoming the norm and 1980's road racing bikes are becoming less common. That means bikes often weighing 70-80 lbs., and front and rear fenders (yes, even old fashioned conventional bikes in Seattle will have fenders). So bike storage solutions that are hostile to heavy e-bikes and front fenders are a problem. 2) The ADA was enacted at the federal level in the early 1990s, essentially based on accessibility laws from the 1970's (already in place in Washington State, California and New York). Today, accessibility needs go far beyond the minimums of the past that focused only on wheelchair access. Wheelchair design has evolved and more often than not is motorized too. In addition, a whole generation of mobility-impaired now struggle with knee replacement and other challenges that do not put them in a wheelchair, but do make stairs and steps and big obstacle. You can see one of the new generation of non-wheelchair mobility-impaired in your video crossing the street with her walker. In more recent years, buses have made a feeble attempt to address the stair/step issue with low-floor designs, that help, but do not solve accessibility issues.
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@tedbellWRV fully agree about the importance of ADA, but with low floor buses that board at level platforms I’m unclear on what your concern is? Also, I would think these internal bike racks would make it easier to load a large e-bike?
@tedbellWRV
@tedbellWRV Ай бұрын
@@thehouseoftransit2719 First of all, I very much appreciate your video. And yes, depending on the particular configuration, the low floor buses can help to get INTO the bus. However, once in the bus, the seating too often requires climbing up and down steps or steep ramps. The articulated flooring is not much better. All this presents a challenge for the millions of us with bad knees, etc. that are unsteady standing or going up and down levels. (Even though people like me are certified as disabled, we are not in wheelchairs.) Part of the issue, is that often the "main" level area of a low floor bus (or on a street car or light rail, for that matter) is set up for standing or in the case of your video, bicycles (or wheelchairs). I'm very pro bike on bus, as I was using KC Metro buses to commute into Pioneer Square going back 30 years. That said the bike storage you showed is for a lightweight, non-e-bike. Personally, I can lift my e-bike up - but many e-bikers are age 50 to 75 year old and especially smaller riders cannot lift an e-bike that weighs 75 to 80 lbs. Also, the U-shaped "hook" used to secure the top of the front wheel will conflict with the front fender, front rack and light often found on commuting bikes. The BRTs are alienating a rider group the transit agencies don't seem to recognize exists. There are millions of age 50 to 75 year olds forging a second car and are riding e-bikes to get around. This group would love to use transit to go Downtown and avoid parking, etc. Even without a bike, the "lame knee" crowd would love to ride transit to go to doctor appointments, entertainment, events, etc. My dream is the transit people that are seemingly hell-bent on BRT, figure out the challenges they are ignoring and find solutions.
@ninaschenk4039
@ninaschenk4039 Ай бұрын
0:45 bus leaves newly build station, instantly has to stop for a red light lol. guess signal priority wasnt in the budget
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@ninaschenk4039 yeahhh pretty big oversight
@CyanideCarrot
@CyanideCarrot Ай бұрын
The G Line absolutely *deserves* to be the best one, and it should be theoretically, they just didnt do the proper testing to make sure it actually works
@vette1
@vette1 Ай бұрын
any random suburb in Canada cooks yall on ridership
@thehouseoftransit2719
@thehouseoftransit2719 Ай бұрын
@@vette1 Canadian suburbs are built different I’m genuinely lost on how they perform so well
@jmstransit
@jmstransit Ай бұрын
Vancouver's rapidbus network is an express overlay to the existing frequent local bus corridors (4 trips an hour minimum), which is very different based on what I experienced taking the A-line for a few stops. As a result, ridership blows RapidRide out of the water.
@canyontiger4022
@canyontiger4022 Ай бұрын
This is what Omaha’s ORBT should have been. This is how you do bus transit!
@MelissaAndAlex
@MelissaAndAlex Ай бұрын
Cheap housing? Huh
@jackiecs8190
@jackiecs8190 Ай бұрын
Nice video! I know people give it a lot of shit, but I love the G
@SmallSpoonBrigade
@SmallSpoonBrigade Ай бұрын
They didn't figure this out when they were training the drivers? Normally when there's a new route there's some degree of actual drives by the drivers so they know what they're doing when they drive the route for the first time with passengers.
@SmallSpoonBrigade
@SmallSpoonBrigade Ай бұрын
It's worth noting that I've been seeing an increasing number of regular buses with additional ORCA card readers at their other doors. I haven't been keeping track of it, but I do wonder if that means that there's going to be more times when the just let everybody enter through all of the doors and just tap their cards on the way in.