3:22 the hive Tyrant is a tax, he's needed to make the faction work.
@EvilGranny4202 сағат бұрын
Counterpoint re- shining spear being bad Breakas make less attacks with worse wounding and are much slower with equal durability. And everyone thinks they’re cranked
@BryceHannigan2 сағат бұрын
The autarch wayleaper fell right off this list...
@im2randomghgh4 сағат бұрын
Do generic get outperformed by named characters even with enhancements factored in, or only in the absence of them?
Thursday State of Chaos Knights. "Solved faction." Spam Wardogs, sprinkle in deamons to taste, It really really needs a rebuild to be made interesting. And for the love of god, if you are going to make their theme Battle Shock tests, make them better.
@tbone73535 сағат бұрын
Time for gw to give some love back to my sister unbelievable not to see them in the top 20 our nerfs where unbelievable
@taylorlathem66545 сағат бұрын
If you were playing deathwatch and running 10 deathwatch vets, would you rather have them lead by a watch master or a judiciar??? Can’t decide right now
@CollinDavis-qv1vd5 сағат бұрын
generally, the watch master is better, with thief they slap just as hard, and the watchmasters free strat and extra movement stuff is more than worth it, deathwatch is an army that really wants to spend like 2-3 CP at a time so anything that makes it cheaper is great
@im2randomghgh4 сағат бұрын
Are you playing multiple 10 man blobs? That can affect the answer significantly. Also depends on your opponent. Against WE putting Judi in 10 watch in 5 is probably the way, but that's not always the case.
@JackDespero6 сағат бұрын
28:20 Excellent point. When some people complain that you cannot have 10 scions + command squad in transport, and thus why they are forced to take 10 scions alone, I ask them why not replace 5 scions by the command squad for mere 10 points? In my opinion, you should always make your scion blobs with 5+5. And then if you need a bigger one, you go for the 10+5. Other than the points from assassination, there is really no reason why you wouldn't want sustained hits, better weapons, self order, etc. for just 10 points!
@triplea657aaa7 сағат бұрын
I'd say Vahl, but this video is about the best units IN the meta...
@erictanis19797 сағат бұрын
Absolutely agree with John’s comment, when Orks shoots accurately and reliably to take out a T9-10 vehicle something has gone very wrong. Plus their jury rigged piece of junk is more powerful than a epic necron weapon…it’s silly.On top of that when Orks start getting orders like the guard, again very wrong. It’s getting close to the level of wrong the Eldar has previously with their fate dice where probability and randomness gets taken out of a dice game.
@JayzusKhrist6 сағат бұрын
Ehhh this is all a stretch. Read some Ork books and lore segments and get back to me. They make some pretty badass crazy powerful weapons in the lore. And, they’re constantly getting ordered around by warbosses and have loose military structures. It all makes sense. Also John and Nick gripe about ork characters and then immediately put a Rogal Dorn commander next with no mention of its rules being broken. Hypocrisy at its best 😂 love em both though
@TaylorX-g4b5 сағат бұрын
Idk man, orks have taken down titans canonically... General speaking though, yes, ork shooting should suck unless you really lean into it and then there is a way to make their jury rigged rokkit launcha somehow work well
@daa1855 сағат бұрын
If they didn’t want ork shooting units to be playable they shouldn’t sell them. Orks have always had a stack of shooting models. Having trash rules feels miserable. Most of the ork shooting range isn’t even viable. Heck they have tankbustas, lootas, flash gitz, shoota boyz, big meks with shokk attack guns, mek gunz, stompas, battlewagons, deff koptas, boss bunkas, boomdakka snazzwagons, kustom boosta blastas, megatrakk scrapjets, rukkatrukk squiggbuggys, shokkjump dragstas, blitza bommers, burna bommers, dakkajets, wazbom blastajets and warbikers. I’d say all of those are primarily shooting units. There’s even more shooting units that have more of a hybrid roll (like the rest of the dreads).
@daa1855 сағат бұрын
@@JayzusKhristOrders are especially lore accurate for blood axes, who are known for their relatively greater discipline and imitating some imperial battle practices.
@Backalleywizard7 сағат бұрын
Lord Discordant on Helstalker #1
@NANA-lq5md7 сағат бұрын
The best characters are the friends we made on the way.
@jonathanhaynes99147 сағат бұрын
Thanks John and Seigs
@weswtf8 сағат бұрын
Everyone knows the best character is the ministorum priest an auto take in every sisters, guard and agents list 😂
@christopherherrera86669 сағат бұрын
Anytime someone's main faction is being reviewed, you need to move the ranked faction a grade above what they put it imo. Quinton thinks its A? A+1= S. He's great but not objective. None of us are.
@stevenburton77259 сағат бұрын
Reaper’s Wager got super fun with the new Harlequin’s datasheets!
@youtousim10 сағат бұрын
Do the Guardian Battlehost Stratagems apply to the unit, even if it has a Seer Council, Farseer and Heavy Weapons Platform? Cause suddently rerolling wound rolls on an infiltrating, overwatching unit of that type sounds kinda scary.
@theophrastusbomblastus82111 сағат бұрын
Craftworlds will absolutely not be GT competitive with this codex as the AoW MFM leak points stand, they may win some lgs RTTs with lucky match ups but I doubt it. There just isn't enough points in 2000 and all the fiddly fluffy "tricks" will eat up the timer. The army rule being non-violent, ie not killy, for an unforgiving glass cannon style faction essentially constitutes a nerf that would require a 5-15% points reduction to every unit across the board, also the individual units that were genuinely nerfed, and there are many, very many would need an additional 5-15% point reduction as well. The detachment rules are weak in contrast to other factions, in some cases pathetic. For example, for a wraith host you have to take the Spirit Conclave detachment just to get the army rule at all for most of your units, mind you an army rule that is not very good to begin with. For all of the detachments there is only one good enhancement if that and maybe a niche second, and none of them are "wow" strong. The stratagems are decent across the board, but even the spiteful marine monkeys at GW can balance one point abilities. Something that might help is a small paragraph in the army rule that allows you to spend a token once per round for a command point reroll, something like that to put some shine on this totally lackluster army rule. The d6+1s should just be 6". Whoever wrote this codex either hates the eldar or is just plain stupid or both and the same holds true for whoever did the original points and the MFM leak changes. A fragile unit being able to duck behind cover after being shot is just worthless, less even on a random roll. My feeling is that the playerbase and GW at large are so prejudiced against the eldar that this is a hopeless faction for the remainder of 10th ed. I predict this will be the lowest point in the eldar's long and storied 40k history, probably by design.
@ArtofWar40k11 сағат бұрын
The MFM points are not a leak, that is a preview of the official MFM launching alongside the Codex.
@jeancouscous10 сағат бұрын
You read as a terrible player
@eldenwarden967311 сағат бұрын
Nick used to be the main eldar guy for AoW, Quinton actually loves the faction though and you can tell.. cheers guys
@jacklenz184112 сағат бұрын
The biggest thing about this codex is I think it can actually be balanced with points or other numerical changes if it ends up too powerful.
@einrauser610312 сағат бұрын
"Fun" is the current code word for broken.
@theophrastusbomblastus82112 сағат бұрын
Actually it is people covering for how bad this codex is.
@y00rch11 сағат бұрын
It is what you would expect with eldar, shenanigans, speed, violence and extreme fragility. That is always difficult to balance but is the archetype
@swabilius13 сағат бұрын
I just wish this was a video :)
@swabilius13 сағат бұрын
15 games , did I hear that right, what can Men do against such reckless hate!
@TerryG6713 сағат бұрын
Finally, the REAL Eldar Codex review we've all been waiting for.
The amount of times I heard, "that's pretty good" (echoed back-and-forth 3 times) and not a single, "it's probably overpowered/broken."
@everettcolby8976Күн бұрын
Yall are sleeping on the shadow weaver 😅
@erikvogas687Күн бұрын
Fantastic assessment! So helpful, and even more so now with the Halo Screed detachment available. Many thanks!!!
@jonathandavis9118Күн бұрын
Sounds like a great codex. Sisters, in particular, have no chance against it, due to the fade stratagem. The idea is first you shoot something with an immolator for ignore cover, THEN you shoot for a castigator so you get plus one AP....then you shoot a 3rd castigator.
@SamuelRodriguez-y2cКүн бұрын
How is that bit about the Troupe Master consolidating back into a transport without a token? The TM skill says you have to get closer to the closest enemy unit, right? Got confused there and would love to understand what's am I not getting here bc that's a sick trick.
@ProAntagonistYT7 сағат бұрын
the star*weaver transport allows them to consolidate back in. the TM just gives a 6inch consolidate instead of 3 now.
@ald5979Күн бұрын
29:10 can you explain lethal hits on 5?
@bryanramsey9129Күн бұрын
Shout out to Brown magic from the guy in the smoke pit!!! Yall are incredible 🎉 to anyone who hasn’t met you it was great and it was truly pleasant to meet you.
@ArtofWar40kКүн бұрын
@@bryanramsey9129 it was great meeting you too!
@sakkiebasson2052Күн бұрын
Either of those aeldari games harlequins?
@ArtofWar40kКүн бұрын
Harlequins will be in a battle report in February!
@jakestevanus1807Күн бұрын
Thanks, guys.
@rottenice5837Күн бұрын
Shouldn't eat peanut butter during interviews
@YoruUesugiКүн бұрын
Awesome video!
@finnhowell5943Күн бұрын
I have a question about the Ynnari Transport thing: The "Servants of the Whispering God" rule states that ASURYANI Units are becoming "YNNARI Units". The Falcon/Wave Serpent Rule says "It cannot transport "YNNARI models". As Far as i understand it from previous rules like Spiritseer joining a Wraithlord. That Unit and Model Keywords are different. So if thats true, arnt ASURYANI in YNNARI still no YNNARI Models, but the Unit is YNNARI and therefore are able to embark into an Falcon/Wave Serpent? Im not sure about this, thats just how i understand it and pls correct me if im wrong. Thx for the awesome video. <3
@G-enomeКүн бұрын
My guy was stunned that he spends his entire life trying to win tournaments 8 hours a day and then Mark just rolls in with all the carefree opposite strats and wins 😂
@dicetroyКүн бұрын
Why there are no Ynanri Drukhari points in the MFM section? I was so curious if the book ones are final 😢
@CalebWalsh-fx8bdКүн бұрын
Guardian detachment's rule cover Dire Avengers too!