Are there many human drivers out there that don't know a flashing red light is the same thing as a stop sign?
@Vardraq2 сағат бұрын
38:42 This is very interesting to me as German (EU). We have a clear hierarchy Police > Lights > Signs > General traffic rules. So, if a traffic light is out, or blinks yellow for some reason, you need to fall back to the signs, which tell whether you have right of way, have to yield, have to stop. And if there are no signs (which is unlikely the case when there is a traffic light put up), it is right before left. I hope FSD will understand that hierarchy and understand the general traffic rules to be applied when there are neither lights nor signs. Currently I see Tesla's autopilot do so much stupid mistakes, which has me really concerned. But then also, the Autopilot version outside US is basically archaic in comparison to what it can do in the US.
@GKingdom18 сағат бұрын
Chuck, thank you for taking the time to do this. Your camera skills are top-notch. I wanted to know if I could pay you for your time to make another 3D-printed bracket like you had to cover up the wire on top.
@Wol74710 сағат бұрын
RELYING on HD mapping is not a viable avenue: who is going to pay for hourly updates of the maps even if it worked? Even updating at that frequency or even more doesn’t work - there’s a huge difference between having a human overseeing the car and the car being totally autonomous, which for me necessitates the ability to adapt by sensing the real world instead of relying on a database.
@agoatmannameddesire885612 сағат бұрын
I think the two video streams got unsync'd a few minutes in (screen HDMI feed vs cabin video)
@RubenKelevra14 сағат бұрын
I wonder if your car has an alignment issue. Your steering angle is always around 1-1.5° to the right, while you're going straight, while the steering wheel is slightly pointing to the left (hard to tell exactly because of camera distortion tho) :)
@seattlevienna14 сағат бұрын
The screen recording is out of sync by like 1-2 seconds. Just a heads up
@brianp838415 сағат бұрын
Thanks Chuck. With all the drone coverage of various Tesla facilities, have you heard of anyone spotting testing of driverless cyber cabs?
@allieflounder576415 сағат бұрын
Got it today and it is far and away the best update yet. The only issue I had was lane staging. Otherwise flawless, smooth and finally an end to the constant throttle push. Nice video chuck!
@richt.490015 сағат бұрын
🇬🇧Love your channel from this side of the pond here in England 🏴. However, I think this is a badly thought out and designed piece of Cyberkit. IMO, the Cybertruck is the equivalent of the iPhone compared to old mobile phones, it’s a game changer! Why would anybody make you look away from your normal, safe driving view? 🧐The View in the Tesla screen was just as badly designed & positioned, sometimes ‘no part isn’t the best part’. If this accessory is going to be a game changer, utilise the area for the sun visor. Imagine if you had a large, wide screen for your sun visor that displayed your left, rear, and right hand side views.
@owerobbi18 сағат бұрын
Speaking to AJ’s question about attention monitoring being more aggressive, I can’t fully speak to it but it is very aggressive when you have a hat on that black the camera. I often sit in a way that my hat barely covers my eyes and the camera barely even gives me any time before it defaults to requiring the wheel torque. I wish I gave me more than 2 or so seconds
@eruveo19 сағат бұрын
i wish tesla stopped removing essential driving safety features like the rear mirror, like stalks, like real horn, like the sw wiper button a few years ago.
@MrTechfreak9519 сағат бұрын
Always nice to watch. :) But this time the Screen + Kamera video is de-synced by ~2sec
@ChuckCook19 сағат бұрын
Sorry about that
@MrTechfreak9519 сағат бұрын
@@ChuckCook No worries, watched it till the end anyway. :) Interesting thoughts/inputs about HW 3 from AJ. That begs the question when a upgrade from HW3 will be necessary. Till we here in Europe get FSD... will be a few more years anyway.
@TeslaFSDBetaVideos20 сағат бұрын
So disappointing to see that it still can't figure out how to brake properly to use regen instead of using the friction brakes for every stop with clear visibility from far away that there's going to be a red light or stop sign.
@rockafeller9421 сағат бұрын
Currently running 12.5.4.2 & totally relate to your first issue of the car, not being able to recognize traffic speed accurately 40 mph+. Completely agreed that it pokes around too much and just needs to commit to a pull out. It wants to feel out traffic too much still.
@garymunson249322 сағат бұрын
Thank you, Chuck! You are one of the reasons FSD will come sooner than later. That (AND you) will be responsible for MANY saved lives and avoided injuries!
@ChuckCook21 сағат бұрын
I appreciate your support.
@kdub166623 сағат бұрын
Chuck keeps milking a need for the question mark. Not me. No need to spend more time in the line of fire or complicate interactions with cars in the median waiting to turn left. Leave well enough alone.
@ChuckCook21 сағат бұрын
I agree that it's not always necessary, but I like to see how it reacts in different situations.
@appa831323 сағат бұрын
Hi Chuck! How’s the quality at nighttime? Any chance you could film another video to show what it’s like in the dark?
Very important that the map data includes current traffic control and speed limits in addition to the car using visual clues for safe driving.
@JamesBond-qv2htКүн бұрын
I am installing it now.
@RubenKelevraКүн бұрын
The audio channels are flipped and the recording of the screen has a lag of 2-3 seconds
@malteohlsson2061Күн бұрын
Screen recording is slightly off sync. Otherwise great vid!
@raymiller5738Күн бұрын
Re line markings which are not painted to standard. It would seem the Tesla's FSD is real good at finding inconsistencies. I'm in two minds where the road authorities should fix the issue or the car FSD should lean to handle it. My preference would be the road authorities should correct to the standard as other drivers would also get confused. I remember driving this year in Canada and one of the eastern states make a real mess of highway turning lanes. Both FDS and this driver made the same mistake and ended up on the wrong side of the road! The state makings for centre lane turning across oncoming traffic were following some weird local standard different to everywhere else. Maybe Tesla should be alerting/working with the local authorities to fix the corner cases and improve the safety for everyone.
@genmilkКүн бұрын
Slowing down for cars with blinker on is a long time feature since v11. I often use that to take advantage of Teslas.
@mariusmeyer14Күн бұрын
Thanks Chuck for sharing. Pity the mirror could not interface with the existing cameras but I'm sure this is going to be a good addition to the Cybertruck. Love the 3D printed cover.
@jamesmcneal1821Күн бұрын
Hey Chuck or AJ, have you guys ever used FSD when a deer ran out in front of you? If so, did FSD handle it appropriately?
@techgeekteslaКүн бұрын
Hi Chuck and AJ! 👋👋
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
Hey there! Thanks for watching.
@paragoneКүн бұрын
16:11 again! The lane lines! Look down at the lane lines. I’ve noticed that FSD “follows the rules” sometimes where a human wouldn’t. If you look at the way the exit lane lines are painted, you can see it stays solid - for too long. And FSD just obeys that solid until it breaks.
@jessiejanson1528Күн бұрын
Might also be because he changed the navigation. The path vanished and recalculate while at the exit.
@paragoneКүн бұрын
18:45 I think this wasn’t a “bad lane change” just FSD following the rules too closely. If you look at the visualization, the lane lines don’t break into dashes until really late - and FSD doesn’t like to cross solid lines, so it waits until the break in the lines, and then it moves over.
@paragoneКүн бұрын
It’s really poorly drawn lane lines.
@originalambivalКүн бұрын
On AI4 with advanced updates and just got 12.5.4.2 yesterday.
@tonyfromaus7855Күн бұрын
Thanks Chuck once again. Great stuff. If you get time could you please do some parallel parking between two cars? It was slow and mediocre previously…. has it got better? Can it park in tight spots? Is it quicker or as quick as a human? Thanks for these vids.
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
Great idea
@health101DOTorgКүн бұрын
But when getting off the highway, "HURRY" disappeared and "50" was still there for at least another 5 seconds before it changed to 35. Hmmm.
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
I have seen two different timing's on this now, so I am a bit confused now.
@quedokidКүн бұрын
Where is the screen turn signal pop-up window? It never shows entire video. Hardware 3 recognizes other cars blinking turn signals, and slows Tesla to let them move over. Annoying when other car is too cautious or is errant blinker. It is very accurate, when other car is tapping brake lights it does not seem to fool it, it must be a turn blinker.
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
I have it turned off for filming, so it doesn't block the screen. That is a selectable option.
@kiankhan07Күн бұрын
I would love to see AJ's HW3 car on the first impressions route
@MrTechfreak9519 сағат бұрын
Oh yes that would be great. :)
@tulio1711Күн бұрын
486 / 5,000 Chuch...at many times you are so comfortable in your conversation with the passenger who accompanies you! At times the conversation is physically like a conversation in a living room and not like a driver in action on the streets of a city. Impressive, especially being one of those drivers who are more focused and attentive when they are driving. It really is impressive that you are having a social experience while an autonomous car is dominant in driving the vehicle.
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
Thank you for the feedback and support.
@Klaatu_Күн бұрын
Thank you for making the video. I too had bought this kit and it is nice to see the job I have ahead of me. I too wanted to mount the rear camera in the same spot. I don't have a 3-D printer. If you are printing mounting brackets I would gladly pay you if you can make one for me. It is going to be nice turning on the blinder and not loosing the review. I was however thinking of mounting the front camera on the glass behind the back seat in the cab so I can easily see if my load has shifted during transport. You really don't need a front camera because CT already has one already.
@Klaatu_20 сағат бұрын
Sorry I now see you included a link for 3D Print Housing. Darn it is just the files. Now I just need to find someone to print it.
@accumapmodelsКүн бұрын
Thanks Chuck.
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
I'm glad you enjoyed it.
@rebellionair3Күн бұрын
Wow, this one seems unreal except for some slight stylistic errors. Curious to see how it goes from here, Chuck.
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
I think you're right, it was surprisingly good in many ways.
@138porscheКүн бұрын
Is it just me or is there a 2sec delay on the overlayed screen data? Appreciate the vid!
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
This was an editing mistake by me. Your keen eye is one of the few that have noticed. Thanks for the feedback. This is on me.
@knewhunter1Күн бұрын
As long as the programmers stick to the coffee cup test, the car will never do a fast U-turn.
@jessiejanson1528Күн бұрын
If it has to see what's in front before moving, then a u turn must be slow since if it went fast the front camera wouldn't process the images fast enough. Having more frames per second could allow for faster turns.
@accumapmodelsКүн бұрын
Thanks Chuck.
@beehappy7797Күн бұрын
Great entertainment as usual. Getting better with every update.
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
Glad you enjoy it!
@routyboutyКүн бұрын
52...51...50...49...48...47...46mph. Still refuse to use until they fix this bug.
@alexp.6406Күн бұрын
I’m still on 5.4.3 and it slams on the brakes HARD at greenlight intersections with no other cars or pedestrians around, it’s really getting old. Hopefully it’s fixed in …..6.3?
@DevinOlsenКүн бұрын
Really hoping that this goes wide, I love the E2E and driver profiles.
@aminesaibКүн бұрын
A question for AJ. AJ, I'm on the same version as you with HW3. One of my main complaints is how it handles red and green lights-often hesitating or braking hard even when the light is green. I think it tends to happen when the intersection is busy. Have you experienced the same thing?
@silberlinieКүн бұрын
Hey Chuck, I want to tell you that your sound system needs to change the left channel to the right channel. Because when you watch this video, it sounds reversed.
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
thankyou
@scotsrule08Күн бұрын
Chuck, thank you for all you do. I can only imagine how much work you put into this passion project of documenting FSD but I just want you to know it doesn’t go unnoticed!
@ChuckCookКүн бұрын
Thanks, I appreciate that. It's a lot of work, but I enjoy it.