ታላቅ የክርክር መድረክ!

[@Gololsha]

እጅግ ምርጥ ውይይት ነው ብዙ ነገር ተምሬበታለሁ ሁለታችሁንም አመሰግናለሁ፡፡መሰል ምሁራዊ ውይይቶች መቀጠል አለባቸው፡፡

[@genetmechal7333]

kzbin.infoHUsDRyhOs5M?si=dcSScoEu4EgqGhE5

[@alemtedan2431]

ሞገስ ሐሳቡን ወደ ጠረቤዛ በማሞጣትሕ እናመስግናለን በግሌ የይሳቅን ሐሳብ ሙሉ በሙሉ ኦገዛዋለሁ ዛክ እንደሁሌው በርታልን

[@thaile9751]

ይስሐቅ ጥሩ ተናጋሪ ነው ግን ነገሮችን ለእሱ እንደሚመቸው አንዳንድ ነገሮችን ያለቦታው ይደነቅራል:: ልክ ኢትዮጵያ የተለየች አገር ወይንም ሌላ አገር ላይ ያልተደረገ ነገር እንደተደረገ አስመስሎ ያቀርባል:: እና አሁን ዛሬ ኦሮሞውች የምያደርጉትን ነገር ነገ ለልጆቻችን ነግረን ነገ ደግሞ አጸፋ መመለስ ይመጣል::

[@mafi635]

@@thaile9751 you are exactly what he said, but issac’s idea is the only option for peace in Ethiopia 🇪🇹

[@genetmechal7333]

kzbin.infoHUsDRyhOs5M?si=dcSScoEu4EgqGhE5

[@adamushagermosusha2910]

Thank u so much, guys . Isak, your answers are perfect and reality. Thank you

[@asfawn.beyene1200]

ይስሃቅ ድንቅ አድርገህ የብሄር-ብሄረሰብን መሠረታዊ ጉዳዮችን አቅርበሃል እናመሰግናለን!

[@genetmechal7333]

kzbin.infoHUsDRyhOs5M?si=dcSScoEu4EgqGhE5

[@maryadam215]

This guy is brilliant! Moges, hope this was a learning experience for you.

[@solomontesfaye1643]

ይስሀቅ፥ በጣም የማከብርህና የማደንቅህ ሰው ነህ።ኢትዮጵያ፤ እንዳንተ፤ ያለ፤ ሰው ይብዛላት🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@tesfaywoldemariam8010]

I really wanted to thank you both. It is my second time listening to Moges's debate, and do need to listen to some parts again but you guys rock. I say keep it up. Great discussion!

[@rashadabajihad5991]

Thank you Isaac for your expression with evidence. And also thank you moges for your invitation.

[@saidaman6424]

My appreciation to both of you. Such progressive and eye opening discussions should dominate the airwaves. Keep up the good work.

[@James-oj8kq]

Ishak very good and well organized debate. Moges’s was very confusing and he denied historical injustices. His argument was logically incoherent. Ishak 10/10😊

[@bellaethio4426]

This debate wasn't eiser historical or future, the topic is what's going on right now. I don't think moges confused. You confused brother, sorry

[@yonasd64]

Such open discussions of opposing ideas is absolutely fascinating and should be encouraged to continue. I learned a lot from both perspectives. It's so refreshing to see people coming together to share their unique perspectives and engage in thoughtful, respectful dialogue. This kind of open-mindedness and willingness to consider different viewpoints is what leads to real growth and understanding. Cheers to both gentlemen!

[@thombahre1735]

This guy is he knows what he talk Wow give him a big ❤

[@josefjalatadhaba9905]

Thank you both of you for such a detailed discussion

[@memiahmed-eu1er]

እስሃቅ በጣም የማደንቅህ የታሪክ አስተማሪ ጭምር ነህ ። ሞገስ ግን ሚዘናዊ መሆን ሞክር ማንበብም ሞክር ትንሽ እውቀት ያንስሃል

[@billowaaree5609]

የኢሳቅ የአሃዳዊነት ገለፃ በጣም ትክክል ነው

[@dkw9669]

ስለ አሃዳዊነት አንብብ መጀመሪያ።

[@tbarekyohannes]

@@dkw9669ሰለ አህዳውነት ባይንብ ኑሮ በኢሳቅ በኩል የተነገረው ትክክል ነው አይልም ነበር ለማንኛውም ሰለ አህዳውነት ያንበበከው ካለ ለምን መጽሕፍ አትጠቅሰውም?

[@dkw9669]

@@tbarekyohannes ለምን google አድርገህ ስለ unitary system አታነብም

[@Tube-bi4eu]

ኢሳቅ እሸቱ ከምር አንተ ማለት መፅሐፍ ነህ። ጥሩ ውይይት ነበር በርቱልን ❤❤❤

[@seidahmed-kd5er]

መፅሀፍ ለማያነብ ደደብ ትልቅ እውቀት ሊመስልህ ይችላል

[@Tube-bi4eu]

@@seidahmed-kd5er ምን ታደርገው ቁስልህን ነካካብሀ አይዞሽ ጌጤ

[@seidahmed-kd5er]

@@Tube-bi4eu ደደብ የደደብ ቋንቋ ነው የሚገባው ።አዲስ ነገር ማመንጨት የማይችል አይምሮ በታሪክ ልዩነት ላይ ተቸንክሮ ይቀራል

[@Tube-bi4eu]

@@seidahmed-kd5er በቃ ከአፋችሁ ፀያፍ ንግግር ከመናገር ውጪ ሌላ ነገር አታውቁም አይ ቆ*ጬ

[@seidahmed-kd5er]

@@Tube-bi4eu ቆምጬም ጋላም አብዛኛው ደደብ ህዝብ ነው

[@ethiocanada2876]

Very nice discussions, I wish many learn from this .

[@የሀሳብገበታ-BuffetofIdeas]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@nebaabd]

ዋው ይሰሐቅ በጣም አሳመኝ ያለፈውንም የአሁኑንም ተአመኒ እና ተጨባጭ በሆነ መልኩ አቅርበሃል ሞገስም እንዲህ አይነት ውይይት ማቅረቡ ጥሩ ነው ግን ሞገስ የተባሉት ትክክል ገላጭ መሆኑን ቢረዳም ላለመቀበል የሚያስቸግረው ነገር አለ

[@AlemAraya-x7d]

Your discussion is eye opening, it should be appreciated. Yisak, to my knowledge, you are really the one who is very clear and articulative in explaining the root cause of the curse of the country, Ethiopia.

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Moges Masaya lay endet new Shaleka Dawit Wolde Giorgisn yaltekeskew? meri honew yetemeretu Main stream eco nachew!

[@samethio8594]

Thanks!

[@dabalebonsa1138]

Thank you Isak, you did it well.

[@aliadil8141]

Ishaq is on another level. አጥቦ ነው ያሰጣው።

[@mahmedyezid187]

ይስሀቅ ሀሳብ ሙሉ በሙሉ ደግፋለው

[@adamushagermosusha2910]

Talk Ethiopia thank u so much for the best analysis and deeply expressing the truth

[@mamushgope1650]

Bravo Isaq you are ever great

[@g.t6746]

Thank you Brother Isaac your explanation is loud and clear ኢትዮጵያ ለ ዜጎችዋ ጨቋኝ እንነበረች በትክክል ገልጸህዋል።

[@abdumohammed8560]

Respect for both ishak and moges for your courage to come forward and question ideologies.may God bring peace 💚💛❤️

[@rubeeshaatii3400]

Thank you Yishaq

[@fikrebobo1370]

ይሥሓቅ እድሜህ ይርዘም።

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Moges lezemenat yekoye chigir bande yistekakelal teblo yitasebal? tiyakeh tinsh?

[@henoksisay1224]

moges jegna berta

[@Adikaadika-pq4je]

ኢሳቅ ምርጥ አገላለጽ ጀግና👌👌👌👌👌🤮💪💪💪💪💪🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@danielzenebe4575]

የአባ ቦራዉ ጊቢ ምርጥ አይዛክ በርታ። ምጌ በጣም ጥሩ አደረክ ይች ናት ኢትዮጵያ ቀጥልበት።

[@assefaregassa1396]

Betam yemegerm agelalets new ye Eshetu agelalets! Thank you both!

[@gezaashu3132]

I appreciate both you for bringing this topic to the table. On my observation, Issac was super, but Mages tried to deny the truth.

[@haftomembaye]

thank you isak you are talking with evidence thank thank you isakye

[@tamentega4751]

Ehetu, you’re the best and the most truthful person! You and Ass Prof Assefa Wodajo are the only 2 Men of their truth words!!! Igziabiher idimehin yibark! Ye Amhara elites yezih iwunet telatoch nachew!! Love you, Eshetu! Moges you’re #1 to facilitate this debate!!! You deserve respect!!

[@HabteTisasse-hq5my]

Are the individuals mentioned by isaq really represent all z amhara people?😊

[@edentilahun2919]

የሚያስፈራቸው የአሀዳዊነት መመለስ ሳይሆን(ከነሱ በላይ አሀዳዊ ሲጀመር የለም) ሀገሬ ብሎ በድህነት ቢኖር በክልሌ ለምን በሰላም ኖርክ ብለው ያፈሰሱት ደም ነው የሚያቅበዘብዛቸው....የህፃናትና የእናቶችን ደም ፈጣሪ በከንቱ አያስቀረውም...ሁሉም የስራውን ያገኛል

[@andygebrzgie5633]

What Amazing discussion you guys have.especiallly Yisak was a good listener, polite and he present himself with facts .

[@yusufmohammed4958]

ሞገስ እጅግ እጅግ ድንቅ ጋዜጠኛ እንደሆንክ ይህን ጋዜጠኛና አክቲቪስት ነኝ ባይን ሰዉዬ ቡቱቱ አድርገኸዋል ራሱ ፅንፈኛ ሆኖ ፅንፈኝነትን እታገላለዉ የሚል ብዙ ያላነበበ እና ገና ብዙ የማያዉቅ ጎጠኛ መሆኑን ግልፅ ያወጣህበት ዉይይት ነዉ አሀዳዊነት አለ ብሎ የገለፀበት መንገድ አላዋቂነቱን ያወቅንበት ዉይይት ነዉ።

[@ST-lt2rw]

ድንቅና መለመድ ያለበት ነፃ መድረክ👏👏👏

[@yeshiwondwoldekidan7173]

Do you know the alfabet the one you reading now is Do you know the ortdox gives you?

[@abrahammikru4270]

በመከራከሪያ ጥያቄው ላይ የመረዳት ችግር ያለ ይመስላል ጥያቄው አሀዳዊነትን መዋቅራዊ መመሪያ አድርጎ የሚንቀሳቀስ የፖለቲካ ስራት የሚያራምድ ፓርቲ አለ ወይ ነው፡፡

[@yerowako8507]

Moges zare teshenefehal

[@keepwalking6910]

Thanks outstanding show. As always, your dedication and efforts never cease to impress. I particularly wanted to acknowledge Isak for his remarkable presentation in this show .His ability to articulate his point of view was truly impressive and thought-provoking. On a different note, I believe it is essential for us, as Ethiopians, to confront a harsh reality, one that we often overlook: our reputation for arrogance. It is imperative that we acknowledge and show remorse for the oppression experienced by our fellow citizens. Only by doing so can we begin the process of healing and establishing a more united and compassionate society. Furthermore, it is crucial to address a section of individuals from the northern regions who have taken to terrorism as a means of expressing their grievances. It is essential for these individuals to understand that the past cannot be reversed, and we must collectively work towards a brighter future, leaving behind the dark times that have plagued our nation. In conclusion, let us never forget that unity and understanding are the foundation of any prosperous society. By facing our shortcomings and learning from our mistakes, we can pave the way towards a more harmonious Ethiopia.

[@belaynehfantaye8486]

ሁለታችሁም ትክክል ናችሁ፣ ተግባብታችኋል፣ ያልተግባባችሁት ከአገላለፅ ልዩነት ነው፣ ሞገስ የሕግ/ጠበቃ ባለሞያ ነው መሰለኝ ነገሮችን ሲገልፅ ባጭሩ ነው፣ ይዝሐቅ ያንን ለመተንተን ተስኖታል/ጊዜ ያስፈልገዋል። አንዳንዴም የሰፈር ወሬን እንደማስረጃ ያቀርባል። ለሁለታችሁም ታላቅ አክብሮት አለን፣ እናመሰግናለን።

[@ninaabay2140]

Viva Issac very good explanation!

[@manyalewbogale7155]

ቋንቋ ኢትዮጵያ ውስጥ አማርኛው ባይኖር በምን ቋንቋ እንማር ነበር ? 1:21:20 በዛን ሰአት የነበሩ ቋንቋችሁን አትናገሩ ተብሎ በህግ ወይንም በማንኛውም ዘዴ ተከልክሎ ነበር ወይ ?

[@assocakazama9269]

ምርጥ ውይይት ነው! ሞገስ ሰሞኑን የምታዘጋጃቸው ፕሮግራሞች ጥሩ ናቸው ቀጥልበት! ይስሃቅ እጅግ የሚደንቅ ዝግጅት አድርገህ ነው የቀረብከው! አህዳዊውን አስተሳሰብና የዘመናችንን ቅሪቶች ትርክት በሚገባ ግልጸሃል! ቀጥልበት! ይስሃቅ ማለት የፌዴራሊስት ህይሉ ዋነኛ ጠበቃ እንደሆንክም አስመስክረሃል! በተረፈ ዕውቀትህና አቀራረብህ ብስለትህ የሚደነቅ ነው! ቀጥልበት!

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Moges programun astafi lemadreg 3 seat kuch blo lademete sew 2 dekika beki new? tinsh degnet chemrbet ena, bayihon 3 dekika argat!

[@hiwotfentahun5382]

በርቱ እንደዚ አይነት ውይይት ይበረታታል👍

[@mohammedyousuf2432]

Bravo Eshetu! Mogos this is not your problem because you are the beneficiary of the system and you keep fighting for unitary system.

[@filmtub8067]

የይሳቅ ብሔር ምንድነው?

[@novelethio9891]

የወሎ ኦሮሞ

[@sabitzakir-ww9ic]

Moges thanks for your platform

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Moges pls be Focused! areb ager mehed lemin asfelege?

[@elemoabdu9201]

Wow esak just wow! Perfect bro 😎

[@rahamahussen3479]

ዋዉ ከሰማሁት በኃላ አደነኩህ

[@eliassani141]

ሞጎሴ ደፈጣጭ አለ ወቅቱ ስለሚፈቅድ መደፈጡ ተገቢ ነው የሚል እምነት በምን መሥፈርት ነው ፍትሃዊ የሚሆነው?

[@TefedppmTefedppm]

Good point and issac is very good ,truth regarding to political issue of Ethiopia .

[@adera9371]

በጣም ቆንጆ አስተማሪ ውይይት

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Moges Siltan beMerit bicha yihun yemilew manew? I think here and there yalewun yagere gezinet bota teklilo meyaz yemifelg new!

[@genetdagem2409]

ይሳቅ በጣም ጎበዝ ነህ በርታ ያንተን ድምፅ ለሁላችንም ይጠቅማል

[@kirosaberra4615]

Too bad, Moges get lost himself in a corn maze field. He seems too young to understand what Ethiopians have gone through to change unjust governments that Ethiopia and Ethiopians had to endure!! Moges, if you openly listen to this gentleman, you will learn and get free yourself from whatever propaganda you willingly allowed to have fed!! Never seen a person who studied law and advocates former and current criminals, wake up and do not try to defend obvious injustices that have happened to the Ethiopian people!!

[@ethiocomment1707]

I'm surprised how much moges is not open to understand simple logic, I think he is blind by love of old Ethiopia. Open your brain and try to discuss like a foreigner. On the other hand, the guest is brilliant, and he is fine to be corrected, and he never interrupted. Moges is a master of interruption.

[@firehiwotefirem6034]

በጣም የሚመቸኝ ነው ሰላየሁት ደስ ብሎኛል

[@newlife2805]

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏ሞገስና ይሳቅ በጣም ደስ የሚል እና እንዲሰፋ የሚበረታታ👏👏👏

[@fekaduf.dinssa5022]

Moges, you are amazing person to organize this program. If we really like our country, we need such kind of forum that brings people from all

[@sibhatgebregzabher2349]

ይሳቅ እሸቱ የምታቀርበው ነገር እውነትነት አለው እንዲያውም ይመስለኛል አንተ ጋር ብዙ የቪዲዮ ማስረጃዎች እንዳሉክ ይገባኛል የምታቀርበው ሃሳብ በሙሉ መቶ በመቶ እጋረዋለው

[@humanityjustice6933]

Isaac=90% and Moges=30%

[@markogr112]

ሀገሬ በጠማማ ሰዎች ተሞላች። እኔ ብነግስ እንደ ይሳህቅ አይነቱን ከምድር ላይ አጠፋለው። የአማራ ጥላቻ ይደፋሀል እንጂ አማራ ገና ይለመልማል። 1 ኢትዮጵያ

[@jemilferej6518]

በጣም ቆንጆ መደረክ ነው።

[@kartikazad5012]

Waw is was good discussion izaq ❤

[@mesfinabebe1582]

በጣም ጥሩ ሙጉት ብቻ ሣይሆን አስተማሪም ነው። በርቱ❤❤❤

[@mieessaayaachis2336]

"አገር በብዝሃዊ መልክና ማንነት ስትገለጥ ምቾት ያለመሰማት...." definitionኑ ተመችቶኛል። በጣም ግልፅነት ተንፀባርቆበታል። ዜጎች በዚህ መልኩ ቢገነዘቡና ለውይይት ቢዘጋጁ ወደ መግባባት እንደርስ ነበር።

[@genetmechal7333]

kzbin.infoHUsDRyhOs5M?si=dcSScoEu4EgqGhE5

[@yosephtefera4584]

ይሳቅ አውነት በጣም ጀግና ሰው ነክ. አውነት ከ ማስረጃ ጋር ማለት አንደዚህ ነው ❤❤

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Yishag kebher poletica mewutat endalebn minim yemiyateyayik ayidelem! pls yebiher poletica poletical correctnes endelelew endet lante yiseweral!

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Moges & Isaac lemehonu gemgami dagna ale weis endet new? yetemerete dagna binor tiru new! kalhonem Accountability Partner ship Team beyeglm bihon binorachihu tiru new.

[@badhanetussa2658]

Well done Isahak eshetu 👍

[@mernu2003]

Great analysis Yisehak

[@eskenderalemayehu2915]

Dear Mogos, I wanted to take a moment to express my deep appreciation for your exceptional skills as a lawyer and debater. Your ability to analyze complex and often intricate legal matters, coupled with your eloquence in presenting your arguments, truly sets you apart. Wishing you continued success and many more accomplishments in your new show and debating journey. I am confident that your remarkable talents will undoubtedly make your show a talking point in Ethiopia and beyond. Warmly,

[@James-oj8kq]

he is not great at all. He is so so ignorant

[@Kaleb1988]

You’re betraying the fact that Moges lost every bit of his debating points severely. He’s so ideal and trying to rationalize a very loosely configured motto of oneness in a very diversified nation like ours. All the monarchial emperors he praise centralized their power based on the root of their origination. All minorities smashed within the personal identity of Ethiopian kings in-terms of language, religion, cultural and traditional variables. Not only minorities; the unique identity of Oromo people got diminished purposely in order to conquer its geographical territory to collect its resource so that they can strengthen their power. Fighting for the theme of equality can never be categorized as failure. The setbacks of TPLF and its rhetoric can’t demonize the main concept of federalism and confederation. Ethiopia can never be unitary but federation only. And The wide majority of her citizens believe that. Even the Amhara start to fight in order to administer itself by its own administrators. Swallow that fact or your country will disintegrate Infront of your eyes in the near future. ..Moderate yourself!!

[@1978monas]

Moges is very intelligent. His argument is real and well grounded. As a Muslim I appreciate Isak's argument on the basis of historical facts & his pro federalist view, but it essentially lacks forward looking view and practicality as it heavily dwells on the past.He can hardly tell the means to get out of the existing political quagmire we are in to ensure peaceful coexistence between "nations & nationalities ". This is my first visit to this channel and i have just subscribed your channel hoping to have a good insight about the real problems and possible solution of Ethiopian politics.

[@MIZANAWI]

If you're interested in participating on his platform (Talk-Ethiopia), I can arrange a debate with Isshaq. I aspire to hear your elaborate words in a real-world context.

[@WaduckoFactsBlog]

I wonder if you have watched the full debate, or even have gotten the Discourse of thier topic.....!! . You should have understood the argument of both of them before hurrying to conclude who was genius or not...who was correct or not, whose argument is real or not.... What's exciting more is the way you started to draw your conclusion; you claimed as you're Muslim as him to justify your biased Comment against the man for the readers....

[@MIZANAWI]

I want to see this guy perform on stage with Yissak, but please refrain from asking tough questions. Like did you watch? ... kkkkkk

[@alemtedan2431]

ሞገስ ጭቆና የነበረ ነውና ቢቀጥል ምን ችግር አለው የሚል ሐሳብ ያለው ይመስላል ችግር ስላው መስለኝ ዲሞክራሲ በስፈነባቸው አገሮች የተሽነፈው በኛም አገር እስካሁን እያተራመስን ያለው ዛክ እንደሁሌው አንደኛ

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Moges time yalkew Good point new. Chigru gin ahun enasketlew maletachew new!

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Thank You Moges For Wonderful Conversation! Thank You Yishaq!

[@masaramoti]

Good on you Issac you defended the ethnic federalism very well

[@JustaThoughtUSA]

Yishaq. Great 👍 man!!!

[@beteselassiebiru9671]

የትኛው ነገድ ነው በፊውዳሉ ስራት የተጨፈለቀው ? አሁን በስልጣን ላይ ያለው የገዳ ስራት ግን ከሃያ በላይ ነገድ አጥፍትዋል።

[@Maggieforreal]

I love Isak. Well done 👍

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Ishaq gidelehm yebiher poletica lemanm ayibejim!

[@eliassani141]

የመኢአድ ፥ የእናት ፓርቲ አመራሮች የተናገሩት እና የሰጡት የፓርቲ መግለጫዎች እና ማብራሪያ የአንድ አገር ሐይማኖት ቋንቋ ጨፍላቂ አሐዳዊነ ኃይሎች መኖር የሚያረጋግጡ ማስረጃዎች ናቸው።

[@fekaduf.dinssa5022]

If we say suppression of others' language, culture and religion of others was the norm of the time in the Past, how this should be corrected in the present day and future survival of all in equality in the country?

[@rubeeshaatii3400]

Mogos got true challenge today We need more discussion

[@fasilgebreselassie6988]

ይስሃቅ በጣም ትገርማለህ እነዚህን ሰዎች እየገመገካችው ያለህው በዝህ ዘመን ያሉ መሪዎች አርገህ ነው ። ይሄ ስህተት ነው ። በነበራቸው የትምህርት ዝግጅት እና እውቀት ነዉ መመዘን ያለብህ።

[@gebruabrha9306]

moges arif new yastekakelkachew

[@daniaserat7723]

very Good ysak

[@ameteselamtube7773]

Moges gidelehm! Denay madregu mefthe ayidelem!

[@deribamegersa8283]

አውቆን የተኛ ሲቀሰቅሱት አይሰማም ማለት በትክክል እንደሞገስ የመሳሰሉ ሰዎች ናቸው፡፡

[@mengistu9600]

መሀመድ ነብዩ ተከታዯቻቸውን እንደላኩ በዛን ሰአት የተፃፈው ምን ይል ነበር እምነቶች ትዋግተው ነው ዛሬ ምታወራላችው ምድር ላይ የተገኙት

[@tbarekyohannes]

I really appreciate this two gentleman’s intellect and knowledge this kind of debate will benefit everyone concerned having said that for the first time I witnessed Mr. Mogos taking to school by Mr. Issac as far as Islam in Ethiopia.