I am definitely trying this one in the storage system I'm working on for Deep Storage. Silos up top for Cobblestone, shulker loaders on bottom. I tried Silents, and I managed to get the loss down but didn't manage to completely eliminate it. This, I think is my perfect solution.
@brokenbones6236 ай бұрын
Awesome dude, ya Silents design doesn't work good or look good
@swiggityswag7097 ай бұрын
Pretty cool, I love the UI! Having built some box loaders in the past the UI is the number one concern. Lots of designs out there, and most don't look very good at all. This is by far the best looking one. I've been thinking of rebuilding my 850.000 capacity item sorting system that would have some box loaders for the most bulky storage purposes. Tired of emptying chests to shulkers manually. Will try this out later.
@brokenbones6237 ай бұрын
Thank you! By UI i take it u mean User Interface? And by that I take it its the the player interaction with the loader? I like this too, it is the best looking and working design out there
@swiggityswag7097 ай бұрын
@@brokenbones623 Yes, user interface is very easy to access and can be made to look very nice! Most of the box loaders are not. It's something that the player is going to be interacting with a lot, so it's very important! Good job with this one!
@brokenbones6237 ай бұрын
Thanks so much
@fishfishy338611 ай бұрын
There needs to be a slight change now that blocks can be powered from the side, just make it 4 comparators instead of 3
@brokenbones62311 ай бұрын
Mine still works fine i think u may have done something wrong or build on a chunk border thats messing with your set it. If 4 comparators works for you, keep it, but the tutorial is still up to date and works just fine, and I update MC earlier today
@brokenbones62311 ай бұрын
But I appreciate the feedback, very helpful if some else has the same problem Ill tell them ur solution
@fishfishy338611 ай бұрын
@@brokenbones623 I’m not sure what the issue was but for the small price of an extra comparator, I’ll take the loss
@brokenbones62311 ай бұрын
If it works it works, good job bro
@tylerlong3147 ай бұрын
@@fishfishy3386 The issue was probably that you only built one shulker box loader instead of multiple beside eachother. The redstone can trigger the bottom piston and send the piston into an infinite push/retract everytime an item passes through the hopper. a fix would be like you said one more comparator ORRRR... you can add one redstone adjacent to the first redstone that gets powered and it will fix the issue you are having.
@upthedubsguy10 ай бұрын
Hello, again, @BrokenBones623! I built another two-wide version for my guardian farm, underneath item filters. The shulker box loader started itself automatically, and the first shulker box filled and ejected flawlessly. Thx to your advice on this loader and GruvaGuy's shulker sandwich farm, I'm doing great! I'm not sure how soon I will get relevant videos out, but I will eventually, and I will make sure to credit your advice. Thx again! :- )
@brokenbones62310 ай бұрын
thx, im gonna sub to u and tune in
@upthedubsguy10 ай бұрын
@@brokenbones623, Cheers, bro! :- )
@brokenbones62310 ай бұрын
@@upthedubsguy cheers
@Riskofignition7 ай бұрын
Works like a beauty in bedrock realms. The loader anyways. Didn't try the unloader
@brokenbones6237 ай бұрын
Both are awesome
@brokenbones6237 ай бұрын
Thanks, im glad you like it
@casperghost98087 ай бұрын
This is by far the best design on youtube but i hink you can trim some fat of this guy. you dont need 2 of the compaitors or the piston with the redstone block. Im sure you have a reason for em but i can't see what they add to the circuit aside from unnecessary delay.
@brokenbones6237 ай бұрын
What those do is keeps the front looking nice, I don't want a loader that looks ugly from the front. This is a machine that most will throw in their base and why would everyone else design a simple design but it looks ugly no matter what side u view it from from. So those comparators push the signal to the back rather than having it on the front, hense the 3 comparators. I challenge u to build this design and simplify it but also keep the front looking good. If u do, post a photo of it in my Discord Fan chat, link to that is in all my video descriptions
@RaythMinecraft8 ай бұрын
Don't use this for non-stackable items. It'll break the shulkers right away instead of filling up.
@brokenbones6238 ай бұрын
True, thats something i didnt think about
@simonmartin41095 ай бұрын
Wish I'd read this before building it on my allay sorter for my raid farm 😒
@brokenbones6235 ай бұрын
Awe Im sorry dude, ya, non stackables are different
@christianking48315 ай бұрын
The breaking mechanic seems to be broken now where even when a shulker is full the comparators don't up the signal strength to trigger the top sticky piston.
@brokenbones6235 ай бұрын
No it still works, I use these all the time, please join my discord fan chat for Redstone support, link is in the description, and send pics of your redstone. Thanks
@voldemort88949 ай бұрын
Still works!!
@brokenbones6239 ай бұрын
This should always work, its not using any glitchy mechanics or bugs that will be patched, this is all basic Redstone that will be in the game forever
@martinschlegel182310 ай бұрын
nice. Am trying to design a new storage system for me for 1.21 with the autocrafter. directly hooked up to shulker and wood farms so that it autofills with shulkers. Plan currently is: build one chunky 4x unloader for unloading, that's about the speed I can currently easily build without needing to much space or creating to much lag. If you know of faster unloaders that are reliable with small footprint let me know... Before the unloader a seperator that seperates shulkers from non-shulkers so that I can send one directly to the storage system and unload the otherone first. than a huge storage system with sorters obviously, than after each item filter a shulker loader (can be 1x speed at that point but needs to be reliable and 1x tilable, while unloading can be 4xspeed, it will than be "buffered" and put into a normal hopperline sooo....), than some chests to hold the shulkers. Than a shulker presenter, that gives you one of the shulkers so that you can take out single items or push a button to have it broken and take the full shulker. That's the plan. Not a small thing to build in survival, current plan is to build it for at least 256 different individual Items to be sorted, maybe 512, and that the storage should be able to hold at least 4 double chests of shulkers of each. But it's for an old survival world where I have tons of ressources. So let's see.
@brokenbones62310 ай бұрын
I do have this video, which is dropper circuits, but they unload chests, see what you can do with this video to make a super-fast unloader. Personally, I don't like minecart unloaders because they are glitchy and unreliable, but I have seen them, and I've watched several people struggle with the dependability of them. I prefer to just use 4x 1 wide tileable shulker unloaders, its just as fast and way more reliable
@brokenbones62310 ай бұрын
That there is a comment lol
@martinschlegel182310 ай бұрын
@@brokenbones623 I have never had issues with my "normal" two times hopper speed minecart unloaders and single speed loaders. But they do not deal with shulkers yet because when I build them all around my world, you couldn't yet farm shulker shells so I didn't use that many shulkers. In the past I had problems with minecarts stopping or completely disappearing on the border between loaded and unloaded chunks, but that's been way back, in the last few versions, since 1.18 or something it always worked fine for me. Still try to keep loaders / unloaders within one chunk where possible.
@brokenbones6239 ай бұрын
Yeah, it's just a bummer when you're in your face and you build something and you're like shoot it doesn't work because it can't go here because of a chunk border, so I try to make all my tutorials that would go in your base not need to have chunk alignment so you can throw it in wherever you want
@040ryno2 күн бұрын
I built this in a previous realm no problem. Now for some reason the shulker does not break when full. Any suggestions? I replaced all barrels with single chests. Will that make a difference?
@brokenbones6232 күн бұрын
Hmm, Thats weird, Join my discord fan page in the description and send photos, Ill help u fix it
@040ryno2 күн бұрын
@brokenbones623 thank you so much. Will do
@brokenbones623Күн бұрын
Well, mine still works. I would need to see it. Join my discord fan page and lets get this working for u. Links in the description
@brokenbones623Күн бұрын
Ya I look forward to seeing what u got
@brokenbones623Күн бұрын
@@040ryno Well we got u all fixed up rather quickly. Thanks for using my tutorials
@namansaboo32335 ай бұрын
If I want to drop the filled shulkers in a water stream can I just break the bottom hoppers?
@namansaboo32335 ай бұрын
Also top piston doesn’t seem to auto push when shulker is full, how does it get powered
@brokenbones6235 ай бұрын
yes sir
@brokenbones6235 ай бұрын
@namansaboo3233 the comparators, are u bedrock or java?
@namansaboo32335 ай бұрын
Bedrock
@brokenbones6235 ай бұрын
@namansaboo3233 did u chuck align it?
@pavanramkissoon73708 ай бұрын
Hii how do you get out partially filled boxes?
@brokenbones6238 ай бұрын
U can hit the button
@brokenbones6238 ай бұрын
If u use repeaters and buttons on every module, u can do them individually, I always would leave it to fill up and take whats full
@timmckay28957 ай бұрын
Hey mate, as your newest subscriber, I want to hook this up to my mob farm. Do I have to wait until the pistons are charged for all silos before pushing the button. Sincerely hope not. Or if you have a trip all the better
@brokenbones6236 ай бұрын
No you don't have to wait for all the Pistons to be charged, you just won't collect anything in those. But I do recommend building yourself a shulker Farm
@timmckay28956 ай бұрын
@@brokenbones623thanks, already have my schulker farm built
@brokenbones6236 ай бұрын
@@timmckay2895 The whats the issue with filling them up with shulkers
@upthedubsguy10 ай бұрын
Hi, BrokenBones. I built a small, two-wide version of this. When are you supposed to push the button, and is there a way to have the loader work automatically, without pushing a button? Thx! :- )
@brokenbones62310 ай бұрын
It works automatically after the first button press, the issue is there's no more room for a comparator behind the dispenser to fire the dispenser when an item goes in. As long as it doesn't run out of shulker boxes to load, it will stay fully automatic
@brokenbones62310 ай бұрын
So essentially u could add as much storage as u want and it will never stop till the last shulker box is filled
@upthedubsguy10 ай бұрын
@@brokenbones623Thx for the quick reply. Got you on no room for a comparator to read the disenser. So it will just keep loading a shulker as long as new items keep dribbling in? And when that shulker is full, it pops, and then a replacement shulker takes its place? Now I need a shulker farm! Ha! :- )
@brokenbones62310 ай бұрын
@@upthedubsguy thats correct and it will keep loading till it runs out of shulker boxes, and I recommend this shulker farm, I built it in survival and found the problems with it and upgraded it so it works really really well, here's the video, and the 2nd video shows how I fixed it
@brokenbones62310 ай бұрын
@@upthedubsguy here's how I built it in survival kzbin.info/www/bejne/g322aKynhptre8Usi=gteyIVauHyJcT7dH
@daytonvalley6869 Жыл бұрын
You have to click the button after it fills up
@brokenbones623 Жыл бұрын
If want to, most people using shulker loaders have so many items, you just leave it for next time, but yes you could if u want your shulker back
@daytonvalley6869 Жыл бұрын
Ok
@brokenbones623 Жыл бұрын
@@daytonvalley6869 what are u using this for?
@danielflitton5771 Жыл бұрын
It doesn’t auto break the shulker box after it is full
@brokenbones623 Жыл бұрын
It should just like it does in the tutorial. If it's not, you may have built it incorrectly or perhaps on a chunk border that is making it work not as intended
@scheduleddrop19749 ай бұрын
Does not work with non-stackable items
@brokenbones6239 ай бұрын
This can be fixed by adding a 4th comparator and 1 more redstone dust in the back
@brokenbones6239 ай бұрын
but yes u are correct
@jamesrichardson97908 ай бұрын
If this is fixed by adding the extra comparator, does that essentially mean you can use this design (with 4 comparators) for any item in the game? It would be nice to not need different designs for stackables and non-stackables. @brokenbones623
@brokenbones6237 ай бұрын
No, thats too many ticks of delay
@swiggityswag7097 ай бұрын
I can imagine separating items by type is the job of the sorting system before they arrive. So, a mob farm would need pre sorting, burning the unstackables and then passing output to filters that pass it finally to these box loaders. Stackables could be handled by another type of a loader if we need that.
@T.J953 ай бұрын
not working
@brokenbones6233 ай бұрын
This design still works, whats not working for you?
@brokenbones6233 ай бұрын
I see another comment saying adding a 4th comparator worked for them. Idk why cus the og design still works
@T.J953 ай бұрын
@@brokenbones623 thanks for the help, I was just looking for inspiration to try to compact several designs into one