17. Imam Ali’s (as) opinion of Abu Bakr & Umar | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Holy Ramadan 2024/1445

[@ahmedelbahja6301]

We need to reach a stage where the bakris need to prove their beliefs, not the other way round. We can't always be on the backfoot. We are on HAQQ. They need to feel like they've always got something to prove. Ahsant Sayed Ammar, you are changing the mindset of many. God bless you for your excellent work.

[@Last2LP]

The information is available. Not your responsibility to teach who doesn’t want to learn

[@captainrtf]

I agree with you 💯%. Sometimes I feel like how you feeling. But the indoctrination those guys give to children from early age is just unbelievable. I was told never to listen or talk to a Shia. My wife was told Shias don’t fast or pray. Shias have different Quran. Shias don’t believe in the prophet. Jibreal made a mistake in giving prophethood to Mohammed instead of Ali. Can you imagine how many kids are being fed with these lies. Therefore they will grow up hating on Shias for no reason and they will not be ready to listen to Shias version of the lies. This is why it’s still important that we make the truth known. At least those of them who Allah guides will make meanings from what Shias preach. 🙏🏽

[@Mer_67556]

Sit down, shias are not even 10℅ of the Muslim population

[@ZoePerrault]

@@captainrtfvery well said. that's the reality. many of our Sunni brothers and sisters know Shias based on false information.

[@aliishahh]

Facts!! I was thinking the exact same recently. Why should we act lesser to those arrogant and ignorant fools!

[@s2JZ]

FACTS ARE FACTS whether we like them or not, we need to let go of our emotions and accept the facts… This man here is speaking facts……. PERIOD

[@saidkhan5086]

My parents raised me as a sunni, but Allah guide me to the ways of ahl bait

[@niyas4719]

It's Shaythaan who guided you... Be careful..

[@MehdiRizvi-c4z]

​@@niyas4719😂😂

[@m1serymirwais824]

loving (ahli bait) is good, But i think beliving that hazrat ali karamullahu wajhu is god that is sheirk

[@m1serymirwais824]

and learning from guy who has tattos and beliving that ali ibni talib is GOD thats not good

[@lamintouray7262]

They are all sectarian follow no group and submit yourself to Allah alone who commanded us to follow the Creed of Prophet Ibrahima

[@mkms7317]

اللهم صل على محمد وال محمد وعجل فرجهم الشريف حفظكم الله يابن الزهراء عليها السلام

[@ALIH4SH]

Thank you again Sayed, another video i can send to some of the ignorant sunnis.. majority of our shia lectures speak with love, and you are one of the best examples of that. Thanks bro

[@rKaraa]

A KNEE ON THE NECK A KNEE ON THE FEET A KNEE ON BOTH OF OUR HEARTS “ALI ALI ALI ALI 🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🕺🕺🕺 LETS BEAT OURSELVES”

[@JamieDelour]

a teacher with tattoos who disrespects the Sahaba .... this is the person you learn from seriously?

[@rKaraa]

@@JamieDelour what do you except they are shias, they are not Muslims

[@ALIH4SH]

@@JamieDelour shut up, your no one the judge the people you learn from are ISIS members of staff

[@ick_incinerator]

​@@JamieDelourwhat because he has tattoos he's a kafir? You sound stupid bro its just ink on his skin cuz

[@infernoblaze1235]

Waaallahi thank you so much sayed ammar.. may allah bless you ❤❤

[@bambi9857]

thank you Sayyed! God bless you!

[@stephenrambau8165]

Let Mufti Menk produce his Hadith of Ali running to vote for Abu Bakr during the funeral procession . I never saw Hadith like that unless written by Mufi Henk in his own book or mind

[@JamieDelour]

Your hatred is blinding your heart and mind.

[@eunlee2022]

You are truly blind and can we just say that he is not even using Shia books but imagine if he did you guys will go ballistic

[@shahzadraza-kd5pw]

Let Mr Menk provide the evidence smoking gun proof

[@pharoahball]

Amazing lecture sayed

[@oversteer6771]

Truly heartbreaking seeing imam Ali a.s words in his own book 💔 it’s all there but they don’t want to believe it

[@VictorKassyan]

Sayed Ammar you great Ma Sha Allah

[@nazneenahm]

My mother's family are from the Ahlul bayt. The earliest ancestors immigrated from Baghdad to India. Our forefathers said Hazrat Ali (AS) was the appointed spiritual successor of the Prophet (SAW). We are Sufis if the Chisti order. However no.ome taught us anything about the dishonesty and betrayal of the sahaba, perhaps because they have all been very devout and strict followers of the Quran and Hadiths and refrained from speaking ill about anyone. I always suspected foul play against the Ahlul bayt because even to this day, Sunni leaders try to downplay the importance of the family of the Prophet. Until recently, Hadith and Seerah books were not available in India so we were ignorant but truth is emerging now

[@comparativereligiondailynews]

How Can I Be Convinced That Your Mother Is From Ahlul Bayt ? Give Me Some Proof ? @ 3 April 2024

[@MehdiRizvi-c4z]

Exactly sir,if we Shia's say that the it is the Prophet of Allah who said that never leave my Ahlulbayt and the Quran and you will not be deviated from the truthful path.And we narrate this the Sunni's say that the Prophet didn't teach different Islam to the Ahlulbayt and the Sahaba.But it is a very clear opposition to the Hadith I just narrated above(also known as Hadith-e-saqlain).Also this Hadith is Sahih from all aspects.

[@nazneenahm]

@@MehdiRizvi-c4z the reason for that Hadith I think is that members of the family of the Prophet were taught mystical knowledge of the Quran by Hazrat Ali (RA). This knowledge is so powerful that it can be revealed and taught only to a select few. People with bad intentions and bad character will misuse it. It is not fiction that Sufis can walk on water and fly in the air. But if i say aloud to the public that to be able to do this, one must be trained and at the beginning of the training, one must give up eating his favourite item of food and sit in the graveyard at night doing dhikr, most people will call me mad and say it is kufr.

[@zaraazeem5408]

You just cannot go wrong following the Ahlul Bayt , the FAMILY of the Prophet PBUH.Fatima. Imam Ali. Imam Hassan . Imam Hussain. Yep. Ill follow the sunnah of The Prophet & his Family instead of those who’re constantly being excused, justified &even accused of kicking Hazrat Fatima & killing her innocent baby. The house of Saud can spend millions on the propaganda machine to elevate the sahaabas to the family of the Prophet but thank God for the Shias. Thank God for people like Syed Ammar Nakshawani. Enough said.

[@mohdkhalid698]

But he very smartly skipped the incident of when Umar beated the ali and Fatima together and ali kissed the feet of Umar just to safe his life... Zulfiqar was broken with the fear of Amir u mominie hz. Umar alhi salam....

[@BahramZareie]

@@mohdkhalid698 Mal'oon Ali (as) and fear of death??? Ali came out after he heard the cry of lady Fatima and as soon he came out they jumped him and dragged him on the ground and pulling him on the ground while his clothes and legs were getting hurt by ground and took him in such way to AbuBakr and put his hand on the Hands of Abu Bakr. Yet Imam Ali never made a bay'at to AbuBakr till lady Fatimah as was alive but after lady Fatimah died and there was treat made to his life he made a Bay'at. Your mother Ayesha is recorded in Saheeh Muslim who says: That man (meaning Imam Ali) did gained the respect of the people until he made Bay'at to Abu Bakr.

[@TheMahdi12349]

Brother the Christian’s actually destroy them what do you think we will do. For example the Christian’s ask them how can we believe in a prophet who gets bewitched… silence.

[@zdty677]

@@mohdkhalid698Don't worry you and Umar will reunite in hell let him tell you more fake stories when you meet

[@ukimenustah26]

But umar and Abu Bakr are the family of the prophet

[@shastribuddin5740]

This man, Sayyed Ammar Nakshawani is full of intellect! A rare breed of scholar! Truth is truth! Let's remove our emotion and just stick to the fact. Truth will always prevail. The rule of majority, is not the very rule of ISLAM. If there are two ways of directing our lives; one path trudge by Ameeril Muhmineen, Imam ALI ibni Abi Talib A.S., and the other is traversed by the other caliphs and with the many folpowings, I would travel along the path of Imam A.S., even, with the few company...Sallu aala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad!❤❤❤

[@BilRas]

Fatima has the phrase, alayhas salaam in Arabic , at 26:54, in Sahih Bukhari volume 5, Hadith #4240

[@cano8448]

عَلَيْهَا السَّلاَمُ; peace be upon her

[@relaxedsoul8600]

Thanks syed ammar for great lecture

[@Billionaires_Muslimmotivation]

So happy that this series is to be continued ❤😊😊😊

[@konainabbas7233]

Ali Awal al Madhloom, this lecture honestly brings you to tears.

[@samb8335]

FINISHED!

[@TahierShah-z8h]

Thank you sayed

[@FreePalestine718]

May Allah bless you

[@1dejabu]

this is like gold.. thank you my brother for your honest work.

[@bluepartyhat93]

I am rendered speechless and completely process the wealth of information in your videos. I am only leaving this comment to assist your videos with reach in the KZbin's algorithm. Peace be upon you, Sayed Ammar Nakshawani.

[@MuniraSamad]

ماشآءالله ❤

[@VictorKassyan]

👍👍👍☝️☝️☝️

[@BilRas]

Yaa Ali

[@MrHaiderh]

Phenomenal lecture and series by Sayed Ammar. Love how he is using sunni books to refute all of their accusations against Shias. If only more sunnis were open to actually reading their own books rather than taking what their mufti menk's preach, more of them would see the truth. So proud to be Shia aH

[@JamieDelour]

search "response to Sayed Ammar Nakshawani" watch the rebuttals to your tattooed sheikh.. he's been dismantled multiple times and actively hides from a debate. We both know why...

[@MrHaiderh]

@@JamieDelour So I took your recommendation and did search... and the most watched was from a man "Farid responds." His response was so weak, it was quite funny. In fact it was so weak, that if you actually scroll the comments, it is filled with sunni brothers and sisters extremely concerned about the inadequate response and asking for further clarification. Which leads me to believe that you yourself did not watch the video. Sayed Ammar has given a masterclass in education by using only sunni sources, so there can be no rhetoric of "oh your shia books are so inaccurate." Will you dare say the same about Bukhari, or is this just going to be another in the long list of excuses.... And struggling to see what his tattoos have to do with anything that he is saying but when you have nothing else to cling to, always resort to personal attacks right? May Allah guide you to the right path of the Ahlul Bayt iA brother. WAS.

[@JamieDelour]

@@MrHaiderh Farid has uploaded 6 videos about Ammar in the last 4 weeks. Which video did you watch? what was the "weak" part you found funny? Because I have watched them. Check out the one titled, Ammar Nakshawani Accuses Umar (ra) of Denying the Will of the prophet. It has Shias pretending to be Sunni in the comments, are these the comments you are talking about? hilariously one got caught red handed. Ammar is not a person anyone should be taking knowledge from. He has poor arguments and he knows this. It's the primary reason he doesn't debate.

[@zainkhorasanee1684]

@@JamieDelourBut the knowledge is not taken FROM him but THROUGH him - he is only transmitting the knowledge that is contained in the Sahih Hadith books, isn’t he ?

[@JamieDelour]

@@zainkhorasanee1684 Playing semantics is boring, it's already clear what I mean.

[@Sectixx]

What’s the latmiyah playing in the background at the start

[@spursfan9991]

Jazakullah

[@syedraza4627]

Great job syed.

[@jewadalbaghdady3285]

Jazakallah khar, ur almost covering everything between sunni and shia, just last thing is tawausal (even though it's been talked about alot)

[@farhad6195]

As a shia, Till this day I am genuinely astonished of how sunni brothers call themselves muslims and then dont allow other sects of islam to portray their viewpoint/interpretation of history … like a get a life, if you think we are soo wrong then let Allah swt judge us on judgement day. There are some aspects of shia teaching I disagree with, and some aspects of sunni teaching I agree with. But I remain a shia and following the teaching but also dont follow certian teaching where evidence is not adequate. I take on board all information and follow according to what I think is right, I have taken on board some sunni teaching and use that for my benefit! And GUES WHAT THERE IS NO HARM IN DOING THAT. Like go do research, look at both shia and sunni teaching, if you end up completely disregarding one then cool, if you mix and match then cool, you decide. I have watched all of muhammad hijab, adnan rashid and Farids, walid ismael videos. all they did jump the fence and say oh you are interpreting it wrong, it meant this and that… like you portray your opinion and syed ammar portray his opinion. Done and dusted. Let everyone be in peace. For the sake of Allah swt dont judge until you have good knowledge from both sides! Only when you watch and listen to what both sides are saying then you will see biased opinions. So research and go in with open mind

[@TheMahdi12349]

Brother I have a PhD in medicine I used the same strategies I used in my research to look at both sides Walah brother imam Ali is the khalefa. The other major point I found of difference is shia use a3al (mind or reason) it is a hujjah which makes so much sense. Where as most other schools don’t. God bless you.

[@JamieDelour]

This is not a mix and match religion, you cannot curse the sahaba and be cool with that. You cannot reject sahih hadith and be cool with that, these are not small matters. If you have watched the videos with an open heart from the likes of Adnan, Farid, Sunni discourse etc and done your own research there is no coming back to Shiasim. There is a good reason the Shia's actively hide from debate, including Nakshawani.

[@aj1608]

​@JamieDelour Common sense is something unfortunately missing in the realm of Shia, its almost become tribalistic not religious, at the end of the day someone from ahlul bayt or not, we judge them based on their merits. Islam is a religion of meritocracy, not bloodline, the prophet was specific in that regard, it was his fear that people would overly praise him and now the shia ask for help from his family while they can provide no help at all.

[@JamieDelour]

@@aj1608 Spot on brother. Thanks

[@NameLess-sw4yi]

i'll tell u Hz Ali's opinion about Hz Abu Bakr and hz Umar in a nutshell 🙂: I asked my father (`Ali bin Abi Talib), "Who are the best people after Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) ?" He said, "Abu Bakr." I asked, "Who then?" He said, "Then `Umar. " I was afraid he would say "Uthman, so I said, "Then you?" He said, "I am only an ordinary person. (Bukhari 3671)

[@jobaerahmed74]

They don't have an answer to this. Its his own son asking him. Irony

[@mustaffazainon3615]

Mufti menk .. pls dont spread lies.... As a layman, i know the truth when i see one. Why you of all people? How can you make up a story of Imam Ali ran towards Abu Bakr so on and so on....

[@captainrtf]

And yet his viewers who refuse to think and ask meaningful questions are happy, smiling and see him to be speaking the truth. It’s because of people like Mufti Menk that I can’t wait for Judgement Day.

[@JamieDelour]

@@captainrtf .... shia's curse the Sahaba beloved by the Prophet, Sunni's praise the Sahaba beloved by the Prophet, Shia practice taqiya and muta.... Sunni's don't, Shia's beat and tattoo them self, Sunni's don't.. you should be scared for judgement day. Review your beliefs before then for your own sake.

[@ick_incinerator]

​@@JamieDelouri know plenty of Sunni that have tattoos and do muta too bro, you say shia curse the sahaba but imagine murdering and beheading ahlul bayt. I am scared for judgement day but you should be petrified of that day

[@JamieDelour]

@@ick_incinerator Sunni sheikhs don't condone attacking ahlul bayt, sahaba, wifes of the prophet, doing tattos, muta etc etc etc. Fear Allah and seek the truth and stop spreading falsehood.

[@ick_incinerator]

@@JamieDelour brother you've named your children and based your beliefs on the murderers of ahlul bayt, i dont speak bad upon the sahaba but i for sure do not respect the sahaba for what they did the ahlul bayt and the way they treated the prophet pbuh

[@faiyazkassamym]

Jeeez sick lecture

[@toninaaliyah5451]

Sayed my brother ❤ I’ve said this before in another lecture video, you’re cremating them. Thank you ❤

[@JamieDelour]

Watch the rebuttals to your tattooed sheikh.. he's been dismantled multiple times and actively hides from a debate. We both know why...

[@toninaaliyah5451]

@@JamieDelour bhahaha 😂😂😂your so bitter because you know he’s cremated your sunnah of omar not the sunnah of Mohammed prophet!! Give us proof of what he is saying is wrong!! What do you know about tattoos in Islam?? Eshhhhhh🤫🤫🤫🤫

[@JamieDelour]

@@toninaaliyah5451 The rebuttals are already published but you are burying your head in the sand here asking for evidence in comment sections. Search for "response to Nakshawani" and you will find some guidance insh'Allah.

[@Freepalestineee786]

Mashallah

[@mustafa-vohra2811]

Hi can anyone tell me from where can I get the Quran which sayed ammar is using .????

[@mariam_173]

❤❤❤

[@gokupurple6760]

Ahahah. My favorite islamic speaker. I love the way he deceives his audience. When Umar says to ali that u view us as deceiptful and liers and so on it isnt acc that. The person (Abbas i think) who said this about Ali came with Ali to Umar. And umar was making a point. In such where "You and Ali having an argument makes him these words, so when he had a disagreements with Abu bakr does it also apply?" It was to show Abbas that his words were wrong and he should be careful what he says. Even in the hadith of inheritence Ali praises abu Bakr. Amar I love you, because you've inspired me to actually research myself so I can refute your points. You speak in such a high level way where its really easy to be lured in by your mischief. Regarding Menks point, Ali according to some sources did give bayah and was one of the first. However it was due to the change of attitude he gave it again to solidify his position. Regardless it doesnt matter. Once Ali gave bayah all the bs shias (some) talk ahout abu Bakr goes out the window as you can only give Bayah to a muslim. Good or bad isnt even the debate because he is a muslim as even Amar agreed so you cant curse him and you also will have to deal with Abu bakr eventually going to heaven (after some time in hell if you believe he was a horrible muslim. Allah will judge accordingly). Come on Amar. Bring it on :) Also by law no he doesnt need Alis pledge as a good bunch of MnA gave their bayah. However I assume as Ali is a respected and admirable member a bayah from him would be useful. As much as i love Fatima, stop randomly throwing out hadiths for no reason. The whoeever angers her angers me hadith is not even within context. Secondly, Fatima didnt necessarily get angry. Many sahis suggest she was displeased. One says angry. By Az Zuhri and his interpolation. He is known to do this. Secondly sunnis believe Fatima was a human and had emotions. If she was upset doesnt mean Abu bakr is condemmned. The sermon of fatima cannot even be proven (i think it happened but what she specifically said is unknown. Correct me if im wrong). Ghadeer Kum got nothing to do witu this bro. That was to tell the Syrians or Yemeni or someone who had ill emotions to Ali to calm himself. Or else the prophet would have spoken in Makkah. The sunni love the ahlul bayt as much as the Shia. We just dont make a distinction. I love Ali as much as Abu Bakr for example. Hopefully i answered alright so lmk if u got questions. Im not the most educated at all so

[@qasimshah5109]

❤❤❤S.A.N

[@Ali-Al-Aboodi]

و عليكم السلام و رحمة الله و بركاته

[@sidhussain915]

Sheikh Hassan Allayari has covered all these topics in Arabic and Urdu English and has a open challenge on the Islam of Abu Bakr and Umar Khatab

[@Zainee-kazme]

ALI (A.S) HAQQQ 🙌🏻

[@ruberkarl6474]

Mashallah Khalifa number 4 opinions about Khalifa 1 & 2 are that they are liars, sinners, betrayers. Sahih Muslim Also Khalifa 4 hated Khalifa 2 and did not wanted to see his face Sahih Bukhari

[@husseinzulfiqar4026]

Nothing killed me more than mufti menks video. Almost fell out of my seat 🤣🤣🤣

[@syedr.maswoodchannel3447]

Can you show the opinion of Imam Ali ( AS) from Sunni Accepted sources? Thanks

[@THEWATCHMAN-RK0]

Abu bakr, Umar, uthman and Ayesha gave the red carpet for Karbala to take place, we'll see them on Yomal Qiyammah

[@samb8335]

Who are the Mujahideen and Ansar to pick a Khalifa without the person already named as successor? Get real! Thats why ali a.s. is the first 2nd,3rd and 4th Khalifa. Allah swt named imam ali a.s the successor. So everyone else Khalifa is void

[@zedispahany7317]

Whatever took place at Saqifa was NOT out of malice ( u won’t agree as the very foundation of shiaISM will fall apart). I believe people can plan anything they want to but Allah is the Best Planner and in His Wisdom everything happens according to HIS WILL. Hazrat Ali was the spiritual leader of the people and he was Not interested in becoming a political leader (caliph). Imam Jaffer as Sadeq was offered the position to become the caliph of the Ummah but he declined. Hazrat Ali’s advise and judgement was sought by the 3 caliphs in All matters when needed. He as well as other imams gave spiritual guidance to the people of their time. It was Allah’s Plan for them to serve as spiritual leaders of the Muslims. Imam Backer opened an academy of learning which was carried on by imam Jaffer as sadeq. So every muslim has love for the ahlul bayt and the khulafa Rashedun. I Believe that our Prophet was sent as Rahmatul Aalameen who forgave his bitterest of enemies. And the Imams followed in his footsteps. This is my belief.

[@zainkhorasanee1684]

It (Saqifa) may not have happened out of malice, however there was an inclination for grasping political power that certainly belonged rightly to Imam Ali (a.s.). Moreover, we can see very evidently and clearly the damaging results of such an inappropriate and harmful act, in the subsequent history of the Muslim Ummah up to the present date…

[@zainkhorasanee1684]

Another important consideration: IF people wish to follow the Sunnah of our beloved Prophet Muhammad (Peace and Blessings be upon him, his close family and righteous companions) then we have to firstly acknowledge that he was a Divinely Appointed person in whom Allah (To Whom Be All Glory and Praise) had vested total Religious, Spiritual, Economic, Military AND Political power over the Muslim Ummah. Therefore, his appointment to, and assumption of, this comprehensive role of leadership was his Sunnah for the time he was in Medina until he passed away. Thus, in order to be a “Sunni” (who follows this Sunnah) means to agree that ONE single person has to be vested with, be completely capable of, and also perform all the above functions of leadership of the Muslim Ummah - as surely this was (and is) his true Sunnah and therefore the right and straight path to be followed after him…However the events at Saqifa led directly to a harmful deviation from this righteous Sunnah…

[@alinaqi.j2754]

Allahﷻ🤍 Muhammad ﷺ 🤍 And the Ahlulbaytع🤍

[@rajahzia]

I wish Arabs had a proper historian right around the time when Prophet Mohammad was alive. Now all we get are 100s of opinions based on questionable chains of narrations.

[@Nouray162]

There's educating the masses, and then there's SAN EDUCATING the masses. He's borderline funny when he's stating the obvious from their own books 😆 But on a serious note, may Allah bless him and all his efforts.

[@Richest_Person_in_the_World]

Is that Audemars taqiyyah

[@ibrahimrobinson6663]

So i have a question about the Hadith in sahih Muslim though. At the beginning of the Hadith Abbas calls Imam Ali (as) a liar, deceiver, etc. Why did he say that? Was he talking about Imam Ali (as) or was it about Abu Bakr?

[@imtha26]

Beloved prophet Rasoolallah (SAW) said not to criticize or talk bad about my companions -- So just lets follow rasoollallah SAW Words.

[@zainkhorasanee1684]

IF by “companions” refers to ALL “companions” (companions being people who saw and met our beloved Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him and his family) then this cannot be an authentic Hadith because Allah, Upon Whom Be All Glory and Praise, in Sura 63 (The hypocrites) of the Holy Quran certainly refers to some of such people (“companions”) as being hypocrites and criticises them severely. Thus, the only way such a Hadith could be authentic and correct is if the people not to be criticised are the “righteous companions” not all the “companions” (because “all companions” would include both the righteous companions and also other companions who were sinners, hypocrites and evildoers).

[@San-ye6tt]

"Can you please tell me all the names of the sons of Ali (ra)? Please reply to me."

[@jobaerahmed74]

They won't because they can't explain it😄

[@azrahussain5573]

31:10 cracking fr. 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@mouhamedchouman7001]

Assalamualaikum OK So, if this is the case, that Ali(ra) was against Abu bakr(ra) & he did not Pledge his Allegiance Then why didn't Ali(ra) Rebel against Abu bakr(ra) at take back or at least try & take what was rightfully his in the first place We are talking about Huq, so why just let it go if he was supposed to be the first caliphate or not, I don't know since it's not mentioned in the Quran about the order of leadership after Prophet Muhammad, Allah(swt) knows best

[@ammarmansoor7783]

The prophet had just died and a civil war within the muslims Ummah would have been detrimental for the religion. It would turn into a political power struggle in the name of religion (which is not different than the history of previous religions). Also why should he pick up people and start a revolt? They literally had Saqifa where he was usurped. Why does he need to rebel when the prophet chose him directly to everyone (hadith taqlayn)? If they didn't listen to the prophet why would they listen to him? He literally stood back and watched chaos ensue until they begged him to be the fourth khalifa. If I am being honest him not causing a revolution obviously looks liked it was a wiser decision considering where we are in time now.

[@shahsadsaadu5817]

​@@ammarmansoor7783you cannot have both of those things. If prophet Muhammad saw really chose Ali (r) to be his successor, he would have had made it abundantly clear, and provide Ali (r) with enough protection so that he would not get usurped. What Rasool wishes is God's will. And no mortal man can usurp that will. Therefore, you would have to believe that prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) was both stupid and powerless to not make sure that his wished heir would not be next in line as the rightful khalifa. That The greatest and the most powerful man in human history was outplayed by two old men. But hey, you guys can believe that and consider yourselves to be true followers of Rasool (pbuh)....

[@Enhoneypie]

@@shahsadsaadu5817 hadeeth al Thaqalain is clear as day but the hearts are blind not the eyes. What part don’t you understand from “I leave for you the Quran and my Ahlulbayt”?? What part of that isn’t absolutely crystal clear? What part of gathering thousands at Ghadeer Khumm to tell them “whoever I am their master, Ali is your master” not clear? What part is confusing? Wallahi I don’t understand the Sunni’s logic. Please educate yourself my brother in Islam

[@believer3828]

Please come to "Sheikh Hasan Allahyari's" Live Program on KZbin... He is one of the greatest shia scholar, it will be a great Duo of Ammar Nakshwani + Hasan Allahyari ✨✨

[@suzan_sheikh]

34:39 to 35:26 See how he is not reading the full hadidh, he left the last part. Let me show you Sahih al-Bukhari 4240, 4241 Narrated `Aisha: Fatima the daughter of the Prophet (ﷺ) sent someone to Abu Bakr (when he was a caliph), asking for her inheritance of what Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) had left of the property bestowed on him by Allah from the Fai (i.e. booty gained without fighting) in Medina, and Fadak, and what remained of the Khumus of the Khaibar booty. On that, Abu Bakr said, "Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Our property is not inherited. Whatever we leave, is Sadaqa, but the family of (the Prophet) Muhammad can eat of this property.' By Allah, I will not make any change in the state of the Sadaqa of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and will leave it as it was during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and will dispose of it as Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) used to do." So Abu Bakr refused to give anything of that to Fatima. So she became angry with Abu Bakr and kept away from him, and did not task to him till she died. She remained alive for six months after the death of the Prophet. When she died, her husband `Ali, buried her at night without informing Abu Bakr and he said the funeral prayer by himself. When Fatima was alive, the people used to respect `Ali much, but after her death, `Ali noticed a change in the people's attitude towards him. So `Ali sought reconciliation with Abu Bakr and gave him an oath of allegiance. `Ali had not given the oath of allegiance during those months (i.e. the period between the Prophet's death and Fatima's death). `Ali sent someone to Abu Bakr saying, "Come to us, but let nobody come with you," as he disliked that `Umar should come, `Umar said (to Abu Bakr), "No, by Allah, you shall not enter upon them alone " Abu Bakr said, "What do you think they will do to me? By Allah, I will go to them' So Abu Bakr entered upon them, and then `Ali uttered Tashah-hud and said (to Abu Bakr), "We know well your superiority and what Allah has given you, and we are not jealous of the good what Allah has bestowed upon you, but you did not consult us in the question of the rule and we thought that we have got a right in it because of our near relationship to Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) ." Thereupon Abu Bakr's eyes flowed with tears. And when Abu Bakr spoke, he said, "By Him in Whose Hand my soul is to keep good relations with the relatives of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) is dearer to me than to keep good relations with my own relatives. But as for the trouble which arose between me and you about his property, I will do my best to spend it according to what is good, and will not leave any rule or regulation which I saw Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) following, in disposing of it, but I will follow." On that `Ali said to Abu Bakr, "I promise to give you the oath of allegiance in this after noon." So when Abu Bakr had offered the Zuhr prayer, he ascended the pulpit and uttered the Tashah-hud and then mentioned the story of `Ali and his failure to give the oath of allegiance, and excused him, accepting what excuses he had offered; Then `Ali (got up) and praying (to Allah) for forgiveness, he uttered Tashah-hud, praised Abu Bakr's right, and said, that he had not done what he had done because of jealousy of Abu Bakr or as a protest of that Allah had favored him with. `Ali added, "But we used to consider that we too had some right in this affair (of rulership) and that he (i.e. Abu Bakr) did not consult us in this matter, and therefore caused us to feel sorry." On that all the Muslims became happy and said, "You have done the right thing." The Muslims then became friendly with `Ali as he returned to what the people had done (i.e. giving the oath of allegiance to Abu Bakr). See how he is playing with people's mind. May Allah guide us

[@ShahedaAnsari-c9k]

Whenever any sunni scholar challenged this guy ammar ..he ran away not accepting it...just like he claims hazrat umar and abu bakr did.....😂😂😂😂...naksawani has not guts

[@AboeAmir]

What Mufti Menk claims is laughable.

[@GlobalSky-zu6iu]

Fadak was State property, not private ownership. Ali never revised/revoked Abu Bakr decision when he later became the 4th Caliph. 😊

[@kcrypto296]

Then why did uthman gifted fadak to marwan ?

[@antizionist112zaidi]

Your whole sunnism is based on a very weak pillar by clarifying your argument ,you got destroyed by yourself 😂😂

[@omarazmery]

Who was first shia ?

[@baqilicious]

Salman, Abu Zar, Bilal, Ammar, huzaifa, miqdad and many more. Tell me who are the first sunni and on what basis

[@zainkhorasanee1684]

According to the Holy Quran, Prophet Ibrahim (Peace and Blessings be upon him and his family) was the “Shia” of Prophet Nuh (Peace and Blessings by upon him).

[@fawad1976]

Brother Nakshwani, please I ask you do present facts. From the beginning of this lecture you have already misconstrued the statement of Umar ibn Al Khattab, when you said that Umar stated the Allah protected us from this going wrong, which clearly means that Allah is good with what took place. Umar was talking about the Ansar selected Sa'ad as the caliph. I don't understand why you are always focused on highlighting the differences between the two major sects and thus increasing sectarianism. We need unity in these times, not divides, brother. Please focus on bringing the Ummah together in your future lessons.

[@rizwanghafoori1499]

look at the replies of maula ALI A.S. ,he clearly agrees to the hadith narrated by hazrat UMAR R.A. (muslim-4577) .read the hadith, THEN HE TURNED TO ABBAS AND ALI AND SAID: I ADJURE YOU BOTH BY ALLAH BY WHOSE ORDER THE HEAVENS AND EARTH ARE SUSTAINED, DON'T YOU KNOW THAT THE MESSENGER OF ALLAH SAID: WE DO NOT HAVE ANY HEIRS; WHAT WE LEAVE BEHIND IS (TO BE GIVEN IN) CHARITY? THEY (TOO) SAID YES.

[@captainrtf]

And you believe it right? The children of prophets are not human beings who deserve to inherit from their fathers right? You expect their children to feed on feces on after they’re gone. Ok why did prophet Ibrahim’s, Yaqub’s, etc children inherit from them. Sunnis always have weird ways of defending the wrongdoers.

[@jenniferj1763]

1. The point is that, if these books are full of contradictions, how can you trust any message they try to convey. 2. I believe that shias believe that fadak was given as a gift to fatima and thus it was not inheritance, therefore if Ali did indeed say yes to umar about the inheritance point, it doesn't invalidate the claim for a gift. This is just my understanding from observing. I'm surprised this isn't clear to you?

[@captainrtf]

@@jenniferj1763 the pick and choose nature of the Sunnis is just abhorrent. Did the same books say prophet said I leave for you 2 weighty things to hold unto so you don’t go astray, ‘’Quran and my household’’? Did the same books confirm that prophet lifted Ali’s hand and said everyone must follow him after his death and the same sahabas congratulated Ali? Yes the books narrated all these. So why taking these narrations as useless and weak but holding strictly onto the YES of Ali to authenticate the denial of Fatima’s inheritance? When the narration suit Sunnis, it’s excellent Hadith but if it’s against them it’s a weak Hadith. This double standard must stop.

[@baqilicious]

Then why Ayesha inherited the house of Rasool Allah pbuh when prophets don't leave behind any heirs?????

[@hyp3rw4rrior65]

Mufti mak is famous because he talk about couples 😅. He have no knowledge about Islam.

[@omarabdulcaderkadwa]

LIAR

[@AS-wn7ql]

I'm a sunni from the family of the ahlul Bayt. I love Imam Ali عليه السلام the most from the companions. However, I also love the other companions. Nowhere did Imam Ali curse or insult Abu Bakr or Umar. It's just not there. Maybe they had a disagreement, but he was always civil with them and even advised them on issues during their caliphate. Anyway, I love the Ahlul Bayt ❤

[@TheMahdi12349]

Habibi no one needs to curse the sahaba but not all where good. Look at what they did to your family muwaiyah and wife of prophet went to war with your grandfather. Then your other grandfather was slaughtered by muwaiyah son. Then rest of your grandfathers jailed, persecuted and poisoned. Something not right here? What is this enemy that for generations the Muslims fought your grandparents?

[@AS-wn7ql]

I understand your point brother. I don't deny there were disagreements and conflicts amongst the sahaba. All I'm saying is that the Blessed Imams of the Ahlul Bayt عليهم السلام never cursed or insulted the companions. On the contrary, Imam Muhammad al Baqir عليه السلام prayed for the forgiveness of um ul momineen Aisha RA, and even went on to say that she had lamented for what had happened at Jamal. As far as Muawiyah is concerned, I hold the position of توقف. He certainly made numerous mistakes and was unjust in his treatment of the Ahlul Bayt. His matter is with Allah.

[@MultiAmmar2000]

Habibi in your own books Imam Ali calls Abu Bakr and Umar as lying, treacherous, and sinful. Imam Al-Baqir is the narrator of the famous hadith in Al-Kafi where he says that no pain or affection occured on Ahl Al-Bayt except that those two started it and then he said that Allah curses them both.

[@AS-wn7ql]

@MultiAmmar2000 Imam Ali never said that brother. It was actually Abbas, the Prophet's uncle (imam Ali's uncle as well) saying that about Imam Ali. If you read the complete hadith, Abbas says those words about imam Ali after asking Umar to judge between the two. Umar then uses those same words to describe what Imam Ali and Abbas might have felt towards him and Abu Bakr after denying them the inheritance. Imam Ali never said those words. As for the report in Kafi, it's weak.

[@MultiAmmar2000]

@AS-wn7ql The report in Al-Kafi is not weak? It is hasan according to Majilisi. And besides, there are multiple other hadiths in which the imams make their point of view clear. And you are incorrect, the Sunni hadith has Abbas (according to the hadith) insult Imam Ali. Then Umar says that both Imam Ali and Abbas thought of Abu Bakr those same insults and now they think of Umar the same.

[@jraucc6142]

Why would you have anything to do with that guy mink??... Last year he's Sheikh and this year he's Mufti.... He follows the five traitors.. he doesn't know what wudu is.... He's never in his life performed a halal Salat.... He is a part of the renegades.... Is no brother of ours...

[@sohailhussain6081]

Mashallah