2. The Biography of Muhammad ibn Hanafiyya - Sheikh Mohammed Al-Hilli - Masjid-e-Ali

September 11, 2018
Eve of Muharram 02, 1440AH
Copyright © 2018. Masjid-e-Ali, Somerset, N.J. All rights reserved. Any use of this video, without consent from the publisher, is prohibited.
Website: www.masjid-e-ali.org
Facebook: masjid.e.ali.nj
Twitter: masjid_e_ali_as
Instagram: MasjideAlinj

[@shahzadalvicalligraphy3380]

Salawat .. Muhammad All e Muhammad ...Salam Ya Imam as. Labik Ya Imam as .Salam Ya Muhammad Ibn Ali as💖💖💖💖💖

[@sdirfan312]

Hi kya ap k pass Muhammad ibn Hanfiya ka shijra hai.

[@shahzadalvicalligraphy3380]

@@sdirfan312 ...belkul hi...

[@dalvi_]

@@shahzadalvicalligraphy3380 can you share?

[@shafqatullahawan4289]

@@shahzadalvicalligraphy3380 Muhammad bin hanfia wife name please,

[@AlviAwan515]

Alhamdulillah I am descendant of Muhammad bin Ali (as) through his son Aon (as) Aon bin Ali alakbar bin Muhammad alakbar bin Imam Ali (as)

[@salimtalib9037]

As-Salaamu alaikum wa Rahmattullahi wa barakatu, Shaikh. In all of these private narrations that is given with the Holy Imams, how anyone know what is truly said when there only two people are present & they are both dead? I always get these challenges to prove what is said when no one is around to record these exchanges between two people.

[@JaefarSABNW]

An important central factor of religion is that God judges according to capabilities. Muhammad ibn Hanafiyya and Shaybah Ibn Hashim or Abdul Muttalib, Abu `Ali Abi Muttalib being favored by the Shia and condemned by the Sunni is an important difference to consider why the difference in historical claims occur. Aside from Al Quran and the central inspired teachings of Muhammad ibn `Abdullah, the Shia and Sunni share the sayings about how people will be as three types of people in their reaction to Ali Ibn Abi Talib and possibly others; the Partisans of (Shiy`atu) and Believers (Al Muw'mineen), The Rejectors (Raafidah) their exaggeration like unto what Christians say about Jesus, and The Misbelievers (Al Kafiruwn) in their opposing them. People need to neither boast of opulence nor covet what they don't need. Islam is not a particular cultural style, but it certainly should not be denied as something people are free to practice; when it is unpopular.

[@hamzaawan218]

I am a sunni and i don't think anyone in Ahl e sunnat condemns Muhammad bin Hanafiah.. You do know The cast awan is the largest sunni cast in Pakistan and oyr family tree touches Muhammad bin hanafiah

[@syedmubasharhassan4372]

Hamza Awan i heard Awans are the descendent of Hazarat Abbas A.S.

[@JaefarSABNW]

@@hamzaawan218 Shia are less uniform and often something turns out to be a Sunni and not Sunni Islam. Sorry.

[@capcook4569]

But Muhammad ibn hanafiya didn’t defend his brother imam Hussein a.s at Karbala and that is something that should be condemned

[@syedumaralvi7137]

Because Muhammad bin Hanfiyah AS stayed in Madina as an informant of imam Hussain AS, the imam's AS told him to stay in Madina as representative of ahlebait and preach here as well

[@syedumaralvi7137]

Muhammad’s sickness when Imam al-Husayn (a) left Medina for Mecca, which is mentioned by al-Allama al-Hilli in response to Muhanna b. Sinan.[12] According to some scholars, the sickness was related to his eyes.[13] The Imam (a) had told Muhammad to stay in Medina. Ibn A’tham al-Kufi mentions that when Muhamad b. al-Hanafiyya could not convince Imam al-Husayn (a) to stay in Medina, the Imam (a) told him, “It is alright for you to stay in Medina so that you be my informant among them.”

[@dalvi_]

@@syedumaralvi7137 dear Umar, I am wondering if you are also a descendant of Muhammad ibn Hanafiyya. I belong to a Qazi family which claims descent from Muhammad ibn Hanafiyya but I am in doubt of our shajrah to Qutb Shah. Do you have any information?

[@syedumaralvi7137]

@@dalvi_ dear give me whatsapp number, we talk together

[@bk-qr5nx]

@@dalvi_ so you must agree that abu bakr caliphate was legitmate as his mother was from the jihad that he abu bakr did . Masha Allah

[@bk-qr5nx]

Was he legitmate son of Ali or not . Due to the fact if we do not count abu bakr caliph legitmate , his mother was a concinbine ( war slave ) from the jihad war at abu bakr time. So mola ali must have considered the caliph legitimate to free as a slave and have a child with her . How could mola ali go ask her parents for marriage when she was taken as war bounty by khaleed bin whaleed. The only way to free her was one way . Dont lie

[@yxmxxn]

You people hate Saif Ullah Khaled ibn Walid so much and make up lies about him just because he conquered your precious Persian Empire. There's a reason why the real Shia, the Zaidis do not engage in the cursing of these companions of the Nabi, like you Rafidis do.

[@capcook4569]

They aren’t lies they are historical facts if you can’t accept the truth that’s on you

[@yxmxxn]

@@capcook4569 there is nothing historically accurate about the exaggerated and sensationalised version of events told by the 12er Shias. Real historians both Muslim and Non-Muslim tell a different account of things - there’s a reason for this. Facts > feelings.

[@capcook4569]

Khalo ibn waleed killed and raped in both Shi’a and Sunni sources you can’t deny that if you want to make excuses for him like I said that’s on you

[@yxmxxn]

@@capcook4569 the woman ur talking about was taken as a concubine after her husband already died. The Prophet PBUH and the other sahaba including Ali RA took concubines. In fact the woman ur referring to was later sold to Ali RA

[@capcook4569]

That’s a lie from you guys about the lady’s husband that was murdered by Khaled and a lie from you guys about imam Ali a.s