2018 Lincoln Navigator vs. 2018 Cadillac Escalade: Faceoff Comparison

[@Mrrlamb1]

Great unbiased comparison... Cadillac is WAY overdue for a full refresh.

[@CarConfections]

Thanks!

[@smarticus6384]

Let’s not forget that the Navigator should receive another 50 points for an all aluminum body. Free of body rust for the life of the vehicle could be a factor depending where you live. This may not mean much in California but corrosion is a huge factor for the northeast and Midwest.

[@uponthischain]

Smarticus Living in Minnesota, I can confirm the importance of this feature.

[@hellkitty1014]

Aluminum will not rust, but it will corrode. Also the Navigator remains very heavy(L models are still over 6000 pounds loaded) despite switch to aluminum.

[@smarticus6384]

Very true. Much of the weight was reinvested into what appears to be an over designed frame. Aluminum does corrode but it should never be compared to how steel rusts. When Aluminum is exposed over time to atmospheric O2 the resulting aluminum oxide actually provides a thin hard layer that actually protects the metal from further corrosion. Again it should never be compared to how steel rusts away. When paying this much money for a vehicle I think its important that it lasts over time. Junk yards across America is filled with examples of what rust does.

[@yessevenedge6850]

This a very smart and useful point that u highlighted

[@undergod1987]

now first off i will say i am a ford guy so keep that in mind.. BUT dent removal and body repairs for the aluminum is VERY pricey compared to steel. and really when you compare weight your not really getting much except for towing. But keep in mind i am not hating on the Lincoln i just want to point that out.

[@swalling22]

I've always been in love with the Escalade, but damn that Navigator interior is beautiful 😍😍 I like the exterior of the Caddy a little more, but the interior of the navi a lot more

[@robertyeah7280]

I have owned both a Lincoln Cont. and a Cadillac CTS so I'm a fan of both brands. When the FIRST Lincoln Nav. came out it was nasty(very good). Cadillac had NOTHING to compete. However, I knew Cadillac would come out with a version that would smoke the Nav., and they did. In my opinion, the Cad. Esc. have ruled every since. But I'm always a fan of the under dog so I was hoping Lincoln Nav. would make a come back at some point. The 2018 Lincoln Nav. did just that. An extremely nasty ride. The Cadillac Esc. is NOTHING to play with, and in traditional Cadillac style, I know they won't take this lying down. But for 2018, the award goes to Lincoln Nav. hands down.

[@justinbrown2570]

robert yeah Well said. Agreed!

[@UProductions457]

Yes but GM will most likely update some cars next year cuz of the 7th gen Camaro

[@cooperlawrence4885]

Yeah the next gen esc comes out in 2020

[@wade3312]

Damn right! I test drove the new Nav a few weeks ago and it is glorious! I just can't drop that amount of money on one but I loved it! The winner here was clear. Lincoln really did it right.

[@teeduke2918]

can you really watch live TV while on the road like you are in ur living room?

[@RAY-THE-WAY]

Wade Dowden exactly

[@Orginal_Sinner]

I can get you a discount

[@teeduke2918]

on what?

[@gregparker237]

Deez nuts

[@esther2010]

Lincoln interior was much better, just Cadillac Escalade number one selling SUV, this is answer.

[@derrickjohnson3094]

Give me the Cadillac Escalade any day, it's just something about the front and back bumper makes you look like a boss.

[@issac9930]

The front looks better on the navigator, the back looks better on the escalade

[@kryogenicmx591]

nope, the lincoln destroys the cadillac in looks in every way

[@loverboy]

Great video I think I'm going to buy the navigator I have a family of 7 it would fit us exactly right

[@CarConfections]

Thanks!

[@MDinhh]

I love Escalades but the interior is definitely subpar. Even before the navigator was released, I knew the Escalade’s interior wasn’t up to expectations. If I had to choose between the 2, I’d wait for the next gen Escalade.

[@bigmack8307]

Yeah, it’s a shame because the Escalade is probably the coolest looking suv of this era, but Cadillac has really been slacking in every other department in recent years

[@3rdkoast4life]

Ive owned every single navi except this 2018. I must have it 😍

[@cadillacdevile]

I am happy for the navigator fans, it took Lincoln since 2008 to get this right. Although they are similar in size and being domestic, they both talk to two totally different audiences. They both are pretty awesome.

[@guacgirl]

Navigator!!!! No contest, Cadillac needs to go home! Cadillac looks like #teambasic

[@shrikramalei9091]

I had never been satisfied with only one kind of vehicle, I used to own up to 18 vehicles, sport cars, SUV, limos, even an RV, so, I would buy both the Escalade, and the Navigator, I like both !

[@ChizAfterHours]

Great video. I love Lincoln's current interiors. After detailing a few new caddys the materials and build don't hold up over time which is a shame because they start off amazing.

[@zachthornton2806]

I wish i could upload pics of my cadalic 2 warn others because unfortunately this is true & with payments every month just to actually wanna get out of it asap before price falls any more lol or something breaks cuz we all get fucked real long & hard at the dealership especially when its free thats how they get fingers n first

[@ChizAfterHours]

Zach Thornton one of my clients has a 2016 CT6, the arm rest is already worn and several buttons have wear. The touch controls on the center stack wear really fast. I started working at a Cadillac dealer recently and even the new cars, mainly demos, but 2018 Escalades and such have worn screens and touch sensors and all. I have a client with a older mkz and that has held up better.

[@twinkieerella]

Navigator 🔥 *_Simple, but complex_*

[@SlimDON1182]

Overall nice review, accept you fail mention that you was using the standard wheelbase 2018 Escalade cargo dimensions instead of the Escalade ESV. The ESV cargo sizes are, 39 cu.ft behind 3rd row, 77ft behind 2nd row and 121 with all rows down. So you do get a increase in cargo capacity when you get the longer wheelbase Escalade ESV. Also the all new 2021 Cadillac Escalade is coming very soon, it interior design look likes it will give the Navigator interior a run for its money. I am guessing you will do a review on that when that new model Cadillac when it come out next year.

[@jessefehr6286]

The Escalade doesn’t require premium fuel

[@ItsJustWavy]

That's it I'm getting the Nav, now where did I put those 90k?

[@Zachman676]

I'm glad to see Lincoln is once again building desirable cars. The Navigator is lightyears ahead of the Escalade not to mention the interior of the Navigator is beautiful.

[@DJvincedavinci]

Love the side by side comparisons, keep it up

[@CarConfections]

Thanks!

[@KhrissyDaDon]

One of the Sun/Moon roof was squealing, not in a 90k+ SUV! And I’m pretty sure it was the Escalade that did it.

[@CarConfections]

Yes, it was the Escalade's. Not sure what was wrong with it, but it sure didn't sound luxurious!

[@TJC450]

If anything the new Navigator has caddy on their toes. Hopefully a refreshed escalade will come soon or a new model. GM doesn’t historically change their full size suvs in between life cycles.

[@Fall-off-currencies]

Black label with the destination theme👌👌👌

[@kobayashiharuno]

I'm an Asian and i always love this 2 SUVs, but if my family decided to move in USA i want to recommend them the Navigator.

[@MetalMan73100]

I have a feeling that the real comparison will happen when Cadillac will update the Escalade. The Lincoln has an obvious advantage in being a much more recent design, inevitably forcing Cadillac to react sooner rather than later. Personally, I prefer the Lincoln, both in terms of interior and exterior. The front grill looks big but classy, while the Escalade grill is undeniably ugly in my opinion.

[@ninersforlife7682]

Navigator all day. Why would anyone pay almost $100,000 for basically a five year old SUV with 5 year old technology? 😄😄

[@uponthischain]

Fordsuperduty76 Considering your username, I’m pretty sure there’s a slight bias here. (I do think that the Nav is the better vehicle though)

[@ninersforlife7682]

- AvgGuy - lol yes I like Ford but does not mean I like every Ford and every Lincoln. I would not pay $70,000 for 2017 Lincoln Navigator with 5 year old Tech. 😀

[@ericmartin894]

I'm checking out your name And can't help but already assume that you are a Ford Fan from the get go.

[@ninersforlife7682]

Eric Martin lol yes iam. But I also own a Cadillac so go figure that out 😀😀

[@camaro_kyle6851]

Fordsuperduty76 but it depends on the model and year though

[@Mokarney]

I've owned by Escalade for almost 2 years now (2016 Platinum ESV). While the Navigator has more flash and wow factor, the Caddy wins over time. I had the Navigator for a week and I simply couldn't see myself going from Caddy to the Navigator.

[@insanity4146]

Escalade looks so much nicer

[@isthisausername4020]

Insanity ikr I love the taillights

[@Dfgzx12xyw]

I stop watching as soon as I see the price of 81k 😂😂😂

[@BabyFaceDon]

tvhavan guess I’ll go watch a Tahoe video 😂

[@AzenBerries]

I'm sure they'll depreciate

[@eliXerxes]

Simply put, Escalade in my opinion is the best looking big awesome SUV any day and as soon as i have the cash i'm getting a Navigator.

[@popwarhomie]

I’m a Ford guy but this is tough. I HATE the “tablet” touch screens though. Why make them look out of place and sticking up like that??? I think I would take the Escalade honestly.

[@alanlopez1495]

Personally the biggest point should be the room you get for your legs in the 3rd row seat. We traveled in a 2015 expedition and I was "lucky" to sit in the 3rd row and man, it makes a world of difference to have that room. I wouldn't even consider a GM SUV until I know they have improved in that. Now beyond the point, who would consider a Lincoln Continental if the 5.0 Coyote was an option on it, RWD of course.

[@MT-zy7oe]

I used to be an Escalade Fan, still am...but if I were to lease one, I'd definitly go with the Navigator because Lincoln really did a number on this one.

[@christopheradams5607]

Now.... I was not a truck guy until 4 years ago: I fell I love with the Toyota Highlander and infinity so with the Mercedes G550 AMG (I spent 15mins in that truck) But wow, I saw a long wheelbase 2018 Navigator in black and it was epic.!!!

[@timberlinecline3667]

The escalade is the most unreliable full size SUV in its class

[@coureurdebois]

they seem about equal in terms of materials and build quality, but the Escalade is getting dated and its already based off of a lightly edited chassis from before 2008

[@user-gq2yv2bs8g]

Justin Bouche I agree, they have pumped so much in it in the beginning that it has no rooms for improvements

[@camaro_kyle6851]

Justin Bouche i think the next gen escalade will get the ct6 interior

[@Ford_Raptor_R_720hp_V8]

Good Old Justin is back from the dead

[@coureurdebois]

Escape for Mankind is Keith Johnson no inglish no understand

[@amtrakatl]

Yeah but, the Lincoln has a completely rust free body. That means a lot for the people up north. It will most likely last longer.

[@melvinpillay577]

Test drove both, really amazing vehicles but after much consideration, I'm going with the Escalade.

[@powerofpinesol8002]

Melvin Pillay i wouldn’t expect less

[@lorareid3041]

Eat more chicken nuggets man.

[@TRobertsIII]

All hail the new king of luxury SUVs!

[@No_timezone77]

NAVIGATOR ANY DAY!

[@skpenergy]

Aaron Glisson hahahahahahahahahaha

[@cperlera]

Says the guy who can’t effort it.

[@cperlera]

Tiger Man ooh give me a break you “L” Here “S” And I bet you can’t afford either trigger! lol

[@Blckreaperx]

Ewww how can y'all like the navigator ?? Just look at the aesthetics compared to the sexy Cadillac

[@dionnmatthews2954]

naaa escalade

[@David-n5q2v]

Undoubtably, the Navigator is a way better choice.

[@giofromtexas2679]

That Lincoln keyfob is nice and I love how vigorous the twin-turbo Lincoln motor sounds at startup! ... I'm sold I'll take the Lincoln 🤩🤩

[@BinSulaiti03]

Lance Rogers you like how a v6 sounds ? But don’t like how a v8 sounds like

[@giofromtexas2679]

THE UNKNOWN02 I love how the V8 sounds but I prefer the Navigator 😎

[@BinSulaiti03]

Lance Rogers I like the power but definitely not the sound 🤮

[@giofromtexas2679]

THE UNKNOWN02 🤣🤣🤣

[@RammSnipe]

I agree with you. At startup you hear the turbos spool which is sexy. While driving you hear the turbos sucking in lots of air which again sounds amazing. With the V8 they sound great at startup also but then you have the drone to deal with.

[@user-gq2yv2bs8g]

Great review, the Lincoln has finally came back and won over the escalade

[@Forge17]

The Escalade is sexier but it’s seats aren’t comfortable at all, which is totally unacceptable for a 90k SUV. Typical GM Truck headrests too, literally almost hard as a rock. The Navigator definitely takes the cake for being the most luxurious in the literal sense.

[@richardbetz5531]

I’ve always been more of an Escalade person and that continues here. Not as keen on the new Navigator body. The second generation Navigators looked the best in my opinion.

[@isthisausername4020]

Richie Betz I agree this Navigator looks pretty Ugly I preferred the older versions

[@stevenjohnson4207]

Lincoln has displayed just how evolutionary American luxury has become. Cadillac has that retro design that will continue to turn heads.

[@D3thM3tal]

Too many inconsistencies across your reviews. Some of the time you only judge by wheel size options and leave out the looks at it is subjective, others you judge by looks. You did the same on the back end as well. I've seen you award points for more tq and more hp, but then later only give one point for both. Still, one of the best reviewers out there :)

[@CarConfections]

Thanks! We've been working to have a more consistent and specific grading system in recent comparisons

[@xReLentLess213]

That rear of the escalade is atrocious, those 10 foot vertical lights are not pleasing to look at. The clear winner is the NAV

[@robertposton5188]

I like the Lincoln and awe the power of that V6 twin turbo it moves..

[@genosreviews252]

I like the lincoln.

[@johnettapowell3548]

Ceasat dog whisper

[@jrcook333]

I’m an Escalade person, but i’m going to have to go with the Navigator on this one because the interior is 100/100, but the exterior of the escalade is SOOOO american❤️❤️

[@francescosilvioweber2064]

I still like the escalade more, probably because of the 6.2 v8, and its better looking.

[@ShaneCarson]

I currently own a 2015 Escalade, which is the same body style and look of the one shown here. With that being said, I’d like to point out that there were a couple data points that were misleading and/or incorrect as pertaining to the Escalade. 1) The instrument panel on the Escalade is customizable and has several completely different looking “skins” 2) The Escalade ESV has a much larger rear cabin compartment or “trunk” than the one shown here. 3) The Heads-Up display has several customizable options including: speed limit of the road you’re currently on, song playing, engine rpm’s, vehicle speed, and I’m guessing about another 4-5 other pieces of info available to choose from. However, I agree though that the 3rd row seating has limited legroom seating capacity for adults, so I LOVE the Navigator for that. And, I also like the power reclining 3rd row seats on the Navigator too! Ford should’ve made it in a V-8 model, period. I like what the new Navigator is bringing to the table, but I seriously doubt that it will gain enough street cred to be able to unseat the KING, The Escalade! Real talk. (And this is coming from a Detroit guy, who is home to both companies headquarters and who sees on a daily basis what the streets are talking about. There ain’t no American made large luxury SUV that can touch it.

[@t-roy2418]

I like them both to say the truth. Lincoln finally gave Cadillac a run for the money. They both do comfort very well. It depends on what you are looking for. To me I'd take the Caddy... Great video...

[@darrnellsmith4246]

I love the navigator and I already knew it was goin win because it's the best hands down 💕💕💕💕#LINCOLN NAVIGATOR

[@marcial7044]

Some people would always stick to the Escalade just bc of the name

[@Louthemailman]

I like the body style of the caddy better but the interior of the navi is nicer

[@mitchellsanchez7377]

The escalades audio system controls in the center is a replica of all the other cadillacs. Ive seen it almost exactly the same in a 2012 cadillac cts-v

[@RoRo-hw3um]

I leased an escalade 3 years ago and i gotta say navigator is better overall. I still like how the caddy looks tho

[@EricFortuneJr.]

The previous generation Navigator wasn’t bad it was just outdated, but it would make a good bargain for a used car since the new model is out. Usually when a new body style is available car dealers will do whatever they can to get rid of the old trade ins and leases.

[@rubeng9649]

I like how they didn't give the Navigator a point for door handle sensor.

[@mitchellmcgregor428]

The Lincoln Navigator also has free pick up and drop off for any work that needs to be done like oil change or anything else

[@Lololol24LA]

Wow, even without the Black Label it still won by a huge margin

[@hkm_865]

I’ll have the Escalade with the navigator interior please

[@grandizer4531]

If you factor in dependability and resale value, Escalade all day long.

[@redd7188]

www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability/10-least-reliable-cars/

[@lorareid3041]

Where did you get that at?

[@WorldTravelerCA]

They both are Beautiful SUVs and truly luxury one’s

[@andrewl3847]

I prefer the Lincoln

[@mattsaab5811]

I wish Lincoln would consider offering a V8 option. I like that the Turbo V6 makes a lot of power but as with all V6's, they are not as balanced, refined or smooth as a V8.

[@vdelrio999]

For that high price, they should start a bespoke program. (eg. replace all the leather with HD vinyl or other humane vegan option, Cordura carpeting, no plastic, sound-proofing, metal dash and trim, etc..)

[@tremec6]

When this Navigator out of warranty, the consumer really gets screwed. It's Just like the rest of the Fords. Body off or cab off for simple repairs.

[@tgenesis8784]

I wouldn't buy the Navigator because every time I see the rear end I gag a little.

[@534N69]

Thilges1990 at least chevy guys have dicks 😂

[@jacobhurtado1046]

I was thinking the same thing. The Escalades rear is so much nicer to look at lol

[@Legendkiller-vk7ji]

I like the escalade better and it also has sentimental value because it was my first car i bought without the help of my parents

[@Raorl173]

The Escalade has a hint of Tahoe that you don’t see on the navigator/ expedition, the nav feels more unique

[@JojoSol98]

Big turn off for the Escalade is the front turn signal lamps that feel cheap , would of been badass to have them like the cts

[@AFCompany]

I’d would definitely get the Navigator over the Escalade. The Navigator is much more luxurious. But if I’m spending $90k I would be buying a Range Rover not a Cadillac or Lincoln.

[@jonlosito2004]

Navigator is much better full family SUV actually because of the interior is really smooth and clean. I also like the both LED tail lights and day time running lights and they come on in a stunning line just lice the Continental Reserve. I also like the Revel sound system speakers. I would also get that, but i like the Navigator L better so that i get more cargo space, but i would also figure out how to park it perfectly with no major problems.

[@jonlosito2004]

And we also got some weird Drive modes on a Navigator and basic animations which is; Normal, Normal 4x4, Conserve, Excite, Slippery, and Deep Conditions. 0h and we got that slow climb. But i know other people especially some KZbinrs with Auto channels complain and (or) dont like the electronic shifters just like this piano keyboard push- button shifter, but i kinda like it actually because its easy to use than a old school (fashoned) hard stick shifters. And newer Honda and Hyundai cars also have a piano keyboard shifters too.

[@alexarnold6773]

The Escalade is a low compression low revving pushrod v8. Why on earth would you need premium fuel for that?

[@konglee7284]

$100,000 BASICALLY... I'll just get a 4 door truck top model. It will help me out more in life. I hate pulling trailer with suv.

[@st8of1der]

Car Confections is a totally sweet channel😋

[@TheMosesc6461]

Both vehicles are nice. It depends on what you like if your more focus on the exterior then the Escalade wins the beauty contest. But if your more focus on the ride experience and prefer riding like a God go for the Navigator it's wins the interior contest hands down.

[@andreo.e5806]

Thank U so much for posting this! i I love you! ❤️

[@CarConfections]

You're welcome! Glad you liked it!

[@nauticman2707]

Navigator does not require premium but is needed for full HP Torque figure.

[@justSTUMBLEDupon]

Good comparison!

[@johnyi1994]

Great comparison! Will you expect to do a 2019 RDX review this summer? Can’t wait! Keep up the excellent work guys!

[@CarConfections]

Thanks! And we will definitely be reviewing the new RDX as soon as one arrives (hopefully in the next couple months)!

[@masonlilienthal2636]

I personally prefer the Lincoln Navigator, the interior is much nicer and the technology is newer, but Lincoln has a bad reputation. Cadillac on the other has a much more famous name and the exterior is so cool. So, I don’t know what to think.

[@dookiebooger9967]

10/10 whatever the newest design is the winner. Like an endless game of ping pong, new this vs old that then old this vs new that, wash rinse repeat.

[@dylanw890]

Lincoln absolutely nailed it with this new Navigator. I honestly think they dethroned the Cadillac in my opinion.

[@The52brandon]

As much as I favor the Navigator too. You seemed a bit biased in a few of the tests. You showed one field of the Escalades HUD, when you can have up to 3. And a "bass-heavy" stereo can be remedied by simply turning the bass down. CUE hasn't been the issue for me that many say, but the navigation input is infuriating to the point that it loses the points there. 2nd row is nice on both, Navigator taking the slight edge. 3rd row is Navigator by a landslide though

[@Jlukie42]

Hands down the navigator is better and way more spacious than the Cadillac

[@charliemontero5217]

I saw the comparison reviews of the 4 SUV`s very good

[@kclark8080]

I enjoyed this comparo....I did take issue for the awarding of points for some optional things like the wheels styles on those specific units. I agree the Nav's looked like pinwheels but I don't think those will be commonly ordered. Good job though!

[@CarConfections]

Thanks, we'll take note!

[@airborne_12v]

Navigator is just gorgeous we love our 2009

[@rhydynamic8306]

People Buy The Lincoln Because.... They want a luxurious roomy SUV, for a bit less money than an Escalade. So that’s a wise choice. Also because of the awesome 30 WAY Seats. People Buy The Escalade, because that what drug dealers drive in the 90’s with 30”s on it. And celebrity people use it too. Because it’s Cadillac. But the Escalade is luxurious too.

[@prodcrashinrentals]

the detroit type beat at 15:11 got me rollin😂😂😂😂😂

[@ronque23]

Don’t really have a dog in the fight as it’s not likely I’d buy one even if I could afford, but glad Lincoln is making a comeback and leveling the field.

[@piercewjay]

i enjoyed the review, i just dislike how it was biased on the escalade.

[@CarConfections]

Thanks?? The Nav won btw

[@20tea]

Ok, the Escalade is older, so it does appear a little dated compared to the Lincoln. I do prefer the performance of the Escalade and the option to add more hp via a turbo or supercharger. Also the Escalade has more of a head turning presence if you're into that. If that's not your thing, you can get a Denali which is basically a more subtle looking Escalade. I like my Denali, but i do appreciate the look of the Escalade. Just wait till the new Escalade comes out to do a real comparison. Think they're dropping the solid rear and the shifter among others. Love the solid rear, but would prefer a non column shifter.

[@randyrowe3097]

The similarities in exterior styling is crazy. It comes down to preference but. The dependability and huge hp capabilities of the 6.2 ls would tend me to lean towards the Caddy. That is if I wanted to spend a 100k on a beast.

[@randyrowe3097]

I do like the interior better in the Lincoln.

[@DroidzDesigns]

Imo The Cadillac is the go to for me just because of its aggressive look. Yes there are many factors but if it's for looks it's Cadillac.

[@isthisausername4020]

Droidz Designs It doesn’t look aggressive it looks happy to me

[@NA-ck6cz]

Navigator is the better vehicle. Still take the Escalade though.

[@mybro727]

Nick Angelos correction: Navigator is the *newer* vehicle. You can’t truly compare a 6 year old vehicle to a brand new vehicle.

[@x-wingerchannels]

I agree

[@x-wingerchannels]

I take the escalade to