2024 Lexus NX vs Audi Q5 Comparison / Within the Lines

[@fredbarriskell6578]

Was in the market for a smaller SUV recently. Test drove both of these and many others. The winner for me was 2024 Lexus NX 350 F Sport in atomic silver with circuit red interior. It just has more style.

[@craigo2142]

As a previous Audi owner, my advice would be either lease it or sell before the warranty runs out. And, you will get to know your service advisor a little more than you would like. And, bring some extra cash.

[@gaellejean-louis6873]

Well said

[@your_royal_highness]

I dunno, I sold my Q5 with 57k miles after four years and had zero problems. I just dumped my NX350 and got a SQ5. I am changing the oil more frequently etc. We will see if it starts to head south. I will either replace before 50k or maybe try to take it to 75k

[@craigo2142]

@@your_royal_highness I hope your experience is different than mine. All cars are different even same models.

[@emilcasas2707]

Yep! Ex Audi owner right here and they won’t get me again!

[@countersmart]

Ditto..Audi under the bonnet is all plastic tubes which fail after a few years and will cost a fortune to fix...Audi..you fooled me once...never again!

[@zimcoder]

I prefer the Lexus NX interior, it just screams luxury more than the Q5, not to mention the reliability and longevity of the Lexus.

[@your_royal_highness]

Audi for me.

[@jewelnabq01]

I would have to say the opposite on the Q5 as far as luxury feel. I agree on the NX for reliability.

[@deathward990]

Lol NX is no way luxury than Audi. I own A4 and wife owns NX....she just says its a prettier RAV4. But she prefers audi interiors.

[@jewelnabq01]

@@deathward990 what are your thoughts on the reliability issue with the A4? I understand the Audi are more luxurious on the inside, but I’m just wondering on the cost of maintenance. I am also looking at the NX hybrids versus the Audi Q5. It seems the Audi Q5 gives you more bang for the buck but the NX hybrid you get the gas mileage and the reliability factor.

[@deathward990]

@@jewelnabq01 i am using a 2018 A4 Premium Plus with gas and its still going gr8 in 6th year. I get around 28 mpg but I drive city most times. Q5 gas I heard gives around 23-24 mpg. But I wont compare it to NX hybrid as one is gas and other is hybrid. So hybrid will naturally give you better mileage. However I personally feel she should had gone something else than NX as the APR she got for NX was way too high also I don't fit in her NX comfortably. I am 6 ft. I feel bit cramped in NX. I feel like A4 has way better interiors.

[@MediumBluWonder]

Excellent review as always Tyler. Ive owned several Audis over the years both in and out of warranty. I am now a Lexus owner and its fair to say I don't think I will be coming back. But It's not simply because Audis generally have horrendous reliability as they age. This is not uncommon with any german luxury brand. I think its more about what you prioritize. As I've gotten older, that has changed for me. I believe Audis are great for people who are into short term ownership, view luxury as the newest looking and/or most aesthetically pleasing features inside and out, and enjoy brand prestige with evolutionary rather than revolutionary styling. Whereas Lexus is more for people who view luxury as having solid features in a car that they will enjoy for many years to come, styling that makes you appreciate emphasis of form over function, and depending on the trim, driving enjoyment. Either way both groups of people win IMO.

[@jefflee6975]

Lexus for me, reliability, luxury and tech.

[@cristisun184]

I like Audi but as an overall car I will go for the Lexus.Design is subjective but again I believe that Lexus is more nicer and is also without problems compared with Audi on a long run.Lexus Hybrid and plug-in hybrid for a more dynamic and quality/price is an easy pick.

[@Jouseca27]

You can never go wrong with Lexus, and they’re improving their tech and looks. I love my 350H F Sport. Luxury without reliability does not worth the price for me.

[@jameswalsh6131]

Hey Tyler great video! I bought a Q5 last year and I really love it. I have to agree with you that the Lexus will probably do better in the long term but for now I really enjoy my ride. Hoping tht you are doing great!

[@Realistick]

Thanks, I appreciate that, I hope your 2024 is going well too!

[@jefffoxworthyspen680]

Audi is the best German Luxury brand if you just want a good, smooth, sporty car that doesn’t make people assume negative things about you. Sure, it’s more expensive, needs more service and may not last as long as a Toyota (And I’m kinda tired of the “buy a Toyota” people on the internet), but having owned many reliable cars in my lifetime, even new Toyota and Honda products, I always envy my Friends A5. It’s worlds ahead of everything else I’ve driven or been in. I really want one of these cars.

[@Doc1855]

I’m very frugal so I personally would go with the vehicle that has better reliability and resale values, though I have a tendency to drive my vehicles until they are in need of a major repair and then it’s time to sell them. But I am honest with the next buyer and the price reflects that.

[@Chris0-58]

"...run flats instead which is the automotive equivalent to fixing your finances with a gambling addiction." I felt that.

[@bobdbeck]

I owned a Mercedes and an Audi, and then a Lexus. I'm now on my 5th Lexus...That should tell you how I feel about the German cars. Horrible reliability and very overpriced...and I have never had a major issue with any of my Lexii.

[@joskjj3625]

You say that but German luxury automakers continue to grow in sales numbers. Im a Toyota/lexus fan but to say that German cars have “horrible reliability” is far from true. Ill say this the routine maintenance is still more expensive than a Lexus but if you actually put the effort in taking care of a German car they will last a long time and they will be far more reliable than an American car

[@mmwrangler]

I drove both of these base models when considering purchasing. The Lexus has more bells and whistles the Audi is more refined. I personally liked the build quality, feel and responsiveness of the Audi . The big surprise was the Audi driver assist that is extremely natural and will even inform you to take a rest when it detects fatigue.

[@alwaysiyi272]

NX for me, I’m not really sure I care for how my luxury crossover to be “sporty” plus I guess the F-sport exists, but I’m a sucker for good tech mixed in with a nice interior, and I feel the NX checks that box better than the Audi, the Audi just kinda looks outdated to me. Plus any qualms I have with the engine noise of the hybrid system dies when you’re getting 40mpg, some owners have even seen 45-48mpg on very careful loops

[@441meatloaf]

F-=sport is kinda expensive from lexus. But lexus drives like a brick vs Q5.

[@cosmichippo9708]

My current avg is 42.4 mpg - mix of local and highways in Atlanta area. This goes down a bit during winter, but not too much. On some drives, I get well over 50 mpg.

[@wholeNwon]

If you want to look forward to a social, financial and whatever relationship with your mechanic, buy a German car. I had new, "ultimate German luxury" for 20 yrs. NEVER again. No, I wasn't stupid to have bought them in the first place, my company provided them but I suffered through the inconveniences of strandings and repairs. Yes, they all had perfect maintenance by certified master techs who were good.

[@joskjj3625]

I doubt you ever had a German car in your life. And you say you weren’t stupid to buy one? I guess the real stupidity shown when you told someone to buy a Nissan,Mitsubishi or subaru because it has “Japanese reliability”

[@wholeNwon]

@@joskjj3625 You don't seem to understand what I wrote. I had MB's as my daily drivers for 20 yrs. All bought new from Germany by MY COMPANY spending COMPANY money. They were perfectly maintained. ALL were very problematic. Even the dealer's loaner MB S class left stranded once. I have advised friends against ALL of the brands you listed. Spending my OWN money, I've only had Lexus LS's. Bought the first one on the advice of my MB certifies master tech who thought they were superior products and they are. Think whatever you wish. Those are the facts.

[@wholeNwon]

@@joskjj3625 Actually, when I was spending my own money, I took the advice of a certified MB master tech and bought a Lexus. I have stayed with that brand (all made in Japan) ever since. The only other Japanese make that I ever owned was as a young fellow and that was a 280Z. Obviously I would never want the cars you mentioned. If the Germans made reliable vehicles, I'd consider them but they don't, so I won't.

[@JTKels]

lol Audi build quality? You did a good review, but I would research the reliability of both these vehicles because Lexus wins every time.

[@Realistick]

That portion is at the end. When I say “build quality” I am referring to how well it is built from a tangible sense (doors, controls, panel fitment, construction, etc.). Obviously the Lexus takes the cake if reliability is your primary concern (it’s why I would personally buy one over the Q5), but the lexus does have several shortcomings as a luxury car that I highlight in this video.

[@Offensively-normal]

👍🏻👍🏻 Not sure how long it takes to put together a review. I feel the 18 minutes on my end were well spent. Thanks

[@Realistick]

That's my goal, thank you!

[@Doc1855]

That Tan interior looks so much more classy than the throw up 🤮 Gloomy Gray

[@mxrkdecastro]

My personal rule of not ever buying european cars have paid dividends over the years. I love my NX 350h.

[@siren8888]

Thank you!

[@johnhuston5521]

I have owned Four Audi’s. The last one was a2011 Q5 with 122,000 miles. Maintenance was done regularly by a non dealer. Qualified, but not a dealer. At 122,209 miles the engine started to misfire. The diagnosis, a bent intake valve that caused engine failure. The car that we were about to trade for the next Audi was now a $500 piece of junk, The last Audi I will ever own. The communication with Audi HQ was efficient, but yielded the typical corporate response. Thanks for your last 25 years of loyalty, but unable to offer me any remuneration towards another vehicle. Good bye Audi! Hello Honda!

[@441meatloaf]

Rofl saying goodbye to Audi then Hello to Honda......Honda engines literally leaks oil and has a whole issue with their earth dream garbage that stil is an ongoing problem Honda has ignored.

[@joskjj3625]

“Maintenance was done regularly by a non dealer” well theres your problem

[@SelinaLi-fb6jl]

I have a 2015 Audi Q5 WITH 118,000 miles , when I had a maintenance on 102, 000, it was very good condition according to dealer 's report. It has been regularly maintained and I used Premium gas as recommended. All of sudden, my car is machinic failure condition now. Audi says the Q5 has a bad engine valve on cylinder#2 and will need the new engine replaced .....It cost me $16,000 .... Should I buy new audi 2024? or should I buy Lexus ? Thank you

[@Dentmasteryork]

Audi as built quality???😂😂😂😂😂what this guy smokes?

[@441meatloaf]

Compared to new NX audi has better quality than NX.

[@joskjj3625]

There’s a huge difference between build quality and reliability. The audi’s interior is just better built and more solid than the interior of the Lexus however we all know which car would be less trouble in the long run and that would be Lexus

[@jewelnabq01]

@@441meatloaf How is the Audi better quality? Pls elaborate on the NX. I am deciding between the NX and the Q5. I like the build and ride of the Q5 when I tested it over the NX. However, the NX seems to be more reliable in the long run from what I have read so far.

[@441meatloaf]

@jewelnabq01 reliability isn't everything you gotta buy what you prefer. Maintenance cost for all luxury are about the same and if you go to a reputable shop and do regular maintenance, it will just be trouble free as the Lexus. Q5 has far better driving dynamics and handling, much better engine (its literally the same engine as the porsche macan), and is way more agile as a suv. Audi does have a faster smoother transmission, especially if you want a better response on acceleration. It has solid construction on the interior while NX may have some plasticky creek. Audi does have a harsher ride vs NX much softer ride due to sportier driving dynamics. If you are looking for more power, Audi will gladly sell you an SQ5. NX does have a newer infotainment system if you care for it considering q5 is still waiting for next generation platform to come out in 2026? NX doesn't handle that well and drives like a giant brick and if ur going for hybrid it uses a cvt transmission. Depending on region and where you live, cvt aren't that great for torque delivery and will struggle on elevation. Also not all NX engines are turbo charged and you can only get it on 300 or 350. Any other models are strictly naturally aspriated. NX will give you slightly more plush interior such as door, arm rest, while Q5 will give you less of that and trades it for styling. In terms of fuel efficiency - Q5 is better despite both using premium gas (non-hybrid). Q5 does have a plug in version, but IMO its not worth it for the Q5 as Audi puts a premium on the plug in. Its literally the difference betwene do you want a more boring/softer ride of the NX or are you both a practical, but yet looking for at least some excitement in everyday driving? If its the latter then Q5. If you dont care then NX.

[@theletterB88]

Awesome you got an Audi! Hope to see more of that going forward. One thing that I absolutely hate about the Q5 is the center console.... piano black trim and the cubby/storage are awful. Can't wait for more Audi reviews :)

[@miabchdave]

@realistick I just want to say good job on this content/review. You produced a coherent video, excellent commentary, with actually pertinent pop-up stats along the way. I liked your take on the cars as well. I think each car is for a different set of priorities of the driver and you laid that out well.

[@0HOON0]

Toyota's 2.4T might be the first EVER reliable gas turbo engine. Significant numbers of earlier NXs have crested 100k miles with almost no reports of failure.

[@vaw2487]

The 1st gen NX used the 8AR-FTS, which is the 2.0L turbo engine that was also used in the IS. I still think that the T24A-FTS (2.4L turbo) will be reliable since this isn't their first turbocharged engine, but it's still a brand new engine so it's hard to judge reliability.

[@0HOON0]

@@vaw2487 Thanks for the correction.

[@盧某人-k5r]

兩台豪華中型S U V，屬性截然不同；奧迪Q 5 呈現科技感與卓越操控！ 而 Lexus NX350H 呈現出 低調豪華丶妥善率高的特性！ 買車是看個人的需求，並沒有那一家車廠比較強。

[@donaldbanner2185]

" Adaptive Suspension " Not Lexus NX strong spot..........R U Freak'n kidding, the suspension tightens in curves and is Much Smoother on FWY's riding better than any of the Euro's coupled with the change to Michelin's tires ...(dump the DOG RUN FLATS) and you are Golden!

[@md8744]

Good review

[@Doc1855]

And what does Consumer Reports say about the reliability of the Audi ?

[@Realistick]

Similar to the Lexus believe it or not.

[@Doc1855]

@@Realistick Really? WOW, I would have never thought that. Thanks, I appreciate the feedback

[@Realistick]

@@Doc1855 You're welcome, though I definitely think CR's opinion will change in a couple of years after the little bugs are worked out!

[@Doc1855]

@@Realistick I hope so

[@donaldbanner2185]

@@Realistick Audi is a Euro Nightmare....there goes All credibility ....which has been on the downfall lately!...Audi is EURO NIGHTMARE!

[@Splendid_Lad]

Looks are subjective and I can’t never like the Lexus spindle grill. That Lexus interior looks way too much like a modern Toyota interior.

[@joselitomercado]

I will take the Lexus NX 350 AWD over the Audi Q5 anytime, reliable and less expensive to repair

[@danielcastorena3057]

Sounds like a European got butthurt and decided to review his car vs a Japanese high quality build car. Let's not forget your Audi is just a VW as well 😂 Lexus all the way 💪

[@Realistick]

These aren't my cars, I own a GR Corolla

[@danielcastorena3057]

@Realistick right, im sure they aren't yours. Just the whole video felt that way. Every time you talked about the lexus you brought up toyota. Sure it's a Toyota but then do the same with Audi and call it a VW. Truly disagree with your video but it's my opinion.

[@Realistick]

@@danielcastorena3057 It’s okay to disagree but that’s not even the opinion I expressed in the video. The audi does not ride on a platform shared with a VW and it shows. I also chose the NX for myself and if you watched the video, you would know why🤓

[@joskjj3625]

I love Lexus but you Jdm/japanese car fanboys are truly insufferable. “Japanese high quality build car” tell that to the Nissan i rented that already had a bad ac compressor with less than 3000 miles so called “Japanese high quality”😂

[@joskjj3625]

I love most Japanese cars but you jdm/japanese car fanboys are truly insufferable. “Japanese high quality build car”. Tell that to the Nissan I rented that already had a bad ac compressor with less than 3000 miles. “Japanese high quality”😂

[@iracohen3864]

The Audi will plummet in value and will likely be a money pit at 100K...the Lexus will likely hold up better...but the Audi does look like a more enjoyable ride.

[@naveenthemachine]

Just get the Audi. The nx is not a luxury car

[@donaldbanner2185]

@@naveenthemachine HOWEVER ...Much more Luxury than the AUDI and my 450h+ " F " S is much faster and better handling with Adaptive Suspension MUCH faster and I do Not even use gas but rather Plug in to 120 and get 49 miles per charge.....My NX uses Regular gas and 89 eMPG ...however I NEVR buy gas!...........Doi your research and GET LEXUS.....Never buy Euros............LEXUS Dependability and FAR Superior Re-Sale!

[@naveenthemachine]

@@donaldbanner2185 faster than Audi? I don’t think so 😂

[@ryanturnerboles]

@@donaldbanner2185the Audi is faster than your hybrid, plus for the price of that you can get the SQ5 which blows absolutely every Lexus SUV out of the water

[@441meatloaf]

@@donaldbanner2185 Dude all your comments you are responding to is nothing but a shill. Clearly a troll.

[@patrickaustin8528]

I’m a bigger fan of the Q5😊

[@ThatGuy-kv1kw]

I heard the GV 70 rides better than the Lexus?

[@Jarob9]

Time will tell if the 2025 refresh of the Q5 will address any tech shortcomings compared to the NX but its likely not to meet the Lexus on price, resale or reliability. Q5 will be the perfect care to lease while the NX is for the long term buyer.

[@joskjj3625]

The lexus looks far better than the audi. This gen audi q5 looked plain even when it first came out in 2018

[@petergazarek9466]

LEXUS 👌😎👍 THE FIRST CLASS QUALITY

[@alengreen589]

If I would have the money for one of this, I would buy the Lexus because of the good reliability. Audi have not a good reliability in Europe.

[@randysun2390]

Lots of overselling on the quality of the Audi. No doubt it drives well and likely more sporty than the NX but the quality and reliability isn’t close as the review suggests.

[@Realistick]

It’s not a Rolls or an S class, but the difference when you have them back to back is substantial. I still chose the NX for the reliability aspect but no doubt, the Q5 feels more like thoroughbred luxury.

[@441meatloaf]

That depends. Audi requires upkeep but thats expected of any luxury vehicle.

[@XiaolanLei]

why did he not buil the q5 well

[@anotheran]

I'd would prefer the q5 but I've had one as a loaner. it's cheap feeling inside and the engine is buzzy. You really need a sq5 or just buy a x3

[@pokethekat1]

As an owner of a 2017 GX 460, I too prefer the Q5 by far. I've had the NX as a rental three times, now. I hate it! The massive screen is ridiculous to operate (music) and driving it feels unsatisfying. My inlaws have a new Q5 (the 45tsfi) and it's so fun to drive and the cabin layout is far superior to the NX. Great review!

[@jewelnabq01]

I am deciding between the NX35H and the Q5 now. How are the inlaws' Q5 doing as far as maintenance and reliability? That is my concern at this stage. Are they happy with their purchase?

[@user-ye1wn3uj7e]

Any practical person knows there’s absolutely no comparison whatsoever.

[@CapELarry]

I’ve played around with those Lexus HUD dependent steering wheel controls. Whoever decided that was a good idea in the engineering department should be fired. They’re horrendous in practice.

[@PaulYason]

Agreed 100 percent, they should re-engineer that with the HUD control or go back to lower trim hard button system.

[@StarvedGhost]

I have the 2024 Q5 Premium Plus S Line PHEV, and it rides way better than the Lexus, and much faster too. Lexus reliability is hands down unbeatable as I’ve never had any problems with my Lexus previously. I never bought an Audi till now, but I just love the ride way better than the Lexus. It just feels more solid, quiet, and luxuriously comfortable.

[@HenryRoss-wu4lo]

Mazdas aren't the only thing in town cool their are but Lexus and Audi's are as well cool.

[@elmaestro196]

Lexus is much better . I have a Lexus and will buy Lexus again and again.

[@pan4632]

Your reviews are really good, keep it up. I do think that Lexus needs to invest in making a luxury car platform instead of tarting up Toyotas.

[@naveenthemachine]

Well Lexus is not luxury now. They’re probably going to be discontinued considering how lackluster Lexus really is

[@pan4632]

@@naveenthemachine aren’t u the karate kid who spends his entire life insulting Lexus on social media?

[@naveenthemachine]

@@pan4632 gee only now you figured that out😂

[@hoybezy]

I have the hybrid Audi hands down the better car don't like Lexus feels like a Toyota

[@michaelvella8511]

The NX needed to be the same size as the Q5.

[@441meatloaf]

Lexus sells you NX450 for a reason lol.

[@tonyvazquez5006]

Audi don’t hold its value Lexus has a better trade or sale value

[@TheAirak]

This guy owns an Audi

[@Realistick]

If by Audi, you mean GR Corolla, then yes🤠

[@konkurentLC]

why is the NX mentioned more often than the more luxurious Toyota, but the q5 is not mentioned once that it is a more luxurious vw tiguan/skoda kodiaq with less interior space for double price?

[@Realistick]

Because ✨it is not a dressed up Tiguan✨ (like not at all) Do some research on the MLB platform, the only common component between the tiguan and Q5 is technically the engine but even that is vastly different. Meanwhile the RAV4 and NX are so similar they share crash tests😂

[@konkurentLC]

@@Realistick yes, it's different platform, I know about MLB, I have it myself in a6 (not MLB Evo), but if you are not going to V6 in Q5 you have basicly same engines, same transmission (yes vw calls it differently), not sure about quattro ultra (in a6 is "ultra" not full real quattro) of course is more luxurious, better to drive but there are similarities, on the other hand for example Camry vs ES, same platform and also differen to drive... and just to clarify, I didn't mean it in a bad way, it's just that, especially here in Europe, there is a frequent narrative that Lexus is just an overpriced Toyota and Audi is a real premium car, as if the whole concern has been forgotten

[@Realistick]

@@konkurentLC It’s not the same transmission either though and here in the US, it makes 40 percent more power so it’s a stretch to say it has the same engine even if they are EA888. I think you would be onto something if we were talking about the A3 versus GTI or the Toureg was brought into question but definitely not the Tiguan/Q5! Also, quattro Ultra and Haldex are quite different too.

[@jeffreyerickson6766]

Thank you

[@Realistick]

Thank you for watching!

[@jeffreyerickson6766]

Tyler have you ever done a Camry SE Hybrid?

[@Realistick]

I think once in a comparison with a RAV4 Hybrid, otherwise, I drove a XLE hybrid

[@anotheran]

Omg! You got something decent

[@Realistick]

I've been trying to shake things up! However, the initial views are quite dismal, hopefully it picks up eventually.

[@anotheran]

Fridays are slow as ppl planning their weekends or evening. Monday to Wednesday are good viewership

[@rockslide4802]

No spare tire? No sale.

[@alfonsorolli1645]

No comparison. I’ve owned Audi since 1998. My brother owns a Lexus SUV. He admitted the Audi Q5 is much, much better.

[@tominmilton]

I love my Q5. Great car to drive. No problems (yet). I'd buy a Lexus but I can't get past the styling. It's subjective, but I find the NX odd looking and ugly.

[@victorbotea4244]

Not a single word about fuel consumption?

[@Realistick]

10:35

[@victorbotea4244]

@@Realistick very little infos on the pluses of the Lexus. Im not a fan of either of them, but it seems clear you're focused on promoting the Audi.

[@Realistick]

​@@victorbotea4244 Clear? I chose the Lexus at the end, and justified why I did then and at different points throughout the video. If you think this promotes the Audi, it's because for traditional luxury values, the Q5 is consistently better and this video is not centered only around my preferences as a Toyota owner.

[@kevinsullivan7831]

The lexus is one ugly car

[@naveenthemachine]

That’s easy Ones a real luxury car with proper luxury car underpinnings, good performance and handling etc. (Hint… it’s the Audi.) The other one is not a luxury car since it’s just a dressed up rav4 with lipstick. Combine that with pathetic looks, cheap interior, useless tech, useless back seats, small trunk, pathetic performance, pathetic handling, etc etc etc. (Hint… that’s the Lexus). Sure it has a hybrid but like seriously it’s a luxury car so who cares about fuel economy? Despite its age the Audi is still better. Even the RDX is better. Because those brands put out much stronger products in this segment. The nx is one of the weakest offerings in the class along side the Infiniti qx50 and qx55

[@Realistick]

I mostly agree, the Audi is definitively better but I do think the NX has the leg up for people who are flirting with the idea of a luxury suv but are intimidated by the cost!

[@naveenthemachine]

⁠​⁠@@Realistickif someone can’t afford a luxury suv, they shouldn’t even be buying one. If you want the luxury of reliability and or fuel economy, don’t buy a luxury car. Get a Toyota for that.

[@Realistick]

@@naveenthemachine I see that logic but I think there’s a lot of people that have more than Toyota money but still want to save extra cash. It’s ultimately up to the individual on whether or not they can actually afford either.

[@mr.kerryn6865]

Some people just prefer their car to work for them and not other way around. Being in service 24/7 with the car is pain in the ass.

[@441meatloaf]

@@mr.kerryn6865 Exagerate much? Audi Q5s are pretty reliable.