3 Horrifying TRUE Diner Horror Stories

These are three horrific encounters that started in diners. Thank you to the viewers who sent in their stories.
Listen to these stories + more: hypeddit.com/m...
Insta: / realmrnightmare
Twitter: mi....
TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
If you enjoy this type of content and would like to see more of it & support the channel, feel free to subscribe and turn on notifications.
If you want to send a personal TRUE story of yours, please send it through email: [e-mail]
Anything with poorly structured sentences and grammar will not be read, so please just make them neat and understandable. Please also state how you would like your name to be credited in a video.
Music:
@co.agmusic
@Myuu
@incompetech_kmac

[@yolandaponkers1581]

The woman in the first story calling 911 discreetly as she interacted with the guy and revealing the details while talking with him was such clear and quick thinking in an emergency. Glad she’s ok!

[@Ilovetosleep_inabox]

Ya that Nolan guy was DEFINITELY trying to kidnap or harm her I hope that guy is in jail

[@SeanMelendez-df3zg]

He most likely is because she gave the police his description and even if it seemed difficult to search for him they eventually found him and was than sentenced to weeks days years or life in prison hopefully the waitress is safe and sound with no worries 👍

[@MonkeMan2.0]

That Nolan guy was probably a viltrimite who happens to be conquering earth

[@WynneL]

I love it when someone gets into a situation like this and is smart rather than being one of those wishy-washy types, all "but I wasn't sure if anything was connected so I didn't act"--it's like, what help are the police going to be if you wait until the last possible second? How much time do you think it takes for someone to bash in your window? You're not safe in a car. They're not indestructible. Call as soon as you discreetly can and don't let them know you did if it all possible, not only to keep things from escalating but because it gives them more time to escape and do this to someone else. Real world heroes are people who do what she did.

[@Valoelify]

@@WynneL You can drive on a flat tire, you are safe in a car. She should have rammed it into him or sped off with a flat tire buying police enough time to get there. You can even drive off with 4 flat tires. How do people not know this...?

[@ThrillSeeker3524]

Scooby Doo taught us a long time ago that the worst monsters are always human.

[@avigutierrez8948]

Indeed😢

[@verminlordsoulberry8823]

true

[@fynnthefox9078]

Humans in monster and ghost costumes.

[@ThrillSeeker3524]

@@fynnthefox9078 True, but usually to scare people away for the sake of money or land or artifacts

[@DragonGirl2000]

That's true

[@JohannsAli]

Hey Mr.Nightmare, I just wanted to say that me and my father have enjoyed your videos for years. He sadly passed away last Friday. I want to tell you that I have fond memories of him when we watched your videos and thank you for that. Wish you the best of luck

[@Odiekins]

So sorry for your loss ❤

[@JohannsAli]

@@Odiekins thanks for your condolences, means a lot♥️

[@MyUntoldStory-r4d]

I'm so sorry for your loss

[@JohannsAli]

@@MyUntoldStory-r4d thanks♥️

[@dndmeek]

sorry for your loss, keep ya head up 🙏🏽🫶🏽

[@TheDocV627]

“My social energy was drained and I was ready to go to sleep” The most relatable line in all of Mr. Nightmare videos 🤣

[@SirNuggetdude]

FR LOL 🤣💀💀💀💀

[@joseph2832]

Church

[@TheOakle]

😂

[@rapidog5473]

Why would you ever tell complete strangers you live alone and where you live, and then not call the police when they show up at your door?!

[@Justanotheruselessaccount]

Honestly, people like that make me root for the "bad guys." They were asking for it. Also, I think most of these stories are made up. They aren't very good at writing stories.

[@coolwhipwills8365]

Simple they want the opportunity for me the GREAT CREEPY LARRY to come visit them.

[@rogue7723]

I would've said, "Nah, I live with my boyfriend who used to be in the Marines and now teaches MMA and my _two boerbols_ from Uganda who used to guard livestock from _lions and hyenas._ I've _never been_ happier."

[@bloodmoonseance2228]

some people have nooo survival skills 😑

[@coolwhipwills8365]

@@Justanotheruselessaccount Yes ROOTS FOR US CREEPS. By the way give me some info on your female co-workers. Best Regards CREEPY LARRY.

[@bracebrooks967]

That first story was the most interesting one in my opinion. I'm glad that 1st girl didn't get harmed by that creep, and the cops were able to rescue her from being stranded. I just wish that evil guy would've gotten caught and arrested for what he did.

[@GlenDeaton]

How did they not catch him if he payed card? Shouldn't they have been able to track him by that

[@SorrowAvenue]

It didn't happen. It's a classix tyre slash trope. Also, police don't show up to a roadside incident with sirens blaring. Take it from someone who's been rear ended lately. Certainly, not with three cars. Also, if this man did that, don't you think they could track his card purchase and make him out on CCTV? The story is also dramatic, which is great for a story, which it is. Come on, I shouldn't have to think for people. Critical thinking.

[@GlenDeaton]

@@SorrowAvenue yeah I have to agree

[@MattRLN]

​@@GlenDeatonik right? Maybe it was stolen??

[@ThomasMees]

@@SorrowAvenuethey are all mostly not real stories but the police having sirens after the operator hearing the smash, the screams? Yes they very much could arrive with sirens

[@hauntedham4259]

I love the vibe of breakfast diners on a road trip - vintage Americana like diners and old motels are so neat. I always order a coffee every time I go to a diner.

[@PunmasterSTP]

You ever seen David Lynch's "Lost Highway"?

[@ironman2326]

Same

[@tba113]

Diner coffee is good stuff, nothing quite like it. A hot cup of joe and a slice of warm apple pie is peak US of A.

[@thecatatemyhomework]

​It's been years since I had a decent cup of coffee at a diner in my area. Someone once told me it's because they don't clean out their pots. I don't know if that's true but all I know is that the coffee in diners taste like crap. And the food has gone down in quality as well. I live in the NYC area 👎. ​@@tba113

[@soar1ng_el3phants94]

The girl in the 3rd story slammed the door and was like: "Welp, there are unidentified creeps outside my house. Better get ready for bed!" Like girl, WHAT?!

[@PoochieCollins]

I imagined her as one of those SoCal bimbo stereotypes.

[@marshallthepupakathebricks2853]

Agreed girl are you crazy or nuts 😂😮😅

[@conndor2753]

She was just plain stupid for not calling the cops the first time they tried to get into her house. WOMAN, HOW ARE YOU STILL ALIVE??

[@ZPaul_]

Strangers asking about your personal life is an instant red flag.

[@mattstevenson1334]

Who do you date? Your sister?

[@Scarshadow666]

Tbf, MC being from the South and being used to a lot of small talk explains why being pressed for details didn't phase her - but your right that, even in Southern hospitality levels, there is such a thing as getting too personal (like there's a difference between asking if someone is married/in college/etc vs asking specifics about where they live).

[@2dsguy01]

Yeah seriously they don’t need to know any personal information like that.

[@stevenluciano2175]

😅😅😅😅​@@mattstevenson1334

[@avigutierrez8948]

Depends on the stranger🤷🏻‍♂️

[@alexandrad868]

Damn, the last person is so stupid. Why would you say that you live alone and how far you live, to a COMPLETE STRANGER?

[@PunmasterSTP]

Seems like that person was a stranger...to common sense.

[@brooklea98]

Not to mention yelling "who is it?" when you hear a knock at the door when you KNOW there are people trying to get inside your house

[@ZetaReticuli_]

That is one common thread I have noticed about every two out of three stories told here, is the lack of street smarts and overall common sense as they were all avoidable situations.

[@Dembilaja]

And decide to go to sleep without calling the police after they've just tried to break into your apartment 🤦

[@TheSlong123]

And even dumber, giving out her neighbor's names, putting them in danger. She should have said "Ted? Amy?" If their names are Steve and Lisa so that way if the person says yes then she knows it's an intruder

[@bigpapamagoo8696]

The girl in the first story was smart. She consistently made the right calls, and she's probably still alive because of it. It's nice to hear about someone making smart choices in one of thee stories

[@Heitorsexy]

it didn't happen though lol

[@Nic_2751]

Contrast to OP in the last one

[@tylerspunucious7420]

Semi-smart. No gun. Washington is a shall issue state. You go in, ask for a permit, you get printed, and you're good to go. You can keep a loaded pistol in your car of your choice, from a Glock to a Desert Eagle (though that'd be ridiculous). I'm a Washingtonian, and take advantage of this, and everyone who doesn't is foolish. Stuff like this happens, there's road rage, riots, four legged threats out here as well. It's better to be prepared and have nothing happen than it is to not prepare and have something happen.

[@tylerspunucious7420]

Except she doesn't have a firearm, and Washington is a shall issue state. As a Washington resident, it is not hard to get a CPL.

[@WoodlandGloom]

You can make al the right decisions and still lose. (coming from someone who did what they could and still got harmed)

[@Lavel_Sabke_Niklenge]

Bro, the narration is so on the point I can literally visualize the scene with great details and that's what gets me which i love it.

[@FrightFlicksFables]

I've been a fan of Mr. Nightmare for years now. He inspired me to create my own channel :)

[@sunxsetzluv]

@@FrightFlicksFablesnice! I’ll check it out :)

[@MyUntoldStory-r4d]

The actual scary thing is how stupid the girl in story 3 is to let a stranger know where she lives and she’s living alone. I easily get scared of stupid people.

[@hanonmh1995]

And decide to go to sleep without calling the police after they've just tried to break into your apartment

[@SDHorror-m1i]

DON'T SAY ANY OF THEM WHERE U LIVE!

[@newlife1658]

No common sense at all..

[@MelodyChase-pp1fj]

Dude I love ur videos so much I watch them everyday after watching all of Mr.Nightmare and MJV Animations videos

[@otovutru9693]

I can't sleep :( keep thinking about how stupid she is

[@tonyajones1463]

The last story scared me the most. Any time someone asks u if u live alone whether they are with someone else or not is always a red flag and u should never ever tell them the truth

[@FrightFlicksFables]

I was thinking the same thing! I thought people only did that in movies.. turn out people are that dumb in real life lol

[@joseph2832]

Your channel

[@marshallthepupakathebricks2853]

Agreed preach Bro preach ❤

[@marshallthepupakathebricks2853]

​@@joseph2832who's channel are you asking about?

[@blackmetalnazgul4519]

I'm currently eating at a local Dennys while listening to these stories!

[@LunalovaniaGaming]

Enjoy your meal! 🤝

[@zuluzray3638]

​@@LunalovaniaGaming Yiur just glowing

[@wtc5198]

a fellow black metal fan, nice!

[@GrowingwithJ4]

I miss Dennys

[@PunmasterSTP]

@@GrowingwithJ4 Same. The last time I ate there was years ago...

[@AshNicole-8161]

Third story: If someone knocks on my door at 1am, I am definitely not opening it! Especially without looking through the peep hole first! I don’t even open my door for an unexpected person who knocks in the middle of the day sometimes-lol. You can’t trust anyone anymore.

[@griffonwillow7789]

Eh, cops aren't always helpful.

[@coolwhipwills8365]

You can trust me I"M CREEPY LARRY. I'll be seeing you soon Nicole. Best Regards.

[@SDHorror-m1i]

I used to enjoy Mr. Nightmare's stories a lot, but they have become more fictional and AI-scripted, with character behaviors that are so stupid. I still love his voice, but I'm just a little disappointed.

[@jiggy_introvert]

Exactly if someone rings my doorbell and I don't recognize them to be family, friends or a worker of some sort I'm not even alerting them that anyone's even home lol it could be 3 cars in the driveway, nobody's here lol idk how some people can be that stupid

[@mikeysbusy]

For the last part that’s just paranoia

[@bobbeezel2593]

That last girl doesn’t seem too bright...she better move back with mom

[@ashwilliams8876]

Who said it was a woman?

[@oilersbluejayscanada]

@@ashwilliams8876 Her name was Bethany, it was mentioned in the video

[@RickGhastly-ty8cq]

​@@ashwilliams8876last time I checked , Bethany is a female name

[@EmeraldEsmerelda]

@@ashwilliams8876Don’t be an idiot.

[@specialk8329]

Yh, telling the couple she lives alone and then later on deciding not to call the police.

[@thelittlestgiant]

Story 3… She confirms they followed her home from the diner, they tried to trick her and charge into her front door, and she still didn’t call the police? What is wrong with people? Why would you NOT CALL THE POLICE after something like this?! No common sense at all..

[@SalamandraSalamandra27]

Also I wouldn't automatically trust a man with a girl. I wouldn't expect another girl to trust my bf just because I'm there too. Like you don't know him! You don't know her! So crazy.

[@zachsalamida2952]

I have to agree the only thing that saved her life was her not opening the door to them.

[@cammi9948]

Panic is a hell of a thing. People struggle to comprehend that this is ACTUALLY happening to them. Like the bystander effect but as a single person. This is why you need to think about this kind of thing or even practice

[@SalamandraSalamandra27]

@@cammi9948 I agree with this, panic makes me you do dumb things. I do still think he trust is crazy.

[@matthewjacobs2991]

Half of these aren't real and if you write a fiction where you call the police it complicates the function and the 15 year old writing isn't sure what police would do if they came so they write it so that part never happens..

[@Woodsy375]

Why would you not call the police immediately when two people try to get inside your house? Also, stay strapped or get clapped

[@ZPaul_]

Real, at least they were smart enough to not open the door. Throughout that entire exchange I was like “Don’t you open that damn door”

[@Watashi_wa_robottodesu]

because they're made up stories

[@somewhatoccupied8696]

@@ZPaul_me when I open the damn😔

[@SDHorror-m1i]

I used to enjoy Mr. Nightmare's stories a lot, but they have become more fictional and AI-scripted, with character behaviors that are so stupid. I still love his voice, but I'm just a little disappointed.

[@MaxPayne.]

My Walther PDP agrees

[@russellst.martin4255]

8:45 so weird that the cops couldn't identify him based on the security footage, even though they probably also had outside footage of his car, but either way, the dude paid by card, so they would've known exactly who he was anyway. Definitely not a made up story at all.

[@summerjones7904]

“Thanks for the service Beth” is so chilling after what they did

[@joebederka2082]

"Your blood, on me" genuinely creeped me out.

[@aviationexpert72]

Fr

[@pauldavis5665]

There are a lot of psychopaths out there. Stay safe everyone.

[@Jotinko]

That couple most likely had a blood fetish and wanted to recruit that poor girl into their nasty shit.

[@joseph2832]

Devils!

[@Hunter_shull]

I’m honored to say I’ve been watching Mr. Nightmare since 2014. No other channel can beat his content. He is truly one of a kind❤

[@lmfao2861]

Right, I remember when almost the entirety of his videos were paranormal

[@DatMVPP]

Although MrBallen is a great runner up imo

[@PunmasterSTP]

@@lmfao2861 While I don't believe in the paranormal, I loved Mr. Nightmare's videos on the subject! Also, his lists of creepy KZbin channels and videos were awesome.

[@bothermenone]

You mean 2014? Or 2015? Check the date this channel was made.

[@PunmasterSTP]

@@bothermenone You got him! Based on Mr. Nightmare's profile, the channel was started on Aug 2, 2014.

[@moai7344]

Been watching this channel for 10 yrs , the content consistently remains on top! Edit :500+ likes wtf 😱. Make it to 1K 🗿

[@adidasfan360]

I've been watching you for 10 years.

[@slitheringsnake229]

@@adidasfan360💀💀

[@jokestermasteroflaughter7754]

Here since the beginning

[@imJofu]

word

[@DinomanMayorClint]

Yeah and also I like your guinea fowl pfp.

[@lanceleader163]

Thanks for the service, Mr. Nightmare.

[@marshallthepupakathebricks2853]

Agreed

[@funnyhappystudios]

Little story relating to diners: When my family and I were eating breakfast at a Sherry’s, the place gave my sisters and I free hot chocolate because we were the most polite and quietest kids they had ever seen

[@deanfamilyadventures3464]

That’s so sweet 😊

[@ThatTabiDude]

couldnt be me fr

[@salzard97]

Initially I thought you were about to tell some horror story, instead it's such a sweet and wholesome one! ❤ For which I'm glad TBH.

[@drby0788]

Been a listener for 8 years now. Glad your channel hasn't folded, and actually grew man! Love your stuff!

[@ashwilliams8876]

9 years for me.

[@ashwilliams8876]

@@drby0788 Does anyone know the name of the song that starts at 17:25?

[@joseph2832]

Beans and toast by Billy Angus

[@amybrock2592]

No self-preservation in the third story: 1. volunteers personal information to complete strangers. 2. opens door at 1am. 3. doesn't immediately call the police when the girl says someone is chasing her, or call when the man starts trying to break in. 4. doesn't call the police after thinking about it. 5. says "who is it?" and doesn't immediately call the police when they keep banging and don't answer.

[@Formula577]

Who needs to watch horror films, when we have Mr. Nightmare?

[@JeffreyReedy-tm2xw]

3:53 Okay, unless I've missed something here. You have three people in the restaurant. Yourself, the cook, and the customer. How is the third car that's not yours and the cooks weird? 🤨🧐

[@HumanPerson_final]

The customer left earlier. I think they didn’t anticipate the customer still being in the lot.

[@KaionaV]

honestly, to me, what makes mr nightmare stand out so much, and what makes him the legitimate most favorite horror story tellers on youtube is how accurate & deep his tone is, his tone alone is creepy while explaining these stories, its not some over-reactive tone that tries to put as much emotion, & try to sound as creepy as possible which in turn comes out as corny, how the instant creepy images come up after he explains what's going on in a scary story, such as dark figures, scary looking faces, & more. god i hate when those instant images come in his videos, how sudden it comes up really makes my heart skip a beat. nobody really matches him except for maybe chilling scares.

[@PunmasterSTP]

I think the spat of new AI-generated and AI-narrated channels only highlights what makes Mr. Nightmare so great.

[@NiypoFF]

Watching this as a Tire technician while at my shop and hearing someone say they can’t change a tire makes me wanna cry.

[@elizabethebbighausen9341]

I don't understand how anyone who owns a car could possibly not know how to change a tire. My dad made sure I knew how to change a tire by the time I was 12 years old so I was never stranded, depending on someone else to do it for me. I also grew up long before cell phones so that would've never been an option to call roadside assistance or even the cops.

[@ShadyLife101]

@@elizabethebbighausen9341 I agree with you on the importance of knowing how to change a tire, however unfortunately many cars these days are sold with fix-a-flat instead of an actual spare tire. Combine that with the cost of buying one separately on top of the other costs of buying and then owning a car, many people just keep it at that. Additionally, the average weight of commercial vehicles have increased due to the popularity of trucks and suvs, further increasing the risk of an individual getting injured/killed because of a jack failure, since the tool wasn’t rated for the vehicle’s weight.

[@sparknazo]

tbf i think alot of women dont know how to do it cause their dad never thinks of teaching them where im from fixing and troubleshooting cars was a guy thing in our family

[@seandpizzle]

It is a basic bit of car ownership. Everyone should know how to change a tire

[@mitchkelleher7972]

Agree, but in that waitress's case, she'd have been really screwed if she had gotten out to change it.

[@lalisasmr]

"Better safe than sorry" yet doesn't call the cops immediately 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@maddencardinals9551]

At least the 15 year old called the cops in the 2nd story

[@perfectkill2456]

I don't think these are real but interesting af anyway

[@sicooper4230]

It's a shame diners have died out so much.The mom & pop ones were the best so i hear. They had a sense of community more akin to a cafe and were an integral part of everyday life.

[@tommybomber]

my plan is to open a diner in my local area. ive always wanted to own one, figured the area could use something like that.

[@thegodofpez]

Always a beautiful thing when Mr. Nightmare drops a new gem!

[@DugTrouble]

The 1st story, if he "paid by card", he would've been fairly easy to track down. The police could've gotten a real name & address at least.

[@bissutttsmat88788]

Unless the card was stolen, chances are, the man knew that this was a possibility that he might get caught

[@avigutierrez8948]

Possible but likely🤷🏻‍♂️

[@dannybursace9151]

Super fishy…and when do waitresses call the cook, “chef” in a simple dinner multiple times…calling BS on S1

[@poeticsilence047]

​@dannybursace9151 second story too. "I'm a 15 year old guy" lol your a kid bro.

[@sleeperr.d]

PLEASE DONT EVER STOP MAKING VIDEOS 😭

[@sleeperr.d]

We’ll miss you so much 🖤

[@wavy_shams]

I feel like diners are slowly becoming a thing of the past

[@wwemad09]

That’s a real shame. Love diners.

[@korneliusheydrich4095]

@@wwemad09 Tourist diner are still thriving...unless you're talking about those truck/pit stop one then yeah it's dying

[@ashwilliams8876]

No they're still thriving

[@ashwilliams8876]

@@wavy_shams Does anyone know the name of the song that starts at 17:25?

[@Jessa-RM]

Same, in the downtown area of my city there's an actual old-school lunch counter, the interior of the building hasn't been changed since the 30's but the food is solid

[@arcticfox6808]

The last one makes my brain hurt. No police call after they show up? You don't own a gun? Come on, man.

[@NovaJayYT]

The way he said ‘’your blood on me’’ sent chills down my spine 🫣

[@sharonkiely1616]

I love mr nightmare voice ❤ find it very soothing. Listening from ireland 🇮🇪 👌

[@GlitzBunni]

Me from south africa 🇿🇦

[@ultraspinalki11]

I first discovered your channel when i got my nightshift job back in 2014. Im still working there, and still get entertained by your vids!

[@jakel5892]

17:25 why tf would you not call the police? 🙄

[@ashwilliams8876]

Does anyone know the name of the song that starts at 17:25?

[@jordannaive1081]

Why would you tell someone you don’t know you live alone 😅

[@sparklemotion8377]

Any sympathy I had left for telling a complete stranger WHERE you live ALONE went out the window, and I didn't even bother continuing to listen. I need trigger warnings for stupidity.

[@joakimwolff3626]

Nothing better to cheer myself up with on a stormy Tuesday than a Mr.nightmare video

[@j1playz309]

omg you posted as soon as i start watching u again, its a sign! you are greatness buddy!

[@Yoonat3]

Bro has been doing this for at least 10 years with the same format and it still never gets old he knows something we dont

[@TheBlazeMiner]

Mr. Nightmare, I love you dawg. Thanks for providing me, and everyone else consistent entertainment. Work is always slow for me... I work second shift at IHOP. Luckily, my managers don't mind if I pop a headphone in to listen to ya stories!

[@lukashavenstein7975]

5:04 i felt that tap 😮‍💨😮‍💨

[@PunmasterSTP]

Yeah, that got me too!

[@ashwilliams8876]

Does anyone know the name of the song that starts at 17:25?

[@lynnphilo472]

😂

[@SergiuSalcau00]

Same

[@thegodofpez]

For story #1, the server said that “Nolan” paid with a credit card. Ummmm problem solved on finding the guy’s identity right there. 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

[@brandyrodgers4329]

Unless it was stolen

[@shrimpwalk8230]

@@brandyrodgers4329 Even in the circumstance it was stolen, they could've made other payments on the card to give a general idea of where the person is at. Corroborate that with CCTVs of other establishments where said person used their credit card to get more information.

[@MisfitHorror]

It’s always a better day when Mr. Nightmare uploads.

[@bigggguyyyy]

this is a perfect listen for late night job in the kitchen of a sports bar🔥 been listening to Mr Nightmare since 2015 and won't stop‼️

[@907Gaming]

A new Nightmare video always gives me my motivation at work❤

[@bigbsbrickreveiw3264]

At least you get to listen to Mr nightmare while you work at your job because I can't listen to it while I work but I listen to him to and from work cuz I ride my bike each day that I go to work and I have all of his videos downloaded on my MP3

[@__JessieLewis]

All we need is a compilation of some sort or longer formed videos.

[@PawzyCon]

@@bigbsbrickreveiw3264 i respect the hustle. making do with what you got.

[@__Freya__]

I like listening to him well doing my homework or just stuff around the house

[@bigbsbrickreveiw3264]

@@__Freya__ yeah I listen to him all the time what's your favorite video by him

[@sakurahime1325]

Listening to this while on speaker in my room on a rainy day on a day off from work, its really relaxing. Thank you mr nightmare! Been a subscriber for 5 years now, going on 6

[@ExplorinNature]

Love it, you knows it’s a good day when Mr nightmare uploads

[@christiancervantes4264]

Me and my dad always go to Denny's and IHOP Restaurant at some time a week or month for Breakfast, Launch, celebrate birthdays and holidays including my trip, I am still fully aware of my surroundings during the time.

[@wolfcrouch]

Always love an upload by Mr. Nightmare been a fan for nearly 10 years now, any chance of Lighthouse Landlord Missing 411 Stalker First Responder/EMT stories please :D

[@blue-ib1fn]

13:48 you didnt see that question as a red flag...???????!!!!!?!?!? Oh god, she wont make it far in life 💀💀💀

[@dravenbeaupre-trudo5402]

Duuude right

[@redcoffeez]

You are like my comfort youtuber. Love watching your vids

[@ChillingDread-e7u]

I love your stories man. Thank you so much!

[@marshallthepupakathebricks2853]

Agreed

[@YT_Wesley87]

props to mr nightmare for giving us scary stories for years

[@avon1243]

My anxiety levels always go up with these stories!

[@ScaryStoryAnimated-gc8ud]

what time are you guys watching this? Me first, 4 am lol, cant sleep

[@Prakask_solanki388]

12, haha

[@rajeshkumarsingh6348]

5 A.M, it's not that scary lol

[@AngadKumar-oq1qu]

3 AM

[@Faizanhiphop]

8 pm, its not midnight at my place yet

[@सुमितकुमार-फ2ब]

same

[@stupeiacedefective_]

Listening to this on the road at night might just be one of the best feelings 😌

[@NHLBEAST-]

I’m a simple guy, I see Mr. Nightmare upload, i click.

[@slocarfr]

its always a good day when mr. nightmare uploads

[@ragekage702]

Dude is spoiling us at this point.

[@HorrorStoryEnigma16990]

The suspense, the tension, the mystery - all flawlessly done!

[@muhammadchaka4142]

Nothing better than a Mr nightmare upload

[@freddiecook3238]

man for the past few days ive been watching your videos at night after not watching a long time (6-8ish years) and your videos are so good, STILL

[@ankurbhaskar4634]

Listened to all these with my dad for the first time, and after each one I’d pause so he could tell me related stories irl to be street smart. We both agreed that the Bethany in the 3rd story should’ve barricaded the doors [after realizing she was all alone in her house] and called the police right then & there. Had she done that, the police could’ve caught & arrested both of them when they came up the stairs inside the house for a second time.

[@PatriciaClark-su3wc]

Don't ever tell strangers where you live or anything else about your life! This first video is scary!

[@KgopisoSaul]

Mr nightmare is the best indeed ❤😊

[@connorkick7397]

"Toyota or audi or something" that's wilddddd

[@mbank3832]

My heart drops to my stomach when I see Mr Nightmare uploads new video

[@SirNuggetdude]

Same

[@Davidwife]

I love all his videos and how he talks I watch these videos while I’m cleaning my house connected to the Bluetooth speaker and just start cleaning and listening they are the best thank you for your videos

[@Gumi_bearr]

Yay waking up to a upload from me nightmare

[@vs-cd6qq]

Brother, I've been watching you since 2015, I have exhausted your videos pretty much so it's great any time you upload. Personal opinion, but I really prefer focusing on stories instead of interrupting the storytelling with videos. Wishing you all the best!

[@Monica313_]

To think of all these things I’ve gone thru in life the like 10 years or so and throughout all these years Mr. Nightmare has always been a comfort for me throughout everything lmfao. Idk what I’d do if he stopped uploading 😭

[@PunmasterSTP]

Me neither. Since listening to Mr. Nightmare I've gotten married and had kids.

[@RonaldMcDonald-z2g]

@@PunmasterSTPpiece by piece

[@RonaldMcDonald-z2g]

@@PunmasterSTPpop a perk

[@PunmasterSTP]

@@RonaldMcDonald-z2g Why do you keep replying that? I assume this is a bot account, but why did you choose that particular reply?

[@RonaldMcDonald-z2g]

@@PunmasterSTP piece by piece

[@dawsonrank1469]

Couldn’t they have tracked bro in the first story by the card he used at the diner?

[@PunmasterSTP]

Yeah, seems like they could have.

[@dewaldsteyn1306]

Yeah, but it could have been stolen.

[@jessicarodriguez6017]

let’s gooo😩🗣️ i can listen to it while going to work

[@sentient_meat]

Holy Testicle Tuesday! Love when a surprise Mr. Nightmare vid drops.

[@Darkwolf-ey4jz]

testicle Tuesday is crazy 🤣

[@l4mbojon757]

The king of scary stories!!!

[@kazmena4801]

lmao the last story had me burst out laughing 🤣 ik it’s different when you’re in the moment and scared or w/e but “i want you blood on me” has got to be THE funniest attempt at being scary i have ever heard in my life 😭 ok edgelord!

[@chelseacoutts4230]

Mr Nightmare, you absolute legend!

[@marshallthepupakathebricks2853]

Agreed

[@nicholaslaport3354]

That last story ends with "better safe then sorry" and in my head I was screaming that same thing when she didn't call 911 when the couple were at the front door trying to scam their way in after obviously following her home from work! She, for some reason, waited to call 911 after they somehow got to that second door. The people in some of these stories are so hesitant to call the police that it makes it difficult for me to understand their perspective.

[@cell673]

It’s a good day when Mr nightmare uploads

[@yazspaz]

I love seeing a new mr.nightmare video, they be my favorite videos fr

[@PunmasterSTP]

Any other channels you really like?

[@shawnadennis613]

Yes, another Mr. Nightmare video to listen to on my lunch break!! ❤

[@MidnightMysteries-c5z]

This video is pure gold! The part around 8:53 was so interesting! You've got a knack for storytelling. Subscribed!

[@TheChairDude55]

Mr.nightmare can you please do KZbinr/twitch stream horror stories

[@CrypticAbyss-v9n]

This is definitely one of the best videos I’ve seen on this subject. Amazing job!

[@MisfitHorror]

I will collaborate with you one day Mr. Nightmare. You are my inspiration for me starting my own narrations. 👻

[@Elixprix]

You can do it, bro. As a fellow small channel myself, it’s important to never give up and keep going. I believe in you, Brother

[@BapyTheSnowman]

hearing the first story was set in Washington (home sweet home) lowkey hits harder that extra touch of "oh shit this happened in my home state" makes it extra creepier

[@tainamichelle2683]

Mr. Nightmare is one of the best KZbinrs that does narrative videos. His voice definitely adds to the horror and the sound effects too.

[@nevillenaude5295]

You know it's going to be a fantastic evening when it's night time and there's a new Mr nightmare video

[@FrancistheBrave]

Damn a mr nightmare video this early. I will be listening this tonight ✌🏾✌🏾✌🏾

[@MarkGutierrez-n2e]

Much love and respect from Santa Maria California 💙❤️🤖

[@DonnyMartinez-i6n]

Mr nightmare keep up the good work 👍

[@marshallthepupakathebricks2853]

Agreed

[@sanjukumari7684]

Hey, the 3rd one is my story.

[@2AVA37]

Glad you are okay!

[@whitneysanders1213]

Fr!❤

[@BioLivbanon]

Is it real, or did you make it up?

[@TheForgotten101]

Is it real? Also if it is, that's crazy man

[@thomasmarronnnnn]

Right when I needed a video to listen to at work, perfect