4. Jay Smith: Muhammad - A Historical Critique

To learn more about how to love and reach out to muslims for Christ, check out the complete series on onlinelearning.ibiol.org
You can also sign up for our full-time programmes for 6 months, 1 year or 2 years at the International Bible Institute of London. More info on www.ibiol.org
More videos like this here: bit.ly/2vDSDoE

[@srfrg9707]

Islam is not about God. It's about power. Truth is of no importance. It's not the religion of truth, nor the religion of salvation. It's the religion of submission.

[@andvel2]

They are blinded by Satan, and must come to the knowledge of truth as it is in Jesus Christ. The Son of God.

[@rabbithare381]

Exactly it's the religion of submission.. The same submission Abraham Isaac, Moses, & Jesus practiced + followed.. Look it up in your bible or do a google search to confirm these facts....

[@srfrg9707]

Rabbit Hare Wrong. They submit to Ceasar, Jesus teached to submit to God.

[@rabbithare381]

@@srfrg9707 So where did I go wrong? Isn't it the same thing I said or you misunderstood my statement? Like I said Abraham, Isaac Moses and Jesus all submitted to God!!!!!!

[@srfrg9707]

Rabbit Hare In Islam you have to submit to Muhammad and the califes after him. Allah is a pretext.

[@hypota6872]

Thanks, As an ex muslim I always asked these questions about Mohammad and Maccea and never got any answer, now I know the Islam is not more than a tool for rulers, sad for muslim folk.

[@edbtzkhud]

Hypota68 you edited your fake comment yet you still don’t know how to spell Mecca? You’re a phony! Ex Muslim my ass! PLEASE spare me your bullshit.

[@mujiburr.9667]

Yeps so you comes to comment on lecture on Christian evangelist, apologist (Christian Fundamentalist) and a purely Christian Fundamentalist org funded lecture. If you really like to reasonable critique then read or lesson real Scholars and atheist critique. You position here is really questionable. It is clear you are a fake like many others, know nothing about Islam at all. BTW don't your fundamentalist Islamic rulers beheaded you for Apostate???

[@Banditos07]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/f4qwfISBiLtjmLs

[@anggidamara8494]

Here we go.lol. As annex moslem you even cant type mecca correctly

[@abdulazizyalahow3238]

Hypota68 Hahahaha oh yeah lol 😂

[@buddyduddyful]

I sincerely admire the enthusiasm which radiates outword from this dynamic teacher.

[@humatariq4698]

can you traslate all this in arabic and urdu language so it can be useful for pakistani and arabic people.

[@AbuUbaida89]

?

[@parlinsitorus1573]

Hopely someone will translate it, my brother

[@linak7155]

Have you heard of SoniaAzam7? Visit her channel sometime. She's an ex muslim Pakistani British young lady filled with sound speech...

[@lateshpatil5307]

@@AbuUbaida89 Urdu is just same as Hindi just that urdu uses the arabic writing style.

[@anil0420]

Over 90 mins and one slide on Jesus and concludes that Jesus's history he can stand upon 😀

[@nopenein5071]

1. They would not believe it 2. Even if they do they would not admit it 3. They will say you racist and islamophobic

[@v.r.2834]

unknown people on internet In that case I respond them : You are mentally ill like your prophet 😅

[@idapurwadaningsih4500]

The unknow person in internet is fool, use your brain

[@nopenein5071]

@@idapurwadaningsih4500 i did

[@nopenein5071]

@@muktyleo lol indeed

[@idapurwadaningsih4500]

@@muktyleo Some people does not believes about the reality, but in order to make better they just said LOL. Like you, by the way i'm not Christian, i used to bee a muslimah but I realize this is the false when I'm in Egypt

[@esecallum]

When it comes to Muslims, they use four lies which you can depend on them saying. 1: You need to read it in Arabic 2: It's a weak hadith. 3: It's been abrogated. 4: You are taking it out of context. To which I always respond 1: Your scholars translated it into English, take it up with them. 2: If it is weak then why is it available to read? 3: Allah couldn't get it right the first time? 4: How hard is it to take it out of context, don't you understand the words? You just have to remember, it is only when they get cornered do they fall back on those. So count them as points when they say one of those four things because they don't have answers.?

[@dimspacha]

I would respond: 1. Original words are better than translated ones, you would know if you spoke more than 2 languages 2. Weak hadiths have been labeled so, for good reasons, now why they keep them is up to the scholars (probably to keep them as archives of their work, proving that they respected the method they set forth; or to document what kind of false hadith people spread at their time) 3. Abrogated means that their application knows exceptions and are dependant on the context of the situation. Some verses need to be "completed" with other verses to have the full ruling. 4. To take somethhing out of context is easy and you know it, all you have to do is not read the full chapter, or AT LEAST the 4 verses preceding and following what you are "quoting" But I am no scholar and God knows best. As for liars and wordtwisters who would do anything to win an argument, muslim or not, I say shame on them, Truth does not need lying advocate, for truth LOVES scrutiny. Islam promotes questionning, critics and inquiries. As it should, for it is the only way to prove its truthfulness. May God guide us all

[@esecallum]

@@dimspacha And why do you need this cacophony of confusion and ambiguity to live.are incapable of thinking for yourself?

[@dimspacha]

@@esecallum "Man is born free, but everywhere he is in chains" - Rousseau We are all subject/slave to sthg. Some pledge their soul to money, some to glory, love, science, ideas/values, and some to their own desires (alcohol, etc.) If you find this confusing, you would have an aneurism if you studied Law... XD Look where thinking for urself got you... vomiting hate on social media XD Look for inner peace buddy Best use that scientifically unexplicable advanced rational of yours (how can the ability to paint help anyone in his survival and propagation of genes?") to understand that you need to chill the fuck out ;)

[@lionabbass]

anything in the language that it is 1st written/spoken/practiced is best understood in that language and every other languages that is translated into is at best imitation and imitation cheese is not the real thing. weak hadith is classified as such after thorough scholarship on it. you must have to admit that if the original writer knew all the issues about it when he was writing it down, he probably would not written it. the science of classification came as knowledge is gathered through the generations. earth was flat was accepted at some earlier time in human history. consider that as hadith for the sake of critical thinking. earth is now a sphere/globe/orangey. you will accept this later shape. this is now a strong hadith type instead of the earth is flat which i have used to coast you to think about this. drinking was not abrogated at the beginning of prophetic revelation in Makka. it took over 13 years of revelations before consumption of alcohol was abrogated/not permissible to drink it at all. you must now begin to see how your statements against Islam is wrong. Allah does not make things hard. no soul is tasked more than it can handle. whatever Allah commands you, it is not a burden. take for instance if the day you were born, mom told you eze use the toilet to defecate. that will be a hard thing for you to do, instead mom put diaper on you. but now that you are a strong adult like a raging bull in the prime of your youth/young life putting you in a diaper will be abnormal, at least from mom. you now handle your business in the bathroom. this is Mercy. Allah knows your limit and every commandment fits your stage, your limit, your maturity, person-hood. it is absolutely necessary that issues are contextualized. if i say good evening to you when it is early morning, it is either in my time zone its evening. or if we are on the same time zone, i may just be ready for bed or don't know that it the next day because those people in casino gambling don't see the time has passed and the last time they looked was last evening and since time flies when having fun, next morning might have arrived without realizing it.

[@anjaknatz7157]

Very smart! Thank you!!!

[@jackjones3657]

If institutions of higher "learning" were intellectually honest and objective, courses with teachings like this would be mainstays.

[@AggressiveHiDef]

@M-K Production I checked every single reference and even went beyond, not only is Jay Smith correct, there's historic proof he's correct.

[@ibrawolf8440]

@@shafiurrahman2912 shit

[@albusai]

@@shafiurrahman2912 Quran is man made

[@robertnealy]

@@AggressiveHiDef mmm mmm mmmm mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmmmmmmkmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmkmmmmmmmmkmmmm mmmkmkmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmkmmmmmmmmkmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmkmmmmmmmmkmmmm mmmmkmmmmmkmmmmmmm m mmmmmmmmmmmm m mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm Mmmmmmmmmmmm mmm mmmmmmmm mmm Mm mmm mmmmmmm Mmmm mmm mmmm mmmmmmmmmmm

[@juerbert1]

Jay Smith is a fearless man of GOD ! Praise be to our Gracious GOD !!!

[@misterlogik8163]

I do not for 1 moment doubt what he presents on Islam BUT Christianity is also a man made religion as Jesus is a Roman creation.

[@InIt2winIt247]

@@misterlogik8163 they don't want to hear The truth!

[@ThespianKila]

​@@misterlogik8163 lol rubbish. Research DNA - SULFURIC BRIDGE. It's coded into you xx

[@albusai]

😅😅😅 says no true historian ever ​@@misterlogik8163

[@leeeric8436]

1 hour worth of knowledge. My hour well spent. Why didn't all my college days/ hours spent in class touch on intellectual topics of such prominence ?

[@LlyneM-rf3gd]

@@mamstray2624 how can you read the quran and not see all the violence and hate and immorality? Were you given a dhimmi quran? How could you possibly think of Muhammad as a good person?

[@kaka_kaka28]

Jay Smith entangled in his own web of CONFUSION! God goes to toilet BUT He is too great! kzbin.info/www/bejne/hZW3dnhnp9KhaNE

[@stealyourfacekev]

Faster Hard House actually collage does mislead people with evolution

[@kaka_kaka28]

@Collin Lutz , The below vesrses are from the Holy Bible. Kill People Who Don’t Listen to Priests Anyone arrogant enough to reject the verdict of the judge or of the priest who represents the LORD your God must be put to death. Such evil must be purged from Israel. (Deuteronomy 17:12 NLT) Kill Witches You should not let a sorceress live. (Exodus 22:17 NAB) Kill Homosexuals “If a man lies with a male as with a women, both of them shall be put to death for their abominable deed; they have forfeited their lives.” (Leviticus 20:13 NAB) Kill Fortunetellers A man or a woman who acts as a medium or fortuneteller shall be put to death by stoning; they have no one but themselves to blame for their death. (Leviticus 20:27 NAB) Death for Hitting Dad Whoever strikes his father or mother shall be put to death. (Exodus 21:15 NAB) Death for Cursing Parents 1) If one curses his father or mother, his lamp will go out at the coming of darkness. (Proverbs 20:20 NAB) 2) All who curse their father or mother must be put to death. They are guilty of a capital offense. (Leviticus 20:9 NLT) Death for Adultery If a man commits adultery with another man’s wife, both the man and the woman must be put to death. (Leviticus 20:10 NLT) Death for Fornication A priest’s daughter who loses her honor by committing fornication and thereby dishonors her father also, shall be burned to death. (Leviticus 21:9 NAB) Death to Followers of Other Religions Whoever sacrifices to any god, except the Lord alone, shall be doomed. (Exodus 22:19 NAB) Kill Nonbelievers They entered into a covenant to seek the Lord, the God of their fathers, with all their heart and soul; and everyone who would not seek the Lord, the God of Israel, was to be put to death, whether small or great, whether man or woman. (2 Chronicles 15:12-13 NAB)

[@kaka_kaka28]

@Collin Lutz , some more loving verses from the Holy Bible. Kill False Prophets If a man still prophesies, his parents, father and mother, shall say to him, “You shall not live, because you have spoken a lie in the name of the Lord.” When he prophesies, his parents, father and mother, shall thrust him through. (Zechariah 13:3 NAB) Kill the Entire Town if One Person Worships Another God Suppose you hear in one of the towns the LORD your God is giving you that some worthless rabble among you have led their fellow citizens astray by encouraging them to worship foreign gods. In such cases, you must examine the facts carefully. If you find it is true and can prove that such a detestable act has occurred among you, you must attack that town and completely destroy all its inhabitants, as well as all the livestock. Then you must pile all the plunder in the middle of the street and burn it. Put the entire town to the torch as a burnt offering to the LORD your God. That town must remain a ruin forever; it may never be rebuilt. Keep none of the plunder that has been set apart for destruction. Then the LORD will turn from his fierce anger and be merciful to you. He will have compassion on you and make you a great nation, just as he solemnly promised your ancestors. “The LORD your God will be merciful only if you obey him and keep all the commands I am giving you today, doing what is pleasing to him.” (Deuteronomy 13:13-19 NLT) Kill Women Who Are Not Virgins On Their Wedding Night But if this charge is true (that she wasn’t a virgin on her wedding night), and evidence of the girls virginity is not found, they shall bring the girl to the entrance of her fathers house and there her townsman shall stone her to death, because she committed a crime against Israel by her unchasteness in her father’s house. Thus shall you purge the evil from your midst. (Deuteronomy 22:20-21 NAB) Kill Followers of Other Religions. 1) If your own full brother, or your son or daughter, or your beloved wife, or you intimate friend, entices you secretly to serve other gods, whom you and your fathers have not known, gods of any other nations, near at hand or far away, from one end of the earth to the other: do not yield to him or listen to him, nor look with pity upon him, to spare or shield him, but kill him. Your hand shall be the first raised to slay him; the rest of the people shall join in with you. You shall stone him to death, because he sought to lead you astray from the Lord, your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, that place of slavery. And all Israel, hearing of this, shall fear and never do such evil as this in your midst. (Deuteronomy 13:7-12 NAB) 2) Suppose a man or woman among you, in one of your towns that the LORD your God is giving you, has done evil in the sight of the LORD your God and has violated the covenant by serving other gods or by worshiping the sun, the moon, or any of the forces of heaven, which I have strictly forbidden. When you hear about it, investigate the matter thoroughly. If it is true that this detestable thing has been done in Israel, then that man or woman must be taken to the gates of the town and stoned to death. (Deuteronomy 17:2-5 NLT) Death for Blasphemy One day a man who had an Israelite mother and an Egyptian father got into a fight with one of the Israelite men. During the fight, this son of an Israelite woman blasphemed the LORD’s name. So the man was brought to Moses for judgment. His mother’s name was Shelomith. She was the daughter of Dibri of the tribe of Dan. They put the man in custody until the LORD’s will in the matter should become clear. Then the LORD said to Moses, “Take the blasphemer outside the camp, and tell all those who heard him to lay their hands on his head. Then let the entire community stone him to death. Say to the people of Israel: Those who blaspheme God will suffer the consequences of their guilt and be punished. Anyone who blasphemes the LORD’s name must be stoned to death by the whole community of Israel. Any Israelite or foreigner among you who blasphemes the LORD’s name will surely die. (Leviticus 24:10-16 NLT)

[@dadsonworldwide3238]

I try to take Jay's Quran verses to Muslim chat and all they do is ignore me by asking the same old questions of chritianty .he's got them on the defense they aren't prepared .

[@edbtzkhud]

Dadson worldwide shut up you lying coward. If I only knew where you’re from I’d sit and talk or even debate you. Don’t come on here with your lies like atypical coward just to make a stupid point.

[@rayg4360]

and ?

[@emanfotostudio3722]

hahahahah ... J. smith run away from Speaker corner ...

[@husinmamood4616]

Jerzy Wałaszek ..."Ye see tje mountain, Ye thinkest it is fixed at its place.Nay but it fly just like the cloudd fly.Such is the artistry of Allah who created firmest of everything.And verily Allah is all seeing of what you do" The holy Quraan Annaml 88.

[@George-iv1hi]

Husin Mamood: Maybe you should use plain English, you know, I don't speak Arabic.

[@hopesingh1640]

Truth hurts but will set you free and free indeed.

[@stantorren4400]

Amanda no mate Jesus might be real as the romans showed he was real BUT it was the roman empire that spread christianity not jesus also no one really knows whether or not he was the son of god as he has a lot of mystery

[@toni4729]

@@amanda.collaud 😍Who told you these stupid fairy stories while you were so young? Your grandmother? Someone for sure? You swallow this bull hook line and sinker. Something you've never ever seen, something you never will see and you bow and scrape to it for your entire life believing that he, or it will look after you once you've turned to dust, dead. You're terrified of dying. You're so afraid of what's going to happen to you in the end. You're scared to death of something, some ghostly thing your elders told you about that you've never ever seen. Silly thing. FEAR is a terrible thing to be afraid of.

[@normanstratford9329]

The lecture came across very well and the development of Islam was without prejudice.

[@kumarg3598]

I agree. I only wish he didn't add his preference for Christianity because it casts doubt. Not much doubt because his points are clear but I can see how a Muslim may find this fishy.

[@peorakef]

@@kumarg3598 tbf, if he was an atheist it wouldnt be more convincing to a muslim

[@kumarg3598]

@@peorakef if he were an atheist, he wouldnt say that christianity is better or that jesus is a better. He makes it sound like a contest, which it isnt and never will be. Let me put it another way, if erhman or carrier were to debate jay, i bet jay would act just like the muslims hes complaining about. I was born a hindu and am somewhat religious; however, i fail to see why god would care which imaginary figure i pray to. What kind of a god gets jealous? Is this god a child?

[@peorakef]

@@kumarg3598 so youre not an atheist, opinion dismissed.

[@kumarg3598]

@@peorakef i believe theres something and that something could be the equations and constants running our universe. This something neither talk to anyone (let alone me) nor desires anything from anyone, it it just does. I think thats closer to atheism than theism.

[@onestepaway3232]

The question is the Angel. Why did angel frighten and torment Mohammed? No where in the Bible did that happen to God’s prophets. Jesus is my living hope!

[@GardeniaInc]

@Commendatorehow other prophet receive revelation??fyi bible insult mary..but al quran honour her isnt??must confuse between bible or al quran right?why not copy/contain that?

[@GardeniaInc]

@Commendatore that happen when only read translation try learn arabic and its law detail the verse and take it out little by little..will amaze with this verse and shock in praise..worse will revert to islam.need to becareful😁if still talking about cave..until end of the world..will not go anywhere..al quran beyond than it teach extraordinary thing..knowledge from creator..either grab or left it.

[@GardeniaInc]

@Commendatore fyi prophet total send to human exist hundred thousand send to different race i bet you dont know that..simpliest example..start from adam what languange he know and speak all prophet noah,lot,abraham,etc..or moses send to israelite using languange hebrew jesus he doesnt speak greek..or english..but aramic.but the best question why arabic use as final revelation languange..try study that.monothiesm to worship creator already start long time ago..when creation exist.no matter what languange allah swt use who the prophet from which race..😏still not grateful or not worship isnt?..not follow command..of god..that just human excuses.

[@Kaergaard]

@Commendatore Islam has as much proof as any other religion. If its a burning bush or an angel stopping a man from killing his son, it all seems like a bunch of maniacs that in modern day would be put away in mental hospitals, not followed and praised.

[@v.r.2834]

One Step Away Probably was Muhammed psychically ill, suffered of schizophrenia and had hallucinations

[@morugascorpion6021]

Former Muslim here. Thank you for sharing this information!

[@harshum5474]

nice ID name

[@MrSeadawg123]

Uh he is lying to you right off the bat. No one knows who wrote the Gospels. We know Paul wrote the epistles. But it was also modified. This guy deceives by omission. Do a little research. Pretty much all religious people are liars. He is no exception.

[@migzraul2482]

@@MrSeadawg123 he dont have solid knowledge of the bible... kzbin.info/www/bejne/ppfLloZ3mKimqKc..... kzbin.info/www/bejne/qZCQi6Kiq7-LZ5I...

[@asimsarikaya1618]

God thanks you did, Islam does not need stupid people like you. I bet youre a gay or something like that.

[@BEAMERBMWboy]

15. O people of the Book! There hath come to you our Messenger, revealing to you much that ye used to hide in the Book, and passing over much (that is now unnecessary): There hath come to you from Allah a (new) light and a perspicuous Book. Surah5. Verse 15

[@mattkamar9994]

Interesting analysis.... Thank you Jay Smith ... Well Done !

[@hassenounis1832]

www.youtube. com/watch?v=krAJbQ2WxO4 what about this ? he proved that he is a liar

[@atheistsinceborn4903]

@Khalid Ibn Alwaleed dude fuck his debates how could you believe in texts written by a 8 year old fucker?

[@AggressiveHiDef]

@@hassenounis1832 Jay Smith goes by Historic Facts, he is not a liar.

[@toni4729]

@Khalid Ibn Alwaleed Atheism is the only reply to all this bullshit.

[@toni4729]

@@atheistsinceborn4903 😏Now, now my good friend, this is no time to be showing yourself up with bad language. At least have a laugh over it. It's worth a giggle isn't it? No need for swearing.

[@stickman-1]

This and Bill Warners videos should be required viewing in every high school

[@tarekmazouni]

The first fallacy is that the quran wasn't reaten during prophet life. And it goes on. So saying thats historical fact is rong from the begining. "Thats the only narrative" that's also rong statement

[@stickman-1]

@@tarekmazouni LOL. You are the perfect Islamist apologists.

[@tarekmazouni]

@@stickman-1 respending to a critic is being apologist? To what exactly

[@vachevyguy]

Winston Churchill Said it best Islam is to man as rabies is to a dog

[@husinmamood4616]

vachevyguy ..Amd Winston Churchill is dead nut lslam is still alive and more and more british people leaving christianity and revert to God's way of life.

[@humayunanwar]

Islam is there forever .. but Winston kind of shitts went to hell .. He will Never come back .. Difference is very clear .. U plz have couple of drinks and don't worry too much about Islam

[@vikramrazdan5680]

@@husinmamood4616 I don't agree with Winston Churchill's (a racist) statement which was made 'off-the'cuff' without any evidence or historical proof. There is a Pakistani-Canadian who has concluded that the 'original Quran' was usurped by the Caliphs and modified to suit their agenda of military conquests, which could only happen if the Muslim soldiers considered the opposing forces as 'enemies of Islam' rather than 'enemies of Arabs'; that way the conquests could be justified. The question is how much of the current Quran is 'revelation of Allah' and how much has been 'added or modified' by the Caliphs. Instead of belittling the Quran, the objective should be to find out the 'extras' in Quran and weed these out.

[@fainitesbarley2245]

Vikram Razdan Churchill was in Muslim countries and he was talking about a religion not a race.

[@vikramrazdan5680]

@@fainitesbarley2245 I meant that Winston Churchill was a person with biased opinions about other races and religions, and any statement from such a devious person is garbage!

[@boatengjoseph1059]

This video make much sense, now we know thanks professor Jay Smith God Richly Bless you

[@hassenounis1832]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaOke5WHZ7yrhZY

[@tsapp2831]

@@hassenounis1832 Christian prince

[@AggressiveHiDef]

@@hassenounis1832 Thanks for proving that the Koran is made up of borrowed books from Christianity and stories from the Jews.

[@AggressiveHiDef]

@Khalid Ibn Alwaleed Interesting how Muslims continue to deny basic Historic Facts, presented right in front of you all, yet you continue to deny these facts. It makes sense how Jesus Christ raised the dead, healed thousands, never sinned, never killed, never robed, died and rose from the dead, claimed to be God & Son of God that was proven to be right by his own resurrection, and yet you BLINDLY choose to follow a murdering pedophile called Mohammad? Seriously? OPEN YOUR BLOODY EYES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@flnteenof3793]

Watch also this debate of jay smith kzbin.info/www/bejne/gaPboqefncdsidU

[@sashapillai7430]

Bless you for uploading this informative video. I learned a lot.👌

[@penguin1165]

Wonderful video 👍. So interesting and informative thankyou

[@miriamlaldin5397]

Amen God bless you for opening the eyes

[@edoycampus370]

As ten years truck driver in saudi Arabia, that trade route is impossible to exist,,,, and im sure every driver like me says the same😪

[@tishimself126]

Because of the desert?

[@albee8740]

Because you not strong as arab man, pussy lil rat

[@ryanb7385]

@@albee8740 Lol arabs strong? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@albee8740]

@@ryanb7385 yup we are made for desert... lil bitch 😂

[@albee8740]

@manjeet singh you need some history lesson ... ugly bitch 🙄

[@BSwitzerland]

they found out in 2018 actually that at mosque in Turkey in the Provinz Yalova, was built wrong 37 years ago and they prayed in a wrong direction

[@TheEngineer1971]

don james Jesus is the living god whether you like it or not, Muhammad was a false prophet who killed raped and waged wars also he married 40 women including 9 years old which her name was Aesha

[@PianoForte9096]

@don james While I am not of the Roman Catholic Church or the Eastern Orthodox Church, even these groups which use images in worship do not claim to worship these items. Instead, they claim these as vehicles of worship -- much like using the Bible during one's personal devotional time. The level of English in your second sentence makes your meaning unclear. The name "Jesus" is, in fact, the English version of the name. You are correct that this is not the original pronunciation; it comes from the Greek "Ἰησοῦς" (Iesous in the Latin alphabet), which would have been pronounced "Yeshua" in Hebrew. Messianic Jews still call Him this. The name "Jesus", then, is not fake, but a translation. Christianity never claimed that Jesus was a white European. The images that you see in churches were to make Him more relatable to the cultures the Church came in contact with. This is why the images vary vastly depending on your geographic region; the Slavs' image will be "white European", the Italians' image will be "olive Mediterranean", the Ethiopians' image will be "black African", and so on. However, this is of little significance, as again the image is only the vehicle by which all of these groups worship God. Jesus actually never asked for or demanded worship; yet He accepted it several times. (humblesmith.wordpress.com/2010/11/09/jesus-accepts-worship-therefore-he-is-god/) Jesus never suggested to worship wood, stones, or statues, either. I suggest that you read John (one of the four Gospels) to gain a fuller understanding of just how incredible the person of Jesus Christ (or, if you prefer, Ιησούς Χριστός) is. Under Him, we are all equal; we all choose whether or not to have a relationship with Him; there is no such thing as "praying in the wrong direction"; and all that is asked of us is a true faith which permeates every part of our lives, attuning ourselves to God's will. As TheEngineer1971 has stated, Jesus is the Living God.

[@stealyourfacekev]

don james I think you are talking about Catholics which pray to Mary and other idols. We as Christians believe in the one true god and we don’t pray to wooden idols. The historical facts all point to the death of Christ...

[@Realivangarcia]

don james hahahaha 😂, you’re insecure because you know Islam is false.... I’m a Christian and we don’t pray to the cross nor statues. Islamic origins has paganism written all over it, Allah is the moon God. If anyone is praying to Satan it’s you.

[@waheedlawal4731]

I don't want to believe my hear.But to thank God for the good work here by smith

[@kaka_kaka28]

Jay Smith is a liar . In the hands of a knowledgable Muslim he has been proven to be a liar and he is also an idiot . kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3ycm3-tbttnhNk

[@kaka_kaka28]

I have never seen a brainless idiot like him . God goes to the Toilet : Jay Smith kzbin.info/www/bejne/hZW3dnhnp9KhaNE

[@tsapp2831]

10:94

[@tsapp2831]

Watch Christian prince amazing

kaka kaka If you think Jesus was a joke then that would means islam was also synonyms to the answer. 2 X 5 : 10 😁

[@art4freak795]

Always thought the foundation story of Islam sounded sketchy

[@BEAMERBMWboy]

The only sketchy thing is the trinity and God dying.

[@BEAMERBMWboy]

@yohan John Surah 112. THE WHOLE SURAH IS TAWHID.

[@mamstray2624]

For common sense purpose, a man who asked you to do good and help the needy, to worship the one True God who created you, and to live in a righteous life cannot be defeated by a man who cannot even establish a strong point of argument. Listen to this lecture for the second time and pay attention to the dates and the points he is trying to validate. Jay cannot still reach at a strong conclusion. My best advice is to go read the Quran yourself and make your conclusions. Your nature will choose. It is your human right to investigate a message that claimed to be a calling from your own creator. No offense. Just satisfy your own curiosity. Truth will always triumph over lies..

[@user-kf9ij1vh4j]

How can god be subject to his own creation? If God created life and death how can he die? If he created human beings how can he be a human? If he created food and water, why would he need to eat and drink? If he created mercy and forgiveness, why would he need to sacrafice and torture himself to forgive? Lol is that even comprehensible? The greatest trick the devil ever played on mankind is to make them worship the creation over the creator and make them believe that they are forgiven for all their sins, you can go forth and sin knowing you are forgiven anyway.. lol? Who taught you to cross yourself as a form of prayer? It never existed during the time of Jesus, Jesus prostrated to God, why don't you? Jesus didn't consume the flesh of swine, why do you? Jesus didn't deal in usury, why do you? Jesus had a beard, where is yours? Jesus mother wore a headscarf, why doesn't yours? It seems to me that muslims respect and love jesus more than the Christians do.. they are the ones today who follow the teachings of Jesus. Can any Christian explain all these points without sounding like an absolute buffoon? All I get is, oh we are not perfect we are all sinners, so don't you think that the greatest trick satan ever played on you Christians is making you believe that your God, who was a human being lol, came out of a vagina and sat on a toilet died for your sins so you will go to heaven anyway,? How can you people be so deaf, dumb and blind?

[@HauntedXXXPancake]

What about the foundational story of the New Testament: The infallible God messed up his no. 1 creation and to fix it, he had himself brutally slaughtered in a hail-merry-Scheme so ridiculous, a Meth-head would be impressed by the lunacy.

[@vikramrazdan5680]

Can't believe that Muhammad's name is mentioned only 4 times in the Quran whereas Jesus Christ is mentioned 93 times! Does this mean that Hazrat Muhammad is a hoax or planted later on?

[@lionabbass]

25 times Jesus [AS] name was mentioned. where did you get your 93 times? you are so typical. and while every prophet [AS] was addressed directly as a 2nd person singular with yaa [oh], the 4 times the name of the Holy Prophet [SA] was mentioned, it is in 3rd person. all the other numerous times were 2nd person, but with title like muzammil, mudathir, rasul, nabiyy and where you read qul/say, those places, too. in short when you add all of these together, he was mentioned much more than anyone and the whole Quran was addressed to him [SA] and he was not a hoax or a later plant. i am sure you must have read Surah 111 before since your name is saying something of persian. the man addressed in the surah was his [SA] uncle abilahab and as you know he perished and his wife perished as indicated by strangling herself with the rope of her firewood gathering trade.

[@vikramrazdan5680]

@@lionabbass Thanks for the clarification. It is actually 25 and not 93. The total number of times Jesus (Isa) has been mentioned in the Quran is 108 (including 25 times by name) which is more than Muhammad (whether by name, 3rd person or any another way). It is still surprising that Jesus should be mentioned 25 times by name in the Quran, 6 times more than Muhammad! Why I said hoax was because if we replace the name 'Muhammad' with 'Hamzah' at only 4 places, then the prophet will become someone else.I am just thinking logically, I hope I am wrong.

[@lionabbass]

you are wrong more than wrong! count where the prophet is addressed by Say or say to them, etc, they will be at least in hundreds [The Arabic root ق و ل to mean say / statement / message comes 1722 times in the Qur’an. The exact word “Qul” is repeated in, according to this search, 270 verses. about 332 time the word Qul repeated in Quran. like these surahs: Surah An-Nas [114]. quran.com/113

[@vikramrazdan5680]

@@lionabbass I do understand what you are trying to say, but the answer is not convincing logically. Given that the historical dates in Islam and the location of Mecca before 741AD is dubious, it shows that your reasoning is based more on FAITH than on LOGIC.

[@LlyneM-rf3gd]

Throughout the quran, it says "obey allah and the messenger of allah", "obey allah and the apostle of allah" and "the prophet". Mentioning of who was considered "Mahammad" is all throughout it. Don't say muhammad was only mentioned 4 times. The quran is glorification of demented muhammad.

[@nacashok]

Thanks jay smith for uploading this extremely important work of scholarship

[@abdulazizyalahow3238]

nachiketh ashok Hahahaha

[@xxxmmm3812]

@Pieter Maas what is the english language

[@ahmedharris7148]

DigitalUniverse Well it's true that most of the speculative conclusions he draws come from some revisionist historians whose work has been critiqued (in some cases by themselves). The two particular theories that are regarded as closer to speculation perhaps even fantasy are the Mecca is Petra and Abdul Malik creating Islam arguments. He completely for instance disregards the material evidence that challenges his conclusions such as the tombstone of Abbasa bint Jurayj among other artifacts.

[@awakeaware8532]

Ahmed Harris ? kzbin.info/www/bejne/inraYoKGfZuErK8

[@sea-shell8198]

We all need to learn so much if we are to understand the horrific threat we now face.

[@hassenounis1832]

yes, but read from the source and judge yourself, better than believing everyone who want to fool people kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaOke5WHZ7yrhZY

[@LlyneM-rf3gd]

@@hassenounis1832 we know islam has incited the systematic genocides of hundreds of millions of people and enslavement and oppression of even more. That's all we really need to know.

[@solomons5669]

Fuck you

[@hurdygurdyguy1]

Hmmm, and what horrific threat is that?

[@peorakef]

@@hassenounis1832 i know so many muslims who read the quran and became ex-muslims lol

[@pfanderfilms]

Jay has now upgraded this talk with newer and better material, which is now on Pfanderfilm, and can be seen here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y3vYnJuwh7N1as0

[@napoleonlaguerre5734]

I always love jay not only his vase knowledge on Islam but because he is one of our brothers in God through Jesus Christ.

[@peorakef]

@@deepblue8736 nice argument. not

[@GETJUSTICE4U]

The five oldest (known) Qurans (one in the British museum) are all different. They all contain visible alterations. One has whole chapters missing which amounts to about 40% of a regular qurans. Abdul Malik compiled the first huge Islamic scriptures (much plagerised from the Tora, Bible and other popular religions of those times including paganism.

[@Kaergaard]

Its one of the strangest religion man has created..

[@jameswadejr.3836]

And the Bible is plagiarized from Egyptian texts that were stolen by the Greeks. So what should we do?

[@littletraveller5428]

James Wade convert to Judaism ✡️?

[@dhmidahm8231]

You are talking about THE WRITTEN QURAN 😂😂😂 Which is for beginners to memorize ..... it is called the (MUS HAF ) You either don’t know this ... or lying to your friends ... Once you understand this ....you have to move to ... the writing system .... because it kept changing... (where experienced attackers normally lurk ) An example : Turkish in 1920 moved from Arabic alphabet ..to Latin ..... but it is still TURKISH ... Why do you talk to each other like kids So your British copy is different .... right ? Pathetic Another thing .... don’t tell a Muslim some of the Quran missing .... it is ORAL in origin memorized through listening and repeating nonstop for 1400 yrs

[@mcw0261]

​@@dhmidahm8231 You obviously aren't considering the different recitations, nor the Uthamanic destructions, nor the hadiths. How do you know the Quran has always been memorized the same way if complete surahs from different recitation are completely different? First of all the only reason you know about memorization is because of the hadiths. If it was perfectly memorized, then why were there 20 recitations from 7 dialects? Why the Sana'a manuscripts differ completely, and the palimpsest below it differ completely, and the other manuscripts differ in meaning and recitation if it was perfectly memorized? Muslims just need to have faith, IMAN, and stop fighting God. Stop fighting the Bible and stop following anti-christ Imams and read the INJEEL and pray to God for the Holy Spirit because Jesus said so.

[@danielfiavey7735]

Where is the continuation of this lecture? I mean the part 2?

[@krisf6313]

Thank you for making this. I am learning a lot.

[@worldpeace8003]

A mercy to mankind ? According to our earliest detailed biographical source on Muhammad's life, Islam's prophet once ordered his followers to torture a man for money. Here's the passage: Kinana b. al-Rabi, who had the custody of the treasure of Banu al-Nadir, was brought to the apostle who asked him about it. He denied that he knew where it was. A Jew came to the apostle and said that he had seen Kinana going round a certain ruin every morning early. When the apostle said to Kinana, "Do you know that if we find you have it I shall kill you?" he said Yes. The apostle gave orders that the ruin was to be excavated and some of the treasure was found. When he asked him about the rest he refused to produce it, so the apostle gave orders to al-Zubayr b. al-Awwam, "Torture him until you extract what he has," so he kindled a fire with flint and steel on his chest until he was nearly dead. Then the apostle delivered him to Muhammad b. Maslama and he struck off his head, in revenge for his brother Mahmud. (Ibn Ishaq, Sirat Rasul Allah, p. 515) Following this brutal spectacle, Muhammad took Kinana's seventeen-year-old wife, Safiyya bint Huyayy, as his own bride (because nothing says lovin' like torturing and murdering a woman's husband for money).

[@gabrielmoses8505]

He took Kinana's wife her name is Safiya..

[@KS-vs4ke]

this story is NOT authentic, scholars and researchers have ages ago written about it.. so do your homework first before spreading hate and lies.

[@gabrielmoses8505]

@@KS-vs4ke Your prophet ( without prophecy) made war .. 27 x during his life..

[@KS-vs4ke]

@@gabrielmoses8505 Thx for your comment. 27 or 127 battles is irrelevant, because any leader or chief in command has an obligation to protect, defend his people and implement justice. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that (check any nation constitution), please don't let me get into US, christian or Atheists wars LOL. Everyone has the right to be critical and ask questions. But those who are very concerned about the Islam and the prophet (PBUH) should not just repeat Fox news BS but they have to do their own study. For example if someone is concerned and bothered by 27 battles and he thinks that's immoral and anytime he talks to a muslim he tells him that, thinking that he is going to offend him. Well actually he becomes very frustrated !! and I see many ppl here are very frustrated LOL My question to these people: what is the basis of your statement about any subject? have you done any real study or you just hear a clown like Jay Smith and you made your mind ... Please, you are intelligent enough to read history find out why these battles did happen, when who/how they have started, who was involved, how many were killed etc... get things in their perspective. A history of 20 years or more cannot be judged by 2 sentences. You don't have to agree with it but at least you know what is about, you know what historians from both camps have said... etc It's a mistake that we all make . we all try to apply our own predetermined definitions and own cultural and religious perspective on other foreign affair, matter, event, people etc... and the result is : we reject it, we deny it, we hate it etc because it doesn't fit in our understanding model.

[@gabrielmoses8505]

@@KS-vs4ke u know nothing about your book the same like all abdol. Check your Quran.. Surah ar rahman 26-27 Allah has face / Surah Al qalam 42 Allah has SHIN / Surah yasin 83 Allah has hand.. so explain to me..??

[@shaerfan320]

Jay smith killed the Islam,So RIP Islam and try not to resurrect yourself.

[@kaka_kaka28]

Hahahahaha . He is a big Farter. Jay Smith entangled in his own web of CONFUSION! God goes to toilet BUT He is too great! kzbin.info/www/bejne/hZW3dnhnp9KhaNE

[@kaka_kaka28]

@Seto Relentless Crusader Kaiba , I have never seen an idiot like like him who said " God goes to the Toilet " . Do you prescribe to the idea that God go to the Toilet ?.

[@kaka_kaka28]

@Seto Relentless Crusader Kaiba , Jay Smith loves to lie and in the hands of an expert Muslim debater , his lies get exposed . kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3ycm3-tbttnhNk

[@kaka_kaka28]

@Seto Relentless Crusader Kaiba , God can not do stupid things like you Christians think .

[@kaka_kaka28]

@Seto Relentless Crusader Kaiba , I do not need to prove Mohammed is a prophet to bigots .

[@mannyc19]

Extremely well researched,thanks Jay.

[@magaelectrician657]

Mind blown....thanks for the great info

[@childofgod4108]

GOD Bless you Mr Jay. I Thanks GOD we have people like you in this world.

[@JesuschristDisciplesLondon]

Hi ex Muslim too, welcome my channel many miracles Jesus Yashuwa is the only way. peace and lovekzbin.info/www/bejne/aKGWep9srM2gjpo

[@davidwilder7542]

Wonderful academic presentation. Thank you! Question: how much content was changed or redacted in the Apostels, Mark, Lucas, Matthew and Paul over the course of time into the present?

[@stevedoetsch]

Check out the finding of the dead-sea scrolls. It shows that the old testament books are the same now as when written, and the same can be said for the new testament.

[@bellycurious]

I believe quite a lot, but if you want know the truth try an independent historian, when I say independent I mean atheist or agnostic historian. People have a blind spot when their own religion is concerned.

[@Christian-cw9mp]

The bible can only be discerned/understood by the Holy Spirit revealing its meaning. This takes man out of the picture and opens communication and understanding directly between you and God, without man to pollute it. 1 Corinthians 2:14

[@Joel-wu3kk]

Excellent explanation sir thanks you to this message brother God bless you

[@hassenounis1832]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaOke5WHZ7yrhZY

[@albusai]

@@hassenounis1832 address what’s being said

[@khadijahngum315]

I start by asking the Almighty to forgive us all for believing in evil and not believing in the truth.. Only the Almighty can set us free from evil, anxiety, hate,envy,greed,and ignorance. I come from both sides of two religions Christianity and Islam. I personally love, adore and respect both. They all have stories and facts of what is wrong and what should be good and accepted by the Almighty to get us closer to him and a way to enter heaven. Historians can be selective and bias depending on the information they pass on to make a name,but the Almighty is ONE and ONE for all mankind. Anyone who submits to the Almighty is a Muslim,that does not mean you believe or follow the teachings of Islam. It means you believe in the Almighty and his true Prophets and followers and all that he has created for us to share and enjoy in peace and harmony. I read both the Bible and Quran, I have seen similarities and differences. I have experienced through reading both books the effect and changes it had made in me. The most important thing I treasure in these books is how it can make you more of a human and closer to the Almighty 🙏.More to be your neighbors friend and protector, more to respect and appreciate both religions, more to live and let live. I personally went to Saudi Arabia and most of the historic sites are being brought down not to hide evidence as Mr Smith mentioned but to stop the action of idol worshipping. I have seen how people crowd in numbers to pray and ask forgiveness at these sites which are just historic for human knowledge only, but people tend to make a place of worship. That's the reason for all the demolishing. I have visited the place where our Dear and Holy Mother of Jesus ran to after giving birth in fear of the evil people,it's been made seamless to avoid the crowd to gather and make it a shrine. These are all to avoid unnecessary worshipping and insignificant rituals. Mohamed, SAW. was mentioned only few times in the Quran,because as the narrator and messenger he cannot be talking about himself,he was sent to give the message to the people about the earlier Prophets before him and their messages. All he did was revive the authentic messages of the earlier Prophets from the Almighty to the people. To do that he had to quote his past brothers and sisters in Prophethood. The times he would have his name mentioned would be through his divine experiences. Using sites and maps, valleys and mountains to prove that Mohamed and Islam is real is really a man made joke. Let's all appreciate and respect the authentic messages in Judaism, Christianity and Islam. We all came to this world and will return the same way but for our beloved and special Prophet and messenger Jesus. They all came to preach peace,fear of the Almighty, love thy neighbor,Respect your Parents,help the needy,support the Orphan,avoid sinful acts and above all do not take anyone's life,instead try and save lives. With all this on our plate,why don't we all start a new page and clean our hearts of anger, evil and greed and turn to each other and ask forgiveness and make this world not just a better place but the best place to live in until we see Heaven. Let's not speculate, let's experience the goodness and holiness. Let's fight the evil inside of us, let's fill our hearts and souls with peace and love for each other. We have father's day, mother's day, weekdays, etc. Let's have a day called Creation day, a day where we all embrace each other in love, gifts, forgiveness,peace,and harmony not matter what religion,race, culture,or background. Let this day be a day for all.mankind to remember the one and only Almighty God/ Allah.(I use the two names as I understand it in the two books I read,but other names of the same meaning in different languages is also appreciated ).He created us to be one. On a final note, let's all remember that we are closer to the end times and as it is said in the Bible and mentioned in Islam, Jesus will be back. I am a true practising Muslim and respect all authentic religions and books. I appreciate and believe in Islam as the final religion because no other religion can be created after Islam, because Islam has put together all the religions before it into one authentic book for all to embrace. The Quran. Nothing is fake in the Quran,because it's the book if all books, saying it's fake contradicts the authenticity of the books before it. Only the truth from the books before is noted in one book. May the Almighty give us peace and cleanse our hearts and revive our souls to love and live in harmony from today and forever till we all meet in Heaven. Ameen.

[@MM-qh9yh]

So summing up your long essay I can say that Islam is my dick

[@ahmedharris7148]

Well put

[@tropicalstrings]

how can some royals claim to be descendents from Muhammed if he had no sons.

[@michaelhunziker7287]

Because they lie.

[@ahmedelkhwaga2751]

he had 4 girls

[@GardeniaInc]

@Commendatore when you got children i hope people will ask the same question to you😁

[@v.r.2834]

ahmed El Khwaga those were daughters of Khadijah. Muhammad was infertile

[@jeremiahpillay6219]

@@v.r.2834 Also Aisha was betrothed to Muhammad at 6 and he consummated the marriage according to authentic Islamic sources and so, lived with him for 9 years until his passing in 632AD. My question is, why was Aisha barren? For nine years she was with Muhammad, why couldn't she bear him a single child? The answer to this was because she was a child herself. After being sexually molested at such a young age, she was internally damaged and left barren for the rest of her life.

[@jesusismylordandsaviour5663]

Thats right.. Amen..

[@flnteenof3793]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gaPboqefncdsidU

[@FDubry]

There is a gap @52:50 in the conference what are we missing?

[@sentinal2343]

tea break duh!

[@neutronshiva2498]

@@sentinal2343 tea break or pee break :D

[@mohamedrifai8877]

Jay ur voice is very bold and nice to hear.

[@zixianjia376]

Great work. Thanks, Dr. Jay Smith.

[@muneebkhan7465]

Correct your facts...Ali was not his adopted son.Ali was his cousin n son in law

[@braddahbu1066]

muneeb khan .... that’s the only thing jay has wrong in this video? Islam is in trouble! MOHAMUD is a fairytale🧞‍♂️with no historical evidence!

[@muneebkhan7465]

@@braddahbu1066 Honestly speaking,i don't know much about other facts,as i am not a Scholar.But yes...Jay Smith should make a live debate with Islamic scholars so that the audience gets the clear picture...One sided picture( whether from Islamic Quarters OR Christian scholars OR any other Tradition) can't do any good to Humanity

[@sheenashameer5133]

your source for this fable also come from the 8th century bio of Mohamad.

[@muneebkhan7465]

@@sheenashameer5133 ...Well ...if it's so...it should not have been stated by Jay Smith with certainty... Your reply should at Jay Smith... So tell him to mention it in this video Thank you

[@ahmedharris7148]

He has to correct more than facts. He uses outdated arguments from revisionist historians that have been critiqued for their speculative nature and methodological weaknesses. At first exposure, it can sound shocking and ground breaking to non experts, but all of the arguments he uses are not in any way considered objective or without issue.

[@khen9478]

wow! thanks sir for this wonderful work. i will share this video to many people as i can.

[@jamalkhan3708]

Great teaching, love watching your videos, I have learned so much from you, God bless✊✝️❤️

[@kevinmathew4884]

God doesn't exist.

[@orenjuice100]

Mind blowing

[@frnkguard1]

Never mind the book and the man What about the book and the people that is who wrote it For whatever gain

[@flnteenof3793]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gaPboqefncdsidU

[@dadaolujare6940]

and if the websites are not reliable, which sources can I turn to, to get reliable sources, please?

[@carstenhansen5757]

This would be so much more relevant, if he wasn't a religious man. Saying "I don't believe in your god stories, but MY god stories are true, no matter what you say" is not exactly a truth witness.

[@KC_Streams]

The fact that you take a man giving a coherent explanation for why we have good reasons to doubt the historical account presented on Islam, and then contrasting that with the historical reliability of the Judeo-Christian account, only to boil it down to "I don't believe in your god stories, but MY god stories are true, no matter what you say" reflects very poorly on you. It makes you appear like you don't have a brain capable of comprehending arguments.

[@KC_Streams]

@Pichkalu Pappita Fine. Make those arguments. Then I'll care what you say.

[@MoneerCherie]

*impressive information*

[@salvagemagician1644]

72 is a multiple of 7 ?? Only if you involve decimal points in which case you could argue any number is multiple of seven 🤔🤷‍♂️ probably misspoke but still bugged me

[@pfanderfilms]

You are correct. He should have said 77, not 72, which he normally says in other lectures.

[@yashsandhu8366]

" why " is not something that is allowed in Islam ! So never mind ! :p

[@MichElle-sd6gj]

and mohammadan women silenced and hiding under the 🧕too.

[@ahmedharris7148]

The history of Islamic thought says otherwise. It would be similar to saying that it's not allowed in Christianity which is just as absurd and silly.

[@turquoisity6555]

@@ahmedharris7148 ? Catholicism was a fundamentalistic totalitarian regime opposed to every critique. Inquisition meant wiping out heresies. Sunnicism is the same. And this holds true today more than ever! Change will only come from within, and you lacking 600 years will make the reformation come very soon. It will not be pleasant but neccessary.

[@jenspedersen9138]

Why is it not allowed? 🙄

[@OmegaFighter1]

@@ahmedharris7148 try presenting this lecture in any Islamic country and see what happens.

[@commonsenselogic]

So if someone tells you something while you're naked, it must be true. But no wonder they have to attack those who insults Allah.

[@amelialin8877]

Thank you for unvailing this historical facts. "To live is Christ & to die is gain." (Philippians 1:21) I have decided to 💖follow Jesus Christ.👍 No turning back👊

[@moryankek2433]

Check the bible it's not the real one u have

[@AggressiveHiDef]

@Khalid Ibn Alwaleed Nobody on earth is perfect, never was perfect, not yesterday, not today and not int he future, nor the past except for Jesus Christ, He was Perfect & Sinless. Get that through your thick scull and stop embarrassing yourself by defending a false prophet that was historically proven to be a Pedophile.

[@lauragafer9535]

What an amazing presentation!!!!

[@TerryLangTechnicalConsulting]

Abandon Islam. There is no future moderate.

[@greenheartt4150]

wrong!

[@TerryLangTechnicalConsulting]

@@greenheartt4150 A poor rebuttal because all proof points to the doctrine itself containing the poison that will cause eternal violence. It is a vigilante "religion" whereas the individual can take the law into his own hands. The moderate might be "there" for a certain period but the evil words are always there to be acted upon by the orthodox, the jihadist. If you care to discuss this, I am certainly prepared to do so. For now, have a peaceful day and may GOD be with you. #AbandonIslam

[@un7490]

There evil bastards

[@mamstray2624]

For common sense purpose, a man who asked you to do good and help the needy, to worship the one True God who created you, and to live in a righteous life cannot be defeated by a man who cannot even establish a strong point of argument. Listen to this lecture for the second time and pay attention to the dates and the points he is trying to validate. Jay cannot still reach at a strong conclusion. My best advice is to go read the Quran yourself and make your conclusions. Your nature will choose. It is your human right to investigate a message that claimed to be a calling from your own creator. No offense. Just satisfy your own curiosity. Truth will always triumph over lies..

[@TerryLangTechnicalConsulting]

@@mamstray2624 A violent supremacist theocracy will never deal out its perverse justice in these United States. I've read enough and sourced enough to know Mohammed was a sick man, a narcissist warrior... that's all. You are guilty of pedophilia, rape and murder by acceptance of this work of Satan. I've personal experience with families and the sickness that dwells in those households is the work of demons. If you are so certain your intellect has achieved the correct conclusion, may I say you beg for a wicked Earth for all of mankind. May Allah, who dwells in hell, ass fuck you.

[@stephenskung6753]

God bless you Jay Smith. Love your channel.

[@rudramahadev22]

superbly nailed....hoax will go up in thin air eventually no matter what the faith says

[@usmanarif24]

Jay Smith's work and research is commendable. Being a muslim it pushes me to read more, learn more, know more and keep thinking looking for truth. Looking for light. I do have my set of disagreements with Jay Smith's work but i should respect the way he has pitched the whole case. He has opened doors for so many areas of discussion....That's how a knowledgeable discussion should be.

[@albusai]

Cave of treasures, infancy gospel of Thomas, targum Sheba, apocalypse of Abraham and more are the fake sources Quran is made of

[@Arsalan5431]

Finally ...happy for you buddy

[@temporaryaccount5307]

As a Christian, i appreciate ur comment. Out of curiosity, I’m wondering what you’ve since learned about the compilation of ur Qs as it’s now been 2 yrs since u did comment.

[@MichElle-sd6gj]

Must watch Christian Prince (CP) videos too who exposes mohammadans and live talks with them.

[@pyansufyan5987]

Mich Elle hahahahaaha you trust busted black cp lol

[@mureh7047]

Mich Elle Right! Christian Prince ( CP ) is ArabianProphet and translating missing Arabia language in Quran... The Bible are beginning with Christ and end with Christ the Lord God!

[@Jam-dr3wt]

He is nothing but liar and deceiver he introduces u as scholar when ur not as soon as he can’t answer eg hundreds of mistakes in bible he blocks u

[@awakeaware8532]

Jam 187 One brilliant man is CP, Muslims are leaving Islam ALL the time because of him. No one can refute what he says, because he uses your own Quran and Hadiths to prove ALL he claims !!👏🏻👏🏻😂😂✝️

[@suryamanalu1755]

Pyan Sufyan have u see Mohammed face? But 1.5 billion followers. Basically following the blind false prophet.

[@akmaluddinsaid4104]

Excellent presentation and open my mind regarding archaeology and Islam, especially Dan Gibson research.

[@rajiveharvani5502]

Have you seen "islam the untold story" it is a nice documentary

[@ckzckw]

Mecca was founded as a slave port, that's why they took it. it was unknown as a significant location so they could carry on their slave trade and search parties couldn't find their people because it's off the plato, i.e. off any route and in the middle of barren desert. It's basically a secret site that they used to do plotting and likely a secret meeting point for scouts for the raids.

[@gilbertlam9398]

@Jesus is not The son of GOD, that the best you can muster/ offer to refute a simple hypothesis?

[@Basaljet]

@Jesus is not The son of GOD Well that was an intellectual reply!

[@Basaljet]

@Jesus is not The son of GOD All you need to do is make a reasoned defence of the points at issue. Our texts say "You must honour the Lord thy God, with all thy heart, with all thy strength and with all thy MIND". You should make a start on the third element.

[@Basaljet]

G Kelly hello think I have lost the thread of this or the original comment “who’s we” I am just asking our Muslim friend to make a reasoned response to the contents of the video instead of emotive abuse

[@Basaljet]

G Kelly it is the direction in which the building is constructed for accommodating the congregation while at prayer. Mosques or other adapted buildings have recess where the imam sits and towards which the congregation faces

[@ScottJB]

Fascinating and thorough examination of Islam. If only he applied the same rigor to his own faith. Dr. Bart Ehrman does a great job of exploring Christianity's origins--which has nowhere near as many holes as Islam, but still has some major issues. That said, learned a lot from this. Very interesting.

[@connynordstrom6096]

my thoughts exactly

[@albusai]

Barth is not very bright he uses very bad analogy

[@albusai]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nWPRlmakmdOJh80

[@ScottJB]

@@albusai Non-rational apologetics, only designed to work backwards from a conclusion

[@jamesking8241]

Bart Erhman's conclusions have been answered many times over. Erhman isn't that brilliant either.

[@YTpreet]

Thank God , that he pronounced 'himalayas' RIGHT and perfect!!

[@AM-ch3tq]

He was born in Inda. His family has been missionaries in India for than 100 years or more

[@BloodgodArmor8]

"Islam: The untold story" is gone from youtube. I can't find it. Anyone else knows where it is?

[@livingwaters.4U]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aqSbapugoMusoqM

[@bellycurious]

I watched it a few days ago with French subtitles.

[@myfilmku]

Many Muslims memorize the Qur'an without writing on paper. That's the difference with the gospel

[@jamesking8241]

The gosepls were held in oral tradition also before they were written down to past to succeeding generations...your comment means nothing.

[@dennislockhart8627]

GODBLESS THIS MAN ☝️✝️❤️🔥 The Truth Shall Set Us Free

[@mamamarianovits9029]

Dennis Lockhart Good day to you Sir, I come from a Lockhart clan myself. It is not a very common last name in my part of the world, immediately catching my attention upon seeing it.😊

[@behzadmaheri7424]

Because he speak liar

[@mamamarianovits9029]

Behzad Maher I Say what now.?

[@Lisa-oq1bi]

Fancy if they made a movie about the life of Muhammad. It would be a comedy, and the ultimate horror movie all rolled into one.

[@hassenounis1832]

Well, 1/6 of the world believe in muhammed and his teaching, i don't think you are able to understand, only if you read his life, but i don't think you dare to read it

[@ahmedharris7148]

How so? He was an orphan who advocated for a more fair society over the materialistic narcissistic one he grew up in at the threat of his life at times. His skills were recognized and he was chosen as a peace arbiter and leadership was thrust on him. As a statesman, he was shrewd while being humane. The state he created went on to challenge the two superpowers of his day. Unlike Jesus, he combined spiritual power with temporal power. You can disagree with his message but there's no denying he's one of history's greatest men. To this day, billions chant "peace be upon him" to his name and billions more will continue to do so.

[@SM-ly5tf]

it exists, movie is called the message

[@miltonbradley4249]

You got that 100 percent RIGHT

[@DrMarceloSantos]

What a fantastic lecture congratulations

[@martinsilenus4647]

Many of the points mentioned are either interpreted differently by historians, discounted or modified.

[@martinsilenus4647]

48:00 shows his bias stemming from the "Mecca in Petra" argument

[@JH-hx2cl]

@@martinsilenus4647 really? you can just go to those sites on Google Maps and draw a line to Petra and another line to Mecca yourself. Hows math and geography biased?

[@osamazaki5538]

@KT Online Learning ..... 7 And when he opened the fourth seal, I heard the voice of the fourth beast: Come and see 8 And I saw you as a green horse, and sat there by his name Death, and the abyss followed him, and gave authority over a quarter of the earth to be slain by the sword, and famine,

[@grasonicus]

Very good and well presented.

[@akshaypatil4152]

U r wrong about criticism started from Bible... What is the meaning of charvaka-?

[@athallahfathur]

as a muslim i feel Jay smith looks friendly than david woods and the gang

[@JesuschristDisciplesLondon]

Hi i am arab ex Muslimo, welcome my channel many miracles Jesus Yashuwa is the only way. peace and lovekzbin.info/www/bejne/aKGWep9srM2gjpo

[@rodneygardner7421]

Is there a book you can buy with this information in it??

[@akiiki310]

Get Dan Gibson's book:-Islamic Geography

[@jenniebugs1]

rodney gardner Get “In the Shadow of the Sword” by Tom Holland. Tom is a great historian, unbiased but factual. This is one of the books that Jay recommends.

[@Ka112eb]

if you support him on patreon you can get his ebooks depending on your support level

[@Ka112eb]

www.patreon.com/dangibson/posts

[@indialover83]

Books of Patricia Crone are available on the net as e-books

[@dadaolujare6940]

I have a question. I googled the compilation of the Quran, and I found that it was compiled really close to the period after the Prophet's death. the 7th century. So is the speaker saying that the information on wikipedia and other websites are wrong?

[@dadaolujare6940]

@Skeletor # thank you very much for the reply, I appreciate it. But which material do you recommend I reference for this piece of history though? That would be really helpful. Thank you!

[@didasinan9669]

However i rathet worship creator then his créations!! What about Abraham, isac , Noah, Moses who was their God???

[@canecorsomolosser3294]

Interesting theory Petra and Mecca. Nice presentation 😊

[@hassenounis1832]

@Gnostic-Esoteric where's the fact? do you know what's qibla in islam ? you are talking about non muslim fact about islam , sure he would lie, the proof, he never gave his reference, it's easy to believe him because that's what you want to believe, but science speaking: you need proof by references

[@patois]

Whatever, just dont marry your first cousin. It's scientifically proven to be unhealthy, very unhealthy.

[@ahmedharris7148]

Rangefinder Spoken from experience? Good to know.

[@ahmedharris7148]

It's a theory that comes from the revisionist school and from an academic point of view is not the strongest due to its speculative nature. Many scholars discredit it out of hand entirely due to some faulty assumptions.

[@patois]

@@ahmedharris7148 guess you didnt know that ... sad.

[@keithnisbet]

Incredible historical and archaeological fact. Not easily disputed. Much for Muslims to reflect on. Great scholarly work, thanks.

[@TheGreatTimSheridan]

the gosple of thomas was the notes he took during christ's ministry, those formed the nucleus to recall the 4 versions of the ministry.

[@commonman9782]

The gospel of Thomas is an apocrypha

[@sarahqamar6377]

Revisiting is needed.

[@kafirlindaclark6148]

WELL DONE "Online Learning"!!!!!! Well done! Getting this back is a WIN!

[@kafirlindaclark6148]

John Morrison Naw, terse is just fine John. I'd be a bit short if "political correctness" removed my video too. Jesus bless you! :D

[@villaboyjay9869]

“translation from verse of Al quran in authentic since was revealed... “Allah, there is no god but He, the Living, the Eternal. He sent down to you the Book with the Truth, confirming what came before it; and He sent down the Torah and the Gospel.” Verses 3:2-3 “When you read the Quran, seek refuge with Allah from Satan the outcast. He has no authority over those who believe and trust in their Lord. His authority is only over those who follow him, and those who associate others with Him.” Verses 16:98-100 75. RESURRECTION [English translation ] (al-Qiyamah) In the name of Allah,[Allah The almighty creator] the Gracious, the Merciful 1. I [ALLAH] swear by the Day of Resurrection. 2. And I swear by the blaming soul. 3. Does man think that We will not reassemble his bones? 4. Yes indeed; We are Able to reconstruct his fingertips. 5. But man wants to deny what is ahead of him. 6. He asks, “When is the Day of Resurrection?” 7. When vision is dazzled. 8. And the moon is eclipsed. 9. And the sun and the moon are joined together. 10. On that Day, man will say, “Where is the escape?” 11. No indeed! There is no refuge. 12. To your Lord on that Day is the settlement. 13. On that Day man will be informed of everything he put forward, and everything he left behind. 14. And man will be evidence against himself. This verse is revealed by Allah when the Messenger of Allah was approached by the infidels who questioned unlikely that God could revive the dead because of their destroyed bodies. For them, it is impossible for God to recognize and re-assemble the dead members according to their respective proprietors. Then God replied that God was able to bring them all alive and able to rearrange their fingers perfectly (ie able to reconstitute human limbs according to their respective masters) The term to emphasize is their fingers. The question is why does God take a small human being finger? Why does not God use other members such as face, head, legs and others? What is the specialty of a finger so that God takes it as a comparison? All this is related to the identification or identification of the human being since the prophet Adam Alaihissalam until the end of the age. The identity of billions of human beings can be distinguished only through the small tip of the thumb!!

[@kafirlindaclark6148]

@@villaboyjay9869 Hahahaha! How about DNA? How come Allah didn't reveal DNA? And it takes MORE than just the tip of the thumb goof ball to identify a single person. Even Law Enforcement knows this. Where have YOU been? And if Qur'an is Eternal and Uncreated, why didn't Allah send it down to MOSES in the first place? It took him more than 4000 years to FINALLY send down what was with him in Paradise from BEFORE creation? You're a special kind of gullible aren't you!?!? Hahahaha!

[@villaboyjay9869]

warrior at least you know are message the power of our creator...either you believe or not ,,,it always on your mind, did you not think ,the al quran only a book normal size message from our creator but he creation no have time to read,,but if the book so detail like talking dna test on n on,i think many human will asking on n on for example why quran not talking how to make chess cake....so finger print is about identity for everybody that enough be sight of our creator to challenge our intelligent ....1400 years ago ,the modern civilization use the method for identified criminal identity...tq

[@kafirlindaclark6148]

@@villaboyjay9869 Cheese cake only identifies cheese cake, and is irrelevant to your point because cheese cake didn't exist in Muhammads time. You're talking about rhe God of the Universe who CREATED our DNA. If he is all knowing, certainly he knows about DNA!! Yes I believe in the Creator of the Universe. And that God took on flesh and walked among humanity. The word "Allah" does not appear in the Bible. Why doesn't your god know his own name!? The God of Moses told Moses his name and God said this would be his name for ETERNITY: THAT NAME IS YHWH. Not Allah. You have the wrong God my friend.

[@seanmarkhayes8223]

God Bless You ur work is good and I love how you explain

[@edbtzkhud]

Seanmark hayes simplicity is for retards. This guy is an idiot and a liar therefore dumb fucks like you can easily comprehend his bullshit

[@seanmarkhayes8223]

@@edbtzkhud No brother read the Quran properly You will know there is no meaning Jesus loves you

[@edbtzkhud]

Seanmark hayes hey moron why don’t you get your head out of your ass and start worshipping the creator and not the creation.

[@sirplatov8462]

Hi I just saw Dr. Jay Smith`s KZbin video “Muhammad A Historical Critique” in it he says that Ali was the adopted son of Mohammed, but Dr. Patricia Crone calls him his cousin in the book “God's government, Islamic political thinking in the middle-aged” (title translated from Danish) I don’t think it makes a lot of difference in context, but since I have a passion for history, I would like to know, which is it, or is it both?

[@pfanderfilms]

Sir Platov, Ali was the cousin of Muhammad, and after marriage to Fatimah he also became Muhammad's son-in-law, which is more correct than saying he was Muhammad's 'adopted son', though many believe the two are equivalent.

[@jesuslovesu333]

Ali may be loosely considered 'adopted' as he lived with Muhammad from age 5+ (wiki en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ali)

[@blackthunder0074u]

Upanishads, bhagavathgeetha and vedas are not religious books. Let's get over it.

[@silverstonenaomiadelg4954]

Muslims are going through 5 stages of grief.1 shock and denal 2.Anger and shame 3.Depression and detachment 4. Dialogue 5. Acceptance. Love them and they are welcomed to the Christian family

[@minieneighbour7080]

Dr Jay Smith is a fearless warrior against the lies of Islam. May God protect him and his family to continue destroying the Islamic lies that has deceived and continue to deceive multitudes of people globally, including my family. 🙏🙏🙏

[@clintsequipment]

I wish I could have heard this before visiting Petra. How interesting 🤔

[@deafcharismatic]

should write a book. Great informative!!!

[@kayzee2675]

Well organized and fascinating lecture.

[@williamswee]

Keep telling the research done. The people need to know

[@azeefaziz1395]

So miracle. Every muslim can recite surah al-fatihah and some other surah since 4-5 years old. Even before they learn to read. It is called 'verbal revelation'. Different cultures different races. Different places, different ways. Learn, do not hesitate. Peace

[@George-iv1hi]

But you are dumb anyway even in your 60-ties.

[@wishyouthebest9222]

Greetings and blessings to all, Can a muslim explain me what the meaning of life/creation in islam is? Thanks

[@a.m.7895]

Jesus was in the old testament. In exodus. Jesus was prophecied to come by Isaiah.

[@melindalemmon2149]

Amd Moses

[@watchgoose]

The entire OT shows that the Messiah will come, and give Himself for us.

[@toni4729]

And was he named? NO! Now, When you grow up and find that religion is just a means of making money from the ignorant you might decide to get out and see it for what it is. All religions are the same. That's why they all have so much and the poor have nothing, The churches all say they give to the poor but they never get it, they stay just as poor and just as sick while the churches are built bigger and higher and the robes are shinier and more lustrous. Worth a fortune. They don't even pay tax anywhere in the world, so the governemts don't get to give to the poor either.

[@pinakinzaveri4563]

I am hindu from India. We believe in "vasudhey kutumbakam" means the whole world is my family. But during Gova inquisition, Saint Xavier, pop and others missionaries burned 16,500 Hindus. Who did not converted to Christianity. Off course, we do not hate now to anyone for this inhumane act. But intellectual like you, do you still support it? On the name of Christian religion.

[@ahmedharris7148]

Barron Von Monster Truck III You're uninformed if you believe that Islam has no mechanism or doctrine of Just War Theory. As for the historical record, it's clear that Christians have killed far more people than any other religion; the systematic removal of the Native Americans, the Conquistadors, European wars of religion, expansions into Asia, etc. This is not to say that Islam too did not have a bloody history; Transoxiana, raids into India, Ottoman-European wars, etc. In history, no ones hands are clean, at least no one that at one point was in power. But doctrines of just war theory are found in both religions as well.

[@ahmedharris7148]

dom com. "Muslims killed 80 million Hindus". It's interesting that you focus on their religious identity rather than others. Babur, Ghazni, Ghori, and others were all primarily Turks. Even the Rajputs are descended from the Sacae who themselves were a nomadic Turkish group. Why not say that "nomads killed 80 million", or "Turks killed 80 million". Also, that number is not in any historically confirmed and is a subject of debate. But you're right. Many Hindus were killed. The reason has to do with the forces of history such as the assault on civilizations by nomadic groups (such as the Huns, the Xiongnu, the Khazars, Hepthalites, Mongols, Mughals)., and the Turkification of many areas Them being "Muslims" was incidental. This does bot mean religion was not a factor. Only that it was not the main factor and not the only factor.

[@ahmedharris7148]

dom com. Your views are idealistic and naive. I cannot really continue this discussion much longer.

[@atheistsinceborn4903]

Whole world chutiye

[@atheistsinceborn4903]

@@ahmedharris7148 for a matter of fact muslims killed hindus for religious reasons too. Many mughal rulers like babur and aurangzeb had the agenda of spreading islam through violence.

[@DEEJAI0102]

Who was the second lady after Eve that came into existence??what was her name ??

[@toni4729]

Bloody good question.

[@ferrysuawah9279]

Good explanation, JBU