3. Jay Smith: Muhammad - A Historical Critique

This video was re-uploaded here: • 4. Jay Smith: Muhammad...
To learn more about how to love and reach out to muslims for Christ, check out the complete series on onlinelearning.ibiol.org
You can also sign up for our full-time programmes for 6 months, 1 year or 2 years at the International Bible Institute of London. More info on www.ibiol.org

[@jamalkhan3708]

I’m Ex Muslim from Pakistan and I have accepted Jesus Christ my lord and savior. Thank you Dr Jay Smith to show me the light. Only one true God and his name is Jesus ✝️

[@rashidkhalid2010]

Lol...Asmaan se gira...khajhoor mein atka...kuch nahi parra mazhab ke chakaro mein...live free! :-)

[@naseeruddinsk346]

According to bible. Jesus is not only true god. JOHN 17:3 Father(allohim /allah) is THE ONLY TRUE GOD. he send jesus. So allah is the only true god. Jesus is his messanger/prophet.. Go read john 17:3. Acts 3:13 Acts 2:22 Hibrews 5:7. See with your eyes. My allah give you hidayath.

[@arindamdas5421]

God bless you

[@logicalreasoning1088]

Jamal K kzbin.info/www/bejne/haOwaoWKbdNoqrc

[@rbspider]

Well you are one god closer to the truth.

[@walkingtall6004]

Jay is brilliant! I'm so awe struck by his wisdom and knowledge. Thank you Jay for your time and hard work.

[@violinbuff3782]

He is a highly knowledgable scholar. I don't believe at all in religion however the absolute clarity with which he speaks is devastating🎉

[@Stupidityindex]

Yeah, except Jesus Never Existed. see kenneth humphreys

[@NihouNi]

I am grateful and in awe of the courage it has taken to bring out this information and I pray for the protection of Jay and all involved here. The world needs you. Thankyou for increasing my knowledge and strengthening my faith.

[@akmalkhan5251]

Muslim always try to stop the truth. But Christianity is the only truth and no one can stop. Love brother jay smith. And God bless jay smith

[@theguyver4934]

Are you an ex muslim if so then can you please tell me your testimony

[@scania1982]

Could it be that all religions are man made?

[@imexbd]

@@theguyver4934 in you tube you, will find million of Ex muslim and all their father name is Gamil id and facebook id.(changing Name just) you also can be Ex muslim.just make a id with muslim name and say I am ex Muslim.Thanks sir.

[@yakovmatityahu]

Amen...

[@truebeliever3268]

No Christian can answer this question "Show me one verse where jesus said Iam God worship me?" Christian Pastor Stanley Sjoberg Can not answer Ahmed Deedat Queston "Show me one verse where jesus said Iam God worship me?" Whatch below link Let God show you straight path kzbin.info/www/bejne/imHap6h8pZiAY9E

[@sgt.grinch3299]

I’m so glad I found these videos. Makes me realize how awesome Jesus Christ is for mankind.

[@olgamartin4016]

Me also

[@Nexus-jg7ev]

This video actually made me wonder that if Islam was created for social cohesion and identity building over a long period of time, creating narratives of a prophet and divine revelation... The ancient Canaanites may well have done the same to build their own identity in the midst of other people in Canaan. They were tribesmen who transitioned to monarchy and could then create Judaism for social cohesion, replacing polytheism with henotheism and eventually monotheism. Abraham and Moses might have been mythical or at least legendary figures and the Torah could not have been written by a single person. There are many doublets and even contradictions in it. And the Exodus was probably written much later as a unifying story when Egypt was a political enemy of Israel. If we subject the Old Testament to historical criticism, we can see that the Prophets did not make future predictions but recounted events that had passed already. I doubt that any so-called sacred text across human civilizations is really divinely inspired, let alone directly authored by a deity.

[@paulwilliams5855]

God bless your Mr Jay Smith, the Team and the members of this great team.

[@rahasiakusaja]

Thank You so much Mr. Jay, GOD Bless you

[@IvanIvanov-vy7pt]

Yes Sir... THAT'S why I love my Jesus!!! He has NOTHING to hide, He reveals the TRUTH to ALL simply and equally with NO controversy! "Come to me and I will give you rest!"

[@tetteviben]

Jesus never lived..the character was invented by the Greeks and Romans by coping ancient Egyptian mythology and religion. Wake up!!

[@IvanIvanov-vy7pt]

@@tetteviben HaHaHA... Typical atheist answer!!!

[@IvanIvanov-vy7pt]

@Halim Yacob Just keep honestly reading/studying the Bible!!! Hopefully you will understand it sooner or later.

[@kabaarantau8309]

Who is god? .... Jesus Is Jesus the son of Mary? .....Yes Who Created Mary?....... God Who is God?......Jesus Is Jesus the begotten son? .......Yes Who is his father? ......God Who is God ?......Jesus Is Jesus a Servant of God? .....Yes Who is God? ......Jesus Did Jesus died on the cross? .......Yes Who ressurected him? ...God Who is God ? .......Jesus Is Jesus a messenger? ......yes Who sent him? ....God

[@IvanIvanov-vy7pt]

@@kabaarantau8309 Friend, just think about this: IF your god(allah) can NOT do something, such as become flesh, he is NOT God. My God, who created ALL the universe and ALL within it, CAN do ANYTHING He wants, including becoming flesh!!!

[@clarencethom8481]

Islam and Muslims come home 2 Jesus Christ he loves u and waiting 2bring u 2the kingdom of heaven with ever lasting life 4u....

[@r.m.k.1974]

Even if Trinitarianism was true you would still be a muslim since muslim means the one who submits to God. Even if it is gods, or goddesed or gods and goddeses or trinity or monotheism. You would always be muslim whatever you find as true.

[@salehfarman3879]

jc you that guy created by 4 men under the instruction of A PAGAN ROMAN EMPORER???

[@jamesking8241]

1. Do not confuse Trinitarianism with Tritheism.. those are 2 very different concepts 2. Allah was a pagan moon god of the Nebateanians in pre-islamic times. He was one of the supreme gods in a plethora of other deities(gods) he had a wife named Al-lat & 3 daughters named Al-Lat,Al-uzza & Manat. So even Allah of the quran wasn't even " one" & shared his godhead with other pagan gods.

[@jamesking8241]

@@salehfarman3879 christianity has nothing to do with Rome. It was birth from Judaism is actually considered a sect of Judaism. Messianic

[@salehfarman3879]

@@jamesking8241 You are the confuse one that you have disgraced yourself by saying what you have said! Your stupidity is laughable. Your JC, said when he was in the cross, he cried out loud - Eloi Eloi LAMA SABACHTHANI - which means My God My God, why have you forsaken me? - the above is a translation from the so called Greek manuscript "ACCORDING TO MARK" Obviously his Hebrew has a "Greek" accent because his so called original were written in "Greek". But listen to Matthew who is supposed to have written his Gospel originally in the so called Hebrew, which was aimed at the Israelites! St Jerome an early Christian father of the 4th/5th centuries after JC, testifies as follows "MATHEW, WHO IS ALSO A LEVI AND WHO FROM A PUBLICAN CAME TO BE AN APOSTLE, FIRST OF ALL THE EVANGELISTS, COMPOSED A GOSPEL OF JC IN JUDEA IN THE HEBREW LANGUAGE AND CHARACTERS FOR THE BENEFIT OF THOSE OF THE CIRCUMCISION WHO HAD BELIEVE" Naturally, Matthew's accent would be more Semitic (Arabic & Hebrew) than that of Mark & Luke. Matthew records the same scene as Mark 14:34 but note the variation of the dialect: Eli Eli LAMA SABACHTHANI - Pls study the words, from both Matthew and Mark, ask yourself whether these words - Eli Eli sounds like Jehovah Jehovah to you - of course NOT! if the answer if u r not DEAF DUMB or BLIND, ask again whether it sounds like "Abba abba" (meaning father, father in Arabic & Hebrew). Definitely NOT! Hey STUPID, cant u see the cry is ALLAH ALLAH / ELAH ELAH! Unbiased christians will not fail to recognise ALLAH as none other than his - El, Eli, Alle, Elah, Alah, Allah - Call upon HIM by the name or HIS are the Most Beautiful names, as long as those names are not contaminated and as long as they do not conjure up in our minds the images of men or monkeys howsoever glorified they might have been! Furthermore - Now ask your christian friend, if he had heard the word ALLELUYA? Whenever Christian goes into ecstasy, he exclaims “ALLELUYA, ALLELUYA” similar to the Muslims exclaim “ALLAHU AKBAR, ALLAHU AKBAR”. Now i ask u what is ALLELUYA? Read the Book of Revelation, Chapter 19, we are informed John the deciple of Jesus saw a vision, in which he heard the angels in the heavens singing ALLELUYA ALLELUYA. Is it HIP HIP HOORAY? Were the angels in the heavens singing HIP HIP HOORAY to God? So whenever God created somethings the angels exclaimed HIP HIP HOOREY? Is that it....eh? What nonsense!!! [The Last syllable YA is a vocative and an exclamatory particle in both Arabic and the so called Hebrew (created with an Arabic vocab).]

[@rajeshshetty4862]

Jay is scholar of highest order on Islamic teachings.

[@ruyaal]

🤣🤣🤣 good one!

[@prakashprakash79]

clear explanation. to zakir Naik and islam👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@neolia23]

zakir Naik is a clown circus show

[@limanoor7081]

@@neolia23 kzbin.info/www/bejne/hYeQgqiQe89on5o

[@lenwilkinson672]

Keep up the good work Jay.

[@courag1]

What will destroy Islam is its history, which is why the Arabs have built huge structures over the "historical places" in Mecca, (because they do not show any history, there is nothing below them). And with Damascus, where there would be Islamic history, shouldn't be there. But this gives them a reason to destroy Damascus to maintain their "myths". This gives a good reason for the war we see going on in Syria today. It must be destroyed so the archaeologists don't find anything contradictory to the supposed Arab history.

[@briansprock2248]

Thank you Jay!!

[@vikrambmw007]

very brilliant about islam

[@martinunander5074]

Great lecture. I´m going to need some book titles for references.

[@rbspider]

Why would you have small monitors that display the guest speaker . Usually the displays magnify so that people in the back can see the stage easier.

[@beinghuman.9887]

God Bless you Sir ❤❤❤ Stay Blessed ❤❤❤

[@arpitsingh1000]

awesome man

[@ksimongeorge5020]

I had to use earphones.Very informative.

[@olgamartin4016]

Thanks I thought my hearing was playing up again lol

[@courag1]

Jay Smith points out the problem with fighting a war in Arabia in the era of the Islamic conquest. The problem for every army would be water. Very little water and the Meccan control the well. So if you put the holy city where no one can attack, you won't have the sanctuary likely destroyed again. Petra, though it could be attacked, the sanctuary was destroyed in an earthquake and it could be noted that God was not pleased by idolatry which was there. So you need a city where it was not so you build Mecca. Then they pull in the Black Stone whose history comes from Damascus, likely from the temple of Diana, so now you have another reason that Damascus to be destroyed in order to prove Muhammad's story. Isn't it interesting that the Black Stone is kissed but Diana whom this Black Stone represented was FEMALE. Yes, wow do they need to destroy the history but the can't keep destroying history as it is already known. What good does it do now? Because the Arabs will never admit that Islam is and always was a hoax. Islam isn't based on God anyway, it was a construct to support an empire.

[@IvanIvanov-vy7pt]

Wasn't Diana the goddess of fertility?

[@mohamedaliouat]

wow! such pathetic theory you got there! if you're a fan of theoies then i have millions of theories about christianity that you're going to love.

[@sophiawilson8696]

Sir or Miss there were other Stones in others cities or villages. There one other, a White Stone in Perta. Which Muhammad had his people destroyed.

[@khalidqureshi6705]

Like the Roman god with blonde hair and blue eyes

[@sophiawilson8696]

@@khalidqureshi6705 you mean the fake Jesus who a middle easterner!. With black hair and tan/brown.

[@mussaratjalal2433]

Good job God bless you👍💕

[@lennyleapsin5477]

I am staggered why so many intelligent people can believe in Islam. Lots of Islamic professors, doctors, engineers, scientists. Why can't they put their intellects to examine the basic precepts of Islam which Jay Smith has done so very well. Jay has demolished Islam easily and has done so fairly and without prejudice.

[@wishyouthebest9222]

Because islam serves the flesh. What need does someone have for the spirit when he is spiritually dead?

[@ahmedharris7148]

Jay Smith only presented arguments from some scholars of one school of thought in Islamic Studies that is far from being in any way the consensus picture amongst scholars. So I'm not sure he has demolished anything here.

[@thevillagedreams3679]

Education must renewd... 😂 shariath enough..proved.... Its a cult... 🔥

[@Joetheshow445]

A lot of Muslims aren’t actually practicing Muslims, bc apostasy Carrie’s the death penalty

[@ensar3752]

He did nothing to Islam as such. He demolished Sunnah, the traditionalists, conservatives and extremists. Islam in it's purest form, as a sola scriptura religion, is more monotheistic than any other Abrahamic religion in existence. Christian theology is very weak at that, but historically, Christianity is strong due to Roman conversion to it.

[@arindamdas5421]

Please upload the next lecture. It's not there.

[@reggie3467]

Thank you Sir Jay! Please continue to provide us the truth!

[@mmmaaa1433]

Sir Translating Old Testament with some additions was much easier for Hebrew speaking new christians The arabs had to translate New Testament that was written in Hebrew to Arabic

[@MrDarlington8]

To be honest, Jay Smith with your level of critical, creative and descriptive thinking, in my opinion you should be the president of the Christian fellowship association 🌍. I am pretty sure if the Imams and Cleric, they will be pissing in their garments while hiding their faces under their pillows cus they can’t face you left alone debate you because you’re talking with facts all in their faces. GOD BLESS U.

[@mariamagbo4424]

I'm forever grateful to Jesus whose death gave me life. As ex muslim, l didn't know all this information I'm learning now, I'm lifted the more in the revelation of the grace of God.

[@nallamohammedkalanjiam2674]

Keep studying more and more. Finally you will revert back to ISLAM

[@sidprice6214]

Each one has to make their own choice - follow the revelation from God or follow the revelation from men dressed up as revelation from God.

[@stephenarnold6359]

@@nallamohammedkalanjiam2674 Hardly anyone does unless coerced by Muslims. Knowledge makes it impossible to believe in vile fairy stories

[@andreasjhon8080]

need translation for this videos

[@abdulmuhid1816]

Dr Jay Smith presentations should be translated into many languages especially the Malay and Indonesian so that those who couldn't understand English should know what has been said by Dr. Jay Smith. This is a well research product of history regarding the spread of Islam throughout the world and reasonable thinking and a comparative study ol Islamic religion and other religion particularly the Christian and the Jewish religion. Is there any scholars who dare to debate in this and says orherwise to contradict the findings of Dr Jay Smith. We the people of the world have the right to know the true history of the historian findings and comparative studies on it. Thanks you.

[@AswinLubis-bq4pw]

Jay Smith LIAR

[@TheLordofWar1969]

What are some good books on the subjects he covers on islam?

[@beinghuman.9887]

Live long Sir❤❤❤

[@user-jh2fk2zq3b]

God bless n secure u dr jay

[@dgetzin]

Finally! Call Dano, he's bookin' the man, BOOKIN' THE MAN!

[@thefaceofanangel2402]

my muslim friend told me everyone is a muslim and i asked why? and he said as soon as you are born and you cry, you are saying allah is great. if you dont cry, it means you are not a muslim. so i asked him who told him that, and he said it is in the quran and his malam told him that. So, i patiently told him that, if a child is born and do not cry, it means he or she is dead. that is why they use alcohol to rob new born babies who do not cry when born, just to prove that the child is alive and not dead. He has stop talking to me about islam ever since because i told him his malam is lying.

[@icequeen8531]

You are lucky your Muslim friend didn't throw acid on your face!

[@neolia23]

when a child is born the soul is trapped inside that body its clothed with flesh once death occurs the soul departures the body it becomes free into the universe that's why the baby cries but Muslims tell nonsense

[@rahasiakusaja]

abad 7 atau sekitar thn 645 sesudah masehi di kota Barus atau dulu disebut Pancur daerah Sumatera Utara dari Tulisan Shaykh Abu Salih al-Armini., juga ada yg menyebut abad ke-2 dari Rasul Thomas atau Gereja Katolik Suriah Timur. Dan Abad ke-14 di daerah Sumatera Selatan, Bersamaan juga dari Santo Fransiskus Xaverius di daerah maluku dan flores. I'm sorry Mr. Jay this is two claimed in Sumatera Indonesia, 645 Katolik come to Barus and 672 Islam come to Barus, that's so interesting. GBU.

[@waynesumner1829]

No man can see the Forest by looking at the trees. GOD is Light and Love.Any one that hates Love hates himself and his own children. Love thy neighbor as thySelf and fulfill all commandments. Eternal Life is a Commanded Blessing for the Whole Creation. When We all get Heaven We will all see JesUS, cause He has redeemed US All in Himself! Amen!

[@marjuparsada3070]

Dr.Jerald F.Dirks (The former minister of the united methodist church in the United Stat

[@jonson856]

Hello, the second video (with alan craig) does not play. maybe taken down?

[@probablynoone2382]

Thanks

[@felipemillomeda]

God bless you Dr Jay Smith

[@SY-jq4yw]

A fictitious figure and history, yet billions believe in it.

[@ConradoFonacier-lr8qv]

Hi KT Online Learning! Where is the transcript of your video? Don't allow KZbin to impose it's whim on your shreable property. This is a crime.

[@herohero8620]

I have been trying to share this with all the muslums i can .they need to learn about what they believe in. Its written and the truth will set you free

[@ellomirza]

I don’t doubt the scholarship and this man seems to be reporting history in good faith. What I can’t wrap my mind around is how he looks at one fairy tale and recognizes it as such but looks at another fairy tale and proclaims it historical fact. Either everything is man made fiction or nothing is. Either everything is magical or nothing is. There’s no hey let’s look at the Shinto faith, Buddhism, Islam etc etc and point our it’s clearly man made, of course it is. But hey look here this guy Jesus, he is magical. LoL

[@yehiaelyamani6943]

Agree. Consistent logic!

[@Compassion_over_Empathy]

Agree

[@sophiawilson8696]

Jay Smith needs to stick to facts.

[@cbtam4333]

Why? Why must everything be man-made fiction or else nothing is? Seems like a fallacy based on all-or-nothing thinking. The whole endeavor of investigating and seeking truth presupposes that some things are true, some things are false, that it is at least possible in many cases to distinguish between the two, and that it actually matters. If everything is either all true or all false, that would would obviate the need for all scholarly investigation and discourse. Nothing would matter, and so why even bring it up.

[@rudysimoens570]

EVERY religion is invented by men with rules of behaviour in favour of men! Women and minority groups have been discriminated for centuries and still are! The religion you happen to believe in is just a geographical coincidence! Time to grow up and leave all that supernatural nonsense behind!

[@praveenmallikarjunaiah7613]

Credentials of Yeshua has much weight than Muhammad. Muhammad's historicity is not very much accurate...

[@amarnathjha8319]

Thanks moses, only five times of AJAN!

[@sidprice6214]

What is AJAN?

[@denisHolySpirit]

Someone mentioned no one mentions Abraham's father. Before his name was changed to Abraham he was called Abram. His father was Terah Genesis 11:26. Genesis 17:5 his name is changed to Abraham.

[@waynesumner1829]

Abraham represents the "Father of a great multitude, in the flesh and in The Spirit. Ab -is for the Jews, Ra- us for the Christians, and Ham- is for the Muslims and all the other Gentiles. Christ reminds US in Matthew 23:8: " Ye are All Brethren ". GOD is Our Father and JerUSAlem Above Beulah/Hephzibah is the Mother of US All! Praise Our Father GOD He Who Omnipotent reigneth!!!☀️☀️☀️

[@Flagship7]

Crucial point missed here was ORAL TRADITION of the times. Oral tradition is information passed down through the generations by word of mouth and memorization that is not written down on paper. The entire Arabic Quran was memorized and written in the hearts of the people known as “Hafiz” literally meaning “Guardian” during the lifetime of Muhammad. The Quran is the only book that has been memorized completely by millions of people. The Bible confirms, the law of God will be written in their hearts, as the prophets foretold. And the Lord says, “I will put my laws in their minds, and I will write them on their hearts. I will be their God, and they will be my people” Jeremiah 31:33

[@sophiawilson8696]

You correct the same with Judaism at beginning it started oral stories. It was way later the Jews started to write things down 6000 years ago.

[@Dalvidos]

Yeah.... Watch the next video Lol

[@cannonbolt14]

Watch the next video

[@sidprice6214]

They don't want to hear it because they did not do it themselves and this is why we ended up with Greek manuscripts and Aramaic ones of the NT.

[@defenderoftruth3212]

According to Jay Smith is that he believed that there is really ONE ORIGINAL GOSPEL. Since he cannot find it, he assumed that the gospel of John is already that book. But his is only mere assumption. He failed to make any clear evidence to show that his assumption is correct. Hence, he has to show manuscripts in Aramaic as evidence for his assumption that the gospel of John is the already real Gospel of Pophet jESUs (pbuh). By his hasty assumption, he undoubtedly discarded the gospels of Mark, Matthew and Luke into useless books which have no more meaning to the whole Christendom, and hence not fit to be used as the basis of the religiosity of the Christians. -05-14-23

[@invitationtoislam3227]

Challenge of Almighty Allah to all in the Holy Quran: "And if you are in doubt about what We have sent down [i.e., the Qur’ān] upon Our Servant [i.e., Prophet Muḥammad (ﷺ)], then produce a sūrah (chapter) the like thereof and call upon your witnesses [i.e., supporters] other than Allah, if you should be truthful. But if you are unable to do so-and you will never be able to do so-then fear the Fire (Hell) fuelled with people and stones, which is prepared for the disbelievers." (Al Quran: 2: 23-24)

[@holywarrior5719]

If God is present everywhere why pray only in one direction. Also the Arabs have a great business model by making it compulsory to visit Mecca once in lifetime. This will bring them lot of money.

[@milagroman75]

Early Christians and today’s Orthodox pray facing East because Christ will return from the East. Facing a certain direction is a Christian thing too, Protestants just forgot when they diluted Tradition.

[@sidprice6214]

It signifies unity. The Arab Jews and Christians also have a great business model. It is called JERUSALEM.

[@ndjibukabengele973]

@@milagroman75 Are you even realizing what you are saying? Christian comes from the word Christ and if those people you refered to as christians don't abide by Jesus Christ's teachings then you can't blame it on christianity. Jesus Christ didn't say to do that so if people who called themselves christians and did that, that has nothing to do with christianity. Please you can think better than that, come on now.

[@ksimongeorge5020]

Volume not good

[@retnorimbawati9919]

Saya orang Indonesia yang tidak bisa bahasa Inggris. Mohon dengan hormat untuk ada yang menterjemahkan dalam bahasa Indonesia, agar pengetahuan ini bisa menjadi berkat bagi kami.... Terimakasih. Tuhan Yesus memberkati.

[@spidaman0112]

Would require someone there. Unique language

[@mariasham4203]

What ever you do but we'll supercede you InshaAllah

[@alfredojr.esllerescandor7758]

I’m looking for a speaker who will first thing first, will say that He was called of God not of man, like the Apostle Paul beginning statement in his epistles. What I’ve heard to Jay is, he is a Phd and study hard history, well good for you. I’m still looking for a man called of God in this last dispensation. God is God, no one can stop him by talking or calling a prophet now a days.

[@JackSquat54]

Jay Smiths research is located where it can never be erased, never be destroyed.

[@jawshua100]

People are so ignorance and still believe Moh lies eventhough the evidences are overwhelming

[@George-iv1hi]

Brainwashing + intimidation + lack of proper education

[@mohamedaliouat]

what evidence? you're so gullible and blind you believe everything you hear.

[@ndjibukabengele973]

Momo was deceived himself and blinded.

[@imexbd]

Islam says that your neighbors are like your family. Islam says: 40 houses after you are your neighbors.

[@waynesumner1829]

There is an image of Jay on one of his podcasts, all dressed in black, with his arms partially outstretched as if he were bearing a cross. But it must be getting unbearably heavy because his arms are sagging. No doubt he will be better served and comforted when he has cast it off and joined Christ in the Glorious Light of His Resurrection! And won't We all?! Thank You Jesus and Christ for saving the world!!!☀️☀️☀️🌍🌎❤❤❤🐑🐑🐑

[@defenderoftruth3212]

How I earnestly wish that there is now an original ARAMAIC GOSPEL because I am dying inside to read it. I hope there is a translation in English. It's hard to read it in its original form in Aramaic. I don't know that language. I think Aramaic is much harder to read than Arabic. I believe that this Gospel is a book of spiritual guidance from God. Unlike the 4 make-believe gospels, their contents are purely biographies of Prophet jESUs (pbuh) but with a huge hole in the accounts of his life covering the primetime of his age. From what museum or library can we find the original ARAMAIC GOSPEL? Is there any original manuscript for it? I am urging Jay Smith and his cohorts to produce that book as soon as possible so that Muslims and Christians alike will be enlightened. -05-13-23

[@mayaali6506]

Ali was not prophet’s adapted son .Ali was his cousin and son in law as far as I know

[@ssimba2785]

Maya Ali Prophet's adopted son was Zayd ,Ali was his cousin who I believe got married to prophet's daughter Fatima.

[@2paacalipse]

You should do one on nation of islam and elijah mohammed

[@encle]

What is interesting is that this speech would not be allowed today, certainly not at SOAS which has been completely captured by Islamism.

[@stephenhowe4107]

Video working. Perhaps a temporary glitch. Wish people will not indulge in knee-jerk theories

[@tropicalstrings]

Nobody discusses Thera father of Abraham in the Bible. Azar father of Abraham in the coran Genesis 11:27 Sura 6:75 ,or 6:74 in other corans Why not.

[@ezekielamuaalua4564]

You never read the Joly Bible?

[@AswinLubis-bq4pw]

Please read in Jay Smith Liar Bible

[@_billy.mandalay]

low volume

[@waynesumner1829]

By your words O man, ye shall be justified or condemned! Make your bed hard and lie in it and die in it. If We do not forgive EVERY MAN his brother, then your Father Who is in Heaven will not forgive you!

[@ReneHaveman]

Video is still not working

[@thebeautifulsoundofincessa8202]

The society that had not had many enemies and had no progress was late to get history from them. But the Koran is no mistake to this day.

[@JayReaction530]

Islam is as historical as star wars he is like anakin Skywalker

[@mohamedaliouat]

is the resurection historical? and can you explain the trinity logically?

[@bethesda5739]

I wanna know about the women of the Qu'ran

[@neolia23]

the woman are considered nothing only to make children and obey her huband

[@defenderoftruth3212]

According to Jay Smith the LETTERS OF PAUL are just MERE TAFSEER of the Old Testament and “other scriptures” (?). Tafseer means interpretation. If the letters of Paul are just mere tafseer, why is it they become the main core of the New Testament which comprised 90 percent of it. These should be written in a separate book. In the Islamic standard, no single tafseer is included in the Holy Qur’an. Hence, the letters of Paul must be written in a separate book. Jay Smith failed not elaborate as to what specific book or verse/s in the Old Testament that each letter is intended to for being a tafseer. He should have elaborated on the following letters of Paul: LETTERS OF PAUL TO THE DIFFERENT CHURCHES: 1). Romans - tafseer of what is it intended for? 2). Hebrews - tafseer of what is it intended for? 3). Corinthians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 4). Galatians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 5). Colossians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 6). Philippians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 7). Ephesians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 8). Thessalonians - tafseer of what is it intended for? LETTERS OF PAUL TO THE DIFFERENT INDIVIDUALS: 1). Timothy - tafseer of what is it intended for? 2). Titus - tafseer of what is it intended for? 3). Philemon - tafseer of what is it intended for? 4). James - tafseer of what is it intended for? 5). John - tafseer of what is it intended for? 6). Jude - tafseer of what is it intended for? 7). Peter - tafseer of what is it intended for? -05-17-23

[@ss-dg2rw]

There’s a lot of historical error in your presentation, as Quran they did write it early but was not collected till Uthman . I think there is a lot need to be debated here and good to review with their book .

[@ezekielamuaalua4564]

Denying is in the Islamic culture. Bring your side of the story.

[@user-uv8tc3yu7y]

As you are an excellent orator and also you were born in India. So also talk of Hinduism. There is no word " Hindu " in any of our Holy Books. Also explore about Nadi Astrology which would be most fascinating thing evere known to mankind. It would open up a pandora box of knowlwdge.

[@jonc4719]

Gods and ghosts and faieries and a sometimes acceptable madness that has sold books and employed priests for thousands of years.

[@jumanjenga7682]

You can say all you want but can't change the facts and beliefs.

[@waynesumner1829]

What does this Fact tell those with Ears to hear about these two very different faiths? There are ex-Muslims who truly convert to True Christianity, but there are no true Christians that convert to Islam. In Western culture, only societal " misfits," become Muslims. Example: The famous black boxer, Cassius Clay a.k.a. ,"Muhammad Ali", GOD rest his Christ-redeemed Soul. There are no faiths in Heaven, no temples, no synagogues, no churches, and no mosques. Just the Whole Family of GOD, the Children of Light!🌞🌞🌞

[@waynesumner1829]

Why halt ye between two opinions? If you want to know The Truth, look In The Horses Mouth...not in Barrack's, Mohammed's horse's mouth. He was a myth as is his master. The Real Horse 🐎 is His Only Risen Son's Essence, Christ, The Way , The Truth and The Life, The Redeemer of the Spirits of all flesh. But what about my precious body of flesh. Can't it be raptured, or physically resurrected, or reincarnated? Please Lord, I'm only 87 years young, can I have a few more. I want to spend some quality time with my gggrandchildren! Sorry Gramps, that is not how it works. It is appointed unto man once to die. Be glad! The flesh profiteth nothing. Your past is water under the bridge and you have no future here in this world. Fear not, death is but a reward, a release.To be absent from the body is to be Present with the Lord. Today, He saith, Ye shall be with Me in Paradise. And This is All Straight from The Horse's Mouth! Let US ride on the Wings of the Wind!🐎🌞🦅

[@josiahbennett7573]

E.J. Brill and the zakat Foundation

[@steveadams9289]

Any man who claims to be religious never denigrates any Religion he or she might disagree but never say things which he or she is just conjecture based on a few historians

[@sanketrane7311]

Now I know.

[@kafirlindaclark6148]

I think your video "critique of Muhammad" has been removed by KZbin.

[@rahasiakusaja]

Barus adalah ditemukannya makam Syekh Rukunuddin yang wafat pada tahun 672 Masehi atau 48 Hijriah. Makam tersebut terdapat di kompleks Makam Mahligai di Barus. Mr. Jay let explained to us, I think it"s wrong written base on this fact of you

[@mussaratjalal2433]

Jesus is lord . He is coming soon👍🙏

[@andreasferryanto8705]

Is he wrote a book?

[@xondeez757]

It’s simple, nobody had a sense of clear direction back then so the Muslims invented a way to calculate to determine where Mecca was with 100% accuracy

[@davidhale6929]

What evidence is there that the infamous Zam Zam well that is in Mecca existed prior to Mohammed? I am being told that this well was there when Abraham and Sarah supposedly lived there.

[@gabriellecrofts6664]

This is curious

[@dreamerone5082]

May Allah bless us all..Amin.

[@alcaponedarius7730]

Damn… u got heart man🤒🤒🤒🤒still mentioning allah over all these??

[@seye8eyes]

Truth will set you free from pastor 🙌 Ten Commands wishing you good health happiness all your family friends Thanks Giving Did you Call upon a Stranger to your Table in a Crisis time Criminals Christmas 🎄 passing the rapping as they sat around the fire 🔥 🌙 🌉 🌃 🌌 😴 Holly Night 🌙 did you leftovers of your family gathering celebrations 🍾 winter weather you love 💘 Truth will set you free

[@jrex3575]

Islam: Pray 5x daily and in between prayers lie , cheat, abuse, kill.

[@ajitkapadia8950]

Excellent information. Why do we need religion and gods , when NO other living thing needs gods or religions ? Think if have any brains.

[@shahrahman4368]

Jay Smith - Misinterpreted.

[@bersanderdiyok1247]

Ali was killing while he was praying

[@mdarisismail400]

As Salam. You love Jesus (pbuh) thro Quran. No other scripture described Jesus (pbuh).

[@waynesumner1829]

If any scholar of Scripture cannot see The Truth in at least one passage or verse of the Canon of the Authorized King James Translation, then he will not find It in the Dead Sea Scrolls or the so-called " missing" Gospels. Any 2 or 3 verses from any of the 39 books of the O.T., or any 2 or 3 verses from any of the 27 books in the N.T., RIGhTLY interpreted,reveal the definition of The Salvation of GOD, which is, to wit: The Knowledge of The Truth.Only The Truth, THE TRUTH is true , and only Knowing It makes US free. And They Who cannot lie, the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, have promised that All Living Things shall Know The Truth. No one has ever nor can he be saved or Eternally enlightened by believing the words written in a book. They are symbols. GOD Our Redeemer is Fact! Praise Him from Whom All Blessings flow!

[@steveadams9289]

He relies on the men and women who were mere researchers

[@steveadams9289]

Debate Zakir Naik as he is knowledgeable to debate you

[@josiahbennett7573]

KMPG LLC our government is using cel Dr Rajiv Shah CEO behavioral Health Rockerfeller Foundation

[@hashh2019]

Confused Jay Smith- honestly mislead and misleading others too. I pray he is guided.

[@ezekielamuaalua4564]

Thank you Jay for telling the truth.

[@sidprice6214]

God does not guide the persistent liar. Best you pray for the people who really need it.

[@sidprice6214]

@@ezekielamuaalua4564 One has to wonder which one is sicker - the persistent liar or the persistent listener of lies.

[@hashh2019]

@@sidprice6214 thank you brother! agree

[@lenwilkinson672]

HMTQ Elaine. I am glad I don’t have anything to do with it..😊