4everfreebrony - This Is What It's Like (feat. Envia Sun, SaxPon3, and TheMusicReborn)

[@tf299]

Here are my thoughts why I think this is a perfect song for what it is trying to be. (I am not an MLP fan) This is an alternative fan made scenario where after the 1000 year banishment Luna returns from the Moon and she successfully takes revenge on her sister that did this to her, by banishing her to the Moon. (Eye for an Eye style) The song is sung by Celestia after she gets banished by Luna. It starts with her being very cocky saying how she needed a vacation anyway and how bad can this punishment really be. After a couple of weeks she is feeling very irritated, questioning herself how she could have thought this was ever going to be fun, having literally nothing to do. In the last main part of the song it has been 1000 years of being alone with nothing to do. At this point she is completely broken. She doesn't care about who was right, what happened in the past, etc. she just wants to get back home and she is willing to do anything to get back, yet the irony is she is powerless to do anything to change her situation. The chorus is also amazingly done, for it stays lyrically the same, but if taken in context with the main part that precedes it, it changes in meaning. The first time Celestia is asking herself "This isn't so bad, I have nothing to lose I can just relax and enjoy having no responsibilities." At the end of this part she questions herself why she kept her sister here for 1000 years instead of making it a shorter period. A rhetorical question with not very much thought put into it at this point in time. After the second part she is saying "My sister probably felt the same irritation I am currently feeling, why didn't I bring her back sooner, wouldn't it be enough to leave her here for a month?" After the last part she is full of sadness and regret for what she had done. She knows what her sister did was wrong, but the punishment she received was way too harsh. And in the end Celestia realises that she caused the bigger evil by doing this to her sister and completely understands why this is her current punishment. I love the singers voice and the instruments they have chosen, but that is a personal preference with the backup vocalists also meshing well with the main singer's voice, almost like they are her echoes/ cries. The saxophone after the second chorus is a great addition to the song because this is an instrument often used in blues to represent loneliness which makes it perfect for a 1000 year old timeskip of being alone. The beat is good, making the song feel like it has been going on forever (and making it great for looping). And the tone of the song is melancholic, without the lyrics it sounds happy with a touch of sadness which makes it work very well with the mental transitions the character goes throughout the song.

[@4everfreebrony]

I'm so glad you noticed those details! Most of them were intentional, but I didn't know saxophones in general represent loneliness. I should have known that, but I guess I just never thought of it that way. But yeah, when I really want to hone in on a neat concept that I'm certain other people will be interested in, I tend to go for the fully immersive experience, i.e. - choosing the right vocalist to represent the character, making the instrumental fit with the theme, and making sure the lyrics are 100% relatable but also the catchiest they can possibly be. The vocalist sounds a lot like Celestia, the instruments and mixing sound very spacey, and the lyrics hit the nail right on the head in my opinion. Thanks so much for your comment. ^^

[@tf299]

I am glad you appreciated my comment. And thank you again for the great music.

[@ERRR0RR]

"I don't know what I learned, I just want to go home" is such an amazing line, it tells that what Luna went through was just an useless torture and completely unfair

[@eglol]

Entirely possible. Maybe it was nice to be in peace for a thousand years, but Nightmare Moon could've been beaten, heck, fifty years after being banished and Luna would be just as grateful to be back as she is in the first episode. A thousand years is a loooong time! I guess Celestia needed time too, since she could beat Nightmare Moon herself but didn't know if Luna would be okay after however long, and eventually decided to let the thousandth year come and for it to be a test for the next ruler(s) of Equestria, but dang, 1000 years is still... A long time. Celestia knew that Luna wouldn't be trapped in the moon forever, even though that's what she told Equestria, for them to feel safe. And Celestia definitely wanted her sister back! It hurt, every day thinking about what she had to do to Luna, but as I said before, she didn't know if her sister had gotten over everything yet. An unrelated thing, it's funny how I literally just a had autocorrect correct to Equestrian and Celestial, and all I had to do was remove the first letter 😂

[@heatherrockwell9012]

@@eglol You seem to be assuming that Celestia actually intended to banish Luna for a thousand years, which I don't think is at all what happened. When we see the mane six use the Elements, they don't really know what they're going to do, and I assume Celestia was the same. If it was at all under her control, she would've brought Luna back centuries ago.

[@eglol]

@@heatherrockwell9012 That's possible too, and honestly, it makes very much sense that Celestia would've brought her back before if she could. But it's all uncertain. Celestia might have thought about really wanting her back, but still not knowing if she would be okay yet, for a while at least. But Celestia definitely wouldn't have wanted to be alone, and bringing Luna back earlier than 1,000 years might have been worlds better for both of them at the time. Everybody has a different idea of how magic works... and it's important to share our thoughts to get a better understanding of how things could be and other opinions could fix problems and inconsistencies.

[@heatherrockwell9012]

@@eglol I don’t think Celestia ever expected Luna would come back okay; she doesn’t, Nightmare Moon does. I can’t really imagine Celestia would’ve been surprised by that.

[@RedGallardo]

They are immortal deities. I don't think 1000 years is that long to them. It would be a torture to a mortal. We don't know what did being sealed into the Moon mean. Maybe Luna had fun with Sailor Moon all this time. Maybe she lived in Escaflowne world. Maybe time went 1 minute for her 1 year for us. Let there be mystery smoothing the corners of the storytelling. =)

[@CosmiaNebula]

4everfree: "Hey guys, let me play you a song!" everyone else: "Okay, as long as it's not one of those sad songs with a deceptively cheerful tune."

[@NightmareMoon9964]

4EFB" *Plays anyway* Everyone: *yay.*

[@CamarasaurusLover15346]

WTH???!!! I DIDNT EXPECT TO SEE YOU HERE!!!

[@celsetialarchives5909]

*gypsy bard intensifies*

[@Red5rainbow]

@@celsetialarchives5909 little known fact: g***y is actually a slur for the Romani people so please try to avoid using it. It’s unfortunate that it’s in the name of such a good and popular song (the people didn’t know when they made it either)

[@meemeett]

@@Red5rainbow Little known fact: Gypsy Horse is a breed of horse, also known as the Galineers Cob. Please try to avoid meaninglessly censoring words, and actually do something useful instead.

[@katrinasample5783]

"I don't know what I learned, I just want to go home" Ow. This line is said with so much feeling.

[@Dowlphin]

I definitely know the feeling.

[@JycRow]

*Lonely saxophone noises*

[@BioniclesaurKing4t2]

"deceivingly happy-sounding song with a depressing message" Ah, the best kind.

[@marceline_achlys354]

the best kind indeed. If you are interested, here's more of it: The Wombats, any songs but Turn and Walking disaster are my favourite Oreo, Help me Tomska, The Muffin Song Daughter, No Care and Youth The Cranberries, All Over Now and Wake Me When It's Over Of Monsters and Men, Wolves Without Teeth many 4everfreebrony songs or covers Hozier, Take Me To Church Halsey, You Should Be Sad Aviators, Open Your Eyes, especially 4everfreebrony's and Awkward Marina's covers Sylva Hound, Addict MathematicPony, Just This Once man, there are so many... I would beat myself if I forget Giedré, a french artist that specializes in this kind of songs. EDIT: I wanna keep going. MandoPony, Not Like Me and Just Three Days Woodlore, Shining Star Luna Jax, Applebloom's prayer DAGames, Build Our Machine and Gospel Of Dismay (Oreo's covers are amazing) The Dø, Keep Your Lips Sealed and Despair, Hangover & Ecstasy Evelyn Evelyn, You Only Want Me 'Cause You Want My Sister Beetlejuice the musical, Say My Name

[@theunidentifiedchangeling9451]

Yes

[@coastalcapybara]

Is that a reference to Gypsy Bard I see?!!

[@Briselance]

The best kind? O_o Well, yes. But actually, no.

[@TheOfficialPSI]

Old comment, but first reply missed one of the artists 4EFB often references as one of his main inspirations for this style of storytelling: Adam Young. Many of his songs can be fit into that description, especially most of his discography from 2015 and earlier.

[@Stardust_42]

“It better not be one of those depressing songs with a deceptively happy tune.”: 0:00

[@CosmiaNebula]

just like "Here on the moon"

[@exodd1]

Argh... I can't... Please, stop me befo... WHEN YOU'RE RIFE WITH DEVASTATION

[@Codex951]

@@exodd1 🤣

[@nxterminator5796]

Prepare to be hit in the feels

[@coastalcapybara]

@@CosmiaNebula It reminds me of it! They are both great songs, IMO.

[@donuts7687]

She did say in 'Who Knows' she deserved a break but I guess this isn't really what she had in mind

[@CosmiaNebula]

Honestly though, Celestia has lived thousands of years, so many years to harvest regret from. Imagine how much pain is inside her when she sang "And I can't help but think \Of everything I've done wrong"

[@Unregistereduser-vy1uj]

Ashes by Aviators comes to mind

[@chrishill3536]

could not think how many ponys she knew who pass away from old age and sickness. Then have rule land by her self.

[@serenafucito]

I've always thought that, actually, she's a complex character, starting by the moment when she saw Luna after a thousand years. It's an undescribable feeling to sent away the “person” you love the most, wait for years and years (I don't know if she knew that her sister could come back or not, that's my dilemma 😅) and then, finally, hug her again. She's certainly not perfect, but I think she's one of the most interesting characters, that's why she's one of my favourites. 😁💘

[@efaristi9737]

when you are a ruler and a immortal, you're bound to make a lot of mistakes.

[@efaristi9737]

@@serenafucito she knew, the ponytale about Nightmare Moon prophecised that NM would return. And Celestia, unlike most ponies, knew it wasn't a tale. My dilemma is, is she the one that decided when NM would return or not.

[@katsenpai6957]

I love the different feeling "so this is how it feels, when you've got nothing to lose" At the start she's saying it envying her sister's lack of consequences for failure (having nothing that she could lose by failing) But at the end she realises the despair of having nothing LEFT to lose, which is the truth of Luna's time too.

[@Dowlphin]

Imagine having some things left to lose but nothing to WIN.

[@Pokemon-rules]

Imagine having nothing to lose but still losing

[@oskoldir]

​@@Pokemon-rulesdon't have to imagine 🎉😎

[@Her_Imperious_Condescension]

Luna on the moon: sad and angry Celestia on the moon: ROCKING OUT

[@soonamisapphire2425]

I have so much love for this song And the Celestia impersonation is just so spot-on

[@CeperatedSelf]

Indeed 💯

[@vegetafan9922]

You want Daybreaker? Because this is how you get Daybreaker!

[@robertchapman2174]

Oh snap. Everything is about to be set ablaze... 🔥

[@501Magnum]

Personal headcannon: This takes place sometime after "Who knows." And the other princesses had had enough of Celestia sleeping in on her duties, and sent her to the moon as punishment.

[@localvoid69420]

Thought the same thing

[@SwiftpawWolffox]

I like this headcannon.

[@Oatmealism]

I offer a alternative explanation. That it happens after 'Who knows' still, however it was less of a 'the other princesses had enough of her BS' and was more a "You think being trapped on the moon for a thousand years is a vacation?! You want me to cover for you so you can sleep in and be lazy to 'make up for lost time'?! Fine, if I am making up for lost time, you get to go to the moon for a thousand years so you can know how it feels." Aka, a typical tit for tat sibling response.

[@501Magnum]

@@Oatmealism that is a acceptable alternative headcannon

[@Oatmealism]

@@501Magnum Lol, I have internally nicknamed this song the 'Be careful what you wish for song, v2' the first being 'I just can't wait to be king' from lion king, he sings it, and his dad dies.

[@ezrawhitmer1840]

on the surface, this song seems like such a fun and jolly song, but when you actually listen to the words... it hits so hard, and the meaning goes so. very. deep.

[@RuminantHairdo]

I can't help but think "man, this guy writing a cheerful song? Wait its depressing with a happy go lucky tune, yay."

[@Alumx]

How did miss this song holy sh- this EVERYTHING is beautiful, music, singing, art ah!

[@Mr-__-Sy]

Why I heard your voice while reading this?!

[@shadowhawkrine1947]

Your Princess Celestia voice pops up in head voice completely randomly whenever I'm reading. I have no regrets.

[@Mr_Sonicfan]

Old message but, when you gonna cover this?

[@ceruleanrush3315]

"No walls to hold me in But I can't break out" This hits *_hard_*

[@LoneBronyProductions]

I can't stop listening to this on repeat, you guys did great with this one

[@Sunnybrook1]

Ditto!

[@lizarocket355]

Same! I love this song!

[@Adahy_Bullet]

Saaaaaaame

[@solyrasun5021]

What in the world how did you know?🤩

[@PhoenixHorseGuy]

You know, that side of the moon seems a lot less pink than I remember it being.

[@TheCommenterDragon]

Celestia dancing on the moon i love that...but at the same time i feel bad for her. Superlative job on this song everyone the art style, the music, lyrics and vocals are all just phenomenal you've all outdone yourselves!!!

[@sissymorning9809]

And yet years ago everyone said to shut up about feeling bad for luna and think about how tia felt while Luna was gone

[@dinkyborja]

@@sissymorning9809 Well, I think that Celestia did nothing wrong. When your sister tries to kill you I don't thing that there were many options. And Celestia would never kill her, she did what she had to do no matter how hard it was, that's the diference.

[@commissarblyt.8073]

Starts off happy. Ended with insanity, or just sad.

[@l1nus0nl1neproductions9]

This sounds like a hidden bonus track from ”the pink side of the moon” 😌

[@astralaegis]

This song has a nice flow to it that I love. The slow descent into the loneliness that Celestia is feeling, the cheery tune, and the change of emotion meld together into something that tells a sad and somber story while being disguised as something cheerful. Well done to everyone who partook in this, and I always look forward to the next song. Keep up the amazing work!

[@ScribblerProductions101]

I was fine until 'lonely saxophone noises' and now I'm howling.

[@pyre1738]

Indeed!

[@sunnyskies3969]

Oh hey scribbler! Nice to see you here!!

[@Warmfur]

One thing I love, is seeing one of my favorite MLP content creators, comment and watch another one of my favorite MLP content creator's❤❤❤

[@wild20000]

One of the best lines i fully agree with is when she says "my sunlight hides away my shadowed core." That one statment says so much truth

[@bronyhub]

It's criminal a song this catchy with such wonderful animation has less than 10K views here. I enjoyed it so much I made my first bandcamp purchase! The rest of the album sounds pretty great too. These artists are keeping the fandom and its incredible creative spirit chugging along! _It's been a thousand years (ooooh-ooooh) and I'm still hearing this song , someone please help me (oh-oh) I've listened for too long. la la la, la la..._

[@ryanhelton7926]

Envia Sun? That's a name I've not heard in a long time..... Amazing job everyone, as usual! A catchy song that's also really depressing. Those are my favorite. ;)

[@theunidentifiedchangeling9451]

It's a name I've never heard of until I noticed it's actually Sunlestia from years ago.

[@EnviaSun]

@@theunidentifiedchangeling9451 :')

[@account9243]

We talk a lot about Luna... But celestia's life is so damn sad too, like, living in cupability, Over working, faking her super positive Queen image...

[@varianberry]

thats what i thought...

[@nxterminator5796]

Envia Sun has a darn good Celestia voice

[@ryaku5]

I both want you to stop and never stop making music. Every time I look at my playlist, I see it's getting too long. Every time you release a new song, I see it's not long enough. Thus my eternal enigma.

[@CosmiaNebula]

Fluttershy: "Sounds like a nice problem to have if you ask me." (Find a Pet song)

[@AtmaDragoon]

God, "I don't know what I learned, I just want to go home" is so heartbreakingly real. Lonely saxophone noises, indeed. ;-; Well done, all of you.

[@nxterminator5796]

It hits me in the feels so hard. Yet why is it so catchy that I am compelled to sing it to myself for the next hour?

[@timefliesaway999]

1000 years later Luna: “was quite lonely up there” Celestia: “can’t imagine, I’m sure you found something to spend your time with Luna: “you wanna figure it out by yourself?” Celestia: “hmm? What do you-” Luna: *sends her up there* *Not even a minute later* Celestia: “well I guess I know now”

[@lazyrat6687]

it makes sense that luna can banish her own sister to the moon, being, well, luna.

[@NightmareMoon9964]

Luna ultimately yeeted Celestia.

[@malthehuman_]

*lonely saxophone noises*

[@sethsabres]

*You forgot the asterisks*

[@lisa-mariebastian6584]

😂😂

[@normanclatcher]

​@@sethsabres ***_Aggressive Asterisking Noises_***

[@Rewindgamer42]

This is so good! I've had it on repeat at least 50 times at this point. So catchy! and Envia Sun has a perfect Celestia voice

[@thecrimsoncommando3875]

Wow. First Argo with the SFM work for Prince, now Eden Laing with the stellar art for this song! I've never seen this style before, and I think a full animation like this would work wonders. The musicians and artists are certainly ending this year with a BANG! Keep it up, everybody!

[@4everfreebrony]

You should look up Galaxy, Star Hopper, and Night Glider. They're all songs by SoGreatAndPowerful. They actually have very similar artstyles!

[@4everfree1groupie50]

Epic! Such an amazing song!

[@CosmiaNebula]

your username is extremely relevant

[@Dies420]

The little ‘oh oh oh’ after the ‘so’ is why inlive

[@offlcersam]

I wish I found this song earlier, it's one of the few I could listen to on repeat for eternity.

[@EffervescentVeil]

Still Listening to this after three years!

[@dragonkingbeyblader]

You really captured the pure feeling of dread in this song, I may not be a fan of the mlp but when I first listened to this song without watching the actual video I was feeling lonely and lost. That's something I don't feel from a whole lot of songs now and days

[@AstroEden]

AAA this was so much fun to work on!! 💗 Thank you for asking me to do the art, it’s wonderful seeing it all put together!

[@ItsChevnotJeff]

Nightmare moon: You will feel how I felt when you sent me to the moon! Celestia: :/ Ok Daybreaker: Are you serious?

[@venus1333]

Daybreaker: A thousand years was too lenient for you, Luna

[@Briselance]

@@venus1333 Celestia/Daybreaker: "Now, do YOU know how it feels to be alone to rule instead of two?"

[@OMG_Koschey]

Просто шикарная композиция. Музыка - великолепная. Вокал - потрясающей. А также видео, которое отлично подходить и гармонично меняется под произведение. Вместе создают завораживающую атмосферу, затягивающую и погружающую полностью в чувства. А чувства тут. Это как раз та композиция, которая отражает одиночества и переживания. Когда пытаешься согреться близостью, алкоголем, теплом очага. Но на душе лёд и по-прежнему заметает метель. Когда вокруг огромное множество разных людей, но ты как негодна одинок, а всё твоё окружение лишь безликие тени. И при это ты надеваешь маску, что у тебя всё хорошо и ты наслаждаешься жизнью. Но божечки, как же сложно себя обманывать. PS: Вот бы услышать это в живую. Вокал и инструментал. 3:01 - тут бы добавить слезинку Селестии. Она здесь определённа нужна.

[@haymakerpony]

This is fantastic. Catchy, well done song. Totally love it.

[@grayeaglej]

Do you want Daybreaker, because This is how you get Daybreaker. :(

[@NightmareMoon9964]

*_Season 10 Fuel_*

[@ohnibboi3102]

Well, I, for one, welcome our new Solar Empress

[@venus1333]

She's definitely going to return and probably fry everything in a solar flare.

[@ohnibboi3102]

@@venus1333 Definitive Daybreaker moment.

[@chrishill3536]

i do not know this will cause the daybreaker we know.

[@porraporracaralhobct]

"I don't know what I learned, I just want to go home" me at math class be like

[@derp-construction3341]

Reminds me of the fanfic "Celestia's Relaxing Vacation". A well written, but deeply disturbing story.

[@bruh3957]

I love this representation of putting yourself in someone else's shoes, keep up the good work!

[@kybee48]

Man . . . This song bops! I love the beat, and the way the singer sings the lyrics! But now that I look at the comments, I really haven't realized how sad this song is (besides the idea of Celestia learning what she really did to Luna by banishing her to the moon for so long). I applaud you for the idea and concept!

[@marcoslievano5716]

Yet again you have done it, I love your content so much to the point that I click on any video that reads 4everfreebrony! Can someone give this man a Grammy already???

[@kircie5768]

despite the happy tune, I actually cried, like I cried during Lullaby for a Princess

[@Crimson-1]

Как же шикарно, переслушиваю и не могу остановиться...

[@Doc_M4rt1n]

Аналогично. Хотя эту песню я открыл для себя недавно. Я вообще многие песни от 4everfreebrony только недавно смог оценить, раньше уровень понимания английского не позволял.

[@Crimson-1]

@@Doc_M4rt1n Я тоже открыл её не давно, 12 дней назад если быть конкретнее

[@Doc_M4rt1n]

@@Crimson-1 я где-то месяц назад.

[@serenafucito]

It came out 7 months (now) and I've just discovered it. 🥺 It's really cute!! 🥰 I thought it was just a Celestia's funny song, but then I saw “lonely saxophone noises”... well, something unexpected. Funny music with a sad hidden meaning. You're very good!! 👏🏻❤️

[@КостяРуссков]

Голос подобран просто замечательно Мне кажется, что Селестия должна звучать именно так И идея тоже хорошая, что-то новенькое

[@honest6584]

У вокалистки есть канал который она когда-то вела от лица Селестии)

[@Lunamanka]

@@honest6584 Интересно

[@bquncy550]

It's criminal how good this song is (I've re-listened over, and over, and over again). Seeing as I've been in a Twilight 2.0-and-Changeling-anarchy mood, respectively, I'm just stuck thinking "how far could this song be stretched, to mean exactly the same, but for different reasons for different characters?". Either way, this song is _awesome._ Absolutely _awesome._

[@mkssa94]

Wow! I usually listen to the song until the end, and only then like it, but in this case I clicked the like button 10 seconds after the start! Cool music, exciting lyrics and great vocal! Reminds me of "Here on the moon" which I adore, that's awesome! Great job as always! P. S. And yes, I forgot, artwork is awesome!

[@Starlight_post_22]

Mi cancion favorita del fandom, esta muy goooood ❤❤❤

[@meezothecrow]

Everyone: Sad 😔😔😔 Me: Cute art! *likes casually*

[@bingolinging]

I just realized you never really think about how long 100 years is itself People live to one hundred but thinking about that still feels like it's not long enough.

[@Ald4r]

Such a unique art style, I love it! ...and ya know this song is like a freaking banger too 👀

[@zeroinfinit7459]

Beautiful song!

[@SkydreamsArts]

Why you gotta make me cry like this man

[@Plume-Knifehorn]

Блин, люди, вот как вы это делаете? Песня прям за душу берёт, хочется переслушивать, но это так сердечно, что я просто теряюсь и НЕ МОГУ. Тянет под ложечкой.

[@user-zn3st7ko1t]

this song is like when it's late and the *tired sleepy depressed* phase is over and now it's *full of "energy" restless tired depressed*. i am absolutely vibing with the cheery music and the saddening lyrics

[@carmelaisabelleok6073]

It took me a minute to realize thats she’s on the moon while nightmare moon is still trapped

[@ReesesBees]

No? Celestia is the one trapped in/on the moon. Luna's back in Equestria.

[@icecreamcake5329]

IVE NEVER HEARD THIS UNTIL NOW AND I LOVE IT!!!

[@TheGielnik]

I love the music, and the art, and the singing! Everybody did amazing.

[@chyren_ran]

This is such a good song I love it!!! It being in this happy tune and ahhhhh it is soo beautiful. Giving Celestia's perspective on being on the moon. How you come up with and make these beautiful songs is beyond me

[@heatherrockwell9012]

I assume this is set in a hypothetical like the Nightmare Moon reality Starlight inadvertently created. This is one of your catchiest works while also being delightfully sad; I love it

[@fakefaker2894]

I know this kind of music has a specific genre but I can remember what it’s called.

[@4everfreebrony]

"Deceptively Happy Tune With a Depressing Message"?

[@BorkBorkBorkBorkBorkBorkBork]

Lyrical dissonance

[@CalamityVirus]

"Sister, what art thee doing?" "I've been stuck here for a thousand years! I've gone mad! Help me Luna!" "Sister... T hast been two hours.." Edited -think it's more accurate now lol

[@4everfreebrony]

Just for future reference: The old "st" only goes on the end of verbs in present tense, with the exception of "didst" instead of "did" and "art" instead of "are". There is actually a formula to it.

[@CalamityVirus]

@@4everfreebrony I'll never get the hang of it XD but omg you replied

[@daspacepony]

Pink Side of the Moon but it's Celestia

[@skyarrow4583]

ha! I thought the same thing

[@NightmareMoon9964]

_I can feel next album coming..._ And I would buy it.

[@aaronlindsey2219]

I love how inclusive you are in projects like these. It seems like you have a lot of fun!

[@GoldenSpark02]

Sad songs with a deceptively happy tunes needs to be a category or an entire album there always especially amazing, even more so when it's by 4everfreebrony!

[@Ronin20181]

man this is so bloody catchy and fun to listen to, amazing job mate!

[@theartistsan2375]

*ok but why is this such a banger-*

[@ijones36]

cant belive i've slept on this song for a month

[@riverbabbles]

What the heck why is this so happy sounding and catchy yet so sad XD;;; I LOVE the tune, even though I disagree with the message "it's a wonder why I sent her here for so long" - the elements sent her there and Celestia didn't have any way to get her back. But I know, this is going by a different interpretation.

[@johnweber4504]

I’m addicted... halp.

[@filipprecords9446]

it's so beautiful, especially the voice of the singing ponies

[@stanleystrycharz2572]

Yet another awesome and upbeat song with sad lyrics. I really enjoy this music. It reminds me of all the fun and friends in the DA pony club!!

[@Knight_Of_The_Blood_Moon]

I seem to be infected with an earworm. This song is on repeat in my head :P

[@steel-dragon4783]

Celestia seems to be the only disliker lol

[@johntousseau9380]

This song is fire! Loved seeing it live too!

[@samjohnson1813]

Comerades of the Lunar Republic, we have succeeded exiling Celestia for her crimes against ponymanity.

[@可啊啊]

This is so good！ Remains me of my favorite song Here On The Moon!

[@NoName-fj3pi]

can i go back to when i was DEEP into this fandom? i 'left' like 7 years ago but i still feel connected to it.

[@skyarrow4583]

The art is adorable is the song is lovely.

[@ghjjhhddf5990]

2:50 these noises remind me of old spase-theme movies and cartoons I've watched when was younger. Most of them show us beautiful future without any problems here on the Earth, and the brave people, who solve problems of galaxy, bring peace to other worlds instead of live in peace here

[@Makakaka]

can i animate dis-

[@sawyerkettler3783]

oh my goooodness yes hopefully you get permission that would be epic

[@lightgoddess666]

I thought this was going to be a happy song from those first few verses-and by the end I realized I was very wrong at first. Still really love it though, has to be one of my favorites instrumental and vocal-wise!

[@twinet5893]

Bro I'm actually tearing up in the club rn

[@ohnibboi3102]

If she goes insane like Nightmare Moon and there's a chance of her coming back, then whoever sent her there is not gonna have a good time in a thousand years when Celestia, or, rather, whatever she has become, comes back

[@michilunyn278]

This song just gives me so much nostalagia

[@sawyerkettler3783]

yeah in a weird way it's just been around long enough to start giving me nostalgia which s weird

[@albertoftasmania]

@@sawyerkettler3783 It's only been around for two years.

[@Gravy_Goat_55]

Honestly this is my favourite mlp song. I love the art and the music so much!

[@wyvernscale9634]

Im not familiar with mlp at all but this song makes me feel so many things 😭 Also is incredibly inspiring for my own writing

[@BlurredTheLines]

This song is easily at the top of the list of my favorite songs from Eclipse. So good.

[@kaazledazzle6891]

i sometimes try to put myself in luna’s perspective just for the hell of it. 1000 years is just.. wow one year is already so long but a thousand years on a rock alone and cold and then being put into a time period u know nothing about and having to adjust it’s a wonder how luna didn’t go insane in MLP