$500 For This Magic The Gathering Commander Players Collection - Was it Worth It? YES

[@tls5871]

8:09 thopter foundry foil 8:26 time sieve 31:18 that might have been a TSR stinkweed imp, with a timeshifted gray merchant a little after 31:30 night's whisper 33:40 quicksilver amulet and hex parasite 33:47 mirari 36:00 the urza lands, maybe $2 36:05 looks like wurmcoil engine tokens? 36:55 mikokoro center of the sea 42:55 borderless lightning bolt

[@BuddyJackstraw]

Hey now! Nice playable stuff. Good video. That survival is MP at minimum all day! Goblin recruiter is about $7 at 30:22

[@MattcasterMage]

Hell yeah!

[@klaxbloom7613]

@@MattcasterMage Hey there Matt! I have been a fan forever and watching your videos actually convinced me to buy someones collection rather similar to this. I have one question for you though, what do you use to price the cards? And is it individually? Ive been using DragonSheilds App on my phone but its glitchy and slow especially when going through roughly 10k cards. Thanks for the videos!

[@jben6]

That white stack starting at 27:17 - Beacon of Immortality, Loxodon Gatekeeper, Gift of Immortality, Winds of Abandon, Lightmine Field, Aura of Silence, Stonehewer Giant; Red starting at 29:11 - Glint Horn Buccaneer, Reiterate, lots of good stuff.

[@jben6]

Heartbeat of Spring at 15:14 is $2-$4. So is Bane of Progress at 16:42. Sage of Hours at 17:28 is almost $4. Paradox Haze at 17:29 is close to $6. So is Awakening at 17:17. Tunnel Vision at 20:03 is $2ish. Teferis Ageless Insight at 20:52 is $3-4.

[@Duskid]

at 6:00 looks like a species specialist

[@rogerballoujr.6244]

You missed the Gigantosaurus foil at 15:43 which is worth well over 2 bucks. Archmage Ascension at 18:41 is worth a little over 2 bucks. Kiora, the Crashing Wave at 24:22 is worth a little over 2 bucks. Kiora, Master of the Depths at 38:54 is worth a little over $2. If I am being honest it is hard to spot stuff because you are running through the cards so fast and oft times not showing them fully which makes it difficult to see what the set is on some of them.

[@allancook5235]

I agree with the comment this is a great deal for someone just starting out or wanting to resell. I would not pay $500 for a thousand dollars worth of cards that I’m not interested in. Space is limited!

[@vgorgon]

I know I saw a paradox haze 17:29 crashing footfalls 17:10, bane of progress 16:42, wishclaw talisman 14:56, rapid hybridization 13:45, time sieve 8:26, red elemental blast 8:58, luminous broodmoth 9:25, and a brain freeze at 3:45

[@christopherwismann6305]

Winds of change and gift of immortality around 27:30 are worth around $2-4

[@horridfuture3835]

I sold my collection back in 2017. I had to move and had very limited luggage space. I had to move the product fast. Strong decks,plenty of foil mythics and planeswalkers back when they were valuable, multiple kaladesh masterpieces, etc. I didn’t sell singles or anything before just my straight up collection. Total $265 plus tax and shipping. I would love to find a video somewhere of someone opening my collection and going crazy.

[@herbhaley5895]

What are the going rate for 800 ct boxes? I'm selling 40 boxes of commons and 13 boxes of uncommons for $200 USD to a buyer this weekend. Did I charge too much? As far as was the collection worth it? I'd be happy buying it, at least until my wife asked how much I spent. lol

[@coachesmagic2886]

I’d say 10$ per common box and 20$ per uncommon box. About 1000 mtg cards fit in an 800 count box, so that’s only one cent per common and 2 cents per uncommon. I think it’s a tad low at 200$. Buying 53 boxes should be a discount, but not that much. You are at 400$ for the commons and 260$ for the uncommons for a 660$ total. I would have thought 400$ would have been a better deal for you

[@herbhaley5895]

It's come to a point that after buying and buying for a couple decades that my common and uncommon cards have become too big to manage in a little closet. I just picked a price that I hoped would get them out of here. I only received three replies and the first two wanted to talk me down in price. The third person is supposed to drive here this weekend and buy them.

[@coachesmagic2886]

@@herbhaley5895it’s not that bad honestly to move them quickly. If you pieced them out in groups of 5 or 10 you get more, but it’s more risks and pains in the butt. I may have done the same thing just for ease. I don’t blame you one bit; it opens the door for you to collect easier with all that bulk out of the way

[@IndianaDave]

Did you get a final count on the price? Or did I miss it skimming through?

[@MattcasterMage]

Should be at the end. But if I include all the cards I miss I know it was well over $1000.

[@ChickenMcThiccken]

oh absolutely. if your friend who bought this ; wants to sit and catalogue everything. yeah; he will easily have more than 1000. but is easily 4 hours worth of work lol@@MattcasterMage

[@MTG_CMG]

Definitely one of the better collections you've went through. So many playables! Enjoyed this one a lot.

[@MattcasterMage]

Glad you enjoyed!

[@kensey007]

Seems like a pretty smart way to sell bulk -- adding one nice card to it like the Survival here to draw in the gamblers.

[@jben6]

Ponder at 2:30-40 mark. Depending on printing is a couple bucks.

[@squalami2]

@3:45 it looks like there is a brain freeze at the end of that stack which is ~$8

[@squalami2]

@8:26 there is a time sieve which is ~$4

[@squalami2]

@14:57 there is a wishclaw talisman which is ~$3

[@bgmephisto]

He’s just a professional full time magic content creator who tracks card prices for daily videos! How’s he to supposed to know what all these things are worth!?

[@fattymcfatterson9977]

Original printing even.

[@ivana.3162]

He did say if he missed anything let him know. I think that’s what squalami is doing

[@jben6]

Red Elemental Blast at 8:58 is up to $6 for some printings.

[@gangreeen]

@28:27 Pristmatic Strands is $2.16

[@mtgpullz]

At 9:24 you missed at luminous broodmoth worth about $9-10

[@UntarWow]

Interested in buying my collection? I live in Edmonton so close enough. 50k+ from ice age era to 2017ish. Never sold a care so all chase rares I got are still there including at least 1 grim monolith.

[@MattcasterMage]

Possibly! Shoot me an email [e-mail]

[@Treefiddy87]

Bontu's monument is an uncommon going for $6.

[@MTGAttitude]

Loved watching this bro

[@MattcasterMage]

Thank you

[@jonlamoreaux2228]

8:26 looks like time sieve which is 5 dollars american

[@peytonboyle1476]

40:45 wandering archaic is ~$6

[@gangreeen]

@27:58 Felidar Umbra is about $2.50

[@7Alberto7]

This is awesome! These video are my sauce! Congrats to your friend! Big score!

[@robertsweeney7040]

snow lands - those are nice

[@marknicklason]

Peer into the abyss [multiples], thespian stage, foil ichor wellspring. all in like...the 30-36 minute section. there was a gobln recruiter in the goblin section. Just a few i noticed, howeever i watched the first 30 min while in bed with glasses off mostly so im sure i missed many more. Strongly advise for these things to pull all the foils out. mikokoro in teh colorless comm deck. teferi ageless insight 3808. strixhaven brainstorm at 4008. reshape 4105. fabricate + dovin veto 4110 basalt monolith 4115 privileged position 4143 mana geyser 4225 pyretic rit 4239 Many more i assume!! sweet buy.

[@SephirothRevived]

Im happy for your friend but I wish that this was your find. I know you've been struggling to make ends meet and it would be cool for you to find a collection like this. Thanks for the video.

[@MattcasterMage]

I hope soon! But happy for my friend, Jordan

[@vgorgon]

Trickbind 18:06

[@moonbear841]

3:27 Rhox Faithmender is about 5 dollars or more

[@jben6]

Dire Undercurrents at 8:19 is pushing $10 until it gets reprinted. It is funny with Cavern Harpy.

[@coachesmagic2886]

Nice little pick up for your friend! Hope everything is going well Mattcaster Mage MTG and Mrs. Veronica Mage too. I’m still waiting for a baby mage show up 😊…

[@SaintAnthonny]

You missed intuition at @21:03 which is a 100$ card

[@salrusso8768]

Hope all is well. Pretty sure Counterspell Mystical Archives is worth a couple of bucks, Arcane Denial, Pongify, Misdirection, Crystal Spray, War Room, Spellstutter sprite, mirrodin artifact lands...

[@SaoriAmz]

Command Tower and Reliquary Tower near start, over $2? - Reliquary tower in UK is about £3-4.

[@vgorgon]

Teferi's ageless insight 38:02

[@alexssain]

500 is very good deal for this. Almost unbelievable

[@110019a]

you should add the amount of how much the cards are as the video is going

[@timtauber5557]

A running tally would be great.

[@luceeva7]

38:58 Thada adel is worth a good 15$ 😊

[@brokingm]

5:15 Bontu’s Monument

[@captnjohnnyhollows]

Id be intrested in the sleeves if shipping is an option

[@7Alberto7]

Almost forgot! My fav format is 2HG,just too much fun!

[@EastonSavage]

42:39 Electrostatic Field is worth $4

[@jonlamoreaux2228]

9:24 luminous broodmoth is like 9 dollars american

[@BKwakman]

Around 22 mins I saw a Pir Imaginative Rascal, worth a pretty penny

[@catkingtm8779]

sphinx's tutelage is probably worth a bit and in there too

[@TheSpiritombsableye]

21:41 Lathliss!

[@michaelnovak3417]

Recently I've been considering selling my collection. Except for my legacy deck. It would be nice to have a bit of money for when the detective conan tcg comes out.

[@venerac2759]

At 7:57 you passed a God Eternal Rhonas which is like $5.

[@venerac2759]

8:25 Time Sieve also around $5

[@venerac2759]

11:50 next to the Survival of the Fittest is Underrealm Lich which is $6-$8

[@venerac2759]

13:37 Pongify $4- $6

[@MattcasterMage]

Yes!! Thank you

[@vgorgon]

Nezahal, primal tide 40:05

[@davidgray6852]

Starnheim Unleashed is about a 4$ card its at time 28:29

[@akumu2625]

8:24 time sieve around 6 bucks

[@francoistestard2407]

Nice collection you bought Matt 🎉

[@timdial5720]

You should look through some of those cards again. I seen a lot that are over $2

[@jben6]

Rhox Faithmender at 3:27 is $6-8.

[@natepetras6143]

Isn’t the brain freeze around like $6 at roughly 3:50?

[@EastonSavage]

26:10 that island is worth around $3

[@vgorgon]

Glint-horn bucaneer 29:09

[@richardaniballi1624]

Farseek in the meren decks like 3, rites of replication a few

[@richardaniballi1624]

You also missed pongify

[@drew941]

Looked like the remnants of a TnT turbo druid cedh list and an animar list. This person probably sold a lot of expensive stuff prior to this bulk.

[@PokePelago]

You missed a forbidden orchard behind a noxious revival

[@Pixel165]

The amount of 5 dollar cards youve missed is unreal. And as you said the amount of playable edh cards is unbelievable, its almost guaranteed the guy only bought singles.

[@sbabenco]

luminous broodmoth is a 10 dollar card spoted it within the first few stacks

[@kennethbirchler6883]

Paradox Haze, luminous broodmoth among many others probably 200 in value missed because you go so fast

[@Sandro_St]

Awesome haul!!!

[@jben6]

Time Sieve at 8:26 is $5-$7.

[@luceeva7]

41:30 legion landing 5$

[@vgorgon]

Ophidian eye 20:03

[@NateBullock-ow6on]

I wish they would have kept the ulamogs in there but oh well

[@jarodhines6544]

Dude definitely yes great buy

[@shannonwatson8023]

Well worth the $500 for sure!!

[@masonkitchen366]

2:07 Approach of the second son is 2.54

[@vgorgon]

Goblin recruiter 30:23

[@Kuz929]

Brainfreeze at the end of the stack at 3:45 ... worth like $12

[@Gussyboii]

Vodalian Hexcatcher in the 2nd lot of decks

[@Slim3398]

Dude took all the good cards out and left the sleeves.

[@alexssain]

What you talking about? Dude sold his collection for less than half of the price

[@jben6]

Arcane Denial at 12:57 is about $4.

[@latneyporter6170]

So many cards missed lol all good though, love the videos Matt.

[@SaintAnthonny]

Misdirection at @13:39

[@vgorgon]

Cytoplast manipulator 26:35

[@someguy4331]

i wish i had fb marketplace finds like that lol

[@gazzburg5017]

I think I saw a couple of arcane adaptations that's a $3 card

[@PokePelago]

You missed red elemental blast

[@invisiblediscos9412]

8:01 God eternal rhonas is $5

[@TheThoughtDonor]

That's a nice buy.

[@ep1phany62]

I did start a channel to do random buy openings, but my laptop ran out of memory. I still have a couple of unopened random buys, from before ‘the scouring’ (the period we are going through now where most magic lots are completely scoured of value). I hope to get round to going through them one day. The unicorn buys must be out there somewhere😊

[@HSSG7]

If you are someone who doesn't mind the grind of flipping the stuff $5 or less, then this collection would be goid for you. If you are one who prefers to focus on a collection that has tons of $5+ cards, this probably isn't gonna be one for you Overall though, this would be a half decent collection for the point. I say half decent cause you probably won't double your money. But if you grind it out, you' ll do ok

[@Pottering12]

Great value

[@vgorgon]

Fabricate 41:06

[@timtauber5557]

Commander all the way. Cedh preferably.

[@lostingreenbay]

Gross. Cedh is trash

[@jamesmick-zy4ip]

What does that even mean? Commander and cedh are the same thing?

[@greganglin2143]

Cedh is where try hards take a fun casual format and make it a turn 1-3 format. Most of the time, the decks are net decked and are a glass cannon.​ I say of you want to play a competitive game play a 60 card format. @jamesmick-zy4ip

[@Alsifnrbdvehrj]

@@jamesmick-zy4ipI think the c mean competitive

[@Dragracingduleist]

Commander is just mtg for baddies

[@der_magische_Investor]

Awesome Video :) I also like to buy collections and show them on my channel. It's a lot of fun.

[@davestier6247]

First. For that algyriddim

[@MattcasterMage]

🙌🏆

[@Kinverted]

Bontu’s monument is ~6$

[@WestCoastbro91]

Approaching the second sons, like five dollars

[@jeffnorris211]

Species specialist is one you went passed that’s about 10$

[@TacomaTacos]

“A lot of the value has crashed” … yes … yes it has ….

[@vgorgon]

Solve the equation 39:50

[@channel-7848]

Sweet now I know my collection is worth about $800

[@stevenlorenzo6540]

Whomever sold that collection for only 500$ was on some serious crack.