57 Drugstore & Luxury MASCARAS TESTED - Long Thick Lashes Fast 2024

WELCOME TO MY 5th ANNUAL MASCARA ROUND UP! In the past year I tested over 57 MASCARAS. This video is an in depth review of drugstore mascara, luxury mascara & high end mascaras. Many of these are new mascara releases. Come see what is the best mascara at the drugstore, lengthening mascara, volumizing mascara, mascara that won't smudge or flake, & mascara that holds a curl. We want it all right? If you enjoy the video please subscribe!
/ mrsmelissam
*My Amazon Storefront amzn.to/2AhOI3t
When you shop on my Amazon page I get a small commission.
*Try & Subscribe To Amazon Prime Here Free For 30 Days amzn.to/3c3TzuB
*Sign up for Rakuten & get $30 back after your first order. When you sign up I get a small commission.
www.rakuten.com/r/MMULDE12?ee...
Contact or PR [e-mail]
/ melissa.mulder.528
/ mrsmelissam1
/ mrsmelissam1
*What I'm Wearing
Mint Green Spring Sweater
amzn.to/3U7xizE
Turquoise Earrings
amzn.to/3VTxwvo
Blue Ring amzn.to/3JhBlTv
Multi Blue Ring
amzn.to/3JdoW3g
Gold Dainty Chain
amzn.to/3Qia8nZ
Press On Nails
amzn.to/3Jcc51a
(see below for makeup worn)
*Mascaras Tested * Liked:
Estee Lauder Little Black Primer Mascara
amzn.to/3xpASw1
howl.me/cl0jel23BJO
Tubing Mascaras
Caliray howl.me/cl0jdUs5rUj
Milani Highly Rated Mascara
amzn.to/3PTOgid
Thrive Tubing Mascara
go.magik.ly/ml/1wy7g/
ELF Lash Extender
go.magik.ly/ml/1z12f/
Tarte Tartelette Tubing
amzn.to/3xv41Gf
Tarte Tartelette XL Tubing
howl.me/cl0jhKpa6vJ
Runners Up/Really Great!
Milk Touch All Day Long Lift & Curl
amzn.to/3PU3FPC
Essence Lash Princess Waterproof
amzn.to/4atmQYU
Milk Makeup Rise Mascara
howl.me/cl0jj7lmKC0
ELF Lash It Loud
amzn.to/4aOyZHt
Ilia Limitless Mascara
howl.me/cl0jlCYiFxa
L'oreal Lash Paradise
amzn.to/3xAHYxE
CREAM OF THE CROP:
Smashbox Super Fan
howl.me/cl0jm19cWdz
Covergirl Stretch & Strengthen Exhibitionist Mascara
amzn.to/4aMDbYA
Maybelline Falsies Lash Lift
amzn.to/3xtQMFM
L'Oreal Telescopic Lift Waterproof
amzn.to/3TORG7d
ELF Lash & Roll
amzn.to/3vGmEGF
Lancome Teint Idole Mascara
amzn.to/3Jbb0qj
Benefit They're Real Mascara
howl.me/cl0jr2nUUNb
Maybelline Sky High
amzn.to/3JatiYJ
L'Oreal Panorama Mascara
amzn.to/3TNzBq9
*Makeup
L'oreal Infallible Fresh Wear in Rose Vanilla
amzn.to/3vIxyM4
Tower 28 Concealer in 7.0 KTown
howl.me/cl0kVL3rOdT
Focallure Blush/Contour/Highlight palette #08
amzn.to/3VQ695i
Lamora Nude Neutral Palette
amzn.to/3TQuOEj
One Size lip Liner in Outta Line
howl.me/cl0kzmCBIkQ
Sephora Outrageous Lip Gloss In Starstruck Pink
howl.me/cl0kAIGxsdR
*The items listed above are accompanied by affiliate links, meaning I earn a small commission if a purchase is made through my links. This has no impact on the cost to you, the consumer. I link to products this way whenever possible, and it has no bearing on the products I choose to review or recommend because all products can have links attached to them, no matter what they are. I would link the products on Ulta/Sephora/etc website anyway as a means of connecting you to the products, so now it simply offers the potential for a small financial benefit to me, which I greatly appreciate. Feel free to use, or not use, the links provided. And if you decide to use them, thank you so much! Also, if you would like to help a little more, when watching one of my videos please watch it all the way through, that helps to show the YT algorithm that people are interested in my video. If you have time, watch one or two of the ads shown with the video, that's the only way KZbinrs get paid at all, if people watch the ads. So if you have a favorite KZbinr, you now know how you can support them with these little tips. #bestdrugstoremascara
#bestluxurymascara #makeupover50

[@MrsMelissaM]

*What I'm Wearing Mint Green Spring Sweater amzn.to/3U7xizE Turquoise Earrings amzn.to/3VTxwvo Blue Ring amzn.to/3JhBlTv Multi Blue Ring amzn.to/3JdoW3g Gold Dainty Chain amzn.to/3Qia8nZ Press On Nails amzn.to/3Jcc51a (see below for makeup worn) *Mascaras Tested * Liked: Estee Lauder Little Black Primer Mascara amzn.to/3xpASw1 howl.me/cl0jel23BJO Tubing Mascaras Caliray howl.me/cl0jdUs5rUj Milani Highly Rated Mascara amzn.to/3PTOgid Thrive Tubing Mascara go.magik.ly/ml/1wy7g/ ELF Lash Extender go.magik.ly/ml/1z12f/ Tarte Tartelette Tubing amzn.to/3xv41Gf Tarte Tartelette XL Tubing howl.me/cl0jhKpa6vJ Runners Up/Really Great! Milk Touch All Day Long Lift & Curl amzn.to/3PU3FPC Essence Lash Princess Waterproof amzn.to/4atmQYU Milk Makeup Rise Mascara howl.me/cl0jj7lmKC0 ELF Lash It Loud amzn.to/4aOyZHt Ilia Limitless Mascara howl.me/cl0jlCYiFxa L'oreal Lash Paradise amzn.to/3xAHYxE CREAM OF THE CROP: Smashbox Super Fan howl.me/cl0jm19cWdz Covergirl Stretch & Strengthen Exhibitionist Mascara amzn.to/4aMDbYA Maybelline Falsies Lash Lift amzn.to/3xtQMFM L'Oreal Telescopic Lift Waterproof amzn.to/3TORG7d ELF Lash & Roll amzn.to/3vGmEGF Lancome Teint Idole Mascara amzn.to/3Jbb0qj Benefit They're Real Mascara howl.me/cl0jr2nUUNb Maybelline Sky High amzn.to/3JatiYJ L'Oreal Panorama Mascara amzn.to/3TNzBq9 *Makeup L'oreal Infallible Fresh Wear in Rose Vanilla amzn.to/3vIxyM4 Tower 28 Concealer in 7.0 KTown howl.me/cl0kVL3rOdT Focallure Blush/Contour/Highlight palette #08 amzn.to/3VQ695i Lamora Nude Neutral Palette amzn.to/3TQuOEj One Size lip Liner in Outta Line howl.me/cl0kzmCBIkQ Sephora Outrageous Lip Gloss In Starstruck Pink howl.me/cl0kAIGxsdR *The items listed above are accompanied by affiliate links, meaning I earn a small commission if a purchase is made through my links

[@tamic4555]

I combine the Sky High and the Panorama mascara. I went to a women's retreat this past weekend with my church and there was a lot of laughing and crying and tears and I just knew I had lost all of my makeup. When I got back to my room that evening, my eyes were red and puffy, my eye liner was gone but my mascara still looked great lol💖

[@MrsMelissaM]

Oh wow! That's a great endorsement! I'm gonna try for sure!

[@pajamamama5965]

This is incredible! I look forward to this video every year. My favorite part is that you include old favorites and then you put them in the rankings. There's so many mascaras out there, it can be overwhelming trying to find a favorite.

[@jennifermolina4396]

I combine the Thrive Lash Extensions mascara with the L'oreal Lash Paradise. My lashes are on pointe with that combination. I adore mascaras. L'oreal does it right with mascaras.

[@anncollard1742]

I love Thrive but intrigued. Which do you put on first? Would think thrive first?

[@sherrypettit5552]

I am 53. I have been wearing makeup since I was 12. I'm still looking for my HG mascara

[@cindywhite1112]

I use the Morphe blue primer, and boy does it make your eyelashes pop! The blue background just makes the black even blacker! Plus it's so easy to swipe any mascara over it without clumping or tugging.

[@jenniferlyons4150]

😊I work in the fire service (I'm not a firefighter) but I work out in the field 50% of the time. I use the Panorama mascara by L'Oreal in waterproof and it's a solid mascara. I inadvertently rub my eyes as the days get longer and it's still there when I get home! It takes a little bit more effort to remove but I wear it for 12 hours. 😊

[@cath3rine9]

Mascara is my favorite makeup product!!! I love when you do these roundups!! ❤

[@MrsMelissaM]

I'm so glad you liked it ☺️

[@latherandlace]

Whew! What a ton of mascaras! I'm a Thrive or Caliray girl and dont need any other, anymore! Thank you for trying so many!!!!! XO ~lori

[@MrsMelissaM]

I love that you found your holy grail Lori!

[@amyrobinson928]

I needed this!! Thank you!

[@MrsMelissaM]

You're so welcome!

[@jillpotts7472]

love your videos! i wish that the models displaying the shirts you are wearing were normal size. that is now how the shirt will look on me. and my BMI is within healthy limits. but those models are skinny. anything would look good on them. thanks for your honest reviews!!!

[@MrsMelissaM]

Very true!

[@shannonwhite7605]

It's taken me almost 56 years to find a sunscreen that I can use because of my sensitive, allergy eyes!!🙄 but, I found one... now if I could just find a mascara that gives volume & not irritate my eyes I'd be doing great!! LOVE YOUR VIDEO Shug!! And I love you!!🥰❤️💄💋😘 You're always making the world beautiful!!💜🫶🏼🌎🫶🏼💜

[@MrsMelissaM]

Thank you darling girl! 😘

[@katrinat.3032]

Same here it took me till my 40s to realize that the redness on my face was caused by chemical sunscreen. I still haven’t found a mascara that I can wear for more than two hours.

[@shannonwhite7605]

@@katrinat.3032 Same!🤷🏼‍♀️

[@Debra_Barron]

What is the name of the sunscreen that works for you?

[@Debra_Barron]

Thank you Melissa for sharing how those mascaras perform. 📫💗

[@pamelamcdonald9603]

Thanks Melissa! You are a blessing!!!

[@MrsMelissaM]

You're so sweet! Thanks for watching Pamela

[@kb-pn4cu]

Thanks for your great opinions. Loved the video!

[@MrsMelissaM]

So glad to hear that 😊

[@surpriseitsus9622]

My holy grail is by Clinique, in the green bottle.

[@heidispringer3931]

Thank you sweet Melissa you are so helpful❤

[@MrsMelissaM]

You're so very welcome Heidi!

[@cmeyummy]

You are one committed lady! Thank you Melissa.

[@MrsMelissaM]

My pleasure!

[@Lhogchristmas]

❤ excellent totally subscribed 😊thank you

[@colleenh]

I’ve been waiting for this video! Thank you for taking the time to put it together .

[@MrsMelissaM]

You are so welcome!

[@kelliashy7500]

I so enjoyed your video! I needed this as I am looking to try a new mascara. You are so helpful and appreciated. Thank you!!!!

[@MrsMelissaM]

Always my pleasure Kelli

[@trishabee2229]

Whew! Very nice! I’m going to try the elf! Thank you for the recommendation you are awesome

[@MrsMelissaM]

I think you'll really like it Trisha

[@katieharris7219]

Did you know that The Little Black primer can also be used *after* mascara application to keep it from smudging and/ or flaking??!!! It is amazing stuff! Also, the difference in the Tarte tubing mascaras is that the new one (XL) actually removes like a tubing formula. Their original got lots of complaints because it didn't remove with just warm water. They fixed it with the XL release and now it does. ❤❤❤

[@Roadie247]

Love ya girl and thank you for all the awesome recommendations ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@gennyolson2257]

Wow! What a great video❤❤ I have maccara on my Sephora list and now I know which one to purchase. Thank you!❤❤

[@MrsMelissaM]

I'm so happy it was helpful Genny!😊

[@LKC4244]

I love this review. My favs are in your favs.

[@gladyskravitz3715]

What a fantastic video, Melissa! I'm so impressed that you can remember what mascara you have on in pictures!

[@MrsMelissaM]

A lot of them were my faves for a long time, and used in videos, so it was easier to remember.

[@LenaSheppard]

Whoa! Great job! Ilia smudges one me and milani straightened my curl. I got a gift of a mini monsieur big & love it but my fav is the original telescopic waterproof. You're still beautiful. Thank you for being here for me !

[@tiffanysadlertlc]

Wow! The picture of you wearing the number one mascara!!! Sorry you got sick but your lashes looked amazing and so do you!! Thanks for sharing

[@MrsMelissaM]

Thanks so much Tiffany

[@tianiortiz8529]

Thank you Miss Melissa, I truly appreciate you trying all of these and giving your thoughts 🙏🏼😘

[@MrsMelissaM]

You're so very welcome Tiani! 😊

[@Ari_Kle]

I totally agree with your top and bottom picks, so I'll try the other ones you like. I LOVE Benefit They're Real, and the Magnet version of it. x

[@glendagarcia6194]

Melissa thank you for the heavy lift you do on your videos. This was so informative and I may try a couple of new ones (new to me). Mascara is just sooo individual it’s like they’re screaming “I gotta me I gotta be me”! 😂 I don’t know about you but over years, a mascara can lose its effectiveness on my lashes 🤷🏻‍♀️. Kind of in that place now so your video came just in time! Thanks for all your hard work! I know it’s not all fun when stuff just ain’t working on you! Hugs 🤗 😊

[@kitcat102]

Loving your reviews! Totally agree with you about the L’Oréal panorama mascara. It’s really very good. I normally only use black mascara but the brown panorama is lovely and dark x

[@MrsMelissaM]

I need to try it!

[@MsTerri3081]

Great review Melissa!!❤ My favorite mascara is the panorama too!! It really does stay on all day..and I'm very picky with my mascaras cuz my eyes water from allergies 👍

[@LisaEdelmanTarot]

I found Lash Princess smudged horribly, but looks amazing. Sooooo, I use it under another mascara and it's fantastic. Lash Princess followed by any Maybelline and my lashes look so good.

[@MrsMelissaM]

Like a primermm great idea Lisa!

[@crucitasquillace5072]

Wow..what a review!! I love mascaras. For years I used Rimmel mascaras but not so easy to find. I used for the first time yesterday the Panaroma but I usually use a primer. Well…not a good idea. The mascara clumped. I tried it today without a primer today and it did better. The jury is still out on this one. Thinking of getting a tubing lately and I love your choices. Overall this review is appreciated and you look amazing! ❤

[@RavenNl403]

Wow that's a lot of mascaras Thank you ❤️

[@MrsMelissaM]

I felt like I'd run a marathon! Lol

[@deejohnson827]

I love your mascara reviews! I bought the Loreal Panoramic a couple months ago and also love it. So many mascaras have wands that are poky on my waterline and are uncomfortable. So glad I got the Panoramic! Thanks so much for all your hard work here. ❤

[@MrsMelissaM]

I'm so glad you enjoyed it Dee

[@lauracuevas8948]

Hi MrsMelissa! I purchased the L' Oreal Pamorama mascara today before watching your video. I was holding my breath, wondering if you would mention it in favor😂 I was so thankful at the very end, tada!🎉 😄 I'm wearing it today! Thank you. Your videos are so helpful to me ; for aging fun and gracefully!❤ I pray for you every day. Stay blessed 🥰

[@gladysgarrity5721]

Thanks Melissa ❤

[@MrsMelissaM]

You are so welcome!

[@loriunderwood3734]

WOW! So good to hear your opinion. I still love the Maybelline Sky High mascara. May have to give the last one a try. Thanks for trying all of those, so we don't have to.

[@MrsMelissaM]

My pleasure Lori😊

[@carolynbubrig9936]

Thank you so much ❤️

[@MrsMelissaM]

You’re welcome 😊

[@AmberEG]

So glad you posted this, I just went through all my mascara and got rid of most of it because of expiration dates.

[@MrsMelissaM]

I got to throw so many away after this video that I was holding on to because of waiting to film this. It was pretty satisfying I must say! 😁

[@louiseburda3014]

Love your channel. My top 3 mascaras. Superhero, lash princess green tube and L’Oréal voluminous

[@meckismicki]

Was looking for a new mascara & thanks to you I now know what to get❤

[@MrsMelissaM]

Awesome!

[@latherandlace]

I also love Lash Paradise False Lash Effects!!!!

[@heidimargaret306]

Hi Melissa, if I find my lashes are clumping together a use one of those tiny dental brushes, it grabs every lash, I find it works so well 😀tyfs sharing

[@b.b7305]

Thanks so much, I love mascara.

[@MrsMelissaM]

Me too!!

[@mamacita6500]

Wow!!!🎉🎉 Fantastic content and organization. Thank you Melissa. Appreciate all of your extensive efforts to educate us 🙏 God Bless you lovely friend🙏✝️💜

[@bridgettucker3692]

Hi Melissa !! Thank you for all your hard work and testing out all these mascaras for us . I love Tarte and Elf tubing mascara just so easy to wash off . M Sky high is amazing too . I need to try L’Oréal Pamorama now ❤🤗

[@MelissaPaul-gs2rp]

Definitely going to have to try some of these mascaras some of them. I know that I don’t like already that were in your top ones but some of them I’ve been wanting to try that was your number one like the L’Oreal I definitely want to try that one. Thank you for sharing.❤

[@MrsMelissaM]

My pleasure Melissa

[@elainewhitney1609]

Wow. Brilliant info on mascaras. Very impressive. I’m going to give the Benefit - their real mascara. Have a great week. Love from London. Xx

[@MrsMelissaM]

I hope you love it Elaine!

[@martistrachan6692]

Hi Melissa. I enjoy your roundup videos. I like using the Sky High primer before applying the Sky High mascara.

[@MrsMelissaM]

I need to try that one asap!

[@Debbie-Savings]

Hi beautiful friend! 😊 I really like knowing your opinion and trust what you say. I’m going to try the mascaras that you recommend and avoid the ones that flake and smudge. Thank you for always being so honest with us! ❤

[@melindaargintar2424]

Great review! That’s a lot of mascaras! My new favorite mascara is indeed the L’Oréal Panorama in waterproof! Hugs 💋

[@MrsMelissaM]

I need to try it. Love the regular version of it.

[@Alice-fr1ef]

I've always liked Maybelline Masacaras. You seem to pick the ones I would poick as good ones too Melissa. Thank you for a wonderful video with great content. We appreciate all of the work taken to put this one together. Great job. We love you too and be well.🥰❤💖💗💜💜💜🌹🥀🌸🌺💐

[@janeashton2027]

Hi Melissa, l love tubing mascara, yes l use Caliray mascara, and l bought a new one of Lancome mascara too, hugsssss ❤❤❤

[@cvonsutphen]

*Tubing Formula for Small Hooded eyes* . I prefer a tubing formula because my lashes are sparse and I don't want to do a lot of rubbing to remove it. My go-to is the Essence Bye-Bye Panda Eyes. I actually use two wands for application. I use the Wet-N-Wild mega length wand for the first coat then top off with the wand that comes with Essence. I tried the new Elf formula in brown and found it to be difficult to remove and it did flake on me. I never have those issues with the essence.

[@dianawalter1446]

I like a caliray , tower 28, maybelline sky high, thrive, and love lash princess. Love this video.❤❤❤❤

[@marlenekerrmarlene1259]

yes like the sky high too

[@leneskov5184]

Fantastic review - have you ever tried the Clarins Wonder Perfect 4 D - comes in brown too. I love it 😀

[@hmbnd2]

I agree on all those! And my absolute faves this year are : Panorama (I think I bought this based on one of your videos!) and also Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer Mascara in Bronze! I think that one may be flaking. I need to try it without the Essence Primer because it may be the primer causing it to flake. I may have to go purchase the Lash Princess in waterproof because the regular has me looking like a raccoon within an hour or two (thanks allergies). As always, excellent video!!

[@sandybell8841]

I fell in love with Clarins wonder perfect 4 D Mascara, never clumpy or crunchy, excellent formula for length and volume!

[@MrsMelissaM]

Ad another to my list! Thank you Sandy! 😊

[@TracyLeaBeauty]

Hi Melissa! That’s a lot of mascara!!! I keep mind longer than 3 months & mascara is on my no buy list! I can’t believe how many I have! You said you didn’t care for the KVD one, it’s a tubing mascara too! I just haven’t opened mine yet! The Elf extender & the Tarte one are two of my favorites too! Oh and Lash Princess! I have so many of the mascaras you tried out! None of my people use much makeup! Or they are one of the people who never change their products, they always buy the same products 🤷🏻‍♀️ Thanks for testing them all!!!😃

[@ering7530]

thank you, Melissa for your wonderful reviews, sense of humor and beauty. I actually really like the CT pushup mascara. i find sometimes that if a mascara is clumpy on me, i drop the (tightly sealed) tube into a cup of quite warm water, which (for me) seems to thin out the mascara, taking away some of the clumpiness

[@carriemyers5002]

Love the panarama thats my new favorite. i want to try that little black primer

[@MrsMelissaM]

I'm totally in love with "The Little Black Primer"

[@carriemyers5002]

@@MrsMelissaM I like that it's black

[@RitaVernoy]

Thanks to you I have been using the Sky High! I love it. Living in Paraguay it’s one of the few I can find here.😊 I’m looking for the Panarama but have not seen here yet.

[@shirleydilleshaw5289]

Wow that’s a lot of mascara. Thank you Melissa, I ordered the L’Oréal panarama. Amazon has it with discount cpn for $10.39 right now. Your lashes always look beautiful and I have to change when you have a new recommendation

[@MrsMelissaM]

Hope you like it!

[@jillpotts7472]

how do u remember everything! u r a genius 👩🏼‍🎓

[@MrsMelissaM]

I kept notes! Lol

[@katrinat.3032]

Teleprompters

[@MrsMelissaM]

​@@katrinat.3032 lol, I wish I could afford one or that I had the time & energy to go through all that

[@tammyherrera7262]

I like using the sky high then topping it with the milani tubing mascara. It’s amazing!

[@MrsMelissaM]

Thanks for that recommendation Tammy ❤

[@stephaniescofield9433]

I actually just tried the panoramic and I do like it. I love maybelline stiletto and have used it for many years. I actually use regular mascara on top of my primer and then waterproof on top. I feel like it holds better and comes off easily with a makeup remover wipe. I’m interested in trying the Elf. I’ve tried the benefit and don’t like it at all. Thanks so much for your time, Melissa! You take care🌻

[@TN_Whiskey68]

My go tos are L'Oreal primer & Buxom mascara. Have been using both for years. Have tried a lot of others and always go back to these 2.

[@MrsMelissaM]

Thanks for sharing those.

[@leisam8933]

Your video was great! Do you use a lash serum? If so what do you use. Your lashes are awesome!

[@opchick0597]

WOW girl, you do a very impressive job. Thank you. I absolutely hate a curved mascara brush. They just don't work for my lashes. My ride or die mascara is Lancome's Monsieur Big. It makes my lashes long and very thick, doesn't flake or smudge a bit. Perfection.

[@MrsMelissaM]

That's a great one too! 👌

[@shannonfinn4316]

Wow. That was impressive! I love Loreal Bambi Wide Open in the black tube but they discontinued it.

[@juliewilliams40]

I use Tartlette tubing mascara first and then Sky High on top of it. I always think that maybe it will come off a little better with the tubing mascara on the bottom. I love them both!! Thank you for your reviews. As always, love you and you're beautiful!!!

[@MrsMelissaM]

Great tip Julie. I love using 2 mascaras too!

[@kimberlyberger4362]

Loved these reviews! I use the Benefit They’re Real mascara topped with the L’Oreal Telescopic (in gold tube) to separate and add length. For me, it’s the perfect combination.

[@MrsMelissaM]

Thanks for sharing Kimberly 😁

[@beverlynelson599]

Hi Melissa, I hope u r feeling better. 😊

[@tinat232]

Wow, I bet that was a lot of work lol. Thanks!

[@sueellenb8353]

I used to LOVE Tarte Maneater Mascara but just recently I noticed I have raccoon eyes and it’s only about 5 or 6 hours later. I’m going to try the waterproof version. Thanks for this video Triple M!

[@suehembrook6956]

Wow lots of mascaras. I agree, some you like someone else doesn't. I tried Sky High, Exhibitionist, Lash Paradise, Telescopic, Benefit Their Real, Lash Paradise, Maybelline Falsies and didn't love any of them. I really like, right now Lancome Lash Idole and would consider your suggestion of Elf Lash & Roll to lower my cost. I also like Rare Beauty Mascara. I guess, it comes down to what works for our own lashes. I love this round up each year!

[@jeannineenos2758]

Omg, #1 for me is Essence!

[@kentuckywildcatfan5096]

I heard the reason for the 2nd tartelette mascara is because people were complaining that the original one didn’t remove like a normal tubing mascara.? I love the original, but it doesn’t come off like other tubing mascaras. I’ll try the new one sometime soon. Great job!! Thanks for sharing your experiences with these mascaras.

[@MrsMelissaM]

That makes sense. I wonder if they'll discontinue the original?

[@kentuckywildcatfan5096]

@@MrsMelissaM I don’t know. I haven’t heard anything about that.

[@zizzie4081]

Impressive effort! Your theory about natural bristles and volume is intriguing, I will test it. Lash Princess smudges horribly on me, and Lash out Loud makes my lashes look puny. I’m on my third tube of Lash and Roll. We’re all different!!

[@MrsMelissaM]

I definitely agree with that!

[@janeashton2027]

Hi Melissa, those ones you are showing l quite a few of them, and then the ones from Mac too, l picked up 4 new one from Sephora on Saturday, and I got a couple from Glossier, been trying them, so far good, the 1 from Sephora Size Up, they work good for now, hugsssss ❤❤❤

[@MrsMelissaM]

Thanks for sharing with us Jane ❤

[@user-im7tr9uj1q]

I have just tried Essence lash princess false lash effect! I admired my son’s mother-in-law’s thick lashes and asked what kind of mascara she was using! She bought me one. So far it goes on smoother and makes my lashes look thicker than the mascara I have been using!

[@traciefried1249]

I love your super detailed review! What's the name of the mascara with 2 wands built in one? Fyi I love the maybelline define a lash mascara, it's build able, lengthening and doesn't clump or smudge!

[@aadolan3347]

Love Elf lash outloud. Only tubing I've tried is Thrive. Mascara is the hardest for me to find a good one.

[@tiffanysadlertlc]

The Covergirl exhibitionist has been a favorite! ❤️

[@janeashton2027]

Hi Melissa, l need to try that last one, everyone one of my friends keep telling me to try this one, but l forget to pick that one up, hugsssss ❤❤❤

[@Pamela-B]

I’m just super happy about the brown mascara trend right now-being a fair skinned redhead, that’s all I wear. 🥳✨ I loved the Maybeline Falsies mascara formula so much but the darn brush is too big for my wimpy lashes. That mascara goes and goes for me. The waterproof Lash Princess didn’t work out for me unfortunately. It smudged/flaked on me & it dried out fast. Next on the docket is the Panorama. Wish me luck🤞

[@jillpotts7472]

i like the sky high and the princess lash mascara best... but i have not tried too many!

[@MusicLover-sb7mo]

You are right, we each have different experiences and preferences. I don’t like Ilia or Lancôme Tint Idole at all but love the original L’Oréal Telescopic. I too have naturally long lashes, and while they are a bit sparse, I am not looking for volume. I love how it separates and defines my lashes and makes them look like have more with a fluttery effect (not spidery). No clumping or flaking. Ilia and Lancôme are too wet, group my lashes together so I have to separate with a safety pin. Just like I did in High School, but my eyesight isn’t that great anymore, so it’s a high risk move! lol.

[@susanweaver3272]

I used the IT cosmetics superhero mascara for years but the last two tubes I bought were so clumpy I won’t buy anymore. I got the Tower 28 and have been fairly happy with it.

[@mariavotto6069]

Melissa! You are a rockstar for doing this!!!! The Lancome and Maybelline Sky High are my top two - the new L'Oreal is on my list. My only issue with Sky High is it's so hard for me to get off (and don't even use the Waterproof!) I use cleansing balm and then a regular cleanser after and STILL have leftover mascara from the Maybelline! What do you use to remove that one? xoxoxo

[@MrsMelissaM]

Hi Maria. I use those fluffy microfiber cloths with cleansing balm. If I don't use them, then I can't get most off either. amzn.to/3VYlctQ

[@reneeburich9497]

Thrive, the Tartelette tubing and the new Tartelette XL are the only ones for me.

[@MrsMelissaM]

I'm so glad you found the perfect ones for you Renee! 😊

[@RitaVernoy]

Thank you! How are you feeling?

[@buzzydeckert4743]

Oh man maneatter is my favorite mascra and I sweat bad and have never had issues of it running or smearing. Goes to tell you everyone’s body deals different with products. That’s what makes the world a wonderul place to live and we can all agree to disagree and be kind to all.

[@silvanalana6380]

Thank you!! I also love Loreal Panorama but I don't know how to get it of. With warm water it come down but I have it all over my eyes. How do you do it? 👋From Croatia. I follow you so many years. ❤

[@Bay6768]

I'm not having any luck with the ELF mascaras or the Essence Princess ones. I am currently trying the last mascaras you mentioned L'Oreal Panorama Mascara, Maybelline Sky High and so far not impressed with them either. Maybe I need to use a primer.

[@lorirapp8581]

The Panorama is my favorite right now. It’s good and I am thrilled that I also comes at least in a brown black shade. Back in the day, all of the drugstore mascaras came in some shade of brown. I don’t understand why it is that almost every brand of mascara only comes in black now. Black is way too harsh for me now that I’m 66 and it was too harsh for me back when I was 16. But at least when I was 16 I could find brown now it is nearly impossible. Even black brown or brown black is too dark for me but at least it’s doable compared to black!

[@mommared4456]

I also as I got older prefer a brown mascara.. black is just to harsh, same with eyeliner. I recently found a fantastic brown mascara that with a primer, it blows me away everyday I wear it. L’Oréal brown balm mascara . It’s part of their voluminous line. Rich deep true brown! Lashes long and separated and soft soft against my crows feet! Many compliments on my eyes and I think it’s bc no longer harsh with the heavy black. Hope this helps