6 of my Favorite Scary True Stories Through the Years

[@cgumby]

Story 5 is so unintentionally funny because it goes from "dude I'm really scared" to "let's go across the street with a sword" in an instant

[@NadiaSeesIt]

Lol exactly - dudes thinking they are samurai

[@elibonham4388]

It's insnaely scary to think that Marvin guy seemingly had something to do with the guy the window in the broken down house across the street and the loud banging footsteps.

[@Vampire_Bat-]

Even a gun would've made sense but that just leaves me confused considering the Kaatana part seemed like an oddly specific weapon choice

[@Vampire_Bat-]

Also I don't think Marvin had anything to do with it considering he was seen watching TV a little while. It's most likely he knew something that they didn't about that house.

[@Umbrakinesis207]

then goes right back to being scared

[@TrashManJackson]

I’m a trash truck driver and I work 5 days a week and I listen to him while I’m doing my routes and it helps it cause I never know what to expect from this guy! He’s helped me through so many many things

[@TheMithrilGuy]

I don’t recommend watching the truck driving horror stories

[@jonathonlilbourne9264]

I was a garbage guy for one single day it was the worst thing I ever. Done so i say congratulations for making it to a driver position

[@ShermanMark1]

I Recommend watching the Truck Driver Horror stories!

[@henrycalde1991]

I deliver through the delivery apps on my off days and after work for extra cash, I also listen to Mr.Nightmare doing the deliveries

[@InvisiB1e]

W

[@Ian-lp2hd]

Story 1: “Should I bring someone with me? Nah I can drive two cars at once.”

[@MrChologno]

Lmao, also "Why should I call the cops and report a possible body?"

[@komencense579]

@@MrChologno LMFAO Im DED💀

[@masonhall6687]

like bruh a stuffed human being?? come tf on. this would make national news. almost insulting that somebody would dare title this a “true” horror story

[@Xpdiant]

@@masonhall6687 and while I’m sure there have been people sick enough to have at least attempted something like that, they wouldn’t just leave it in plain view of the windows and back door

[@dimgus3653]

Why did i never think of that💀💀💀

[@amandahoffman6912]

You don’t worry Mr. Nightmare. I for one won’t complain if these compilations become a regular thing. I’ll watch them all lol

[@emeliasuch7662]

same

[@preztonH]

I know it’s genuinely interesting to see what his favorites throughout the years have been

[@MattIsTheCat]

I am replying to this comment by stating my opinion: I don’t like these compilation videos that are redone versions of his previous supposedly true stories.

[@samisikdar5417]

As an og fan I actually really like hearing stories from throughput the years again

[@stonedmelodic7918]

I was about to say the same thing. I usually end up re watching through the year anyways haha

[@jejejeje4491]

You know you’re a hard-core fan when you know all the stories 😂

[@WiSHNUKEs]

Once you starting hearing key plot points in these stories youll recognize them in a heart beat😭

[@leviouren3900]

Fr

[@PinesapStan]

I remember first hearing these back when I watched the LLama Arts animation videos of them.

[@WiSHNUKEs]

@@jejejeje4491 damn bro got some super powers. Once I hear where it takes place and where someone goes it usually clicks but you are a true mr. Nightmare enthusiast

[@laughingatthesky7]

swear

[@callmeonyxied7018]

that second story gives me chills. they should’ve looked into it more than just settling on it being a hallucination. i thought i was hallucinating footsteps in my attic for more than 2 years until we caught a squatter in it

[@friedrichjunzt]

Holy cow!

[@Anthonyh4523]

No way

[@TheLeeBonner]

It’s a more logical and likely explanation than a psycho squatter. He admitted to having other hallucinations as well so case closed. Had he never had another hallucination again then it would be really strange but he was probably diagnosed with schizophrenia otherwise he wouldn’t just believe that he hallucinated it because someone told him.

[@waspqueen217]

Ok that’s terrifying

[@TheCornDavis]

Oh that's crazy!

[@Topidoit]

The movie theater one always made me feel so uneasy amongst the others. Truly terrifying.

[@amaramzk]

I just want to know why he didn’t say anything immediately! Just ran out leaving him there with everyone else lol

[@VictoryReviews]

For reals I absolutely hated it. Like why did the person move rows to get closer. Disturbing

[@wills5351]

Same it always made me feel so scared

[@hairymailman]

yeah i hate it

[@themysteryguy85]

@@amaramzk there wasn’t anyone else in there

[@jeremiahm1413]

The consistency Mr. Nightmare has shown with posting this month has been nothing short of spectacular.

[@dinogt8477]

no one cares

[@NinthShinigami]

@@dinogt8477 about you :D

[@rankings727]

@@NinthShinigami I think he’s talking about that bot in the first comment lol

[@NinthShinigami]

@@rankings727 he’s going around putting “no one cares” and other weird stuff on people’s comments (not towards the actual bots). Did the same thing on another channel

[@liamsammon6123]

You could say it's "spooktacular" ..I'll just stick to listenin' to the stories 🎃

[@Prizzlesticks]

Can you imagine peaking out your window to see who your new neighbors are, only for them to bust into your house later with a katana? That's the real horror story.

[@soup3121]

it was probably just a squatter too😂

[@monsterhanna6691]

And when the house was ABANDONED?

[@monsterhanna6691]

@@soup3121 Because squatters are never dangerous?

[@Prizzlesticks]

@@monsterhanna6691 They assume. There's no confirmation from an outside authority. He says the first night there, they 'found out it was abandoned' because it looked rundown, and they hadn't even noticed graffiti on the walls and windows of houses in the neighborhood before then. But like, this is near Detroit, allegedly. An area now famous for its zombie homes and dilapidated buildings because residents who are able to squeak by can't afford to fix up their houses. If you can barely buy a loaf of bread, how are you gonna buy cleaning supplies, paint, and new windows when hooligans go and tag your ramshackle house?

[@sussett]

NOT WITH THE KATANA 💀💀💀

[@sebastianrosa7935]

Can we appreciate that this man remade his older stories instead of just posting the original audio, dude cares about quality.

[@stephanie-ur4ly]

Bob

[@whatzmyusrname]

@@stephanie-ur4ly Who’s Bob? (Sarcasm)

[@miltonmilky5970]

it's the old audio tho

[@Trainmaster16]

I'm pretty sure he used the original audio for theses

[@Trainmaster16]

@@malkakynatas8389 Maybe he redid some of them, but the thunderstorm story sounded exactly the same to me

[@gobenku1464]

As a returning viewer, these compilations of YOUR favorite stories is actually an awesome way to get back into the channel. Thank you for putting them out!!

[@DustyAssStar]

Agreed!

[@floydchupping6299]

The movie theatre story is genuinely one of the most terrifying things I have ever heard.

[@reenasingh6275]

Holy shit- was it real?!

[@preciousbabygirl8711]

@@reenasingh6275 bo

[@lukemiller8404]

@@reenasingh6275 obviously fucking not lmao

[@xxevilellisonxx]

@@reenasingh6275 bo

[@dbdperson9595]

seems like it was just a prank

[@queennyxie2734]

the second i heard the beginning of the first story i immediately gasped and yelled, “THE TAXIDERMY STORY??” i’m so glad you brought this story back. it was actually the first story i’ve ever had an actual nightmare about, and has been one of my favorites to this day.

[@Rey_Palpatine]

The phrase "taxidermied human being" is so iconic, periodically it just resurfaces in my mind and I remember this story

[@stewyyishim]

i remember watching an animated version of that story years back and being absolutely terrified

[@queennyxie2734]

@@stewyyishim yes it was llama arts’ video!! i still go back and watch them, although some of the videos they’ve done of mr.nightmare’s stories have been private unfortunately. that’s so cool, i didn’t know there was anyone who remembers that!

[@Rey_Palpatine]

@*Iris..swaggy* You know how dead animals get preserved by being stuffed sometimes? It's that, but with a person

[@abunn72]

It's crazy because I listened to this this story on Friday and on Saturday, I saw and episode of Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities where this woman taxidermied her husband.

[@TheJazzWick]

Thanks to legend for always delivering

[@dowhatyaluv]

Why did you put that jumpscare at the last 😭😭😭... My heart skipped a beat 😭

[@MMansonable]

Tell me about it. It's 5:40am right now, I'm working and have Mr. Nightmare playing as I'm doing so, and I haven't slept since yesterday and now I'm about to go into cardiac arrest seeing that jumpscare. Then I laughed. Thank you, Mr. Nightmare. It worked. 😂

[@frankcerritos93]

Same, bro! 😂

[@saudadedude]

I swear man, Mr nightmare makes this month of October so much better

[@dinogt8477]

who asked?

[@swearimnotarobot3746]

@@dinogt8477 his 6.3 million subs

[@WanderingLoner1]

Yup! Mr Nightmare making our halloween month better!

[@rankings727]

@@dinogt8477 tu mamá

[@hashimkhn2200]

Its all fun and games til some man in a micheal mihers mask follows you and you turn into a mr nightmare video

[@franky8450]

The shriek in the last story is so gut turning and bone chilling, gives me chills everytime I hear it🎃

[@dericjames2018]

@@Azathoth1999 Already heard the story years ago so I was expecting it.

[@gsellbeats]

BRO SAME

[@leviouren3900]

Literally, that is one of the top 3 stories that genuinely scared me, there was another one about a ware house that just scared me so bad, I don’t remember what the video was called tho, prolly top 3 scary warehouse stories

[@the_boss2194]

@@leviouren3900 I just wonder what that scream could be? Or what the creature or person was

[@rishamccauley]

Tht was the scream i got for my notifications on my phone. Lol when i heard it i was like y is this lady screaming at me again when ik i put my notifications on vibrate. But it was coming from the video lol 🤦🏿😂😂😂

[@booquafolus]

The 6th story is probably the single story from this entire channel that has scared me the most. That scream sound effect gives me chills everytime, and the jumpscare at the end is a nice addition to the remake.

[@nathanielross285]

No it scary

[@Dedligmrdg24]

The sixth story is creepy

[@Lillian501]

Do any of you guys know which video the 6th story is from? I've been trying to find it for a while

[@bigbruno2232]

@@Lillian501that was from the Birthday party stories

[@ЛейлаДаудМансори]

Puma!

[@cypherbrittainnethegodofsl4988]

Story 1 is very iconic. And my God, the story 4 and story 5 still give the chills, especially the story 4. I remember legit having chills when I first hear it.

[@FUNGUSMAN920]

Some weird news about story 4, I googled the name of the guys severed head, and it did sound like a match. Long hair, 17 year old, missing, I don’t know. It’s honestly really creepy.

[@mikellclark635]

Me too

[@mikellclark635]

@@FUNGUSMAN920 yeah I did too I was so paranoid after hearing it

[@kyrohowe3156]

I was thinking the same thing when watching past videos

[@FUNGUSMAN920]

Yeah it’s crazy. Story 4 and 6 were definitely the creepiest for me. The thought of someone abducting someone, cutting off their head, AND PROPPING THEIR SEVERED HEAD KN TOP OF A STICK, it’s some of the most fricked up crap I’ve ever heard. Story 6 is just scary because elf the thought of an unknown creature stocking you in the woods, and that scream at the end was terrifying.

[@theonewhocooks111]

My 7 year dream of Mr. Nightmare posting consistently has come true

[@ShermanMark1]

Same!

[@kenyalmb]

Ur dream comes to an end soon kid

[@Sithassassin9]

I wanna say every October he’s always extra on top of it

[@SydneyConlee]

what you did at the end with the creepy smiling person was NOT OKAY 😭 21:24

[@Stella-wj8xk]

Frfr I got scared frfr

[@Skidoosh121]

I always like to imagine these stories as "misunderstandings". Like the first one was just a guy who had a movie prop in the room and the car was parked and covered in the backyard or something. Watched the guy speed off and thought "huh, weird guy". Makes them funny to me imagining people generating entire horror stories off of simple misunderstandings.

[@mx.menacing]

I get what you mean, but what kind of movie prop is a taxidermied human being?

[@Skidoosh121]

Like a prop of a person, like a wax statue, the person is assuming it's an actual taxidermied human being 🤣

[@Lemurwork]

You should watch Tucker and Dale Vs Evil. It’s exactly that kind of humor.

[@Skidoosh121]

@@Lemurwork Exactly! Love that movie! Watched it on Netflix and I was laughing so hard, exactly how I imagine these stories!

[@darxhart1646]

@@Lemurwork I was just gonna say the same- seriously such a fantastic movie! Though anything with Alan Tudyk is guaranteed to be awesome

[@NinthShinigami]

Mr Nightmare is at the top of his game when he needs to be the most… October. All hail the king of nightmares 🙌

[@stomper2888]

Mr ballen is king but nightmare is a close 2nd

[@username3835]

Just this morning I was thinking we need more Halloween stories this month.

[@brittanycunningham787]

I'm sure it has nothing to do with ad revenue.

[@dinogt8477]

no one cares

[@NinthShinigami]

@@dinogt8477 you again? Dang bot 🤖

[@dolledpawz]

the theatre one was so crazy ? i still can’t believe it omg

[@TheSundayShooter]

It's made up, otherwise he would have called the police

[@boyboss3322]

@@TheSundayShooterYou do know not everyone calls the police right?

[@TheSundayShooter]

@@boyboss3322 Agreed, by 10:50 I would have drawn and give him one (1) verbal warning to remain seated during my exfil in the lobby where staff shall be alerted about his presence and a refund for the ticket processed. Anyway, why bother researching online for murders or abductions without filing a police report? That information would be more pertinent to investigators than whoever is answering phone calls at your local theatre

[@MrSteve0311]

@@TheSundayShooter Always carry!

[@mrheyfuckoff1]

Didn't call the police. Didn't go out into the lobby and tell the staff immediately.. Load of bs

[@Aymarichan]

Thanks for the jumpscare at the end. I definitely didn’t need to see that at 1am alone in my kitchen 🙃

[@jacoblounsbury1686]

You are welcome 😂

[@pedrolota4670]

Thanks for the warning xD ahahah

[@ooozmakappa8850]

gladly i was watching this video on laptop and i listening and watching music on my phone

[@henrywenn]

Thank you for the warning! I’m watching this before bedtime and that face would have delayed my sleep by a few hours

[@thekyledupuis5863]

That pissed my off 😂

[@jbbyaboo1105]

The mom in the closet one is really unsettling, and I can see that being 100% truthfully recollected.

[@Promare2019]

TBH, I don’t really remember hearing that story. Do you remember what video it is from?

[@PalKiba]

I had things like that happen to me when I was a kid too. I'd wake up to my mom being in the room, but the room was so dark that I couldn't see her face. It was just a black void. She was just standing over my bed. I'd get spooked out and she'd tell me to just go back to sleep. I think she was just checking in on my brother who also stayed in my bedroom, and I.. but I think I'd wake up at the wrong time, making it feel like if she was just staring at me. I'd close my eyes and I'd just feel a slight breeze as she went away I think. Never asked her about it. Being half-asleep and in the dark fucks in your mind.

[@dbodooley]

I like that one a lot! That one, the movie theatre one and the scary screaming monster in the woods one (which is really a Fox. Same thing happened to me and a fox screamed so loud it scared the shit out of me and my dog and it oddly does sound like a person kind of)

[@hadlymcmuffin]

By far the most disturbing story on here

[@TheLeeBonner]

The storyteller admitted he suffers from hallucinations? How is that disturbing at all? He’s probably just an undiagnosed schizophrenic. Normal man has condition that causes hallucinations, chills 👀😂

[@ColemanKline]

These videos have genuinely become therapy for me. With all the stress from school, sports, friends and other stuff these really help me stay calm and fall asleep at night.

[@Noah-ot1sv]

These stories bring back so much nostalgia from watching these stories as a kid. Please never stop! 👑👑

[@fieldshore4422]

That scream at the last story was perfectly done, and that cheeky smile at the end really made my night ;). Happy Halloween everyone!👻🎃

[@PatrickWDunne]

It's that time of year again. The time to go on a relentless Mr. Nightmare binge.

[@emocoffee]

and then, find that one story that freaks you the hell out and scares you off for a bit, then come crawling back eventually. rinse and repeat ..or is that just me?

[@evanswauger7246]

@@emocoffee nope me to lmao

[@NaeNaesocute2424]

@@emocoffeenope me too lol

[@A_Viewer]

@@emocoffeethat’s me too

[@Amphros_22Franco]

Yeah same

[@lucasfraczek4320]

Ahhh the Skinwalker birthday story made it to number one, that puts a smile on my face. Seriously that scream sends chills down my spine no matter how many times I listen to it or expect. Whatever that family heard that day wasn't human and wanted them dead....

[@woolynut3166]

Could anyone even confidently say what it was. Like the way he describes it. It can’t be any animal. Like this was the scariest of them Cus of the complete unknown of it

[@darthgoku1580]

Maybe it was the Jersey Devil. The story takes place in New Jersey afterall, and the Jersey Devil is said to have a high pitched blood curdling scream.

[@Nostalgio]

Anyone gonna talk about that last clip before it says “Happy Halloween ;)” ?? 🎃😂

[@Nikkk6969]

Mountain lions have the same scream

[@bombdotcom2168]

@@darthgoku1580 It definitely could have been The Jersey Devil :o

[@therealdirtydan7227]

The taxidermy story is horrifying to think of. The thought of seeing what OP described as a lifeless statue is a bit eerie to picture

[@Spiralredd]

I got shivers thinking about it. It sounds like a tales from the crypt episode. I've always found taxidermy to be a creepy thing to do regardless

[@davidhardy669]

My thinking was like, is it a real human or a mannequin

[@BigBastion623]

It’s always fun to hear what people think r the best stories. Here r some of my personal favs: - Body in Mel’s Basement story. - Field Trip at Abandoned Village Story. - Pizza Delivery to guy with Frog Mask. - Lost Man in Woods Sleeps in Idle House. - Intruder in Basement Vent Story. - Kid took Killer Clown’s Nose Story. - Hunter finds Murderer in Woods Story. - Robbers Invade Halloween Party Story. - Guy gets Kidnapped in Vegas Story. - Friends find Murder in Vacation Home. - College Kids Stalked by Woodside Lake. - Guy’s Parrot Reveals an Intruder Story. - Dude in Woods keeps Hearing Kids Laugh. - Therapist who likes Pumpkin gets Stalked. - School Kids Chased by Shooter in Woods. Just a couple of my favorites in no particular order. Curious to hear what everyone’s fav stories are

[@wickedwiccann]

i love that i recognize most of these stories lol. some of my favorites from this channel have got to be; • something in the water during double date at the beach • kid falls asleep in haunted barn during hide and seek • friends hide in a cave for hours from attacker • students discover an abandoned cabin on campus • guy keeps hearing kids laugh in the woods • person sees lifeless head at the movies and that's all i can think of atm lol

[@chrisvela4860]

damn I couldn't have remembered any of these. great ones on here!

[@calibmatlock]

I think the one about the Halloween party robbery is up there too. That story is fucked up.

[@zayswag2672]

Yo that hunter that found the muderer in the woods was intense

[@AgentAngel2]

@@wickedwiccann bro your first one I love that story

[@WizardToby]

1) Craigslist is probably not the most trustworthy site to buy a car. 2) I really hope that was in fact a hallucination 3) Glad to know the person stopped a potential burglary 4) Glad that person ran out of the theater before becoming a victim 5) Marv is a stalker and Ben is a legend for having a katana XD 6) Sounds like maybe those kids encountered the Jersey Devil in the woods.

[@ShermanMark1]

He should of used Car Trader If it Existed then

[@palmettopurist5549]

@@GalaxyPrincess2020 And unfortunately Facebook marketplace is becoming just as bad.

[@abunn72]

I know a few people who say they have encountered the Jersey Devil, in South Jersey. While listening to their stories, you could tell they were terrified, by the looks in their eyes, tone of voice and body language. It definitely creeped me out.

[@Nikkk6969]

Let me just say auction buys aren’t any better unless you really know what you’re getting. Thought I got a steal. It was supposed to be my daily but it was a project instead. Dude lied to my face “great truck no issues whatsoever” barely even starts in warm weather lol

[@johnathanvelasquez6283]

How is marv a stalker you have no ñroof

[@thegamerator10]

Story 6 was so masterfully told. The atmosphere was spot-on, the sounds, and the scream. It might be my favorite story on the channel.

[@Nano.8258_freepalestine]

That ending definitely gave chills !! Gotta say great job Mr. Nightmare 👏🏻

[@justexploring6979]

Haha definitely wasn’t expecting it! Made me point the finger at my iPad screen! Mr nightmare you cheeky cat! Great video

[@Meme_Team99]

Yep, gotta love his humour

[@rnsteve2265]

Check out Mr Ballen.

[@Nano.8258_freepalestine]

@@rnsteve2265 just checked him out and found he's a scary storyteller with 6.8M subs. That's amazing.. dunno how I never heard of him

[@rnsteve2265]

@@Nano.8258_freepalestine I like Mr. Nightmare but Mr Ballen is top notch. Im addicted to his videos and story telling abilities.

[@mccheeseburger467]

anyone else remember the first story from years ago? such nostalgia :)

[@Devbdyt]

Ya even a knock at the door and a visit to fazbear fright I miss those

[@brokenguillotine6988]

I remember the first story pretty well from when I was in 5th grade I think. This was crazy to hear again.

[@alizadestiny]

Wait.. so the first story is real?

[@ozboz-roblox363]

what’s a taxadiry human?😂

[@HMMELD]

@@alizadestiny They all are real - aren't they?

[@whomp2822]

@@ozboz-roblox363 I think it’s a dead human recreated into a taxidermy statue

[@hyperhurracan1324]

@@ozboz-roblox363it means someone got killed and was skinned and their skin was put on a statue to look like a human.

[@eljox]

you're amazing just for saying "don't worry", we will watch anything from you mr. nightmare, doesn't matter if we have heard it before, thank you for your uploads lately

[@WinterSoldier1917]

The movie theater one has haunted me for so long I've done a lot of research into it. I did find the article about a 17 year old Donald Watkins missing from Meridian Mississippi. I found his family on Facebook and I guess they found him because his aunt posted about him going missing again in 2020 and saying 'he hasn't been taking his medications.' Most recent of anything I can find online is an arrest report of a Donald Watkins in Meridian Mississippi in August 2022 for trespassing, with the same birth year as the one listed in the missing person report from 2017. His own Facebook hasn't been updated since 2018 but from the profile picture and the picture in the missing boy article I'm like 99.9% sure that's him and he appears to be alive

[@deejay5781]

bros a detective

[@avamasquerade]

What year did the theater incident happen? Perhaps he was disappeared the 2nd time he went missing? Considering the fact that the untreated mentally ill are at dramatically significant increased risk of being the victims of violent crime, the idea that he might have met with foul play is not that far fetched an idea.....

[@WinterSoldier1917]

@@avamasquerade the original Mr. Nightmare video with this story was in 2017 I think so sometime around or before then

[@madebyhouse]

It’s made up lol

[@ImGoodAtFn0]

@@madebyhouse then why is Donald Waktons an actual person that has been missing

[@eastonbiggins]

I think the hallucination one isn’t all that uncommon for children. I remember I believed in Santa undeniably my whole childhood. The reason being, I vividly remember (still to this day) one year waking up in the middle of the night on Christmas Eve seeing Santa peeking in my room. I remember, once my parents told me the truth, thinking that maybe it was my dad dressed up but they said he never dressed up as Santa.

[@Perry....]

@@SomeKindOfDood Wtf?

[@TheLithp]

Child hallucinations are very common.

[@Ashlego]

Or I kid you not, could have been a break in🤷‍♂️

[@Pilk4life]

​@AshLego I doubt someone dressed up as santa to break into ppls houses

[@Ashlego]

@@Pilk4life With how cruel this world can be, it’s not that hard to believe. Plus I heard a story about a kid seeing Santa and talking to him. The kid goes back to bed and sees that the presents are gone. He says he saw Santa and his parents are shocked, and call the police.

[@courtneydias9944]

I used to feel comfortable going to the movie theater alone, even if I ended up being the only person in the movie. But after listening to story #4, I will never again go alone again.

[@dataexpunged4784]

It seems like you have a really good *head* on your shoulders then. Definitely not the type to *stick* around in these types of situations.

[@monsterhanna6691]

I'm so happy I don't go alone, even as an introvert. 😂

[@byyfelicia7521]

I know right but regardless how scary how could u just run off and not call the cops or something there is no way I'm way too nosey I would of had to of made sure on what I seen specially to know if it was a real person 😳

[@89kilemal]

@@byyfelicia7521 would've* had to have* saw*

[@byyfelicia7521]

@@89kilemal GROW UP 🙄 and how about making sure you're actually right before trying to correct someone lord some people have way too much time on their hands what a joke

[@dimsword35]

Watching mr.nightmare before going to sleep is definitely a good idea and is definitely not going to keep me awake and paranoid throughout the whole night.

[@meows8603]

Lol right

[@unaipad1128]

Yep. Definitely

[@HowdyFolksGaming]

Kid in the second story has the best sleep paralysis monster - just his mom being a goof 😂

[@cvattt]

I listen to you everyday during my irl classes, even if I might get in trouble. It’s worth it though bc your voice is genuinely so relaxing, and I love your channel

[@chrisvela4860]

irl classes🤣

[@MultiSmash1234]

Most of us won't complain if compilations become more of a thing. They're really enjoyable. ❤️❤️

[@rowanmiller7087]

Just got done with a 2 hour drawing and now I'm laying down,almost paralyzed listening to these stories. Paranoid and scared to move 🤷 these are amazing 🤩❤️

[@rowanmiller7087]

@@The_ZeroLine Oh really? thats amazing,they seem so realistic!

[@pale4146]

Drawing with background noise like these stories is just something I can’t get rid of!

[@JunkMeister.]

@@The_ZeroLine the title says true stories tho

[@amberwaltemate5113]

@@pale4146 I knooooow!!!

[@youajoke448]

This ain’t twitter we don’t need to know what you’re doing

[@3lipalm3r]

Dude I’m just here for the scary stories, and I honestly find it kinda refreshing to revisit old spooky tales.

[@Ja-LonnieBilal]

I remember that first story so well! The taxidermy part was what really set it off for me 😬. That Craigslist comp video was what I think that got me into Mr.Nightmare back in like 2015. That and the pizza delivery volumes. I also remember Llama Arts animating that particular story which would eventually lead to inspiration for all the horror animators we have today.

[@cage512]

15-16 nightmare was a different vibe on god

[@Ja-LonnieBilal]

@@cage512 bruh those were the days! That's when I got hooked on this channel and couldn't help but to binge watch all the videos 😭

[@Moonless87]

The first story is definitely not true. I find it weird how ANYONE could believe it. One: The guy drove to get the car, alone. How did he think he would get the other car, he can't drive two cars at once, lol. Two: if it was truly a taxidermy human why on earth he didn't call the police? He never mentioned calling them. Not once. And I'm very certain that something like that happening would be on the news.

[@kookiemonsta6409]

Love that I’m still watching these videos for the past 6-7 years

[@omphicat]

found this channel all the way back in 2015. glad to see the community has never left and you're still going strong! thanks for being the voice that has read scary stories to me throughout all the years :)

[@lexyfamous]

Fr, he's one of the few OGS that still gets a lot of support and it's well deserved.

[@Hikomii_cc]

Can I just say, Mr. Nightmare, you have a great storytelling voice.

[@niilo-222]

it was obvious from day one, mr nightmare is truly the GOAT of telling scary stories.

[@YBKHEAAAT]

@@niilo-222 mr nightrizz

[@kylegreene1356]

Big sloppy wad on your mouth and face.

[@RasperCafe]

I KNOW RIGHT!!!

[@gridreaper6735]

His voice sounded way different and younger back then in his older videos

[@ForsakenWar]

So.... Story #6. Dude hears footsteps out in the dark woods. Kids want to play hide and seek in same dark woods. Dad says yes?!

[@theofficaluncfan6814]

Do not apologize at all the more videos the merrier to add some upbeat warmth to a cold dark and creepy month, Thanks Mr Nightmare

[@plontu3665]

Watched almost every video, but still gonna re-listen to all these stories, amazing content as always🎃

[@mx.menacing]

Timestamps: Story 1 - 0:05 Story 2 - 3:26 Story 3 - 4:43 Story 4 - 8:53 Story 5 - 12:46 Story 6 - 17:23

[@foxtrotuniformcharliekilo1305]

The movie theatre one has ALWAYS been #1 for me, it’s beyond unsettling.

[@SchizoOtaku]

Mr Nightmare is on a roll with these consistent uploads. Kudos to him!

[@dinogt8477]

ronaldo

[@kyrohowe3156]

Kudos 👏

[@mindyschocolate]

October is his most popular month.

[@beautywoods6421]

The second story about how the mom went into the closet , that happened to my best friend she told me her mom walk into her closet closed the door and never saw her until the morning ….

[@josiahgonzalez942]

Wtf details? Is your Freinds mom a weirdo?

[@Promare2019]

TBH, I don’t remember hearing that story. Do you know what video it is from?

[@escapetherace1943]

@Jesse Evans that stuff can happen as a kid. I woke up to my step brother staring in my face saying "yo!" and I screamed but when the lights came on I was alone. I was pretty young. Nothing like that ever happened again. My step brother wasn't home though, he was at a friend's place, I think. 🤣

[@Horror-Man]

Really wouldn't mind some more of these. I started listening to true creepy stories way back in December of 2015, and most of my absolute favorite stories were the ones I heard during the first 3 or 4 months of 2016. At least one night a week, I had serious trouble going to sleep. Since then, it's been incredibly difficult to find anything that really gets under my skin.

[@VictoriaMarch13]

It's the same for me. When I first started listening I would get so scared but now it's hard to even find one that gets my heart rate up! And I listen to a lot of different narrators.

[@Heckinwhatonearth]

Oof. I remember finding creepypasta in like 2006 and reading the entire site within a few days.

[@ceedeecrazy]

It’s always a good day when Mr Nightmare posts

[@RachelParker-1977]

ALWAYS!

[@ScaryHorrorStories-h2i]

Its dark and rainy over here. Perfect mood for your horror stories.

[@ollieminecraft]

You know that when Mr. Nightmare uploads consistently it's a good month

[@ronald968]

so the guy heard and saw a guy trying to break in to the house and just went back to bed, hoping the guy would just go away, and opted not to tell his uncle, especially an armed uncle? That is absolutely insane.

[@LuxDraconis]

In all fairness, he was probably young at the time. I'd expect a reaction like that from a kid who's scared.

[@commiecomrade2644]

@@LuxDraconis its the parents fault they have this kid so scared to wake up an adult he was more scared of that than a stranger breaking in.

[@Emacula93]

@@commiecomrade2644 yeah I can say in full confidence I would’ve let my elders know IMMEDIATELY if I were a kid and caught someone trying to break in.

[@Thesquirtlegamer]

He says many times that he didn't know his uncle very well

[@Keyatzin]

No, he only went to the bed to pretend he was asleep, because he thought the guy saw him. And because he didn't hear the clang again, he knew that the guy did in fact see him; which meant he either left, or he was staring through the window, which he was. But he was clearly intending to tell the uncle, given that he was literally getting up to tell the uncle, when he saw the guy standing at the window. You could say that he should have run straight to the uncle when he saw the guy. But he was smart to try to be quiet, not alert the intruder, and especially to lock the window.

[@arionamiller7093]

My sister and I listen to your for nostalgia, we been listening since 2016. You’re the absolute best creepy story KZbinr ever and we will die on that hill 🖤

[@edenemerald7030]

Okay, the story with the person hidding in the kids closet kinda freaked me out. Now I know why this is one of your favorite scary stories lol. (Congrats on 6 million subs btw! I know I too late, but still! congrats!)

[@host_arnold6187]

That one screams sleep paralysis to me. Especially since they went to sleep right after. There’s loads of stories on vivid auditory and visual hallucinations around the time of sleep.

[@fatherdeath6607]

Just imagine how many stories he has access too. He’s got the holy grail he can just pull anything he wants out.

[@antalbene4720]

I want to go back in time so i can watch and listen to all the stories from mr nightmare again for the first time because i watched every single story at least 10 times and i hate to wait for a new story every week:(

[@OdyzzeyGee]

Oh yeah, story 4 gives me flashbacks of pre pandemic feels. No restrictions, the best weekends, festivals, sports, and awesome people. Life was goooood👌. Thanks Mr. Nightmare.

[@wickedsickfunkyfreshroller2037]

Extrovert shit, can’t relate

[@sammptus]

@@wickedsickfunkyfreshroller2037 Same i took a personality test and im 86% introverted 💀

[@Freckle_Face2247]

Is your area not back to normal yet? That’s crazy!

[@OdyzzeyGee]

@@wickedsickfunkyfreshroller2037 Well the "no restrictions" part was really the only one for me , and sports, the rest I can see through my phone everyday so...

[@OdyzzeyGee]

@@Freckle_Face2247 It is. But ofc the pandemic was the nastiest crap i have ever experienced. I wish it didn't put everything into a halt. Not to mention the lives it claimed. Some man-made bs.

[@WanderingLoner1]

It's been such a blast listening to Mr. Nightmare on this October, what with the more constant uploads recently. To be honest I wouldn't mind if he posted another video referring to his favorite stories he has narrated, it'd be cool! I wish you all a happy halloween! 🎃 Stay safe and have fun!

[@tjwolftooth3461]

Mr Nightmare coming in clutch this October with absolute mountains of spooky stories. Love the hustle, you deserve the 6 mil.

[@monke3403]

You know his videos are scary when you feel like changing to somthing happy

[@icantthinkofaname15]

Lol never but his videos are the best and the scariest!!

[@Jasonvoorhees57469]

I wouldn't mind if these compilations did become a regular thing

[@greymetamorphosis]

I would.

[@ZebraPrintedBanANA]

The Donald Watkins story is one that genuinely freaked me out. I still google his name occasionally just to see if he’s been found yet.

[@TorisTerrorTime]

Ok but that screech jump-scared me so bad 😭 Also the 5th one is more hilarious than horrifying 😂

[@liamvalvo8904]

This dude is amazing, watched him for 4 years

[@jessicagee5433]

I'm truly grateful to have Mr. Nightmare in my life

[@Nolanexdee]

That ending truly left me unsettled

[@josephtaylor5077]

That damn scary picture at the end scared me more than the stories. Thanks a lot Nr Nightmare! You owe me another pair of shorts. Love your channel.

[@spiderham6630]

I vividly remember story 4, as it was the story that really got me hooked to mr nightmare.

[@mawcespelledwithac]

#4 literally made me feel sick which doesn’t happen often when it comes to scary stuff. I had to check behind me even though I was sitting in the comfort of my own dining room 😭

[@aidanthehigglytownheroesdo2371]

The scariest part is that Donald Watkins really did go missing. I looked him up.

[@HerculePoirotABC]

Been watching Mr Nightmare videos since 2015, consistently brilliant 🙌

[@jasonchilado]

There’s countless that genuinely scared me when I first heard them from this channel, too many to list

[@allisonlong8857]

I don't understand how people can live with no window coverings and just leave everything exposed 24/7. That's just extremely weird to me. Kinda like leaving your garage door opened at night. So weird.

[@Cjsauer8]

I love this channel. He deserves a break after spooky season

[@Average_Edits_]

Mr nightmare is doing great! He never disappoints.

[@lexi-nh6tc]

I need to stop watching these before bed, but I can't stop. I am so addicted to Mr. Nightmare bro.

[@Twistedd_]

I actually really like hearing what your personal favorites are. I wouldn’t mind more of these at all but you do what you enjoy

[@RottingFord]

it doesn’t matter what kind of scary stories you post, we’ll watch them no matter what

[@TrendyrobloxGurl]

I've been re-watching your videos while I wait for new ones. I forgot about that jump scare and screamed but ended up laughing. It's 3 in the morning rn 💀

[@devanshubhatt5392]

Listening these stories during winters in a warm cozy blanket, dark room, holding cup of hot cocoa or coffee best halloween vibes! ☕🗻

[@VIO__]

I love hearing some of the old stories again. It brings back memories and a lot of them I only have vague memories of. I’d be fine if you keep reading these mixed in with new content!🎃

[@mariamagdalena2214]

Listening to this when it's storming outside is perfect. Especially the last story!

[@anarchyalien2279]

I wasn’t actually aware of how much I needed to hear this comp. What a throwback, I was surprised at how much I remembered from some of these stories 😅

[@degenerategambler4830]

Story 4 was genuinely fuckin terrifying

[@bombdotcom2168]

I seriously love Mr. Nightmare. I remember watching his videos in Elementary school and since then my opinion on his content hasn't changed at all. He's honestly my favorite story teller other than Mr. Ballen- And the consistency of each upload this month as well is awesome! Also, the movie theatre story scared the living hell out of me- As a kid, I swore there was someone lurking in the local Jr. High school's auditorium and hearing another story of something creepy happening in a similar environment just freaks me out more

[@strawberryj3lly]

Check out the dark somnium he does a lot of creepy pastas his story telling is brilliant and his voice is soothing. He has a lot of series too I recommend The Left Right Game

[@charlomltte]

i remember hearing the 4th story for the first time and being horrified! glad to see it in this compilation

[@airborneanimations3382]

Thank you for doing your videos! I always tell them your scary stories and they love that they are true ive told them thousands of them

[@justexploring6979]

You know you’re an OG when you recognise all of these stories

[@chrispfri3]

I’ve been watching Mr. Nightmare for who knows how long but he is one of the only KZbinrs I’ve stuck with throughout the years…thanks Mr. Nightmare I can’t wait to see what the future has in store🎃👻☠️🕷️

[@Devbdyt]

Ok if you been watching him for that long than do you know a knock at the door or a visit to fazbear fright

[@chrispfri3]

@@Devbdyt ofc i do, I would say one of my fav vids from Mr. Nightmare was his creepy Craigslist post videos

[@K1ttykat62]

his voice is just perfect, that's why ive stuck around, others get annoying

[@chrispfri3]

@@K1ttykat62 Fr it’s just the right amount of deepness and horror, it’s not monotone at all