A Calculated Death.

[@susangilmour7149]

As soon as you mention the children didn't wake and the dog didn't bark it was clear it was an inside job. Really sad for the neighbour who was terrified into giving a false confession.

[@DarryllCampbell]

I hope there's a place reserved for innocence, where puppies and children play.

[@tammymazon4213]

Indeed it is called heaven!

[@kellyconway5863]

@@tammymazon4213we all hope so😢

[@TheBadasspony]

❤

[@StacyThornhill]

Nobody can punish like God can and children are a favorite of his.

[@sandyschannel6917]

She got a free pass into the pearly gates I believe. Young and totally innocent.

[@requim936]

It's hard for me to believe that a parent can strip their child naked and just dump them like trash. However, I know that awful parents have done just that and worse. Very sad.

[@Dwaine-ir2kt]

That was done to make it look like she was taken by a stranger and rpd to take the focus off him shame a mob didn't get the father

[@MonicaLitman]

My first thought was dad because the dog would know him. What a beautiful little girl. RIP Annie 🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@brendacanter9768]

Heart breaking😢 The dog knew who it was😮 She's in Heaven with her siblings having fun❤

[@VanessaKittredge]

Terribly sad. Poor baby girl. I did not know there was statute of limitations for murder back then. Tragic! And mother went on to have another baby with him?! Just awful.

[@lorrainedalgleish7616]

Imagine what life was like for those little children living in that tiny two-room shack with a nasty drunk for a father. I bet they were petrified a lot of the time.

[@rolfsinkgraven]

A short tempered drinker hiding a murder, a silent dog and the deed was done, poor kid.

[@heathermanning5368]

What a heartbreaking story may Annie rest in peace.💜🙏

[@IrishAnnie]

The stone is so clean. Someone is maintaining it. Looks so petty, but so sad. Thank you Ron for this walk today!❤

[@dawnprochilo8084]

So sad, that poor little girl. What a monster he was to kill his own daughter. He was a psycho. Thanks for sharing this story Ron. RIP Annie and your siblings. So tragic.

[@nnekagrossett3138]

This story is very sad. Rest in peace to Annie and her siblings.

[@monikameza4107]

Poor little Annie😢💔hope she rests in peace. Thanks Ron for sharing her story.

[@teresawilliams662]

So sad all three of those children never made it to adulthood

[@sandratodd560]

Ron, this is so sad! May she rest in the Lord's arms! R.I.P. 🙏❤️🌹

[@LetItBeSummer-1]

I was not expecting that twist! How sad for the little girl 😢

[@monicamorar8047]

RIP Annie 🖤🌹 Grazie mr. Ron ❤❤❤ per aver ricordato la piccola Annie

[@floydgungl916]

Such a tragedy.... mercy

[@craigstorer6571]

Speaking of a shack, my father brought me along with him in the early 1970s to visit a man who lived along the roadside in a shack in Ohio. It seemed to be mostly made of corrogated steel. I was glad to see that the government didn't bother him about building codes. I think the room was lit by an oil lamp. Not a single mouse was seen. I must say that his couch was comfortable, and he lived such a simple, uncluttered, cozy lifestyle that the visit is still a fond memory. I'm glad that I had a father and grandfather who would drive me down backroads and visit interesting people they knew. To this very day, I like to take the long way home (just like the song by "Supertramp"). BTW: I believe dogskins confession was coerced.

[@dimplesMcGillicuddy]

As someone who belongs to the dogs, they let me know when anyone shows up here that doesn’t belong. It had to be someone familiar to the dog!

[@TracyAdams-ry2fc]

Yeah, my neighbor’s dog across the street barks at anyone who walks by

[@sandyschannel6917]

That seems to be the key to the whole mystery, the dog didn't make a sound. He knew the killer, no need to make an alarm to him

[@marlenepearson3936]

That was a good one Ron. But so sad 😢 The Dad? Really. Always gotta wonder when the dog never barks. May she RIP 🙏 Good to see you Ron 😃

[@kellyconway5863]

😢

[@smallchange5946]

I wasn't aware that there was a statute of limitations for murder even back then!!! WTF!!!

[@lemarch57]

Fortunately, there is no longer a statute of limitations for murder or for sexual assault of a child in Wisconsin any more. And that is as it should be.

[@gigicostlow4414]

@@BrianMcCarthy-z9l Ron mentioned there was a bruise on her head by her ear and a cut on her ear, so obviously it wasn't missed.

[@H_H_____]

​@@gigicostlow4414 Very good point. So sad. Awful. Poor little Annie. Some caretaker needs to prune back the evergreen so it looks better around her beautiful family head stone.

[@gigicostlow4414]

@@H_H_____ I thought the same thing about those branches.

[@gary-pietz4147]

I don't agree one bit with you when you try and hide A body even if it's accidental death it's still murder if they were honest about it from the beginning there would have been no issue but it is murder when you hide the body because I know it happened in a situation with my sister's boyfriend

[@zinniagarden]

"Hey gang" ...a nice way to welcome your caring audience, always nice to hear. And always nice to hear the stories you tell us about these people.

[@nancyvolke237]

This story reminded me ofJonBenét Ramsey!!! We never knew for sure who killed her. Great story you brought in today!! Thanks for sharing 👍🏻

[@unapproachablelight]

Yes! Same thing I thought.

[@lindaparker7199]

Odd that all three of their children died early in life.

[@lemarch57]

Back then, they didn't have antibiotics or any way to treat a lot of the illnesses. Entire families would be wiped out by cholera or smallpox and there wasn't a cure or any understanding about tuberculosis. Times were truly rough back then.

[@lindaparker7199]

@@lemarch57 Yes, that is true. Out of curiosity I looked at the "Find A Grave" site and while I didn't find a cause of death for the son, who may have died at birth, I found info for the daughter Marie. It said that she died of heart failure from exhaustion. She should have been about 15. True, who knows?

[@ckotcher1]

That was common back then

[@ErinRenee1990]

I just posted the same thing. I wonder if it was connected?

[@carlaemerson1195]

I'm here with my sisters homemade warm cinnamon pecan roll and coffee. Truly wish I could share these with the world! ❤❤❤Can't wait for the episode

[@FacesoftheForgotten]

whaaaat? yum!!!!! when am I invited??? ;-)

[@evakiss2562]

Yes! That would be awesome!😅

[@lesbw356]

I’m jealous

[@marioncampbell2156]

I wish you could send one to me in Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@steamtrainfanatic]

I've never tried that but it sounds delicious.

[@karenshepler7128]

Thank you for sharing her story and may she rest in peace.

[@eirinn2]

As soon as I saw the newspaper photo of the Dad, my intuition said he killed Annie. Not deliberately, it was accidental but he caused her death. I am glad her sibling came forward with the truth eventually.

[@OnTheGoWithFlo-Kid22]

Besides the loss of this poor little girl, the saddest thing is that someone took her life and we'll never really know for sure who did. Plus, these two fellows are both getting their names tarnished forever in time when obviously only one of them deserves it. My personal feelings is that I think the father could be involved and the biggest clue to me is that the dog didn't even wake up. Having dogs most of my life, I can't see any of them not alerting me if a stranger was breaking in the house. Either way, this is just very sad. What a beautiful little girl she was. RIP Annie ❤ 💐

[@valeriebraden7221]

Rest in Peace Annie

[@MargaretCorriher]

Poor child my her soul rest in God's hands. Thank you for another great history lesson.🇺🇸☮️🕊️😇

[@CarleenMorris-f3p]

How sad and also for kids to grow up without their big sister. R.I.P❤

[@Charger1908]

No statute of limitations on murder to the best of my knowledge.

[@maryleeswope3353]

Rest well little Annie.🎉

[@pastortom7488]

When you said that the other children didn't wake up & that the dog didn't bark I immediately thought that it had to have been a family member or at least someone known to family, then when you stated that the dad gave conflicting stories I pegged him as the person that did it . Of course either scenario is possible!

[@BeeWhistler]

Yeah, that tracks. I know they didn’t smile in photos much back then, but that little girl didn’t even look happy in her photos. Too many kids have died at the hands of the people who were supposed to love them best.

[@theresamcqueenmcqueen7891]

Every time you are in Wisconsin I watch to see my ancestors graves. I am from Alberta Canada. My paternal grandfather was born in Wisconsin.

[@14tfisher]

RIP little Annie❤🙏 Thank you Ron for sharing this sad story of little Annie, such a loss of a beautiful child. As always Ron, be safe wherever your travels may lead you, take care - Trish 💛🙂

[@Suze2233]

Bless her sweet soul.👼❤️Thank you for saying her name.

[@BlackRiverBay]

It seems totally unnecessary to stage a kidnapping and put Annie's body in the lake. If she was struck in the head and died, her parents could've just told people that she fell, hit her head, and died. They wouldn't have to explain any further.

[@donnaelkins186]

How could anyone do this to this poor baby girl or any child . RIP Sweet girl! ❤😊❤. Thank you Ron!

[@kimberlybrown4557]

Such a tragic loss. 😪 Thanks Ron another great video. Safe travels.

[@CarolineWessonFLGirl]

So glad I got to watch this. Everytime I see the notification (even at work), I get so excited about it. You're awesome, Mr. Ron

[@annettelundeby4213]

Hello everyone ! I am a big fan that has watched ALL your videos! You are amazing and so dedicated to helping victims get justice. Having been in LE, you are doing a great service to our communities, and victims. I don’t usually comment, but I am here. North Carolina has( where I am from) has Velma Barfield . The last woman to be executed in NC. She was a grandmother. This is a very sad😢case. My heart breaks for her family.

[@annettelundeby4213]

If there are any family members still living 😢

[@judyclark5736]

Such a beautiful and innocent child.

[@jeffbuelt6953]

How frightening your child is gone

[@tobyresch4189]

I do recall this story mentioned as a chapter in a book on notorious Wisconsin crimes (although I didn't really read it). I do appreciate the refresher. I'm leaning more towards the father, and the mother for her part as well. I really don't see the scapegoat being involved, since there wasn't really actual evidence (or testing) to link him as an "intruder". An inside job to cover their ends, in my opinion.

[@HeatherMarieGibbs]

RIP Anna M Lemburger ❤🕊️ 🌹🌺🌷🌻💐

[@juliacompton8035]

Another great, but horribly sad, story! Thank you Ron!

[@heidemarieemmert2195]

Thanks!

[@FacesoftheForgotten]

thanks Heidlebear. hope you feel better soon.

[@alicefotfmod7094]

@heidemarieemmert2195 thank you🌞

[@Xtro-1098]

Terribly sad story...Thanks ron...

[@roxanneminer1798]

Thanks for the story ,when you tell it , they are truly not forgotten, and your always so respectful, the yellow rose symbolize friendship,warmth, joy, happiness, new beginning a fresh start.

[@pennymurray3088]

Sad and tragic. Bless little Annie and may she rest in peace. Shame on the despicable one who is responsible, especially if it was her own father. Good job as always, Ron.

[@Laurie03]

Such a sad story, may she rest in peace as well as her family. 🌸🌸🌸

[@Minpingirl1958]

Brandee and I will be there...with snacks and coffee as usual.Thank you so much Ron

[@mam8982]

It adds up it was the father Martin. He was escaping prison for manslaughter by making it look like a pervert. What sort of a father throws a beer bottle at a child? I would like to talk to the other children, about what their life was like with Martin.

[@cynthiahusband106]

What a horrible story , possible her father killed her but like you say we will never know. Poor child Annie thought possibly adults were there to protect her not kill her RIP Annie 🥀🕯❤️

[@marierklassen7985]

That is very sad killing an innocent child how could they do that . Thank you for sharing this video 📹 from Marie in Northern British Columbia Canada 🇨🇦

[@Tinks-773]

Rest In peace Annie 🕊️ ❤ thanks Ron for sharing her story

[@firecrackergoddess]

Great to see and hear you! You're such a great story teller! Thanks for this!

[@rachelleischner]

Been looking forward to this all week!!

[@gigicostlow4414]

I agree, it was her father. I knew it had to be a family member when no one, including the dog, woke up. That meant they knew who the person was and wasn't alarmed by their presence. A shame there was still a statute of limitations on murder/homicide back then. Her mother probably would have gotten accessory charges. RIP little Annie.

[@warrencroom7621]

All the stories you tell are amazing. I can’t wait for this one.

[@keith100able]

Still love your videos very interesting and educational. Love the spooky ones for sure.

[@jessebriee3918]

Right off my mind went to why the dog didn't hear an outsider. That was the main clue to me. A parent or parents in order to spare themselves from prosecution for the behaviors. My heart goes out to the lil Anna, what she was feeling and thinking. An awful way to die by the hands of a parent. Thank you for bring this story to us Ron. Be safe 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@kenbarkdoll7252]

Very sad story. Thanks, Ron

[@dsinavich5141]

Hi Ron..a sad story of a beautiful little girl..RIP to Annie...... Daddy Dearest will pay later if he did it..... thanks for vlogging the story. ..... take care....... Deborah 🇨🇦

[@cheryl2962]

Poor Little Girl!

[@footballlvnlady]

RIP to Annie! I had read a book on this case years ago. Very sad!

[@stevemahoney6493]

Sister died at 15. Wonder what that cause of death was?

[@CaroleLeamer735]

Thank you for sharing this Mr Ron ❤

[@nickilamont9209]

😢 what a tragic story rest in heavenly peace beautiful girl thank you Ron for telling her story with such love and respect 😢 ❤❤❤❤❤

[@roberttucker7075]

Hi Ron! Love your videos and channel. I am watching your video right now. This is a sad story. You are awesome Ron.

[@jimbaron2529]

Great content as always Ron! Thank you brother I appreciate ya!

[@irishcountrygirl78]

We had a case here in the late 70s like that one, the dogs in the streets knew it was the uncle, but no proof and one almost confession, they never got her body. It was up in a remote mountsin area where nobody goes and only her family were there and the uncle, he was the last person to see her before her disappearance. How Anyone could end a little child's life is beyond me.

[@shawnhorkheimer5267]

Thank You Ron, for that story !- Your not really too far from the small town I grew up in !- New Milford, Illinois !. It's like: 3-5 miles just south of Rockford !. Safe Travels my friend !.

[@arneldabennett3142]

Another sad one. I just can't comprehend the question of why? Why would a father do this to his own child? RIP Little Annie 🙏

[@GenXfrom75]

I missed your premiere but watching this morning as get prepped for my workday ❤

[@sandyschannel6917]

The way you described it my first thought was inside job. Then no noise from the dog, meaning he knew the killer. The father all the way.

[@angelarogers3137]

As soon as you told the story I knew it was the dad

[@stephenoverend293]

This pretty young girl had her life cut short. Really heartbreaking 💔 😢. May she rest in peace 🙏.

[@Suve35967]

Hi Ron. Hope you and your family are well. Poor Anna, hope she's with God as all beautiful children taken by monsters. 🙏❤️🌹👍

[@LidaDuplessis-g6s]

Sad 😭😭 poor kid thanks for share this with us creepy family sta save pls blessings to you 🦋🙏

[@redrooster1908]

Madison, Wisconsin, our Capitol. Innocent little girl. So sad.

[@brendastibolt6672]

I think the father did it. Good story Ron. Thank you.

[@angelblue7779]

I didn’t know there was a statute of limitations for murder. That is horrible! Anyone can frame a person long enough to beat the statute!

[@FacesoftheForgotten]

It is totally perplexing. Maybe Wisconsin had special rules back then, because even in the 1800s, there was generally no statute of limitations for murder, meaning a person could be prosecuted for murder even decades after the crime occurred; this practice largely continues today as murder is considered a heinous crime with no time limit for prosecution in most jurisdictions

[@louisepotier2784]

This couple still had more children after the father murdered the child. I'm fairly sure that it wasn't the first time a beer bottle was thrown at anyone in that family. A sad story but thanks for telling it. Have a nice day. 🙂

[@LuvBorderCollies]

This isn't the first case I've heard where an angry father reacted with violence against a very young child who was irritating them. Then they panic and start making up stories, usually about some stranger who quietly got past multiple locked doors. Then dad wakes up and sees the phantom perp who either "fights" with dad (causing very superficial wounds) or makes his escape. The phantom perp always has a black ski mask and is so generic he'll never be identified. Whether its a spouse or kid, the dad or other family members are on the list of "persons of interest".

[@cheriessoblessedformerlyfear]

Probably what happened to summer wells .. may hee blood speak out from the ground too

[@MaryHouse-i7k]

Great story Ron and Rip lil Annie...sad 😥....🙏. ❤.........🖤 Mary watching from Arkansas

[@glenwilliamson9419]

Her sister, Marie died in Jan 1923 at 14 years old. Find a grave listed her death as "heart failure due to exhaustion." She died in a Madison hospital. Her brother Joseph died at 2 days old. Mar 25, 1913 - Mar 27, 1913. I could not find the reason.

[@hauntedbearchild]

Likely a birth problem.

[@flyingmonkey1342]

My grandparents and dad are buried here LOVE THIS

[@ml1049]

I knew that had to be a false confession, they were using fear tactics to try and get a confession out of Dogskin, and it worked. I definitely believe it was the father. Not only did he treat his own daughter's body with cruelty and disrespect, he willingly let an innocent man go to prison for his crime. Although his actions were stupid and reckless, I doubt his intention was to kill her. He should have just confessed and taken his chances. Coward.

[@CCcastro336]

Oh my goodness that is heartbreaking. Rest in peace little angel..🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@erlindarenteria4420]

Have a blessed "SUNDAY" to you Ron & to your family.! It's a sad story (RIP))beautiful girl.! Keep safe "RON" while your traveling different state.! Fr. North Hollywood, California😊

[@carolinetinsley3569]

Can't wait to watch it tonight

[@BabesNulliah]

Thank you Ron God bless very sad 😢

[@NDbred]

The fact that they would let an innocent man go to jail for their own misdeeds just makes the story worse. Lives ruined because daddy lost his temper?

[@stephanecomeau8197]

Interesting story, thank you Ron

[@thelittles6859]

Dad did it. 😢

[@BarbaraMinton-c6v]

This story is extremely sad. I felt that her father murdered her due to her siblings and dog didn't react to a man entering the window. The first story didn't sound logical to me Also I can't imagine how her mother could cover up for her dirt bag husband. I am sure both of her parents are burning in hell . I am sorry but that is just how I feel about anyone that would harm or kill a child !!!!