A Compelling Case for the Darkside

[@joemyers3885]

"When a person is broken it takes love and acceptance to heal them" WOW. Thank you.

[@kaboombox1581]

Maybe if the Jedi had made sure Anakin’s mother had been safely removed from slavery he could have freely reduced his attachment to her.

[@CesarHILL]

Mmmh... the thing that nobody ever mentions is that everyone knows there are slaves in tatooine and nobody does anything about it... so I question how this Republic really sees slavery. Obviously its got laws and all within its border that prohibit slavery, but on the other hand they are totally ok walking next to a slave when they go on holidays... So do they really see slavery as the wrong thing that it is and that we see in our reality, or do they co-exist with that concept and merely thing they are above slave as a nation... which would imply that some aren't above being slave... Just doing some logic rethoric here... so nothing too serious.

[@mikagrof9243]

@@CesarHILL You can be against something without going to war for it.

[@BandClarinet3]

@@CesarHILLI’m not deep on the history about this, but if we are talking republic they could say can say the galaxy is big place and they can’t fix all of it and just accept it’s there. Worst is I’ll guess enough republic senators benefit from slaves. Or at best it’s a lot of resources to try and fix the issue. It’s effectively declaring war on certain inhabitants. You can’t just jail them all on coroscant, more lethal means might need to be employed since you can’t police these areas all the time.

[@CesarHILL]

@@BandClarinet3 I'm not so much talking about the political organisations as much as the personal individual believes within the Republic. Obviously you got all the corruption and stuff on the top, or the opposite the whole we are against slavery to gain votes or whatever... I figured if a society has normalised the existence of slavery outside its boundaries it makes for a very different story than if everybody in the galaxy made slavery is illegal and it still exist illegally. The comparison would be today perspective about slavery on the world stage, against for exemple a civilisation in history that wouldn't have had slaves within its border but still accepted its existence in countries around and managed to co-exist with civilisations that used commonly slavery. And so I question how slavery would be perceived by the little people in such case. I suspect there'd be a lot more people that would be OK with slavery in such a context. Just because they see it when they go to other places... so yeah they wouldn't go to war with another civilisation, but the little people would definitely be affected by these interactions on a cultural level and probably would perceive it as I mentioned above. Which is super shady when you really think about it.b

[@Frosty98206]

Or in the Very Least have some Peace of Mind Knowing that Shimi isn't being Beaten by Slave Owners.

[@ichigen511]

We don't deserve Generation Tech. How many videos have you been making lately? I feel spoiled.

[@Gaverny]

Seriously 🙏🏻

[@deadmeat8754]

🤣 🧎🧎‍♂🧎‍♀ Kiss the ring more 🤣

[@Influence_Force_99]

Agreed. Love this man.

[@sammorrow8420]

We?, speak for yourself.

[@ChrisCarberg]

You are among one of the most fair and insightful minds in the Star Wars fandom. I’m grateful for your content and for your general outlook. Thank you!

[@Snarkknight5]

The opening of your video is what it sounds like when someone's allegiance really is to the Republic, to democracy.

[@8Smoker8]

Yeah, but then he proceeds to spread a bunch of misinformation, borderline Sith propaganda 😂

[@theProfessaurus]

i love your videos man but i’ve noticed a distinct lack of spreading awareness about the awful dolphins. they’ve not… gotten to you have they? 😟

[@-Plot-]

He realized Dolphins was just his version of anti-woke ideology so he had to give it up.

[@glacieractivity]

The dolphins said "So Long, and Thanks for All the Fish" by one of the finest writers ever around 4 decades ago 🙂

[@lukesearle1302]

I have noticed a change in him, I think they have threatened him. Allen, blink twice if they are threatening you....

[@abeautifuldayful]

@@lukesearle1302 Alan

[@LeafBoye]

​@lukesearle1302 I looked up and saw him double blink at 0:29 bro we gotta save him

[@OfficialRedTeamReview]

Thanks for making videos like this where you talk about the lore instead of blinding hating everything. Appreciate you

[@mightyrrt]

Have no idea what this is going to be about, but reading "The Dark Side has Soup" is the best thing to happen so far today. Thanks for what you do.

[@DANTICVS]

Watch that ep

[@northprime_unlimited]

I swear this is the only channel I get something meaningful out of sci-fi or otherwise. I always come here after an episode without having to hear complaints or sarcasm about the story, characters or effects like other channels. Instead I get a deep understanding explanation of elements that I missed to see. You give the episode a whole new dimension. You truly are a wise man Alan, I will continue to watch. Happy 4th 🇺🇸

[@gl0bal7474]

you have the best Star Wars analysis channel on youtube.

[@olivercattanach2680]

I loved the intro to this video. I'm British, not American, but we are currently undergoing a general election and its a great time to try and understand other viewpoints that we disagree with so we can understand why particular people vote for certain policies. Dividing a country prevents the flow of different ideas between different groups which is important for us to evolve as a society. I may not agree with the political views of many others, but I believe that everyone at the end of the day just wants a safe environment in which family and friends are protected. Empathy and communication is the only way to reduce conflict between individuals of differing opinions, and if the world had more of it, I believe it would be a much more positive space. Amazing video as always, Alan. I'm so glad we are getting a more nuanced and objective view on the institution of the jedi order through the lens of different individuals who have experienced it in different ways. Glad you're well again and I look forward to more of your content and analyses

[@newtonewell5172]

Thank you for another compelling essay about Star Wars, the Force and humanity in general. Bravo!

[@thomashughes7610]

I rediscovered you a few weeks ago thanks for not being so negative about the acolyte. Other KZbinrs love to shit on it

[@dxjjw]

That opening monologue was *chefs kiss*

[@ChrisCarberg]

Amen on Daryl Davis!

[@eileenhadley2731]

Those Qimer wounds probably came from his master's light whip, Vernestra. He says he left the order a long time ago. He also asks Sol you don't recognize me. I think they were padawans together.

[@jedirayden]

I was intrigued by his choice of words, the way he said "a really long time ago" when she questioned it a bit more. It makes me wonder if he's perhaps older than he appears, meaning significantly older.

[@WOODZY1126]

Cookies and now soup, the dark side just got even better

[@hadeshades2365]

I ll join and bring the BBQ. The dark side will thrive!

[@nadey_nate3441]

Lol 😂

[@darkarrow3683]

Don’t forget the slushies! It’s pretty chill over here on the dark side of the force so join the fun!

[@MaxRamos8]

It's like Porg Pot Pie which is Porg, Carrots, cream of space cow, and wheat from the farmers like the Larstead home. The soup uses bantha broth and a tiny dash of deathsticks to make them addictive, seductive if you will.

[@kevinhernandez2594]

My thoughts exactly

[@Mon21209]

It's badass that you're not afraid to gEt pOlItiCaL in your videos. Life is politics. Star Wars has always been political.

[@4RMULA_arch]

your channel (and urban acolyte) is my goto place for thoughtful SW content...thank you.

[@IamHomelander]

Nemik’s Manifesto and Luthen’s Monologue was peak Disney Star Wars.

[@isaackim7675]

How does the Emperor like his toast? On the Dark Side.

[@reniorjd]

Actually he likes it burnt like Anakin

[@wahn10]

Impressive. Most impressive.

[@deadmeat8754]

Nice! Like his coffee too!

[@H0lland0ates79]

@@reniorjdno no my friend, THAT would be Obi wan

[@craftchest]

Yours videos keep getting better and better. Love watching them everyday. Thank you.

[@captainfach]

Your comedy never fails to get me a chuckle, even when its in public and makes me uncomfortable. Never stop being you, my dude

[@RWCRD]

Thank you. Your videos have been getting better and better. I like the stranger character. Hopefully he’s the beginning of the knights of ren

[@ascensionindustries9631]

I have the art book of the TFA. There designs are awesome. Hasbro is like "You f--ked these characters, now I can't sell them."

[@aarontalksculture4946]

I really respect your work Allen. I agree with a lot of what you say, not everything, but it always seems that you are aiming to unite people through this fun fantasy myth we call Star Wars. Keep bringing it! ✊🏾✌🏾

[@michaelbox6007]

I love "the Dark Side has soup," idea. Creature comforts that nourish our base needs are the way to bond and ultimately influence the lives of others. Soup, yes, but shared experiences are more impactful.

[@Vihaan-hl3lp]

"The dark side of the soup is a pathway to many abilities, some may consider... Unnatural"

[@Woffies2]

Perfect

[@bingostarr3100]

“Some may consider… all natural *brandishes can of organic minestrone*”

[@Nodim1er]

I love your content Allen. You're making a lot of it lately, and I hope you're not overexerting yourself, but thanks all the same.

[@TommyDye]

This is absolutely the best SW channel in the fandom!

[@dreadzilla_9548]

I hate soup. Its wet and mushy and soft.. And it gets everywhere

[@abeautifuldayful]

Eat sand. Crunchy.

[@martinhejtmanek2358]

But it's good for a hangover. It also seduces to the dark side. There must have been some aphrodisiacs in it.😉

[@Jcewazhere]

and it's MOIST!

[@LordSleven]

Soup is a pathway to many stains some consider to be unnatural!

[@wahn10]

I see what you done did therrr.

[@Dan_in_RI]

About your opening statement: Well said, brother, well said.

[@zoebrennan799]

I definitely feel helpless and scared and I’ve been binging you for weeks because I’m so depressed and I need the positivity. I love you man. Thank you.

[@johnfoster7823]

Opening monologue was well done. Great job!

[@xtrafunk]

did the galactic republic have a co-equal judicial branch? to be fair, *"this is how democracy dies, to nonsensical constitutional interpretations by unelected lifetime appointees"* might not have the same ring to it.

[@redman2239]

Mace mentions Palpatine controlled the courts, so I doubt they would've done much of anything to stop him.

[@VoiceOfTheProphetz]

If the courts do there job they can keep the senate and congress in check.... which is why they are vo equal 🤔 but I think the Senate is the court

[@redman2239]

@@VoiceOfTheProphetz IF they do their job, and weren't bogged down by, say, a thousand years of Sith machination?

[@hendrikgreiner8449]

@@redman2239 I would think that probably there are select senators in the High Courts and if Palpatine has those in his pocket or even appointed, that would explain it. I have no proof, but that is how i would explain it. A system that at least mirrors the system in the US to a degree, since Lucas would be most familiar with that. Maybe somewhat changed to his preferences.

[@katraapplesauce1203]

​@@redman2239 jedi skill issue xD

[@aguidamonster]

Dude your opening comments about America and what binds us together was beautiful. Hope your 4th was awesome man.

[@corujariousa]

100% with you! Thanks for the video!

[@terran2023]

Damn dawg, what analysis! Reminds me of English class when students had to break down Heart of Darkness (Conrad) or The Invisible Man (Ellison). If somebody should interview George Lucas, it is you dawg. You are really trying to understand the art of the artist.

[@sethpajak]

It seems that the Jedi are often guided by fear even though they say fear leads to the dark side.

[@TheMortemGaming]

Well said things in the beginning of your video, spread love, compassion, and understanding to one another regardless of background! We are all humans who just need to talk each other with kindness! Also spread soup!

[@captainfach]

The taoism of Star Wars has always fascinated me, and I love when people like you get to talk about it

[@natk205]

The Jedi were destined to fall due to their arrogance. It was only a matter of who dealt the final blow, and how they did it.

[@johnelliott7020]

Arrogance is a serious flaw

[@deadmeat8754]

But the Jedi didn't "fall". This is a false narrative. the Jedi were betrayed and hunted to near extinction. In the Star wars universe, The Force and thus Force users cannot be exterminated. Though they may not use the same title, or organizational structure, until the memory of the Jedi is extinguished there will always be Jedi. In our own world myths we have Knights and Samurai and Cowboys whose 15 minutes of fame, institutional structures and societal context are long gone and still there are those who call themselves such and honor the concept in ways appropriate to a newer and vastly different era.

[@Talia_Arts]

man,, I came for the starters and am staying for the social commentary, so few people talk about this stuff

[@MarcRose96]

You hit the nail on the head when it comes to the Jedi. Ones like Yoda and Qui-Gon were powerful in their own ways because they were in tune with the Force aka they were more in touch spiritually and nurtured it. The Jedi of the prequel era generally were more focused on the physical plane and kept their attention on politics, recruitment, and dogma. Kenobi became spiritually in tune after Order 66 because he transcended death and his consciousness lived on. Despite the faults of the Acolyte, it makes us aware of this because the Jedi in the show are not what we would expect them to be and are more prequel-like

[@brandanreese123]

I can listen to you all day. You're so eloquent with your words and you share many of my thoughts on Star Wars. Your insights are fantastic

[@WOLFxINFINITY]

I've been watching your videos for a long time now. Always enjoy your views on the subject matter. I love your stand on coming together as people outside of the galaxy that's far far away. A lot of people have forgotten that it's ok to have different opinions and thoughts. I stop by for the soup, but stay for the conversation. Happy 4th to you and your loved ones my friend.

[@TitusSmith-i6r]

Rock on, Alan!!!!

[@XeRuSBunny]

Happy Independence Day Y’all

[@bingostarr3100]

Thanks for the thoughtful commentary, and how your analysis balances critique and compassion. I feel like this channel brings people together - that’s what Star Wars is all about! I’m going to make an effort to have at least one hi-how-are-ya conversation with a relative with an opposing political viewpoint at my fam’s huge 4th gathering later today

[@annalivia1308]

The interesting thing is that Anakin fell to the dark side because of what Yoda calls "attachment", or put in a positive way, true bonding (not "friends"). I believe he fell because Jedi refused to deal with true bonding considering it an opening to the dark side. Anakin came back because of true bonding. He felt Luke was prepared to deal with it. And Luke did not want him to die, recall, he wanted his father to live, despite everything. He was prepared to let the past be the past. "Let the past go" - it's already in the OG. Don't let the past decide who you will be in the future.

[@MichaelAmen316]

Loved the opening segment! Also, great physiological insight. Great video.

[@marshsundeen]

Alan, you are level headed, and I appreciate that. Thank you for your pre-show words.

[@professorbulk6415]

Enjoying your content, thank you!

[@flyingsmurf]

Allen, thank you for the content you continue to produce. You have always pointed the Fandom back toward the parts of the story we should be analyzing; relationships, growth, and action. Also thank you for saying exactly what you said about us Americans. We were never meant to tear each other apart. We are supposed to be US. We have so much more in common than we do opposed. I will try to remind the people I spend time with of this fact, by pointing out commonality. Thanks again, and keep it up!

[@travishoyt1068]

First cookies, now soup??? At this point I should be asking why would I NOT join the dark side

[@barnowl012001]

what the hell happened to the cookies?🤣

[@vindurza]

They're fun when you finish your soup

[@CloneScavengerVulpin8389]

They past there expiration date.

[@cloudmaster182]

Dinner before dessert.. even on the dark side

[@kevinhernandez2594]

I ate them

[@deadmeat8754]

Seriously, dude, it's the most important part of any meal!

[@JADub87]

I rock with you heavy Alan. I am a huge fan of your work. You're ability to address SW & real world situations at the same time is second to none. Peace. 💯

[@aforty1]

Dude less than 3 minutes in and you’ve already nailed the truth. I appreciate your videos and perspective.

[@samuelsmith6820]

You know we definitely need more people like you man. If you were on the ballot this year I'd vote Allen for sure sure lol

[@gibbyhart3203]

Your outlook on life is why i watch you. Please write a book at some point. Though at this point you have audio books for weeks lol.

[@hendrikgreiner8449]

That scar strangely made me think of lightning burns, since scars from real life lightning leave a distinct sort. So... did someone hit you with force lightning, Qimir? Since someone also "threw you" away like a certain order of hiding forceusers would?

[@TheTrueMorse64]

“Good soup👌” -Kylo Ren

[@KitsDad24]

This video and analysis is fantastic - pulls together a ton of concepts across the Star Wars universe and makes for a really thoughtful discussion

[@jmckittrick1]

You are a wise man. Love your videos

[@dsb7318]

the jedi are so naive and innocent when it comes to dealing with emotions; they avoid all that feels bad or dark, like they're scared of it, and that is why they will never be better than the sith

[@DragonFangX]

I need to double check if you've covered him before but there is a sith in the Vader comic, Lord Momin. that might be worth reanalyzing in relation to what we're seeing in the Acolyte, as he saw himself not as someone to bend the force to their will but someone who was attempting to 'appease' the force. Ties in a bit with how the Jedi and Sith as they normally are tend to throw the force out of balance.

[@romiguma]

I’m enjoying the show. It’s nice to see a take that is at least neutral. I hadn’t watched a SW Theory video since Ahsoka, and I come back and he’s in the Nerdrotic crowd disliking everything. Will keep watching and liking your videos to support this channel

[@mlubecke]

My favorite channel of the year ❤❤❤❤

[@kemsat-n6h]

15:39 Reminds me of V for Vendetta

[@harmonicdissent]

Spot on as always. Well done and thank you.

[@blindasabat2517]

I've been critical of the show overall, but im a little surprised that no one is giving the actor who plays qimir credit. Think he's been really good despite some of the writing. Also been a massive fan of darryl davis for a long time. Just a top class human.

[@fulgar_films]

The soup Qimir is cooking is called Sinigang

[@weyjosh5213]

lmao

[@jonathanpruett7831]

Yo thanks for keeping it real and staying that way my dudes keep em coming with love for NC

[@aforty1]

You’re my favorite channel breaking down star wars.

[@A_Certain_Point_of_View]

My boy Allen with another great banger. Thank you for what you do, your videos have kept me grounded when talking about this series with peers and friend. [15:26 (he said the thing!)]

[@AhsokaFanboy1138]

The only Soup in Star Wars is the brains the Anzati eat.

[@Dorama1997]

Was slightly concerned about what I’m about to watch but your comment gives me strength. Like this dark-side soup recipe I’m out to make?

[@DANTICVS]

Wrong. There are many soups in Star Wars

[@captainfach]

And that diarrhea that yoda makes for luke

[@GrayifiedX]

You had me at "soup".

[@weeklyfascination]

Great message, and very cool background.

[@Spectre033]

Thanks!

[@GenerationTech]

Thanks!

[@locustsun]

Daryl Davis is one of my heroes. He isn't a perfect person, but we don't need to be. But, I do look instead of at the people I talk to but at the issues and learn to listen and explain who I am and why I believe that. I don't let it become a situation of convincing one another, but rather just telling each other things. We need to talk to each other again and get our heads out of the screen worlds we create for ourselves more often. The loss of democracy will not go with thunderous applause, but without a sound. And no, it's no quote, it's real.

[@chriswoo2289]

This is perhaps the most thoughtful and understanding review of the force ive ever seen. Ive been a fan of star wars from the very first bit of star wars media i saw as a kid(the original trilogy, just before the prequels released) and ive been fascinated by the intricacies of its philosophies ever since. And as such ive devoured countless reviews and critiques of the philosophies of the force. But here someone has looked at these ideologies with empathy in mind. Id really love to see what you make of the ideas of Kriea from Knights of the Old Republic 2: The Sith Lords. Krieas philosophy has always been fascinating to me. I dont necessarily agree with her, but the case she makes is every bit as compelling as qimirs. Also side note. Qimir is my favorite dark side user of all. Right up there with the Count of Serenno

[@DaddyHensei]

Qimir has soup, Yoda has soup.(Return of the jedi) In the end it all comes down to soup. The force is soup. The great schism really occurred because one side preferred New England Clam Chowder and the other wanted Manhattan.

[@ShadowReaper-pu2hx]

New England clam chowder is better.

[@Zach476]

does that mean the old Jedi (Je'daii) had Long Island Clam Chowder (which is a mix of both soups)?

[@DaddyHensei]

@@Zach476 It's all coming together.

[@mattyt2032]

Excellent video especially words of wisdom at the beginning.

[@babytoshiro7014]

And that's why ep 3 was the best ep for me. Many people didn't get it. I said it felt like a serial w/o the SW branding and had some good storytelling and acting. But many couldn't see pass the "Lesbian Witches in Space chanting"🤦‍♀ And Qimir is clearly manipulating Osha. He just taken a broken person and now he's grooming her. Jedi are a sanitize organization and really needs an HR🤭

[@BillyBeenFishing]

2:12 Daryl Davis is amazing. Great episode!

[@abandonedplane]

"What about that horrendous wound on his back?" Well, here's my 2 cents: those scars are remarkably similar in pattern to that which one might sustain from being whipped. And, gee, where have we just seen a whip-like implement in the last episode? Hmm...

[@zufalllx]

He didn't seem to be cut into multiple pieces though. You know as one would be if hit with something like that.

[@Kyleplier]

What happened to the cookies?! 😭 I offer my homemade brownies as compensation. They’re Ultimate Chocolate Brownies with butterscotch morsels and mint cream cheese frosting. Literally melt in your mouth good 🤤

[@allenmitchell09]

Allen gives great analysis to these character arcs.

[@patrickfrazier5740]

Another great video essay with some good humor and its all about Star Wars of all things. I think this is what the founding fathers fought for was the freedom to be this awesome. Let's get this man a Pulitzer. Is there an award for best Star Wars KZbin reviewer? Maybe get him some soup, if nothing else.

[@jasonabrams639]

Alan , I've been a fan of your channel for years.. Happy 4th of July!

[@GenerationTech]

thanks man!

[@clavenbostic8212]

Lady with the bald fade whipped him.

[@Nephalem2002]

I want Qimir to top me

[@Mogorman87]

Brother I love your lighting and backgrounds, so awesome. Also just found you and really enjoy your vids. Keep that shit up buddy 👍

[@solarpixiejournals]

Alan, this was a wonderfully scripted, well presented and appropriate video for the times we are living in. Well said.

[@79mib]

Excellent work, my dude. 🎉

[@nathanael114]

I sincerely wish this episode's themes were as emotionally and thematically rich in execution as in your analysis. You say Mae abandons Qimir because she's fueled by love for her sister? I watched Mae knock Osha out with a force push, strip her wounded sister's body down, and then leave her unconscious in the perilous forest (where it's been established that killer moth swarms and rampaging Sith are in close vicinity). Mae then leaves Osha unconscious and goes with Sol. They go into space. In ep 6 Mae doesn't show any curiosity or concern or "hmmmm what ever happened to my unconscious and wounded sister?" Also, in regards to Dark Side Soup vs. Jedi Boomer Bureaucracy, you briefly mentioned that Qimir ambushed the Jedi. Yes, and he nearly murdered them all, tried to murder Osha too (threw his saber at her), cruelly refers to Jecki as an "it" after killing her. Qimir and Mae are both portrayed as willing to murder (remember when Mae threw that knife at the bartender's head in ep 1?). I love your analysis and I want to watch the show you're describing. It's just that the Acolyte undermines its own themes with extraordinary clumsiness. I think they REALLY ARE trying to convey the cool nuanced themes you're describing here.....BUT, they have neither the skill to convey these ideas properly on screen; nor do they have the discipline to fully commit to these themes.

[@Driftking305forlife]

Preach it brother this is exactly what I don’t understand why @Generationtech does not call out the horrible flip flop writing. This show makes zero sense.

[@nathanael114]

@@Driftking305forlife Glad you see it too - was wondering if I was losing my marbles

[@magallanthepenguin9132]

Jedi got humbled :)

[@deadmeat8754]

Only because their part was _written_ that way...duh!

[@TitusSmith-i6r]

Yay, Generation Tech!!!!🧡💛

[@brandonholland929]

Thank you! Star Wars is fucking fantasy!!!!! So refreshing to hear an authoritative voice say this!

[@GazingTrandoshan]

Thank yooou, Elzar Mann is a super cool jedi during the HR who had fell for a moment but felt fear in that but he had a support structure during the time where the Jedi at least tried to help you know, stuff Anakin needed so badly , to just be told itll be ok and get help with his feelings besides "dont have those"

[@hiedra68]

Mae's driven by love?? Mae is obsessed with Osha because she wants to control her, to force her to be like she wants her to be. She has a very toxic relationship with her sister, that's no love. She left Osha in the forest with the man she was running from. C'mon!

[@Vantud391]

It's love but toxic kind.

[@kainslegacy78618]

Yep, she was a toxic, possessive and hostile brat. Despite having had 16 years to grow, she hasn't changed. Still convinced that all of her problems are from outside influences misguiding and taking away her sister from her. The small amount of talk they have very much emphasized that, she does not respect that her sister makes her own choices and completely dismisses her agency. That is not love, it is obsession and delusional expectations.