A FULL FOOD REVIEW of JAMES MAY'S PUB!

[@jpht1964]

As a trained chef i can say that the plating is really a work of art. Definitely going to plan a visit. I give it a 10/10

[@GaryEats]

As a chef I really respect your score thank you

[@pvtjohntowle4081]

The kitchen has got their stuff together. They look like they have a passion for the food they cook by the end result. Thanks for this review GaryEats !!!!

[@shashimenon1000]

Despite the derisive expressions of Jeremy Clarkson in Top Gear, I always appreciated James May....for his simplicity, wierdness and downright honesty. No fancy stuff.

[@GaryEats]

I think James has done a great job

[@steve3291]

10 all day from me. What a beautiful place. I get sceptical about celebrity owners but James May really has done something special there.

[@GaryEats]

Steve I agree he has done a fantastic job

[@charlesconnaughton7292]

Didn't surprise me James may always been a class person beautifull thank you.

[@GaryEats]

He runs an excellent pub Charles

[@jaytonks8065]

Gary, what a gentleman you are. Down to earth, and, such an honest man. A rare breed to say the least. Love watching your content as it so relaxing humbling. I'm a massive foodie but as a result of anxiety and depression I struggle to eat at the best of times. But you inspire me to keep on going. And chase what I love. So thank you!

[@GaryEats]

That means a lot Jay. I'm really sorry to hear about the anxiety and depression and just wish you all the best. Times can be difficult but all we can all do is persevere!!

[@nigel8499]

10/10 from me for the cuisine. and a beautiful English countryside pub. Unbeatable. Tourists need to visit here.

[@GaryEats]

I agree Nigel 👌

[@justthetruth1]

Why?

[@timmellor2599]

@@justthetruth1 To ruin it for the locals and the English, of course!

[@justthetruth1]

​@@timmellor2599😂

[@MsSkippygirl]

Picture perfect location. Delicious food. 10/10 . What a real treat to watch. Thanks for taking us along with you. Absolutely fabulous. Thank you so very much.

[@GaryEats]

Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for the lovely comment

[@danquaylesitsspeltpotatoe8307]

@@GaryEats "hand cut cups" AKA inconsistently cut chips for inconsistently cooked chips!

[@juncusbufonius]

I would have given a 10. I think larger deserts are not good in modern dining. Too much sugar is not a good think and appreciating the other aspects should be compensation enough.

[@Therearetoomanyplonkers]

Love hearing those birds in the background. Seeing this is an antidote to a cold winters English day.

[@GaryEats]

It’s a great sound

[@neilwinkelmann8540]

The cars roaring past? Not-so-much.

[@Therearetoomanyplonkers]

@@neilwinkelmann8540 😂

[@Val-h4d]

These celebrity pubs are really top notch much better than the celebrity chefs ones . Shoulder of lamb is my favourite and that looked stunning massive 10

[@GaryEats]

I said that to the cameraman, they seem to get the correct chefs in 😃

[@hoilst265]

There's a reason why James beat Gordon Ramsay in a fish pie cook-off.

[@louisemorrison4496]

The food was a visual feast and the pub itself looked lovely - tempting !

[@GaryEats]

It was excellent cooking and wonderful food, Louise

[@momuv6980]

In my opinion, some of the most impressive plating & presentation of any of your restaurants. A feast for the eyes and soul! The food looked amazing and as I used to tell the preschoolers I cooked for, "Dessert is not the meal" so a petite, beautifully prepared portion for me is a big thumbs up! I would've given a 10 out of 10 based on quality of the food and plating. Bravo to Mr. May for revitalizing and improving a local establishment!😊❤ Another wonderful video, Gary! (BTW - With your first bite of lamb, I said to myself, "If it's amazing, he's going to lean back in his chair" and you did! I knew things were going to be positive from that point forward.😊)

[@GaryEats]

The presentation was absolutely spectacular, some of the best I’ve seen on the channel!

[@CaribbeanLife101]

That lamb did look delicious...the plating was exceptional. Thanks Gary

[@GaryEats]

Glad you enjoyed it and couldn’t agree more with you

[@matthewetheridge4535]

I can understand why ewe thought the lamb looked delicious!

[@CaribbeanLife101]

@@matthewetheridge4535 hahahaha good one 👍

[@robertleach9120]

What a lovely country pub both inside & out. Delightful surrounding area too & terrific spring weather. How nice was that soup. Looked great & tasted fantastic ! The braised shoulder of lamb made my mouth water just looking at it ! Lamb is my favourite also. Lucky you for being able to taste it Gary. The presentation of each dish is a work of art. 10/10 to their Chef !

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Robert I agree congratulations to the excellent chef 🧑‍🍳

[@shaunportlock4924]

That soup looked beautiful

[@men5m2k]

We stayed here last October for our anniversary, was absolutely brilliant. Friendly staff, great selection of beers. Food was incredible, well presented and good size. We stayed overnight and the room was really nice and good value. Really nice walks with the dog in the surrounding area too!

[@maksimlipecki232]

Stunning countryside landscape, delicious food, big portions and a relatively affordable price. Definitely worth visiting.

[@GaryEats]

I agree this is worth making a trip 👌

[@jamesbuckingham5771]

Congratulations James May!! Absolutely Magnificent 💯!! Cheers 🍸!!

[@GaryEats]

I agree with you completely, James

[@roberte5057]

You are such an honest foodie. Love it.

[@GaryEats]

That’s very kind to say, Robert thank you

[@bobinator17]

I feel that the Joy on your face, at multiple times, says it all... I hope to one day be able to enjoy that pubs food!

[@GaryEats]

This is definitely a pub I would recommend

[@garyfontanini9646]

I thought that pud was the perfect size for the meal, who wants to be bloated after a meal. Great channel Gary, nice to see a knowledgeable 'everyman' reviewing food and not a ponce like we normally get. 👍

[@GaryEats]

That is very kind to say thank you very much, Gary and maybe I was harsh on this occasion

[@annegraham4307]

@@GaryEatsI thought the dessert portion size was perfectly fine, especially after a first and main. If price for the size is the problem then perhaps the restaurant could reduce the price a wee bit. I feel that way in a lot of restaurants. I’d rather pay a little less for a smaller dessert since I’m usually too full for dessert but want to try a dessert. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇺🇸

[@johnbaldwin143]

Apart from the food which is excellent! I see a defibrillator on the wall. Now that is care and thought too.

[@GaryEats]

That is a very good point John thank you

[@johnbaldwin143]

@@GaryEats Just the way I think. Had to help a Bloke in Blackpool a few years ago. He lived but one of those would have been priceless!

[@michaelh7453]

Is that there due to the prices. Nearly £50 for one meal. Imagine taking the family, and add on the price of a few rounds, you are talking a week's wage. lol.

[@AJ-sv5qg]

Worth every penny. Looked absolutely fantastic

[@GaryEats]

It was fantastic

[@adrianmcgachie]

Excellent menu choice, Gary. They all looked like spring on a plate, and with the weather, and birds tweeting in the background, I was as relaxed as you were. I was a bit full by the time your pudding arrived just thinking about the first two dishes!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so much and appreciate you commenting. I hope the birds tweeting in the background added to the atmosphere Adrian

[@rogerlishman2532]

The man in the white van wasn't lost, he was taking in his share of aroma and meal presentation. Probably considering a visit to the pub in a few day's time!

[@GaryEats]

LOL brilliant Roger

[@rationalbacon5872]

You're really spoiling us with all this content Gary. Thank you and your long suffering cameraman.

[@waynemoore2248]

Don’t think the long suffering cameraman wasn’t on this video was he Gazza

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much and the cameraman’s absolutely fine, he films on every video and eats well 👌

[@waynemoore2248]

@@GaryEats just been to IKEA Gazza that dime bar cheese cake is damm 💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦

[@GaryEats]

Superb isnt it Wayne?

[@seantynan1]

Now, that is top notch food, beautifully presented, with the idyllic English countryside setting. Excellent stuff Gary!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much Sean 👌

[@starlucanyaart]

I like your channel because you go in little english and peaceful locations, and it's exactly my own philosophy of life (and i love ancient wood panel signs, it's absolutely beautiful), it's great to see villages that kept this traditional spirit. It's so full of life and soul.. Beside, i'm very happy to see someone stll able to appreciate the calm, the fresh air, the song of birds (it's true happiness!) while our society is too much captured by virtuality, smartphone and technology or need to have big shopping mall or nightclub to be happy. I'm french and i live in a big town, but my dream is to live in the countryside. But even outside in my town, I also always pay attention to the sound of the wind, the song of the birds and i keep my phone in my bag, because so many people are the noise in their phone, and don't realize anymore the presence of nature.. I find that it changes from the channels that goes mostly in big town and restaurants, with a big crowd.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you! I really love going to places like this!

[@cawstongreenway]

So pleased to see this pop up just now. Gonna grab a beer, sit back and enjoy this, that's for sure 😁

[@GaryEats]

Have a great evening and enjoy your 🍺

[@alasdairstuart3394]

We had dinner and a night’s stay last year. The meal was superb. The finest mushroom soup I have ever had - with goats cheese which surprised me but worked brilliantly - followed by venison which was perfectly cooked. All washed down with a lovely bottle of red which was very reasonably priced. It was a terrific dinner; they have a proper chef who really knows what he’s doing. And the service was excellent - polite, friendly - spot on for a place like this. The room was warm and cosy on what was a miserably wet night. Highly recommend 👍😊

[@jeto-gu5ni]

Looks like the perfect spot to sit outside and ❤enjoy a meal with family and friends .

[@GaryEats]

I agree with you completely a fantastic spot

[@brianjonas4654]

I am so in love with the English country side. Another great review Gray. Thank you so! Blessings from Texas,USA. 👍😊❤. 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@paullewis2413]

Yes, when the weather is good (not often enough kkk) the English Countryside is hard to beat that’s for sure. It’s great that unlike 20+ years ago there are many country pubs serving really good food though this one, The Royal Oak is exceptional.

[@alisonhinkley480]

I am a recent subscriber and now addicted, love the variety of restaurants and locations and Gary's positivity even when he gives a negative review..lets watch the channel grow 🤗

[@GaryEats]

I really appreciate that thank you Alison

[@pab777]

That to me was a quality posh pub dinning experience. Didn't expect Lamb shoulder to be presented like that. Shredded and a ramakin cooking process. Loved all ingredients Soup looked delightful. Thank you for the video. Its a 9. from me for that three course splendour.

[@ashku27]

Lamb would have been braised, 'pulled', rolled tightly in cling film to form large sausage type shapes while still warm, chilled, then portioned and reheated

[@pab777]

@@ashku27 Would you add gelatine/aspic like you would with a terrine? Thank you.

[@ashku27]

@@pab777 It doesn't need it if rolled super tightly. Adding a touch of reduced braising liquor will help though.

[@GaryEats]

This was great cooking with fabulous presentation 👌

[@747jono]

So refreshing to see you enjoying fresh excellently cooked food Gary . I am sick of food channels showing guys cooking (lol)warming up frozen ready meals and pies etc expecting good food to cost nothing. I shop in Aldi and Lidl and buy fresh food to cook at home. These guys just eat greasy processed food unbelievable. Lamb looks delicious slow cooked amazing easy dish 4 /5 hours in the oven fantastic. It's good value in my books mate . Satisfying when you get great quality and don't mind paying for it. We have great food in this country yet so many people don't know how to prepare it. Cheers take care

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so much Jono, take care of yourself

[@Raylufc]

Absolutely perfect 10/10 and the presentation 10 plus cheers Gary

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Ray

[@RealistGunner]

How can you give this a 10? Yes, the food is quality but the portion sizes aren’t going to fill up majority of people.

[@Raylufc]

@RealistGunner it will fill me up, but I'm old

[@davidwasher3292]

Always look forward to the notification of a new review. A fair and passionate review every time. Thank you Gary

[@GaryEats]

That’s very kind and appreciated David thank you

[@thaisstone5192]

(85) Well, once again, I did "What would I get?" and was thrilled you chose the soup starter. I just ADORE asparagus and after nearly 25 years of badgering, got my husband to eat some (PROPERLY) cooked asparagus and now he's a convert. I thought about the lamb, but the Aubergine dish sounded too good to pass up. I'm NOT a fan of "floral" flavors (except a bit of orange blossom water or rose water every so often) so it would have been the British cheese board for me and a glass of wine. The burger you had on your first go seemed OK at best, but the a la carte dining is where this place seems to shine. Thanks for the upload (hope the van driver found his destination) and happy you got another winner!!!

[@GaryEats]

Another huge asparagus fan, that’s great to hear

[@hoilst265]

Canned asparagus, which is how most people come across it, is a crime against cuisine.

[@paulclancy4221]

Instant 10/10 for being Dog friendly. They also have a heart defibrillator outside.

[@RubyMarkLindMilly]

Wow wow wow the pudding too looks incredible all in all what a fantastic meal you lucky sod 😋👍

[@GaryEats]

Thank you 😋

[@eahmed1000]

I feel for the cameraman 🤣🤣 he has a lot of patience

[@jennyli7749]

I wonder if the cameraman gets fed too

[@sivabalasingham9918]

Cameraman always getting fed by Gary😂

[@jennyli7749]

@@sivabalasingham9918 🤣

[@markdavies2825]

Yes either that, or the lost style twist will be he is a she...

[@unnamedchannel1237]

@tonynewman3631it’s just a contraption that is hooked to strings and pulleys and controlled by Gary’s feet

[@mathewdeu3328]

Three course meal....well worth it......the way the lamb melted...and the dessert....quality right there.

[@GaryEats]

I agree with you it was excellent quality

[@sensationalfailure]

It's always such a joy to see you enjoy good food.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so much, this was spectacular

[@lmak7285]

In a town where the wind whispers secrets sweet, Lived a man named Gary, with a hearty appetite to meet. With a fork for a wand and a spoon for a song, He danced through the day, never thinking it wrong. Gary eats with gusto, his palate knows no bounds, From crispy bacon mornings to moonlit seafood rounds. He feasts on laughter, savors every bite, With each meal a story, a journey in the night. In his kitchen, a symphony of sizzles and sighs, As flavors entwine beneath the starlit skies. He crafts culinary dreams, from dusk until dawn, In the tapestry of tastes, Gary's spirit lives on. So here's to Gary, the king of cuisine, Whose hunger for life is a sight to be seen. With each meal, a masterpiece, a work of art, Gary eats with passion, straight from the heart.

[@CheshireCat6639]

Brilliant 🎉🎉🎉

[@GaryEats]

My favourite comment thank you

[@hazelduerdoth4333]

That’s absolutely brilliant and spot on to 😃😃

[@hazelduerdoth4333]

@@GaryEatsthat’s a comment that will never be beaten ever 🤣🤣

[@mmmyeah7]

Brilliant stuff haha

[@sylviamatthee8172]

It looks amazing to me. How pub food has changed. Truly beautiful presentation, and it looked absolutely delicious. Well done, The Royal Oak. I'm glad that you had a good time.

[@GaryEats]

I agree congratulations to the pub Sylvia

[@VicYo-en3wm]

Presentation is awesome when food looks good and tastes good the experience is whole !!!

[@GaryEats]

I agree with you completely

[@drumstick74]

Amazing you had the place to yourself (compared to the Clarkson's pub I just watched). Food looked superb!

[@GaryEats]

We try not to film other customers, it was actually very busy, especially when I left, thinking about that, maybe it was me lol 😂

[@drumstick74]

@@GaryEats Haha, thanks for replying.😆 That is respectful (to not film other customers)...a lot of youtubers just start filming. It's not _illegal_ per se, but some people just don't want to be on camera.

[@JimCarner777]

@@drumstick74 *per se

[@drumstick74]

@@JimCarner777 Thanks! Edited and corrected.

[@JimCarner777]

@@drumstick74 You're welcome. Have a good one.

[@oliverdots]

I never understand why some restaurants can give a small portion of something that really doesn't cost much. To make a slightly bigger spounge would cost pennies.

[@BmanNL1]

Could be because of the balance in flavours between the different ingredients. In the end, Gary did not go home hungry 😂

[@markhill8150]

Same thing with small chip portions. Makes such a big difference to the customer for such a small cost.

[@alankirkby465]

​@@markhill8150Hello to you. Your comment, I've also often thought that myself. Peace to all.

[@alankirkby465]

@oliverdots Hello to you. I fully agree with your comment. I've often thought the same. Peace to all.

[@JanetBrown-px2jn]

As a pastry Chef in my opinion that’s a perfectly normal potion,and many people would not eat it all.

[@sandriagutierrez2605]

See, now I thought that was enough dessert🤷🏻‍♀️. Anyway, enjoyed watching. Seemed like such a relaxed, and charming place to spend an afternoon! Thanks

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Sandria and completely understand that, just looked small in my opinion

[@sandriagutierrez2605]

@@GaryEats and that is why it’s ’Gary Eats’ not Sandria Eats😉.

[@amandavokins5958]

Have eaten there often,never had a bad meal.lovely setting.

[@sandriagutierrez2605]

@@amandavokins5958 😊

[@erik3371]

Happy new year Gary! Thanks for last year it was fun following you. Watching or rewatching this one because I can't remember if i saw it or not.

[@GaryEats]

Happy New year to you too

[@andrewroberts4736]

That soup looked really good as did the lamb. Shoulder of Lamb is my favourite meat for a roast dinner so I would have ordered that! It's so succulent. That was a very good dish. I would have been very happy with that. I really think that pudding was as pretty as a picture. My aunt in Australia used to make lemon curd and I have always loved it! The whole meal was worth every penny. It's a 10. Thanks for taking us here Gary.

[@GaryEats]

You’re more than welcome Andrew and a great comment

[@GordonCraig-t8g]

10 all day. Sponge/sorbet/lemon curd proportions were perfect. You tight git, Gary 😊

[@edwardsp1916]

Hi James, I enjoyed you in Top Gear.

[@andywatts8654]

It was a full ten

[@JameelQ]

Totally agree with you, that was a defo 10/10 Gary just being mean and nit picking.

[@davidharkness1042]

I agree he wants quantity over Quality

[@GaryEats]

Sorry to use your comment to reply to all, the price of the dessert was £8.50 it tasted fantastic however as a portion I believe the sponge was small, the sorbet was almost the same size, I marked the restaurant as a 9.5, this wasn’t like I said an 8, if you are happy with that portion then perfect, this is just my personal opinion. Would I recommend definitely 💯

[@RobinPalmerTV]

That looks great and a+++ they’ve got a defib outside!

[@GaryEats]

Good point Robin

[@terryjohnson7389]

Another great review Gary i certainly miss quality UK pub food here in Brazil.

[@GaryEats]

This was quality Terry 🇧🇷

[@pippin1ful]

Me too in Gascony, France.

[@valentincodrean4937]

Thank you for your videos. I got a really bad last months and seeing you having that nice meals and hearing your voice makes me think that not all is falling apart and that in the world are still normal people living 😊

[@GaryEats]

I really really hope things improve for you dramatically please take care

[@angiemackellow8004]

Guaranteed every time, well done James, Always top class

[@GaryEats]

I agree congratulations to James great job

[@irevisibel9237]

Treat to watch, will definitely visit the Royal Oak!

[@GaryEats]

Very good and thank you

[@bobburroughs6241]

Wonderful and a perfect score Gary.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much as always, Bob

[@Sally50534]

I always look forward to your videos Gary.😊

[@GaryEats]

So nice of you Sally

[@markboon341]

Wonderful review as always. I would definitely recommend this to friends down south❤

[@GaryEats]

That’s wonderful to hear, thank you, Mark

[@sheilam4525]

What a beautiful setting, Gary and great food😊

[@GaryEats]

It was excellent food and a lovely pub Sheila

[@CheshireCat6639]

Its cruel Mr G whilst i am on a ready made lasagne n garlic bread😮 that looked darn yummy. Lamb is a winner for me too. Ty for sharing 🎉 and yes a big 👍 to Mr May 🎉

[@GaryEats]

I’m having Lasagne tonight lol 😂

[@CheshireCat6639]

@@GaryEats haha tbf it was ok...hope yours is home made tho..i do a mean one in the slow cooker!..enjoy Mr G ...🥂🍽🍷

[@LindaDemaggio]

Bravo Gary! What a great place! For the first time, I have to disagree with you on the portion size of the dessert. I often share a dessert after such a meal because I’m pretty full but want just a little something sweet to end the meal. I thought the dessert was perfect! The food looked extraordinary. Your review as well. So nice to see you enjoy yourself on such beautiful day. Loved this episode, your channel keeps getting better and better! As always, Linda from Laguna 😊😊🏄🏻‍♀️🏄🏻‍♀️🐳🐳🧜🏼‍♀️🧜🏼‍♀️💕💕

[@GaryEats]

You couldn’t share this one Linda as was a little small, how are you keeping and all good in Laguna Beech 🇺🇸 x

[@Richard-yd1ws]

@@GaryEatsYes restaurants get away with small portions, arguing that’s what their women customers prefer

[@boondocksaint7737]

I have to visit the Royal Oak. Looks amazing

[@GaryEats]

It is definitely worth a visit

[@CinSpain]

I seem to have started a Sunday binge on your videos today 😂 Thank you for them, you are such a kind person, and you really enjoy your food. The food is so different and it's been a pleasure to see your puddings, curries and sauce, through your eyes. Thank you ❤

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much, glad you're enjoying the videos

[@marilyngoossens1379]

Hi Gary Oh that lamb looked Devine!my mouth was watering ,the whole meal looked delicious. X

[@GaryEats]

All round this was really good and a wonderful location x

[@johnmcclements9358]

Lamb looks stupendous ❤

[@GaryEats]

It was top John

[@ManCityCheats130]

Live in Brazil now, but English country pubs in the summer are something I really miss. There's nothing better in the whole world! Cheers.

[@GaryEats]

I agree with you completely

[@ManCityCheats130]

@GaryEats you stated that you welcome any suggestions. You keep stating that you've put a little bit of weight on. Well, I always say, never trust a skinny food critic or observer. Food has never really been important to me, probably because I lived in Holland for 15 years before meeting my missus, and now in Brazil. I stumbled across your videos and can't stop watching them. I am very enjoyable and hope you have every success in the future, mate. Come on England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

[@Richard-gk3kq]

Looked really nicely presented quality food.

[@GaryEats]

It was definitely that Richard

[@RubyMarkLindMilly]

Lovely to go for a treat what a beautiful meal I'm genuinely overwhelmed in how good it all looks 😊

[@GaryEats]

It's so good!

[@riffraff6506]

Excellent review ,just flicking through the comments and I can’t believe you take the time to reply to so many.i take my hat off to you,a true gentlemen

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much

[@suzanheywood]

The whole meal looked really good. Presentation was excellent and the portions looked very good to me.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you 😋

[@paulc1553]

Always look forward to your videos, Gary. Chicken soup for the soul, mate. Paul xxx.

[@GaryEats]

Cheers 🍻 Paul x

[@paulc1553]

@@GaryEats: Pleasure, pal xxx.

[@Pots57]

Worth the ticket just for the lamb🎉made my mouth water literally nice one ❤️

[@GaryEats]

The lamb was sensational

[@zoltanlapicz9117]

Absolutely loved this revue that lamb looked amazing.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much

[@randomcro24]

such a beautiful relaxing video great work the food looks delightful

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much

[@charleswillcock3235]

Most dinners if they had your three courses would have been fine with the desert portion size, and would have gone 10/10.

[@GaryEats]

Maybe I was a little harsh Charles

[@charleswillcock3235]

@@GaryEats They might have heard you mention you were putting on a bit of timber in your intro. Congratulations on your presentational style. Absolutely first class. I hope you share some of the food with your cameraman.

[@pamelaallan6521]

@@GaryEats its the cost of it, you could have taken some home to enjoy half another day. putting timber on lol haha , funny expression, go with your gut.

[@glenn5328]

That’s what a country pub should be like. Really looked great…..think you were slightly harsh over the sponge size! At least you didn’t knock them down a point for the van passing by!!

[@GaryEats]

Spot on and maybe a bit harsh!!

[@StutterBoyECFC]

When you said: "The phrase," I instantly said: "Melt in your mouth." I know! I said it instantly, as in without stuttering! How good!

[@GaryEats]

The lamb was sensational

[@malcpaul996]

Been a couple of times with my family. Food is perfect and will have to go again after Xmas.

[@GaryEats]

That is wonderful to hear

[@gaz-8721]

Of all the reviews you done Gary, this one strangely caught my eye the most, and I've probably watched 99% of them. For some reason, the more I looked, the more I fell in love with this idyllic countryside pub. Absolutely agree, would be lovely to visit on a hot summers day with the smell of the fresh countryside breeze, even to just call in for a tipple. I wasn't expecting such high quality food to be served in such a quaint little pub. Head chef, Jonny Sutcliffe, and the team certainly know how to deliver when it comes to quality cuisine. Every dish looked spectacular. It certainly looked like you enjoyed the food, no arguments there. Not so sure I would have deducted half a point on the dessert, but then again, I'm more of a 'starters and main' type of guy. Possibly a 10 for me, but it's difficult to judge, as you would need to be there experiencing everything first hand in order to give a true score. What I do like though is that every dish created, is made from fresh locally sourced produce. This means the menu changes frequently in accordance to what is in season at the time. So the next time you visit, there is a high probability you will be presented with a range of fresh new dishes. For me, this adds to the excitement when returning, instead of mulling over the same old menu. Price wise, giving the status of being a celebrity owned pub, I would have expected it to be a lot more expensive. I could imagine sourcing their ingredients locally helps keep the price down, along with strategic and versatile thinking when creating a menu. If you take for example their 8oz flat iron steak, an excellent alternative to more expensive cuts like ribeye and sirloin. Hats off to James May for the investment and teaming up with landlord Chris Byett. They transformed this once rough, over-grown and neglected building into the perfect little, world renowned, gem it is today. Their website provides an insight into the history of the bulding from c.1705 to present, along with spectacular pictures. For me, knowing a little about the history of the restaurant certainly adds to the experience. If I ever make it to that neck of the woods, I will definitely make this a stop over and make use of one of those luxury rooms. Gary, you never disappoint. Your reviews are as honest as anyone can make them and as always, look forward to seeing the next one. From me and all your viewers, thank you so much.

[@GaryEats]

I really appreciate this wonderful comment. I think the setting with the weather, the birds and the village contribute to a wonderful atmosphere and experience.

[@Youtube-Censorship-Police]

for once gary could cross the road without being chased by cars and he appreciated it, love the subtle humor😂👍 the food looked gorgeous and was obviously made with love, wow!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you as always have a fantastic weekend

[@Youtube-Censorship-Police]

you too gary!

[@GodsDogICXC]

Solid stuff. Wholesome channel bro

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much

[@TimK2646]

Why isn't Gary dancing around a MAYPOLE ready for the sacrifice like WOODWARD in Wicker man

[@julianmeek2156]

That's an idea. Singed cuckoo and flame-grilled manchops... "Let's give it a go..."

[@GaryEats]

😳😂

[@user-vr1mu9eb3p]

Hi gary , had to watch this again at james mays Pub, the menu was quite special and the lovely bird chirpy location .

[@GaryEats]

James has done well at this pub

[@virgil_tb2]

Hey Gary, thanks for another great review. So glad you returned to JM’s pub, the food looked tremendous. Definitely a 10/10 for me…presentation, value and quality there for all to appreciate. The lamb looked perfect. Another observation, not only was the soup served with bread, but a proper soup spoon too…as it should be. I’ve said it before and I will say it again, best YT channel mate!

[@GaryEats]

My pleasure Virgil. Thank you so much and appreciate you commenting

[@georgebethune7315]

That Lamb looked amazing 😮

[@GaryEats]

So good!it was fantastic 💯 George

[@IansOddInterests]

Fabulous… anyone who can step in and save a pub is ok by me …. That statement you made … a true Brit. 👍

[@GaryEats]

I agree completely

[@user-xs9fp3ic9y]

Yes expensive but all local products. The pork sausage roll looked lovely. The lamb looked good too 😋😋.

[@GaryEats]

It was excellent

[@moto3463]

Beautiful spot beautiful food and atmosphere 10/10.

[@GaryEats]

James has done very well here

[@MrVulcanbomber]

Beautiful location, and stunning food, ooooh that lamb is just mouth watering 🐑 fair score there 👍

[@GaryEats]

This is definitely worth a visit and well done to James

[@Brasc]

There once was a man named Gary Who's pursuit for good food ne'er did tarry From starter to meal, from amount to good deal And his viewers he did leave merry

[@nigel8499]

Lol

[@GaryEats]

lol all of these poems 🤣

[@marpop99]

Nooooo. That dessert was fine (oink oink) Harsh. 10/10

[@priesty4783]

I agree, but I'm not sure why KZbin offered to translate your comment to English 🤔

[@GaryEats]

No problem 🐷

[@gauravipal9518]

For £8.50 the size was a tad small. Had they charged a little less, I M sure Gary wouldn't have dinged them. Seems like a value for money issue.

[@MySkyranger]

Don’t forget to feed the cameraman😂

[@GaryEats]

He is my son and I always feed him

[@hulme187]

I've only recently discovered your channel and I'm enjoying your reviews. Great job!!

[@GaryEats]

Awesome, thank you!

[@clairejones3919]

Cooked with love for the ingredients and eaten with care and love also. Really enjoying these videos. Haven’t got out and about at all in 2024, working too much, but storing up these excellent places for 2025. Thanks Gary

[@GaryEats]

Slow down with the working life is too short Claire

[@tonyluff5856]

Being harsh personally the desert seemed enough especially that quality

[@GaryEats]

Yes I was harsh on this one Tony

[@Dodas302]

James may is a great man 💯

[@heathermartin8932]

I`ve got a story about James May that would twist yer melon...sadly not repeatable here due to graphic and adult content.

[@GaryEats]

I think he is a great character 💯

[@markhicks5471]

Should have been a 10 +, knocking off just because u thought the sponge was too small, definitely unfair

[@GaryEats]

Maybe I was a bit harsh Mark but still a great score 🤷‍♂️

[@aquaticspasticp5024]

Not at all if it's small then it doesn't reflect on the customer more the selfishness of the owners! Those ingredients are cheap to buy!

[@maiadonkitchen7009]

Thank you Sir for the review!!!! Fan from Anchorage Alaska!

[@TheAvarusAnimus]

Lemon curd looks like egg yolks! Delicious!Looking forward to visiting...

[@GaryEats]

I think James has done a great job here