A Perfect Circle Feat Stone And Echo

[@thesunpilots]

One of my fave live videos! Times for each song: 0:00 Annihilation (Crucifix) 03:53 Imagine (John Lennon) 08:35 Weak And Powerless 12:05 The Hollow 15:08 Rose 18:47 Blue 24:02 What's Going On (Marvin Gaye) 28:57 People Are People (Depeche Mode) 32:52 The Outsider 37:15 Peace,Love And Understanding (Brinsley Schwarz) 42:04 When The Levee Breaks (Kansas Joe McCoy & Memphis Minnie) 48:32 The Noose 53:57 3 Libras (All Main Courses Mix) 1:00:27 The Package 1:08:40 Gimmie,Gimmie,Gimmie (Black Flag) 1:12:20 Orestes 1:18:09 Passive 1:23:52 Counting Bodies Like Sheep,To The Rhythm Of The War Drum 1:29:50 Fiddle And The Drum (Joni Mitchell) 1:33:14 By And Down

[@annamsernas]

e,

[@joshuaspong7913]

+The Sunpilots This needs to be top comment.

[@HACtool]

+The Sunpilots Some heroes do not wear layer :v

[@hectorsalinas101]

+The Sunpilots, a top comment for you kind sir.

[@C70W11]

+The Sunpilots Thanks, helped a lot

[@PrincessSilverDawn]

Best accident I've had in years stumbled across A Perfect Circle I'm a happy hippie today Peace & love

[@annabellgrey7657]

Absolute Peace to you and congratulations on finding this “ peace of mind “ for Maynard’s brilliance!!!! ☮️☮️☮️☮️☮️

[@papajay111]

I'm just happy as f*ck MJK is with us in this life!!!

[@MariekeKopinskaya]

I love this concert, the sound is amazing and the versions are incredible. And OMG BILLY YOU ARE SO BEAUTIFUUUUL.

[@RG1570L]

50,000 Views, thanks for choosing My Channel to view this show :)

[@sarahbojangles1]

I probably listen to it every day hehe. Best concert of all..wish I were there. \m/

[@damonkoh489]

RG1570L May I know how did you get this footage? I would like to keep a copy

[@FenSiriunIxx]

RG1570L This'd be my second time around, the first time gave me my first impression of APC.

[@techslam]

RG1570L its APC....expect more....

[@sarevok6]

I'm sad they dont play Judas live. Easily the coolest song they have

[@kevin43324332]

Saw perfect circle 3x now (TOOL like 4)...... I think Maynards voice was insanely great in the late 00's to mid 2010's.. Still GREAT on both ends but he really challenged himself during these years.

[@turian_noises]

I haven't found any comment about Howerdel's awesome voice, so here it is.

[@ZenLina47]

yes the combination from his and maynards voice is so epic!

[@ArdentK9]

agreed, he is incredibly underrated on both guitars and his vocals.. the amalgamation of maynard and billy is simply beautiful.

[@TC-lk2ev]

Shit yeah the harmonies are awesome.

[@julevasquez]

Billy is awsome!

[@nancymcdaniel1903]

Agreed...his voice is beautiful.

[@welders4truth135]

BEST BANDS OF "ALL" TIME!!! APC!!! TOOL & PUSCIFER!!! MAYNARD IS THE VOICE OF MY GENERATION!!!! NO QUESTION!!! ❤🎶🎸🥁❤🎸🎶🥁❤❤❤

[@kayshuhart]

going to sessanta in april!!! APC Puscifer & Primus!!!!!!!!

[@suesanc1]

You my friend are right not only genx but history in the making . Maynard is Midas

[@Richard-du7yj]

Absolutely!! He has continually pushed it to another level with everything he has done. From Undertow to fear innoculem he raised the bar. A true master. Everything he touches turns to gold.

[@cpgilliam7]

Exactly!!! My son introduced me to them when we were on a road trip. He's 39 that was when he was 15. Maynard, no.matter....whoever he's rocking with is THE BOMB❤❤❤❤

[@HERMETICSUBROSA]

Anything dude touches....

[@dclarkmusic]

Why this isn't universally accepted as musical excellence is beyond me!

[@RyanDavis-xl6vn]

Algarythm dosnt share outside boxes so no new fans for anyone...😮

[@carolineboves4043]

Well, that is because humanity is not advanced enough to comprehend this level of excellence 😅

[@QuestionOfHeaven]

01. Annihilation 1:43 02. Imagine 3:53 03. Weak and Powerless 8:49 04. The Hollow 12:09 05. Rose 15:10 06. Blue 19:40 07. What's Going On 24:05 08. People are People 28:58 09. The Outsider 32:54 10. Peace, Love and Understanding 37:18 11. When the Levee Breaks 42:04 12. THE NOOSE 48:38 13. 3 Libras 53:58 14. The Package 1:00:29 15. Gimmie, Gimmie, Gimmie 1:08:43 16. Orestes 1:12:22 17. Passive 1:18:13 XX. "Encore" 1:22:33 18. Counting Bodies Like Sheep, to the Rhythm of the War Drum 1:23:54 19. Fiddle and the Drum 1:29:54 20. By and Down 1:33:16

[@arrianne311]

QuestionOfHeaven Bless you sir.

[@SunDedGon]

QuestionOfHeaven LOVE YOU LOVE YOU LOVE YOU

[@RyuatNight]

QuestionOfHeaven thanks

[@tutsybassista]

Does anyone have the set list for their December 2nd show in Portland, OR?

[@atlantisfunktions]

outsider brings me to tears! so good

[@Ghost-fe1vp]

NOTMYWORK 0:00 Annihilation (Crucifix) 03:53 Imagine (John Lennon) 08:35 Weak And Powerless 12:05 The Hollow 15:08 Rose 18:47 Blue 24:02 What's Going On (Marvin Gaye) 28:57 People Are People (Depeche Mode) 32:52 The Outsider 37:15 Peace,Love And Understanding (Brinsley Schwarz) 42:04 When The Levee Breaks (Kansas Joe McCoy & Memphis Minnie) 48:32 The Noose 53:57 3 Libras (All Main Courses Mix) 1:00:27 The Package 1:08:40 Gimmie,Gimmie,Gimmie (Black Flag) 1:12:20 Orestes 1:18:09 Passive 1:23:52 Counting Bodies Like Sheep,To The Rhythm Of The War Drum 1:29:50 Fiddle And The Drum (Joni Mitchell) 1:33:14 By And Down

[@chronic_johnson_a.r.a.b]

What a setlist!

[@RodHammett95]

to the top!

[@Thedawg88]

You're the best 👊

[@emmybegood12]

Thank you for this!

[@welders4truth135]

Thank you man+! I use this every time I wanna hear a certain song

[@MrDjfacepunch]

Whenever Maynard nails the scream in The Outsider, an angel kicks a coldplay fan in the balls.

[@dclarkmusic]

Ow oof my balls!

[@janmeier6496]

Do YOU want to be kicked in the balls, J.D. Ward?

[@hermonsinurat8814]

36:07

[@42Jed]

I think this is my favorite KZbin comment.

[@mbloom99]

I'm glad I'm not a Dave Mathews fan.

[@immrnoidall]

Omg. I came back to find the , the LIVE - Libras (All Main Courses Mix) I remembered hearing. I can't believe it has been 5 years since I was here.

[@TheDrNojo]

Orestes, sounds more than perfect in this live, amazing and better than the original.

[@Agozlan048]

totally! i'm listening to this take endlessly

[@rrh2786]

1:15:55

[@1210ksmith]

Orestes is such a beautiful song. Unbelievable musicianship.

[@yosshy4774]

The version from 2010, which is included in the Live CD for Mer De Noms, is better. Although both are their best versions.

[@jeromed2]

I don't want to feel this overwhelming hostility, I just don't :-)

[@josephleonard3696]

This is one of the best concerts ever, by anyone! Embarrassingly, I never listened to A Perfect Circle before 2023. I've been a Tool fan since 2000, but was ignorant to A Perfect Circle. Billy Howerdel is amazing! This band is stacked with talent. I pray I can see A Perfect Circle in person someday. 🙏

[@lobato87]

hands up if Clever brought you this far and Tricky got you in!

[@tuningintoDivineAscension]

lmao, love it!

[@lauranroger]

Lmfao hell yeah!

[@Marinaaa3]

That Levee cover at 40 minutes .. everything maynard touches turns to gold.

[@jubankta1627]

That’s Led Zeppelin sweetheart

[@theendistheend123]

@@jubankta1627 that's Memphis Minnie and Kansas Joe McCoy sweetheart.

[@f.collado]

A Perfect Circle live at A Perfect Place feat. A Perfect Performance

[@welders4truth135]

Nailed it!!! ❤❤❤

[@mattreinecke6260]

I've lost count of how many times I have listened to this concert while I work. I've seen TOOL 4 times, Puscifer once (twice more in November) and I NEED to see APC and then the circle of Maynard is complete for me

[@davidg19741]

You have to, they really rock live, more than u think their album would. Must see!!!

[@timmay6634]

Or you WANT to see them and NEED to HEAR APC. So you square the circle? imho

[@elizadouchecanoe1542]

I know why you're here, listener... Orestes starts at 1:12:20 You're welcome.

[@ginofactap]

Eliza Douchecanoe thanks!

[@TheHopporto]

+Eliza Douchecanoe thanks fam

[@dathioz]

+Eliza Douchecanoe that song hits home every time

[@samuelsara9299]

+Eliza Douchecanoe That's very sweet of you, but most of us are here for By and Down at 1:33:10. ; )

[@darkwing1128]

my favorite apc song

[@pennymutz]

One of the VERY BEST singers to ever grace a stage. Not to mention the VERY BEST musicians on the planet. This whole band compliments each other just as good as tool. I don't think Maynard could put out anything bad when it comes to music. ABSOLUTLY LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS GUY AND HIS INTELLIGENCE!!!! HES BY FAR ONE OF THE BEST OUT THERE. 100% SCIENTIFIC FACTS

[@rebuddle4]

Got engaged to this very show on this very night ! perfection and now I have memories for life!

[@TheSludger]

Absolutely amazing: PERFECT executions, they sound even better than in studio.

[@RG1570L]

I agree totally

[@jubankta1627]

Close studio is a lil better only bcause they dialed it in closer to what they intended it to be I did not like 3 libras here why take a song so perfect and slow it and change it so musically it’s less than a cover

[@lucasmartin2489]

99% agree. i love so much this band but i hate this 3 libras version.

[@bradmohr8098]

@@lucasmartin2489 it's just the Massive Attack version

[@j.m.provencher1677]

Yeah couldn’t have said it better

[@swiftbunny88171]

The two people that disliked it are not humans, they are reptilians. Amazing show, I have been enjoying letting it play while I spark up and get captivated by Maynards voice along with the excellent musical accompany.

[@RyanDavis-xl6vn]

Those were accident dislikes. Or they are mad they werent there!😂

[@zaidatique9349]

OMFG..when the levee breaks

[@dclarkmusic]

Zaid Atique right! Might be one of the best covers ever

[@milohasagun]

i came

[@papajay111]

IMAGINE,,, (sung in NIGHTMARE MODE)!!! fucking right on man

[@cherylwantz2179]

How is it possible this doesn't have 71 millions views? Maynard rules the universe....

[@dkvon]

Everything Maynard touches becomes gold.

[@erstermontag908]

MJK's voice is exceptional , the rhythm section is extraordinary. remarkable show, in general.

[@kcottleaprn]

36:08. MJK signature.

[@Linkubiss]

im in love

[@kma86]

​@@kcottleaprnsometimes (or maybe most of the time) I come to the video just to listen to that scream. Perfection and absolutely satisfying!

[@BillyChrist-r2k]

Happy Sessenta to Maynard! Amazing band! My dude is 60 and he just keeps getting better. His voice is aging like his wine.

[@timothylancewalker267]

The More i learn about my self,The younger I become How much do we still get to learn before thy exact moment that we begin.

[@kollinasbury]

Elaborate

[@kollinasbury]

Please 😮

[@SaladoElFede]

Truth is, this is a masterpiece. I don't care how much sound post-production is on it, they are true musicians, and they played it LIVE! This concert was really powerful, and APC is still an underrated band

[@johnl1686]

Federico Vázquez I appreciate the extra production for this video. Sounds way better than most of the videos shot with someone's phone

[@kollinasbury]

Exactly. I thought the same after my first listen

[@shawnsmith4616]

Under-rated according to who or by who? People with less talent can't under-rate anything, they simply aren't qualified. Sorry but the cliche "under-rated" comments get to me. Is a passive aggressive way of saying that you know better than who is in question. They are highly respected in the business and Maynard is one of the most successful singers of all time so please explain how they are under-rated.

[@federicovazquez7989]

@@shawnsmith4616 I get your point, I'll just say that your comment does the same thing you are complaining about. Which is just, like... your opinion, man.

[@shawnsmith4616]

yes. Nothing more than an opinion. Not a right or wrong thing. "Complaining" is a bit of a stretch, don't you think? @@federicovazquez7989

[@celsoborralho1972]

Billy has a ridiculously beautiful voice...

[@tuningintoDivineAscension]

Maynard is Medicine. 💜🙏💯✔🎶🎹🎼🎤🎸

[@SelimxBradley]

great show and great job by the sound engineer.

[@rocketboy9127]

0:00 Annihilation (Crucifix) 03:53 Imagine (John Lennon) 08:35 Weak And Powerless 12:05 The Hollow 15:08 Rose 18:47 Blue 24:02 What's Going On (Marvin Gaye) 28:57 People Are People (Depeche Mode) 32:52 The Outsider 37:15 Peace,Love And Understanding (Brinsley Schwarz) 42:04 When The Levee Breaks (Kansas Joe McCoy & Memphis Minnie) 48:32 The Noose 53:57 3 Libras (All Main Courses Mix) 1:00:27 The Package 1:08:40 Gimmie,Gimmie,Gimmie (Black Flag) 1:12:20 Orestes 1:18:09 Passive 1:23:52 Counting Bodies Like Sheep,To The Rhythm Of The War Drum 1:29:50 Fiddle And The Drum (Joni Mitchell) 1:33:14 By And Down

[@fyou2327]

THANK YOU!

[@jcp509]

THANK YOUUUUUU

[@Heisen-d3n]

up

[@elliotmorley9075]

Thank you 🙏

[@MoZaHo]

I must have watched this show over and over and over. The entire show is perfect. Song choice, to execution of every single song. APC are legends. Love it

[@nicolast.5648]

One of the best show ever.

[@RG1570L]

500,000 + views!! i haven't commented on here for a while, but im so lucky that the video wasn't reported! thank you all for subscribing, watching this epic performance thank you

[@melissagypsyconnors9382]

2024 a long time Tool fan CAN'T BELIEVE IVE NEVER HEARD OF PERFECT CIRCLE OR PUSCIFER?? WTF? HIW FAR WAS MY HEAD UP MY OWN ASS TO BE OBLIVIOUS.....AND HOLY SHIT!!! HOW HE COVERS " IMAGINE"... AND MY HEART, JONI MITCHELL'S " FIDDLE,& THE DRUM" IM FUCKIN SPEECHLESS. .😮

[@havi.1197]

You must be trolling. If not, welcome!

[@StefaanBoel]

The Noose!!! Even more goosbumps in this live version!

[@thebookdoc.writing.and.editing]

Some of the most beautiful modern music. Learn to count in 3 or 6 or 17.

[@BigSkinny29]

Studio quality every. single. time.!!! You would think you were sitting in on the recording of the CD. Maynard is a phenom. Pure magic.

[@mohamedfarouk824]

“Whats going on “best cover ever 👌🏽🎯

[@robertgowdey]

Billy has a great voice. Underrated.

[@jckzz]

I saw them not long after this was recorded in Australia. Billy absolutely nailed it, especially during Imagine.

[@janineschmidt3822]

Das geht so dermaßen ins Herz❤😢... ich liebe euch dafür❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉...seit Jahren ❤❤❤❤

[@seanburgess3259]

WOW They're better live!!!! 👍👌

[@tutsybassista]

Why doesn't this have a M views by now?

[@FlyingWhale213]

A Perfect Music.

[@titobikegarage]

es una cosa de locos el sonido que tiene, se ve que a la banda le encanta eso, que locura!!!...

[@mikequintanilla114]

Billy absolutely nails the guitar solo on The Package....can't wait to see them next week in San Antonio....

[@JerryDodge]

This was so great that 55 people accidentally liked it up-side-down! Impressive!

[@pitbulllover76]

I dislike the video, because most people go to see them because of Maynard, but you barely see him at all, just a figure, in this video. I have seen Tool 5 times, amazing shows, and A Perfect Circle once, another great show. I think this performance is awesome, but again, you don't really see the LEAD man. He doesn't like the limelight, which doesn't make sense, he shouldn't be in any bands for that matter. Performance=good, video=not good.

[@JerryDodge]

Puscifer on the other hand, while a similar situation (Maynard's off to the sides), he at least likes to make an appearance. I saw Puscifer here in Louisville this past 4/20, and he was wearing his glasses inside of his wrestling mask bahahahaha

[@pitbulllover76]

Now thats pretty funny! I am sure the rest of Tool are pretty upset with him going off and doing other things!

[@ryanmustain6545]

Orestes and By and Down will fulfil your day.

[@aankaa452]

I cant ever describe how much I love it. I so wish I was there back then. Love you Billy, Maynard and all APC members. Hope to see your concert one day live.

[@mikequintanilla114]

at 1:05:30 Billy gives a little hand signal before diving into his guitar solo and I gotta say he absolutely nails it....this live performance has gotta be one of the best live performances I've seen this band put on.....

[@bsc479]

I was born before this, but I wish I was alive back then.

[@Jeff.Heatwole]

I saw this same set live standing in the front row in front of Billy and he threw my roommate and I some picks. His stage presence and musical sensitivity gave me chills and some of those harmonies with Maynard make me tear up hearing them in this video. Just an insane musical experience.

[@tommyjones9121]

"This is the part where where we walk off and come back on pretending we weren't going to come back but then we do... This is not the exiting band you were looking for... And we're back!"

[@Spiritcrusher86]

The best APC concert I've seen on KZbin, thank you for uploading (y)

[@ManJunk427]

Soo good too see James found a good home.....after the Pumpkins Smashed up

[@c0smo263]

When you can sound just as good, if not better than you do in the studio, that's when you know you've got it.

[@kleinwong_]

I don't think I've ever heard a better rendition of Counting Bodies Like Sheep

[@bariswheel]

The vocal harmonies on top of everything are just exceptional. What a fitting name for a band. Outstanding artists.

[@ronmckee9019]

Man i wish i was able to make this actual concert tonight in NY. A Perfect Circle, Puscifer & Primus. P P P Perfect! Oh, how amazing it must be!!!!! I will 100% Not Miss the Next Show!!

[@bobrobert1123]

I was at this show!

[@fromkeajra]

Thank you so much for this stunning performance. Much bops were had in my room x

[@pablorodrigocalvo]

7 people are perfect squares

[@genhuiesperanto3923]

pablo calvo hahahaha

[@DukeGibo]

The Hollow was my song back in the day on repeat

[@smash666]

This is unbelievable!

[@benbrennan4953]

The Noose performance. WooooooowW. Always gives me chills down the spine!!

[@humbertocarneiro07]

Shame this felt like a farewell concert! Impressive vocal performance and great crowd! Worth every second!Thanks!

[@kat1york]

FOR LAYNE: "We only die completely if the memory dies as well" ~MJK~

[@fosgate375]

This is an excellent concert. I'm just over an hour and 20 minutes into it and it's blowing me away.

[@tensuitengu7695]

ONE OF THE BEST MUSIC THAT HUMAN CAN CREATE IS THIS LIVE

[@KaptenBlaupf92]

The scream in the outsider was so fucking perfect! Almost perfect vocals through the whole show!

[@millerkmd1]

+Oscar Bergenholtz auto-tune.

[@KaptenBlaupf92]

+Kevin mc donnell yeah right.

[@millerkmd1]

This whole show is completely processed and over dubbed in post. Let me clear, I'm a MASSIVE fan , just don't want people thinking this is live. It's not.

[@KaptenBlaupf92]

+Kevin mc donnell well.. There is no autotune on his voice, thats for sure!

[@millerkmd1]

hahahaha! seriously?? trust me, im not just here blowing my own trumpet but ive an honours degree in music production and i did my whole thesis on auto-tune/pitch correction, TRUST ME. there is a SHIT load of auto tune on all the vocals. i dont know how educated u are on the subject so ill not go into it but for now why dont u just youtube a shitty fan vid of them live and listen to the differnece in the pitching

[@nikkilynn5694]

Yes agree watch this almost every night... this concert is just too perfect! Even if its from years ago...

[@tutsybassista]

I still listen to the 2000 show!

[@RG1570L]

Thank You, Enjoy!

[@thedoveston6781]

RG1570L btw is your username a postcode by any chance?

[@sergioajaimes]

+the doveston thats an Ibanez electric guitar model, AFAIK... A left handed one...

[@aibanhoe]

version of what s going on of marvin gaye is my favvvv

[@elbayis7181]

I can’t believe it Orestes sound amazing

[@abick8725]

I came across this video - Been a fan for some time, since the formation of this band really as I was a huge Tool fan before these guys (I saw the original Mer De Noms tour back when Maynard would come out wearing nothing but a pair of skivvies)…lol….never realized they covered “What’s Goin On?”. Didn’t know it was possible, but having been raised on Marvin Gaye, I have even more respect for them than I already did.

[@linkenski]

Fuuuuck, he nailed it perfectly! 36:08

[@xXeddie92Xx]

its maynard of course he nailed it

[@tomashradil3994]

I know it sucks when you're at the gig and it is raining, but this had to be brilliant

[@RG1570L]

03/17/2019 810,498 views! Almost 1,000,000!! Thank You!

[@sebizbir]

Most mysterious and moving song on the ETE album.

[@peaceondeath2319]

Absolutely excellent. Thank you for the upload!

[@RG1570L]

your very welcome! but if you have a youtube download plugin i would suggest you try to download the video and share it on your channel in case my copy is taken down too. i seem to be the only one with the full show on youtube now. so any help in the direction would be much appreciated , thanks

[@marystout2870]

I love your band.You are fun to play with.

[@ABOLITIONIST269]

This looks like it took a really long time to edit. Perfect show. Its officially one of my favorite KZbin videos.

[@Stelix.]

1st time in my life ivé found this. NOO idea why YT auto play brought me here, but i LIKE it (the cover from Lennon OMG) Mabey somebody can explain me who they are, and why my ears keep telling me it's TOOL

[@AAAngus1]

This is brilliant. Everyone is in fine form and playing tight. Maynard's voice is possibly the best I've heard it. Brilliant.

[@aleksandrajabonska2442]

Perfect Music. Perfect People. Perfect Circle.

[@billiehobbs8084]

Perfect perfect perfect, I literally could not fault this, this is my absolute favourite live performance, so fucking flawless, and Billy is SHITHOT!!!!!!!! such an amazing and beautiful live set. Who ever was lucky enuff to be there, you must be chuffted to bits. Xxxxxx

[@ZenLina47]

so fucking good i cant describe it... APC for ever the best band!!! songs will never die for me i have listen to them a thousend times i think and they are the soundtracks to my life!!!! i am so sad that i will never hear them in concert because i live in germany.... =( since i am 13 years old it is my favorit band!

[@derekd23]

Everytime I listen to this it's just amazing.This is definitely one of the best live performances I've ever heard. The entire band is perfect through the entire concert and Maynard is just unreal!

[@mr420krinkle]

April 26 2017 San Antonio,Texas I am there!!

[@rumisfordrinkingnotburning]

mr420krinkle post some vids bro

[@mr_hoggy]

I can't help but be amazed at this, what an incredible concert that was!

[@Photo4Corners]

Listening to Imagine by John Lennon, it is a very melodic, pleasant and peaceful song with lyrics that feel positive about our future. In this version of the same song with same lyrics, it's dark and ominous with a message of control over the masses- one world government looming around the corner. Thanks A Perfect Circle for pointing it out with this song.

[@alevan1898]

Thanks RG! This is ace!!! Love it! Can't understand those losers who dislike such a super performance!

[@richimc1899]

Please come to new Zealand. I know where little but we appreciate big acts like no other country.

[@zpe1200]

+richi mc saw them in chch back in 2003 or 04

[@Caustyler10]

Thank you, this got taken down from it's original post. This is only full version I can find...

[@RG1570L]

i would suggest trying to upload it to your own channel so that we can try and keep it alive

[@Caustyler10]

RG1570L Where can I download this, I'll put it on my channel

[@stephaniehopebach9741]

This freaking feed is AWESOME! I've been an absolute Maynard fan since the 90's Always will be. **PREACH ON MAN, I hear you real clear***