A Perfect Circle - Judith (REACTION!!!)

[@stevemartin7013]

A little context: Maynard’s mother, Judith Marie, suffered a stroke and as a result, was wheelchair-bound for the rest of her life. But despite that, she continued to hold strong to her Christian faith. As the lyrics to this song make clear, Maynard does not share that faith. Although, his feelings for his mother’s continued belief evolved. When she passed away, he wrote the lyrics to “Wings for Marie” and “10,000 Days” for the Tool album 10,000 Days. Lyrics that helped me with my own mother’s death. I recommend that you give those songs a listen some day so you can fully appreciate the difference from the vitriol shown in “Judith”.

[@DavidGreen1993]

I'd love to see them take a look at Wings for Marie

[@RvBDopp]

Getting to see those songs live was one of the best moments at a concert for me. 10,000 Days has a part that makes me tear up EVERY. TIME. Beautiful songs.

[@trejones1345]

"Jimmy" is another one of his mom and him dealing with what happened to her... Such an underrated song.

[@sinner13halloweenfiend76]

U said it perfectly man its a grate song.

[@mode3517]

Also 10000 days is about 26 years. Which is how long his mother was half paralyzed

[@RoyalistKev]

A perfect circle - Orestes This underrated song happens to be their most beautiful. There is only one like it.

[@eliash8903]

Orestes at Red Rocks with Billys back up vocals is probably APC's best performance ever.

[@jlrgaming8754]

My thoughts exactly. It's my favorite track of theirs on any album.

[@mixtlilozano465]

My favorite of all time

[@williamrc84]

favorite APC song

[@360.Tapestry]

unless they just do one of those random picks, this track will not receive enough support to blip on their radar

[@Addam1978]

Maynard’s mother Judith suffered a stroke that left her paralyzed, but she never gave up on her faith.

[@ectomorphine4609]

True faith.

[@bryanwelch6209]

Nailed it.

[@GahMehGrrrr]

@@ectomorphine4609 All hail the jug of milk.

[@WornDownSaint]

Addam1978 I’ll bet she was happier than most of us that aren’t... Jesus is completely awesome...

[@shaynecullen2882]

Exactly

[@thecomet6276]

You two interpret the lyrics exactly as he meant them. I really appreciate that about you two. Not just this song or this genre but every song you two listen to. Ty. Truly unbiased opinions. 👍👏

[@Ramathustra]

I disagree about the meaning of lyrics, not just this song, but any song, or any poem. The writer has a certain idea, meaning when writing it, but as soon as it's released, the original meaning loses shapes and it changes, transforms into a shape that is provided by the reader, listener. The new meaning doesn't make the original meaning... meaningless (sorry, couldn't resist), but to me, as a listener in this case, it may be nothing more than just a vague guide in order to help me reach my own interpretation of it.

[@christinamills7374]

They genuinely listen as freethinkers...the message is always received when the invitation is there. Killer job guys!

[@jockmcque3018]

Beat me to saying the same thing.

[@cameron_fairchild]

Yes! I love that they didn't over-research it before hand.

[@BliboranBass]

The difference between Tool and APC is that APC is usually simpler, softer, has shorter songs, and are more alternative rock than progressive metal / hard rock. I slightly prefer Tool to APC but APC is still incredible. They still display the fantastic musicianship that Tool does, but their songs are more straightforward with a standard structure. Oh also this song leans on the heavier side for them. Definitely do "The Outsider" for your next APC pick though! It's the "Judith" of their second album; guaranteed you'll both love it!

[@GlueGunsRoses]

Good explanation & hit the nail on the head ❤

[@jcole4341]

Agree👍👍

[@bryansimms6245]

Typically in 6/8 vs 9/8/7 times.

[@BliboranBass]

@@bryansimms6245 yep! (kinda like this song haha)

[@viktortunic]

yeah, reading this I see I shouldn't have bothered to write my opinion on the difference, that's it...

[@pinballwizard3419]

Holy crap thank you guys i have been requesting this for a year!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you so much Third eye By tool!!!!!!!! The remedy by Puscifer!!!!

[@Analdelrey333]

Pinball Wizard THIRD EYE❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@AzureKite619]

If they do Puscifer then they gotta start with Toma, Telling Ghosts or Momma Sed.

[@pinballwizard3419]

AzureKite619 they should totally do those songs but just like a perfect circle Judith, you have to start them on something they’ll Definitley like so they will be more open to other Puscifer music and do more reactions

[@Andy-nl8uq]

There are better puscifer songs imo (agostina is a personal favourite); but the Remedy is a great gateway to them.

[@jasonbartels1485]

The remedy is the perfect song for youtubers and the constant troll in chatrooms

[@Melrapuo]

Dear God, you’ve reviewed my favorite song ever. So hyped

[@trevorsanso32]

the noose is one of the most beautiful songs you'll ever hear in your life

[@bmanson626]

Love love love The Noose

[@vanessabragdon2687]

Yes yes yes

[@howiecrowe4489]

Agreed

[@brandyhimmelmann5651]

Yes yes yes ye. One of my most fav from them. Gorgeous song.

[@ryukan250]

Orestes and By and Down are just as good

[@seanammon6993]

Would? - Alice in Chains is a song for you guys!

[@MoonlightRaven_]

yes!

[@danielantunovic459]

Love hate love live!

[@damianwhite7771]

Hell yes!

[@sophiecat14]

Would? *Definitely* 💯🔥🤘🏻 I'd also love to see reactions to Man In The Box, Nutshell, Down in a Hole, Brother... Actually, too many to name ❤️

[@camelsmokes1892]

That or rain when I die

[@devinup3981]

The Noose is my favorite APC song. 3 Libras and Pet are great as well.

[@randallwilliams2184]

my favorite is 3 libras but second is the noose

[@sebastianpacheco9846]

My favorite is The Outsider, Orestes and Talk talk, but all their albums are amazing. I love Rose, Thomas, The noose, The Hollow, Weak and powerless, etc. Man, this band is amazing

[@RC-hv1yx]

Blue is great.

[@tobiasrottenbach1769]

The Noose was my favourite song this year live in Zürich

[@The_Fat_Turtle]

You have good taste, The Noose never fails to give me chills, such a great song I don't see mentioned enough. Throw in Passive as well and you've got top shelf APC.

[@JoeBlythe]

Angry Maynard is straight fire, end of story. Outsider is a great song too.

[@Droogie128]

Best angry Maynard = Ticks and Leeches

[@pedrogarcia9783]

Judith was Maynard James Keenan's mother's name. She was a very religious person. One day she had a stroke that left her in a wheelchair partially paralyzed. This stroke only strengthened her belief in God - something that Maynard found to be pretty ironic. The lyrics in this song reflect how he felt about the whole situation.

[@Tool_jira_shugg]

Maynard to me is such an anomaly. I haven't really resonated with any other vocalist like Maynard. You can FEEL his emotions when he belts out. His range is amazing, and I REALLY enjoy his gruff, pissed off vocal delivery. To top it off, his lyrics are also something that has helped me and been somewhat therapeutic to me in life. That may sound corny and Maynard probably wouldn't give 2 fucks either, but I still stand that way lmao

[@jos7886]

You haven't listened to enough music.

[@Tool_jira_shugg]

@@jos7886 Lmao, what a pretentious thing to say. So me favoring a vocalist over most others I've heard means I haven't listened to enough music... How does that work?

[@jos7886]

@@Tool_jira_shugg I dunno man I'm not interested in an internet argument with you. I'm far too important to be be bothered with that right now.

[@Tool_jira_shugg]

@@jos7886 LOL troll detected

[@therombaro]

Listen to “Daddy” by Korn. Jon Davis, the singer, was molested as a child, and his parents did not believe him and the abuse continued. In “Daddy,” he has a legitimate emotional breakdown in the song, and at first his bandmates thought it was just him channeling his rage. They didn’t know what to do, so they kept playing and what followed sends chills down my spine as Jon comes unglued and spews endless rebukes against his abuser. It is a song so deeply personal, Korn NEVER performed it live for 20 years. He never could face that song, and even if he could, he couldn’t go back to that place emotionally. He performs it now that his abuser is dead. He has healed over the years, but it is still very hard for him to do it. He says he only performs it because he knows his voice can reach children who endure the same things he endured, and wants them to know he has been there too. It is a damn DAMN hard song to hear - for me at least. To have a meltdown during recording, and still publish it on your FIRST album takes some serious guts. here is a link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5aZnKWNi8uBbqs

[@danielm5531]

Tool Stinkfist. That is a banger

[@matthewchapes2967]

Not enough, I need more, Nothing seems to satisfy. I dont want it. I just need it, To breathe to feel to know i'm alive.

[@Queenfairypants]

they freaked out to these lyrics, imagine the reaction to Stinkfist lyrics XD

[@jerredwayne8401]

Shoulder deep

[@SuaSponte75]

imagine how they freak out to Right In Two lyrics

[@beyondthegrave91]

The live version with the extended Danny Carey drum solo is epic!

[@Cleve_Crudgington]

This is one of their more Tool sounding songs. They have a few songs similar to this but they have a lot more mellow and melodic stuff as well. And while Tool songs often feel very meticulously put together I feel like these guys kind of go with the flow a bit more. Also the polls were great, I'm definitely on board if you guys keep doing them.

[@Deauxtje]

Cleve Crudgington i dont think it sounds like tool at all except for the vocals. Guitars and drums are totally different in sound and playing style. Its an amazing rock song that links to the Tool songs about Judith. Just my observation.

[@davelanders8688]

This is one of APC's earlier songs, too. I think the Tool influence was more prevalent on their first album than subsequent albums. Pet or The Noose would be another good one that's got a bit of a Tool vibe, but is more evolved into their own style.

[@joeshmoe5193]

I think APC originally was more like a radio friendly Tool. Songs were tighter and less epic and more accessable.

[@RH-xs8gz]

Cleve Crudgington - True. Their new album sounds nothing like Tool.

[@thebatman1482]

@@Deauxtje The riffs are really reminescent of Tool, kind of hard and heavy but with an hypnotic feel, especially when there Is some delay and in the slide parts. Just influence though, the style Is totally different

[@getbendt2970]

Maynard carried that last lyric for like 20 seconds at full throttle.

[@dozerroman4325]

Brings me to tears. Every. Single. Time. Not ashamed

[@anthonyferris8536]

I've seen them 3 times live. There are VERY few vocalists I've heard live that can replicate their album performance near 100% accurately, and sound great live. Maynard is something else; The guy seems inhuman at times. When I saw this on their first tour, my jaw was on the floor. He made it seem like he even had more to give. He was definitely emotionally charged during the performance.

[@CitroChannel]

If you liked the drumming at the end, you should check out their song "The Noose" which has an awesome drum groove. APC's drummer on their first two albums, Josh Freese, is different than Tool's Danny Carey, but still a top tier drummer and one of the most versatile in the entire business. He's great. As for the difference between APC and Tool, the former is a bit less progressive metal and more alternative rock/metal. Generally they have shorter songs, that are also generally not as complex and with more typical song structures and time signatures, but they are still very creative and definitely morso than most modern alt rock, I'd say. The drumming is definitely different, but both bands have two of the best rock drummers active. While Tool uses their bass and guitar about equally for rhythm and melody, I would say APC, while still having good bass work (especially on some particular songs) the guitar is a bit more prominent as a lead instrument with short solos and cool lead lines/licks and they make more consistent use of a rhythm guitarist in their grooves unlike Tool who only has one guitar player. This is very likely due to lead guitarist Billy Howerdel actually being the co-founder and writer of most of the instrumental melodies for A Perfect Circle. But generally, APC isn't quite as complex or intricate and is a bit more straight forward alternative/art rock, but that is by no means a negative. I would say they are more accessible, but that their songs are also a bit more varied in sound (even if most aren't as complex as most Tool songs) due to not being as focused on the progressive or metal elements. But they still have some killer riffs, leads, drumming and, of course, singing and lyrics courtesy of Maynard James Keenan. The two bands are both distinct, but both equally brilliant. Some people may prefer one over the other and that is understandable and cool, but APC is super talented just like Tool, just a slightly different flavor. That's how I would put it anyway. Cheers, love the reactions and like the polls, but I would say still choose at random from the suggestions too since sometimes the most popular song requests aren't the best. Judith is a great song though and I definitely look forward to seeing you guys react to more APC!

[@aidentorres3004]

Citron A long ass comment, means ur a devoted Tool/APC/Puscifer fan

[@richeerich561]

Nice to read such a long comment and agree with every word. Well said friend.

[@hansikursch484]

Maynard knows how to choose his beat keepers. Tim Alexander from primus also contributed to the albums i believe.

[@PalmettoPrepared]

The Noose!!! My favorite

[@Bmetalful]

The noose is good but probably a boring reaction song since half of it is super slow. "Pet" might be a good one.

[@TheLocalFuzz]

Now I'm just waiting for Albatross - Corrosion of Conformity!

[@devenscience8894]

I like "Heal My Wounds" better, but either one would be cool.

[@devildart]

Senior limpio, seven days, wiseblood, wishbone or deliverance

[@jeremywells3231]

Love C.O.C. they are badass

[@mun6832]

they would LOVE that! that groove man

[@alexsurles]

pearls before swine. or get political and do Voting with a Bullet. lol

[@andyfox8377]

Steven Wilson - the raven that refused to sing Porcupine tree - the sound of Muzak Dream theater - Blind Faith

[@TenTonNuke]

Don't know if anyone has mentioned that F**k your god! is the only instance on the entire album where he swears. He saved it for that one sentiment.

[@matthewsmith4647]

And in that i respect Maynard. That sentiment is soooo heavy. Im a christian and no fan of Maynard (in fact i hate Tool lol) but as a human stuck on this shitball of a planet and whose struggled with my faith when i lost the person i loved more than my own life, i get that blind rage.

[@colemarie9262]

Great point. I didn't even realize that, and it makes it way more powerful.

[@BrummieMorgan]

The guys from the Growth Project spotted that straight away. Search for Pastor Reactions to see their video. They're genuinely awesome guys.

[@BoomyNation]

Amen to that.

[@paulstacey8547]

@@BrummieMorgan just discovered them and they are good peoples.

[@omega42587]

Maynard is a special person in music. PERIOD

[@valormafia7721]

I agree , he does what he wants with music , and how he wants to do it. Doesn't let anything hold him back. He surrounds himself with brilliant musicians and goes to the next level with them . He is a brilliant and well-educated man.

[@danielm5531]

Deftones - My Own Summer

[@bobbelcher7352]

Shove it!

[@burntchrysler5922]

Around the Fur, MX, Rickets, Head Up... all killer songs off that album. I think these guys would love the drumming on the song Around the Fur.

[@omnigeek]

Their first 2 albums are their best.

[@rhyanbrooks1303]

Yep! This one too

[@lv999sozkyy4]

Yes mate!!

[@ReXtion88]

A Perfect Circle is about as much Billy Howerdel's band as it is Maynard's, he's the one who got it going in the first place after all. In terms of comparison to Tool, thematically there are a lot of overlaps but they're explored in slightly different, more "radio friendly" ways, and in terms of the music Tool are a progressive metal band, A Perfect Circle are an alternative rock band, so the two don't muscle in on each other too much. I absolutely love all of Maynard's work, Puscifer are absolutely sick as well. Uneven Structure - Frost/Hail

[@jonsmith3556]

i'm sure the fact that Billy was tools guitar tech is the reason you hear some similarities between apc and tool.

[@kelst75]

Totally agree. Billy is a totalluy underrated creature

[@EbolaSandwich]

This ^^ Maynard just "fronts" [backs?] Billy's band lol

[@HorseloverFat1984]

You guys are by far the best non rock/metal-head reactors on KZbin. I love how you understand the appeal of all those songs although it's not your personal taste in music.

[@Empiregaming_26]

Am i the only guy that thinks 3 libras is the best song ever. i enjoy most APC but....3 libras is so perfectly imperfect

[@felyciti]

Love Judith but 3 Libras is freaking awesome, too

[@CEllis1036]

Especially the Live Version

[@Graveflowerrrr]

One of the most beautiful songs ever

[@Jaeno311]

3 Libras is my favorite by far.

[@crystaldelacruz-casas5640]

My top 5 songs of all time

[@Frejborg]

45 seconds in to one APC song and you love everything about it? Well than you'll be blown away when you sit down and listen to the whole album. It's phenomenal.

[@stormcorrosion176]

Frejborg Dude Mer De Noms is good from start to finish. Agreed.

[@planetdustbowl4825]

@@stormcorrosion176 and thirteenth step is even better(imo) so much good music :)

[@redrosa79]

Amen

[@seamusburke639]

"The Hollow" has to be one of the most perfect band introductions. Three minutes, all killer, no filler. "You still here? Cool, strap in, here we go..."

[@sarakatz6541]

Thought the same thing. But honestly, that’s how that album also started for me. I just put on the first song and never felt the urge to skip anything. It was ALL good. I’ll never forget that, that’s the sign of a great album. And the fact that I can still do that today as well.

[@maikes.8649]

So glad you liked „Judith“ 😍. I recommend „Momma sed“ by Puscifer to enhance the Maynard world.

[@karenroyle1907]

That and Horizons

[@Metal_Vault]

This song represents true artistic expression/emotion, the way it should be. 'Mer de Noms' is a phenomenal album.

[@vgarc7]

Jeff Buckley-Grace Jeff Buckley-Grace Jeff Buckley-Grace

[@thanegoldberg453]

🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@padawansound6423]

Live at Chicago though

[@mowainwright73]

@@padawansound6423 Nah, though great in it's own right, they've gotta do the studio version and take in all that vocal goodness. Seriously guys, react to Jeff Buckley Grace asap

[@padawansound6423]

True say, tbh we just need some Jeff up in here asap

[@Erica-jv7ze]

Or “Lover, you should’ve come over”

[@JackChurchill101]

Maynard has come out saying that he writes with two different minds with these bands, - he writes for Tool with a very masculine mindset and he writes for APC with a feminine mindset. He also describes it as left of the brain for Tool (the functional, directional, thinking side) and the right side for APC (the linguistic, emotional, reasoning side)... - His words, not mine, - but he definitely thinks there's a difference, either way. The other guys for the two bands are also very different musicians and write in different ways, - you'll need a few more songs of each to nail down how you think they play.

[@GBcommander]

I didn't know that, thanks for the insight! Makes perfect sense now.

[@888altamber]

I also didn’t know that but can immediately agree with it. APC is softer and more ethereal in comparison to TOOL. TOOL is intentionally aggressive and thought provoking.

[@JackChurchill101]

@@888altamber - That's the one.... :)

[@thegenericnerdking]

9:55 LIV: He's still holding that note. 10:45 Maynard: Hold my Beer

[@rabblerouser6744]

Fuckin right!

[@aspion89]

Hold my Wine 🍷... 🤣

[@infctdppt]

I think "The Grudge" Maynard screams for like 30 seconds straight lol

[@Zeta9966]

@@infctdppt Right around that. Honestly, it's really not that hard. Maynard isn't really "Screaming" as much as just throwing vocal fry over his normal singing voice. In doing that, he can hold that shit as long as any other note.

[@MsAlliwannadoisdance]

@@infctdppt It's a 42 second scream - i timed it xD

[@thundarrisaboss2725]

watching people react to something you have known is amazing, for a long time, is fun.

[@jillreisinger]

Exactly!

[@jeremyandlaciedooley6471]

Tool=Mind A Perfect Circle=Heart Puscifer=Spirit

[@Hilltoptoys]

Duely Dooley well said!

[@grizzlymanverneteil4443]

My cuntry boner wont go down

[@Vivianblue.]

Brilliantly said!

[@MC-ep8cu]

Puscifer = weak

[@clipcalhoon]

Duely Dooley puscifer=genitalia

[@БълхатаНаКоткатаНаНикиБанков]

A Perfect Circle - The Outsider A Perfect Circle - Brena A Perfect Circle - 3 Libras

[@fuel20]

Orestes

[@judynabakowski8313]

3 Libras..my fave!

[@bones.thaprofessor]

Maynard also has a THIRD! group called Puscifer. They have a song called "Horizons" that is a must-hear. It's about his mother, Judith. He has a lot of songs about her spread across his 3 groups.

[@felyciti]

I feel like...as a Tool and APC fan, that Puscifer is almost like a joke. I mean Tool & APC are pretty serious most of the time, but is Puscifer just his "let go"? His release? If not, what should I listen to from Puscifer?

[@mdn19912]

felyciti a lot of Tool fans have an issue with Puscifer because the fans take themselves too seriously. Going from 3rd Eye to Cuntry Boner is uncomfortable them. They don't seem to see the art in play. But as far as Puscifer goes, I tbink it reall shows us how creative and funny Maynard can be. I would recommend sticking to Conditions of my Parole and Moneyshot albums, they are easier fo digest. The songs Momma Sed, Rev 22:20, and the Undertaker would probably fit your taste as well.

[@tobiaswedin]

@@felyciti He actually created music under the Puscifer parole as a means to market his wine, which then became his most utilised channel of musical creativity. Like Mark said, most fans take Tool, APC and themselves too serious as Maynard is a super goofy guy and it is clear within all of his music and performances.

[@bones.thaprofessor]

@@felyciti definitely Conditions of My Parole album. If you're a fan of Maynard as an artist, you can appreciate this album. "Horizons" is my personal favorite.

[@montv291]

Puscifer might be my favorite. This new APC album is amazing though. Listen to The Remedy by Puscifer.

[@anatolio8689]

10:44 - *Maynard's voice surges through Ryan's body* 10:54 - *Enlightenment begins*

[@germerican7182]

Lol right

[@alisongallagher95]

It's called Judith. It's about his mom. So is 10,00 days....

[@mtninja3093]

The whole album 'Mer de Noms' is one of the best rock albums of all time. So many good tunes on that!

[@grungyasscinema]

Judith is actually the name of Maynard's mother, she was paralyzed for quiet some time, I'm not sure what illness she had, I think it might've been cancer, but this song was written while she was still alive I believe, so this his feelings towards how he felt about his mother keeping her faith strong while she was going through this illness. The Tool album '10,000 Days' is a reference to how long she suffered before she died (some 27+ years) the song of the same name is in memory of her and is the polar opposite of the anti-god lyrics in Judith, that one is more paying homage to how great she was to him. Edit: It was actually a stroke, I believe this happened when Maynard was 11 years old; referenced in the Tool song "Jimmy"

[@bobbobson5245]

I believe 'eat the elephant' by APC is about her as well.

[@Kharmatos13]

she had an anurism(?) when he was young and was debilitated. He then had to go live with his dad because she couldn't even take care of herself.

[@karenroyle1907]

@@Kharmatos13 if you read his book he did take care of her when this happened. He saw some of the parish criticize her and they said she deserved the stroke. Judith thought it was to much for a young boy, that's when he went to live with his dad. His dad was a teacher and wrestling coach, Maynard was a wrestler and track person under his fathers guidance. His book is an interesting journal.

[@Stevexedplays]

Maynard has 3 main bands and has been referred to as such: Tool is the Brain, A Perfect Circle is the heart, and Puscifer is the loins. This says a lot about the differences between them, such as the mood, tone, rhythm, lyric content, vocal style, and are all 3 amazing in completely different ways.

[@carafitch1442]

Please react to Would by Alice in Chains! PLEASE

[@SamGoesLolls]

Yes, please do Would? and Nutshell by AIC!

[@highspeedenthusiast6628]

Into the flood AGAIN!!!

[@carafitch1442]

@Robert Garza I don't think they've done that one yet

[@spaztron5000]

Do Wings for Marie Parts 1 & 2. It is the answer to this song and it is the greatest piece of music I've ever heard.

[@kpag3030]

Sam Sommers it’s so good, and shows his evolution of his understanding and acceptance of his mother’s faith. That one makes me cry.

[@spaztron5000]

@@kpag3030 same.

[@ameliacharles2284]

Maynard's Trilogy to his Mum (Judith / Wings For Marie Pts 1 & 2) are an incredible insight into the soul of a human being. The progression and how he comes to terms with his Mum's faith is so touching. And I agree Wings For Marie Pt 2 is one of the greatest pieces of music ever written. The lyrics hit so hard

[@justinbenoit4]

Agreed! You’ve got to get the full picture and the “coming to terms” moment for Maynard on his moms situation.

[@jacqf3583]

@@ameliacharles2284 and then Horizons by Puscifer to follow

[@WretchedDreams]

Great video for a great song. The poll thing on patreon is a great idea and I was excited to get notifications that a new poll was put up. Keep it going!

[@onthemarc22]

Gotta check out Rise Against "Savior" and other songs by them. Keep up the good work!

[@JRodizAwesome]

The emotion in this song is beautiful. I love MJK!

[@JoeyMontoyaMusic]

RAW EMOTION masterfully expressed through vibration. Gotta love the passion and anger of Maynard in this song. So haunting and horrifying yet so real. Head banging the whole way through 🤘🏽

[@bluecollarcurr]

Great review for an excellent song choice. "Would" by Alice in Chains should be on your list 😁

[@AnonURnot]

They already did would

[@bluecollarcurr]

@@AnonURnot Nope. Link it or it didn't happen.

[@gimbo2145]

FunkyBassLick33 he’s lying, they’ve only done Rooster.

[@AnonURnot]

I remember a duo reviewing it and I clearly remember one of them talking about wearing sunglasses inside being cool. If it's not these guys then my mistake.

[@NefariousKoel]

Definitely need more Alice In Chains!

[@grantshortell4416]

fun fact: Josh Freese recorded the drums in 1 take

[@percyaisling5892]

Grant Shortell love Josh Freese. He’s a beast!

[@user-wh6sp6st8s]

That’s what any drummer worth their weight should be able to do

[@steveh7418]

@@user-wh6sp6st8s nah, maybe playing straight forward 4/4 but the difference between a drummer worth their salt and a world class recording artist is being able to first take complicated parts with all sorts of variation/fills/signature changes Etc.

[@user-wh6sp6st8s]

Steve H yea..like I said..one take. I’ve never seen a take 2. If you need that, you’re not ready.

[@steveh7418]

@@user-wh6sp6st8s what band you playing with, big hoss?

[@LafemmeDLux]

I have been waiting for this since I found you two!!!🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

[@jsnel9185]

This is the emotional reason I left the faith. My mom has been paralyzed and unable to speak for seven years. I have many other reasons but this song is the visceral feeling that was the seed for my apostasy. When you change your moms diapers and the Christians in your life are more concerned with "saving her soul" than helping their sibling, you see the hypocracy so clearly it makes you ill. Edited to say you guys do an EXCELLENT job. Well done!!

[@nenadbajakic2980]

A Perfect Circle - Passive

[@Spthomas47]

Gahd I f'n love this song.

[@excystium]

My favorite APC song, good suggestion.

[@brettgranger4781]

This.

[@cwancyk]

yup, great song, have You seen "Constantine" with Keanu Reeves? They used that song in this movie, scene in the club

[@nenadbajakic2980]

yes. I watched that movie :D

[@lowstryder1022]

YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!!

[@dustcord9488]

I have been watching youtube almost every day since 2009 and your my first subscription. I find both your perspectives intuitive, insightful, and UNBIASED glad your doing what your doing. Keep up the good work.

[@dafiro03]

The way this relates to me is: my grandfather 95 yrs old, served to the church since he was 60. Cooked four times a week, distributed food for the homeless in Cuba, matanzas. And then after serving all those years for a cause, his house hit broken into and he was beat to death. That has changed my ways to see religion, to see this song, to see all the things that are important. Not sure what to believe in anymore heartbroken

[@kmcclinton71]

Good one guys! Corrosion of Conformity - Albatross or Clean My Wounds

[@Dixielinemuzik]

Yes! 13 angels is a good one too

[@evilcousin442]

vote with the bullet

[@bionicj1]

Albatross would be an excellent introduction to Corrosion of Conformity

[@TheAlmightyEmmanuel]

3 Libras, Orestes, The Hallow, Pet, The Outsider, Blue, and Gravity are also REALLY good songs by APC. Any and all are worth checking out

[@beccaglitters8585]

Absolutely LOVE Blue

[@JimothyBridgemont]

Wow I really enjoyed that you guys loved this so much. The polls are awesome. I’ve been requesting the band Chevelle for some time now and I think there are some definite crossover characteristics between APC and them that you would enjoy. Chevelle is alternative metal like APC and had some big hits around the same time and are still making music. I would love to see a poll for Chevelle.

[@charitizzle6028]

marvelmaniac88 yes! I love Chevelle!

[@jermz8273]

Gotta Start with Point #1

[@nwmstudios]

Hard to believe this song is 18 years old. I can remember the first time this was played on Triple J all those years back, still one of my favourite songs and albums.

[@glenmontpiankhi]

3 Libras another great one. The build up on Judith to the end, amazing

[@scooterss2112]

Porcupine Tree - Arriving Somewhere But Not Here

[@mpactdesignmedia]

One of my fave PT songs...although they have dozens of great ones.

[@artificialcomplex]

Let's flood with this amazing piece of music

[@neurosin]

Trains is a better song for newcomers.

[@Psymon1471]

yes!!!

[@miloblackmetalhate]

yassssssq

[@tadsite]

My favourite Apc track is the Failure cover: The Nurse Who Loved Me. I don't think you should react to it, but I'm not seeing any Love for it in the comments, haha. So likes please.

[@davidtyler9198]

That is a very good song. Thumbs up on the good taste

[@vanessabragdon2687]

I love how you guys really go outside of your normal musical tastes. Welcome to the world of metal heads lol

[@MegaRockstar48]

Josh Freese is the drummer....in my top 5 drummers of all time

[@11ELeVeNthiRtYFouR34]

MegaRockstar48 josh freese is a badass but Tim Alexander (another badass) recorded the drums for this song

[@MegaRockstar48]

@@11ELeVeNthiRtYFouR34 You sure about that?

[@mwbrazier]

I believe that Tim Alexander recorded The Hollow, but not Judith.

[@mattmarkus4868]

11ELeVeNthiRtYFouR34 there’s no way this isn’t Josh Freese. It’s his sound..

[@ligmaballz3584]

Just saw them live in Baltimore. Josh freese wasn’t there.😢 but it was still awesome

[@quest1524]

Jeff Buckley - Grace

[@isabelcarvajal7591]

Yesssss

[@brandonlievano1329]

I've been waiting on this!!!!

[@joshuasmith6950]

"You never thought to question why." "Shout out to the free thinkers."

[@scottprince2718]

Dude I love this song and I enjoyed watching it with y'all,glad y'all liked it,yall have open minds when it comes to music,i appreciate y'all's opinions👍👍

[@carmen-monoxide2955]

I love APC they feel so much more romantic and emotional than Tool. This is the band where Maynard works his shit through. Mer de Noms is such a magical album, helped me work out so many issues.

[@inthewoods999]

APC comes from the heart and Tool comes from the 3rd eye:)

[@danielm5531]

That album in particular is beautiful. The hollow and orestes are wonderful freaking songs

[@danielm5531]

and brena

[@sum-dum_nerd]

If you enjoy the emotions of Maynard, I recommend his other project Puscifer Humbling River

[@carmen-monoxide2955]

@@sum-dum_nerd Yesss! I've heard Puscifers stuff too. So so good , that and "V" is for Vagina and "C" Is for (Please Insert Sophomoric Genitalia Reference Here) are excellent!

[@slaytanic777]

Perfect circle did a remake of john lennons-imagine. Its a MUST HEAR

[@jasonwilliamson583]

barnyard vapes a modern take on a classic

[@wildmantis1]

INCREDIBLE song

[@pingpong12429]

Wow. I've never heard of you guys or seen any of your videos but instantly im subscribed. You guys have some seriously spot on takes and comments on this song. The takes you took from the lyrics on your first listen really impressed me. Went at it with an open mind and gave some honest on point commentary. Keep up the good work fellas.

[@spice_krispies]

Been saying it for a year or more.....PLEASE react to Cult of Personality by Living Colour! If you've seen it already, cool, if not....give it a go guys! Head nodding groovefest with educational lyrics. Right up your ally!

[@revolutionday1]

Watch the video of them doing it with the mighty Sevendust, on Shiprocked. I'd been waiting decades to see that shit!!

[@damjanp7920]

Alice In Chains - Them Bones or Again Please

[@rcurl44]

I Stay Away

[@piratealeks6865]

THEM BONES, YES!

[@fidacuca]

Junkhead.

[@diaperenthusiast]

Man in the box We die young

[@erinherrington2501]

Shame on you

[@Obscure4747]

A Perfect Circle - Pet, I really recommend that one in regard to vibe and lyrics.

[@sirhoon87]

Dont forget the rhythm of the war drums

[@crystaldelacruz-casas5640]

3 Libras or Sleeping Beauty

[@SilverScreenDreamer]

Please do 3 Libras!

[@cndluluv]

The best music leaves you exhausted. This song always, ALWAYS, leaves me spent...

[@drummerdoingstuff5020]

I kinda dig these videos cause im always trying to introduce these types of songs to people who dont know good music. Its cool to see someone new appreciate these works of art.

[@brianmccauley4849]

Love this reaction. Seen APC 6 times live and they are absolutely amazing

[@Ou81269]

Without knowing any of Maynard’s history, these guys were able to pick up the meaning or significance of the song.

[@MrBassPlayer1]

A Perfect Circle Halo, The Package, Blue, Three Libras... ALL play list worthy. Headphones, alone, eyes closed. Experience. 🎶🎼😎🎼🎶

[@MrBassPlayer1]

My apologies. The song is called The Noose not Halo..

[@zigureru824]

TESSERACT - Of Matter (Live at Sphere Studios). Gotta check this out! Amazing!

[@crumb5756]

Mer De Noms takes the cake for my favorite album of all time for a REASON

[@paulashwin247]

agree sir.

[@pamb440]

***George & Ryan, you guys are the best!!*** this is the first video I watched from your channel and ever since, I’ve been a subscriber and rang that bell for notifications on all the videos you post. I’ve spent whole weekends just trying to catch up on all the interesting and smart reactions to some of my favorite songs that you’ve featured here. Being a huge fan of Tool, 46 & 2 and Lateralus were two of my favs. You guys were on the right path about 46 & 2 right from the beginning. Better than I did at my first listen. I did some research to find the meaning behind the song and that’s the best when a song might require some homework if you’re not quite sure what the lyrics mean at first listen. When you learn something new from your favorite music, that’s awesome. You guys are smart, funny and so entertaining, and pretty easy on the eyes I might add. Two handsome, smart men with a lovey outlook who happen to be free thinkers, who could ask for more?! You guys are the best! Keep doing what you do, I’m in it for the long haul. 👍🏼😉

[@themawsjawz_9491]

Now all y'all need to react to is some Puscifer and you'll have one deadly Maynard trifecta

[@noonenow8515]

Definitely, it would be hard to pick one song though considering the vast span of style that the songs cover. It is almost as if a listening of the entire Maynard catalog would be ideal to grasp his capabilities as an artist. That doesn't mean I don't want them to do it. I hope they do, i just don't know how to convince them to listen to his catalog.

[@themawsjawz_9491]

@@noonenow8515 Agreed. There's too much to cover.

[@tyler7313]

@@themawsjawz_9491 Conditions of My Parole, Rev 22:20, Cuntry Boner, or The Arsonist.

[@SinisterGreed19]

@@noonenow8515 the humbling river is a good start as well

[@Spthomas47]

Indigo Children? Vagina Mine? Queen B?

[@Kniveus]

Most people have explained what this song is about. But it's a 3 part serie, Jimmy talking about himself younger trying to deal with his mother's sickness when it happened, Judith when she was still alive and praying and then 10000 days part 1 and 2 after her death. 10000 days because she stayed paralyzed for around 10000 days. A whole album is named from tool is named 10000 days, and here's why, hf with the trivia !

[@JackChurchill101]

I did not know that that was what Jimmy was all about... But then again - it took me a year to realise that Stinkfist wasn't just being metaphorical and he was actually singing about literal anal fisting!

[@ReignSurvives]

Jimmy was certainly about his mothers stroke. Great song. Yeah, Stinkfist does use anal fisting, but it's clearly a metaphor for the way we become jaded to life in general, to relationships, to our feelings, and our hopes. That feeling of not enough even in the best of times that diminishes the good. I think, looking at the song literally really misses the point spectacularly

[@benjibanks7894]

Tool Right in two

[@secondeyeopensgently]

nah.

[@KCdurt]

You should check out their cover of John Lennon's "Imagine". It's legitimately badass and fitting of the times compared to when it was written imo.

[@feldspar3858]

As much as I love Maynard, their Imagine is horrible.

[@ayeewtasko2601]

Tool - The Grudge!!

[@keithjones5309]

I'm surprised Pet didn't get more love. Either way, you should get some Puscifer in to keep going with Maynard bands. Love the poll idea.

[@convour1]

Maynard has told us in interviews as of late his process for writing music and his involvement with Tool, especially in light of everyone's anticipation on waiting for their new album. According to him, he has very little to do with the instrumentation for Tool and won't write any lyrics or anything until the rest of the instrumentation has been done. Once Danny, Adam, and Justin are satisfied with their product (which takes a REALLY long time btw), Maynard can then write melodies and lyrics. You've heard the masterpieces the band has created, and this is a result of a bunch of perfectionists refining what they've written over and over again. Maynard's side projects, A Perfect Circle and Puscifer, are a result of him wanting to write and make music while waiting for the rest of Tool to "get their shit together." While I don't know for certain just how involved Maynard is in the writing for these other bands, it's safe to say that it's more than Tool. A Perfect Circle may sound Tool-ish, but it is and always will be very different from Tool because Maynard wants to accomplish something different through these outlets.

[@tmage23]

APC is basically done the same way - Billy Howerdel records demos with the instrumentation and Maynard writes lyrics for them (though much of the first album was already written before Maynard joined as it was originally Howerdel's band)

[@drewp1076]

Maynard did an interview recently i believe with Joe Rogan and it seems like he is almost at the breaking point with tool. As you stated in the interview it was the 1st time that he explained the music process of the band. For a long time he would troll the fans as far as us constantly asking how much longer? But it seems like he is becoming like us, by stating pretty much its the others that is taking forever to get the music to him as you stated. I never thought Maynard would be this forthcoming about the process and his own frustrations. Their next work better be a masterpiece for real.

[@karenroyle1907]

@@tmage23 Billy was Tool's guitar tech and Maynard's roommate. Maynard did APC to help his friend.

[@ianlewis4132]

I know I’m getting to these videos late- but man. You guys have no idea how much joy I felt watching you guys bop to deftones, make faces to Tool, and George- you manage to talk yourself through song meanings so quickly that it blows my mind. I’ll be subscribing on Patreon. You just made a fan

[@jasonstone1938]

Would! By Alice in Chains!

[@zparkplug2788]

great choice

[@Musicxpert]

Would is a nice song, but when you want to listen to something that really ROCKS, try TOOL!

[@markd4926]

You guys are awesome, so much better than any other reaction videos

[@TheLegendofGumby]

We appreciate you guys \m/ Try the song ‘Pet’

[@stephenjacobs8500]

I think one of the defining characteristics that puts Maynard above most is his fearless honesty in regards to his lyrics and his artistic approach to melody.

[@candyman329]

The Noose - A Perfect Circle Can’t compare Tool to APC, Maynard delivers regardless...he’s also in the band “Puscifer”

[@randomname3109]

blue and the noose belong together as a single peice to my mind

[@jjschmidli8896]

Probably my favorite APC song

[@BelialSinister]

Puscifer is his solo act.

[@NaumAlberto]

Tool - Parabola

[@biggred333]

Shew. Please please please

[@evanwest4751]

YES!

[@glowingmountain1273]

But both .. parabol + parabola... and video! You guys would be like whaaaaat?

[@biggred333]

@@glowingmountain1273 they would just transcend this dimension and never be the same, nbd

[@sassyest8292]

@@glowingmountain1273 yes yes yes, back to back

[@SonOfaBieber]

You should react to either Vicarious or Aenima by Tool next

[@bse523]

They'd so an interesting job breaking down the lyrics to Vicarious

[@pandorafox3944]

Stank face AND headbanging??? It was a stellar day for Lost in Vegas! Beautiful song, stunning lyrics. Great video guys! 💗💗💗

[@coolhand62]

This is by far my favorite APC song, which I would expect for most APC fans, especially if they came over from Tool. Most APC songs move at a different pace, but this one is cutthroat. It grabs you by the collar and does not let go! I live and die at the gym with this tune! This song is thunder rock! Maynard pours out his heart onto the music sheet screaming for his mother's woes, damning her beliefs, but you get the feeling that Maynard is still searching for the answers no one has. Listened to this song a thousand times, but never tire from it. A cherished piece indeed. You guys rock!

[@JaRW7]

I grew up a hip hop head; Thirteenth Step was one of the first full albums to get me into rock. Because of that, I prefer some of the songs on that album but Judith is FIRE! I love the video and if I had to be objective, it probably is there best song.

[@coolhand62]

​@@JaRW7 I can certainly understand your enthusiasm for songs on TS. Judith is certainly the 'crossroad' song between Tool & APC and I applaud Maynard for creating that link. It was certainly my introduction into APC oh so many years ago. I look forward going to a future Tool concert and hearing Judith. Not sure if it will ever happen, but I can always hope. Happy Listening!

[@aarrgghh87]

A Perfect Circle is one of my favorite bands. They're playing in Vegas this weekend (11/18), flying in to see them at the Cosmo.

[@natalie-lr2dc]

Amazing song Jeff Buckley - Grace

[@blairnorton4727]

Oh hell yes!!! A brilliant song unique a truly unique, haunting singer and song writer!!! Thanks for reviewing this brilliant song guys!!! Entertaining and insightful as always.. Those melodic voice swells harmonizing with the guitars at the end a re a massive highlight.

[@michelleaguirre6382]

React to "Aenima" by Tool. My favorite song OF ALL TIME. the lyrics are phenomenal and powerful and mean so much, especially during these times. Also react to "Right In Two" by Tool

[@kayjay7940]

I was so happy to see this video was up! Been wanting to see your reactions, these guys are great! My favorite song by them is "Pet" now how about some Pantera Cemetery Gates! Love you guys!

[@RageAgainstRustyCage]

I think they did a Pantera song, but Phil was Phil, and ruined any chance of a future reaction. I'd like Strength Beyond Strength, or Revolution is My Name, personally.

[@RageAgainstRustyCage]

Cemetery Gates though, awesome track too.