A Valentine’s Day She’ll Never Forget

The plaintiff had her first date with the defendant on Valentine’s Day, and he showered her with gifts. However, the plaintiff soon discovered he was seeing another woman, and he gave the other woman the exact same gifts on Valentine’s Day. She’s suing him for breach of contract after the plaintiff bought jewelry under her name intended for the defendant, but he failed to pay her back. The defendant claims he believed he and the plaintiff would be a good match because they’re both single parents. He later found out the plaintiff was jealous, possessive, and sneaky. He’s countersuing the plaintiff for an unpaid loan after he reportedly gave the plaintiff money for rent. He’s also countersuing for defamation.

[@BlkMagickGaia3]

That face tatt shows her decision making skills 🤣

[@izzdaboss]

The face tat told me all i needed to know. Case closed, verdict: she’s for the streets !

[@ms.jdelivereddiva123]

Right .. guffy

[@liljerry496]

That’s my perspective …. I just dont fuckin get it …. y Tho ? And they’re broke 🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿🤷🏾‍♂️🤷🏾‍♂️

[@TSR228]

Yes 😂

[@tamaradiax3929]

Lmao

[@smutjunkies559]

It's no reason why a grown man with full custody of his daughter should go into debt for a damn chain. Smh

[@jazmindax2255]

Got a Rolex also. Make it make sense. smh

[@firstladya2142]

He didn't go into debt, she did. 😏😂 technically...

[@myronyoung1091]

@@firstladya2142 😂😭 Facts! In the words of Judge Mathis " Seven THOUSAND" lol

[@aprila6628]

He gotta get dat bling bling!

[@yadams5554]

@@myronyoung1091 t.

[@reddrum9716]

Atleast these women were cordial to each other instead of blaming each other

[@Sheherhis]

Yes, good to see this!

[@lareinanueva]

EXACTLY! And Judge Mathis couldn't fathom that. I guess it made more sense to him for them to be at odds with each other 🙄

[@Sheherhis]

@@lareinanueva I know that surprised me that he would treat her like her and the women were in the wrong for being descent to each other.

[@kirby3486]

++++++++q+++++++++++++

[@POFs_Tuxedomask]

They just nosey

[@Lovesmyred]

$7,200 Really? I guess I’m old school and cheap. I’ve been married over 30 years and my 30 year wedding ring was not $7k ..What world are they living in? Save that for a down payment on a home…good grief 😮

[@stephanieshaw4695]

Right

[@valeedadavidson678]

2 WEEKS AT A JOB.., GIRL HE'S STILL ON PROBATION. HE HASN'T SECURED THE POSITION YET. SMH

[@versatileduplicity9313]

Y’all like dating bums

[@queenbee3828]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@jspearsgregory111uuyb5]

Some people love jail bait

[@itsmelissa7752]

“Are you a scrub?” The seriousness in Judge Mathis face kills me 😂

[@hotfishfromsharktale]

"are you a scrub?" Is the first thing that I agreed with JM on during this episode

[@theredwhoop9372]

Halfbreed or are you a dirt dolphin

[@jasonallen3678]

I doubt if he is a scrub though

[@NoName-mr8tr]

Pretty is temporary, dumb is forever! Perfect example 😌

[@cashoutsteve2495]

I remember Judge Judy quoting it.

[@NoName-mr8tr]

@@cashoutsteve2495 exactly where I got it from. Love JJ & her many unpopular truths! I see we are both court tv fans and know our judges and their sayings 👩‍⚖️👨‍⚖️

[@cashoutsteve2495]

@@NoName-mr8tr Great minds think alike!

[@G3.9-6]

Yeah that face Tatoo is pretty dumb🥸

[@Cereal_kwilla]

Pretty where?

[@focuz4899]

Patna went in the store on Valentine's Day and said, "let me get two of everything" 😂.

[@albertaowusu3536]

Maybe it was a bogof.😊

[@deannapeterson3615]

I’ve been with my boyfriend for 5 years and I be DAMNED if I put a $7500 loan in my name.

[@truly2realthereal]

Exactly lol

[@DJLeHut]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Bbyb00gangsta]

Facts

[@brittneyreigns]

A 5 yr boyfriend is not a flex neither.

[@DJLeHut]

@@brittneyreigns who made that up🤨

[@msknich0le]

She should have left him alone after Valentine’s Day. Then, in April she financed a chain. Now, he’s lying that he returned it. When people show you who they are the first time, believe them.

[@caramama1731]

Always!

[@chelleb.1436]

Exactly believe everything he shows about himself and run …… learn by the experience. But we always learn after the fact. They use your kindness.

[@margearettarmstrong4779]

So true that would've been it for me 💞

[@sequanamcclary8753]

I like the old Mathis, 20 mins in y'all still didn't get to the actual case.

[@sequanamcclary8753]

So he has full custody but don't have a bank account or a job.

[@iDreamOfJeanii]

RUFUS!? Rufus!!? RUUUFUS!!? THE THIRD🥴. Girl you should’ve ran right then and there lol

[@OcteseLikesToEat]

Not the “ two for one” … Doyle gone come through w/ a punch line if he don’t do nothing else

[@myrastyles7891]

😂😂😂😂

[@kimberlyhampton5332]

Exactly

[@kkhaze]

STRAIGHT FACTS THOUGH 😂🤣😂👌🏾💪🏾💯💯💯

[@chanitaquince8995]

That's his REAL Job💯😂💯

[@OcteseLikesToEat]

@@grandpahouse I believe comedy is his hobby lol

[@tracyoneal4975]

She should’ve lost this case out of stupidity. Financing a 7500 chain for someone you’ve dated for a month is beyond me 🤣

[@Naenae040]

Their priorities was all out of whack🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️😫

[@BlackaneseCantRap]

For reals tho. Priorities are messed up. If you don’t have a job why do you need a $7500 chain

[@kortnot86]

JM was on her ass lol

[@christianbailey3579]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@bukumiBrown]

i agree . she better be glad she ain’t go to JJ🤣🤣🤣🤣 she would’ve called her all types of dummies and put them out!

[@euqinom8561]

His name is the 1st red flag...no man named Rufus is loyal. Of course a no good cheater.

[@y_e_i8213]

This message really made me laugh hard

[@shalanathomas7751]

Lmaoo

[@deejai1173]

@@y_e_i8213 me too!! 😂😂😂

[@amberhi874]

I was saying the same thing!!!! Rufus is not a loyal name!!!!

[@RacieRain]

🤣🤣 right!

[@melsalih8212]

He had an income, she just didn't want to say what it was 🥴😂

[@coast2criszy]

Takes out credit for 7k necklace instead of the eye doctors appointment people have weird priorities 🙃

[@wildfiregirl1556]

Lmaooooo.

[@andreawashington5430]

I said the same thing… but I’m guessing she couldn’t open a line of credit at the eye doctor…

[@wildfiregirl1556]

@@andreawashington5430 You mean him. It was his appointment not hers. She already spent enough. Blessings.

[@jessbossgirl2235]

That doctor appointment was the underplay for the overplay he knew what we was doing, she was just stupid enough to fall for it!!! 😂 Ain't no way u ain't even got money or insurance to pay the doctor how u gone pay me! Think 🤔 baby think

[@godizself1]

If you can't afford glasses surely you can't afford a diamond necklace

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

🤔🤔

[@Cereal_kwilla]

Them lenses WAS giving Mr. Magoo 🤣🤣

[@jbcwms]

Thank you!! Omg!! 😂😂😂

[@beverlyhall4578]

Females with a.tattoo on their face is so tacky.

[@WarGrowlmon18]

"Your claim is dismissed player!!!"🤣🤣🤣

[@goodwillloveyou2133]

😂😂😂😂

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

😹😹😹🤦🏾‍♀️🧑🏽‍⚖️❤️🍿☕

[@SLIMBABYSIX]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@lakiyarhoden1905]

😂😂😂

[@tyshaso9277]

When Judge Mathis said that I was in tears😂😂😂😭😭

[@boombap7579]

How you let him around your kids on da 1st Date..🤔

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

We went to breakfast that was it.. I don't have Babysitters like that available so I had to bring him.any otha ?s

[@michelebrown5142]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 I have a question. Is that the Oxford Valley Mall in Langhorne? Not to come at you. I just used to work near there and shop there, if it is.

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

Nope In aurora il

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

😳🤦🏾‍♀️

[@lndicababyy]

you could loan a man thousands of dollars but can’t pay a babysitter instead you’d just rather bring your kid around random strange men…. get it together.

[@lndicababyy]

why as a single mom is she giving a guy almost 8k…???

[@d820m]

because she's thinking he's THE ONE

[@heathab...._-_]

EXACTLY my thoughts an she really mad about it, like girl you don't even know the guy like that he already showed her he ain't loyal

[@taylor7326]

She didnt give him the money, she cosigned the loan that he was supposed to pay off. No money was supposed to come out of her pocket

[@kizzyrichards593]

@@d820m her son should be THE ONE

[@anthonyhale5237]

Talking about desperate for just any man. !! Just a body will do. !!!

[@jazmynjohnson1060]

Not to count pockets but if you have to put something materialistic like jewelry on a payment plan, especially one as relatively high as the one in this case, then it’s safe to assume that you don’t need it in the first place. My goodness, he buys her dinner and a teddy bear and she puts her name on a $10k gift for him. What an exchange 🤣 hope she learns from this tho, especially for the safety of her children.

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

Definitely did

[@jazmynjohnson1060]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 good for you! Happy that you used this as a learning experience because there are some slick men out there who put up a facade. Hope you and your children are doing well

[@larrywise1865]

only thing she needs to put on layaway for me is that phat rabbit lemme grabbit

[@margearettarmstrong4779]

Right 💞

[@Strawberryfreeze3000]

This ! The math ain’t mathing

[@scottrogue946]

It’s wild to me you have men like this raising daughters. His daughter is going to deal with a dude just like him 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@wb3725]

The dude is broke. How is he taken care of his daughter?

[@winniewera2510]

Exactly

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

His parents ;)

[@lailanimessina1473]

@@wb3725 or maybe he’s “broke” because he takes care of his daughter and all the bills etc by himself So after responsibilities are taken care of he doesn’t have extra

[@versatileduplicity9313]

@@wb3725 welfare check

[@palo5959]

This is a classic example of I desperately need a man and I’ll get me one by all means necessary

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

You really have no idea what you're talking about it was a lone agreement not a gift... And I am never desperate or lonely... He had plenty of money which I chose not to discuss on national TV as to how he got... I just wanted my money... Anything else

[@michellelogan9177]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 if he had plenty of money then your money should have stayed in the bank. Stop being so desperate for love

[@rashaunwilliams6121]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 I dont think your desperate I think you need standards that guy is a clown regardless of what happened between you two

[@rashaunwilliams6121]

Palo that guys a clown and she is too for given this fool a 7200 dollar chain

[@rashaunwilliams6121]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 when a man cheats you leave him not buy him a chain

[@brizy___]

They hadn’t even been dating long enough for her to co-sign a damn thing 😅😂 let alone a CHAIN. Not a car loan but a loan for some jewelry for a man who wasn’t even working when you met him. Lawd. SMH

[@rentyrollins1697]

I agree Brianna , and I'm a man she was just dumb

[@heathab...._-_]

🤣🤣🤣

[@jacquelynn2051]

If ANY MAN gives me a stuffed animal as a gift and I’ve shown ZERO evidence of liking stuffed things outside of shrimp or lobster or chicken…I’m beating him with the stuffed animal…..allegedly

[@Rayallwayz]

When he lays a right blow on your chin knocking you out. Police won't do nothing because you hit em first. Lol

[@tessokafor1656]

😂😂

[@tessokafor1656]

😂😂

[@lilliewalker3126]

He's the sneaky one... lying Abt the doctor appointment

[@lavenderfields8783]

🤣🤣🤣 Exactly! After a certain age, stuffed animals are no longer what I call a gift to be excites about unless it's from a child

[@Sunshine134chick]

No Accountability from the Defendant he is most definitely a scrub 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@SPEIGHTS78]

Ok within 30dy he shouldn't be doing all that especially with her kids. If anything that should have been at least 6-8mos B4 even meet the kids 🙄 And then she goes and buys and gives expensive items using HER NAME to a relative stranger?! So lets recap-- She has brought a STRANGER around her kids and allowed them to get close, she CONTINUES to speak with the ex-girlfriend about him for whatever reason when they're not seeing each other anymore, and she bought this STRANGER an expensive gift under HER CREDIT. All within or less than 30 damn days of meeting each other. This folks is definition of a D.L.F.F ( Desperate, Lonely, Foolish Female) Don't let this happen to YOU seriously.

[@amirayoungblood9101]

💩I’ve been dating a man for a little over a year and he still hadn’t meet my son.

[@SPEIGHTS78]

@@amirayoungblood9101 and see that's smart 👌 👏 wait until you see what you guys are REALLY doing with each y'know

[@Tina-xj9rj]

You explained right on. Desperate is #1.

[@amirayoungblood9101]

@@SPEIGHTS78 I mean I think that’s really because my son father is deeply involved in his life he doesn’t miss play when it comes to him. Only time he’s unable to be there for our son is if he is out of town. We agreed that if the relationship isn’t serious like long term or to where there maybe a ring involved there’s no reason for the kids to be involved.

[@NKAB4]

@@amirayoungblood9101 I love it I was seeing a guy for 2yrs he never met my kds…I didn’t even tell him where I stayed no no no…

[@Kava_Lisa]

His name is RUFUS? Well, that was the first red flag. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

I think so😹😹😹🤦🏾‍♀️

[@trish6541]

Lmfaooooooooooo

[@treshasstarr1513]

Hahahahahahha big red flag

[@tanikabrownlee3863]

😂😂😂😂

[@Mocharocks9966]

Big ups judge Mathis for calling him a scrub

[@melvino8926]

Never trust a guy named Rufus , Bark bark 🤣🤣😂

[@jasonclyburn1499]

They probably linked back up once they got back to the hotel room 😂😂😂😂

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

Definitely didnt

[@trewilliams914]

Definitely did!🤣

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

They aint even put us in the same hotels dummiez..n they provided all transportation...like fuckn stop it..these comments hilarious...gota love J.M

[@lilliewalker3126]

She lied Abt the doctor appointment...his motive was to get her to the mall to get the chain

[@AtypicalM]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 Did the judge grant you the money? I think you're a good person with a pure heart but came across a bad dude.

[@Tina-xj9rj]

She thought she was all that but she only made a big fool of herself. Woman stop trying to buy men. Jessica has to be the biggest fool I’ve seen on JM so far. I wonder if she’s embarrassed after seeing this.

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

Not at all embarrassed..We had a loan agreement and he did not keep up his end..I did what I needed to do...people dont know the story..and who is anyone to judge my life. THAT SHOW IS 4 ENTERTAINMENT..THEY PLAY IT OUT LIKE THAT ON PURPOSE :)

[@amandapicicco7643]

Maybe you should know the whole story before u people want to talk shit!!

[@alannatiernan61]

I don't think she made a fool of herself. This guy thought he was slick and the ladies outsmarted him. And also he doesn't seem to know the difference between ask and axe. 😅🤣

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

@@alannatiernan61 preciate that

[@soulsistah5738]

lost soul some people desperate money can’t buy love

[@dannykchanell_]

😭😭😭😭😭 he's embarrassed & that's good 4 him

[@FayStayPaid_]

That man said, “I don’t have the necklace so, what am I paying for?” With a straight face and a Kanye shrug…whew chile😮‍💨🥴

[@catitude7117]

lmfao Kanye shrug 🤣🤣🤣💯

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

Lying his ass off....I never seen that chain after leavin the store...why would i pay 4 small claims court if he gave it back..🥴

[@FayStayPaid_]

@@catitude7117 straight savage...Sway ain't have no answers that day 🤥🤐

[@KLynn19877]

He looks like an off brand Ninja Turtle! 😬😅 I like that for the most part, JM is an equal opportunity CAPPER! He clowned them BOTH on an individual level & still laid down the business. 😅😆😆👌🏾

[@treshasstarr1513]

Hahahahahahahahahahahahhaha woieeeeeeeeeee “off brand ninja turtle” I can’t hahahahhaahhaaha u nah easy at all

[@UTBBT]

You need to be stopped 💀💀💀😂

[@jeremyjones8917]

I would be pissed at my family if they named me rufus 🤣😂🤣🤣 hell I barely like jeremy 🤣

[@calba24]

Agreed…Rufus sounds like Ruffles.

[@mrshappilymarried1]

😂🤣😆😆🤣🤣😂😂

[@mrshappilymarried1]

@Ebonee Price Right! At least he can be called J for short vs R. 😂😅😁

[@mrshappilymarried1]

@@calba24 I'm laughing so hard at yall!😂🤣😅😆

[@jeremyjones8917]

@@mrshappilymarried1 🤣🤣

[@5857612]

Judge Mathis be on point sometimes, pointing to someone illogical decisions

[@amandapicicco7643]

Don't u guys know the show is for jokes the judge wants everyone to ridiculous that's how they get their views and then they pay the people for being on the show just like Jerry springer and maury!! Half the show they cut out because they didn't want the judge to look like an ass!!

[@islandgirlruby2750]

Agreed

[@versatileduplicity9313]

Common sense

[@MrsClean1]

She met this man online and let him meet her kids the 1st week of dating. Women like this shouldn't be mothers

[@valpooh7532]

She’s gullible af!! What kind of woman befriends another woman who’s telling you she’s sleeping with the same man you’re sleeping with. Then you still be with him?!! He had every right to play the game how he did if she’s that stupid. Glad she got her money back though

[@najrutledge]

And she’s still in communication with her at that. That woman is only “befriending” you to keep tabs on how the relationship is going. I’m 25 and wouldn’t go for that.

[@blessedmomof2]

At 1st I was getting frustrated with JM thinking he was going to side with this guy...but boy did he do a 180° real quick! I think it also surprised the guy lol

[@GreenChronicles561]

Those are his emotions all over the place lmaoo as he gets older he’s becoming allot more grumpy & seems to rule off of his emotions sometimes 🤣🤣

[@cyyrious]

no he does this so women that are in these situations aren't coddled like he does crack heads he wants them to see how stupid their decisions were and not come to him because of it...he goes hard but usually knows he is going to side with with the woman when it comes to being a chump giving money he just wants them to realize it

[@blessedmomof2]

@@GreenChronicles561 yes! Sometimes I'm like...wait..does he know this person because he sure is mad at them LOL

[@badseedent4827]

It doesn't take much for judge feminine to side with women ... It's not his age it's his upbringing..

[@fadethechannel]

Apparently u don’t watch often lol

[@srtjay8862]

Goodmorning y’all have a great one take care of yourselves and one another god bless

[@kimberlyhampton5332]

Back at ya!

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

❤️💐

[@lauralee60]

"are you a scrub?".. Lol omg

[@goodwillloveyou2133]

Big time 😂 Scrub

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

Yes!😹😹😹🧑🏽‍⚖️

[@dcspace7198]

He showed his real self in the end.

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

They always do🧐🍿☕

[@amaliomar]

JM is a wierd dude. I would think he was getting senile but he has always acted this way.

[@Meeksfamilymatters]

Facts. Sometimes he just rants on and on and on. He's also an antagonist

[@Lovely_1One]

He’s actually much worse over the years! He’s A MESS!!!!

[@MrCJ-qz9dl]

@@Lovely_1One l thot he is much better than before. I would prefer him over Judge Lake or Judge Judy; even though l like all 3 of them.

[@tinawalker5335]

He’s getting worse. I watched him for over a decade and never found him weird

[@TexasBorn_TexasRaised]

@@tinawalker5335 facts

[@BigAce12121]

For of all his name is Rufus 😂. Should've known not to trust him lol.

[@boombap7579]

Rufus something The 3rd🤣🤣

[@sheshell8165]

🤣🤣🤣

[@elizamk05]

Lmaoooo i said the same thing 😂😂

[@mrshappilymarried1]

I hollered!!!😂🤣😅😅😁

[@misterbee66]

What is so dishonest about the name Rufus?

[@queenye.6667]

I'll never understand why woman put things in their name or "loan" large sums of money to someone they barley know but are usually aware the recipient doesn't have or can't get any credit, barley a job, job hopping and no bank account. People like this burn bridges as a hustle. The plantiff was just his new victim!

[@mrshappilymarried1]

Shout Out to my JM Family in these comments today! I was having a rough day but I swear I'm laughing so hard at yall I'm feeling so much better!!! 😂🤣😅😆😆😅😂Yall on a roll with this case!

[@kimberlyhampton5332]

😂😂😂

[@catitude7117]

why were you having a rough day ?

[@chanelcarlson3001]

GOTTA LOVE JUDGE MATHIS…HE JUST TELLS IT LIKE IT IS!!!

[@pookulj]

Eventually, we ladies need to be impressed that a man has a job, house and car. Not jewelry.

[@het-herukhepra752]

Thk you a JOB please SMH 😤!!

[@13outsidecenter13]

$300 a month for a gold chain? Thats a car payment!!

[@cme7527]

First time watching this show and I gotta say that I already love that judge 😂👌 He's awesome!!

[@taylahenry1702]

He says who cares but he asked 🙄🤷🏽‍♀️ he’s so ridiculous.

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

🤡🤛🏿😒😒

[@twocents6951]

Damn people are still meeting from Facebook? I thought that was over with the poke button 👀😅

[@Iwant2BYRLova]

Lmaoo ☠️ ☠️ ☠️ ☠️

[@CS48293]

what? Its the most popular social media. why wouldn't people still be meeting online? Social media is not dying out lmao

[@dollarperlike4087]

When did it stop? Are up under a 🪨

[@susiesolangesimpson2828]

You must live under a rock. It's a whole dating section on Facebook.

[@peacefaith560]

thirsty

[@SBell-wi5gi]

He caught the Bogo sale. 🧸💌🍫🧸💌🍫😂

[@mrshappilymarried1]

😂🤣😆😅🤣😂

[@wildfiregirl1556]

Got save them coins lol.

[@albertaowusu3536]

Bogof.

[@kamariasia]

What a beautiful couple.... a Becky and her black KANG❤️

[@Breakfastwithmo]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@fantamclemore7254]

😂😂😂

[@minae9935]

I dislike being early because the comments aren’t here/good yet. Someone call me back when they get juicy. I’m the 3rd comment and the first one is someone saying they’re first lol

[@deborahsuely7]

Im the same 😂

[@mwoodson1026]

READYYY😂

[@lashastaturner7813]

I swear I was thinking the same thing...lol

[@wilmanchrty3406]

Bro was off the chain the whole time. Now he gets to wear it again.

[@l.d.3226]

JM needs to un-bunch his drawlllllls. He gets so upset for no damn reason. It’s aggravating

[@shalanathomas7751]

Right!!!

[@mrblue2011]

He gets so worked up that I look for him to blackout ! His MOODS SWINGS are legendary lol

[@lareinanueva]

He's going senile. 🙄

[@chasc6334]

He getting old y’all, y’all know how some old folk get 😂

[@lovely_brownskin]

Agreed, I couldn't go on his show. I would be kicked out cause I'd cuss his old ass out.

[@neisci]

What's in her forehead?Ain't nobody tattooing their forehead. This woman financed a $7000.00 chain?$300 monthly payments?What in Ghetto fabulous is going on in here?

[@mrshappilymarried1]

I thought it was a bandaid🩹😂🤣😅😅😁

[@isiahwarner3087]

I thought it was a booger on her forehead. Thanks for clearing up the confusion. 🤔

[@heathab...._-_]

EXACTLY who pays a carnote on a chain every month that's stupid

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

Its my sons name actually..n it was a loan agreement..not a gift...he had money..he jus bitter🤣

[@catitude7117]

​@@Prilinc3sswag26 why the tat on your cute face and not like your arm or somewhere else ?

[@BlkMagickGaia3]

If it was their 1st date, so what he gave another woman the same thing/a gift ? They weren't in a relationship then. Duh

[@jplaya2023]

This brothas name is rufus? I know he was born during prohibition

[@mrshappilymarried1]

😂🤣😆😆😅🤣😂😂🍸🍷🍾🍶🥃

[@y_e_i8213]

His daddy is 90 and he’s the youngest boy out of 10 girl siblings. The oldest being 70.

[@nataliemaye1305]

I know guys named Rufus..people need to stop acting soo ignorant

[@jplaya2023]

@@nataliemaye1305 i got about 30 rufus names in my family tree. I was mainly joking. Rufus unfortunately was a common slave name

[@cheryltaitt2119]

JM started out clowning the plaintiff 🤡 but made the correct decision in the end. Women stop falling for the ole okey doke. When the plaintiff found out the defendant purchased the same cheap gifts for her and another woman, she should have dropped him like a bad habit then, but instead proceeded to not only date him, but purchase an expensive piece of jewelry on her credit for him. If the loser has no job, no credit, no money, the question I have is why deal with him at all? Some women would rather have a bum than no man. Smdh😑

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

He had plenty of money...which I seen...im not slow... I don't disagree it was a dumb decision to do it so early on... But trust and believe he had money to cover the minimum payments. He just became bitter because I broke up with him...

[@leeleentony]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 girl good on u for leaving this bum fr N TBH he def looks like the type to get hella salty when a good woman walks away from him n girl trust me I know all to well what it's like to make dumb decisions for a man who is playin u and makes it look like he's on point so u don't think shit will turn on u. I'm sorry u went thru that mama but many blessings n prayers for ur future 🙏 🥰🕉❤💯✝️

[@actualfactual1882]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 that's even worse if you had a man who get his money in the streets around your precious kids anything could've popped off you don't know who looking for him or may want to rob him 💯

[@blackgirlmagic9487]

JM needs to keep his personal feelings & experience’s to himself. Your a judge. Go off facts & the case not your own personal misery.

[@ItsYaBoi888]

Truth

[@elainewhite-spencer4191]

I totally agree

[@tanishasummage3094]

Yes, he is a Whole Scrub!!!! 😂😂

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

No Doubt 🤡🤛🏿

[@reignbowjonson4766]

He looks like a great value LL Cool J 😂😂😂

[@MrKwelrich]

The judge is no judge Judy at all. He’s very cantankerous and ghetto

[@BVaxter]

Anybody with that name is a strong NO

[@ScorPOQween]

I know his name ain’t no damn Rufus

[@isiahwarner3087]

The only Rufus I know is a dog that lives in a scrap metal junkyard!! 🐕

[@mrshappilymarried1]

😂😂😆😅🤣😛😛😂😆😁😄

[@heathab...._-_]

@@isiahwarner3087 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@nataliemaye1305]

His Parents named him...gtfu

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

It is tho😹😹😹😹🤦🏾‍♀️

[@y_e_i8213]

Rufus know those glasses aren’t prescription. We all know the game to wear glasses to court and interviews to look nerdy.. you cute though

[@WarGrowlmon18]

Both of these women are too good for him

[@quincydavenport9977]

Nonsense, all the people involved are single parents, it just didn’t work out.

[@blahaaaaaaan]

and they are trash so what does that say?

[@naleebrooklyn]

Nope, they get what they choose

[@heathab...._-_]

Ain't no good decent man want a woman with a tattooe on her face no

[@misterbee66]

Indeed they are.

[@boombap7579]

CORRECTION...Da 1st Week you got him around Yo Kidz....🤔

[@nchellcatbadboy3625]

Lol I make 6 figures and I wud not pay 7k for a piece of jewelry. How in da hell can he wear 7k on his neck with no job, bank account or credit. He shura got her to loan him money to go pay for classes for something to better his situation. That was rediculous. Hint if someone has bad credit that means they don’t pay their bills so u probably won’t get get paid either. And a Rolex too lol wonder what woman ate that bill smh

[@y_e_i8213]

They clearly aren’t paying you to write.. 🤪🤪. Jk. Your point is good though

[@darrellsadler2848]

I left towards the end with yet another terrible migraine headache after listening to so much pathetic craziness. Dude was/ is seriously dumb to the fact that people rob and kill other people who are foolish enough to1. purchase a $7,200 chain necklace (working or not...credit or no credit) 2. to wear it out in public especially at night in a nightclub setting. Unfortunately, he and countless others will never learn their lessons on the this and will keep on doing it.

[@joibilee]

Oh wow! BM and their preferences lol! She is so ghetto!! And what is that doodle on the side of her head 😅😅 I love SYSBM! It seems to be working out very well for you guys!!

[@lndicababyy]

must be her prison tattoos

[@Crystal-Love]

The doodle 😂😂😂

[@joibilee]

@@lndicababyy ok cause she definitely has been there before 😂😂

[@joibilee]

@@Crystal-Love 🤭🤭

[@actualfactual1882]

She said it's her son's name and she got it there cause she's proud of him 🤣🤣🤣

[@ra4207]

Lol judge said ARE YOU A SCRUB! Haha yes! Yes he is!

[@Jg-ww7rr]

Lol sometimes I think judge acts like a know it all but I gotta say HE KNOWS IT ALL! 🤣

[@toyalasha5421]

“Are you a scrub”🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@cassandracole7498]

Yes…you a real scrub

[@toyalasha5421]

@@cassandracole7498 😂

[@TracyShereee]

Tattoo on her forehead ???🙄😂

[@dollarperlike4087]

It’s 2022 👵 or 👴….it’s very common these days 😃

[@BigRollieBaby910]

@@dollarperlike4087 Exactly

[@ElderSlimm]

@@dollarperlike4087 That shit ain't common.

[@cupofchi_]

What’s wrong with that ?

[@dollarperlike4087]

@@ElderSlimm if you’ve seen the world like I have, you’d understand the transition. It use to be because you couldn’t get work with tattoos but now as you see it you get out from time to time, MANY businesses hire people with tattoos in just about any place. Let them live THEIR life.

[@ashslay3224]

Mathis ate both of them up 🤣🤣🤣

[@WEGOTBUCKSENT365]

No he didn’t. He’s becoming more of a character, a personality (grumpy old judge) whether than actually making rational decisions. Name calling, everything. He’s very unprofessional. I use to like Judge Mathis show, now it’s jus cringy to watch a judge, especially a black judge, act this way smh

[@Imissyoulou]

@@WEGOTBUCKSENT365 Well why do you watch him? I don't like judge judy, therefore, I don't watch her show.

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

yup!😹😹😹😹

[@WEGOTBUCKSENT365]

@@Imissyoulou I watch him because I’m a fan. I was watching before this KZbin shit. And actually liked him, BEFORE. Now it’s like he’s cranky and old. I know plenty of older men who acts the way he acts. And as a fan, it’s disappointing.

[@Imissyoulou]

@@WEGOTBUCKSENT365 I always loved the judge, and I can relate to a lot of things he describes. He gives EXCELLENT ADVICE, but it is up to YOU to take it. I've seen him reach out to people trying to give them a break. There are a lot of other issues I can touch on regarding the judge but, I am old and cranky too. If you keep living, you are going to be the same way.

[@OcteseLikesToEat]

“Sister Wives” makes sense. No way she admits to sleeping w/ your man & you continue communication 😮

[@PaulPaid]

Plenty of ways ....she would be glad she told her

[@OcteseLikesToEat]

@@PaulPaid she should’ve cut off communication from the both of them…Weird!

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

Theres so much more to the story...I tried to leave...he wouldnt leave me alone...Yall really have no idea wat i went thru n thats fine

[@kizzyrichards593]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 but you were happy to stay with him it seems. If he wasn't living with you, which you stated on the show, he couldn't have been in contact with you without you entertaining him. If you wanted him to leave you alone, there were ways to do it. You said she's a nice girl...how is she nice when she is fucking someone she knows is in a relationship and then CALLS you to tell you?! What it sounds like is she is dirty and disgusting.

[@winwithjames8833]

Why the plaintiff in the comments section? This is our forum. Lol cute looking plaintiffs. To have a woman in contact with ex is problematic the guy is always going to be on the defensive. Like the judge said this dude is no player. If you have custody of your child $7000 chain makes no sense.

[@OcteseLikesToEat]

Only been working for two weeks & has NO BANK ACCOUNT but yet you put $7250 of credit in your name… I need her hahahahaha

[@jonathanlewis6834]

Hell yeah

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

He had plenty of money ...think outside the box

[@MsFlorida813]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 You keep bragging about his money lmao you not only brought your kids around a man you don't know, I guess you are letting it be known you let a drug dealer live with your kids 🤦 and btw you look pathetic replying to all these comments like you need to prove something. You weren't "helping" him, you bought a damn chain for him it wasn't a necessity. You know you're for the streets and obviously you are use to paying for "love".

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

@@MsFlorida813 I aint braggin about shit n it wasnt a gift...otha wise I would not be takin his ass to court goofy ass..And he did not live with me...dumb ma fukas speakin on shit they kno nothin about....Carry on

[@liljerry496]

304 tendencies ……. Fellas run the other way 🤷🏾‍♂️🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿 🏃🏿‍♂️💨💨🌬

[@winston6031]

Looks like someone tagged her face

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️

[@leggs4113]

Don’t lie yall know y’all clicked cause of that face tat.

[@Crystal-Love]

Facts😂😂😂

[@adrianpharr7480]

I watched it because it was on my notification

[@leir2005]

That title is pretty alluring too. I clicked to hear the story

[@Fourlittlefurpeople]

I can’t stand hearing those nasty fingernails clicking on that podium, just 🤮

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

annoys my soul😖😣

[@janna7249]

Judge is so damn smooth.

[@rayman1269]

Rufus jones the 3rd is one hell of a name aint it 😂.

[@thequinstewartexperience7073]

Nuggah's name is RUFUS...what did you expect? 🤔🙄🤨😆

[@wildfiregirl1556]

Lmao.

[@mwoodson1026]

That young lady must have A-1 credit?! She could have used that money, along with down payment for a house?! THAT SHITTY LOOK RUFUS DO, WHEN SHE MENTIONED HE STOLE SOMETHING UGHH.. 12:09

[@doitallmike10]

If you gone be friends with the other woman and still be with him all 3 of yall might as well date😂

[@susiebevacqua2555]

Jessica looks like a 2022 version of the Mona Lisa!

[@jasonwhitfield6161]

JM stays asking stupid questions and gets mad when ppl don't know how to answer them

[@suzieque5989]

Facts!

[@sequanamcclary8753]

True indeed. Like get to why she suing him. He gets on my nerves.

[@Orlandoloc83]

Listen to her testimony she said she broke up with him..@11:55 then said to the judge he was excusing her on chatting but also said she just broken up with her baby father smh can someone please make it make sense to me who was she with lml

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

@@Orlandoloc83 my bd and I have been off and on and he still had some stuff at my house?Cuz people dont do that ..Chill out🤣yall thinkn to hard

[@birdchoyce4332]

I think a lot of his questions are geared towards seeing if the person is honest or just full of deception. JM is very smart and knows what he's doing and that's why he's been in for so long, imo !!!

[@trav-zm7ix]

Mathis gone believe a woman Ovwr the man any day of the week. He asked that nigga what store was in front of the parking lot…. In a real court of law both of they cases would have got dismissed from lack of evidence and I seen Mathis take family testimony plenty of times.

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

I had all my proofs...fyi...it was loan agreement

[@trav-zm7ix]

@@Prilinc3sswag26 yea but did you have proof that he didn’t give it back? I don’t know who’s lying so that’s where both parties need proof. He said he gave it back, she said he didn’t and neither side could prove what they claimed.

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

The judge didnt even ask me 4 any evidence.He knew he was lying...they also cut out alot ...it was all entertainment..if he gave it back why would I be suing him...n have to put my business on tv...wen in all actuality i still took a loss ..the show only pays up to 5000....

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

I had to pay just to start the small claim...400$ then the show actually reached out to me.

[@SaViiKrstEYE]

Can’t beat a 2 for 1 special 😂

[@mrshappilymarried1]

😂🤣😅😅🤣A Deal is a Deal!

[@hateisforlosers6116]

Smh.... if a woman calls me or reaches out to me about a man , its a done deal!! Don't have the time for foolishness.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣JM is crazy he said you thought it was another man but it was your woman🤣🤣🤣🤣 these women are crazy 7250.00 for a gold chain ...thristy and low self esteem 🙃 🤣🤣🤣😍🤣🤣🤣JM Says are you a scrub🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@MsRayBay]

No offense that’s why they love y’all though!! 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Elijahhuey2015]

Why judge Mathis eat him up like this 🥴😂

[@themadmillionaire]

All the single mothers with two jobs in the world and he picked the one with a face tattoo 👀

[@izzdaboss]

The face tat told me all i needed to know. Case closed, verdict: she’s for the streets !

[@Prilinc3sswag26]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Tiffany-un3hw]

😂😂😂

[@Sunshine134chick]

At least the women didn’t fight each other over a man

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

Im happy about that