AbiGirl's 1st time listen & reaction to "Otonablue" by Atarashii Gakko!

[@johnestes9316]

I absolutely love Atarahi Gakko! Their collab with Maximum the Hormone “Shimi” is fire. More up your alley.

[@jimnusbaum3589]

@@johnestes9316 but almost impossible to react to given MTH iron fist control of their songs

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'm hearing this a lot!

[@richardxpowell]

AG describe themselves as an anti Idol group. I just think AG are completely hatstand. They are crazier than a crazy thing with a degree in crazy from Crazy University. Their humour is twisted 90 degrees to reality. I love 'em.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Haha they do seem fun 😅

[@mechanicat23]

Man With a Mission is a bit crazy to. Much better in concert than just their recordings. Lots of goofy hijinx

[@cuttysark8017]

AG! have certainly been described as an "anti-idol" group, but I don't think AG! have said that about themselves. They have said that they are not an idol group and prefer "song and dance group" as a description.

[@wismsgre]

I love how every person that watches this is broken somehow. 99.99% of pure happiness, and then you, by pure confusion. That made a really fun reaction, haha

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

😅😅😅

[@Grum-monkey]

They had to rein in their choreography for this... They are a song and dance unit performing their own choreography to their songs. They bring humour to all their performances but the lyrics often have a serious message (delivered with charm). There other stuff is worth checking out as no song or performance is the same as any other. They have a ton of videos online. Like many old rockers, I'm a huge fan because they have attitude with a smile.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'll have to check out more!

[@cuttysark8017]

Otona Blue means "Adult Blues", but there's a pun as Suzuka always introduces it as "Otona Buru" which means "to act like an adult". It's heavily influenced by the 70s Japanese hit "Furui Nikki" by Akiko Wada so that's the funky synth stuff you are hearing. AG! are very much about a whole performance; they all have dance backgrounds and do all their own choreography so they are very different from other idol type dance groups and you won't find the usual moves. FYI they don't see themselves as an idol group and avoid the banal sexuality of most female song and dance groups. Here they come up with a memorable way to get on and off stage which is a basic requirement of a stage performance that many performers find difficult. Suzuka is the main singer because of her strong voice and even stronger on stage personality - she body surfs the crowd at live shows - but AG! does not have a leader. Rin does a lot of rap and Kanon and Mizyu use their higher register voices to sing more melodic parts. I can see that their style didn't click with you, which is a shame, but they are irreverent and funny and have other songs so give them another chance and you might come to admire their talent more. You didn't mention the lyrics at all and they are really important and quite controversial with many reactors. The song is about how a teenage girl experiences the male gaze and her desire to experience adult emotions and love even though she knows that she's still too young for them. The lyrics were written by AG! which saves it from being really creepy and it's probably a subject that is very relevant to 4 young women who have made their careers performing in front of audiences. AG! were formed in 2015 by the Asobisystem agency. Mizyu (oldest, shortest and with 2 x hair bunches) had worked with the agency before as a backup dancer to Kyary Pamyu Pamyu and they brought in Rin, Suzuka and Kanon to make AG! They worked on developing their act and choreography and put out a couple of jazz influenced albums, but their quirky style and music didn't bring big sales so their record label dropped them in 2019. So your opinion was shared by many people in Japan. They were picked up by the American label 88Rising in 2020 and paired with the producer Money Mark and since then they have had international success and went viral in Japan in 2023 with Otona Blue. They completed a world tour in 2024 and look set for even more success in 2025. If you want more AG! check out "Atarashii Gakko, live in Koln, NaiNaiNai" and "Maximum the Hormone - Shimi, featuring Atarashii Gakko"

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Thanks for taking the time to write your insightful comment! ^_^

[@TherealSeriousMoonlight]

Having fun is what Atarashii Gakko does. (They are pouring on the _silly_ quite a bit for First Take.) They're also fantastic singers and dancers. Thanks for the reaction!

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Thanks for watching ^_^

[@bryansaladino7602]

Fun fact if you want to check out Babymetal has a new radio show on TokyoFM and their first guest this week on Friday is Atarashii Gakko. Look for it Saturday and most likely there will be a KZbin video up with English subtitles. If you would like to hear that collab give me a hell yea lol. Also, may I recommend their song Toryanse if you like to see more of what Ren does which is rapping and she's awesome at it.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Oh that's awesome! I'll check it out!

[@Dante94]

Suzuka's voice is described as a Show-Ya style voice. It was very popular for J-Pop idols to sing like that during the 80s and the heyday of city pop. This song is a huge homage to that style of music. AG is very silly but also very talented. And when you ask what genre of music AG plays, the answer is always "Yes!".

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Haha yes!

[@rakjr6]

Babymetal has just started a half-hour radio show in Japan talking about metal music and having guest musicians who are also metal fans even if their own music is not. The next 3 episodes will have members of Atarashii Gakko as guests. The lead singer of AG is Suzuka (Su-metal of Babymetal is also a Suzuka). Yes, they are comic, even downright demented. One of their songs is entitled "PIneapple Kryptonite". But the songs can be musically sophisticated, ranging over genres like jazz and hip-hop. And the lyrics can be quite dark. They do their own choreography. They performed at Coachella last year and performed on Jimmy Kimmel's show. At Coachella for the song "Tokyo Calling" they had as guest performers an LA-based taiko drum team and members of the USC Trojans marching band.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Radio show seems fun!

[@TreadheadA1]

@@Abigirl_Reacts It is a lot of fun! There is a sub-titled version on BabymetalTube's channel. It is audio only unfortunately.

[@stevewesley3841]

These girls are so funny, especially Suzuka, and they were excellent in Maximum the Hormones rerecording of Shimi

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I gotta hear that!

[@mechanicat23]

Oh hell ya.

[@mechanicat23]

I saw Atarashii Gakko perform concerts three years in a row, in San Francisco. They sell out every time, and I got to meet them before they became big and signed with 88 Rising. Soo much fun in concert.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'm so happy you got to see them live! ^_^

[@tackle47]

Total metal fan and I love this group so much.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Nice! What's your favorite song?

[@tackle47]

@@Abigirl_ReactsKoi Geba the song is a a jazz, rock, pop fusion about inappropriate relationships between teachers and students. They actually tackle quite a few societal issues in many of their songs. Watching your reaction yes at times they are silly…it is fun. I mean I can listen to Cannibal Corpse and still enjoy fun. This is actually a pretty brave song they are singing about how they felt transitioning from kids into adults. Only thing that confuses me about your reaction is this serious? This band is free from the tight constraint’s of Japanese society, the music industry and conventional tropes. Also you do not have to sing in harmony to have multiple singers. The group is all of them not just Suzuka. It is actually and don’t think this the wrong way but rude to say the others are not needed. The others sing leads at times in other songs. As a reactor I suggest to keep getting challenged from things you don’t understand or feel on 1st listen.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I was challenged. That's why I was confused! While I still find it unnecessary to have 3 girls singing the same melody, I am sorry you found it disrespectful. I look forward to hearing more from this band because I loved Su's voice! (As I mentioned in the video)

[@tackle47]

@@Abigirl_Reacts oh no offense taken but gang vocals is used by many groups so found it awkward to call the other 3 members as unnecessary.

[@GraueMaus-d1e]

@@Abigirl_Reacts I think Koi Geba would be a good second impression for you as it is one of their more serious works. Having said this, the crazy story in their music video for Pineapple Krytonite is "not from his world". (And this is coming from someone who loves Babymetal, Lovebites, Nemophila, Unlucky Morpheus and The Warning.)

[@Olkam-w5u]

They have an American producer working with them, Mark Ramos Niishita, better known as Money Mark. He worked a lot with the Bestie Boys, if you remember them. This is especially noticeable in the song PIneapple Kryptonite. Also, it wasn't visible here, but they are brilliant choreographers, they choreograph not only for themselves, but also for others. Specialists are constantly amazed by them

[@jimnusbaum3589]

@@Olkam-w5u he worked with them on one or two songs

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I believe you!

[@lencooke944]

Hi Abs, probably not the song I would have given you first up, but we are here now. Atarashii Gakko is a very talented vocal/dance outfit. It's hard to call the girls a band because they perform their vocals and dance almost exclusively over backing tracks. However, despite this, AG has gained a broad base of fans worldwide due to their quirky performances and relevant social messaging towards their target audience. Atarashii Gakko are loved by some, not so much by others; you will find that most of their fans understand this and won't negatively mark your dance card. So, it's absolutely fine if you don't like them. As an Australian, I liken AG to Vegemite, a sandwich spread that divides the world. As with Vegemite, you have to start with a little smear on your sandwich to start building up your tolerance to the taste, AG are a bit like this. Once you find the smear of Vegemite's flavour waning, you spread it a bit thicker. AG is a similar process for western viewers, start small, work to big. Abs, you kinda landed in the middle here with no prior context, like a medium layer of Vegemite on your toast in the morning, it can be a bit shocking, enough to make your face screw up and make your sphincters go into overdrive. Abs, you didn't like this, and that's fine, but I am about five years into AG and I love them; however, each to their own.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Maybe it was just an odd way to be introduced to the band so I was incredibly confused and put off but I wouldn't say I don't like them. I LOVED the main singers voice. The overall style of the song wasn't for me but I'd be willing to hear something else!

[@oji_weeb]

This song has cultural resonances in Japan that don’t usually resonate with folks abroad. It’s simultaneously a parody and an homage to music of the 80’s and 90’s, with specific nods to artists like Akiko Wada (an extremely popular artist and TV personality with a deep strong voice and a masculine persona that verges on drag), or Akina Nakamori, who sang very sultry songs at an age that would be considered pretty inappropriate in this day and age. For the Japanese audience , it was silly, nostalgic, satirical, controversial, tantalizingly ambiguous, maybe even feminist. As an American with a fair amount of context to go by, and a love for serious-minded goofiness, I think it’s genius. Don’t feel bad, there are lots of Japanese folks who hate on it too. But please give AG more chances. They are totally eclectic and like nothing else out there. I’ve seen them twice live in the US, and they REALLY know how to connect with a foreign audience,when that’s the goal. They put on an amazing show.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'm so happy you got to see them live! ^_^ I'm totally willing to give them another shot!

[@John-l7y1t]

I dont know if you knew but Babymetal has a radio show now. Guess who is their first guests?.. Atarashii Gakko =)

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Awesome!

[@billmcleangunsmith]

I'm not normally a fan of pop music, but AG is the exception. They have a lot of variety. You may like the next song you hear from them.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I believe you!

[@jimnusbaum3589]

AG is a dance performance group. They do sing but don't play instruments or have a live band. They cover very serious Japanese social issues. They are frequently silly but that is part of their charm. The front woman, Suzuka, has loads of charisma. They all sing very well and choreograph their own dance. I am a bit confused by your reaction.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I can't picture then being serious at all! I'll need to listen to more.

[@jimnusbaum3589]

​@@Abigirl_ReactsIf you read the lyrics you will see they are pretty serious. They are quite popular and put on great live shows. They have toured the US quite successfully.

[@jimnusbaum3589]

But you certainly have a right to your opinion

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I think I'm the end, I just gotta hear more!

[@ronrimsite6948]

They're huge worldwide. Just saw their second sold-out solo tour here in NYC.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'm so happy you got to see them live! ^_^

[@keithy_is_tired]

the song is basically about teens pretending to be adults, so yes, the song is supposed to sound kind of childish. otherwise though, AG just do whatever they want and have fun while doing it, so even though a lot of their songs have serious or even dark topics (like Koi Geba) addressing different characteristics of Japanese society (both in celebration for the good and in critics to the bad), there's always a fun/silly element to their songs, performance, and/or choreos (which they do themselves)

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Oh OK, awesome!

[@docmetal8194]

Love AG!! I've seen them twice in the last 14 months, and they are one of the most energetic, entertaining, and FUN groups I've seen in decades! Arigato! #NewLeaders

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'm so happy you got to see them live! ^_^

[@alastairmcintyre4752]

Atarashi Gakko ( unlike some people ) don't take themselves too seriously - they concentrate on entertaining people 🙄 They are a performance dance group whose shows are based on both singing and dancing with some comedic elements thrown in - and they are WILD live . There's a reason this video has had 72m views in a year and they've just had a sold out world tour ( inc . the US ) and are invited to play at major festivals. There is a heavy emphasis on choreography in the shows and the songs ( like this one - for those who bother with the lyrics ) often hold a strong social message or commentary on Japanese mores . #Confused 🤣

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

#confused is right!

[@hedoban_nord]

Haha, getting confused by AG! at first is quite normal. I love these girls, especially their earlier stuff when they still sound very jazzy. But they have a huge variety in styles.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I love variety!

[@jeffedwards9180]

I'm looking forward to the Babymetal radio program with AG. These are the last 2 groups I've seen live, Babymetal in Milwaukee and AG in Chicago. This MV was my first exposure to AG, I found it quirky and fun. As a metalhead in his 50's I was WTF??? Then I read that they worked with Beastie Boys old producer, I checked out "Pineapple Kryptonite", "Forever Sisters" and their take on Beastie's "Intergalactic". That led me to "Suki Lie", "NAINAINAI", " Woo Go", " Tokyo Calling" and "Fly High" and others. I saw them with my daughter at a show that was sold out (5,000) or pretty close to it just after their collab with Maximum the Hormone was released. The fans were hyped, and all their dancing had the venue's floor flexing... This was the first concert that I've ever been to that there wasn't a band on stage, just 4 young ladies having fun and dancing their hearts out. I had a blast, please give then another try. Nice to see a group that entertains without taking themselves too seriously. Also, Momo-metal says she's so excited for their radio show with AG that she doesn't think she'll be able to sleep.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'm absolutely willing to give it another try! As I mentioned, I really enjoyed Suzuka's voice! But a lot of the people in this comments section trying to yell at me for being confused at this band I've never heard of or watched before or know anything about, especially with a song style like this that is new to me... idk. If this is how their fans act because my opinion differs than theirs or because I was confused, I may just watch AG on my own time. You gotta admit this wasn't the best song to dive into the band with considering knowing nothing about them.

[@jeffedwards9180]

@@Abigirl_Reacts I was confused also after this being my 1st song, but I've learned that this new wave of Japanese music is a bit different from what most of us know, sometimes it takes a few songs to get it. Once I saw them live I totally understood what they're doing. Maybe don't question what's going on right away, go with the feel...is it interesting, does it make you smile, is it different, Suzuka does have a great rich voice from you normal Japanese voice... It's all good. Sorry some of the fan base is giving you grief... I apologize for them... They're probably kids 🤣

[@4QIL07]

11 January.. Atarashii Gakko will be the official guest to Babymetal radio show

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Nice, good to know! Thanks a lot

[@stevewesley3841]

They are massively popular in Japan, most of thier songs are very rebellious so they are not popular with the Japanese music industry. They had to sign to an American record label. They look very young, but they were idols when they were at school and have been around about ten years. Their work on Maximum the Hormones Shimi was excellent and I'm guessing your patreon was setting the scene for that.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I have heard this mentioned previously! I'll have to take a looksie

[@Olkam-w5u]

They signed, their label is 88 Rising, USA

[@dreadinside654]

Come on Abi. You should listen to their other songs too. 🤣They don't sound the same with every songs and also they incorporated different styles and genre. They're goofy and not to be taken seriously. That's what they are. They do their own dance choreography. They are not parodying anything they are original. They also colloborated with Maximum The Hormone with the song "Shimi". If you like hard metal that's your que.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Sounds more down my alley

[@kfh1]

Loved your reaction Abi!!! This made me laugh out loud!!! 😂😂😂😂

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

It was funny ^_^

[@kfh1]

@@Abigirl_Reacts Just to be clear, I didn't care for the song at all, or the performance, to be honest, I thought the lyrics were a little creepy. It was your reaction to it that made me LMAO!!!

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Yes this song wasn't my favorite, I definitely gotta listen to more!

[@devilta666]

lol, zi can't stop laughing when watching your confused face😂

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I understand 😅😅😅

[@DaElfer]

the deeper voice is why i love Saiki from Band Maid as opposed to the girls from BabyMetal. Some good ones from AG are Suki Lie, Giri Giri and Tokyo Calling. They also have a really good video which is Maximum the Hormone featuring AG called Shimi

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

That's also why i love Saiki, you very me! I'm doing Shimi very soon, can't wait.

[@Elvie.trbl3]

Also could you react to phantom siita They are a retro girl group produced by Ado

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Sounds lovely!

[@DaniloSouza84]

I think it would have been better to start reacting to the official music video instead of First Take to understand them better. It's a very different JPOP group.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Possibly!

[@IAMisLove]

@@Abigirl_Reacts They are like BABYMETAL, shocking and WTH at first listen. Some fall in love after a few performances and some say, "Not for me". And there is nothing wrong with either response. 🖖❤

[@lordspydergaming3154]

​@IAMisLove No, they are amazing onfirst listen if the Fandom can stop being dumb and requesting their only garbage song all the time. Otabablue put them on the map because it's just boring pop. But that's not them. Seriously stop requesting this song. If this was the first song I had heard of them I would of written them off right away. I can't imagine how many other people have been turned away because this garbage song was the one they were instructed to listen to. Seriously everyone who requested this song should personally write an apology letter to Atarashii Gakko for turning away a potential fan.

[@jimnusbaum3589]

@@lordspydergaming3154 wow tell us what you really think! Maybe not their best but certainly not trash. Wouldn't have recommended the first take performance though.

[@lordspydergaming3154]

@@jimnusbaum3589 Maybe I wouldn't of hated it soooo much if the fandom didn't constantly request this as a first listen song. I've seen it a hundred times over that this is reactors first listen and then they're done. It really irritates me when a reactor does MTH Shimi and then there is a dozen AG! fans in the comments screaming for this song, then there is never a second look at AG! after that.

AG! is a happiness pill, every time (no matter how serious are the topics they talk about in the songs). Make yourself a favor and go into this rabbit hole. I feel like you are quick yo judge.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Lol I'm not quick to judge. If I was, then I wouldn't be open to hearing more from them. I feel like you were quick to judge me. =P

[@kirariniwa3948]

Good reaction!! I love your reactions. Yes they are very crazy and silly, but don't underestimate them, they are VERY talented. Fun fact: MIZYU and MOAMETAL are very good friends, so fans have always wanted a collaboration between these two groups, especially because both main vocalists are called Suzuka, and now that Babymetal has their radio show METARAJI and their first guests are Atarashii Gakko, fans are more excited to see a collaboration in the future. Songs I recommend: --Maningen --Fly High --Omakase --Change

[@cuttysark8017]

Ever since AG! and BM were photographed together at a festival and from a couple of tweets about a hug backstage there's been the idea that Mizyu and Moa are friends. Is there any other evidence for this? I don't know of any and I think a Mizyu/Moa friendship is fandom wishful thinking maybe to replace MoiMoi.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Added, thanks a bunch! ^_^

[@kirariniwa3948]

@@cuttysark8017 Yes and no. Many fans, especially in Japan, confirmed their friendship with the hug because rumors had been around before. This is because Mizyu is Moametal senpai, they were in the same high school And because Mizyu is a friend of Moa's friends And several girls from Sakura Gakuin like Hinata Sato. It may be that they only know each other and are not friends, but sharing a circle of friends and not be Friends would be unusual, but it may also be.

[@cuttysark8017]

@@kirariniwa3948 I have no idea whether or not Moa and Mizyu are friends, it just seems that conclusions are being drawn without much evidence. Maybe there'll be more evidence when AG! are on BM's radio show.

[@stevewesley3841]

It's slightly naughty comedy song.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I got that vibe! Hehe

[@deacon45]

Have you never heard a song before that was just supposed to be fun? This is entertainment, not a work of art. It's not the first time I've heard people singing in unison.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

This is the first time Ive heard of this band. The whole reaction was me wondering if this was supposed to be silly or not. No, I've never heard 3 singers in a girl group singing in unison but I'd love to hear another example for me to check out if you have one!

[@mikeb7379]

From way out from left field, I just watched Uncle Ray react to your Love Money 4 reaction. Absolutely hilarious! You really need to react to that next? "AG Money"

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

React to Ray reacting to me reacting to Ren? I'd enter the twilight zone if I do that haha

[@carlosismaelavilaromero9447]

"Jajaj, I like the contrast between this Suzuka and Suzuka Nakamoto, the Babymetal singer. They are completely opposite: extrovert vs introvert."

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Oh for sure!

[@stornowayscotland]

Thank u abi ❤

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Thanks for watching ^_^

[@stornowayscotland]

@Abigirl_Reacts your most welcome anytime

[@briandelgado6003]

You should. Check out Giri Giri by Atarashii gako , they have nice dance moves in that one

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Thanks Brian, I'll add it to my notes! ^_^

[@Olkam-w5u]

By the way, the so-called kawaii voice is not a natural voice; idols are specially trained in this vocal technique.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Was it what I was referring to with the really high pitched vocals?

[@joao_off]

Want something weird by them ^^? ATARASHII GAKKO! - Pineapple Kryptonite

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I need something EPIC

[@GraueMaus-d1e]

@@Abigirl_Reacts Would it be "epic" enough for you if the whole world is at stake? Then... Pineapple Kryptonite. ;-)

[@traylor2502]

@@Abigirl_Reacts +1 for Pineapple Kryptonite... With such a title it can be only EPIC, don't you think?

[@GrayPennell]

Abi I love AG but its cool if you don't. Since you said you would dig just Susuka singing well its a duet with Sheena Ringo but the other 3 just dance, kzbin.info/www/bejne/r6DEi5Zta66WjJo

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Yessss thank you so much for the link! This really helps ^_^

[@GrayPennell]

@@Abigirl_Reacts no problem i knew the minute you said you didnt like silly this was going to backfire so seriously kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWKmnqJjq8uZh7M

[@Lasakar]

Seeing Atarashii Gakko the very first time with this performance on "The F1rst Take" could be confusing. I suggest the following songs: "Change", "Nainainai", "Night Before the Exam", "Fly high". Then you can form your own opinion.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Of course, I'll check it out!

[@LouisFLamas]

J-Pop With a Strange twist is my take. Saw them in concert not to much of my cup of tear, but they are entertaining. Play to good crowds in clubs of 5,000 and less most of them. Will most likey check them out next time they come to Texas and see if they do anything different. I talk with someone and they are not huge/big enough to have a live backing band. I think it will serve them well. Backing tracks are limited and some lip-singing.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'm so happy you got to see them live! ^_^

[@Gadoshka]

Не будь такой серьезной. Это оригинальная песня. Они просто забавные девчонки и это их изюминка. Они нам именно такими и нравятся.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Awesome! I was more confused than serious though.

[@Elvie.trbl3]

Definitely react to more of their music videos. Most of their song have meanings behind them I recommend koi geba and change

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Perfect, tyvm!

[@thorstenkrieger6289]

Oh my!🙄 I will leave it at that!

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Honestly, same with this song. I gotta hear something different from them!

[@kc28kenneth]

Maybe you'll get to like them if you give them a little time. They have quickly become my favourites after Babymetal. Yes, completely different genre, but who cares? 😁 My favourite track is Essa Hoisa. Unfortunately no music video for it yet, but you'll find the song on KZbin.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'm sure they'll make a music video soon! Have a good one Kenny!

[@Ssserrrge]

finally i've found someone appreciating this epic reggaeton march ! it's my #1 song now (taken the crown from koi geba). it's much better then overrated tokyo calling while having the same epic vibe, but i understand how tokyo calling is more digestible for an average listener. really want to have a proper mv for this gem.

[@DarrellW_UK]

Haha, it was a comical parody about Japanese social issues - I really don’t think it’s presented in a way that makes it easy to take as seriously as the topic itself. I think that maybe a live performance rather than a One take may have been more interesting but the lack of harmonies I think is deliberate to add to the parody. TBH I didn’t like it much myself but as you said the main singer does have a nice warm tone.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

She does! I need to hear her sing some more

[@Ssserrrge]

do you always jump to conclusions by watching exactly one song of a new performer ?

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

What conclusion is it that you think i drew?

[@Ssserrrge]

​@@Abigirl_Reacts sorry for this hasty comment: I wrote it before going to the comment section where I found out you're going to give AG another listen. When you said "it's not for me", I assumed you're going to pass on them. This is a really bad song to introduce someone to AG. It's very similar to BM's Gimme Chocolate, which tends to turn people away (although, I find this song a perfect example of what kawaii metal is). The problem with AG is that their songs are so diverse that it's hard to guess which one the first time listener will like: there's always a chance the reactor hate this specific genre. Maybe, Tokyo Calling will be your thing. It's not my favorite, but seems a lot of people like it. It has epic brass section (and you asked for something epic :)).

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Its OK, I'm happy we cleared that up. I'll add this request to my list, thanks so much for the suggestion!

[@ApocryphalBob]

I know it is hard to believe, but these girls are PUNK. Fight the system PUNK! Atarashi Gakko translates as New School Leaders, they are leading a new school of Japanese 'being'. Using cute and silly as weapons, their lyrics may seem opaque and superficial to many Westerners but in Japan they know how to read between the lines. I have read, and believe, that they are regarded in many quarters as 'the most dangerous band in Japan'. Now, I am not a particularly big fan of their music style as such, I prefer Band-Maid and Maximum the Hormone. I am a 66 year old white guy from the UK and watching them does make me feel a bit guilty, like I am some asian fetisch prevert. But, I am and always have been, up for anything punk, rebellious, different. Atarashi Gakko does that for me. They are very talented at what they do, and yes, Suzuka has a fantastic voice. I hope you give them a chance reveal more, by reacting to Tokyo Calling and Shimi "with Max.t.h." Thanks for reacting to this though, enjoyed it as always . 👍✌

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

As much as that one is being requested, I think I'll do it!

[@iBleedsMetal]

Vast difference between fun & silly

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Depends on the person and the circumstance. I know nothing about this band and as a first time viewer, it was quite confusing and silly to me. That is my opinion.

[@apocalypse10rus]

How can you take everything seriously there?

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

The way this sounded, I did not take it seriously. It was just confusing for me. I thought it was a parody.

[@taihavard]

So what happens when you combine Atarashii Gakko! with Maximum The Hormone? This happens :D MAXIMUM THE HORMONE -SHIMI (feat. ATARASHII GAKKO!) kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpa1mJtmZr2VZ7c Worlds collide. Much more Atarashii Gakko! headbanging in this suggestion XD Edit: I love that with all the full on metal you have done etc, this is possibly the first time I have seen you this confused XD

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

LOL I was definitely confused but MTH sounds more down my alley!

[@debbieguillory4379]

Love it!!!too cute n funny

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

It was funny 😁

[@IAMisLove]

👍Awesome performance. Atarashii Gakko is not afraid to ruffle a few feathers. I'm going to speak it into existence and say they will collaborate with BABYMETAL one day😊. 🖖❤

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

That would be amazing!

[@rolandkarlsson7072]

Personally I really love AG. But yes, they are silly. Even though they exaggerated it for this First Take IMHO. But, they are also deadly serious. They are excellent dancers and athletes. Their songs are generally catchy and they contain some kind of social engagement, sometimes very serious and sometimes small stuff, like eating candy and get sugar high and sugar low. One of their more serious ones is Koi Geba which is about teachers taking advantage of female pupils. Very dark video.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I'll have to check it out, sounds intense!

[@rrahl]

Supremely talented band/performances by this group. They are quite unique. My personal favorite is Tokyo Calling.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Added, thanks a bunch! ^_^

[@DeePal072]

What's her name? Suzuka. Of course, it has to be Suzuka 😅. Try Tokyo Calling, different vibes. BTW Maximum The Hormone last year released a couple of collaborations, one with Ano, the other with Atarashi Gakko (no leaders).

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I may check out the maximum the hormone one soon!

[@daniellegarcia4287]

More Atarashii Gakko reaction 🙏🏻❤️

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Coming soon!

[@rayharley597]

Think my faves of what I've heard so far are Tokyo Calling and Toryanse. Generally I prefer the heavier bands, such as Band Maid who I believe have the same line up as when they formed many years ago, but this bunch have a sense of wicked fun about them that appeals to this 'ol Queen :-). I get what you say in your reaction as this is not a favourite of mine, though I do like it, kerk

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Ok cool, thanks for telling me your favorites. Noted! ^_^

[@rayharley597]

@@Abigirl_Reacts If you haven't already, do check out the official video for the track; much more impactful, especially when you pay attention to the lyrics. This is not your ordinary group; very reminiscent of bands like Bikini Kill: L7 and even Portishead in the mixture of lyrics; style and genres. kerk

[@mikye8876]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👍👍👍😄🤟There are various expressions and various artists in Japan.😂

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

This is an accurate statement. ^_^

[@PaleHorseShabuShabu]

This performance does a good job of showing their personalities, but there's a youtube channel called Wings of Pegasus where the guy on the channel breaks down how First Take is a fraudulent channel that clearly uses autotune. He uses this song as an example. It was . . . depressing, but enlightening and hard to refute.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Really?! Can you provide a link please?

[@nonggakko]

AG, es diferente, es único y es divertido, los que estamos hartos de lo mismo y lo falso, buscamos algo original y AG es la mejor opción.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I can't wait to hear something else from them. Thank you!

[@tracycarnes1048]

You’re just being insulting now, and you shouldn’t be so proud of your ignorance

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Geez. What was insulting?

[@tracycarnes1048]

@ it was when you question3d whether Kanon , Rin, or Mizyu were even necessary because they were all singing the same thing, you instantly reminded me of “Amadeus” when Mozarts rival had the king complaining that there were “too many notes”, they’re singing like this because they are supposed too, this is how the song goes, it’s part of the song. They were having a blast and you wanted them to be “serious” because you couldn’t figure out if the song was a comedy? Watched your other episodes and love them, it was just these guys, and I kept thinking how hurt they’d be to see your review of this (now that I’ve reread this, it’s definitely a “me” thing🤦‍♀️😹)

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Hi Tracy, although I personally find it unnecessary to have 3 girls singing in unison, it's fine if they do so. It's just not for me. I wasn't reviewing them or anything. I just don't get it. It's why I was confused for the majority of this video. I don't want them to be serious. I definitely didn't think it was serious, I thought they were being silly. At least that's the way my confusion was leaning. You gotta admit, this wasn't the best song to introduce me to the band. I'm going to hear something different soon because I gotta hear more of Suzuka's voice. I really liked it!

[@tracycarnes1048]

@ give them another listen, try pineapple kryptonite or their collaboration with maximum the hormone shimmi, they’re awesome (Love your channel too🤗)

[@olonoli]

Ag its. Weird experience but the more you listen to them the more kinna make sense 😅

[@minamihideki7123]

Atarashii Gakko! is a talented group of artists. They don't play instruments themselves, but they dance and sing. They write the lyrics for some of their songs and direct them live. And in this performance of ‘The First Take’, I think they provoked and enjoyed us by attacking the edge of sillyness and seriousness. I am glad you take up AG!, but it might have certainly room to think about whether this song or this performance is the best choice for a first song. It's certainly a popular one from them, but the minority opinions, those say this performance doesn't showcase their true energy having in the live shows and I agree with it. The other songs, or live performances showcase the individual personalities of each of the four girls. However, then I am not sure about what to recommend. I prefer their earlier songs to their more recent works tghough... Anyway, I hope you keep on reacting to AG! more. Thank you from Japan.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Thanks for taking the time to write your insightful comment! ^_^

[@semiijs]

I love AG! Mizyu is my fav :D

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

🥰

[@bleedsmetal]

Fun Fun Fun Fun .

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

😅

[@Lord_Heron]

Was this a real reaction, or a parody? Not impressed. Such a dismissive attitude. Awful reaction to an excellent group. I will be avoiding your channel like the plague.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Lol Sorry you feel that way. Whelp, thanks for watching! I was so dismissive, especially when I talked about really liking Suzuka's voice and needing to hear something else from them.

[@sreypovchun663]

The different between cute japanese girls and whatever horrorshow that comes out of the woke western world blows my mind

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Mine too.

[@kevinbowland4686]

Not really a fan of J-Pop, but I know they are popular. Their collab with Maximum the Hormone was incredible though. Shimi is a pretty hard MTH track. I think you will enjoy it.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I gotta hear this.

[@softmr]

日本の音楽は真面目な人には向かない事が分かった

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

To be clear, I wasn't serious. I was confused. I love plenty of Japanese music and also not a fan of some. It depends on the individual song. This one was not my favorite but I enjoyed Suzuka's voice a lot so I plan to react to more from this band.

[@abjbusti8586]

It was one take too many 🤭

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Its not for everyone 😅

[@robertmcclanahan7755]

Wrong song to start with as they do not all sing on that track. Toyko calling you should give a listen to.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Thanks for the suggestion! ^_^

[@oldmanjimh3165]

Okay*!*!*! Did like lower vocals but no idea why they have so many views. Really didn't like the song.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

They must be doing something we're missing out on! Will have to watch more to find out.

[@lordspydergaming3154]

Im so sorry that this song was your fisrt foray into Atarashii Gakko. The fandom, like that of Hanabie do an amazing job of requsting their worst song that is in no way representative of the group or their other songs. Otana Blue is hot garbage and more than a little creepy. Other much better songs are Tokyo Calling, Fly High, Omakase, Suki Lie, Toryanse, or my personal favorite Change.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

'Hot garbage' had me rolling lmao in any case. There's no doubt they're talented, the views alone explains that! I'm willing to give them another shot, I liked Suzuka a lot!

[@lordspydergaming3154]

​@Abigirl_Reacts Sazuka's voice is exactly why Change is my favorite song from them. She goes soooo low. It's amazing. The song was released at the end of August and still somehow manged to make it into my top 10 listened to tracks of the year. I'm a metal head, but Atarashii Gakko is one of my top favorite groups. They are so much better than this song. Also they did a collaboration with Maximum the Hormone that goes hard

[@oji_weeb]

Completely disagree about it being hot garbage, but I also understand that it doesn’t travel well pulled out of the Japanese pop culture context it came from.

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

I think I'll do that collab soon!

[@willemkoekemoer5042]

After watching some of your reactions i am realising as soon as you dont like the song and band you will start hearing strange musical instruments and completly loose interest in the reaction if i had to pay for this i would demand my money back just stick to your Baby metal reactions leave the other japanese groups alone

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Name one reaction where I suddenly heard strange instruments because I didn't like it. I heard strange synth because this song had strange synth.

[@willemkoekemoer5042]

Nemophilas cover of Babymetal or did you forget

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

Still thinking about that reaction from 4 months ago eh? Yeah, I remember that one. I thought the main singer had a unique narrow voice. What I don't remember is, what instrument did I suddenly start to hear?

[@jesusolivas8933]

jajajaja your face 🤨

[@Abigirl_Reacts]

#confused