ACC vs Automobilista 2 vs Gran Turismo 7 - Nissan GT-R NISMO GT3 at Monza Comparison

[@MotoGamesTV]

Real life onboards for comparison: kzbin.info/www/bejne/hn6tlpWFYsh4Y68 kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6e1g39jgs9mfa8

[@vyasrushi5177]

Wow, GT7 sounds surprisingly more accurate than what people gives it credit for....ACC is still Sligh more accurate though thanks to its transmission whine noises

[@Ary634]

Because AMS2 uses a previous generation of GTR, here is another onboard video to compare. 😊 kzbin.info/www/bejne/jpqVioWga8ykeKM

[@AnotherWatchChannel]

I have all 3 games. GT7 - playtime 400 hours and I’m done playing - good but cockpit view sucks. - it’s still Arcade-ish - FFB is decent but not great. - graphics are the best - this game is more about the career mode, online, and getting all the cars. Not a lot of replay ability once you have done everything. ACC - 100 hours ish.. don’t play much anymore - good for only one thing… GT3. - FFB is awesome. - sound is really good - only good for online multi, and offline GT championship. Due to only one class of car I hardly play. I’m a big F1 fan so this game is not really my cup of tea. AMS 2 - 600 hours and rising - the best FFB and feeling/handling - graphics almost as good as GT7 - sounds the best overall by far. - the amount of content in this game is insane.. (55 track locations with 90+ tracks) - historical tracks and cars (if you like any vintage F1, GT stuff you will love it) - custom championships allow replayability to the max. All F1 cars through the ages to 2023 so you can create custom season later with the same car and historical tracks, or take them on modern tracks. If GT racing is your thing, you can take Gt3 cars on Nordschleife unlike ACC. And create a custom Gt3 endurance championship which means you have ACC if you have AMs2… no need for ACC. - Le Mans is coming this year 2023… All 3 are good sims, but AMS2 is the only one I keep continually playing and overall.

[@Big1_]

Assetto Corsa is the best.

[@davidcastineirasgarcia7751]

If you like looking at the trees more than feeling behind the wheel, Gt7 is your game, if it's the opposite, AMS2 is the best I've tried...

[@darkizofficial]

fr?

[@chuanjenchang3153]

I like looking at trees

[@lukeskywalker3839]

The truth hurts and I feel the pain cuz I am a big fanboy of GT saga but since GT6 this shit became arcade

[@Pupixario]

@@lukeskywalker3839 It was always arcade but this is the most complete car enthusiast franchise that ever existed. It's beautiful and the cars are very well represented. Both visually and emotionally.

[@lukeskywalker3839]

@@Pupixario but thrust me the only thing you will get if you try to take this as an reference point for irl racing is being slow af or getting injured or worse in the best escenario for you

[@thenuvolari9834]

I like how Polyphony put especial care to put the different tree species where they are on Monza instead of just 'Hey let's put some generic 3D trees here and there no one will notice if it's inaccurate or not', ACC got this as well too, only thing that's missing tho is Parthenocissus quinquefolia, the creeping plant that lives on the trunk of the trees. AMS2 creates an illusion that the trees are 3D but unfortunately they aren't very good 2D trees that throws me off a bit, and the coloring is weird as well.

[@wordsshackles441]

interesting comment

[@thanekrios3211]

AMS2's colouring is actually the closest of the three to real life Monza in my opinion. Look at Charles Leclerc's onboard lap for reference.

[@oppos727]

I think AMS2 goes the extra step for overall accuracy, plus the trees and surrounding foliage completely change based on seasons/time of year. The Nordschleife looks totally different in the summer and winter time, for example.

[@MrBonger88]

I liked ACC for in car and GT7 for chase cam . I really like how you can hear the echoes of the car sound in GT7

[@flyingphoenix113]

I have no idea why AMS2 decided to go with the oldest version of the GTR GT3 for their latest update. It seems completely nonsensical, and it is handily outperformed by the other GT3 cars currently in the game.

[@huks.]

I think it's a reused model from Project Cars 2. Which is fine, it's good that at least someone is getting use out of those assets with the PC franchise now dead.

[@flyingphoenix113]

@Huks , that would explain it. I hope they are able to utilize all of the Project Cars assets if that is truly the case.

[@kolysion164]

AMS2 is for a like aliexpress, cheap without quality, ACC is premium quality, GT7 is the king for console with Forza

[@Ary634]

Because AMS2 uses a previous generation of GTR, here is another onboard video to compare: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jpqVioWga8ykeKM I love AMS2 and ACC so much, but also, I like the sound of the paddle shifter in GT7 (i didn't play with that).

[@andrelfity]

I am really impressed how the lap time are very similar in all sims. Did you try to control the pace to match them or was it "natural"?

[@MotoGamesTV]

In this case, in each game I did some testing laps first to see what times I can get and I knew that in Automobilista 2 I need to drive slightly slower, because lap time difference was +1 second compared to other games.

[@vyasrushi5177]

@MotoGamesTV I think that just shows how accurate and similar the tracks scans are in GT7 and ACC as both of them are FIA certified

[@spitfire5452]

acc and ams2 pretty similar sounds and definitely more accurate. gt7 not realistic, more like stock gtr.

[@conchaelapelota]

GT7 ♥

[@firstgengamer4443]

Acc competizione is best in visual and realism

[@Dustparticle000]

Chill agent venom

[@firstgengamer4443]

@@Dustparticle000 agent Venom 😁

[@Coporfo]

This comparision is not fair. 2018 vs 2015 GT-R GT3, very different car and a very different sound IRL. Vastly revised engine, different exhaust setup, different gearbox and so on. You should use the 2013-2015 car in all games.

[@MotoGamesTV]

Still not fair, since AMS2 version is 2017.

[@Coporfo]

@@MotoGamesTV Perhaps they said that because of the livery. AFAIK, last major update for that car was in 2015. The version that ran from 2013 to 2017 received EVO updates through its life, while the 2018 model was a brand new car. This is why this comparison is not very good IMO.

[@MotoGamesTV]

Mistakes ware made, but this video will get like 1500 or 2000 views max, so it's not worth to fix it.

[@Coporfo]

@@MotoGamesTV Fair enough. Love your work.

[@esplayerr]

All good, GT-R ever good 🏁

[@vitalyrasp]

В AssettoCorsa положение в кокпите звучит реалистично!👌

[@cheslynholland1487]

ACC looks the best IMO.

[@mkv35]

Все три машины хороши. Но, для оценки какая самая реальная, вы сами знаете чего не хватает. Реальной машины на реальном треке в этом обзоре. Но это на самом деле сложно сделать.

[@alevila4862]

Jogo o ACC e pelo que eu sei, ele foi criado com o feedback de pilotos da própria GT3. Creio q deve ser o mais próximo da realidade.

[@victhorkz]

Sim também já joguei o ACC é incrível só falta mais categorias e carros

[@victhorkz]

Não jogo ACC pelo o fato de só ter carro GT3 e GT4 e ter que pagar a maioria dos carros para usarem

[@alevila4862]

@@victhorkz verdade, seria melhor msm... mais categorias, GT1 e até monoposto.

[@victhorkz]

@@alevila4862 sim falta mais carros DTM,F1,BTCC,V8 SUPERCARS,24HRS,NASCAR

[@alevila4862]

@@victhorkz até uma stock car brasileira

[@Dustparticle000]

Where is project cars 3?

[@vyasrushi5177]

Dead

[@Dustparticle000]

@@vyasrushi5177 Not completely bud!

[@vitalyrasp]

Не актуален! К сожалению.

[@lucasomeister2823]

In garbage

[@herrlogan17]

The thing I really hate in Gt7 is the "step on gas" lack of fluiditiy. There is something missing in terms of engine sound. Good comparison though :)

[@johnmay330]

Yes I agree. It's like an on and off switch, which really bugs me because great sounding loud cars for instance Porsche 911 GT3 RS, Ferrari F40 just to name a few suffer from this. They haven't fixed this since GT Sport. I'm really sad about this because GT6 didn't have this problem.

[@herrlogan17]

@@johnmay330 Yep, it's strange and something definitely shouldnt be present in such title.

[@kak8895]

@@johnmay330 Because GT7 is still arcade game. Bootleg iRacing

[@skyhightrees]

@@kak8895 not at all. They are talking about sounds. It's nothing to do with how arcade or not the game is. bootleg sim racer

[@tongquoccuong7898]

ASSETTO CORSA have the best sound ❤🎉

[@vyasrushi5177]

Sounds- GT7, ACC, AMS2 Graphics - GT7, ACC, AMS2 Replays - GT7, AMS2, ACC I'm surprised that AMS2 is loosing to ACC in terms of graphics Before ACC and AMS2 fanboys come here crying, check out the second link of his pinned comment, GT7 is by far the most accurate out of all 3 in terms of sounds from the same steering wheel camera angle

[@nuf2188]

Sounds: ACC, AMS2, GT7

[@vyasrushi5177]

@Nuf lol, nope....just check out the link of real life versions he has posted in the pinned comment....GT7 is very accurate....unfortunately a lot of racing game fans have this misconception that loud and fake noises = better sound design, but that's not how it works Not to forget that AMS2 doesn't have the same car but even then it's sounding nothing like the real thing

[@hennessey861]

How on earth can you judge graphics on a KZbin video

[@vyasrushi5177]

@Hennessey 86 I have played all 3 buddy, that's why I was surprised that ACC is looking better here while I think AMS2 is a better looking game than ACC overall...maybe it's just this particular track...but GT7 wins out easily with its lighting and car models

[@nuf2188]

@@vyasrushi5177 AMS2 doesnt have "fake loud noises" lol. It sounds realistic especially in 3rd person. GT7 sounds nothing like its irl counterpart. Even if they're different cars, AMS2 still sounds more like its irl counterpart than GT7 does.

[@GeorgeTigra]

GT7 sound is the most accurate!

[@ALMAHDI1720]

wtf ???????? ACC is the best by a mile from everything else here ?

[@GeorgeTigra]

@@ALMAHDI1720 I don't care your opinion.. i have heard this car for hours irl...

[@ALMAHDI1720]

@@GeorgeTigra this is not an opinion, these cars aren't remotely the same at all, and ACC has the best interior sounds ever on a racing game, while their exterior sounds, even tho they're still recorded, are lacking. GT7 doesn't even use a real GT-R Nisma GT3 engine, they use a regular GTR which they add transmission whine

[@فراسحمايده-ل8ن]

@@GeorgeTigra i like this bro

[@فراسحمايده-ل8ن]

@@ALMAHDI1720 bo you sbik arabek

[@lucasomeister2823]

I wish we have just one with best of all of them

[@g1b.ar1]

GT7 is perfect

[@antoniocarlosmoita1937]

First Assetto in second Automobilista

[@JoshsoJB]

Both this version and the 2013 one in GT7 are completely wrong. Not a bad sound, just wrong.

[@vyasrushi5177]

Did you check out the links he posted in pinned comment? GT7 Sounds very accurate, especially the second link which has the same camera angle as this gameplay clips

[@huks.]

Yep, GT has the sound of the 6-to-2-to-1 exhaust of the road car (where merging the last two pipes causes the high pitch sound) while the real GT-R GT3 has a 6-to-2 exhaust layout with side pipes.

[@sudd3660]

the sound is so bad, that is what hold racing games back, its the bass frequencies that are missing. grand turismo is the worst, no better than the first game. console shit

[@Ar2_Dee2]

"WEEEEeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee"-GT-R in ACC

[@PettyWingman]

Its sound in GT7 is recycled from the GT-R Gr.B Rally Car. I desperately hope that this car, the 2013 model and R.S.01s get a new accurate sound.

[@vyasrushi5177]

Did you actually check out the second link in his pinned comment? Gt7 is actually the most accurate out of all 3

[@PettyWingman]

Of course I did.

[@vyasrushi5177]

@Petty Wingman And you find it inaccurate compared to AMS2 and ACC?? Lol...those 2 are nothing like the second clip

[@TinoushGTR]

AMS 2 dash and sound is way off. as a gtr owner i can tell you that gt7 sound is spot on.

[@Tripokaridos22]

Do that with Raceroom and u will not believe how better the environment looks.

[@VulpesVulpes144]

Maybe its just me, but why does the sense of speed always feel so much slower than what the speedo says.

[@barracadoseuze4213]

FOV plays a big part of the Speed Sense in Games, sometimes you need to change it to get a better sense of speed

[@VulpesVulpes144]

@@barracadoseuze4213 thanks I'll try this out

[@فراسحمايده-ل8ن]

GT7 is better than all respects

[@clown_6937]

Fanboy

[@neilbezuidenhout9284]

@@clown_6937 Clown.... Is just stating facts or are u blind?

[@animeflvray4208]

@@clown_6937 check the pinned comment first*

[@Incognito-vc9wj]

Lol.

[@Tripokaridos22]

First mist try to be a sim.

[@ozer928]

Yep, GT7 smashes it just right.

[@darwinLee81283]

Untill you drive it and realize it's an arcade game

[@ozer928]

@@darwinLee81283 Haha, jokes on you.

[@neilbezuidenhout9284]

@@darwinLee81283 I'd love to see u master this arcade game big mouth. Go put dome top 100 times in.... It should be easy for u...... U defs are a joke

[@darwinLee81283]

@@neilbezuidenhout9284 Lmao. Go Drive Races from your Roof Camera and Upgrade Wing packages and Turbo kits 😭😭. " The Real Driving Simulator" 😭😭😭🤡

[@neilbezuidenhout9284]

@@darwinLee81283 how bout I race you in any Sim of ur choice?? As far as I know I am able to modify cars in real life?? Not so? Ur a wannabe, and it's trolls like u that are normally slow. I'd really be keen to see what u go Mr pro Sim Sim racer..... I can guarantee to you.... Ur gona be embarrassed. Let me know big boy

[@wordsshackles441]

GT7

[@charonunderground8596]

All 3 games with poor graphics native to 2014

[@vyasrushi5177]

Another Forza baby troll lurking in the comment section of non Borza videos

[@charonunderground8596]

@@vyasrushi5177 Spierdalaj

[@andreasmoller9798]

@@vyasrushi5177 agreed👍

[@KuchingKingVideoGamer]

Miles better than what Forza is doing 🤣

[@thegame6038]

Gt7 sounds so boring.

[@vadimsubaru1]

ACC - best graphics. GT - best sound.

[@vyasrushi5177]

ACC has constant shadow pop ins, whitewashed lighting, over exaggerated car body reflections Making the car look like plastic, wrong material response of interiors...nothing about it is better than GT7 in terms of graphics

[@vitalyrasp]

Best graphic - GT7!👍 But sound effects better in ACC!👌