According to YOU: the BEST lip liners EVER

[@kathleenevans8902]

I love this series. I really think it would be helpful to do a skincare routine version as well. Like favorite facial sunscreen, favorite cleanser etc.

[@ale.marmon]

It honestly surprise me that Essence liners didn't make it in this ranking, I think they are so good! Truly long-lasting and great price point

[@mimi3981]

Can you recommend shades?

[@arielts06]

It’s interesting that there were so many high end winners for this category. Lip liner is a category that I cannot see myself paying more than $5 for. I will pay $100 for an eyeshadow palette and $50 for a lipstick but best believe I am pairing it with my $5 lip liner that I bought on sale 😂. Morphe, LA Girl, and Milani are my go-to.

[@DahliaAsmr143]

I love LA girl lip liners nyx is also good

[@talia841951]

Morphe Color Pencil in shade Sweet Tea I got it for £4.50 on Asos and they had 30% off

[@arielts06]

@@talia841951 Sweet Tea is one of my favorites! I just bought the lip kit so I could have a matching lipstick and gloss 🤗. Makeup Talk is another favorite from Morphe.

[@judithbeckham4165]

The LA Girl retractable lip liner is awesome- better than most high-end, also Believe Beauty makes a great one!

[@arielts06]

@@judithbeckham4165 Totally agree about the LA Girl liners! I have not tried Believe but now I want to LOL

[@steph____]

Holy cow, your eye look in this video is beyond stunning. I literally can’t stop looking at your eyes and I am totally distracted! LOL! I immediately went to your description section to see if you listed out the products you used, but unfortunately, I didn’t find it. PLEASE replicate this look in a separate video, it is jaw-dropping gorgeous. 😊

[@alyssajennings3046]

Please, please give us a tutorial on this eyeshadow look and/or tell which palette you used. You look even more stunningly beautiful than you always do!!!

[@allieglines]

Thank you so much! I filmed it!!! It’ll be posted later this week!! It’s a full face of nothing new so keep your eyes peeled! 🎉💕

[@erikayaz]

I’m pretty sure is the Patrick Ta major dimensions II Palette 💕

[@Raymondgogolf]

Hi Alyssa I hope my comment didn't sound as a form of privacy invasion your comment tells of a wonderful woman with a beautiful heart which led me to comment I don't normally write in the comment section but I think you deserve this complement. If you don’t mind can we be friends? Thanks God bless you….🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@prateeksha_karanth31]

Omg Allie!!! I can't take my eyes off of you! Your makeup looks absolutely flawless♥️ And you are looking stunning as always🔥

[@allieglines]

Thank you so much!!! 🥰

[@elizabethruggiero9950]

Allie, I always find your videos so informative… my fave lip liners are Revlon colorstay. Creamy, and boy do they mean STAY. You look absolutely glowing, and it’s such a joy watching you do what you love. You are as lovely on the inside as you are on the outside❤️

[@calamariii96]

Allie is by far one of the few youtubers that are genuinely appreciative of their subscribers/viewers. Much love to you Allie! You deserve it. I still continue to use your bags--its really the only reason that gets me excited to use my makeup 😂

[@ellieharbold8511]

Thank you for brightening our day with your videos! I had a rough day today that almost made me cry. And your video helped to calm me down.

[@violetviolet888]

1) Charlotte Tilbury: Pillow Talk - Lip Cheat 2) NYX Professional Makeup: Slim Lip Pencil 3) ColourPop: Lip Utensils 4) MAC Lip Pencil 5) Milani Cosmetics: Color Statement Lip Liner 6) Jaclyn Cosmetics: Poutspoken Lip Liner 7) Rare Beauty: Kind Words Lip Liners 8) TIE: Make Up For Ever: Lip Liners AND Pat McGrath Permagel Ultra Lip Pencils 9) NYX Professional Makeup: Suede Matte Lip Liner 10)TIE: Huda Beauty: Lip Contour AND Makeup by Mario: Ultra Suede Sculpting Lip Pencil

[@ashleymccready978]

Yay! Love this series! On a sidenote, I noticed you have a home favorites on your Shop My and I was thinking it'd be awesome to see a vlog about decorating for fall. I love your fall makeup and your aesthetic and I think it'd be really cool to see what fall decor stands out to you. Love you and hope you have a fantastic Tuesday 😊

[@carolynk8004]

Omg omg!!!! My comment made the video on the rare beauty liners😍😍😍😍Thank you so much Allie!!! I’m 2 days late from traveling but you absolutely made my day!!

[@audreyredigolo7104]

I love the rare beauty lip liners & lipsticks. These are by far my favs at the moment

[@sarapiland5340]

Love you Allie! I rediscovered your channel this year and enjoy all your videos. Thanks for being an influencer.

[@sarapiland5340]

👆

[@hannahb3787]

Allie!!!!!! LOVE this series!!! You should totally do a top 10 according to you skincare series next! such as exfoliator, serum, moisturizer, toner, etc. Thanks for doing what you do love watching your videos when I get home from work 💗

[@b.b.8955]

I love this series as well. CT is one of my favorite lip liners as well. One of my favorite lip liner colors is Walk of No Shame. The perfect everyday natural red lip. LOVE OVE LOVE IT! 🥰😍🥰😍

[@deborahselincourt8060]

Hi Allie, my fav lip liner atm is lawless honey rose. Ty for all u do!!

[@steffid_]

i would love to see other youtubers doing this series as the results woule change depending on the audience tastes. Would be fun to see a version of this with folks that do a lot of alternative makeup styles 😍

[@Metzli]

Same, sometimes I submit more "alternative brands" into her form but, eh, it's never on the top 10 xD

[@MilliDavison]

You’re looking so autumnal today 😍😍 beautiful as always x

[@fantcgirl1978]

Wish there were swatches.

[@allieglines]

Most of the submissions were about the formula, not necessarily the shade! Next time I’ll definitely incorporate swatches for specific color mentions :)

[@danaelise88]

I think she probably wanted to see how they applied on the skin

[@divyasasidharan2960]

​@@allieglines swatches help with formula

[@ceceliavanegas8954]

@@allieglines yeah, no but she doesn’t wanna admit it

[@ceceliavanegas8954]

@@danaelise88 yeah, no but she doesn’t wanna admit it

[@nancysuda9471]

Very interesting video. Love all the lip pencils in the running. I will try a couple to see if they work for me. Thanks

[@camilledotson9782]

I would love to see a video where you watch all of these lip liners and same with the upcoming lipstick video! Love your videos! They bring me so much joy 💛.

[@sassynurse5355]

Allie! I don’t know how I missed the vote on this. I’m a try-er…I’m always looking at the new stuff EXCEPT when it comes to lip liners. The best lip liner ever, ever is old school….the color Fig by Estée Lauder is the bees knees, lol. I’m scared to death they’ll discontinue it, so at least one person in my family puts one in my Christmas stocking every year. I am not a pro make up artist but I do weddings on the side for friends & family…it’s also my go-to bride color. Love your channel, Allie!

[@angelab5000]

Ik me too. This slipped passed me

[@bee3027]

Loved the lip liner video! Cannot wait for the lipstick one too!! Thank you for sharing!

[@camilleollo8131]

LOVE. i can't wait for the lipstick and lip gloss categories as well!!!!

[@shoddypockets9666]

Hey Allie, favourite most helpful KZbin series EVER thankyou to you and the voters x

[@kaleidospiked]

This series is amazing!! I watched this one and then went back and binge watched all the others. Have put my vote in for my favourite category of all time, lipstick. Can't wait for that :)

[@genietillery878]

Thank you for these videos. They are so helpful and I need some new lip liners. Now I know what to get.

[@nevinewahba6240]

OMG this eye look is everything!!!!!!!!😍 Pleaseeeee share the details!!! LOVE 🥰🥰🥰

[@MeganGerardin]

The only lip liner missing from this list was the NYX Nude Suede Shoes Liner! Thank you Allie, I love you and I am so inspired by you 🥰

[@Future-zx9ts]

Don't sleep on the Essence 8hr lip liners. I bought a couple of colors a few months ago, and I am always shocked at how well they last! And they go on smoothly and have such great colors. I have the Pat, Mac, CT, Rare Beauty, Mario and a whole plethora of other lip liners, but the Essence is one I reach for as often as the high end and high ranked ones!

[@infullbloommonica]

Yay if you ever come to South Africa you will have an amazing time! You definitely have fans here 🌺

[@Anaa38]

I like the cool toner vibes of your makeup look. It really reminds me of fall

[@kelseykmua]

MILANI IN SPICE IS MY FAVEEEEE!!!! Literally makes my lips look HUGE and is the perfect color for year-round! It's warm enough for spring and summer to wear with a gloss, and deep enough to wear with a Matte lipstick with in the fall and winter!

[@neenazeebee]

Yes! It's so good!!!

[@alliv3052]

Haus Labs in the shade Arc. It’s a Demi matte but it stays on so long and it’s such a beautiful mauvy rose color. I use it all the time and it’s worn down to the nub. Going to purchase another one 😊

[@baileydx]

I know you are going to do a full face of all the #1 products, but i would also love to see #10! I would totally watch #1-10 but i know that is a lot to ask LOL. Love this series❤️

[@Alice-fr1ef]

Hi Allie, as usual you have done a great job with your makeup today. You look beautiful. I like the Colourpop, NXY, Moira and Smashbox lip liners too. I have really enjoyed this series Allie and gained great ideas and new products. Thank you so much and we love you too💐

[@jennycorral4830]

These videos are so fun!! Especially when I own the number one ranking, idk why but i get so excited lol. Love you allie. Such a fun series!

[@hannahhubbard]

I absolutely love this series! Can’t wait for the next one! ❤️

[@CeleryStickz]

Love this series so much! How many more products do we have left to go? Lipstick, gloss, eyebrow products, setting spray, and eyeliner? I can’t wait for eyeliner!!

[@allielinder4462]

She already did eyeliner 😊

[@CeleryStickz]

@@allielinder4462 oh really?? It’s not in the playlist :( maybe she forgot to add it

[@Metzli]

@@allielinder4462 i looked for it recently and didn't find it.. Is the video title majorly different? :o

[@juliepiller3532]

Omg Allie yet again u look totally stunning ur makeup is so amazing and beautiful I just get so excited every Tuesday Thursday Saturday to just watch ur videos they are amazing and I learn so much from u Allie on how to do my makeup can’t wait till ur next video xxx

[@juliepiller3532]

Hi Allie I’m messaging u to claim my surprise xx

[@steffid_]

I can't wait for the final video with all the products!

[@Cladams620]

Nyx lipliners!!!!! Best ones 💖 I like soft-spoken and Los Angeles

[@laurieclarkson9180]

Thanks Samreen! I got the NYX Suede Matte Lip Liner in Cold Brew and love it! I needed a good brown one.

[@mundodamaquiagem]

I love this series. Love your makeup look too. It's so beautiful. My favorite lip liner in the moment is Rare Beauty. Love xoxo

[@angelab904]

I don't have many but my favorite one is from Kylie Cosmetics surprisingly. They are easy to apply and last a while. I also love Maybelline lip liners too. Mine are getting old so I need some new ones ASAP lol. Thx for this video! I think I'm going to try NYX since they're cheap and just a 5 minute walk to the Target by my house lol! Sephora is about 10 min ( I live behind a big shopping plaza which is good and bad!) Funny thing too is that Ulta is also just a 5 min walk from my job haha. In other word's I'm in trouble bc of easy access to my favorite makeup stores!

[@rhonda2337]

Allie I need a tutorial on this makeup look! The eyeshadow is chef's kiss 👩‍🍳 💋

[@neesa5613]

Omg! I got a shoutout AND you said my name right! 🥰 Love your positive demeanor. Your channel is my comfort channel and after getting cavities filled today, this was such a treat!

[@allieglines]

Yayyy!! Thank you for submitting your review!! Good luck at the dentist today! Love you lots!! xoxo

[@lavayuki]

Thank you for mentioning my quote on the Huda lip liner in your video, that makes me really happy :)

[@makayla8693]

Hi Lava

[@lisamason6881]

I didn’t get a chance to vote but I would say my fave is Jaclyn lip liners!! So glad it made the list. My fave shade is Faith !!! Thanks Allie!❤️❤️❤️

[@makayla8693]

Hi Mason

[@bymillie]

Not shocked that the CT liners came out on top! I have 3 in my collection and LOVE them!! 😍😍

[@PamelaH_HappyVibes]

I absolutely love Profusion lip liners. They really should make more colors. This series of videos is so much fun.

[@Raymondgogolf]

Hi Pamela H I hope my comment didn't sound as a form of privacy invasion your comment tells of a wonderful woman with a beautiful heart which led me to comment I don't normally write in the comment section but I think you deserve this complement. If you don’t mind can we be friends? Thanks God bless you….🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@demilo828]

Can you do a full face of MAC? you always say how much you used to love the products but don't use them much anymore and I would love to see some of your faves! ❤

[@dm_lunsford]

Confess I'm one who hasn't worn lip liners. I'm typically a gloss and go gal. But this video has encouraged me to give this makeup step a try. Lots of good options in this video for me to consider.

[@rehammahmoud9416]

Can't help but admire your eyeshadow. What I eyeshadow palette did you use? It is stunning!

[@bethanymcdonnell6115]

Do you have a tutorial for the makeup look you are wearing in this video? It's beautiful!

[@vickycorey8195]

This was really cool to watch, Allie!! Thanks!

[@Mekan1ka]

Your eye makeup is stunning!

[@Dragonflyathena]

Love you Allie! I love lip liners and my favorites were included - nyx, Colourpop, and MUF!

[@queencara]

Thank you for featuring my comment! I want to buy ALL of these! Can't wait for the lipstick category!

[@tonioudalstoel6686]

Ekk. My comment got chosen! How exciting. Getting closer to the full face. Cannot wait.

[@shainaannx17]

The liners I have are definitely all because you recommended thm, Allie! Some of these I've never tried though. So I'm excited to pick up a few. 🤗❤️ I don't think any of us get tired of you "talking our ear off" lol

[@mollyjane01]

Love this series, miss Allie! Thank you for it! You MUST give Natasha Denona lip liners a try! They’re long lasting & offer great colors in a creamy yet pigmented base. Love u!! ❤

[@CareyXO]

Great series! I wear lip liner every day. My go to’s are ABH, Nyx Line Loud, and Moira Cosmetics. I have a ton of lip liners that I love from other brands, but my fave shades are in the lines I mentioned above.

[@alicefrazee8934]

Have you done best of eye brow products??

[@Ms.Alaniz]

You mentioned you were wearing iconic nude lip liner. What else are u wearing on your lips? They look amazing

[@NasiaGeorgakopoulou]

I was so so sure about number one!!!Love these videos!!!

[@marieduff8594]

Another fantastic video Allie. I forgot to complete the form, but like your other subscriber, I too bought CT iconic nude because of you and it’s my favourite lip liner. I’m going to fill out the lipstick 💄 form now before I forget!

[@jocelynbeever377]

Yes! I fell in love with Milani Spice last year and for me it’s great for darkening up some nudes that are a little too light for me, and toning down some lipsticks that feel too bright.

[@theabbyalexa]

Anastasia lip liner is luscious. Surprised it did not make it. I am excited to try some of these! 😊

[@Marwa.AR2019]

omg Allie i miss you!!!! can you please do a tutorial for this makeup look you look stunning.

[@eimeargall7037]

Hi Allie! Loved this video! Just wondering what lipstick you’re wearing here? Love it! Thank you xx

[@fridaoropeza8965]

Spice from Mac is amazing too is the perfect shade of color for anyone with medium olive skin tone, I think I have repurchase it like 20 times at the very least even though I do have a thing for lip liners so I have quite a few different shades and brands of lip lines

[@carlawithc4494]

Thanks for the video Allie! There are some lipliners that I want to try, It surprised me the Dior lipliners didn't make the ranking, they're the most creamy lipliners I have ever tried

[@themightythor8459]

omg! you said my name absolutely correctly. Much love

[@aleksandrabouma2396]

Which liner do u guys recommend if I'm looking for a long lasting lip liner and love like a bit colder rosy shades?? That looks natural or something leaning a bit brown maybe?

[@lucylawal5370]

I gotta pick up the shade Daniel in mbm lip liner! That’s my husband too! Wish I knew about it before my wedding hehe

[@blancamarmolejo8404]

Iconic nude is my all time favorite as well. It's too good. Nothing else comes close or works so well with so many different lip products. A combo I also love is the CT liner in hot gossip with the Huda lipstick in Hustla.

[@arinemiko]

Great series! I have become a lip liner convert in the last few years, so this was very informative and interesting to me. 100% co-sign NYX, charlotte Tilbury and MUFE liners are the best!

[@sallycain3716]

I totally love the rare beauty lip liners. I have talented and worthy. I also love the Charlotte Tilbury iconic nude, pillow talk and pillow talk medium

[@fionadarragh1004]

Hi Allie, I'm loving this series. I have some lip liners from Mac also NYX because of you 😘. I also like lip liners from Bareminerals that didn't make the top ten. Look forward to your next video 🥰!

[@lisaannehill]

I love this series! Thanks Allie 😊

[@louisesharpy]

Love this series. It’s so fun. Just fun for all your subs. If you have an iPad. You can’t read the community tabs on iPads. I noticed I. Issued a bunch of questions or submission

[@juliazoltzer9125]

And at the very very very end, please do a roundup of brands. What are our favorite brands and why!! Xx

[@ilsecontreras7467]

I love the il makiage waterproof lip liners, they are the best in my opinion!

[@aemerson1970]

Totally agree CT lip cheat pillow talk and iconic nude are the best of the best

[@R0291-l1l]

Thanks for this! What EYE LOOK are you wearing tho??? So pretty!

[@HiliBStern]

Wow what a timing!! Thank you 😍😍😍

[@Akasha987]

Hi can you please mention what lipstick and eyeshadow you wearing in this video ? Please please 🙏

[@sherriestewart3306]

A great dupe for the CT pillow talk is the flower beauty spiced petal with the nyx nude suede shoes liner. I love the color of CT but not the price :)

[@pinkTonya24]

Yay I love this series! It's my favorite series on youtube next to Hump it or Dump it by Makeup4lossedtime

[@alannaphelan7029]

Charlotte tilbury lipstick! And miss dior love there pink lipstick!💋💖

[@spookybard]

I would love to see both a bullet/traditional lipstick video and a liquid lipstick video in this series, cause I feel like they are so different, trying to narrow down my fave between the types is gonna be tough.

[@Raymondgogolf]

Hi Amanda I hope my comment didn't sound as a form of privacy invasion your comment tells of a wonderful woman with a beautiful heart which led me to comment I don't normally write in the comment section but I think you deserve this complement. If you don’t mind can we be friends? Thanks God bless you….🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@elizabethcourtois3522]

Thanks for mentionning me Allie 😊 Good video as usual!

[@bjog95]

I’m surprised L.A. Girl and Morphe didn’t make the list! The Morphe lip liners are amazing!

[@ylvaoverland]

The colourpop "little one" was from the ZoellaxColourpop collection, so I don't think it's available anymore. But it is such a good shade!

[@Memphischic35]

You are an absolute delight 💗

[@joannecava2418]

Love these videos!!!!! Keep them coming

[@gailschaefer-guajardo6731]

I love Revelon Colorstay LongWear Lip Liner in Nude and Natural. Milani's Understatement Lip liner French Rose. 🌹 I like Nyx Matte Lip Liners. LA Colors Gel Liner Cafe. Pahrump, Nevada Sorry I missed the form. Essence Soft & precise Lip Pencil in Legendary.❣️❣️❣️ I also would love to see how you did your eye makeup, please show us.

[@kristenreehil3196]

NYX Slim Lip Pencil Creamy Long Lasting Lip Liner in the shade Rose is my go to lip liner