The BEST NEW Drugstore Lip Liner?! Swatching ALL 10 SHADES!

[@stacyleiter651]

I bought Line Leader and Big Lift after you first mentioned them. They are better than either Charlotte Tilbury or Makeup by Mario! I have to get more. It would be great to know which colors pair great with your lipsticks.

[@AngiePhiffer79]

I agree! I really need a good liner that has some contrast with Lily.

[@deborahselincourt8060]

I just returned a Charlotte tilbury lip liner, it was trash. I don't get the hype

[@lifelongrobin]

It has been YEARS since I’ve seen a true lip swatch video. So nostalgic. Wonderfully done Allie! 🩷🌸

[@ChristinePacinda]

I was never much of a lip liner gal until a got older. Now, at 54, lip liners are an absolute must. They keep my other lip products from fading and bleeding and just help me better define the shape of my lips.

[@dylanbray14]

They SET in place! I love the fact that they don’t budge it’s amazing!! And the red reminds me so much of fenty??!

[@sarah.weaver]

Just a quick shout out to Allie for having a baby and not changing her entire channel to be about that. ♥️

[@jessicawhite3893]

Totally agree!

[@danaratliff1443]

FOR REAL

[@Katie8ginny]

Yeap! ❤

[@Bebebeas1]

How is it that Allie looks amazing with every color? You’re so beautiful Allie!

[@neyisek6928]

This was SO helpful. Just seeing the color of a liner on the package is near useless. Seeing a swatch is good but having an actual lip color behind it is perfect. Thank you.

[@mizlincoln]

Officially influenced. Just ordered Line Leader! Looks perfect for what I’ve been looking for.

[@armilemmetdeles8981]

Maybelline makes good products. Its a brand that I have access to in Watsons where I buy most of my complexion products. I followed your advice, Allie regarding investing in tools and my makeup application has been easier. Using a setting spray and slightly pressing it in before it dries really creates an airbrushed look especially in photos. Thank you so much for sharing all of your tips and techniques. 💛

[@consciouslypure2176]

I got the shade line leader after seeing this video thinking that it will be perfect for me but it actually looks so different on my skin tone! I know that every shade will look different on everyone but on Allie this shade looks like such a beautiful nude pink, but on me it’s like a purple tinged light pink and doesn’t suit me as well… I am a light skin tone too so thought it would suit me but I am probably slightly darker and warmer which is why it looks so different on me. This colour definitely leans slightly cooler toned so just keep that in mind if you are a bit warmer in skin colour like me! Hope that helps someone 💕

[@chaoticgood8645]

I was wondering about that after seeing swatches on the models online after this video! I was wondering if it was just classic weird studio lighting on Ulta, but I'm really glad to have read your comment because I have a similar skin tone to you and I hate when I accidentally get a grey-leaning pink lip color 😅 So thank you! I will try one of the other colors instead

[@consciouslypure2176]

@@chaoticgood8645 glad I could help! In this case you would probably not like big lift either. It is also a bit cooler, a bit more grey and darker than this. I experimented with other shades afterwards and discovered the shade out of line which is just perfect for me 🥰 it is definitely warm toned and brown-ish with just a touch of pink and I looove it

[@AshleyWilliams-ib8rm]

I love these liners! I found them a week ago and have been using them all week. You definitely need to try the NYX line loud liners too. They’re similar in that they’re ultra creamy and don’t budge once set down. Check them out!!!

[@tinalaws7506]

Yes! The Nyx ones are great too!!

[@Queenmarie88]

I just got mine in the mail and I love it !! I got #7 BIG LIFT and for once the color is just what I want. It’s a mauvey brown with no warm tone. It is super creamy and las t a very long time. These are amazing♥️

[@MeowMammy]

I love the Lifter glosses especially the plumping ones. They are my all time favorite glosses! I will definitely be on the hunt for these...They look amazing! 💋

[@midlifemom5829]

Thank you Allie!!! I think you've started a resurgence of swatch videos. There aren't many lip liner videos along with combo at the end . Excellent content!

[@myleeleonard536]

Thanks for swatching them on your arm too. You look amazing in all of them, but the first two I loved on you. What liner goes good with the Maybelline lifter lip gloss color Petal 005?

[@oliaziabrieva8662]

Out of Line and Big Lift look so gorgeous on you!

[@eliseraifman4766]

Just started wearing lip liner. Love using them all over the lip then adding a lip oil. Haven’t tried Maybelline yet but am planning to after watching this.

[@angelafishburn7654]

I'll be honest; I'm not a lip liner gal. But Allie, because you're you, I had to watch anyway. I've said before, you're a breath of fresh air. Thank you for starting out my day in a positive light.

[@missipixi]

Right? Allies the best! I’m not really a lipliner gal either, but I’m actually heading out to the CVS to see if they have these. The mauve one is just too pretty to pass up!

[@iwillstom]

I am definitely a lip liner purchaser, wearer not so much. 🙃

[@Queenmarie88]

YES !! I googled swatches of these the other day but I can never really tell by that so I am so glad to see this video! I have been wanting to get a pinky brown lip liner so I hope there is one in here. Now I am off to watch ~~~ thank you Allie 😎♥️

[@kacieharkins839]

Just picked up 4,6 and 7. So creamy and easy to apply. I tossed 3 hard liners that I was struggling with application. Thx Allie!

[@nataliehughes4143]

Your eyeshadow color makes your eyes pop!! So pretty ❤️

[@UnpurrfectRobyn]

I've gotten more and more into lip liners and pulled away from traditional lipsticks in the last year! These look amazing! I'll definitely be checking out a color or two soon.

[@milomazli]

I am obseeeessed with lip liners these days. Appreciated this video. Would love to know what is you preferred longest lasting formula ❤ thx

[@carmensandiego5788]

I'm currently falling in love with lip liners. However, in Canada we don't get a lot of what is released in the USA. I do hope that these will come here as I'm very intrigued to try them out ! Thank You for your post Allie !

[@Sky-Child]

I don't use Maybelline but I love a lipliner. My colouring is very similar to yours so I am soaking in all the good info about your favourite shades!!

[@tinalaws7506]

I love these! I've worn them nonstop. Big Lift is my favorite. Have you tried the new Covergirl clean lipsticks? They're great too!

[@minnauyeda7339]

Yes! Just in time! I have Fine Line, and wander Line Leader, can’t decide between Player and On line. I am lip line obsessed! These are fantastic, they don’t claim waterproof, but they’ve lasted me even on pool days.

[@samzetnick4558]

Also would love to see the new elf lip liners swatched!🤎 & even a throw back to swatches of the lifter glosses (if you’d be down)!☺️

[@AllyGummybears23]

I just ordered out of line, I’m so excited to try these. I Still am dying to try the glosses too!

[@lianagoncalves2358]

My goal in life is to get my hair to style like yours!! I love your style!!

[@Amyntj]

I have been wanting to see these. Thanks for the swatches! And yes, definitely a lip liner gal. I wasn’t when I was young, but at 41, I feel like my natural lines have faded. I am obsessed

[@fritzpeterson6273]

Thanks for the swatches! I started with one and now have 3 so love them too! Great quality for drugstore. So far my favorite is No 7 but will get more after seeing your swatches❤. Used my Charlotte Tilbury liner ystd and it was so drying and hard to get on.

[@Nezomiro]

I used Big Lift with Lily and it looks phenomenal!!!!

[@sams2946]

Lip liner girlie as well. I've only used MAC liners Chesnut & Currant because they fit my skintone. But will look for these.

[@rosef5264]

Thanks for swatching the colors on your hand. I love that you showcased each one, Big Lift is my favorite as I like muave lipsticks. They all look great on you! You inspired me to use lipliners again 😊 love your channel ❤

[@MamaOwl4]

Allie I’m going to London to visit family in a few weeks and my “lip wardrobe” will be your Effortless Lips. Can you please do a video sharing which of these lip liens pair best with your lippies?

[@carolinacarreon698]

Here again from today’s video! Always grateful that you show all the colors, even we’re not the same shape it really helps me to know if I have a chance even trying something ❤ thank you

[@lisayates6729]

Would be great to know which lifter lipliner colour goes best w each lifter gloss colour

[@genietillery878]

I bought Line Leader, it's great.

[@biogirl1381]

i’ve had big lift and line leader sitting in my ulta cart, and now i’m going to add that yummy neutral brown as well. i’m a lip liner junkie and maybelline makes some of my favorite lip products, and i’m definitely going to take advantage of the sale to grab these. thank you so much for swatching all of them, because it was incredibly helpful. they’re going to go perfectly with lily and dahlia!!! 🥰🥰🥰

[@barbschultz9323]

Thanks! On your rec I just attempted to purchase #6. How in the world are you guys able to find the name or # on the liner?? Still in wrapping and will try it later. Fingers crossed I picked up 4, 5 or 6. (The display was not in an orderly manner to be able to choose based on labeling.)

[@mimik6414]

Oh I didn’t even know they were new products! I needed a new lip liner and happen to come across them and I love it!

[@michellegentz7026]

You made me love lip liner. I never really used it in my routine but now I can’t live without it haha. It really just makes a difference.

[@gailschaefer-guajardo6731]

Thanks for trying every lip liners. It was helpful and informative.🌸✔️👍

[@gymrat2022]

Thank you for swatching all these shades. i love big lift and planning on trying it soon!

[@nikaleelawson9451]

I’d really like to get all of them except the red ones. Haven’t really used red but I would like to be adventurous and use the deeper ones

[@samzetnick4558]

Loved this vid! It was so so helpful! Would love a summer lip combo vid sometime soon & then another one in the fall time.😍💄

[@terriblack1562]

Always love a great lip liner and I haven’t yet tried these out. It’s great that they’re soft enough to blend in smoothly yet stay put, so I am going to give these a try! Nice to see all the shades too- Thanks for the helpful video Allie 😍

[@Libby_Hannah]

I am a sucker for a good lip liner and belueve it or not is super hard find lip liner in my country, specially drugstore ones! I hope I can find those in the future because I am in love with the Lifter Gloss ❤

[@cindyryan5169]

Lip liner is a staple. These look nice. I will try them.

[@Emi-G]

What eyeshadow do you have on?❤

[@alesiaturner8186]

Yes I’m a lip 👄 liner girl 🧒. My favorite is that first one you tried then the 3 you like. Yes these will be on my list to pick up.

[@teresawilliams1201]

Need to try these! Your hair looks so gorg!

[@JJ-up5ie]

I have such pronounced circles. Dermablend is the only one thick enough to cover the darkness. Could you recommend a few others that might be like it but easier to find and a bit less costly? I would really appreciate it. Thank you!!

[@AmyBlack1206]

I wanted a brown liner. So over having reds. I can’t wear Revlon in Chocolate. It’s so thick and ends up looking muddy. I just bought Let’s Bounce. It’s so freaking awesome. I love that it doesn’t look red. It’s awesome w a brown makeup look. Now I need more!!!

[@Bestie_Bri]

Oooh these remind me of the Charlotte Tilbury liners ! 😍👀 These swatches were stunning!! I just ordered some for Walmart pickup..I’m so excited 😆🙌🏽🥂

[@carolinemcintosh9132]

Great video. Could you suggest which ones look good with your brand.

[@leannsmith6516]

Can't wait to get these. Love when you give your favs due to our skin coloring being so similar. I can just buy those!

[@HaydeeSophia]

My favorites are On It and Big Lift 🥰

[@MyLoVeLyMaN]

I love lip liners! Those look so smooth and even, gorgeous! Would wear them instead of a lipstick too! Btw, how's the longevity on the lips? On Amazon uk lifter liner on the pencil is in gold

[@truewants]

Always so hard to choose.. yes lip liner girlie too!

[@daspeachy]

I’m captivated by the lip combo 🤍

[@madimei]

What is a good lip liner sharpener that’s affordable?

[@jenessastrickland1555]

Oh man, I want to try these so bad! The vast majority of lip products contain ingredients I’m allergic to, but these don’t, and the colors look incredible! Sadly I’m having to avoid makeup on/near my lips while I get over some dermatitis. But as soon as my skin recovers, I’m going to be all over these.

[@monacal6872]

I bought the player shade, and I love the color! My only complaint is that when you sharpen it, it breaks off because it's too creamy.

[@judithcatlett8518]

Allie, I think these pencils are the Maybelline Ultimate lipsticks just in lip pencil style. I ran to my Maybelline collection and lined my lips with 088 More Coffee lipstick and filled my lips in with the Maybelline Lifter 010 Crystal gloss. Their lipstick feels the same as your pencil description.

[@Lillianna11]

What would you rate them over all with your new rating system you mentioned earlier this year?

[@katherinekelly9689]

Hi Allie, these lipliners by Maybelline look fantastic, I can’t wait for them to arrive in my drugstores. Love Katherine xoxo

[@dpowers2005]

Which of these liners would go best with the Ravie beauty lipsticks in dalhia, Lily, and zinnia. I just ordered all 3 lipsticks and would love a recommendation of lipliners to pair them with.

[@HonesTeaBeauTea]

Oooo I LOVEEEEE Maybelline and NYX, Elf. Those are my top drugstore & now I NEED them. I only do lip liner, lip stain (I need the new covergirl.. its literally the only product from them I own. Mine are OLD, they discontinued yrs ago and just came back) and lip plumper. I do just lip liner and plumper most though. Oooo im excited. I love neutral lip with colorful eyes or colorful lip with neutral eyes. Lets bounce compliments your eyes. I want player. 😊 I agree. I noticed I used to only like twist up lip liner but then I noticed they dont stay as long as the ones you shapen. Im so excited for these.

[@harikliafrangos4946]

Trying to start using lip liner to help my beveled lower lip look less crazy in lipstick 😂 but finding a natural looking shade is really hard, way harder than finding a good lip color!! this is very helpful ❤

[@carriewilson2104]

This video was super helpful, Allie! Thank you so much!!!

[@bunnymelchor]

Whoa that lip look you created… 😍😍😍

[@bernasal82]

Can you please compare them with Rimmel lasting finish lip liners for wear time and texture? I think Rimmel makes best lip liners in the market

[@Sunshine00799]

LOVED THIS video! Need more summer lip combos!

[@Darbsi]

Wow thanks for sharing. Love a good lip liner. ❤

[@lorenward3733]

Allie I bought the liner on big lift gorgeous and ice lifter gloss

[@Patriot1789]

Maybelline does a great job overall with its lip products.

[@lisamason6881]

I have a couple of these and they are fantastic!!! HELP!!! I need a new sharpener…a good one. What should I get?

[@lunamoonstone420]

I was so focused on your lips that when I looked up at like 4 mins in I realized your eyes are just like mine! Beautiful 😍

[@jennifermolina4396]

I purchased 3 of them. I purchased On It at Walmart. Love it. I just purchased 2 more on Amazon.

[@jennylozano9635]

Omg- they all look gorgeous on you 😍

[@megans1178]

Omg when I got a notification about these my jaw hit the floor! I’ve been waiting for the drugstore to come out with a good lip liner and I love the lifter line. I’m not a fan of the nyx ones every one loves. I usually use Mac. Can’t wait to try!

[@Mara-ll3js]

when are we getting a video on drugstore lip color combos for summer 🙌🏼

[@audreyso1201]

Hello Allie, color n2 is very beautiful ohhhhh. Thank you for sharing💗💗💗

[@katechipata9934]

They look stunning! I want some of them

[@staceynoffke]

Yay! Love your hair!

[@Lizeth0102]

What mascara are you wearing? Thank you.

[@conniescreations1633]

I was not a gloss girl until I tried the lift gloss, love these already used up 2 I have one in car, one in purse one in vanity , thanks love swatches TFS xoxo

[@charlotteharris4825]

I am new to your channel and loving your content... such easy-going and informative watching, thank you!

[@sandraschmied6459]

So funny. Part of the fun of going to Wegmans is my trip down the makeup aisle.🎉

[@Amyntj]

I really hope they don’t discontinue the old liners though because raw chocolate and totally toffee are my favs

[@CarmenZynger]

I needed this. Thanks girl!

[@melaniefarrow7152]

"But I dont work at Maybelline do I?" I trust your suggestions without hesitation. Im off to buy 6 and 7. My lifter gloss and vinyl lip colors are on constant rotation. Sultry and Witty are my favorites.

[@Lottesettle]

I have wasted half of one trying to sharpen it😩 I love it, but there’s a problem! I’m using the same sharpener to do my other pencils and my sharpener works fine. What sharpener are you USING PLEASE??? 😮

[@stephaniechacon1010]

Can you do swatches of the new Tower 28 lip liner shades?? Please and thank you

[@Kynurse76]

In my opinion these are the best liners at the drug store! I like them better than my Charlotte Tilbury and Rare beauty liners.

[@amandalarson8789]

Allie did you see the amazing Hung Vanngo use Effortless Lips in his video? ❤

[@lisablinn3264]

Oh boy, I should just purchase all of the colours at once, they all look so nice.

[@JuggrnautWraith13]

Thank you for showing on the arm AND lip swatches of each color! I also LOVE a really dark brown lip liner, that doesn’t lean too red, and that first one looks perfect. Also it looks like a perfect deep fall color for you! Every color looks great on you.