Actor & Filmmaker FIRST TIME REACTION to BTS "Spring Day" Official Music Video & Explanation Video

[@CedricGegel1]

I've watched this music video five or six times since the initial reaction and I am really falling in love with this song. The visuals, too, are really quite well done, and the explanation video revealed an amazing depth that I hadn't grasped. Next, I'll be diving into behind-the-scenes, as requested, and mixing in dance rehearsals and live performances as I go. I don't want to see any live performances of any songs I don't know yet, though, so please reply to this with live performances that only feature songs I've reacted to ("Dynamite," "Fake Love," "On," "Blood, Sweat and Tears," "Save Me," and "Spring Day"). To those that encouraged me to start a Patreon - thank you. I think I've got it set up. Open to feedback, of course. I'm figuring that out as I go, much like this KZbin thing! Please and blessings! Thank you for watching and sharing the music you love with me!

[@xarchanx]

haven't seen it yet but I can't wait to watch. You're awesome and wish you the best on future endeavors

[@MM-et2jr]

I was hoping that this video in particular would be interesting to you as well as us. I'm excited for tomorrow. Thanks for reacting to the suggestion.

[@Lynne_Naz]

Spring Day always be my top 1 BTS Favorite Supreme Song.💜

[@danii5505]

Ahhhh they've got so many good live performances for these songs but I'll try to leave it at one or two per song. Here you go (LONG COMMENT AHEAD, I hope it's not a bother): *>>* for "Dynamite": the performance @ Grammy Museum (kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3fIpmZjbLd3sKM) and the one @ America's Got Talent (kzbin.info/www/bejne/m2mUkpdrgtWZh5I) *>>* for "Fake Love": the one @ MAMA 2018 (kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKeboWZ8g6pshck). Some side notes about this... don't get scared when you see the length of the video lol there's an intro and one more song (because that's how live performances work in music awards shows there), Fake Love takes the first 10 minutes. This performance has a dance practice video in their channel (bangtantv) and also a "BTS focus cam" version if you want to get a closer look at the choreography on stage. The version of the song they used for this is "FAKE LOVE (Rocking Vibe Mix)". Another great live stage for this was at the MMA 2018 *>>* for "On": you CAN'T miss the performance @ Grand Central Terminal for The Tonight Show!! (kzbin.info/www/bejne/g4vLXqpoo96mq6s). They've got a BTS episode for this day on their channel as well. And here's another one from a music tv show from South Korea: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXexe4d3lqaMpLc, their voices are clearer here *>>* for "Blood, Sweat and Tears": live @ the MMA 2016 (kzbin.info/www/bejne/aWi8kqVpa9Odq5o). Again, there's a second song here so stop watching after BS&T is done *>>* for "Save Me": Comeback Special @ Inkigayo 20160515 (kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z4qkZJ6JhtOgopY) *>>* for "Spring Day*": @ MMA 2017 (kzbin.info/www/bejne/nKK3e6uJo5qfqtU) and @ iHeart Radio (kzbin.info/www/bejne/f2qcfGpon6uWnZI). You must've noticed J-Hope doesn't have a rap verse in this song, he actually sings the background vocals in the chorus, so for the live performances they rearranged it in order for him to take the opening verse and the chorus. Yes, he can dance, rap AND sing [sobs] Sorry for such a long comment. I'm definitely looking forward to your video for tomorrow! I like how insightful your reactions are, you even catch on things I haven't, despite all the years I've been a fan lol. And you always make interesting comments! Thanks for taking your time to learn about them and everything. I wish you the best on your projects as well. But now I'll shut up before this gets even longer, hope you enjoy the live stages!

[@samsam_gsk]

i really recommend the live performance of ON at the Grand Central Terminal on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon :) my favorite dynamite performance live was on America’s Got Talent! :) i hope you enjoy those. i have my reminder on for this premier. i’m super excited and glad to know you love it the song 💜

[@mhparkmusic]

Looking forward to it! This is my another favorite song of BTS. I was living in south korea between 2013 and 2015, for the national service of 21 months, and I still remember the day when it happened. I was having breakfast with my colleagues at the mess hall and first I thought they've put a movie channel on tv(kinda weird early in the morning) so i wasn't really paying attention. Soon I sensed somehow a different atmosphere and looking at the tv again I realized it was live broadcasting(on every channel). I also remember the particular moment when I saw the famous fake news "every students rescued" during the live, and we were all confused. It was so unreal, happened without any warning. For me, the explanation video you saw didn't covered enough some points... First, the MV has way more specific details to the incident(like the clock's time in the laundry scene, color of oxidized carrousel and all context of 'you never walk alone' campaign etc...) rather than a rather generic 'young generation standing up for justice against grown ups' discours. Another explanation video(from italan army I believe) covers very well these details if anyone's interested. And the reason why I'm convinced that the MV specifically refers to this tragedy, is that it wasn't just an isolate event. It is an iconic incident which was literally the trigger to massive movements against the government up to the impeachment and imprisonment of the president 3 years later. The ex-president wasn't unanimously trusted from the very beginning of her presidency anyway(being the daughter of the former dictator of the country in the past). One thing discovered during the investigation which frustrated me the most is the existence of the blacklist of creators&artists who expressed or illustrated any opinion which didn't suit to their political discours. Director Bong and Snowpiercer's main actors were in the list as well and these had to suffer from being practically excluded from the media industry during the whole period. So there was a very severe form of political censorship in media and I still can't believe it happened in a democratic country of 21st century. This emphasizes the subtleness of this MV about references about the Sewol incident. Crazy thing is, even now at the end of 2020, there are still people in the former president's political party claiming the whole movement as a purely political agenda, still downplaying victim's family's pain. The "grown ups" telling to survivors to forget and cheer up in the interview is not some random adults but very precisely these people. Of course, it wasn't for cheering up but to cover everything wrong behind it. "let's forget it and move forward" was slogan broadly used in that party. I wanted to explain how this tragedy has a big meaning for south koreans. The movement and massive protests kickstarted by this has marked a page in the history of the country. And the announcement of the impeachment was such a dramatic moment, just like a movie ending. If you're curious, here is a video of people how they reacted at the moment they heard "We announce the decision as the unanimous opinion of all judges. We dismiss the defendant president Park": kzbin.info/www/bejne/nJDcan94ZZqje80

[@CedricGegel1]

Wow. Thank you for sharing all of that. Deeply informative. As I explain in the video, I really knew almost nothing about this incident, so thank you for providing even more context. Such an awful, devastating event. I appreciate you sharing your experience and educating me. Thank you.

[@andreadeleon8595]

@@CedricGegel1 in case you were looking for the explanation video he mentioned kzbin.info/www/bejne/fKO3ZZSVe9xppqc

[@pensandnoodles681]

@@andreadeleon8595 Thanks for sharing; I just watched it and they referenced Carousel and the song that @Cedric Gegel talked about while watching the mv too.. love having these insights!

[@erume5776]

Spring Day is the Longest Charting Song in MelOn History (korea's Biggest Streaming site) and is *still charting*. it's cherished a lot by fandom and by boys. they had stopped perform it quite a lot time ago, but, as lockdown became a life we live now and their upcoming world tour for Map Of The Soul 7 got canceled and they could not interact with fans face to face which is the most important thing for them... they performed Spring Day 4 times online on different shows. because they miss us and this song is a feeling of longing itself

[@jiminsmorningcoffee3952]

I love that it charted so long and keeps climbing up the chart every comeback. Like keeping it on the chart will keep the memories of the tragedy alive, not allowing people to forget.

[@liza2561]

Not only us and the boys it is love by all the korean citizen be it army or not... it never leaves the chart.. the funniest moment is when it always comes and overtakes bts's new songs in the chart after some time of the release

[@elmariajin9483]

The Queen Spring Day🌼

[@japji6110]

Update- its still there!!!!

[@erume5776]

MV and lyrics definitely can have a lot of ways of interpretation. RM noted that this song is for ones who need comfort but i think director of MV had that idea in mind to commemorate this tragedy, and it's quite a hidden message to those who is not familiar with what happened, because talking openly about the tragedy and all mistakes made by government was a rick to get blacklisted by people in power. The government did not allow anybody to reveal anything about the case because of the corruption. It was hard for people even to send charity to the victims' family or even speak about it, because they will get punished by the government. So the message of MV is structured on symbols and references to films and literature. Though BTS & Bighit secretly made a donation (it was discovered lately): 100 million won to support families. At some point money were needed to start the searches for child remain bodies because the government rejected to lift up the ship. Only two years later the government finally lifted up the ship after the president get impeachment cause of her corruption. Helping people was always the most important thing to the boys and they keep it true to themselves

[@ebony7177]

I don't think it was Lumpens' idea because he said years ago that some things that people thought meant one thing which related to the tragedy but wasn't like the shoes.

[@JoobieLoobieSoobie]

A lot of people will insist that the Sewol incident was the inspiration for this song. RM has repeatedly said (as recently as last week) that he and Suga wrote the lyrics about personal friendships they lost when they moved to Seoul. He has also acknowledged that it struck a chord with the nation in regard to the tragedy, and he is glad the song has been interpreted this way, and brought people comfort. The music video is a separate piece of art, and I think it definitely addresses the tragedy. BTW Theory 2 is all about suicide. And fun fact! V wrote and submitted lyrics for this song too, but PDogg chose the ones RM wrote.

[@prisharai7225]

Yes, I think the song was meant for the overall theme of loss of friendship but the director or whoever came up with the music video based it off of the sewol tragedy

[@Erin_-hg7qi]

@@prisharai7225 Yeah Jin also recently confirmed that it goes both ways.

[@serendimin]

Jin confirmed last night that it is indeed about a “sad event” in an interview. What RM and suga talk about is what the song is about, not the MV.

[@js3839]

@@serendimin I’m so glad he finally addressed that it was multiple meanings. I always believed that the members wrote personal lyrics about loss for this song that referenced the tragedy. It was always supposed to be both. I don’t know why people didn’t consider it could be both. BTS always have multiple layers.

[@serendimin]

@@js3839 oh it definitely has more than one meaning. The MV itself also includes references to the BU. It’s just layers upon layers, that’s what makes Bts amazing

[@fernrouintree563]

Don't be too hard on yourself for not grasping the full meaning on your first listen. Your interpretation was thorough, insightful, and touching. As an ARMY of only 3 years myself, I often have to seek out other resources (such as xCeleste's or DKDKTV's theory/explanation videos) to fully grasp the depth of BTS' lyrics and cinematography. As you know, art is subjective and we each take away what we need from it. Along with this message of remembrance, "Spring Day" has become a precious connection point between BTS and ARMYs expressing how much we love and miss each other, especially in these unprecedented times. BTS has performed it many times in the past year as a specific message to ARMYs. We hold each other in our hearts and memories until we can be together again 💜

[@kimmyh2157]

💜

[@Mar_velouslyOT7]

I agree with you regarding Jin looking back at the "window" that looked like the ones on a ship. To me it looked like the rescuers hopelessly looking at the victims through the unbreakable window and couldn't get to them. Following are some of the things I had interpreted that were not mentioned in the video - just my interpretation... * Tumbling clothes in washers : the drowning passengers in the sinking ship being tossed around * Light shun on Suga: rescue light finding Suga amongst the victims * The constant tilting of camera : the sinking ship

[@wizardofrozplays1933]

K. I had to pause. I am always so impressed with your knowledge in different areas... but the colour palette connections...! Dude! I’m only a few minutes in and I’m so satisfied. I’m very happy that I get to experience BTS with you! .... in the words of the lovely Park Jimin, “You nice, keep going” 💜

[@genevievehiguera6162]

BTS is the gift that keeps on giving. Full of beauty, full of surprises, full of hidden treasures. Nothing is done without meaning or purpose. I am so grateful to have lived long enough (72 years) to be able to experience BTS. They are hip hop, pop, R&B, rock, rap, immersed in art, philosophy, poetry, culture, cinematics, all delivered by the most talented, hardworking and humble young men.💜

[@aarceeandtannies2217]

Yesss 🥰🥰🥰💜💜💜

[@malinstalheim]

Spring day is our queen, she is the epitome of BTS's music and artistry. She holds such a special place in ARMY's (and the korean general public's) heart, which have made her the longest charting song on Melon in history. Very glad you checked out the explanation to get the sad and deep meaning of this song, even if you are not a fan of BTS you just got to admit that she's a masterpiece.

[@littlemeowida]

This was such a good reaction. As are your others. I notice you take time & notice a lot of details that you even add on in your comments during editing - that shows so much effort & care. Both Namjoon (RM) & Yoongi (SUGA) have mentioned that the song is also about their past experiences but the Sewol ferry tragedy reference has always been apparent & the main theory among ARMY (since many artists were being blacklisted for talking about it BTS were brave to use it. They also made personal donations to the families). They had never officially acknowledged the reference before though. But finally yesterday during their Esquire interview (A MUST READ by the way) they did. I think you may want to watch the Italian ARMY explanation video in your own time to get a much more detailed explanation- but fair warning, be prepared- I have never watched it without crying. Thank you for your effort. You are possibly my favourite BTS reactor. I appreciate that you recognise them now & all the little details (learning a lot about camera angles 🤣) Also, you’re the first reactor to catch the YNWA Carousel link that I’ve seen. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@CedricGegel1]

Thank you! I watched the Italian explanation today and absolutely teared up. So awful. Appreciate the kind words and you being here to watch!! :)

[@so_rhapsody]

I live in Korea, and I saw and heard the accident about the Sewol ferry. An incompetent and corrupt government that did not save young children was eventually impeached by the people. Those involved with Ferry Sewol are still on trial in a South Korean court. BTS's Spring Day is an album released when the incompetent and corrupt government was in power(Ferry Sewol It was released on the same date in the third year of the incident). I was glad to hear that you had a good inspiration from this song. I'm sure you'll making a good movie. I often watch your BTS's MV reactions, and I thought your senses were very good. I'm glad you reacted to "Spring day". :-)

[@inuyashalovergyal]

I didn't know the shoes had a different meaning, I live in Toronto and in Canada shoes hung on wire poles or trees always symbolized a spot where someone died. The clips are hard to watch of the tragedy. You can see from areal shots the ship sinking was surrounded by boats to help but they didn't do anything while the students were screaming for help. It breaks my heart how some parents were on those boats but the coast guards wouldn't save them. BTS almost got blacklisted by their own government. If any celebrity was caught helping the victim's families or speaking out against them the government took action against them. BTS had no choice but to use symbolism in their MV to get their message across and they've done it beautifully believing ARMY would receive their message. Spring Day is the queen of south korea music, she never left the charts since 2017 and she will remain there years later since the song comforted many people in the nation.

[@pensandnoodles681]

Yes! I am so glad they created Spring Day because so many did finally learn about the tragedy and hear the truth.. I know that without this song and music video, I still would not have known that the Sewol Ferry Tragedy happened or known about the deep corruption from their government. So tragic but so important for more to know what happened

[@Ichigo29ify]

it actually is to commemorate the dead, however its been asociated w drug dealers bc of how dangerous these places are. La conmemoración viene primero, las demás son deducciones

[@djguidopolese]

Can't wait! You're really a good and interesting reactor... This is gonna be good i know :)

[@CedricGegel1]

Thank you, that means a lot. Hope I don't disappoint!! This video was really cool.

[@djguidopolese]

@@CedricGegel1 I am sure you won't anyway :) Hugs from Italy 💜

[@isabellereffas3679]

The Sewol ferry led to the demise of the government that tried to ban artists writing and singing about the disaster. There were discussion at the higher level to ban BTS from radio but it never happened because the song was not directly written about that (unlike the video). The song was written by Suga after a friend of his passed away.

[@lunalovesyou875]

I've never heard about that, when did he say that?

[@isabellereffas3679]

@@lunalovesyou875 www.koreaboo.com/news/bts-rm-suga-reveal-inspiration-behind-mega-hit-song-spring-day/

[@lunalovesyou875]

@@isabellereffas3679 I'm sorry, but that doesn't mean his friend died

[@isabellereffas3679]

@@lunalovesyou875 I saw a video where he said it but I don't remember where that's the only article I could find.

[@griswaldgirl]

The song was written by RM who wrote most of the chorus and came up with the idea and suga. They both were writing about friendships that they missed. I think that Suga's song on his mixtape about his good friend who got into drugs and went away to prison and even now out of prison is still a drug addict. In it you realize how much he loved this friend and how the two of them did music together and planned on conquering the world of music together but then this friend got wrapped up in addiction. This stole his friend from him and he missed him but it was also very angry at him. RM speaks more about his friends from school and a different life that he lived that were so precious at the time but now five choices have separated them and make it so difficult for them to reconnect.

[@leeswhimsy]

As an older fan (a LOT older), I so appreciate your love of "the classics" -- Thanks for a great reaction! I also appreciate your thoughts on mental health, and your putting up a helpful website for people, as my son has mental health issues.

[@DarkMatter1962]

I am sure you are aware the "BE" dropped a couple of days ago, along with the second single from the album. Looking forward to your reaction to "Life Goes On" and the MV directed by one of the members...

[@xxnanxx3630]

They actually confirmed that the mv was about the accident in a recent interview. (While the song itself is about missing loved ones) There's a lot of political sides to it (the best informing anyone can do is not only those videos but also articles and surviver/docu videos) , it came up in 2017 again bc information was published that connected the corrupt parts of the government to it in a way that it could have possibly been prevented. This video is the shortest and most watched but it misses the side of what was actually happening with the accident and in politics, which is why i would love it if you watched this one (link in replies) it's in italian but has english subtitles. I find this to be the better one, the one you watched only scratches the surface in comparison in my opinion. Also on a side note tons of artist anf public figures got blacklisted for speaking about this by the corrupt president that got impeached later, so doing something like this was a good way, but also very risky. Thank you for the reaction 💜 i always enjoy how attentive you are while watching the MVs, and you detailed commentary :)

[@xxnanxx3630]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fKO3ZZSVe9xppqc

[@CedricGegel1]

@@xxnanxx3630 I actually just watched that - it was suggested in the premiere chat - and you're so right. It's a brutal watch, but so informative. Thank you for sharing!

[@flyushkifly]

@@CedricGegel1 yes! thank you for watching Italian ARMY's video, as well. As soon as you referenced Carousel, I knew you were analyzing on a deeper level than the basic theory vid.

[@girlwithluv_and_ugh9975]

BTS have never confirmed that this was about the tragedy since any celebrity who spoke out against it, was blacklisted. Although, in the new Esquire Magazine interview that was released yesterday or today, the interviewer asked if Spring Day was about a specific sad event. Jin said “It is about a sad event, as you said, but it is also about longing.” So this theory may stand.

[@purplecloud90]

I think BTS wanted the symbolism and this song to be timeless. So i think it effects people in different ways, to each person's personal struggles. So for everyone effected by the Sewol tragedy its a very powerful song, and for everyone else it can be song about loss and hope. I think that is what makes this song so powerful and relevant. so relevant in fact that it can be used in most somber situations. Thus making it a song that everyone can love even after all this time.

[@kripolik]

13:46 "dude, you missed so much you might as well be a stormtrooper" I can't 😂😂😂

[@tamannabora]

My favourite BTS song ❤ When I lost my dad last year, I was like a zombie, working on automaton..... My daughter introduced me to BTS. I would listen to Spring Day on loop and cry for hours.... BTS helped me come out of my grief..... Their music touches the deepest part of my soul.... Your reaction and insight are always interesting!

[@ykortrakul]

The most sad thing is that the students had times to send clips to their parents saying goodbye before the ferry completely drown. I watched the news & clips in that year... Its' super sad

[@rhagelynmanalili7419]

They confirmed that this song is about the tragedy so its not a theory anymore FACT: this song is often to as "QUEEN SPRING DAY" by armys. That's why spring day never leaves korean chart, Cause even when bts release new song you can the it beside them on the chart. This song is very meaningful for both bts and armys.

[@miraflordugan9496]

Where did they confirm it?

[@rhagelynmanalili7419]

@@miraflordugan9496 its on the article, they did not really say it based on "that" tragedy, its just based on a "tragedy" that happened in there, that's what I understand. p.s feel free to correct me if I'm wrong

[@miraflordugan9496]

@@rhagelynmanalili7419 thanks!! i'll look into it^^

[@breea3426]

i love the little commentary at the bottom

[@ellenha4230]

Yes.... this mv shows bts is not kpop and how much bts is different with kpop. Bts has singularity. Bts is special.

[@anniescupoftae3938]

You are probably one of the most perceptive reactors I've watched, if not the most. Thank you for your deep thoughts and comments about our boys' music💜 and MVs.

[@sami-qm8od]

Yes. Everybody is loved. We exist for a reason. Thank you for saying that. Hope anybody who needs it will hear that.

[@Holly-kj6rs]

Wow I'm so impressed by how much you picked up on in your first viewing. You'd be surprised how many reactors don't even notice the you never walk alone reference. I really enjoy your reactions and perspectives on things. Thank you especially for your comments on mental health. It's so important now more than ever. As Jimin says, "You nice. Keep going."💜💜💜

[@anorvedana]

Omg he talking so much about the dutch angles just made me realize it’s a reference for the ferry sinking 💔 maybe somebody else already pointed this out but I didn’t knew wow

[@trepearound3915]

Your intelligence and perception when dissecting BTS videos is so amazing. I’m so glad you found them, and I found you. I hope one day you dive into their alternate storyline called the BTS UNIVERSE, because hearing your thoughts on that would be amazing. Thank you for all the videos 💜💜

[@jess0219]

This is one of my favorite songs. Even though I've watched the music video so many times, you still pointed out things that I've never noticed before. I value your reactions - you are so thoughtful and insightful. Your comments always help me to understand the depth and meaning of the song/video/art/production better. Thank you! With that said, you absolutely crack me up with your self deprecating notes on the screen... I legit laughed so hard I sprayed the screen at the Stormtrooper comment. 🙈

[@heyhey7423]

I think that all the interpretation that people make of these songs/stories just accumulate into something great, like a collective consciousness. No matter what your interpretation was, if you were able to get some meaning out of it, then i think the art did its jobs. They specifically mentioned that this song was about missing friends.

[@CedricGegel1]

A collective consciousness. That is a *great* way to say it, thank you for adding that to the conversation. And thank you for watching!

[@virginia_the_elder]

After watching your reaction to the "alternative universe" I'm appreciating even more the multi-levels of meaning in the Art behind BTS. Not just the official members of the group but everyone else involved with them. "Bang PD" opened the opportunity for choreographers and producers and cinematographers and those I can't even guess at to do so much more then create "pop" music. The fact it built a billion dollar business is encouraging. And inspiring.

[@LiKeReX]

hey man i randomly saw this and just wanted to let you know your words midway through the video made me tear up because of how my life has been in my 20+ years so far thanks and because of people like you i find the strenght to keep going another day every single day is a fight with myself to survive and i struggle every second of it but thanks to strong people around me im still fighting! just thank you man, thanks so much

[@CedricGegel1]

Hey Rex - I’m glad the words meant something to you and that you took them to heart. You’re worthy and you can do it. If every day is a struggle, then every day is a victory. Keep telling your story and reminding yourself of your inherent value to the world 😌 be well & be strong. I’ll keep you in my thoughts and my prayers, if that’s okay with you!

[@reagan1312]

This is just one example of BTS putting their career at risk for their art. A lot of writers, artists, musicians etc were blacklisted for talking about the tragedy. Them putting this out there was a huge risk. I believe this song played a major part in keeping the tragedy in the forefront of the Korean public's mind, which was a catalyst leading to the impeachment of their former president. The fact that it never left the chart in Korea speaks for itself.

[@Lisathom22_Seven]

I was hoping you would skip to do their new song. “Life goes on”. It’s so relevant. 🥺🤞🏻🤞🏻

[@martina7926]

YES. One of my favorite songs. I had to stop to comment how I love your reactions. And the written commentary (instead of pausing and talking) is great 👌🏼 Thank you! Ok now, let me go back to watching...

[@marar8045]

Your interpretation wasn’t incorrect at all. It’s true that recently BTS finally admitted they did think of the tragedy while doing this song but it’s more than just about the tragedy. It’s about loss in general. They felt the country was in need of healing and made that song. Just like they did Dynamite to lift our mood during these times and then the album BE with Life Goes On to help us all heal. It’s what they do. They see something happening and get together to think what can they do to help? Wether it’s social injustice, or growing up, or loss, or mental health. It’s one of the reasons we all love them so much.

[@susantham7665]

Thanks for reacting to Spring Day - I never fail to cry each time I watch the video 😢

[@iddaalbar2129]

One thing you should never be sorry is how you’re interpreting their songs. They always mentioned that their songs are open to the listeners interpretation. Up until today we never know if the song really is about the tragedy until they kind of confirm it in the esquire mag interview. RM has always mentioned that the song is about missing someone, a friend. I do love how you explain the mv without knowing anything in advance. It’s refreshing 😃 their earlier albums have a songs that critique the gov and Korean school systems disguised as fun songs. I think you would like those. And there are explanation videos too which would make sense to watch together. Can’t wait for you to find them! 💜💜

[@Krissy-rz4wy]

Honestly you are a very genuine person. Its been great to see your opinions on BTS and they’re work.

[@sabaalogman7525]

Lol you getting mad at yourself via commentary after you filmed the video is sooo funny but don’t be soo hard on yourself

[@athelas5305]

What separates you from other reactors are the comments you write on the video. I have actually snorted with laughter more than once at those! ETA: That "Boy!" 🤣

[@miamaria83]

I started to cry at the end of the MV and you talking about mental health, and then comes the commentary with stormtroopers and I laughed out loud. Thank you for that. I love the humour in the commentary.

[@CedricGegel1]

I like to take any serious moment and ruin it with a dumb joke. (in all seriousness, thank you so much for watching and I'm glad you enjoyed! Be well and don't lose that compassionate spirit!!)

[@aviewer9516]

There is another GREAT explanation video by an Italian Army fan - she did an exceptional job at diving even deeper. I was very impressed. Yes, you are correct that the washing machine (or dryer) windows are reminiscent of portholes. In addition, when Jin looks at the empty dryer, he sees that there are no clothes in there, meaning, no survivors (I'm thinking). And the coins being put in the machine represent the greed that precipitated the continued ignoring of saving the passengers. There is SO MUCH symbolism and SO beautifully done. It breaks my heart in a million pieces every. single. time. I can't imagine what those kids and their families went through when it was so avoidable. GAWD.

[@stephanielemons2995]

You are the first person to reference "Carousel." And to reference "You'll Never Walk Alone," from that movie. Which I believe was the influence for their song. Now you said it was your grandmother's favorite song. That tells me you are at least 20 years younger than me. You see it's my mothers favorite song. And God's knows I can't hear it without bursting into tears. You see many years ago, a actor/comedian named Jerry Lewis (I very sure u know who that is.) He did a telethon every year on Labor Day for Muscular Dystrophy. The point is at the end of the telethon he would sing that song for, who they called "Jerry's Kids". And when I see that, that is what I hear in my head. What you should do is watch the explanation of the video to see how close you got....you are very good.

[@KaterynaM_UA]

Please take care of yourself! We will be here a day or two later or even a week or a month, those are some crazy hours you are working!

[@jessie6243]

I remember that tragedy so vividly. I was glued to my computer that hoping they saved more lives. There’s documentaries on it that show just how badly everyone failed those students that day

[@TheSweetApple2]

I loved this reaction. So genuine and respectful. You have no idea how many reactors I've seen who are so obviously fake and just use BTS' name for clout. Thank you so much :) welcome to the BTS' ARMY 💜

[@flyushkifly]

Out of the dozens upon dozens of reactions I've watched for this video, *no one* has ever mentioned the impossible paper airplane throw! I always thought "Against the wind" but yes, fragility, too!

[@TinaJung0218]

your captions are hilarious, thank you

[@jujubeesbtsarmy0613]

BTS tackles a lot of social issues & social phenomena... they are "artists for healing". We're lucky to have artists like them create something beyond just a song... it can resonate.

[@Nickajix89]

Found your channel today and I can already see an ARMY in the making. Gonna go ahead and welcome you to the family.

[@T7Karou]

I'd love to hear your perspective on Life Goes On since the director is one of themembers (Jungkook). He did not study the career butloves to film and edit 3-5 min. videos, kinda like vlogs but with music. He made a few called G.C.F (Golden Closet Film, since he did them in his room which was actually a closet). I would like to see if you think that lack of director career makes Life Goes On have a different and unique touch!

[@sakshinarvekar6697]

I actually loved your interpretation and insight on this !! Especially how you noticed the carousel with You Never Walk Alone written on it is juxtaposed with Jungkook and Jimin standing alone in their location. And with the clothes pile scene where you theorized that they are sort of camouflaged in there and the clothes are like their past relationships. That was a quite unique take and I agree with it. This song is generally about loss of a loved one and looking forward to when better days come and we can lose a loved one in many ways - growing apart because of some fight, or distance or just losing contact with each other. This is why I love to see reaction and reviews. To see different interpretations of a song I love. I believe such unique takes enrich the song in question even more. And when someone in the creative field uses their technical knowledge to explain how certain colors / camera angles / directing / cinematography is used to tell the story, evoke certain emotions and convey the message - I fall in love with the song even more.

[@wildflowersinwinter]

I liked your interpretation so much! I think the mv definitely has a lot of direct, specific references to the tragedy, but that doesn't mean you're wrong at all! The song itself, whether you know about the tragedy or not, still evokes the same feelings of, at least in my opinion, grief and sadness and loss and hope. Thank you for continuing to post these reactions, I look forward to them every time!

[@emmas8786]

I'm super impressed that you picked up on the carousel reference and the no vacancy sign.

[@ParallaxHearts]

Oh my god, you got that first Snowpiercer reference immediately. Ps: the Kratos "BOY" thing at the end was hilarious

[@Mori-Chan613]

The dance practice of this song is evenly beautiful and meaningful too. BTS are such a positive influence!

[@luojingjie4236]

love your screen name

[@kime-e]

Your passionate and serious review is touching. This reminds me of the situation in Korea back then. I was shocked to the point where I lost my appetite and people were collectively depressed. Because the slow sinking of the ship was being broadcast live, and we couldn't do anything. We watched people die in front of us for days. We held the government accountable for the deaths of these children. It's because unfortunate accidents always happen, but the process of settling them was very disappointing. Through this song, "Spring Day," Bts gave the impression that they were serious young people who expressed their opinions about social phenomena.

[@alyssag9836]

I literally laughed so much at your little messages calling your self out hahaha

[@DanielleMDM93]

Thank you so much for this reaction!! You are such an amazing person and I always look forward to your reactions!! I've always connected shoes hanging on a tree or cable as reference to death ever since I watched the movie 'Big Fish". I recommend checking it out if you haven't seen it already!

[@CedricGegel1]

I LOVE BIG FISH AND I LOVE EWAN MCGREGOR, and how did I not think of that 😂

[@harumori3538]

Love it when someone learn new things, new perspective, new point of view, new etc through BTS music and MV 💜

[@gerriberri.4412]

Gets you everytime. Visuals and lyrics never fail.

[@chiararoldanblanco1881]

Ohh.. I can't wait for this reaction.. 😄

[@melodysmith674]

This is probably my favorite or most meaningful song. Bogoshipda means I miss you. It has always touched my heart as I relate it to losing my husband and missing him. It was not too long ago I learned about the connection to the tragedy, so that just adds another depth of meaning to it. 💜💜💜💜💜

[@craftjoy6712]

Cedric you are awesome. Your interpretation was great. Love your empathy. You make me see all new factes to this song, wich makes it even more beautiful, Thank you.

[@QueensThief76455]

I love your pure interpretation before the explanation video. Of course, we all know that this song seems to have specific significance, but BTS songs are so amazing because of how they can speak to everyone personally. Thank you for sharing yours. Also, you caught many things! Wow, I didn't connect the carousel to Carousel. That was lovely.

[@CedricGegel1]

Wow, thank you! That's great to hear - and you're so right about their music. It's going to mean something to everyone.

[@mariajin6975]

Man rap mon is genius... What amazing work he has done with the lyrics 👌

[@luojingjie4236]

I love your comments on the angles. The Dutch angles especially reminded me of a ship that is listing from side to side as it's sinking. The color scheme info is awesome. They have a song on their new album called Blue and Grey written predominantly by V so when you pointed out the blue and grey color scheme with V I was reminded of that. Also, loved the Psych shout out.

[@ninamarie4069]

just yesterday jin basically confirmed that this is partly about the Sewol tragedy (i think it's more the music video) and also about longing. this theory is supported by the fact that BTS quietly donated money to the families and also the choreography heavily implies boats and wave imagery (HIGHLY RECOMMEND you to watch the choreography maybe the dance practice! many people miss that this song has choreography and it's really beautiful choreo too and goes with the sewol ferry theory.

[@ChotiMintus]

It was interesting to see how much you got from the video, you had more insights than most reactors I've seen. And thanks for the info about the "you never walk alone" song from Carousel. Will definitely check it out. This year some students etc sang Spring Day as a tribute to the doctors and nurses and those affected by Covid. You should check it out, it was awesome

[@freeandgentletv6403]

My favorite song. Can't wait to hear your reaction

[@alexuslopez5626]

I really hope you’ll dive into the I Need You series. The films are so symbolic and shot like a movie. They do go in a specific order! And are heavy with symbolism and details! I can’t wait for that! And the wings short films as well :) eventually you’ll see how all the videos tie in together :) but if I can support you on patreon I’ll try to request it there too.

[@rebeccacarmichael6745]

Thank you Cedric for another thoughtful and respectful reaction.I hope your recent endeavours are working out well.Although you're not planning on listening to BE yet,the album is mostly an anthem to Covid.The first track,Life Goes On is sad but comforting at the same time.Track three,Blue and Grey,is about depression.

[@bluewolfdancer]

Another great reaction. Love your explanations of the cinematic effects and that you immediately watched the explanation video as well. When reactors are good, it doesn't matter if the video is long - in fact, it's a bonus. Why not throw a dance practice in for good measure? :D (sorry, I know you must also have a life ;) ) Don't deprive yourself of the pleasure of discovering BE and joining ARMY in that wonderful ride. Our BangTanSeven made this album because of Covid , so I guess you could say it has a storyline of it's own. Of course there are details you might not recognize (like RM watering the tiny tree he took with him In The Soop), but I have no doubt you'll be able to connect the dots. You're good at spotting those! ;)

[@pensandnoodles681]

I'm glad that you're waiting to listen to the new album because a lot of reactors reacted immediately, and more than a few were so they would get a lot of views.. appreciate that you're wanting to get context instead of doing it for likes and subs :)

[@pensandnoodles681]

also love that you took the opportunity to touch on mental health and how we're not alone in it- so important

[@mintgi4136]

You are so knowledgable, it's like you know everything!

[@samsam-rd7vz]

I watched spring day earlier this year and also did my research on the Sewol Ferry incident. Such a heartbreaking story, and I love that BTS talked about it in the song (even though it's not explicit). I think that the South Korean people are very aware of it and they love spring day so much. I look forward to watching more of your reactions.

[@TheWaywardChicks]

I knew I was gonna be an ARMY for life when I heard/learned of this song.

[@yungturonsauce]

18:55 YESS you got it !! 👏👏👍

[@ginamc6123]

I just love watching you Cedric’s! When you reacted to the theory, I knew you felt it! I felt the same way, and I also googled it cause I didn’t remember hearing about it on the news. It’s such a beautiful song. Every time someone listens to it, those victims are remembered 💜!

[@eupetrosarktou7866]

"Omelas" is actually the first six letters of "Salem, Oregon" read backwards. LeGuin was driving through Salem, stopped for gas, and saw the partial reflection of a sign reflected in her rearview mirror. She liked the sound of it, and later used it in the short story referred to in the MV. It is oddly reminiscent of the name of Yoongi's "second self", Agust D. That is "DT Suga" backwards, DT being his birthplace, Daegu Town. A coincidence? Probably. But with BTS you never really know ... ###

[@ninamarie4069]

actually in the US shoes are also hung on power lines to commemorate the dead too. oftentimes friends of youth who are killed due to gang violence would commemorate the dead this way, so unfortunately some people started taking it as a warning of gang activity (which is where many ppl start thinking of it meaning there's drug dealers) but really it's to commemorate the dead here too.

[@ronnybts7902]

Spring day isn't called queen for nothing My all time favorite 🥺😭😭😭

[@samsam_gsk]

I WANTED TO COMMENT BEFORE I FORGOT IM A HUGE PSYCH FAN! okay going back to watching huhu

[@CedricGegel1]

I'm KZbin reactor Shawn Spencer, and this is my partner, SamSam the steamed ham. C'mon, son. (so glad you like Psych too!!!!)

[@samsam_gsk]

Cedric Gegel yessss!!! i love it. don’t take me out in public i will point out every pineapple in sight 😂

[@jeremiahong6881]

Yessss, Cedric your blue eyes are mesmerizing. Love love your reaction as always. This Spring Day always melt me, tearing me apart, let alone the explanation video always break me apart. OMG. I can't. I can't. TKS to react this great BTS. Borahae. I 💜 Purple you.

[@dzieckoziemi]

"Dude you.missed so much you may as well be a Stormtrooper". I LOVE your SW references 👌

[@elisam4228]

I always cry when I rewatch the video of the explanation

[@mmmmha1489]

You were so observant and thoughtful in your interpretation of the song and mv!! Just wanted to say that.

[@chiararoldanblanco1881]

I loved your theory.. I think you reallygot the feeling of the song.. and thank you for all the messages about mental health 🥰 You know this song represents why they are so unique and good at what they do. They offered a shoulder to those who went to that tragedy, they somehow criticized the government and the society, they talked about losing people, what does that mean and they did it in a way so people can easily relate to and feel/know they are not alone... And even if you haven't been through this particular tragedy.. you can relate to it! A lot of people around the world didn't even know about this! I learned it because of them... It's really sad.. but beautiful at the same time.. this song it like "the Queen" of their songs.. if you are getting into their world, this song is a must go... I loved your reaction.. THANK YOU!

[@stephaniewilliams3573]

Dude, I have a serious bone to pick with you! I was crying (cuz this song always makes me cry) then suddenly Kratos pops up. My body didn’t know how to process those polar emotions so now there’s tea all over my screen.🤣 I’ll leave a thoughtful comment when I collect myself. Borahae!!🤣💜

[@CedricGegel1]

I reconsidered putting that there but felt like lightening the mood haha you’re the first person I’ve seen to catch it 😂 sorry to have ruined your tea!!

[@kimmyh2157]

Ur reaction was amazing! It was very thoughtful and u got a lot of the theme and it’s open to interpretation. Please please please watch life goes on! It’s very timely 💜

[@aniloj2000]

dont worry. you are close. You are looking from someone from the west. I cry every time I watch a reaction. You did a good job.

[@flam9960]

When we take someone that havent heard of the background it is interesting to see how art can connect us... You knew almost nothing but you could understand the feelings and the idea that they wanted to convey...

[@sooh6299]

Editing Cedric is my favorite!

[@marlabrannan8180]

Super interesting - I really enjoyed your explanation of the colors of their clothes. Neat!

[@vicesandvirtues8]

Love your reactions! So genuine!

[@CedricGegel1]

Thank you so much!!

[@kaklongyusoff7753]

Now this is the reactor that we can feel the genuineness toward bts and also we can learn a thing or two from him. Good observation 👍, will subscribe 🙏