Aespa proofs they can sing live

[@FernandoOusjes]

Their live vocals are stable than my mental state💀

[@nikunjkhangwal]

Us bro

[@evelyneeve5614]

make it two of us 🙃

[@Commander_HW]

Then you need to go seek help from professionals.

[@moaswrld]

I would hope so since most of the times they aren’t really moving

[@virtualangel12]

karinas last high note in girls is seriously one of my favorites in all of kpop, I think its so beautiful

[@huongnguyenthu8073]

I agreeeeee, so satisfyingggg

[@star-miubin]

They look much happier performing live tbh...

[@cosas_de_gatos]

Fr. You can tell lip syncing annoys them, Winter doesn’t even try anymore. During high notes she barely opens her mouth, and looks bored. It’s kind of sad, SM needs to let them sing live

[@W-I463]

It's nice knowing they actually enjoy performing

[@shannarafryer3111]

Most artists prefer it. Well except the ones who can’t sing

[@yasminchan7425]

Oh definitely, I mean they trained to become singers it's not fun to just pretend to sing

[@Oopsie_kpop]

So true 😍

[@giorgiacarlottarossato6399]

SM artists are the standard.

[@darthunleashed]

SM lmao 😂😂😂 Aespa are nice tho

[@_linlin_]

@@darthunleashed Yes SM even if they have prerecords often everyone in the industry knows ALL OF THEM CAN SING, which is THEIR JOB! So yeah - SM, they are the king company for visuals and vocals. No wonder why HYBE is inspired by SMe, but will never be able to replicate. =)

[@Oopsie_kpop]

​@@darthunleashedwhy are you laughing??

[@snoopandas3899]

bro u can clearly see how less exhausting this choreo is comparing to other choreo

[@Bloomingkpop6661]

​@@snoopandas3899yea cuz there's no need to make k-pop a dance show.

[@Katarinabluu_MY]

They are very stable but those antis don’t want to accept it cuz their fav can’t 💀

[@ipromisethatserendipityisa9656]

I know which fave that cant.... lol

[@tobennaokoli4450]

Ha 😂

[@yeonjunchoi-qc4nj]

@@ipromisethatserendipityisa9656 who

[@blackbird251]

@@ipromisethatserendipityisa9656too many

[@888emm]

They’re literally like the only 4th gen group that can ACTUALLY sing and rap live. They’re honestly underrated which I don’t understand considering they’re the IT girl group for 4th gen imo.

[@tobennaokoli4450]

Maybe this is why SM never lets them sing live. Dish it out little by little so fans keep coming back to every concert.

[@y0ung5one]

some people jokingly said that it is SM strategy. if we want to hear them sing live, we have to give them a music show win so we can get an encore stage.

[@nyah1808]

I get that but why were they not singing live at the concert their FANS paid MONEY for??

[@wedidntdoanythingwrong]

@@nyah1808they do sing live at concerts?? concerts have long setlists so you can’t expect them to be singing live every second whilst dancing, that’s not realistically possible

[@Vlad_serapkov]

@@nyah1808 actually SM artists sing live more at concerts than any shows/perfomances

[@aerismahiwagangsandok]

@@wedidntdoanythingwrongof course they do sing live atleast 90% of a concert, not only them but every kpop group ever, even Twice

[@cursedepub]

they sound GREAT overall but especially with the harmonised ILLUSIOOOOooN. i agree w other commenters, i used to think aespa looked like they hated their jobs onstage back when they debuted lipsyncing, they look so much more engaged and are way better to watch when they sing.

[@exotickyungssssoo]

they are singing live like the whole sm town..

[@nikunjkhangwal]

Winter high notes are insane

[@seruleanade]

this is why i like SM groups. they are WELL-TRAINED to do their job. make good music, sing live, deliver good performances, and staying true to their group concept to be trend-setters. each group in SM has their own sound and talent, which is nice to have. this is what i look for in k-pop and they do it well!! (except SM gives shit ass promotions and poorly manages their idols)

[@philippechornet935]

No one questioned their vocals but we still love

[@fearnotmyinsomniaonce4579]

Before Aespa started singing live more often than their debut/rookie era, there were far too many people who were convinced that the only reason they lip-synced so much is because they can't actually sing, so I wouldn't say no one.

[@fearnoted]

wym aespa had the biggest hate train

[@gzzelle]

Itzy left the chat​@@fearnoted

[@elle_et_dani]

@@gzzelleAespa got it from their debut and still do, Itzy just got it these past 2 years. Itzy were extremely loved by the public.

[@aerichndsu]

​@@gzzelle try being a my in 2020-2022 and you'll see who had it worse

[@babyanimals7271]

Another reason why they are the best all-around group in K-pop right now.

[@sakshigreatelkandir6000]

They can clearly sing live and are hella stable, i hope SM give them more lIVE PERFOMANCES like this but not lip sync

[@harrytuan1923]

their voices are insane!!!! OMGGGGG

[@Nekorbmi]

Thats what always got to be about kpop. I Know the talent is real, the vocals, the dancing, the beauty. But with all that dancing and moving about youll get out of breath fast and wont be able to sing properly. Im ok with lip singing in kpop because i know the talent is really there.

[@connorelie6700]

Fr

[@Rolandajohn]

Yeah, I agree and also a lot of the time they have a pre-recording because I think Christopher had talked about it on live once where they would record them doing it live because they have to do the dance multiple times and it gets tiring to have to sing dance so they would do a pre-recording and that’s what they would go off of so that’s why sometimes it’s like they’re singing live you hear them breathing and everything but actually it’s a pre-recording

[@yibocheeks9666]

I'm glad that after all the senseless hatred towards Aespa since their rookie days where was heavily criticized, they are now turning to see and recognize how talented the girls are. I hope Aespa continues to grow because of her great talent, they are the whole package. I look forward to their next comeback.

[@yuuraaa-wd3xi]

Winter's vibrato is the death of me

[@cjb9892]

It is not a surprise that people don’t think they can sing live. They are as stable as it is prerecorded. It is more than perfect.

[@foreverinsfired]

Oh Winter ATE these notes 1:12 1:21

[@sakurasai781]

1:31 she’s insaaaaane

[@Sofia-airsignrights]

yes omg and to think she went on bubble and said she was disappointed in her high note and said she would do better next time lol

[@Lee_Sohee960]

@@Sofia-airsignrights yes because started flat (1:28) but she was able to get herself up and be on pitch (1:31)

[@sofia.BPEOTW]

I don't know why SM don't leaves sometimes the opportunity for Aespa to sing live. They all have amazing vocals! ❤

[@ai-ki2716]

Sm is home of vocals

[@ilovegolcha]

If they can sing the songs great in studios they can do it live too what makes you think they 'cant sing'

[@loveyou4695]

Agreed lol

[@cranberryrosebud]

an alarming number of people say they can't, I think this video is here to show them - from the editing, I think the person behind this channel is a MY

[@TheTHEPARTYROCKER101]

That’s not what people are talking about. It’s singing LIVE. Aespa can do it. SM is just being an ass for not allowing them to sing live when they can. There’s this whole bs that they have to sound perfect. It’s ridiculous. If your watching a concert they should sing live period.

[@lunaloverbts4529]

I don't think anyone thinks that they CAN'T, but rather complain about SM not allowing them (or their other groups as of recently) to sing live.

[@belaytriks]

No. It is not the same. In a studio they are in a controlled and comfotable enviroment where they can sing all the times it is needed until the producer or director is satisfy with it, they are not dancing and can have all the rest needed to sing right. In a studio recording they record by phrase, word or line, it is unnusual for them to sing a whole song in one go. They have too their coaches there if needed in order to instruct them how to do a note. All that without counting the touchs made for the producer. In a concert you are moving, there is no controled enviroment, you have to sing many, many songs one after the other, there are a lot of things going on and one mistake can produce others. Sing live in a stage is different that sing inside a record cabine. Once that said, that does not mean Aespa can not sing live, I think they can and that is why is so frustrating all the lips synch.

[@RC-ud4qo]

SM artists can sing live

[@ventaliq]

winter ate

[@BobGolob]

These girls rock! They never disapoint.

[@pluto3603]

theyre so amazing

[@yeonfeels1981]

song name plzz

[@NewJeanius]

@@yeonfeels1981 Illusion - æspa

[@yeonfeels1981]

@@NewJeanius tysm^^

[@NewJeanius]

@@yeonfeels1981 Yww :)

[@pluto3603]

@@yeonfeels1981 the first one is illusion yes and the second one is called girls

[@cherlynlumaghan3564]

Aespa vocals are so stable , they proved it many times. VISUALS WITH TALENTS!

[@user-ib1is7ny7r]

wish they would sing live more often, they’re superb

[@OpalStar76]

Their vocals in illusion definitely lacked a little but they definitely made up with that AMAZING live Girls performance. MYs should be proud

[@mybit4eva]

Aespa is probably my 2nd favorite group after LOONA- their vocals are literally so nice to hear 😭😭🫶🫶 i love their voices so much, every time i hear their songs it feels like i’m ascending or something

[@ryuniverse..]

let’s be honest.. if SM idols always sung live, they would be so much more happier, you can tell they don’t like lip syncing

[@manusia-wf6hj]

Maybe SM just don't want to make them too tired with live singing, they tell them to lipsync to give their vocals enough rest and avoid vocal injuries which are very likely to occur during live vocals. Sorry for my bad english, I'm not very good at it

[@369lala]

Yea every SM idols hate it because they trainee a lot Then in the end they have to lip syncing

[@HelTra91]

@@manusia-wf6hj That is literally what they train to do though, if they aren't going to sing live on shows and tv appearances then what was the point of all those years of training. You can say to give their vocals a break but then they go and do a bunch of concerts which are all live with way more energy and dancing for longer periods of time.

[@ipromisethatserendipityisa9656]

They have the skill, they should sing live more so the people would respect them more as performers. What the hell is wrong with SM?

[@yibocheeks9666]

That was one of the first performances where they were already letting the girls sing live TOTALLY, I guess the SM distributed it little by little in their concerts because now they do it more frequently than before, where they were strongly criticized by people saying that They didn't sing that it was illogical since that company is characterized by great vocals, now you can check out performances from their most recent comebacks. I invite you to watch this video as an example: kzbin.info/www/bejne/m6OUZK2hjdyXh7s

[@viclusiv]

SM: "wanna live? come to the concert baby"

[@maiavitale8458]

bold of you to assume they don’t have the ability

[@anormalgurl8]

Who assumed?

[@maiavitale8458]

@@anormalgurl8 someone

[@TheTHEPARTYROCKER101]

Some groups struggle with live singing, due to the company not training them enough. Some groups are not allowed to sing live for some dumb ass reason of by the company. Aespa can sing live SM just doesn’t want to showcase it, it’s beyond ridiculous.

[@lu_xuryyy]

It was so good that i had to watch this without SKIPPING

[@ChadVarquez]

Should’ve done this during their concert.

[@keonheehe]

Yes. Tbh, after being disappointed on the concert performances, I just looked at this one, bcz it gave everything the concert should have (wich translates into: it actually gave us live vocals)

[@maiavitale8458]

lmao most songs are performed live in their concert and every kpop group uses some kind of backtrack at the concert too bp literally lipsynced the half of their concert i know they got lot of hate but nobody’s deserving this hate wtf every group lipsyncs at one point period

[@keonheehe]

@@maiavitale8458 even though I love the girls, and I know that if it was their desicion, they would've sang live more songs, they didn't. The only songs that were actually with the mics on was aenergy and the ones with hand mics, the rest, was obviously with mics off, since you couldn't hear any hard breathing or variation in their voices

[@ipromisethatserendipityisa9656]

@@maiavitale8458 They have better vocals than BP. They should at least use it for their fans. Who attends a concert to hear a recording anyway? A big part of the art of performing is in their vocals.

[@nmixxingup]

KZbin casually putting videos on the algorithm 9/10/11 months after its release

[@Jisooeunida]

Frr💀

[@ОляЗайцева-з1х]

I honestly think they have the best vocals in K-pop. I would be glad if they sang live more often

[@SunhaJae]

Ningning's live performance skills>>>>>>

[@sseraeno]

sm is the vocal powerhouse idk why theyre so scared to let their idols sing live

[@Rosieee65]

Not a MY but dayumm NOW THAT'S WHAT YOU CALL VOCALS. MY GIRLS SLAYED

[@ryn4286]

Excuse me WINTER!?!?! 🤯

[@hindosman7186]

They can sing live but i don't know why sm make them lipsink

[@viclusiv]

SM want you to go to their concert

[@nctgirl373]

Yes and spend some money 🙂​@@viclusiv

[@Emii_XO]

Lol people just cant accept that aespa IS the best girl group with visuals, vocals, and dance too! Just becuz of their faves. Talent matters more than popularity and fame.

[@elmin82]

They sound good

[@viclusiv]

wdym kinda💀💀💀, they can sing and can live. both.

[@elmin82]

@@viclusiv don't worry, i modified the comment

[@kxntolicious]

Bagus bangetttt🥰🥰🥰

[@LihnLee]

They are very good!

[@Missblink-lo9jt]

they are the perfect girl group. they can sing live and pretty

[@khulanpurewsuren9943]

why youtube recommend me this vid after le sserafim coachella

[@idol7833]

Yes they can sing live, it's just SM deleting thier live vocal 'cause I saw some video

[@naddd7308]

Slayyy~

[@roughlyscha58]

SM artists never disappointed

[@LovelyLara123]

They are SO STABLE dadcceacecaeca

[@Svt_caratt]

Winter is very angry

[@medeatheesolon]

I hate the fact that sm and music shows don’t let them sing live from their debut, now haters and non fans assumed they never sing live

[@aishahrahman-zm4xh]

how can people not know aespa always had good live vocals

[@nacchip]

não adianta não tem vocal melhor que o delas!!!!!! 💕

[@Hia2213]

I live Karina vocal

[@jckwan7714]

winter was too good!

[@project-pe6ly]

proof they know how to sing: sm

[@tokyoluv_]

Anyone else thinking karina looked sm like haerin in the thumbnail??

[@OMGMyHypeBoyKeita]

I thought so too I was so confused at first

[@viclusiv]

thay CAN sing LIVE easily. i think SM set the price of lipsync and live different lol.

[@kkaebsong1368]

all of them can sing

[@10_657]

WINTER >>>>

[@nara_saya]

One thing about SM, they never miss on vocal talents

[@Mindungie0]

SM should stop having their artists lip sync😭😭

[@ManduJendukie]

Its good sm makes them lipsync. That way they dont strain their vocals and can give the best performance when needed

[@horizonkyun7203]

wow karina looks like haein in the thumbnail

[@nosugarnoprob]

Haters cannot believe it’s LIVE because they think their fav is the standard. Listen yall, Aespa is standard🎉

[@kunaikat2232]

mind blown

[@seraphina1226]

remember guys, their vocal is more stable than our grades.

[@yncu]

Imagine being a singer and not be able to sing live when you actually can😟

[@drpat4892]

Its actually so sad how most of time sm doesn't let their great vocalists (like aespa, nct) sing live cus they're so stable!

[@kaylaazrina8013]

They enjoyed live performance, we all can see that obviously. They're sick of lip syncing

[@motherhoodsbeauty9279]

And their hater will still say they can’t sing live. They say that about all groups.

[@TristanLoh4200]

of course they sing live... people need to stop calling them out for lipsyncing damn

[@desiwahyuni4206]

Winter❤❤❤

[@moon_dlwlrma]

cantan muy bien en vivo, pero seamos sinceros, se crearon una mala fama en cuánto al lipsync, ningning y winter son excelentes vocalistas, nunca entendí porque SM no les permitió mostrar su verdadero potencial

[@ak1ak1ra]

They are one of the group that can sing live but SM doesn’t allow them to sing. The other groups that can’t sing live, their comp allow them to sing. 😂

[@imkhangyn]

now aespa sings better than lesserafim at coachella :D

[@aesserafim585]

tbh even if they lipsync idc, they have proved them selves as great vocalists. never speak on their vocals!

[@chaelicopter]

proves *

[@Ana-eo3fs]

I'm not really an Aespa fan but I think they're pretty talented. I like some of their songs and see a lot of potential on them, but the fact of they lipsync so much make people underestimate their skills and think about them just as pretty and talentless faces.

[@kchloezy]

The caption is Aespa (*aespa) but there is no Giselle singing part in the video :))? She was cut in places where she was about to sing?

[@jk_ilyu]

NOW THIS !! is a proper performance!!

[@mundokpop1234]

aespa devora cantando en vivo pero obtuvieron mala fama al hacer lypsinc varias veces por obligación de su empresa :( que triste

[@Seulgies.]

Can we hype up giselle too please?

[@happiness4654]

During this performance, she had lots of mic problems and wasn't sadly audible compared to the other girls. She's great though

[@Seulgies.]

@@happiness4654 could’ve shown other live performances 🙁‼️

[@handler00017]

proves

[@Leon玲央]

People could just watch them recording songs to know that.

[@ruu406]

Its a different thing to record and perform

[@sapphireblue1953]

They prefer singing live..and they really really hates lip syncing..😊

[@theetaurus1832]

oh this set up.

[@YESHIROFOREVER]

On the thumbnail, I thought that was haerin😅

[@mitramani8346]

Karina ❤

[@shy.ihhPvP]

Original video please?

[@happiness4654]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKPNpKhrnZ2LgLcsi=qXJndKezaNuOfODE

[@ivyungsod05]

I swear those anti fans keep hating on them bc their fave cant sing live but literally can hear them singing live bc of 2 layers of vocals and different pitches

[@carolwolfih5354]

Can, yes, but they dont do it usualy its just that

[@juhphopie]

SM fault

[@giarivera9674]

Can we give Rina highlights again

[@Ana-eo3fs]

I don't really understand why SM don't let them sing live. Like, all them have capability of sing really well while dancing and (at least for me) Aespa's choreography doesn't seems to difficult to perform. The only song I feel they would have some difficulty is Black Mamba because the choreography seems a bit tiring but the rest of their songs, I feel they could dance and sing live perfectly well.

[@imeaniguess.6963]

1:08 Which one is this one? 🧐

[@imeaniguess.6963]

@@usagihearts Ah, thanks.

[@TristanLoh4200]

ningning

[@cc00781]

💯

[@steakoncearmyengene9326]

Totally Red Velvet juniors