The Shia of India

With 40 million Shia in India today, this documentary aims to unearth how and why Shia's migrated in such large numbers into the subcontinent with a look at the various dynasties where they ruled and contributed.
Click Here to subscribe & keep updated with all our latest videos:
kzbin.info...
Be a part of the Ahlulbayt TV mission:
goo.gl/h2FV4z
Follow Ahlulbayt TV on social media:
Facebook - goo.gl/j7bM8g
Twitter - goo.gl/bp81Ey
Instagram - goo.gl/aEYf9u
Telegram - goo.gl/8XiHTg
Snapchat - goo.gl/DvTPLH
Website: www.Ahlulbayt.tv/
Ahlulbayt TV (Main Channel) -
/ ahlulbayttv
Ahlulbayt: Documentaries -
/ ahlulbayttvdocs
Ahlulbayt: Reborn -
/ ahlulbayttvreborn
Children's ABTV (CABTV) -
/ childrensabtv
Ahlulbayt: General Q&A -
/ ahlulbayttvqanda

[@Peraj82]

I have always been puzzled about the cultural, language and even facial similarities between Indians and Iranians. This documentary helped me to understand a lot. I wish British has never made that organised mess in India, the land land of tolerance and diversity. I hope people would find their common roots and start to unite, even-though mostly are further deviating unfortunately.

[@ndorobei4391]

tdot22 only north indian, the aryans

[@VK-wf9qe]

tdot22 you must be an ignorant idiot

[@ayushvashisht70429]

Jelly Belly 😂😂😂😂 every Muslim in indian subcontinent is an decedent of hindu ....their ancestors were hindu ..pls go educate yourself dont just follow madarsa schooling

[@RiazKhan-wq9qt]

@@ayushvashisht70429 Yes, 90 % Muslims are descendant of Hindus. Hindus are converted to Islam. Aryan are descendant of Alexander. Dravidian are Dark. A mixed nation, indo-Ariyan. Parsi, Jewish, Arab , Iranian, Mongoloid etc. If any body says 'Ugly Hindus', its is a crime. If anybody says MUslims or Shiks or Christian or Buddhist are ugly, that's also a crime.

[@zaryabshah6060]

@@jellybelly688 LMAOO🤣

[@Iraqijaafar]

Salam from Iraqi Shia from City of Karbala 🕌

[@CurryCreator]

Jaafar Almaliki walekumassalam bro To the Pure land of Karbala Iltemas e dua love from India

[@mirzaalibeg6387]

Walekum asslam from India

[@nadeemali.7868]

Walaikum salaam bro

[@kidsfunvideo7064]

W'salam mashallah

[@abdhulmuthalib7619]

Walaikum assalam warahmatullahi wabarkatuh bro

[@bismillah1677]

I'm Iranian and shia and I always loved India. thanks for great informations...

[@scmfrmanzil]

bismi llah may allah bless you . May allah bless me to visit qom ,mashad

[@professorx39]

bismi llah I am an Indian Sunni and Sunnis in India hate Iran just as any other Sunnis. Iran was a Sunni nation before 16th century. It was the Shia ruler, Ismail Safavi, a Rafidah pig, who tortured and persecuted the Sunnis and and systematically converted Iran into a Sunni nation

[@optimusprime5199]

Faiz Rappo Before Sunni, it was Zoroastrian land, which were persecuted by Sunnis. So it's square.

[@MohdZakir-xp8im]

India is a puppet of US remember ,you shiya always defiant to Islam and help those who are enemies of Islam ,history tells us

[@Ahmed____]

@@MohdZakir-xp8im Please give proven and verified examples of the situations where the Shia have helped the so called 'Enemies of Islam', with links to reputable historical sites please.

[@brianbars9108]

I am a Christian who loves reading Imam Ali. He is one of the great philosophers of the medieval times and should be studied regardless of your religious faith. One of my favorite quotes by Imam Ali is If we are not brothers in faith, we are equals in humanity.

[@ishaanrohmetra3447]

any english books ? regarding imam ali and his philosphy

[@ahmedzaidi1453]

Bro where did you read this quote i just wanted to know the source so that i can read more about my imam

[@persiansultan6444]

​@@ishaanrohmetra3447 Nahjul Balagha

[@josephthomasthankyoujabbar6302]

​

[@madni6447]

I am shia from Pakistan.. we love our Indian brothers because we are human first we need to distribute humanity each other..in our shia sect there is no concept that says when you kill someone you are going to heaven and enjoying with girls

[@fookoboy9623]

K2 Gilgit bro don't try to compare Pakistan with India.

[@zulfiqarhashim1376]

great sentiments brother we should follow example of france and germany after centuries of war they live as one now ..open borders and no rhetoric from their leaders

[@fatoomabbas2984]

FOOKO BOY plz try to minimize haters ,he is not trying to compare ,he just said we love indian brothers ,infact we love shia in.every corner of this world not only in india

[@cortex3334]

K2 Gilgit "People are of two types, they are either your brothers in faith or your equals in humanity". Ali ibn abi Talib

[@yashrajsingh6554]

K2 Gilgit try to learn from india ....How much we love our shia brothers .........U should also support Hindus in pakistan

[@ANKET47]

Love you shia brothers for being contributory members of Indian society.

[@arshadabbas544]

Anket Shetty luv u my hindu brother i m proud to be an indian jai hind 💖😊

[@NaseerAhmed-sc5bl]

Anket Shetty Shias are non Muslims

[@asadullashariff8795]

Naseer Ahmed what problem do u hv frm shia first learn the religion thn say. Are follower of prophet Muhammad saw r follower of Muhammad abdul wahab najdi

[@yogeshparmar329]

+Moon Dweller Great man, proud of you brother....

[@kailasa-rr1xr]

Yes shia is right hand of India

[@alibazzoun1129]

Thanks India for protecting my relatives and my Brothers and Sisters in faith. Much respect to India ❤ -A Sayyed from South Lebanon.

[@CurryCreator]

Love from India to Lebanon May Allah Safe our brothers in Lebanon they lived happily life

[@ambar94]

Ali Bazzoun i am from india and sayyad so good to see this documentry .

[@mirzaeffendi5405]

Ali Bazzoun love frm india sayed be in peace in lebenon

[@toxic9525]

India will always welcome you

[@thetruthhere8606]

Shia Indians are partially Arab people

[@joker72Ghost]

Salam from IRAN to all my brothers in INDIA

[@optimusprime5199]

Ashish Kalkal So what it has to do with, him saying Salam to all Indian's.

[@billionaire6792]

Not call Salam say Namaskar or namaste🙏

[@nishanttyagi3543]

Chabhar port 😍 thanks iran

[@kviolin1313]

Thank u bro love from 🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@user-dz4pb2ll3k]

@@nishanttyagi3543 i love muslim

[@haidersl4769]

thanks to this documentary I proud to be a indian Shia...

[@mahakalkabhakt8737]

haider sl I am hindu but I love shia brothers

[@kviolin1313]

@Unonown _ANONYMOUS i didnt know iraq had shias!

[@MyMs05]

Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you, [O Muhammad], are not [associated] with them in anything. Their affair is only [left] to Allah ; then He will inform them about what they used to do. (Quran 6:159)

[@Robinhood-k]

Salute from Afghanistan Shia to our brothers and sisters in Indian❤

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

This is how it should be brotherhood between all shia regardless which country they are from

[@alijarallah8699]

@@Shia.Ahlulbayt 👏👏👏🌹

[@musaperouz]

MashAllah brother

[@musaperouz]

@@Shia.Ahlulbayt from Afghanistan also(:

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

@@musaperouz salaam to our brothers & sisters in Afghanistan too 🙂 Many Allah (swt) bless them

[@user-dc4jm7uf5p]

God bless the Indian Shiites I met individuals in Najaf and Karbala Also from Pakistan and Afghanistan We are all brothers in religion We hope to see you on the anniversary of the visit Forty Imam Al-Hussein, peace be upon him Greetings to you from Iraq

[@sayedsamadabbasjafri4713]

Insallah From india shia ❤️ Stay safe

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

This is how it should be brotherhood between all shia regardless which country they are from. Alhamdulillah I have been arbaeen many times. Insha'allah will be able to go again. Greetings from UK my Iraqi brother

[@Meliodasthesinofwrath]

Indian shia has nothing to do with islam

[@truthseekerseeker4454]

The great Hindu Raja dahir gave his life & kingdom to save imam husains grand children's .

[@sayedmohammed3180]

Love from Pakistan Sayed 🙌❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@nimavalizadeh3120]

God bless all Shias from India to Lebanon👍

[@guidinglight7337]

Hey ! What about Iran ? If you pray , pray for All . That way Allah will reward you !

[@nimavalizadeh3120]

salam dear brother, sorry that's a misunderstanding! when I say from India to Lebanon means India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and all, not just India and Lebanon! btw I'm an Iranian (living in Isfahan)✌

[@suraiyarehmani5095]

God bless us all !! :)

[@suraiyarehmani5095]

God Bless us all :)

[@suraiyarehmani5095]

Well said, Guiding light. Well said.

[@digibro1296]

The thing is that most Hindus aren't aware that there are Shia Muslims. To this day I meet Hindus and they are surprised to know that we are different from Sunnis. I just want my Hindu brothers that please learn about Shias. Like most of the comments here, Hindus who have exposure to Shia Muslims know that they are educated and liberal. Because of Sunni and Wahabis, we have to face the stereotype and prejudices. Only if we Shia could separate our identity from the Sunni and wahabis.

[@thewayiamblue229]

Do that man, we need more people like you in the our country, once I had been to a khoja clinic in Hyderabad, I saw how indifferent they were, calm, composed and non judgmental.

[@ka.270]

I'am Thankful to this channel for making this documentary on us. ~An Indian Shia from the region of Awadh.

[@Lockheed_007]

You are real Muslim. Sunni and Wahabis are on wrong path

[@pranavazrenkar7981]

A Hindu sacrificing his kingdom, his family and his life for Descendants of A Prophet (PBUH) of different faith. That's the true spirit of India. Proud to be an Indian.

[@randomtraveling1517]

Though Imam Hussain gave his life almost 1300 years ago, but his indestructible soul rules the hearts of people even today

[@user-xw8sp9vp2d]

nitish singh indeed

[@NaseerAhmed-sc5bl]

nitish singh imaam hussain was murdered by the Shia and they murdered hussain children in karabala Singh Saab

[@NaseerAhmed-sc5bl]

nitish singh they are not Muslim so please don't call them Muslims and insult Islam the Shias are the Children of the Jews

[@imransayyed806]

indeed thats why we still mourn for hussain ibn ali a.s we will not forgot for why sacrifices he give for islam not like others who happly cleberate muharram and the deth of imam hussain a.s Jai hind

[@emmydude6584]

and our respected Prophet also..

[@guidestudio744]

love and respect for my shia families in india from afghanistan

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

This is how it should be brotherhood between all shia regardless which country they are from

[@musaperouz]

Me too(:

[@Soroush202]

Wow - I never knew India had such a beautiful shia history. Thumbs up and salute from Lahore.

[@Soroush202]

I wont be coming to your America mr. Trump :D

[@Soroush202]

First of all, Pakistan is not all sand like KSA or any middle eastern country. Seems like all Trump supporters have some DNA defect that they can't distinguish between people. Second, you use middle eastern resources to fuel your sick economy. Just go and study how your economy, during the great depression of in 30's, recovered using the MUSLIM OIL. If today the middle east dumps dollar to some other currency, your economy will come crashing down within 48 hours. The muslims OWN YOU. Keep this thing in mind.

[@Soroush202]

My forefathers migrated from central asia in 1926 and settled in Baltistan ( Northern side of Pakistan ). We had business of wool and fabric before partition in Srinagar.

[@BSDas-mt5sb]

Before Pakistan it was Indian subcontinent ( Hindustan ) called good for migraints

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

This is how it should be brotherhood between all shia regardless which country they are from

[@hitesh8354]

If any of Islam is left in the World... I see it in Shiaism... May Allah keep All Shias Blessed...

[@qatarimapping3810]

Amen..... From Sunni Muslim

[@logic1137]

Correct bro

[@hasankhan1535]

Right

[@logic1137]

@god hates them Absolutely the best example of this is Iran

[@KashanReza]

I'm Syed Shia from Karachi, Pakistan, and my grandparents were from Lucknow my greatest wish is to see Bara Imambargah of Lucknow and to see Azadari of our Indian Brothers.

[@qatarimapping3810]

Btw I am Muslim from India but I am Sunni Muslim I love Shias

[@sunniareourbrothers.8888]

Welcome my bro .....from India

[@KashanReza]

@@sunniareourbrothers.8888 will come soon after this pandemic ends 😊

[@amankumar-xk8je]

@@KashanReza Mai lucknow se hu,agar koi dikkat ho to mujhe batana,here mostly muslims are shias

[@KashanReza]

@@amankumar-xk8je shukria bhai btw some of my relatives still lives there 😊

[@bekaradami6178]

I'm a Hindu, But I like my Shia brothers. India is the only place where Shia & Sunni live peacefully, unlike middle-east.

[@rjhaveri8bh]

In Fact no muslim country in the world offer freedom of religion to its minority muslims where as in India they all have freedom of religion Listen Again and Again even in the video he says even the shia or Ahulul Bayt Muslims converted Hindus . this despite the hindus given shelter to the prophets family and descendants and still the muslims continued to convert hindus instead of live with them in tolerance side by side. where as the hindus were tolerant they even went to save the prophets family in Karbala. Most muslim dont understand quran or islamic books this is the curse of the muslims I like to ask you herein to confirm the following verses from quran and clarify. Surah Fatir, chapter 35 verse 24 Al-Quran 35:24 Surah Rad, chapter 13 verse 7 Al-Quran 13:7 There was never a people, without a guide or messenger sent to them with the message of allah Do you agree. Surah Anbiya, chapter 21 verse 107: Al-Quran 21:107 Surah Saba, chapter 34 verse 28 Al Quran 34:28 We sent thee not, but as a mercy to all creatures, and warning them against sin but most men understand not my message then how and why do muslims claim that all muslims will go to heaven and all non-muslims will not. Do you agree. It is mentioned in Sahih Bukhari, vol 1, book of salaah, chapter 56 hadith no 429 Narrated Jabir bin Abdullah; Allahs messenger said, Every prophet was sent in their language to his people only but I have been sent to all mankind. Surah Nisa, chapter 4 verse 164: Al-Quran 4:164 Surah Ghafir chapter 40 verse 78 Al-Quran 40:78 Of some messengers we have already told thee story; of others we have not Only 25 prophets/ messengers of god have been mentioned but in the same verse they say that 1,24,000 prophets/ messengers of god are sent to earth. Every messenger sent to people in their own language. And nowhere in Quran does it mention, that all the past prophets/ messengers were sent for a particular period or time, nor does it say that other prophets were less superior then prophet mohammed then why does the muslims misinterpret the quran and thus the word of allah, are there misinterpretation, work of munatifs. Surah Al Imran, chapter 3 verse 49, Al-Quran 3:49 Mohd is appointed as the messenger of children of Israel. This point is mention over 50 times in the Quran, but the muslims ignore this intentionally, because they want to hide these facts and divert the attention from questions regarding the killing of prophet mohammed and his kins by muslims. Then why do the children of hindustan (hind) need to follow the messenger sent to the arabs and children of Israel, when a messenger was sent to them in their own language why to they follow the messenger sent in arabic language. Allah does not say his message to other messengers was different but Muslims say this. Who do you want to believe the muslims or the word of Allah. The muslims who interpret that Mohammed is the last and final messenger of almight are putting words into allah's mouth. The quran does not categorically say this anywhere. Also muslims hate Jews, muslims hate Israel, the muslims say the jews dont belong in Israel. If the quran has mentioned the children of Israel more then 50 times then why do muslims say the jews should leave arabia why do the muslims want to push out the jews in to the sea. Is it correct that 56 muslim countries have banned israel. When 6 muslim nations have been banned by US the muslim world made such big out cry. On what basis would you say the settlements by Israeli is illegal. the state of israel is 67 kms, this is less then the city of new york. so why do muslims all over the world believe the Israelis don't have right over this land , infect it is other way round it is the muslim who are occupiers on the historical land of the jews. like you have right to live so do the israelis. infact the real fact is muslim for 18% of Israel population they are happily coexisting, but muslim dont want you to know that. Infct there no jews in arab land where as there were millions once upon a time ago This muslim behaviour almost replicates everywhere, in paakistn 22% of the population was hindu in this hindu land which is the birth place of vedas and sikh religion but today there are no hindus just 1%.. In afghanistan which is birth place of buddha there are no buddhists left today all killed. In bangladesh there were 29% hindus today less then 6% left. Does this show that muslims are not tolerant towards others who do not follow same religion as muslims, infact muslims not even tolerant to other diversions of islam. Prince Mohammed bin salman of Saudi 6 months ago gave an interview where he said Saudi was asked by west to fantasize and brainwash Muslims in south east Asia, he acknowledged that Saudi did do the task as requested by west. Do you thinks 90% muslims are not following quran or preachings of prophet mohammed they are following saudi arabia version of salafi or wahhabi islam which is not quite the Kashmiri muslims where even sunni and shia muslims exists have done exodus of hindus, killed them and destroyed their temples. So does it make it all right if non muslims do to muslims as muslims done to them. How will you like it if 80 million muslims killed by hindus in the name of religion as muslims done to them, how will you like it is 390 million non-muslims kill muslims, as muslims done to them. The fact of the matter is there are no jews left in arabia once upon a time the arabia was land of jews, but now all jews are killed or forcefully converted. in afghanistan the land of buddhism but there are no buddhists alive there today, iran is land of zoroastrians, but today no zoroastrians alive there all killed or forcefully converted., in pakistan also almost no hindus and sikhs in the land of hindus and sikhs. so would you agree that non muslims and hindus have been comparatively more tolerant hence muslim population is rising in india and non muslim countries, in israel muslims are allowed in parliament and are living alongside israeli jews. same does not happen in muslim countries. It is seen that shia muslims are following the path of sunni muslims not following the prophets preachings or ahlulbayt teachings perhaps there is infiltration of yazid muslims in shia community who divert them.

[@SasukeUchiha-br1wq]

Have u ever met Shai Muslim in india . Remember owasi is also Shai muslim

[@dragonemperor5079]

@@SasukeUchiha-br1wq really?😂😂😂

[@SasukeUchiha-br1wq]

@@dragonemperor5079 then who is Owasi?? Isn't he shia? Was not Jinnah Shia??

[@juice8431]

this is some hardhitting facts

[@AbbasJaffery-qj8mv]

Labbaik ya Hussain a.s love from Hyderabad India 🇮🇳 Jai Hind Proud to Be an Indian Shia Muslim

[@divyanksinghal1173]

I like shia and sufi muslims they r peacefull and respect our culture our country we should promote that aspect of islam

[@travelsphere7402]

Fayz Pirzadeh u r wrong

[@NaseerAhmed-sc5bl]

Fayz Pirzadeh sufis are cult they are in the same boat of the shia

[@samnaqvi4868]

Bro it's not only your but our country...We are one our country is one...

[@ayesha2963]

it doesn't matter Sufi shia. majority are not Sufi shia and others the majority religios looking or not but they are nicest. its got nothing to do with shia sunni. your ignorance is bad bro

[@user-yx2kz5bd8r]

@@faizokhan187 no they are Sunni

[@touseefabbas428]

salam to shia's of india from shia's of Pakistan.

[@247_shivamkilanjar2]

@@asifanwarsajid8332 unless y'all stop mistreating Shias and call them kafir

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

Now this is how it should be brotherhood between all shia regardless which country they are from

[@logic1137]

Wa

[@haydayalltime6260]

Wa alaikum aslam.

[@shehrozrajput9174]

​@@247_shivamkilanjar2 stop killing Dalits and kashtrya Hindus stop calling them lower cast and untouchable, stop hating prophet Mohammad and Jesus Christ . Stop calling them converted. Stop being racist towards abrahmic religions. Provide justice to Sikhs who killed in 1984 in India . Provide justice to Kashmiri Hindus and Muslims. Provide justice to Gujarati Shia's and sunni's Muslims . Stop killing Muslims in utharpardesh , Gujarat , haryana , uthrakand, Maharashtra , Dravidanadu and north east India .

[@manojsainathreddy9515]

we hindus love our shia and sufi brothers.

[@yashraviraj2808]

also yazidi

[@muhammadk9081]

Because you can relate to their beliefs

[@anzar_imam_9]

We too love you.♥️

[@pobilisehristikrist2292]

Muhammad Kamran Anwar Hindus probably see in shiism some sort of politeism and they (hindus) are arch enemies of sunnis in general and Pakistan in paticular.

[@TWOCOWS1]

And the Shia love you. Too sad that not so the Sunni or the jihadi Wahhabis/Salafis. pity

[@loyafghanistan9587]

india is real great country..besides some riot..muslims of all sect living in peace in india although it not islamic country.look out other islamic country there are lot sect violance between us...hope my country become heaven for my people..peace on all humanity

[@divyasingh4505]

Peace ^_^

[@salmanj786]

Muslims live in terrible conditions in the Hindutva-inspired country of Afghanistan's masters. Just do some google search. An example: "Is Modi’s India Safe for Muslims?" foreignpolicy.com/2015/06/26/narendra-modi-india-safe-for-muslims-hindu-nationalism-bjp-rss/

[@sadenb]

It's probably because the Hindus are mostly pluralistic

[@hs6736]

english p india has a dalit president , a dalit prime minister , what more do you want ? we have come a long way, but to be honest yes there is still some rift between the various castes but it is more about political power rather than casteism. it is about rich vs poor today , in places where dalits are powerful they also do atrocities on the brahmins,rajputs , vaishya or even other dalits. please update your knowledge if you are Indian. if you are Pakistani - bhaagg chutiye , gand dhone k liye pani ni milta inke logoon ko , bacchon ko prostitution krva rhe h - charsi bna diya aur ye india p ungli utha rhee hain . ek kaam kr muh uppar kr aur thook aasman p . any other countries - please read my description , we still have problems but we'll solve them - casteism is non existent in major metropolitan cities and dying down all over india.

[@k-atrending940]

Bcoz majority are hindus

[@pedramriahi3372]

woow. I'm from IRAN. I've never known there are Shia in India. my deep love and respect to all of them

[@12345678939630]

India has the second largest population of shias after iran

[@ayesha2963]

WHY do it matter. in REAL islam its HARAM to create separate sects . try learning rEAl islam. Also no such thing as SHIA. Hazrat ALi , Nabi Muhammad NONE were so called SHIA. its manmade by non muslims to divide power hungry who want high positions as clerics to stay rich and brainwash you sheep to think that devote unchanged original mulsims sunnis are not when they sunnis are most unchanged muslims closest to Nabi Muhammad and Ali. Ali was NO shia. iran was NEVER SHIA until much later after some foreign tribe of Caucasus Azerbaijan who wanted power and he along with NON muslims created SHia sect so called to make people think that this tribe is best to rule. and in india long before the Prophets Ahlul Bhayt came to India even before Muhammad bin Qasim the hindus certain cities converted to Islam because they saw splitting of the moon and other places because many Sahabas very good heart oldest first muslims from Saudi ARabia yemen who were LAST PROPHET BY ALLAH Nabi Muhammad they were HIS companions came to cities in india and told the indian hindus about Islam and so they converted. this is all long before Ahlul BHayt came to India. also at least several of oldest masjids after Saudi ARabi masjids like Kaba, masjid Nabawi and oldest masjids mosques are in INDIA not other countires. also even today it doesn't matter to REAL actual honest muslims as to who what sect so called muslims belong to . stop your niggardly jahil sectarianism !!!

[@tusharjain1801]

Still you support Pakistan where, ever year Shia Muslim are persecuted.

[@12345678939630]

@@tusharjain1801 no shia of any other place supports pakistan. But you as an Indian please stop comparing pakistan with India. In India if any crime against the minority is committed justice is served. In Pakistan many shia clerics have been killed and their masjids are bombed every year no hearing no condemnation no action nothing.

[@user-yx2kz5bd8r]

@@12345678939630 but indian Muslim mostly following Sunni

[@7sn520]

respect from bahrain shia to india shia

[@sayedsamadabbasjafri4713]

I also love you From india Stay safe

[@qatarimapping3810]

What about Sunni ?

[@7sn520]

@@qatarimapping3810 i love sunni but i hate Wahabi takfiri

[@qatarimapping3810]

@@7sn520 we all are Muslim except wahabbis

[@7sn520]

@@qatarimapping3810 Yes. ❤️🥰

[@upanshudutt3557]

Shias are very nice as they worship peacefully as well as they don't force others that's a true religion

[@hilariousharry3470]

Thankyou brother!

[@alimehdi4322]

proud to be Indian : the only land where the family of prophet can live safely. my love for the nation and respect for hindu brothers always increases whenever I read the history of shia islam. our brothers must proud on their ancestors that they have develop such a dynamic culture which has the capacity to save other cultures too. this is the unique example and world even the Muslims countries should learn from this.

[@gouravdash]

One of the best comments I have ever come across here.

[@faatimahsmk6661]

Ali Mehdi I don't think so other Muslim country accept it brother because they r majority sunni followers...n even they said Shia in India lack in knowledge of Islam.

[@brainchod2383]

Ali Mehdi chal theek h Teri desh bhakti ka ek test! bol AURANGZEB KUTTA, BABAR KUTTA, TAIMOOR KUTA, KHILJI KUTTA, OWAISI KUTTA, ZAKIR NAIK KUTTA AUR JINNAH SUAR! BOL HINDU KI JAI, HINDUTV KI JAI! BOL SHUKRIYA HINDU MUJHE PANAH DENE KE LIYE!

[@brainchod2383]

Ali Mehdi rehne de 10 minute ho gaye! tujhse nhi hoga! mujhe maar de jaan se! kaat de hinduo ko! apne purwaj RAAM ka Mandir todne wale ko hero maanta h! bol KUTTA RAAM! bol KUTTA KRISHNA! BOL KUTTA HINDU AUR SUAR HINDUTW! DIKHA KITNA JIHAAD BHARA H TUJHME!

[@alimehdi4322]

Brain Chod Bhai to sach m brain chod hi hai me Muslim hu issliye aesa nhi Kr sakta. ye quran Sharif k khilaaf hai

[@travelerineu4544]

in Pakistan in Afghanistan every year around 4000 shias killed . nevertheless those are Muslim country..but in india all shias are safe .i love india

[@PINTUKUMAR-um5hs]

Because Hindu is majority in India. Hindus are innocent people. Our book teach us humanity. Sanatan religion is great. Long live!

[@bioshock7459]

Hafiz Kaderi i am a shia from pakistan and i am a proud pakistani

[@mirzaeffendi5405]

bro ur wrong in kashmir in gujrat many shias wer killed

[@hamidnoori4257]

Muslims are being killed in eating for eating beef 🥩

[@lulsec]

@@hamidnoori4257 because beef is banned in India , if I draw the pictures of mohumad will you let me live in Pakistan

[@gilgit110]

Such a beautiful documentary on Indian Shia Muslims... And their contribution in building the Indian cultural, historical and architectural heritage... I wish, I was living in the united India visiting every corner of India. Much love and respect from Gilgit Baltistan. ❤

[@Robin-il4ev]

United india is a distant dream as if now atleast , hearts have been occupied by hate thanks to internet and Radicalisation . But still you can visit India , You are most welcome .

[@syednaqvimyvideos6143]

Proud to be an indian ...and I am proud to be a shia muslim ..

[@Aloksharma-oe1gm]

Bhai kya difference hai dono mei

[@Therealhamidreza]

Take care brother ❤️ From Iran

[@samip3124]

Love to Shia's from Hindus ❤

[@dalinaik9996]

Shia hindu sikh christian we are true desh bkts Love

[@ImamReza8]

मेरा दिल मुझे मशहद अल-रज़ा ले जाने के लिए उत्सुक है

[@mahakalkabhakt8737]

East or west shia is Best I am hindu but I love shia Muslims

[@cortex3334]

india zindabad Thanks Bro "People are of two types, they are either your brothers in faith or your equals in humanity". Ali ibn abi Talib

[@ajazahmadbanday4383]

I am Suni from indian Kashmir . I also love Shias by Heart May this Sect florish in Sub Continent.

[@raufsalmanov3141]

İ say SALAM ALEYKUM VA RAHMATULLAHU VA BARAKATU from Azerbaijan to my all shia brothers and sisters

[@sunniareourbrothers.8888]

Rauf Salmanov @walekum ASSALAM

[@NiidaanFoundation4India]

Alhamdulliah proud to be a shia & an Indian. The best place in the whole world for any religion. Jaihind.

[@sindhiuk]

The Hindu King who sheltered Syeds in Sindh was no one but great Maharaja Dahir. Proud of my Dharti Sindh.

[@Himanshu-hq8og]

Aur fir usi Sindh se hindu bhaagaye gye

[@bapupanda5760]

@@Himanshu-hq8og sunni arab nei yah kiya na ki shia arab nei

[@ramesh6177]

And out of respect they raped his daughters ...

[@pinkneanderthal4456]

@@ramesh6177 the Syeds didnt Bin Qasim did

[@blacksheep6174]

Fake Theory

[@shivanisharma175]

Yes even my shia friends are more liberal , peace loving, educated , open minded, with no such relation to wahabism , zihad unlike others... luv u shias..

[@mumtazhussain8694]

Shivani Sharma thanks bro from 🇵🇰💚💙

[@mohdilyasgmt7838]

Thank you very much dear Shivani sister.. Love u people... From an Indian Shia from Kargil.

[@aniksinha6409]

@@mohdilyasgmt7838 can u tell me are kashmiri people sunni or wahabi ??

[@mohdilyasgmt7838]

Shivani ji.... Kashmir has diverse culture,,,, in Kashmir Valley,,, people are mostly Sunnis..there are almost 20%shias in valley... Rest 80% is Sunni ore may be Wahabis too.. But if u see in Ladakh particularly in my district Kargil we are 80% Shias.. We have Buddhists and Sunnis too... Comparatively leads 10-15%... We love them all... We have two tiny and Lovely Sikh families too...

[@aniksinha6409]

@@mohdilyasgmt7838 that's why i have never seen anti india movement in kargil. Shias are progressive unlike sunnis or wahabis

[@sigmarule1779]

Shias don't kill people in the name of religion like sunnis or wahabies ..They are peaceful people..They beat up or whip themselves to mourn the pathetic death of Prophet Muhammad's grandsons..Love Shias ..Love Hassan and Hussain..

[@dominoreal3125]

James lol I guess you are blinded then..cuz there are a lot of killings carried about by shias in Iraq.

[@user-xw8sp9vp2d]

Domino Real source?

[@dominoreal3125]

Where's your source that shias don't kill?

[@mxhsvn_b7866]

Domino Real where's your source that Shias kill?

[@shadmansaqib9022]

James , then what's hizbullah militia? what's Iran? lol. search about Iranian balochs who are dominant Sunnis. their area is underdeveloped just because of being Sunni. I'm a Sunni Muslim. I admit that shias are tortured where they're minors and feel sorry for that. but you can't deny the tortured Sunni people's conditions. stand for justice. and one has already told about Iraq in the reply.

[@Moonitot]

Shia muslims are peaceful and respect all religion's ❤🙏

[@touqeershah484]

Very good ☆☆☆☆☆ I m shia from pakistan I wish to go india

[@mahakalkabhakt8737]

Touqeer Shah yes bro shia Muslims ka welcome h yeh India jitna hinduo ka h utna shia Muslims ka shia Muslims India ke ley bhut kiya h hm Hindu h but I love shia brothers

[@govindindurkar3100]

not welcome

[@religiousfatigue3700]

Good luck getting the visa

[@7_years_and_]

why. Are you not safe in pakistan ?

[@sagdwi3340]

Touqeer Shah bro welcome...take all Shias from Pakistan come here but plz send wahabi Sunnis from here to Pakistan so that they bomb each other out and not Shias Christians and Hindus

[@saudpasha8032]

I'm sunni but i love shia people bcz they are lover's of ahlul bait

[@javeedthewellnesscoach7091]

They are the lovers of Ahlul bait but at the same they are the hater of Khulafa and ummahatul momineen. What do you have to say now?

[@sharifkhan9370]

@@javeedthewellnesscoach7091 sahi bola aap nai

[@MohammedAli-jl9zb]

We sunni are also lover of ahle bait

[@reyhanerezaee6042]

@@javeedthewellnesscoach7091 becuz khulafa weren't in true path of Islam they did many bad things toward bibi zahra and imam Ali(as)

[@javeedthewellnesscoach7091]

@@reyhanerezaee6042 if they weren't on the right path, then why Ali raziallahhuann kept his children's names as Abu Bakr, Umar and Usman raziallahhuann

[@arshadabbas544]

proud to be indian proud to be shia jai hind 💖💖😊

[@kailasa-rr1xr]

हिन्दू और सिया मिलकर देश के गद्दारो और आतंकियों से निपटना जानते हैं।

[@impossiblestuff3983]

Love u from Indian hindu

[@datz_alive]

Yes RSS aur BJP ke Bhagwa Atankiyo Chun chun ke marenge. I Am shia ne Ali

[@nadaanparinda688]

@@datz_alive Ansari kab se Shia hone Lage🤣🤣🤣 chutiye

[@jenniferkoyu8020]

Jai hind

[@anandhindu2804]

it is the greatness of Hinduism n Hindus that we accept everyone, not based on their religion, just seeing n believing we are all human beings........ Jai Hind.... Jai Bharat,,,,,,,,

[@winstonbachan4296]

andy joe GOOD THINKING

[@scmfrmanzil]

andy joe jai hind jai bharat

[@rashadshahzad8186]

andy joe yes you have proved that in gujrat

[@malmalhi007]

so does fear... Muslims have become more radicalised in the last 25 years.. india has already been split because Muslims cannot live with the rest.. India will never be split on religion lines again and if Muslims demand another country there will be a bloodbath.. so tolerance has to be met with tolerance... Muslims should not over produce children to try and create a Muslim majority.. even Muslims cannot live with Muslims in a Muslim state...

[@petitwhite6366]

Ask the Dalit of India if they feel accepted or discriminated.

[@syednasir4800]

Hindu ek azeem qaom he his ne hum ko hind me jagha di, hamari jaan maal izzat ki hifazat ki, ae Hindu qaom mera slaam ap ko,

[@kushmishra2421]

Love you so much brother.😍😍

[@saregamasaregama7387]

Love you bhai

[@Aijaz2929]

@@kushmishra2421 Love you too brother

[@subratabhattacharya7983]

Love from a Bengali Hindu♥️.

[@chahatalizaidi4290]

I love hindu so much ...but andhbhakt ,🤷🤷

[@feliper5463]

In love with the Shia of the whole world Labbayk Ya Hussain

[@salmanhyder6053]

Jai Hind !!! Mera Bharat Mahan. Salamat rahen saara Hindustan.

[@ManishGupta-yr3cc]

@RealDeal441 idiot

[@shubhamsaxena7726]

Thnx apna BHARAT MAHAN THA HAI AUR RAHEGAA 🇮🇳 💪 #countrystrong....

[@nayanmishra9011]

Hm khare hai tumhre liye, tum isi miiti ke ho mai v, hm ek hai religion ko bhul ja, ek sec ke liye tumhre liye mere jaise croro hai hm tumhara raksha krenge situation kuch v ho hm tumhari hi nhi kisi v non hindu ki raksha krenge chahe meri hmri jaan chali jaaye.... yahi hm sab ka culture h tra v mera v yahi to bharata h hmara Hm tumko ya kisi ko nuksan nhi pohochna chate but hinduo me sath sautela vyavahar ho tha tha hm tum ek sath ayenge and mai bolta hu tu khush reh tri Khushi ke liye in shah allah jaan laga dege.....bas yad kar lena apne Hindu bhaiyo ko is desh ke kisi v kone se........ Tra chota bra jo man bhai muzaffarpur bihar se

[@rohitsardna4841]

I am working for an ngo...I work for shia culture ...I cant explain the peace I feel in shia mosque..and Hussein we love you..need your courage and bravery...indeed Islam is peace just feel your inner heart..its like when I meditate in my holy temple

[@syedtabreznawabsoflucknow5528]

Thanks brother from a Shia

[@AhmedTuri1]

Excellent documentary on India's Shia population. Great contribution by Imran Imam. Thank all those who participated and produced this documentary.

[@mirzaeffendi5405]

Ahmed Turi bro ur frm pak ryt

[@yawaralimirza8052]

Documentary is showing the historical status of Shias.Current status is very pathetic and the Shias are not even able to assess it.Unable to differentiate between lakh & million.

[@AhmedTuri1]

@@yawaralimirza8052 agree some how.

[@mastmaula6175]

Love and respect to our shia brothers and sisters. Hindu shia dosti zindabad. Labbaik ya Hussein. Jai hind

[@hameed9653]

Jinnah wouldnt agree with your "Hindu shia dosti'

[@mariavontrapp8346]

Hameedur Rahman oh aye? He was a Shia and only intended it to allow everyone to have opportunity of work not turning it to a Sunni state even his family later feared persecution and denounced him as Shia but he was a born Shia and a lover of social justice and did not want this to happen what the Sunnis did. He was a regular frequenter of spending time with Ghandi and respect and Gandhi proved to be a better Shia till death a lover of the selfless sacrifice of imam Hussein and won victory for India and in turn Pakistan due to adopting the none violent methods of imam Hussein go learn world history. Your lack of knowledge betrays your stupidity. Jinnah was no Sunni Muslim.

[@mastmaula6175]

@RealDeal441 Off course all good people will be on same side that day and evil ppl will be jealous of them as ever

[@mastmaula6175]

@@hameed9653 who is Jinnah? An Ayatollah or Imam.He was just a politician

[@wardak9554]

whos that on your prof pic

[@anzar_imam_9]

Strange is it, one who are Muslims do not consider Shias as Muslims, but those who are not Muslims, they consider only us to be true Muslim. ☮️

[@Robin-il4ev]

That's the reason Shias are more safe in India than in Pakistan. Even in pre-independence era Hindus supported Shia processions unlike Sunnis. We don't hate Muslims we hate Radical islam who Can't coexist with other faiths

[@singhrajput6949]

Because Shias are peaceful people,they know how to give respect to other religions

[@anirudhvenugopal1386]

As a Hindu, i feel Shias follows the real principle of Imam Hussain and Prophet Mohammad and contribute to the development of the country and are always ready to help others in case of any emergency. And last thing, never judge others on basis of their faith

[@mairajasadsayed2505]

Amazing documentary..! this has cleared many thoughts of how Shia Sada't migrated here in India.....its a privilege to live in India..Jazakallah..!!

[@THERIGHTEOUS]

Animesh Das no no..before Muslim invasion India was not suitable for dalits and backwards.After Muslim invaded INDIA THEY TOUGHT brahmin and thakurs how to deal with everyone in a friendly manner.

[@THERIGHTEOUS]

Animesh Das Mohammad(saw) is one of the greatest lawgiver of the world out of 18 lawgiver honoured by USA IN 1935.Most laws which Indian constitution uses was invented by mohammad(saw).Michael h hart in his book also put mohammad(saw) over everyone saying he was a religious as well as secular leader.

[@THERIGHTEOUS]

Animesh Das Shias were more powerful then Sunnis.Humayun was a shia,Aurangzeb was a shia.Sayyid brothers were shias who were credited by mughals as the best warrior because of whom INDIA WAS gained by MUGHALS.Go and learn some history INDIAN shias don't know the history hahahaha I can go on.

[@THERIGHTEOUS]

***** MOHAAMMAD(SAW) IS THE GREATEST LAWGIVER OF THE WORLD HONOURED BY USA SUPREME COURT IN 1935 .STUPID people don't know anything.

[@Peraj82]

Get a life idiot

[@syedjafferimam5789]

Salaam Ya Hussain a.s A PROUD RIZVI SHIA from India.

[@aliqasim9157]

India is one of the most tolerant, generous, and hospitable places in this world except for Yogi Adityanath.

[@loyafghanistan9587]

yes bro...

[@vaishakhpv13393]

yea good for you !! dont migrate here

[@winstonbachan4296]

+PureNT Shit can also be in the mind of Fools like you!

[@winstonbachan4296]

+PureNT Because all fool's has The Abilities to Judge Without Umderstanding

[@winstonbachan4296]

+PureNT the middle class Indians are the population of Pakistan Europe and America Combined. That's Power don't you think so. based on Economics

[@alijarallah8699]

♥️All shia ♥️FROM IRAQ 🇮🇶

[@sahilabbas123]

proud to be shia n proud to be indian ... 👌👍 nice documentary

[@brainchod2383]

sahil abbas Teri desh bhakti ka ek test! bol AURANGZEB KUTTA, BABAR KUTTA, TAIMOOR KUTA, AKHBAR KUTTA, KHILJI KUTTA AUR JINNAH SUAR! JIS HINDU NE PALA USS HINDU KO MAARNE WALE MUGHALO KI MAA KI CHOOT! BHARAT MATA KI JAI BOLNA MATT BHOOLNA END ME!

[@brainchod2383]

sahil abbas bol HINDU KI JAI! HINDUTV KI JAI! SHUKRIYA MUJHE PANAH DENE KI! MAIN TUMHARA EHSAAN KABHI NHI BHOOLUNGA!

[@rythymdivine]

Dr. Brain Chod, Are you Supreme court of India ? Now you are gonna decide ? Anyways, chanting Jai Hind is not what makes you an Indian, feeling and associating yourself with it makes you 1.

[@bekaradami6178]

I like that you're an Indian. We need more people like you. God Bless you my Shia Brother.

[@kalsangboztemir7962]

you are so filled with hate. I pity you. are you really a muslim or just in name only

[@nishanthparamesh2310]

Shiaism is very peaceful sadly only few countries adopt it in India they are safe because of Hindu brothers ready to protect them

[@almasifar4110]

Thank you brothers luv u all

[@aatifa_z]

Thankyou so much ❤ we really feel safe with hindu people more then some sunni who consider us kafir !!

[@Prophetteachings]

@@aatifa_z kafir ????😅😂😂😂

[@sajjadzaheer8136]

We shias are not narrow minded (our heart is open to ALL)

[@Jvs-eq3iy]

That is why Shias are even more enthusiastic about conversion of the Hindus to Islam.

[@SWAPNESH23]

I love Shia Muslim brothers and Sisters ❤ they respect other cultures

[@muhammadabdullah-qf8ro]

ASSALAMUALAIKUM I am Shiite from Jakarta Indonesia. Shiite came to Indonesia about 1000 years ago, I want to know which part of India who came to Indonesia ?

[@shukran3907]

may allah protect you brother, I know you don't have it easy in Indonesia

[@Nzjeufbdjsuehdbdkdlsm]

Maybe from NORTH EAST India 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 Joke

[@username-ht9vx]

Gujarat

[@jaffrisaab]

Brilliant work. My Father shares his childhood memories of Azadari at Shaheed e Thalith's Shrine in Agra .Thanks for Showing Mazar e Shaheed e Thalith(Reh). I wish i could come to India once to pay homage on his shrine. JazakAllah

[@harishcet04]

Very nice documentary. I knew that India had been a safe haven for communities like the Jews & Zorastrians (Parsis) who fled their homeland due to persecution, but didn't knew that even Shia community also sought refuge in India. The way Shias and Ahmeddiyas are persecuted in Muslim nations like Pakistan, India is undoubtedly one of the safest country not only for minorities but also for the minorities within the minorities. Long live India

[@zaqiyumani3245]

Harish Shanker fuck India ... they kept killing us. now we are in every corner of the planet. your enemy will be abtur. surah Kuthur...

[@troytomohenjodaro]

India is Holy land

[@amishsurani4765]

Indonesia Malaysia gulf countries are secular

[@mjnon4936]

Shia in iarq❤🇮🇶❤🇮🇳

[@baryalirahimi3849]

Good bless Indian Shia from Iran

[@Nzjeufbdjsuehdbdkdlsm]

And they say we hate Muslim. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Good to us.... We will be good to you.... If you betray us..... We will fooook you up..... Plain and simple..

[@Naturalvideosofindia]

love from kashmir .... I ❤ my religion shia...never ending religion....peace full religion...

[@ara..edits.....4019]

Shia killed imam hussian ra

[@adamkhan8723]

@@ara..edits.....4019why didn’t Sunnis save him them? Why did Sunnis just watch him (as) being killed by shias? Are they both equally the culprits ?

[@IrshadAli-qs5fh]

​@@ara..edits.....4019no Shia don't kill Imam 3 dog of Islam betrayed Imam you know your omar usman abubakar par bashumar lanat lanat lanat.........

[@asgharvlogs786]

I proud to be indian Shia.. please protect all Shias..

[@alijarallah8699]

♥️shia ♥️

[@Nzjeufbdjsuehdbdkdlsm]

From who?😂😂

[@dalinaik9996]

Shia hindu sikh christian Are true desh bkt

[@stunna6389]

@@Nzjeufbdjsuehdbdkdlsm from sunni extremists

[@neofive517]

in my 7 years research of islam I claim to this matter that only perfect shia of imam ali is true Muslim because imam ali and his families(ahalabat) had powerful personality and POwer of God. they do like Justice so I see in all the world that any shia Muslim do not kill other muslim on the name of islam. shia is very peaceful china. I am impressed the personality of imam ali.

[@ajazshah9693]

Neo Five respect for you sir please read mula Ali a.s ..letters the book name is nehjul balagha

[@abdulgaffar1011]

Who was the first shia in the world

[@salimahmad2914]

Those who seek know . Very true brother.

[@ambar94]

Neo Five absolutely right !!!

[@dragonemperor5079]

@@abdulgaffar1011 slmkm bro.the first shia was janab e Aadam a.s because he prayed to grant him forgiveness by reciting the names of ehlebaith..panjetan paak.Allah granted him forgiveness becoz of Aadam a.s's love for ehlebaith

[@haidarnaqvi3842]

I m Shia nice documentary I love my india jai hind

[@Nzjeufbdjsuehdbdkdlsm]

Hell nah! Aren't you the same RIOTERS who throw stones to people ? Don't lie 😂😂😂😂

[@ZawarHussaincomrade]

very informative documentary . Lot of LOVE for all indian shias from LHR .

[@mohsenmajlise618]

Proud to be a Indian shia Hindu Shia brothers Jai Hind

[@pallavibarman6214]

❤️

[@alirizwan5889]

This documentary has shown a glimpse my roots and my ancestry. The great depictions, diligent storyline and a soothing narration has left me teary eyed.

[@amankumar-xk8je]

I am from lucknow,here mostly are shias,very nice people just like us

[@sadenb]

As a hindu , I want to see Shia build a huge mosque of brilliant architecture that can also represent their religion . Like we have a great Gurudwara , amazing temples , even the sunnis have. I hope beautiful mosque worthy of being an emblem of India is made. Similar to the level of Akshardham in new delhi . I have no hate for any muslim who love India and wan't to be liberal and keep religion personal .

[@yungdaku212]

sanch Sanchayan there is the bara imambara in Lucknow

[@sadenb]

Yea but that is of old times. I want to see a contemporary one .

[@Husaingr]

There are huge mosques in gujarat built by shias.... And not less than 500 mosques

[@yawaralimirza8052]

@@Husaingr How many are functioning out of 500?What is Shia population in Gujarat State?

[@Husaingr]

@@yawaralimirza8052 bahot hai bhai mere ghar ke paas hi 5 hai in vadodara

[@al-hassan9200]

greetings from Baghdad 💛🧡

[@reyhanerezaee6042]

Actually I'm Indian but I grew up in Iran ❤Proud to be an Indian (isna ashari)shia❤

[@soupisfun1239]

I am so so proud of my Hindu brothers, you guys literally co existed peacefully with every community, asal dharam toh yehi hay!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ Although I am not Shia anymore, Im agnostic, but i come from a shia background, and my anscestors were hindus, i am so glad to know that these two communities have lived peacefully.

[@cordedcandle1756]

Just because you said you're agnostic and you come from a shia background, if you don't mind, can i recommend you a book?

[@soupisfun1239]

@@cordedcandle1756 um yeah, why not?

[@dominancepreserved8749]

@@soupisfun1239 yo! @Corded Candle here. I actually lost that account of mine. Sure here we go, I'd post link of two good books regarding tawheed (oneness of God). Before that, I'd like to post few sermons by the Holy Ahlulbayt (pbut) regarding tahweed as well, please do read them as well.

[@dominancepreserved8749]

*Imam Ali Al Riza's (a) (8th Imam) Sermon On The Unity/Oneness Of God* Al-Ma’mun (May God Curse him) sent someone after him and he came. The Hashemites told him, “O Abul Hasan (Imam Riza)! Climb up the pulpit and display for us a sign whereby we may worship God.” So he (a) climbed up the pulpit and sat there for a long time with his head bowed down in silence. Then he trembled - a great trembling - and stood up straight, praised the Sublime God, and recited God’s praises and asked for His blessing for His Prophet and the Members of the Holy Household. Then he (a) said, “The first element in the worship of the Sublime God is His recognition. The root of recognition of God is to profess to His Unity. The order for professing the Unity of God is to deny He has any attributes, since the powers of reasoning testify that every attribute and everything which possesses an attribute are created. Everything that is created testifies that it has a Creator which is neither an attribute nor does it possess any attributes. Every attribute and everything possessing an attribute testify to the association between the attribute and that to which it is attributed. Any association testifies to temporality. And temporality testifies that it accepts not the Beginningless which accepts not the temporal. So it is not God whose Essence is recognized through striking similitude. It is not His Unity that is professed by someone who attempts to fathom Him. It is not His reality (haqiqa) that is attained by someone who strikes a similitude for Him. It is not He who is confirmed (tasdiq) by him who professes an end for Him. If one points to Him, it is not God that is pointed to. It is not He who is meant by him who compares Him (to something). It one ascribes parts to God, he has not indeed humbled himself in the presence of God. And it is not God who is desired by one who conceives of God in his imagination. Everything that can be known in itself is fashioned. All that stands apart from Him is an effect. God is inferred from what He fashions, the recognition of Him is expedited by the powers of reasoning, and the argument for Him is established by (man's) primordial nature. God's creating of the creatures is a veil between Him and them. His separation (mubayana) from them is due to the fact that He is disengaged from their localization. That He is their origin is proof for them that He has no origin, for none that has an origin can originate others. That He has created them possessing means (of accomplishing things) is proof that He has no means (adapt) for means are witness to the poverty of those who use them. So His names are an expression, His acts are (a way) to make (Him) understood, and His Essence is Reality. His innermost center separates Him from Creation, and His otherness limits what is other than Him. Therefore ignorant of God is he who asks for Him to be described!Transgressing against Him is he who seeks to encompass Him!Mistaken is he who imagines to have fathomed Him! Whoever asks 'how?' has compared Him (to something). Whoever says 'why?' has professed for Him a cause. Whoever says 'when?' has determined Him in time. Whoever says 'in what?' has enclosed Him. Whoever says 'to what?' has professed for Him a limit. Whoever says 'until what?' has given Him an end. Whoever gives Him an end has associated an end with Him. Whoever associates an end with Him has divided Him. Whoever divides Him has described Him. Whoever describes Him has deviated from the straight path concerning Him. God does not change with the changes undergone by Creation, just as He does not become limited by delimiting that which is limited. He is One, not according to the explanation offered by number; Outward, not according to the explanation of being immediate (to the senses); Manifest, not through the appearance of a vision (of Him); Inward, not through separation; Apart, not through distance; Near, not through approach; Subtle, not through corporealness; Existent, not after nonexistence; Active, not through coercion; Determining, not through the activity of thought; Directing, not through movement; Desiring, not through resolution; Willing, not through directing attention; Grasping, not through touch; Hearing, not through means; and Seeing, not through organs.Times accompany Him not, places enclose Him not, slumber seizes Him not, attributes delimit Him not, and instruments are of no use to Him. His Being precedes time, His Existence precedes non-existence and His Beginninglessness precedes beginning. By His giving sense to the sense organs it is known that He has no sense organs. By His giving substance to substances it is known that He has no substance. By His causing opposition among things it is known that He has no opposite. By His causing affiliation among affairs it is known that He has no affiliate. He made darkness opposite to light, obscurity to clarity, moisture to dryness, and heat to cold. He joins together those things which are in total contradiction with one another and separates those which are near. They prove (the existence of) their Separator by their separation and their Joiner by their junction. That is (the meaning of) the Sublime (God’s) words, ‘And of every thing We have created pairs: That ye may receive instruction.’ So through them He separated 'before' and 'after' that it might be known that He has no before and after. They testify with their temperaments that He who gave them temperaments has no temperament. They prove by their disparity that He who made them disparate has no disparity. They announce by their subjection to time that He who subjected them to time is not subject to it Himself. He veiled some of them from others, so that it might be known that there is no veil between Him and them other than them. His is the true meaning of lordship when there was none over whom He was Lord; the reality of Godhood when there was nothing for whom He was God; the true meaning of All-Knower when there was nothing to be known; the true meaning of m Creator when there was nothing created and the interpreter of hearing when there was nothing to be heard. It is not because He created that which makes Him deserve the true meaning (of the term) 'Creator' and not because He brought the creatures into being that the true meaning of 'making' is derived. How (could it not be so)? For using such words as ‘ago’ conceals Him not, 'already' brings Him not near, ‘perhaps’ veils Him not, 'when' limits Him not in time, 'at the time of' contains Him not, and 'with' associates Him not. Instruments limit only themselves and means are only effective upon other similar means. Their activities are found only in things. The word ‘ago’ keeps things from being eternal; the word 'already' shields them from beginninglessness; and the words 'if only' wards off perfection. Things become separate and thus they prove (the existence of) their Separator. They become distinguished and thus they prove their Distinguisher Through them their Maker manifests Himself to the powers of reasoning, and He becomes veiled to the sight through these powers. To these powers of reasoning imaginations appeal for a decision. And in them is substantiated (only) other than Him. From them is suspended the proof and through them He has revealed to them the acknowledgement of His Unity. Confirmation of God is made fast by the powers of reasoning, and faith in Him attains perfection through acknowledgment. There is no religiousness except after recognition, no knowledge except through sincerity and no sincerity along with striking similitude. If one ascribes attributes for God, then he has indeed drawn a similitude. So nothing in Creation is found in its Creator. All that is possible in it is impossible in its Maker. Movement and stillness do not affect Him. How should that which He affects (in others) have any effect upon Him, or that which He has originated recur for Him?Then His Essence would be disparate, His innermost center would be divided and His being Eternal would become an impossibility. How would then the Creator have a meaning different from the created? If something from behind limited Him, then something in front would limit Him. If perfection were seeking Him, imperfection would be upon Him. How should that which does not transcend temporality be worthy of (the Name) 'Beginningless'? How should that which does not transcend being produced, produce the things (of the world)?There they would have arisen in Him a sign of having been made and He would become a proof after having been the proven. There is no argument in absurd opinions; there is no answer when it (absurdity) is asked about; and there is no glorification of Him in its meaning. Nor is there any absurdity in distinguishing Him from Creation, unless it be that the Independent accepts not to be made into two, nor does the Beginningless accepts to have a beginning. There is no god but God, the All-High, and the Tremendous. They have cried lies that ascribe equals to God! They have gone astray into farreaching error and suffered a manifest loss!May God’s Blessings be upon Muhammad and his Pure Household. Uyoon Akhbaar Imam Al Riza (a) vol.1 p.142

[@dominancepreserved8749]

*Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (a) Refutes The Dualists* A dualist came to Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh). Among the things Imam Ja'far Al Saadiq (pbuh) said to him was: If you claim that “there are two (gods)” there can only be three possibilities. One: that both gods are eternal and all-powerful. Two: that both gods are weak. Or three: that on of them is all-powerful, and the other one is weak. Now, if both of them are powerful, then why doesn’t one of them overthrow the other, and mange all affairs single-handedly? If you believe that one of them is powerful, and the other one weak, then you have proved that He is One, and to the apparent inability of the second. And if you say that “they are two,” then only two things are possible: one, that they are both united in all aspects; or two, that they are separate in all aspects. However, when we contemplate the organization in creation, the orbits of the planets in the celestial sphere, the variation of day and night, the sun and the moon, and how everything operate in harmony, everything points that he Manager is One. Furthermore, if you claim that there are two gods, there must be a division between them both which has always existed, and that division would have to be a third god. However, if your claim that there are three gods, then there must be two divisions between them, leaving us with five gods, and so on add aeterum. Hisham (the Narrator) said: The dualist then questioned him until he asked, “What is the proof of His Existence? Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) replied, “The existence of great wonders is proof that they were created by the creator. When you see the imposing structure of building, you know instinctively that it was built by someone, even though you did not see him build it. He enquired, “What is He?” The Imam (pbuh) explained, He is a thing unlike other things. Consider the word “a thing” in order to understand its implication. Since He is Real, and He Exists, He is indeed a Thing. However, He is devoid of both body and image. He is neither sensed nor felt, nor is He perceived by the five senses. The imagination perceives Him not. He is not subject to time. Time has no effect upon Him. The questioner asked, “Therefore, you are saying that `Verily, He is All-Hearing, and All-Seeing?” The Imam (pbuh) responded, He is All-Hearing, and All-Seeing. He is All-Hearing without tools, and All-Seeing, without instruments. In fact, He hears by means of His entire being and He hears by His entire being. My statement does not mean that “He hears by means of His Entire Being” in the sense that He is something, and His Being is something else. I am simply using this example in order to answer your question. I say: “He hears by means of His Entire Being” and not in the sense that He has parts. Rather, I am attempting to make myself understood. My only other option would be to say that He is All-Hearing, All-Seeing, All-Knowing, and All-Informed, in His Very Essence. The questioner questioned, “Than what is He?” Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) answered, He is the Lord. He is the Worshipped One, He is Allah. When I use the word “Allah,” I am not referring to the combination of the letters “A,” “L,” and “H”. Rather, I am pointing to its meaning. He is a thing that is the Creator of all Things, and their Manufacturer who is described by means of these letters. He is the one who is referred to by the names Allah, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful, the Honorable, among other names. He is the Worshipped One, the High and mighty. The questioner enquired, “So anything we can conceive of it created?” Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) replied: If things were as you claimed, then recognizing Divine Unity would be beyond our reach. We are not obliged to believe in what cannot be imagined. However, we say: everything we can conceive with our senses is perceived. Therefore, whatever the sense can discover and demonstrate is created. In order to prove the existence of the Creator of All Things, we must do so without recurring to two erroneous approaches: the first of which is negation, i.e. abolition [ibtal], and non-existence [`adam]; and the second is anthropomorphism, i.e. description, composition [tarkib], and formation [ta’lif]. We cannot prove the existence of the Creator on the basis of these two approaches as they are created, The Creator is not like the created. If He resembles the created, then whatever applies to the created would also apply to Him: such as coming into existence after non-existence, growth, change of color, change of strength, and so forth. The questioner said: “In attempting to prove His Existence, you have limited Him.” Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) responded, “I have not limited Him. ON the contrary, I have demonstrated His Existence through the only means possible: assertion and negation.” The questioner said: “Is His Existence real and actual?” The Imam (pbuh) replied, “Yes, His Existence is Real as nothing can be prove without being real and actual.” The questioner asked, “Does He have a shape?” The Imam (pbuh) explained, No, because shape is description that delineates. We must move away from negation and anthropomorphism Whoever negates Him, denies Him, eliminates His Lordship, and abolished Him. Whoever compares Him with other things describes Him on the basis of created attributes which are not worthy of Him. Nevertheless, we must prove His Essence without referring to shape. None is worthy of His Essence besides Him. And no one shares His Essence, encompasses it, or knows it but Him. The questioner said: “Does He sustain all things by Himself?” Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) answered, “He is far Greater than sustaining things directly as only created beings bring things forth directly. Exalted is He! His Intent and His Will are effective. He is the Mighty Doer of whatever He wills.” The questioner enquired, “Does He feel pleasure or anger?” Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) said: Yes. However, His Pleasure and His Anger differ from the pleasure and anger fund among created beings. Among created beings, pleasure and anger cause a change of state which is an attribute of the created, the incapable, and the needy. He (Allah) is the Blessed and Exalted, the Honorable, and the Most Merciful. He is not in need of His Creation, while all His Creation is in need of Him. Verily, He created all things by means of invention and innovation, without any need or cause. The questioner uttered, “Then what about His Word: The Most Compassionate is firm on the Empyrean.” Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) replied, He described Himself as such in order to convey that He is the Possessor of the Empyrean, not in the sense that the Empyrean carries the Empyrean and restrains it. And we say this because His has said: His Throne extends over the heavens and the earth. Therefore, we say of the Empyrean and the Throne what He has said: and we refute the notion that the Empyrean or the Throne contains Him as He is not in need of space or anything which He has created. On the contrary, He has created them and they are in need of Him. The questioner said: “Then what is the difference between raising your hands to heaven and lowering them towards the earth?” Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) answered, That makes no difference in His Knowledge, Encompassment, and Omnipotence, but He, the Mighty and High, commanded His Beloved Ones and His Servants to raise their hands to heaven towards the Empyrean because He made it a source of sustenance. This is proved from the Qur’an. It is also proved from the tradition of the RasoolAllah (pbuh) which says: “Raise your hands to Allah the Mighty and High.” And this is agreed upon between all the schools of thought in the Ummah. The questioner asked, “How can you prove that Allah sent Prophets and messengers?” Imam Ja'far Al-Saadiq (pbuh) explained, Verily, we have proved that we have a Creator and a Producer who is Exalted from His Creation, and that he Producer is the Most Wise. It is impossible for His Creation to see Him or touch Him. He does not contact His Creation directly nor does His Creation contact Him directly. He does not reason with them, and they do not reason with Him. Thus, this proves that He has Representatives and Servants in His Creations who guide humanity towards what is best for them. They shall be granted eternitiy if they accept guidance. And they shall face destruction if they reject guidance. Evidently, those who promote the good and forbid the evil in His Creation must have been sent by the Most Wise, the All-Knowing. This demonstrates that He has Interpreters, and they are the Prophets, the Cream of His Creation, who are men of wisdom whom He has sent to guide and educate humankind. They are human in shape, but not in nature. They are endorsed by Allah, the Most Wise, the Omniscient, with wisdom, signs, proofs, and evidence, like giving life to the dead, healing lepers, and restoring sight to the blind. Verily, Allah’s earth is never without a Proof [hujjat] (of Allah) who brings the teachings of RasoolAllah (pbuh) and who embodies justice.

[@asadabas4283]

Salute to you sir ! Amazing episodes captured in an outstanding manner. Never before has such elaborate & detailed history of Shia Muslims been presented in a documentary. The painstaking process of simplifying the intricate facets of history keeps the viewer on the edge of his seat. Scholars' & historians' views enhanced the beauty of the presentation. My compliments in their respect. Cinematography is par excellence augmented with the exceptional narration of Imran Imam. Hats off to Script Writers, Directors and Producers. My tribute to the entire team of Ahlulbayt Documentaries Channel for their great work. This was my first time watching this channel and I'm glad that I did. It has broadened my horizons. For the love of Muhammad PBUH Wa Aley Muhammad PBUH, I'm amazed at the brotherhood and fraternity between Hindus, Sikhs and Shia Muslims of India. It is a blessing to live in such peace and harmony.

[@miller0079]

Even Sunnis bro . only some people from all sides are extremists . common people live in peace in 90℅ regions of India of all faiths .

[@nishantpatar9020]

Raja Dahir is my hero.. He was the one who save my ancestors in Sindh. I am proud to be their heir... Long live Dahir..

[@ronki23]

Shias make more sense than Sunnis. I always believed that the Imam should be the relative of Muhammad. Also the likes of Osama bin Laden, Ayman Al Zawahiri, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi,etc. are Sunnis

[@lilly9972]

Long live lovers of Ahlulbayet💖 Very educational and eye opening documentary. Thank you from an Afghan Shia Muslim in USA. May Allah SWT protect those who protect Shias.

[@aunnaqvii6273]

Proud To Be Shia Of Imam ALi (A.S)...........Proud To be Pakistani ....Meri half Family India main rehti hai Lucknow main cz i love india

[@travellingwithorfee3600]

M Sunni Muslim from Lucknow

[@moebazzi2068]

I love india and I love the Hindu religion.

[@scmfrmanzil]

very detailed documentary and i am from ajmer so thanks for covering Taragarh .😃

[@rizwanaly]

I wish I knew details about Ashurkhana there earlier. I missed it when I visited Ajmer Dargah, just to pay my respects to the Shia momin Saint there... Sadly the Sunni caretaker in Dargah behaved rudely to me and pushed me to kiss the hand of a wealthy person while smiling to beg some donation.

[@zarghamabrar475]

aslam o alaikum listen plz

[@zarghamabrar475]

aslam o alaikum listen plz

[@scmfrmanzil]

Sajjad Aly will take action against khadim soon

[@yungdaku212]

ah dear brother you are lucky 😞 my life long dream is to go to ajmer sharif

[@zehrahasanzaidi110]

After 4 yrs I'm watching this documentary........great work...and .thankyou for making it on india.....very informative as well

[@mustufakerawala1796]

thank you for this wonderful documentary about shiaism in India.. Really enlightened me about the shia culture in my country which I didn't know about

[@NaseerAhmed-sc5bl]

Mustufa Kerawala beshumar allaah ki Lanat hu najis shia kafir par

[@ramprasad4936]

Mustufa Kerawala thanks brother .we also love Ali Ra

[@syedghazi67]

@@NaseerAhmed-sc5bl here's a Sunni ❤️

[@BrokenHeart-ev3st]

Long live India India always helps Iranians

[@baryalirahimi3849]

Love India from Iran

[@shubhamsaxena7726]

@@baryalirahimi3849 but why your country is supporting PAKISTAN

[@247_shivamkilanjar2]

@@shubhamsaxena7726 no it is not they're enemies Iran recently did surgical strike on Pakistan

[@Aijaz2929]

@@shubhamsaxena7726 No Iran doesn't support Pakistan

[@sunniareourbrothers.8888]

@@shubhamsaxena7726 iran always support haq right path innocent people ......and against of bad people

[@najeebullahyazdani915]

Salam from Afghanistan to all indian and my shia brothers

[@shahjehan3810]

May Shia's and Hindus be together in Akhirat , Ameen !

[@sadiqrahman8723]

Yes in Jahanaam both brothers will be there. Ahla Sunnah will be alone in Jannah . Ameen

[@shakeekahmed3798]

@@sadiqrahman8723 nice

[@ghmohidin8514]

You Sunni's to be with the killers/enemies of Hazrat Imam Hussain(As).Aameen.

[@ghmohidin8514]

@@sadiqrahman8723 you forgot ur brother's the ( Zionists)and the enemies of Ahlulbait,you love them and they are your forefathers the whole world knows you puppets can't live and rest without them in the Hell.You are the son's of muawwiya and yazeed,ur loved father's.

[@syedghazi67]

@@sadiqrahman8723 yes the ones that behead 7 year olds in the holy city of Makkah 😂

[@KashanReza]

Salam from Pakistani Syed Shia from Karachi,Pakistan

[@sayedsamadabbasjafri4713]

@Debanjan Biswas they are killed day by day

[@KashanReza]

,@Debanjan Biswas we're totally fine here yes there are problems everywhere but that doesn't mean all things are bad.

[@KashanReza]

@@sayedsamadabbasjafri4713 not true at all

[@Taqi142]

@@sayedsamadabbasjafri4713 Not true, I am from Pakistan, Shias are safe Alhumdullilah

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

salaams from UK. This is how it should be brotherhood between all shia regardless which country they are from

[@nasirhussain9883]

Salute to all persons who have contributed towards MAKING of such a beautiful and complete documentary on spread of shiasam in INDIA. I did not know about such marvelous history, the efforts which were put by Shia rulers and ulamaas to spread the teachings of Ahle Bayt(A. S). Salute to all of them. The work they had done is truly an inspiration for all of us to lead our life for the teachings of Ahle Bayt A. S). Regards from a Shia of Pakistan to all the team of documentary

[@imranabbas9780]

It's really helpful documentary about the history of Shia's came to India. Really love it. I wish to visit India. Peace ! God bless humanity :)

[@maddyc503]

May indias culture of brotherhood and diversity flourish. Long live liberty, jai Hind

[@ImamReza8]

मेरा दिल मुझे मशहद अल-रज़ा ले जाने के लिए उत्सुक है🙏

[@sayyidzafarabasssafavi5346]

long live safavi dynasty. ..best ever shia Kingdom that contributed a lot to shia community and protected all shia sufis and preachers at that time....

[@sumbulbilgrami]

Was waiting for this from a long time! JazakAllah

[@ThatWhiteChicanoMuslim]

Salam From An American Shia Muslim

[@panditsharma9366]

I am from India and we love only Shia sect not sunni Sunni surf bombing and terror sect ha so that’s why a lot of hate for Sunni wahabi

[@Aijaz2929]

I am shia

[@sajjadzaheer8136]

it's your greatness brother

[@firozhussain445]

shia hi sahi Islam or deshbhakt jai hind

[@mahakalkabhakt8737]

Firoz Hussain yes bro I am hindu and I love shia Muslims

[@onlinereading3460]

@@mahakalkabhakt8737 bro aapne HR comments Ka reply Kiya

[@hindusenaindia6443]

hello my shia muslim brother.. plz app logo se ek request haa.. plz logo ko jayada se jayada battiyen ki shia and sunni mein bahut farak haa.. shia muslims bahut acche hote haa.. they all true indian.. app sabh logo ki mein bahut respect karta hoon.. nd agar kabhi muslim ki baat aati haa toh sabko explain karta hoon ki shia muslim aise nahi hote haa.. jo aise karte haa vo sunni hote haa. respect to shia muslims.. jai shri ram

[@user-xw8sp9vp2d]

Abhay Sharma bohat shukriya bhai much love❤

[@madni6447]

Abhay Sharma we respect you to my brother tanveer from Pakistan

[@reyazhussain2613]

Abhay Sharma bro we also respect u

[@BabaBaba-uy2dp]

Abhay Sharma yes brother i am from kashmir I love my india my country

[@reyazhussain2613]

Naseer Ahmed And sunnis are children of moawiya and hinda

[@mohdjajarrizvi5077]

I m proud of you my indian shia

[@QuranDuaTransliteration]

Mashallah, thank you India

[@singhrajput6949]

Welcome 😊 brother

[@miller0079]