Amazing Italian Cream Cake Recipe | Soft and DREAMY

[@plantbasedtheo]

For anyone trying to decide which pan size to use (the video states three 8" and the website says three 9"), I made it with two 9" pans and baked at 350F for 36 minutes.The cakes had great texture and were very light. I also made 75% of the frosting recipe and still had about a cup leftover.

[@AndySaenz]

I had a lot of frosting left over too! I’m just going to cut it down to making half of the frosting.

[@retroraccoon3122]

Sooooo how many 8 inches would I get?

[@Ice.muffin]

Very weird, I ALWAYS have to add more of the ingredients so I'll have actually enough frosting, sometimes I have to even double them, never enough if I were to listen to the recipe. How can someone have _too much_ frosting by following the recipe is WAY beyond me and I do not want to understand such logic either. Such sad cakes.

[@emiliamartucci8291]

Thank you for the confirmations and info. Those were definitely 8” in the video.

[@Jkm898]

Very useful information. Thank you.

[@chorjel1]

I’m one of the viewers that requested it. lol. Italian cream cake is my FAVORITE!🤤😋

[@LemLTay]

7:20 Just to clarify, in each pan, it's about 1 pound (454g) of batter, not 1kg (2.2 lbs). [Just in case any bakers panic if they've used scales to check the distribution of weight between the three cake pans]. The total weight of the cake batter is just about 1.4kg all up, so each pan should just about hit the 460g mark.

[@daddyslilgamerbrat8059]

I think it made 7 cups of batter.... I used 3 pans and did 2 1/3 cup batter per pan and it came out about the size of his.

[@eringobraugh24]

Thank you for this. I managed to scrape out 500 g each pan. I made this recipe twice today and each time I had the same weight, about 1500 grams total making each pan with 500 g each. As for the cream cheese, the total weight is 446 g… one stick is the 226 he’s mentioning

[@sangerishi]

Hi John, today my sister 25th wedding anniversary i did this cake its so yummy and everyone said its superb. Entire family enjoyed a lot. Thank you so much..

[@theherd5830]

The little shriek while pouring the coconut was Fabulous!

[@catmitchell2962]

430th comment! My daughter’s birthdate. Lucky me! I can’t wait to try your version of this recipe. My last Italian wedding cake was so dense and dry. Preppy Kitchen guy, you bring me joy!

[@YeaNo.]

Making this for my husband's birthday wanted to try something different this year. Update: One of the best cakes ever. My husband's new favorite. Decorating was super easy too.

[@daricejohnson9963]

I’m from Kentucky and I’ve made this cake on several occasions for more than 25 yrs. It’s a family favorite. You made it look so simple. Love all of your recipes and demonstrations 😊

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 💯👍💯

[@AndySaenz]

I love Kentucky! Lots of amazing singers have come out of there, including MaKenzie Thomas and Jordan Smith! Jordan WON The Voice several years ago and wrote Ashes for Celine Dion.

[@sandrawilde6088]

When we have our church festival in October, this is one of the cakes offered in our desserts.

[@daddyslilgamerbrat8059]

Heyo from KY. This cake is my wedding cake. Of course I have to make 9 cakes but it will be ok. I need 3 -12in x 6in, 3 -9 in x 6in, and 3 -6in x 6in cakes and probably 4 times the buttercream.

[@ebaybae3575]

SHUT THE FRONT DOOR!! This cake is everything and more than I anticipated. I KNEW I'd like it, but I LOVE it! I only made half the recipe and it's perfect. Thank you so much. Chef's kiss!

[@thefceUSMC]

I made this last week for my wife's birthday. The four of us ate the whole thing in three days. The best Italian Cream Cake I have ever had.

[@debjudisch5548]

Chad, I hope your wife realizes she has a keeper! lol! I have been married twice and neither of those guys ever made me a birthday, let alone a cake like this! This takes a bit of work, unlike a plain, old birthday cake out of a box! How impressive!!

[@thefceUSMC]

@@debjudisch5548 thanks. I plan on making it again for our anniversary next week but I am going to use cake strips, should be even better. Every time a watch one of John's videos it makes me gain 2 pounds. LOL

[@debjudisch5548]

@@thefceUSMC Oh well, that's okay Chad just more of you for her too loud! You sound like an amazing husband and father. Did you purchase your cake strips or did you make them using John's instructions? So, how many years will this anniversary be? Let us know how it goes...I would bet that you have something very nice planned. you seem like that kind of guy. BTW, I am not flirting, I'm 66yo, and just find solid relationships fascinating, these days! May Gpd continue to truly bless you and your family. You've got one of the most beautiful things left in this warped and evil world. Cherish and guard it.

[@thefceUSMC]

@@debjudisch5548 I actually bought them. They are fairly cheap and I have a small addiction to buying things for the kitchen. LOL

[@BubbasBathWater]

I just made this cake yesterday and everybody loved it! First time using almond extract and it tasted amazing.

[@maryfabian9081]

Growing up we had an Italian cake for our birthdays. Now in our 50s & 60s we still ask for an Italian cake, when given the choice. Thanks John for the memories.

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@victoriapinto2624]

This is what I needed to cheer up my day, it’s amazing how one of your videos can cheer me up. Thank you for always helping me even though you don’t know me.

[@PreppyKitchen]

Hi Victoria! Thank you so much for the kind words!

[@cortneyro7747]

Italian cream cake is a staple in any Texas holiday, and I am usually the one that makes it for my family. I've never used almond extract, but I may have to give that a try. Your cake looks delicious!

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@spikecobrador9300]

Cool

[@lidyaabbott8229]

Don't like almond extract too strong

[@sandrawilde6088]

I love almond extract. Try it in chocolate chip cookies some time.!!

[@debjudisch5548]

@@lidyaabbott8229 If you know how to use it properly, it can be a wonderful flavor to use. You don't necessarily taste the almond, but it helps to bring out other flavors. But, it CAN be a disaster when not used correctly.

[@alycvntn]

I’ve never been so excited to bake, thank you John for being my teacher, 👨‍🏫 I love your recipes!!

[@Phebeeee]

I love this cake! I made it last year for my husband’s birthday and everyone loved it. I’m not a baker so I followed the video and tips exactly. It turned out perfect!! I’m making it again today for his birthday.

[@GGWP_19]

This is my grandmas same exact recipe to the T that I make. Everybody loves it! Yours looks beautiful.

[@emiliamartucci8291]

Most recipes for this cake call for 5 eggs. Do use 6 eggs like John? Thanks.

[@omnimo]

I made this cake. Amazing. The hardest part of this recipe was at @4:48 because I only have one Kitchen Aid bowl and it took me a while to transfer everything to another bowl.

[@janette927]

I keep waiting for Brian to come in at the end and sneak a bite. I am hoping it happens soon. So cute!!!

[@tootsla1252]

Now Yer Talkin’!!!! I’m so here for this!

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 🍒🍒🍒

[@janicebosnjak3351]

The timing of this recipe is perfect. Was looking at recipes to make this for my daughters birthday. Love everything you post 🇨🇦

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@MahsansBakery]

This cake is amazing, I guess it's the best choice for birthday occasions, take a look at my channel too if you desire 😊 I would be very happy to share my simple and delicious recipes with you 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@debjudisch5548]

@@noratameu4051 Why do you keep saying this?? Is it a plug for yourself, or what?? A bit strange...

[@lisayerace5578]

OMG - decadent!!!! And GORGEOUS!

[@bluexwings]

I tried a delicious version of Italian Cream cake with raspberry jam/fruit filling layered along with the frosting. It went beautifully with the almond flavor. ❤️

[@rcradney]

Love this cake. Watching you is like dessert and a show😂😂😂❤

[@ferocebaskow9148]

this is surely one of the most relaxing vids ive ever watched

[@kristinrendon385]

This is such a great recipe. I've made it 3 times now in the past 2 months. I get 36 cupcakes from this recipe. Everyone loves it.

[@emiliamartucci8291]

Could you please tell me how long you baked it. Did you rotate the 3 pans while baking or did you use 2 oven racks. Thank you very much for you advice.

[@gaetzzjharleyph2618]

everything in your kitchen is so organized and adorable

[@feyiawosika]

I’m telling you. This was uploaded just as I am making your vanilla cupcake recipe!!!!

[@theherd5830]

Amazing cake! But I had to rewind several times and rewatch you pouring the coconut flakes…. the little scream was PRICELESS ❤️❤️🥰

[@al4005]

FINALLY!!!! I HAVE BEEN COMMENTING FOR YOUR VERSION OF THIS CAKE FOR FOREVER!!!!

[@PreppyKitchen]

YAY! Thanks for waiting. It's such a great cake.

[@karlaklein1]

Love how you emphasize that the cakes don’t have to be perfect! You have such a lovely way of presenting your recipes. Big fan! 🇨🇦

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@noratameu8674]

channel of cake

[@elizastonereliza3545]

Ohhhh that's my husband favorite Italian cake. That's for sharing

[@MrCaptainsmartass]

Oooowee!! John, you did it again! Ya did it again!👏🏾🤌🏾🇮🇹

[@jc428]

My mom makes THE BEST Italian Cream cake. I love this cake! You make it look so easy. Great video on such a yummy cake!

[@CoyGonzales]

I'm from the Philippines and I am loving your recipes. Thank you Chef John.

[@PreppyKitchen]

Thanks and Hello from CT!

[@karennetherland2327]

Hi John, I was born and raised in Branford Connecticut and while I lived there, there was a bakery called Castellons run by Tony Castellon ( pure Italian guy) and his Italian cream cake was to die for. It was totally different from any other italian cream cake. It had 4 layers, and each layer had a different filling ( pineapple , strawberry, chocolate bavarian, and vanilla bavarian). It is topped with italian cream made with mascarpone and heavy cream. 😋. The best mascarpone frosting ever!!

[@catherinesanchez1185]

Is the bakery still there cuz your description makes me want to jump in my car and drive to Connecticut! Live in Maryland btw.

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake

[@itwillbeokay5475]

Made it and every one loved it.

[@BayouCityFilmNews]

This cake looks absolutely delectable. Italian cream cakes are my favorite.

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake is so amazing 💯👍💯

[@sarahboyd9096]

I made your italian cream cake for a friend she was in love with it thank you

[@nikkilovesrocks]

The Man of the Hour... John! I'm ordering your book & was so excited to see you on the Drew Barrymore Show! Your tired days & amazing recipe demos are paying off! You deserve this friend, cheers 🥂 🍓 I just made Mille-Feuille, so after we gobble that up I will be making this cake! 💖

[@PreppyKitchen]

Hi Nikki! Thank you SO MUCH! That is beyond sweet and I can't tell you how much I appreciate it!

[@nikkilovesrocks]

@@PreppyKitchen Awe, we really did have a moment 😊 So happy for you!

[@CatsPajamas23]

This looks so delicious. I love your channel and recipes. I worked at an Italian bakery briefly when I was in my late teens. (That'sv where I learned how to use a pastry bag and flower nail, etc. I made gallons of canolli filling at least three times a week, and the hardest part of that job was resisting taking a spoon and eating it, especially since we had to judge the amount of cinnamon oil and take a tiny taste to make sure it was ok. ) Italian cream cake was one of their specialties, but I never knew the history of it. This is an excellent recipe, but to my knowledge it's not really an Italian cream cake, which traditionally has ricotta, fruit and custard, and often whipped cream in the frosting or a whipped frosting, although it looks absolutely delicious. I made one, deviating somewhat from their recipe,(different filling) for my eldest daughter's dedication when she was a baby. This one is reminiscent of a Southern coconut or Hummingbird cake, sounds so good, and I'd love to make this for the spring holiday. 🥰

[@MZB80]

He did say it's not a traditional Italian cake, as it originated in Texas in the 30s. Created by an Italian baker, even though it's not Italian style.

[@pisces031372aj]

I was thinking hummingbird cake as well.

[@tammiemartinez6485]

@@pisces031372aj Yep, me too...

[@artinstitchtute9731]

"A rose by any other name..." 😁 I don't care what its called! I can't wait to make this cake😍😋It's looks devine!

[@debjudisch5548]

@@MZB80 Yes, he did...I think he is great about explaining things about whatever he is making, which is nice! I have learned a ton from him! I LOVE the fact that he not only cares about how his creations taste but how they look, as well!

[@squange20]

I have tonnes of chores to get through, but how can I resist John’s videos.

[@NoOne-vp7xi]

Looking for this recipe thinking: "I don't have walnuts and won't buy and I wont go to the grocery store, I don't love them, nothing is writing in stone. I do love pecans and toasted are heaven and I have on hand and"... you are a genius

[@pennyclements6674]

I Love this guy's voice. I could sleep listening to him. That cake is insanely delicious❤😋

[@AndySaenz]

I’m trying to eat healthier and cut my sugar intake. So I used stevia for the frosting instead of powdered sugar, and it’s just as delicious. I just made it and it’s absolutely delicious. I’m going to make it again for my birthday. Thanks, John! 😋

[@mlgtactics9911]

Whoaa ty for giving measurements in the video, ur blog is good too but its easier to follow with everything in the video!

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 🍒

[@shannonmoore8117]

I have used this recipe several times now and everyone has loved the cakes. Thank you so much for sharing your recipes, skills and techniques to help me grow in my baking!❤️

[@carlamoore2710]

I am so glad that you put out this Italian cream cake video, I'm a little bit of a Johnny come lately and I was binged watching your videos and looking for the perfect cake to make for Easter. Thanks so much John for sharing.

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 🍒

[@latishastone2439]

omg this cake was amazing! I just started baking and decided to make this cake last night it was delicious. Icing was a little soft so I know I need to work on that but it was good as well. thank you

[@RuthHenriquez1]

Thank you for this tutorial; you are an excellent teacher.

[@tomdececco2806]

Love this cake recipe definitely will try it - watched you on the Drew Barrymore show - great job and agree with what she said about the way you speak - Thanks 👏👏

[@PreppyKitchen]

Thank you soooo much!!!

[@analissalowe8469]

When was this? I missed it!

[@kpgunther]

This recipe appeared in a cookbook from the 'Junior League of Jackson, Mississippi' first published in 1978 called 'Southern Sideboards'. It's truly amazing and so delicious, what a treasure!

[@cjl1967]

This one of my all-time favorite cakes. I’m a Yankee so it is always a hit when I make for a party.

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 🍒

[@jerellellenado7186]

thank you very much for sharing youre baking cakes or for cooking....i learn too much with you...god bless.

[@AmberU]

I have been on sabbatical from these delicious indulgences but I really want to make this i know someone who would love this cake!

[@shirlcrane3838]

Love your touch to these amazing recipes!!! You are awesome. Thank you for sharing

[@tinagale9288]

I luv, luv, luv Italian Cream Cake!! The cake is not too sweet, which makes the frosting really stand out!!!

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 🍎💯🍎

[@lolaottinger3038]

I’ve had a recipe for this cake for years but I’ve never made it, I’m more of a pie baker than cake baker unless the cake can be baked in a sheet pan. My Mom did both equally well, but her baking ability was way up there and mine not quite as much, but now I’m motivated to make this for Easter. Italian Cream Cake was my wedding cake, it was soooooo good.

[@debjudisch5548]

Oh, my goodness, what a yummy cake for a wedding! Just wanted to say that I have made Italian Cream cupcakes before. People loved them and are always asking me to make them again! So, you can do something other than a cake.

[@maurak3774]

Oh yeessssss. So happy for this recipe. I needed this recipe. Perfect timing.

[@PreppyKitchen]

Hope you enjoy!

[@deedeeacquisto8558]

This is MY FAVORITE CAKE! I have made it for years, ever since I had it at Litton´s Restaurant in Knoxville, TN. I have used Emeril´s recipe, but yours looks tastier. Will be making it for my next party!!!

[@johannagillenwater616]

More like….Amazing Italian Cream Cake Nom-Nom-Nom!!!! 😋

[@clawdeeverproud1761]

I made one of his Lemon cake recipes. One of the BEST cakes I've ever made! Not only that, it was the first cake I've ever made from scratch.

[@deborahojapinwa7834]

Tomorrow is my brother's birthday and I couldn't figure out what to bake so thank you so much for sharing this recipe John ❤❤❤

[@PreppyKitchen]

Happy birthday in Advance!

[@deborahojapinwa7834]

Thank you so much

[@catherinedonnow5108]

I need to try this soon. Looks amazing! Hint from my late Mother (and Grandmother) whenever you use bagged pecans in a recipe, but sure to eat a pecan from the bag first. Sometimes you'll get a bag with rancid pecans and the whole recipe is ruined.

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake is so 💯👍💯

[@sandrawilde6088]

Also make sure you go thru them for any overlooked shell pieces.

[@SusanMatthews_TiteChatte]

Italian Cream Cake is my absolute favorite cake. Love it. Delicious 😋 I make mine with walnuts instead of pecans. Just a preference... Both are yummy 😋

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@JayJS1410]

Oh I only had walnuts and came to the comments to see if anyone used it instead of pecans! Thanks for your comment 😂

[@SusanMatthews_TiteChatte]

@@JayJS1410 , you're welcome 🙂

[@reneebanbury7066]

OMG! That cake is calling my name LOUDLY! A must bake for my hubbys birthday! Thank you as always for the great tutorials! Hugs from Texas!

[@mildredz7777]

Me gusta la idea del plato giratorio... Buen cake...yummy!

[@sisi1514]

I made this for Thanksgiving. It was a hit!

[@lmdny]

Oh my!!!! So yummy… I don’t know how you two are so slim with all the yummy 😋 food you make!!! I gain weight just watching. 😉🤩🤗 Another great recipe as always!!! 💕💕💕

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 🍒

[@clubgus07]

I might Also add soaking the sponges in Tia Maria or Frangelico gives it that adult Birthday cake feeling. Cheers for the receipe

[@kayjacoby290]

Grew up & live in a city w/large Italian population, including several Italian bakeries. Never heard of this cake.Around here an "Italian Cake," is Rum cake. Moist vanilla cake soaked with rum syrup, layered with chocolate/vanilla rum custard, frosted with whipped cream.

[@breh1589]

when John said "I gotta put me first" I'm like, YOU BETTTA PUT YOSELF FIRST ! that's what I'm talking about 😂

[@annsmith9825]

I loved how thoroughly you explained each step, and in things between the steps like putting some frosting on the cake board to help hold the cake in place. little things like that are awesome.

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@claregarland5762]

Wow !! I made this yesterday and it's absolutely delicious 😋 It is enormous so had to share lol 😆 Everyone loved it. Will definitely be making this again. Thank you 😊

[@Rose_-nd5ff]

as an avid watcher of this channel, i can only imagine how much butter, flour, eggs, and sugar you must go through!!!

[@susandoyle6551]

My favorite cake of all!!

[@stevec5375]

I love Italian creme cake and I love your KZbin Channel.

[@figmo397]

That looks a-MA-zing! Seriously, you've got me convinced that I need to get some cake bands so my layers are even. I was amazed at how even the three layers were and how you didn't have to trim them.

[@musicroom7185]

Sorry to butt into your thread, but you HAVE to get the cake bands! I was shocked at the difference they made...my layer cakes are so much taller without the trimmed parts gone & the edges have a nicer, soft texture. Good luck!

[@fmcm7715]

My eldest is moving country soon and I think I’ve found the cake to make for her. Looks devine.

[@tiabug82]

This was soo good. I made this for our church homecoming and it was completely gone! lol which I was hoping for a few slices to take home lol 😂

[@staceya9580]

My favorite cake 💕💕💕💕 If you live in Atlanta, at A Piece of Cake in Buckhead, try their white chocolate cake with cream cheese frosting and pecans. It’s wonderful and I have had it mailed across state lines for my birthday 🥳

[@phyllisbowen3698]

Italian cream cake is one of my favs!! I loved seeing you on Drew Barrymore’s show. You were so cute 🥰♥️♥️♥️

[@buckeyefangirl1976]

I'm gosh this looks amazing and so yummy. Have got to try it. Thanks as always 👍😁❤️

[@Holmer188]

I am going to get your new cookbook for my mom. She loves watching you, and all your wonderful recipes. This cake looks so good. Thanks for sharing.

[@elizabethbaldwin8488]

This was my sweet sister in law's favorite cake. This made me tear up lol you are right that it's amazing.

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake is so amazing 💯👍💯

[@qwertyqwert2772]

Oh god that looks divine 😍 thankyou for making these things seem possible and non intimidating ❤️❤️

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@jamiepaul6305]

My mouth is watering.... yum!!!

[@cherylgriffin9242]

I just love watching you you are amazing so amazing I'm definitely going to try this I love baking thank you

[@sdavenport3450]

Yet another gorgeous recipe! Been making your brownies for over a year now and they turn out stunning every time! Definitely gonna try this DREAM of a cake! 🫖☕️🧁🥰

[@linlovecraft2023]

Same his brownies are why I subscribed

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 🍒

[@catherinethomas1276]

Wow you make it look easy peasy ! Looks so good ❤

[@marialuizascremin3909]

So glad you posted this recipe! I am planning on doing :) Thank you, John. Have a nice day/night

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@annjohnson543]

I love Italian cream cake and request it for my birthday every year. SO, SO delicious.

[@kimberlycornelius7911]

Recipe the bomb, made today for restaurant Christmas party tomorrow, it look soo good! happy holidays John

[@alyssarosengard6674]

Saw you on the Drew Barrymore Show! Loved that recipe too. I’m going to try it.

[@xiaoyudessert3092]

This show is really great, without too much introduction, the explanation is very detailed, it is really great, it is worth the world💖

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 🍒

[@zahraakhan2793]

Could i please have a chai tea cookies recipe this cake looks fantastic Jhon

[@noratameu4051]

Channel of cake 🍒🍒🍒

[@zahraakhan2793]

@@noratameu4051 whatttt

[@annemugamangi8552]

hi John,your recipes keep me permanently in the kitchen ....thank you. you bake often which kitchen aid stand mixer would you recommend?

[@nujumgaffar6198]

Omg John you HAVE to try this with toasted pecans folded into the frosting!! You won’t get those beautiful smooth edges but SO GOOD

[@noratameu4051]

Nora tameu channel of cake 👍

[@deborahfreese8255]

You inspired me to be a better cook 👨‍🍳 thank you.

[@phoenix2.020]

Looks delicious John. I love cake. And Italian cake looks interesting 😋😋

[@PreppyKitchen]

Thank you!