Americans First Time in Scotland! *BLACK PUDDING, HAGGIS..*

[@ItsJps]

Hi everyone, I tried to explain my sentiments and thoughts throughout this video so I hope I came across as transparent as possible. See you all tomorrow where we will be trying Fish and Chips and a fried mars bar!

[@peterd788]

You should try being English in Scotland. You can differentiate between Scottish people by the size of the chips on their shoulder. I should know. I married one.

[@andyberry7644]

Loving the videos guys.

[@wightcatladydavies65]

try asking are you local x

[@peterrogers7800]

Should’ve visited wales instead of Scotland mate, people are much nicer an the country is beautiful.

[@margaretwaite7226]

Sorry they treated you that badly. They have issues . You're nice guys with good manners . Enjoy the rest we your trip .

[@jambossaan1874]

You've got to remember, Edinburgh is a university town, the universities up here are hotbeds of political ideology. It's sad that was your experience of the people in Edinburgh but you must have had a few unlucky encounters. Nothing but respect for my US cousins. Love Edinburgh

[@dbz9393]

Also Scots are ultra lefties due to the fact they don't really have to deal with the crap from mainland Europe

[@rossco3852]

As a scot of over 4 decades that's lived my entire life here, I can honestly say that I've never even heard of "Scots hate Americans" - I work with Americans every day! Whoever told you that is talking absolute crap. Unfortunately in this case I think you have just been unlucky and bumped into the wrong people. I'm thoroughly enjoying you sharing your experiences so don't let them get you down and keep it up!

[@LeeTheKnight]

With all due respect you are an entirely different generation.

[@rossco3852]

@@LeeTheKnight Yep, not arguing with that at all, but if this is what all the younger generation in Scotland believe about all Americans then I do despair. For what it's worth, I have a 22 year old stepson that I mentioned this to and he's never heard about "all Scots hating Americans".

[@ASMRMagic]

Well I'm from the other end of England, but I was really surprised to hear him say Scots don't like Americans, I've never heard that before and I don't think it's true at all. I think they were just unlucky and met a few crappy people who probably would have been rude to anyone who talked to them 😕

[@kennasmith1293]

I'm a 51 year old Scot and I've NEVER ever heard "Scots hate Americans"

[@kennasmith1293]

@@LeeTheKnight regardless of generation, if you live in the country you would think that at some point this phrase would have been known!!

[@karenrussell5339]

Scottish born & bred & im sorry to hear you encountered this..we are a great bunch..gutted hearing this..whoever said we hate americans can speak for themselves also..❤

[@richardsales6996]

Bang on there

[@karenrussell5339]

@@richardsales6996 thank you richard 👍

[@jerseattle0722]

Thank you for posting this ❤❤❤ Love scottish ppl

[@karenrussell5339]

@@jerseattle0722 ❤❤

[@wscottcrawford]

As a Scot, I would say that Edinburgh possibly isn't the friendliest of places. You should've come through to Stirling - could've met up and shown you the sites! Perhaps on your next trip, spend more time in other parts of Scotland to get the real beauty of the place and meet the nicer people!

[@simonjones7727]

Yes, Stirling is a great place!

[@dye5915]

aye right then ya serial killer! 😁

[@victorcamarasa7882]

Hey Joel, looking forward to watching another video. Don't worry about bad interactions mate, it's common. Everyone has them, some people are twats and that's that. Enjoy the rest of your trip brother

[@toonbarmy4201]

Yep...you get those just about everywhere...

[@cultfiction3865]

@@toonbarmy4201 Not everywhere. I watch travel videos including Noel Phillips and in some countries he says that the people are lovely and cannot do enough for you.

[@toonbarmy4201]

@@cultfiction3865 oh they are everywhere..Just sometimes you get lucky and dont meet them :D

[@cultfiction3865]

@@toonbarmy4201 some places have large amounts of them though and others don’t. I spent two weeks in Cuba and two weeks in Egypt and never met one single person anything like that. Yet these guys meet several like that in Edinburgh in just one day, has to say something about the types of people from there

[@dylanmurphy9389]

It’s not common in Liverpool, he’d have been welcomed.

[@nicholasstokes8330]

I apologise for some unpleasant behaviour. Please don't see this as a common feature of the British and Scottish. You make excellent ambassadors for the US.

[@blackn7150]

It was the Scots, don't drag the rest of Britain into it.

[@gallantscotland8590]

No its not scotland is renowned for its hospitality its obviously just a couple of wee idiots ye get them every where and i have no idea why ye said brittish and Scottish ye could have just said Scottish because im sorry but we are clearly a sovereign nation who want nothing to do with Britishness yer either Scottish or English simple two completely separate countries

[@airbritain]

Yeah man, just like everywhere there is always a dick head 😔

[@leightzmill]

The Welsh sent to bad either.

[@mannsjewellery]

Don't say British this is about Scottish cheers

[@alessia0064]

Joel, there are arseholes in all walks of life, I think you where really just unlucky to find them in a cluster, I'm sure your Cousin Wendy would agree with me. Can't wait for the rest of your trip. Keep your chin up and have a blast.

[@lescarpenter162]

I encountered that in Edinburgh but in a milder form, the worst time was when I tried to pay for my drink with an English bank note. 😂 Once they got to know me we had a good time. A far worse time was a visit to Lands End in Cornwall. Everyone was a snob, had their heads so far stuck up their backsides you had a job to see their shoulders. 😂 So rude and my mate who set up a tent to stay there a week was bullied and jostled the first night and got the train back ASAP. I guess all Cornish men are not like that but the few give everyone a bad name.😮‍💨

[@colinclarke5544]

I would love to see more of your cousin Wendy in your videos going forward. Could you incorporate her into your reaction videos.

[@TheRedPeril]

I know lots of English who have had terrible experiences with Scottish people. I haven’t myself, all good. But a lot do hate the English and the Americans. Hateful streak in a lot of you.

[@paulinehewitt992]

Hi I am English and on holiday, the Scots I encounter are lovely pleasant people

[@piggypiggypig1746]

I’m sure your Scottish viewers will be mortified by how you were treated. Hope you went on to have a better time.

[@1903Zippy]

As a Scot, I can say that we're most definitely not like those that were not nice to you. Its a shame that you had to experience that. Highland - get to the highlands - go through Glencoe.....it's a must. Hope rest of your trip is enjoyable.

[@Gambit771]

Well the ones that were like that to them were so you can't most definitely say that isn't how you are.

[@TheGiff7]

It’s Edinburgh during the Fringe and Tattoo. Place is a nightmare and the locals become pretty nippy. Lived in the city for a number of years and for 9 months people were sound.

[@TheGreenManFJ]

Yes absolutely. Get to the Highlands. They are the nicest people.

[@Lovelee123]

Hope he does get to the highlands but as he’s travelling by train I think Glencoe won’t be an option.

[@belltond1527]

What’s the bet they vote for the SNP

[@hosiemon]

I am so sorry you experienced some awful people. I am Scottish, lived in Edinburgh for 8 years (Uni for 4 years, work for 4), a stunning place but there's definitely some idiots there. Glad the beauty won you over, by the looks of it.

[@paulm.d3003]

JP just ignore the idiots, we as Brits have to put up with this All the time from immature children. As a solo traveler I visit Scotland on a regular basis from England and I find the Scots to be a great bunch of people and if you avoid the big cities then you have a much better understanding of the locations and the people who live there. Just enjoy your trip around the UK and enjoy what you see and do forget the silly childish individuals out there. Hope this sort of thing doesn't change your mind of the UK unforfortunately this is all part of the society we live in. Enjoy your remaining time here and take home some good memories. 👍

[@amandacunningham1783]

Well said xx

[@sueKay]

Very well said. I've found that most people the length and breadth of the UK are lovely, just watch out for the idiots and some of the "edgy" kids who think they're being smart. Other than that we're a very friendly bunch!

[@davidmorton883]

Great to see you enjoying your trip to the UK jP sorry people are so rude to you but no matter where you visit one will always find arrogant people enjoy the rest of your time in the UK I have American friends and they are lovely people.

[@lordgemini2376]

The Scots tend to be the same towards the English as well sadly

[@CaptainQuo]

@@lordgemini2376 And English towards the Scots, Welsh, Irish........

[@litterpicker1431]

I've encountered similar hostility from a young Scottish woman who seemed to hate me for being English. I explained to her that I was neither proud of it nor ashamed of it, that I had no say in where my parents happened to procreate, and that I was not personally responsible for the Battle of Culloden. I had met the young lady though two of my best friends at that time, who also happened to be young Scottish women. So, Joel's right, you can't judge an entire population by the behaviour of a few.

[@samuelbarrett9403]

@Nessan Smith Women these days are entitled Brats who mostly bring feck all to the party. It’s mainly due to the Woke Media putting them on a massive pedestal just for being a Woman!

[@kevinb6831]

the SNP certainly have a lot to answer for.

[@clare2401]

Same. I went up there half expecting it as an English person and they didn't disappoint 🤣. Rude, was an understatement, as a 41 year old im thick skinned so I brushed it off but I can imagine others would feel extremely intimidated by it. We were made to feel like complete outsiders and even the receptionist at our hotel was making little passive aggressive digs at us. Never again, I'll stick to Wales in future lol

[@gallantscotland8590]

@@kevinb6831 dont be stupid i support the snp and i dont hate English people only their government and I even have English family so their ye go and their is nothing wrong with a sovereign country ending the union that is clearly falling apart

[@gallantscotland8590]

Most people dont know this but it was scots v scots at culloden even some English on both sides

[@SneakyFERRiS]

A Brit here, wasn’t expecting to sit through the whole series of this trip but really enjoyed seeing from your point of view, good vids guys 👍 thanks for the random content

[@daryllmoreton7131]

Joel you two guys are such nice people, I’m very sorry that you had a bad experience in Edinburgh. Not all Scottish people are rude or bad, I love Scotland and have always enjoyed it. Keep your chin up buddy, it’s a beautiful Country. Keep on enjoying your time in the UK. Take great care and keep safe.

[@belltond1527]

You often find the younger people in Scotland ruder because they have been brainwashed by the SNP

[@GayJayU26]

Sadly the view people get of America is Trump, guns, shootings racism. I've been to America and have American friends, but the press and media have given America a bad rap.

[@belltond1527]

@@GayJayU26 absolutely. But I think Joel received abuse in Scotland is because of the SNPs hate for other opinions.

[@c_n_b]

​@@GayJayU26 And yet those Scottish people were the ones being 'racist'.

[@Zveebo]

@@GayJayU26 That doesn’t excuse being rude to people though.

[@solpat1977]

Hi JPS- unfortunately the world is full of ignorant, ,ill- mannered people of all ages - do not let the rude people you encountered spoil it for you and Will. As an ambassador for your country you are doing an excellent job. Hope you enjoy the rest of your holiday (oops I mean vacation 😀)

[@Greymange]

I feel your pain bro. One of the biggest issues is that outside (and arguably sometimes inside) the US has horrible international PR. Then you add everyone believing what's said on social media and you're looking at young people today. I'm a 36 year old Brit and I've noticed the same thing when travelling in some places in Europe. People think "Brit = drunken racist lout who eats shit food". The UK also has horrible international PR

[@NYCOPERAFAN]

If by bad PR you mean regarding Trump or Boris Johnson, Brexit, MAGA etc. its more than amply deserved. Just unfair to extend it to every resident of those nations (at least those who don't support such horrible policies).

[@johnfused8281]

@@NYCOPERAFAN not really

[@Codex7777]

@@NYCOPERAFAN - Especially when you consider that the majority didn't vote for Trump or Johnson. Trump lost the popular vote and Johnson's Tories only got 43% of the vote, with most people voting for left of centre parties. If the Brexit referendum had been held at any other point in time, before or since, we'd still be in the EU. It was the perfect storm unfortunately. Some people even had legitimate reasons for questioning EU membership, lack of democratic accountability, lack of transparency,a bureaucratic log jam paralysing decision making, being locked into a neo-liberal economic system for perpetuity, etc etc... I was on the fence but leaning towards Remain. After thorough research, I came to the conclusion that the pros of EU membership far outweighed the cons but I can understand why some people voted Leave. Of course, after decades of lies from the Tory media, a lot of people made more ill-informed decisions, based on those lies and for some, decisions were made for unsavoury reasons, some idiots even used it as a protest vote and some people, especially the young, didn't vote because they thought Remain would win easily but most people who voted for Brexit did so because they were badly informed, not because they're bad people. If young people had bothered to vote, Remain would have won easily. Analysis of the voting showed that the older and less educated someone was, the more likely they were to vote Leave. In fact, only the 2 oldest age demographics were pro Brexit. Unfortunately older people voted in force whilst 50% of the youngest demographic stayed at home...

[@hceggeberth]

@@Codex7777 And some of us voted Leave because we were well-educated, well-informed, well-intentioned people who arrived at a different conclusion about the consequences of EU membership than those who voted Remain - as you briefly acknowledged, sandwiched between the 'But Remain was the RIGHT decision' rhetoric- and we don't regret our decision. Opinions, eh!

[@denisrobertmay875]

August also sees the build up of tourists in Edinburgh, peaking with the Festival. Some people just get overwhelmed by it, everyone you meet seems to be a tourist from somewhere.

[@tracy6568]

I am so shocked of his experience in Scotland all my family are Scottish but I was born in England and my most favourite place to visit is Scotland every time I go i feel such friendly and helpful people it's when I come back to the south of England that I feel lack of friendliness

[@tonightwefly]

As an Englishman I've always got on with every Scot I've met, I've been to Edinburgh and Glasgow. The people of Glasgow are much more approachable though! I've always got chatting with the Scots when I've been in Spain on my holidays and I've stayed in touch with a few Scott's too.

[@louisekno1129]

I must admit I am shocked that this is your experience! I’m 36 year old, Scottish from Glasgow and this is not the usual reaction to our transatlantic friends. I love America ! Sorry you have met some young, tiktok kids who get their info and beliefs from social media. Next time come to Glasgow, our motto is the people make Glasgow x

[@rozhunter7645]

Definitely need to come and see us in the West Louise I’m not from Glasgow but not too far from it

[@louisekno1129]

Hehe and your statement proves the point made in the video, oh and your rude! Your entitled to your opinion I suppose but you don’t sound very friendly to me, I know if I was a tourist to any country I would much rather bump into someone like Roz Hunter on the west coast than a negative Nancy who doesn’t have much nice to say about anything.

[@rozhunter7645]

@@deeperanddown I don’t think anyone would deny there are social problems in Glasgow and Edinburgh but let’s face it it’s same with any city in the UK not just Scotland

[@anneonimous9306]

Just don't ask for a Glasgow kiss.

[@rach15ish]

Glasgow has the friendliest Scottish people in my experience of Scotland 💕. So different from Edinburgh and Aberdeen.

[@sharonalexander4327]

aww guys don't loose heart, you've just came across a bunch of "right roasters" (impudent, ignorant folk) take it with a pinch of salt, especially when alcohol is involved. just enjoy the journey and experience. we all admire your tenacity and maturity. Don't let ignorance spoil you trip. be safe

[@simon4179]

These people are obviously small minded Joel. Some Scots have a dislike for English people . But that's more of a rivalry I guess !! Scotland is a lovely place .

[@sandersson2813]

There is MASSIVE anti English bigotry in Scotland

[@jasmineteehee3612]

@@sandersson2813 I don’t agree, as a Scot married to an English man, now lives in England, I’ve had more bigotry towards me in England than my hubby has towards him in Scotland. I feel so bad for Joel and will, this is not a good reflection of Scottish people who are normally one of the most friendliest of nations, it makes me very sad. I hope it doesn’t taint their trip.

[@shugiemullen6664]

@@jasmineteehee3612 😂😂😂😂😂 I smell. Shi. E

[@lynnejamieson2063]

@@jasmineteehee3612 I’m a Scot who lives in England too and I’ve been on the receiving end of many ignorant and xenophobic comments but I don’t recall my English ex receiving any of that when we lived in Scotland. Though my English Granny got a little of it when she first moved to Scotland in the 40’s but I think that was mainly due to a clash of personalities with some of my Granda’s sisters, who just used the fact that she was older and English as a way to give her a dig. There is also a huge difference though between the people of 1940’s Scotland and those from 2020’s Scotland.

[@prm1701]

@@sandersson2813 Sorry, this is just not true!

[@john_smith1471]

From the videos so far I think Will very much keeps his own counsel, he’s open minded and willing to try out different foods and drink, never complains, even knew about using the tea strainer, although I think you both could wean yourself off sugar, tea and coffee is better with no sugar.

[@laurielovett8849]

Tea coffee better with sugar

[@jamesvanian5524]

As I was born in Scotland but now live in England I am surprised by your reception. I would have no problems with people from the USA. I want to apologise because from my generation the Scottish people are really nice and friendly. I do hope you enjoy the rest of your stay. Keep well and safe. James.

[@digofthedump]

me too i blame the stinky fishes governance .

[@sandradring6265]

It’s really sad that the Scottish people treated you like that Joel. I think the comments you made were really nice considering how you were spoken to...👍

[@Mark-Haddow]

How do you know they were Scottish. In Edinburgh, the University City. The second most expensive place to enjoy a night out, in the whole of GB.

[@BC_26fhj]

You can't assume that all Scottish people are the same just like you can't claim are American's are the same.

[@traceys8065]

You’re just assuming that those girls were Scottish. They could have been from anywhere 😕

[@jamesholliman6859]

@@Mark-Haddow lol nice one.

[@joekidd9456]

@@Mark-Haddow The Accent might have given him a Clue!!!🤔🤔

[@callumfrizzell1117]

I’m from England and live in Scotland, my pals said the nicer looking City is Edinburgh but the best city for the people is Glasgow! The people make Glasgow :)

[@timelord5920]

Unless you get a Glasgy kiss 😂

[@PC-vg8vn]

I went to Uni in Glasgow. The people there are no different than anywhere else.

[@Daniel-jo4he]

As a Glaswegian myself, that phrase “people make Glasgow” makes me puke. There has never been so much BS in 3 words.

[@samuelbarrett9403]

Glasgow on a whole has far friendlier people from my experience. Edinburgh has to many rude Snobs fir my liking.

[@geoffreythomas4145]

Don't bother too much about some not very good meetings with some people. Some Scots aren't too keen on the English either, so you're in good company! I've travelled to many countries (including the US and Scotland) and have mostly found people to be friendly and welcoming. The area in front of Edinburgh Castle is set up for the Military Tatto, it's not usually like that. Looking to see what you make of fish and chips!

[@BBKing1977]

“The Scottish need to stop judging all Americans by a few bad examples.” Er… do you see the problem with this statement?

[@russelljohnson2148]

😂😂😉👊🏼

[@chelseathompson2796]

As a 21 year old Scottish person now living in London… we definitely perceive Americans as problematic which is just something most people have made the judgement of due to politics etc but that opinion came mostly from what we see on the media as many young Scot’s haven’t even been to the U.S so I’d like to apologise for the impression these rude people left on you, please know not all of us are like this and as much as I do understand the opinion that Americans can be problematic and annoying - not that I agree but again, I know this is what a lot of people in the UK think… there was no need for you to be spoken to like this. Scots are generally kind people and it’s not surprising that it was younger people giving you this treatment. Loving your guys’ content and please visit Scotland again! We’d love to have you ❤️

[@nisatrinidad5750]

Hey Guys, stay positive and keep your heads up high. Stay true to yourself 💖 This is what travelling is all about. You will meet people from all walks of life. Love your vlogs.

[@thegrebe6]

I live in Norfolk, England. I think a lot of the attitude you experienced in Edinburgh can be attributed to the media coverage we get in this country (Capitol riots - Trump, Rowe v Wade, school shootings) . I seriously doubt if the majority of the people you had bad experiences with have visited the USA or met many ordinary Americans, so please don't judge too harshly. Really loving the blogs and hope that you enjoyed your visit overall and will return one day.

[@PC-vg8vn]

Dont blame it on the media. Youd have to be a dumb idiot to believe all Americans are the same with the same views. No country in the world is like that, including Scotland!

[@wotsitjimbob2271]

Aw you should have come to Wales, we are a friendly bunch 😀

[@kevingrant7098]

Friendly and daft as a brush

[@daviel6595]

Black pudding is lovely

[@dianepiggott6804]

I believe the "stadium" you saw was actual a temporary structure for the Edinburgh Tattoo. The tattoo happens every year.

[@michellethole]

Hey Joel, I've only just come across your vlogs and I'm really enjoying them. I think you are very respectful, considerate and mindful of the culture, traditions and offerings of each place you've been to so to hear that you haven't felt welcomed by your first Scottish interactions is sad. You may have gotten unlucky with the meetings at the start. I'm sorry about what the people in the nightclub said about politics and being American. I agree with you about the representative nature of those statements. I hope you get to experience happier interactions with other Scottish people in your next vlog. From my experience, the Scottish people are lovely and Edinburgh is a great city. Well done on getting stuck into the black pudding and Haggis. It's not that bad. Now a jellied eel on the other hand - bleugh

[@JustMe-ks8qc]

Can we applaud Will for a moment? You really threw him under the bus by making him try the haggis and black pudding first, and he proved he was game with huge forks full. He clearly enjoyed his entire breakfast.

[@richardcoleman3425]

Wil is awesome, and rockin' it with this visit - Haggis, Black Pudding, and makes the best tea! The lad is a natural! Totally deserves more screen-time!

[@JustMe-ks8qc]

@@richardcoleman3425 If the lad likes Jaffa Cakes and eats curry sauce or mushy peas (or even gravy) with his fish and chips, and laughs at Blackadder, maybe we'll even let him stay. Those are the entry requirements, aren't they?

[@debbiem7337]

These 2 lads put alot in this country to shame that's for sure . They are so polite and keen to learn. Very refreshing to see love the channel Joel and would love to see you do more with Will.

[@gorgondrifter458]

Hi, I'm English and half-Scottish and have family in Edinburgh and they don't have any issues with Americans. I'm really sorry you experienced that. It's never fair to judge the people of a country by their politics.

[@jaxl6772]

That’s such a shame, I’m English and my ex husband was Scottish, lived there for years and always felt welcomed by the people that mattered to me. I think you’re both doing a great vlog, unfortunately there’s some rude and ignorant people everywhere. Ignore them and have a fab time.

[@sueKay]

I'm really sorry and really shocked that you had bad experiences in Edinburgh. I would say that Edinburgh is generally a little less friendly than other places in Scotland, but that is absolutely no excuse for any rudeness. I would also say that our younger people are sadly getting less and less friendly. I don't interact with many young people here as they tend to be hostile and argumentative (this is fairly new, I wouldn't have written this even 3 or 4 years ago). My age group aren't perfect, but I'm very glad I'm not school or college-age here right now! The whole 'not liking' Americans thing is new to me. Most of us can separate Americans from politics.

[@Kelsprettys]

Another enjoyable video guys 😀 Disappointed to hear the Girls had bad manners and were rude 😡 No need for that.

[@gillianbuchanan8194]

The hills in the background are in the Kingdom of Fife, the only Kingdom in Scotland, I lived there for 7 yrs before joining the military as a nurse, but the real scenery is in the Highlands with waterfalls such as Dog Falls and Loch Ness, Eileen Donan Castle the River Ness and the forests not forgetting the Miunros (mountains above a certain height) there are over 200 Munros in Scotland x

[@Nottsboy24]

I've been to Edinburgh, Scotland a few times as a teenager with my parents years ago and it was really nice....we had a few looks at us but no words. On your next visit you must visit Wales! the Welsh people love Americans 🙌👌:)

[@normaowens5127]

Yes come to Wales its beautiful and you will have a warm welcome.!

[@Nottsboy24]

@@normaowens5127 Agreed 👌 i go Wales and Canada on my holidays 🙌 :)

[@brentwoodbay]

@@Nottsboy24 On the other hand I am from Wales, but now live in Canada!

[@brentwoodbay]

When I lived in Wales, my butty and I used to go into country pubs and both say in LOUD American accent, "Gee we just love these English pubs" Always good for a laugh!

[@Nottsboy24]

@@brentwoodbay oh my days 🙌 i got family in Canada on my mum's side of family, I go Toronto ☺

[@NickHobbs]

I remember about 20 years ago as an Englishman I went into a relatively upmarket pub. I went to the bar and asked for my drinks.....and the place literally went quiet and I felt people looking at me. I have NEVER felt that uncomfortable! But, on another note - I met a Scot this evening who was one of the most genuinely nice guys I have ever met! So, like everyone says, there's good and bad in every nation. Enjoy the rest of your visit :)

[@skidzer1]

I had the same in Wales, however, excuse my language, there are d*cks in every country and nice people as well

[@jimjam7764]

Try Belfast!

[@inamortz2372]

@@jimjam7764 Yeah exactly, the Scots in Belfast can be harsh.

[@cultfiction3865]

@Nick Hobbs. You can’t just say it’s a coincidence though when everyone has been acting that way all day and the only nice guy they meet happens to be an Irishman. It’s only a coincidence when it’s a one off. Not when there is a pattern of it

[@dye5915]

what bar though? you remember the bar but withhold the name? yeah i smell a bit of Bs.

[@RichardVassie]

Matee, dont worry about it, I'm Scots, have American Cousins. Stay safe and enjoy ursell

[@stephaniehamilton6217]

Next time you are in the British Isles you should catch a very across the Irish sea to my neck of the woods, Northern Ireland and you will find beautiful scenery, amazing architecture and very friendly natives, who are so embroiled in our own political mess that American politics is child's play. Seriously though, you will love the place, especially if you are a fan of the Netflix show Derry Girls (my home town) we have amazing local history and some amazing sights. Come on over, you are very welcome!

[@PokhrajRoy.]

I’m living for the extended freeze frame voiceover. It’s very succinct and comprehensive.

[@seanhopton.]

I look forward to seeing your next instalment of " Great Britain by the American Dudes !!! 😀😂👍👌🧡 HONESTLY l love and look forward to every posting.Best wishes from 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿England Xxx

[@valeriejackson7659]

Think yourself lucky you aren't English. The Scottish National Party drum up a lot hatred towards the English and the young Scots in cities soak it up. You and Will are too intelligent to fall for their drivel. But don't judge beautiful Scotland by a few idiots. I'm a Yorkshire woman so I'm looking forward to seeing your visit to York. Yorkshire folk are very friendly and we will make you very welcome. You'll find we will talk to you as though we've known you for years. Try to go into York Minster and hope the choir are rehearsing. It makes the hairs on the back of your neck stand up. Good luck.

[@sharonb7910]

It is very common for people in other countries to dislike Americans. As a Canadian, I have traveled extensively throughout the UK and Europe. I have often been asked if I am American. Once I tell them I'm Canadian, they're happy to hear that and tell me that they don't like Americans. This has been the case for the past 20 years. Scots have always been very friendly towards me, once they learn that I'm Canadian.

[@cathycooper5606]

😮😮

[@neilsthompson589]

Hi guys. Loving your genuine appreciation of the U.K . I feel bad for your having bumped into a couple of wrong uns in Edinburgh. I,ve really enjoyed following you both. A pleasure. Your parents should be proud!! Enjoy your travels!

[@harrytomlinso7559]

100k views in 24 hours in the last video 👀👀. Could watch you doing uk things and read texting all day 👌🏼👌🏼

[@AbbieJH0]

Hi Joel! I’m loving these vlogs and glad your having a good time! Sorry to hear about your encounters with some Scots but please don’t let it stop you from returning because as you said not all Americans are the same just like not all Scots are the same. I’m Scottish and I’m proud to be Scottish. You get horrible people wherever you go, sadly it’s just todays society. Try and ignore those people they are just ignorant. I love Americans, I know your not all the same so take what those people say with a pinch of salt. Looking forward to seeing you try fish and chips! Have a blessed day 💜 Abbie

[@cazzaa5012]

Well done both on trying the black pudding and Haggis. It’s best not to think about how it’s made when you’re eating it, much like other animal derived food ! Sorry for your bad experience with some Scots..not all Scots are pigs though, as you must know, there are good and bad in every race xx

[@andyonions7864]

This is true. British Sausage is no better, but it has a porkier flavour.

[@Sarah_270]

@@andyonions7864 when you say "British sausage" what part of Britain are you talking about? And there are farms all over counties let alone countries, that make sausages with herbs, and flavours are differing according to the region's pigs and rearing.

[@ninaturner1546]

I am English and have been to Scotland many times. I love it there. Not all Scottish are like this I can assure you. You clearly have had a bad experience but there are many lovely Scottish people.

[@Irnbru4ever]

Sorry to hear your first experience wasn't the best...hang in there because we are historically a very friendly people and as a general rule don't take ourselves too seriously.

[@derekrossborough6161]

I'm from Edinburgh. If I walked up to the lassies with a drink in them and asked them that question then I would have received the same reaction. Maybe a we bit naive abroad. You live and learn.

[@jillyc8589]

Never an excuse to be so incredibly rude. The young are so worried about being upset about something, but they don't appear to be bothered about upsetting others.

[@PokhrajRoy.]

Joel’s reaction to Black Pudding is me when Joel poured his tea in the wrong way. I don’t know what to make of it lol

[@pauldenby878]

LOL yes indeed!

[@margaretpearson2761]

As a Scot from Edinburgh, Scots used to be the friendliest nation but sadly this is not now the case. All down to politics which is sad. Did enjoy the black pudding/haggis challenge.

[@AC-tn9hg]

Yep. Edinburgh is really left wing. Was a student there and I'm not surprised in the slightest by the comments.

[@TheAmusementsArcade]

I think it's Edinburgh, they've always been unfriendly. Glaswegens are a different story

[@BC_26fhj]

Most Scots are still very friendly

[@jimwest7107]

100% I'll openly get told to go back to England even if I'm just in a shopping centre there and heard speaking. It's so brazen it actually makes me laugh.

[@mitzy123]

From personal experience it's mainly the younger generation who have an ultra leftist mindset. Older generation couldn't be any nicer.

[@thingybob4375]

Joel, with all due respect, I'm not at all surprised you had such a negative reaction. British people are very reserved, we don't , don't ever talk to strangers on the street without good reason to do so (perhaps to ask for directions) and so to be approached by a random American (perhaps with a camera and a microphone) and to be asked if we are Scottish would be seen as really odd and an unnecessary intrusion of privacy... If it was me, I may not have been abusive but, gosh, I too would have wanted to avoid you, it would have really freaked me out. You are a really nice, genuine guy, but British folk are reserved, not attention seekers. This is the absolute opposite of the video you posted called "America!!", about the carnival funfair reaction where everyone was super keen to be on camera. In Britain we don't, we will talk with you in depth in a social setting but few British folk will have any wish to be a celebrity on cam and broadcast on KZbin Yes, it's wrong to portray everyone from a nation as the same, but if you don't explain your own personal views when asked then people will only assume you are of the majority view

[@thingybob4375]

@Niall Stephen Thanks Niall

[@dbz9393]

Yeah if someone asked if I was Scottish I'd be offended too tbf poor sods

[@JackJack-zq6hz]

I’m surprised as I lived in Scotland for a few years and I found them so friendly.

[@dreadmoose76]

BTW I am totally loving your UK series...I am hanging on for the next drop each day! Keep doing what you do coz it's bl**dy brilliant 😀!

[@cornishmaid9138]

Edinburgh’s architecture really is lovely. 👏👏

[@geddesjimmy]

I'm Scottish from the Highlands and have visited and worked in Edinburgh and Glasgow and have found many people in Edinburgh to be quite abrasive, there are just as many nice friendly people there too but I found Glasgow people to be much friendlier, helpful, with a much better sense of humour. No doubt I'll get some disparaging remarks, but that's been my experience.

[@sueKay]

I live about an hour from Glasgow but know both cities well and like both of them, and I agree with you. Edinburgh got the looks but Glasgow got the charm! In saying that if I had a choice, I would pick the highlands over either city each and every time!

[@paulguise698]

Hiya Jimmy, Rab C Nesbitt, that reminds me of

[@rozhunter7645]

Sounded like wee Neds low intelligence and down right rude and I’m horrified that these were the Scots Joel met and shamed us all

[@speak4003]

Wish I'd seen this earlier. My Niece was graduating in Bath, she would have taken you to all the best places. Have a lovey holiday!

[@andymcgill354]

I'm Scottish and I'm both very surprised and very disappointed at my fellow Scots treating you like that.Please accept my apology as most Scottish people are very friendly.

[@alanna4858]

Omg my fiancé and I are in our mid 30s we’ve been watching your videos for ages and we were sooooo excited to see you in Edinburgh 😰😰😰 We’re in Glasgow. Awww I’m gutted I’ve never heard of people being anti American but the young people / internet / politics thing might be right. Ahhh we’re heartbroken for ye. You have to remember that Scottish people swear by reflex. I’d say come to Glasgow the cheuchters are ay weird xxx

[@MoonSpinners]

I think the bloke in the nightclub who said Scots hate Americans was probably just taking the piss. It doesn’t matter where you go, there’ll always be an arsehole just around the corner. I’m English, my dad was Scottish, and I spent every holiday and weekend in Scotland, I never ever had a problem with anyone, but on the other hand, when visiting an aunt in London, some people made fun of my Yorkshire accent!! See? Arseholes are everywhere 😂

[@denniswerner2046]

Its amazing that you are so honest in your videos. I really like the way you are. I dont get why people are so nasty in the comments. The only treassure in the life we live, Is in the meassure of the love we give. The love in you and the love in me, Is all that matters. Respect from Denmark

[@chrismckellar9350]

Hey Joel, America has a bad image outside the US due to 'America the great and we are best country to live in' image that is portrayed by Americans traveling overseas. The Scots are friendly and hospitable people. As the guy said in the club, play it cool and be yourselves as two guys on an overseas venture😊

[@ellentownshend8496]

Hey guy's I don't know if you're going to visit York but you should do, there's so much history there! You should also come to Manchester,were voted most friendly city in GB and we love Americans ❤️

[@debbiem7337]

I've just said the same Ellen I really think they would enjoy Manchester 😍

[@stuartscott8099]

Will, good for you for getting stuck into the black pudding first

[@Satankat666]

Whilst a lot of people say Scots have a problem with the English I've grown up here since I was 7 and have a mostly English accent and not had problems. Boyfriend is English and not had problems. Mostly in Edinburgh people are quite used to foreign visitors too, it's a very touristy city, so I'm kind of surprised at the reaction you've had. The girls may have just not been very nice people, or they might get too many guys trying to talk to them and get fed up with it. Honestly swearing is quite common here (in some places just about every second word is a swear word). Mostly the views I've seen of Americans isn't so much hate as seeing them as stupid (though I am a an older generation than you). With what people see in comments on the internet which often show narrow minded Americans who don't seem to realise that America is not the only place in the world, and Americans who try to claim a Scottish heritage without actually knowing anything about Scotland, and the things people see in the news about America it doesn't exactly give a positive image, though I would have hoped most people were able to understand not everyone in a country is the same.

[@skidzer1]

some do, thats life. I had it in Sterling, also later that night at the hogmanay, with Lulu about to go on they had to make announcements to stop the anti English singing. Then on holiday when I was younger, although we had some attitude from a couple, we took two scots in to our group and by the end they were telling us that we were actually alright and not what they thought. I suppose it's the same as everything, depends who you are around everyday and the influences they get. On another note 2 of us walked in to a Scottish club in Tenerife, ordered drinks, then realised they were all singing anti-English songs, a Scot heard me order, leant over, said, "your English", I was like, Im screwed, "yes", "don't worry about us were only have a laugh", had a good night after that. Idiots and good people everywhere.

[@mermcd8899]

Don't make the mistake that all Scots are the same, as those fools said all Americans are the same. If I'd seen you, I would have bought you lunch. You are a lovely guy, and you'd be so welcome in Glasgow. Not evey young scot thinks the same, you just got some idiots. Love your content, keep doing what you're doing, you boys are amazing

[@ndetrixhe]

I’m Scottish, but have lived in America for many years with my American husband. I have to go back to Edinburgh every year as I get so homesick. However, I have been shocked to hear the amount of cursing from young people, compared to the USA. It didn’t used to be like this. One of my sons love Britain, but my youngest prefers America. I can’t believe the heat you experienced! I usually pack layers of clothes. Also, Edinburgh people are usually friendly. Really am enjoying your experiences!

[@LoganLavery]

Will ROCKS !!!

[@krisjonesuk]

Despite my being a “Sassenach” (a Gaelic derived term for the English), I’ve always found a warm welcome in Scotland. Of course it’s wrong to judge people on their race or nationality, but I’m afraid that when you travel, you’ll often find that people stereotype others on the basis of where they come from.

[@ladykat637]

And sometimes on who they met before you. I'm French and boy how often did I have to justify myself on the rudeness of my fellow French citizens who were there before me. No, we are not all dirty and arrogant. Some of us do clean up. ;)

[@iriscollins7583]

@@ladykat637 The French people do get a bad press. I've always found French people very helpful and kind, My brother went to live in France, many years ago, he and his family were welcomed with open arms, admittedly he was in a rural setting, not a town or city. His children soon learned to speak French as did his wife, I'm afraid it took him a bit longer. But he is quite fluent now. When I used to visit them I was always made to feel welcomed.

[@ladykat637]

@@iriscollins7583 Thx a lot for cleaning our rep !

[@cpmahon]

Well done on finally trying black pudding!!!

[@lynnesears6254]

I'm old enough to be your grandmother so I have to point out that I appreciate your knowing there could be all kinds of reasons for your negative reactions to Edinburgh but I'd also guess a lot has to do with a)age of those you've talked to b)location of encounters ie-nightclub/pub c) maybe your conversation starter: In Scotland asking a person on the street if they are Scottish? Their response was pretty lame but..... Anyway, I am enjoying your series and look forward to more. Somehow I get the idea that you both might enjoy the countryside more than the city and have also learned that planning ahead might get you in to see more of what you would like.

[@sandersson2813]

Agree, different countries have different ways of approaching people and asking "are you Scottish" isn't the best introduction. Perhaps, excuse me, do you have a second may have been a better starter.

[@sueKay]

Agree about the age factor (and the nightclub factor). It's been years since I had a nice conversation with someone under 25 and I'm only in my 30s. The younger generation are definitely becoming difficult to talk to. It wasn't even an issue for me even a few years ago, it feels like things changed fast!! Also agree about visiting the countryside. in Scotland the countryside is the winner, and that's been true of everywhere I've visited!

[@welshknight1456]

Guy's, you must put either Tomato sauce or HP brown sauce on your english breakfasts , It makes a big difference.

[@sarahmichie4382]

I'm sad you had a hard time in Edinburgh - it did irk me a bit that you complained Scots had generalised Americans and then did the same to the youth of Scotland. I promise most are not hostile to Americans. Having worked in tourism, Americans are uniquely curious and definitely much louder and vocal than most Scots, so that can be a bit tiring for some, but the enthusiasm is always welcome! Hope you come back one day :)

[@PokhrajRoy.]

Seeing Joel makes us all so happy. Also, I think the views shown in the videos are absolutely brilliant!

[@leec6707]

And seeing Joel unhappy brings us all down.

[@DidrickNamtvedt]

I'm sorry you had a few rude encounters in Scotland but there will always be people like that in every country rpetty much, ignorant people brushing all Americans with the same comb thinking they're all the same when that's not the case at all. I generally try to avoid political topics when I talk to strangers (heck even with friends and family) as that can get messy real quick. But I'm glad you and Will enjoyed Scotland, watching this video makes me proud to have roots from there! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿😍

[@marionpetford7374]

Sorry that the people were not to nice. Edinburgh is beautiful city. I am so glad that you and Will tried black pudding and the Haggis . Well done I will be sorry when your videos about your trip end

[@SmeadsUK]

Hi Joel loving your travelogue. Don’t be disheartened but I think you just experienced your first big culture shock between the States & UK. It’s not like the States where you can just go up and strike a convo with strangers and sounds like the two girls you chose were particularly nasty anyway, it might have been perceived as a bit patronising asking a Scots person if they are Scottish. Bit like asking an Eskimo if they like ice. But hey you could have met a particularly nasty American that day we are all different in our personalities. Just don’t think on it, just be reserved and stay cool about it. But you are great doing your mic presentations!!!

[@donkeyboi9863]

Your lad Will went straight in on the black pudding! Good on him! Glad he liked it. Black pudding & haggis are 2 of my favourite foods! Did you get some potato scones with it? They make it all come together.

[@TimeyWimeyLimey]

Another two Americans complete the Black Pudding Challenge. Well Done.

[@oml81mm]

Hi there, I am originally Irish but have lived in Scotland for 20 odd years and would not move back. First off I am sad that your first interactions with the Scots were not favourable, but please believe me when I say that there are twats everywhere but everywhere in the world most people are OK. I have visited the US many times, mostly New England and Louisiana and have found most Americans to be friendly and great people, but sadly you do have a few twats of your own. I suppose all countries are the same. I have learned that it can be best, if a bit difficult at times, to steer clear of the tourist traps as they are not representative of the country. I am glad you enjoyed haggis and black pudding although black pudding comes in two varieties, not so good and excellent. Try Stornoway black pudding. Some folks over here have formed an opinion of Americans based mainly on all the bad news that has come out of the country recently but bear in mind that bad news makes the headlines whereas good news often does not. We have politics over here and we have the extremists on both sides (just as you do) my advice if people bring political subjects up is to listen politely, but do not offer an opinion or get involved. Anyway, enjoy the rest of your stay and good luck.

[@simongivens]

Shame you had a poor experience with a few narrow minded individuals! Great videos, really reminds me of my first ( alone ) visit to the US, when I was 18! Very similar in reverse! Hope your next day went better!

[@belltond1527]

I bet the are SNP voters

[@kahana4159]

I'm so sorry about the heartless Scots you met, most are lovely (I'm from Manchester, England). There's good and bad everywhere you go, but they were so rude to you & Will, you guys didn't deserve that. Please don't think any less of Scotland because of the few ignorant mfkers. You're so lovely and we here truly appreciate you. Never forget that! xxx

[@johnfused8281]

Yeah his a nice lad isn't he I'm from South east Its embarrassing when our own population don't behave themselves. But like you said good bad everywhere.

[@paulhynes170]

I'm from Manchester too and been to Edinburgh loads of time and found it alright guess there is good and bad everywhere

[@grahamnoel5519]

Don’t feel too bad about your experience a lot of Scots don’t the English either but we love the Scotts and most of them are great people. My father was in a Scottish regiment during the war and he really admired them and made great friends.

[@ymrabc]

I’m sorry you experienced that hostility, you are such nice lads I can’t understand why anybody would be rude and aggressive like that, it’s very small minded and ignorant. As others on here have said the Scots are often like that with English people too. I had a similar experience to you in Glasgow. I always wanted to visit Edinburgh and thought it might be different there but I think I will give it a pass as it seems attitudes have not changed.

[@colinanderson7384]

Products of the SNP education system.

[@johnmcgeachy1480]

Vast majority of Scots are lovely please give us another chance I'm sure you would love Edinburgh.

[@RM-hb9ze]

Hearing an English accent in Edinburgh is almost as common as hearing a Scottish accent. You’d be fine. I have found Edinburgh to be a little like London, people can be very reserved in contrast to most talkative and open Americans. Having said that, most Americans on KZbin seem to have had the opposite experience as Joel 🤷‍♂️

[@colinanderson7384]

@@OneTrueScotsman Ah, you're a comedian.

[@roseadams5362]

I've only had one bad experience with Scots. I was on the train from E to London and the buffet car gave me all my change in Scottish notes. I knew I'd have trouble using them in London where I worked so asked if they had any English notes. A group of men behind me jeered and laughed and insulted me. As a young woman travelling alone is was quite intimidating. BUT that was a one off and have had many happy times in Scotland meeting warm wonderful people

[@halloweenville1]

The Scottish BRUTE mentality, it's a thing among a lot of Scottish men.

[@Cainb420]

Try getting paid in them and any where you down south you can't spend them.

[@roseadams5362]

Yes much more annoying of course, I get that. Where I lived down south accepted them but I knew in this part of London they wouldnt

[@peterc.1618]

@Penderyn The train went form Edinburgh to London, they'd probably crossed the border by the time she went to eat.

[@grannyweatherwax5558]

@Penderyn I’m Scottish but if I’m going to a place in England where I know I might have bother with the Scottish notes, of course I ask for English notes from any shop I’m in before I head to England. If they don’t have them then hay ho but if they do, it saves me the headache and stress of having to deal with the problem when I’m in England. Should shops in England accept Scottish money without a stress and a fuss, absolutely but I’m not gonna stress myself out trying to change full on company policies when I get there if I could conveniently ask English money instead of Scottish money when I’m on the way to England.

[@simonman3042]

Come & see us in Ireland ☘️ We’ll introduce you to some leprechauns! 😁 I’m sorry you had the experience you did, I think it was just an unfortunate incident, there’s idiots in every country! ❤️

[@tcharles2466]

Really interesting upload, Joel. Sorry about the negative responses you experienced. It could happen to any of us anywhere in the english speaking world (where we can generally understand what people are saying!) regardless of our nationality/perceptions about our respective country's politics! Kudos to you both for your mature 'perspective' and commentary, though! Best wishes from the UK.

[@moopet8036]

The view of the city is probably best from Blackford hill because you get to look down on it more and see over the water better. Worth it if you ever get the chance.

[@BomberFletch31]

So you finally tried black pudding and haggis! Although it seems that Will is far more adventurous than you as far as trying new food is concerned. I'm definitely looking forward to your fish and chips vlog - and that deep fried Mars bar!

[@digidol52]

Will is such a star, he just shoved in a big mouthful of both the black pudding and the haggis, and enjoyed it. No fuss, no problem.

[@gillchambers9008]

I'm English and never tried black pudding or haggis wouldn't want to. Had bad experiences in Scotland from Scots so don't worry they don't like anyone. But I do enjoy your videos.

[@iainlaskey7285]

@@gillchambers9008 You're missing out. One of the best things I've ever eaten was a small tower of layers of black pudding and haggis with a whisky and cream sauce. It was stunningly good.

[@renabrown6107]

So sorry you were treated rudely. So glad to hear that you also met some nice Scots. I'm not sure what actual date you shot the video. I'm in Edinburgh a lot. Was there yesterday for my mum's birthday. I see you found a giraffe on Calton hill!

[@auldfouter8661]

I ploughed my way through a Have Your Say on the BBC News pages regarding the Hinkly Point B Nuclear Power Plant closure. There's an SNP bot on there loudly claiming that Scotland has no nuclear power - despite Torness ( 30 miles from Edinburgh ) still being in operation. The weakness of the SNP's arguments leads to ever more fractious exchanges.

[@gangshowgraeme]

I'm sorry people were so rude to you, that's such a shame and not what the majority of us Scots think. I'm from Edinburgh, I've lived here all my life (apart from a year in the US) and I've never heard anyone talk that way about Americans. I think (well hope) you were just unlucky with the people you met. Don't let it put you off coming back to Edinburgh and exploring more of Scotland, you'll love it.

[@mikkianderson7903]

Your bro rocked the black pudding and hagges!!!