Why Afghan forces surrender to Taliban | Ethnic & Tribal Dynamics Explained

[@AnandAKGupta]

Saying this video is informative is a gross understatement. This is intelligence agency level research. Well done.

[@prs283]

Lol

[@eddiedann6472]

😊

[@viper3253]

Being an Afghan most of he said is Misinformation

[@prs283]

@@viper3253 can you elaborate point by point

[@raghuware2469]

@@viper3253 elaborate please

[@misterbacon4933]

Very good analyses! Thx from the Netherlands! 🇳🇱

[@lavish4094]

🙄 wow 😁 👍

[@HarshRaj-qf8zu]

Sir is getting famous in Netherlands wow🙂

[@SumitYadav-ik2df]

@@vikasit_vikas the fact that his video got into someone's recommendations in Netherlands means that there's a portion of people who watch the stuff that is generated by him. Soo yeah his video are being seen in Netherlands as well. In a small number ...but it's there

[@oldbordergeek]

I'm from the Netherlands too. That I watch this is more of a interest from Indians point of view then expecting facts.

[@oldiescast3623]

Lol 😂😂....

[@rdg8390]

This helps foreigners understand the complexities of the conflict - thanks

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@pashtoonmiakhel8292]

Well im Afghan and this was 60% accurate, im not even a pashtun, but clearly he was biased towards our brothers pashtun

[@ZyroAniCapped]

not even accurate, but its still a good video, its very deeper and more complex than wt this guy is speaking

[@vineethvenkatesh8892]

finally wait is over for a video from this genius 😃

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@TheSadhguruSense]

After many days....some "premium content "🌺🌺🙏🙏🙏

[@Karls_Thorfinn]

every content of his is premium

[@SumitYadav-ik2df]

@@Karls_Thorfinn he means that he hasn't posted in a while ...that's why it's he hasn't been able to watch any" premium content"

[@TheSadhguruSense]

@@SumitYadav-ik2df correct

[@inspirationalstories1575]

@@Karls_Thorfinn What every content. Current affairs is rare.

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@juanignaciochaves7020]

Learning so much from your videos, here in Costa Rica 👍😎🇨🇷

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@unpredictablewarrior1431]

I AM PASHTUN AND THIS IS THE BEST VIDEO EVER EXPLAINED ON THE CURRENT SITUATION.. THANK YOU I AGREE WITH THIS BREAKDOWN OF CULTURE & ETHNICS

[@anushirwanirani2950]

well no beacuse the pashutun and all cultures of greater iran and iranic peoples are off branches of iranian lanaguges and them being culturally diffrent is just a tad bit not more

[@kassimka123]

H K. At 1st you are a Muslim. Then you may be an Afghani and a Pashtun.

[@unpredictablewarrior1431]

@@kassimka123 afghan means Pashtun Pashtun means afghan!! Our culture pashtunwali is inline with Islam

[@hudda9125]

Yeah we r proud moslims And proud poktoon

[@penpithmind1941]

@@kassimka123 No, we are first Human, then Pashtun and then Muslim.

[@narutohenaruto]

The moment people stop looking at the world through The Great Gandhiji's eyes and start looking at it through Chankaya's eyes, they will understand the Geo Politics much better

[@Risingphoenixfire]

And then there will be war everywhere and no humanity.

[@jitin695]

@@Risingphoenixfire chanakya neeti is not about waging wars, but maintaining peace with practical means. Realism is required in geopolitical world, not idealism.

[@debalik8806]

@@Risingphoenixfire Gandhi's failed view of Idealism failed to stop wars. It is a realistic wiew of politics like Acharya Chanakya's "Arthasashtra", Bismarck's "Realpolitik", Sun Tzu's "The Art of War" that really prepares someone for Geopolitical Knowledge.

[@narutohenaruto]

@@Risingphoenixfire it has ALWAYS been this way. Open your eyes and read the history and also know what Chanakya Neeti is and then have an opinion. Don't be a semi literate.

[@yoyomodiji]

@@Risingphoenixfire andh namazi asmani kitab padhne wale peace ki bate kare, accha nahi lagte

[@eddiedann6472]

Thanks for a brilliant presentation. The Raw truth and take home message - “ America n it’s Allies, Did not loose in Afghanistan. 21 minutes of sheer enlightenment. I loved it. Thanks 🙏. 👏👏👏👏

[@Meowmelody01]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZPSaIOVpdSXf80 - anti war veterans explaining how America lost Afghanistan and the leaders profiting and lying about about the situation

[@abinavrathinam7287]

@@Meowmelody01 bruhh 😒😒😒

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@InterwebsTeaTime]

The USA STRAIGHT UP lost with their tail between their legs, looking like cowards and liars with no integrity, nice try though lol

[@krollpeter]

It was a waste of time and money, not only for the Nato but from the moment the first Russian soldier crossed the border to Afghanistan.

[@p.m.rangarajan1055]

The Tang Dynasty of China learnt it in the hard way, followed by many empires. Peace was lost when Shankaracharya's Gandharam, the present day Kandahar, was razed to accommodate the new ruler and his religion. Now China is making a second attempt to make Afghanistan as a vassal state.

[@danielch6662]

@@p.m.rangarajan1055 they are smarter now. They will buy friendship with money and the promise of economic development. Military conquest is for fools. Just look at the size of China's economy. If they were to just redirect some of their imports in favour of Afghanistan (from say Australia), it could make the life of all Afghans very comfortable. After all, all the mineral wealth in Afghanistan is still in the ground. Factories in China wants them. And with direct land borders, the US navy can't cut off shipments. PS: Peter, the Soviet supported PDPA government were doing well, until the US decided to arm the rebels.

[@joimy95]

@@danielch6662 PDPA was the only chance Afghanistan had to modernise but the west put a stop to it. Blody fools.

[@Pillow2789]

It's always a pleasure to see the right map of India.

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@EdgardoValentinoDOlaes]

Thank you, Amit Sengupta for the ethnic, cultural, traditional, and tribal explanation of this diverse people of Afghanistan. Yes, power struggle can hamper the progress and stability of this historic nation Afghanistan, both in economics and governance. I hope and pray that this nation will continue to run its own course without foreign intervention or invasion. (By the way, there are many surnames Amit in Cavite province, Philippines. From Edgardo V.D. Olaes.)

[@FishOniDeviantArt]

I love how succinctly you managed to explain such a complex issue. Thanks from Brazil

[@pashtoonmiakhel8292]

its more complex my bro, his facts were 60% accurate, as an Afghan who lived and experienced the situation his very biased towards the pashtuns and wrong information of why ANA forces didnt fight back

[@FishOniDeviantArt]

@@pashtoonmiakhel8292 do you have other recommendations, then?

[@uhfmdrg4635]

KZbin is honoured by your work, i use your videos for my rrb ntpc preperation. Thank you brother. Love from Tamilnadu, Jai hind.

[@lalithdas2093]

Ashraf Ghani can't guarantee 72hoors for his soldiers against talibans.

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@mayanky7337]

My unacadmy plus senior faculty pavneet singh which teaches us international relations praises your content and especially he said Amit Sengupta sir is best teacher in India for geography. And he also mentioned you in His book. 🙏

[@vinayanand8887]

Pavneet singh taught us IR in Vajiram class

[@mayanky7337]

@@vinayanand8887 he left vajiram and joined unacadmy

[@francisprasad2171]

Beautifully explained. There is no unity in diversity...such a rich country with plenty of natural resources. Even religion couldn't unite them. They need a strong leaďer to unify and run this country. Very nice analysis hope more different topics are analysed and posted

[@AfG_313]

Exactly we’ve had weak leaders since the birth of Afghanistan. Not saying my Pashtun brothers are weak but they have been leading AfG and look where they are I hope one day Khorassan will come back

[@xS146roar]

@@AfG_313 Why not you unit . Aren't 99 present of Afgans are Muslims ?

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@vanderest57]

Let tourizs

[@readmycomment4696]

First of all, an amazing video Thank you so much. Love the content. After listening to the way ethnic community holds control of this country or other way around, doesn't let anybody to hold control, we are so lucky that our India somehow we are still one large country. What I'm saying people living in cities may not realize, but the moment you step into a village you'll see deep divide even now within the same religion under castism. We are truly lucky that India is the way it is. This is the beauty of our country and we love it.

[@kaceobrwa7039]

Wtf this has to do with video ?

[@bharatkumarreddy294]

Taliban ideology born from Indian Islamic school of thought Deoband in Uttar Pradesh.

[@dailytopvideos1190]

Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh Deobandi ka adda

[@landoftheafghans9856]

So I just finished the video and clearly I can tell his very biased towards the pashtuns, I will tell you why....He showed the Afghan army to be majority pashtuns when the army ethnics are 40-45 percent Pashtun, 30-35 percent Tajik, 10-12 percent Hazara and 8-10 percent Uzbek and other groups Second point is his talking of Pashtun/Tajiks as if there completely different people, well in fact there quite similar to each-other in every way as there both IRANIC groups. Both have been living together for thousand of years and adapting both cultures and way of life which gives us "Afghan culture". He was talking about educated pashtuns to be speaking Dari later when moved to big cities, when in fact both tribal people intermarriage with each-other as they share same culture and way of life which will result in both speaking pashto/farsi. You will find a Tajik in kabul speaking pashto and a pashtun man speaking farsi, both people speak both languages as there BOTH the NATIONAL language of Afghaistan, remember both are Iranic languages too. This point is quite useless, but as an Afghan most of the Afghan rugs are MADE in Pakistan by Afghan people which later on exported to Afghanistan to be sold and name it "Afghan rugs" as its very popular and bought by nearly all Afghans there and tourists. I will write the uprising of Taliban and no Im not part of Taliban or did "Pakistan army" or "ISI" created this movement. After the soviets left, there was a power vacuum as Afghan warlords were going around villages looting/raping/killing village after village. When 2 women who were raped wanted to seek justice, no justice was given, instead they went to "Mullah Omar" who was a mujahideen and a Mullah of small mosque in Kandahar, Mullah Imar avenged the women's with his companions and hanged the 2 Warlords who raped them. This news went across Afghanistan and a lot of tribal people and warlords supported him which later on formed the Taliban to bring back peace/law in Afghanistan. A lot of warlords were against this power like "Northern Alliance" which fought each-other and Taliban won and controlled Afghanistan. the rest is history after 9/11. "Taliban" Means "Student" in pashto, not "Religious students". Talking on matters of "Pashtunistan" is only "Pashtun nationalist" who wants this, it's only a minority of pashtuns who dreams of this movement. When he talks about "Persian" speaking pashtuns are different than the KPK ones is totally false. First of all, majority of pashtuns in Afghanistan speak Pashto, 50% of them speak BOTH farsi/pashto. The ones living in KPK speak pashto and both URDU because there closer to the neighbouring areas. They both share the same culture and follow "Pashtunwala" code of life. So if you live in balochistan or Afghanistan, Pakistan, America, UK, Canada pashtun are pashtun, they all follow the same code and speak pashto. Theres no difference in between them just like I said about Tajiks/Pashtuns. Did this guy forget Pakistan was created 70 years ago? and why Afghanistan still refuse to recognise the durrand line? Anyways the video was 70% accurate, but it was very informative, to all Afghans reading this, please read what I wrote and add on anything else you want that I missed, also people from KPK.

[@AfghanDrill]

Yes brother this video did lacks lots of knowledge and also was very biased

[@lovelyzakir687]

Of Afghanistan's 40 million people, 13 million are Hazaras, is that 10%?

[@andyrozario7]

Oh God thank you... Amit...I just love ur work...thank thank you soooooo..much.... India Rocks..

[@meatiest1989]

Love from an Afghan 🇦🇫 this video seems very informational

[@paulrajamannar1824]

Fantastic analysis of the Afghanistan people. Brilliant. No one on the earth can bring unity among them. Let them be left alone and decide themselves to their fate.

[@tprestonmarshall4195]

This Should've been Broadcast on Every Media Outlet over 20 years Ago. It Wouldve saved lives by swaying public opinion BEFORE the public's opinion became so, well, uh " woke" for lack of a better term.

[@maharajjiiasacademy]

as usual amazing ..really appreciable is the effort & quality ,in the content that you put !

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@priyanshpandit6688]

Please do a Geography revision series for Prelims 2021..

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@harmb1109]

Good analesys, very clear and oncomplicated, thank you mister Sengupta👍

[@satyamdwivedi7006]

Finally got information that matters. Real core information that no one is discussing. Thanks Brother.

[@AmberClayton777]

I request Amit to do a show on Ghengiz Khan and his dominance of Afgan areas and why and how his persona is misrepresented by modern historians.

[@sahiljan7857]

in battle of parwan afghan tribes man killed 30thousand mongols plus chengiz grandson

[@penpithmind1941]

@@sahiljan7857 Source?

[@pashtoonmiakhel8292]

He had a hard time in Afghanistan, after killing nearly the whole population in 3 cities, another city uprised against them and ghengis khan slaughtered all of them which lead on to another uprising...later on they only inhabited northeast province of Afghanistan as other parts were literally cannot be controlled due to tribes and uprisings, thats why some Afghans are racist towards the hazara people who are the descendants of the mongolian empire in Afghanistan

[@penpithmind1941]

@@pashtoonmiakhel8292 Source?

[@Ankit-d9f4u]

@@pashtoonmiakhel8292 source ?

[@Karan_905]

No one is better then you in “International relation” your analysis of situations are so Awesome Sir 😊

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@shivkantraorokkam7177]

Love the way he teaches. Crystal clear explanations. I love the voice

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@jatwarrior2140]

Nice Presentation 👍 We can conclude that Corrupted Members of Afghan forces wore the Uniform for their Personnel Interest So they switched to Taliban Regime

[@pyy8625]

I learnt so much abt afghanistan from dis video.Thnk u sir.

[@anushirwanirani2950]

well some facts for you the turkish parts he talked about were scthian iranians and lanaguges all orginated from iran and the culture diffrence is only miner

[@ZyroAniCapped]

@@anushirwanirani2950 yes culture are similar since Tajiks/Pashtuns living with eachother for thousand of years and both speak farsi/pashto due to intermarriages between tribes, both are Iranic groups

[@AjushiPhotography]

Hmm, who knew Afghanistan was this complicated - finally someone explained in detail - great job !

[@muthiahsiva]

அருமையான விளக்கம் Nice information

[@SherSingh-el2hv]

Deoband is a town in Saharanpur district, UP.

[@muruganvenothkumarr9590]

Yeah.. It's known thing.. That's y senior leader from deobandi school said CO education at school and college must be stopped.. Applicable to muslims and non muslims... As Taliban's are implementing same as of now and image hit here in India.. Even then he said same here bciz they are same school deobandi...

[@penpithmind1941]

It's a wild place. They are still living like 7th century.

[@skygun6742]

Here you are, Thats called a true dissection of cadaver by a very fine anatomist

[@drmodestoesq]

Or a arson investigator looking at the smoking remains of a house.

[@randysanchez1397]

Absolutely amazing content!!

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@Justanotherhumn]

Request from an Ardent follower of yours and fan. In the light of 20th anniversary of 9/11, Could you please enlighten us about the surrounding conspiracy theories on 9/11?

[@abhi36292]

nah lighting up the conspiracies wont do any good, he is a teacher and teaches what happend not what could have

[@pranitasahoo769]

Yeah same here

[@sahilverma7045]

Why are you concerned with some attack happened in usa, just because it was in usa it gained so much popularity, ask about 26/11, things related to our country should concern you more than internationally highlighted news

[@sudhakar7889]

There are lot of documentaries just see them. Especially DW news documentaries.

[@inspireraj4303]

Outstanding experience very different prospective Thank you sir....

[@habib08m]

I am a Hazara from Afghanistan and I would like to say that this video is 1000000% correct. although the complexity is more than this but as a conclusion this is the best explanation about Afghanistan for foreigners.

[@gaurav4211]

When a Premium Content segregates with a Top Notch voice🔥🔥🔥

[@trolllovindaddy]

What do you mean by segregate?🤔

[@sudhakar7889]

Segregate?!!!

[@shailesh5514]

@@trolllovindaddyig he means combines.

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@haerhan4175]

I like your impartial narratives in a chaotic situation in Afghanistan and appreciate your high competency in providing us information about the military role during the present power commotion and the tribes diversity in surrounding that involved in composing orders in Afghanistan. I will continue to be interested to always see and listen your specific narrative that sounds clear and always neutral My best regards from Indonesia.

[@jerrybenjamin7660]

Amit Sir, I really look forward to your videos. Well explained and very informative.

[@akshay-iq3qn2jp2c]

Crisp , clear, lucid and complacent.....that is wat mr.amit sengupta is

[@scc_saifai]

During whole video , I couldn't wink for a moment

[@rolanddey6025]

Well researched and efficiently capsules. Thank u.

[@Sandy-kd1nn]

Very informative …explained in a simplified manner 🙏🏻

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@kamakshitrivedi8561]

I never knew that you know programming. I saw your channel's playlists today and get to know that. That's the reason you brilliantly explain each and ever topic😉

[@trdviner2095]

My school uses your history books to teach us

[@Abhianand420]

What's his book name?🤔

[@trdviner2095]

@@Abhianand420 history and civics is his book name

[@Abhianand420]

@@trdviner2095 oh, thanks... I wasn't aware of it

[@danielch6662]

Hey, Amit, famous guy watching your video. Except it looks fake. He has only 6 subscribers.

[@Nidhi-ll3yq]

No words... this was just brilliant ! Thank you so much sir

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@DineshPatel-zw8ny]

So good, don’t know how you do your analysis. 👍👌👏🇮🇳

[@requited2568]

This is where the horse soldiers, and I believe a marine officer, had it right, instead of hunting down the tribal leaders you empower them to protect their people.

[@gautamchaudhary4098]

Deoband is in Uttar pradesh near to Muzaffarnagar , it has the largest Madarsa in asia , when you'll go over it through flyover you'll feel like you're in some middle East country. Before BJP govt there were many potential terrorist threat hiding there but for now Govt was active enough to throw them out. Deoband muzaffarnagar Ghaziabad Meerut truly depicts why west Uttar Pradesh has majority of Muslims.

[@rajeshjawajala1422]

Simply put, a Brilliant Analysis in a compact and precise way. Thanks very much for posting this

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@herobrine3686]

Thankyou sir ... for providing such a rich content!

[@yashrajshiv1778]

Thank you so much sir the way you make us understand everything no one ever had before and don't think no one will ever be 🥰 We respect you soo much Love you soo much sir

[@CrackUPSCwithus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHfGaqWeh8pgla8

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@ojaswadubey1943]

Finally crystal clear analysis ... Thank you, sir ... Big Fan of your teaching. I hope we'll meet soon.

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@samsindhi269]

The way you explained the complex issue talks genius of your intellect Thanks a lot sir

[@meenugkrishna]

Thanks alot sir Your lectures are always top Your explanations are really worth watching

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@sujeetsingh9889]

"Amit sengupta" only channel where I learn and know anything easily 🙏🙏

[@BharatKumar-bn5fw]

VERY informative & research oriented video . 🙏

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@elisiodominguesdesouza5388]

Very informative... well explained! Thanks!

[@uzmaa25]

Amazing sir! 🔥❤

[@Abhianand420]

Are you from Afghanistan?

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@ghanshyam1990]

Very good video explaining all the intricate communities and their inter-relations. It's understandable in a situation where they didn't feel inclusion, they they didn't want to cooperate.

[@NAVEENSHARMA-gd8jt]

I think you nailed it. ❤️ from Taliban !!

[@prajwal9348]

I think your comments nailed it😂😂

[@ZubairAhmed-rk6gg]

After watching Your video, Now I'm more proud of Pashtun.

[@ZubairAhmed-rk6gg]

India 🇮🇳 be prepared for losing Kashmir

[@komalparmar2223]

@@ZubairAhmed-rk6gg in your dreams 😄😄😄

[@komalparmar2223]

Its india not afganistan

[@Abhisheksharma-bn6ou]

Lols, you could never get enough importance for us to travel there and punish you. Unlike russian, americans, chinese, we are not waste hunters. Lets see wats new you have got 😫😫

[@aks2858]

Example of Microsoft was hilarious in the end

[@songsabai3794]

Haha... hi-tech tribalism!

[@utopian1111]

What a video, lovely, best one to explain the whole scenario. Love your content brother

[@akulemero3829]

Love you Sir... you teach amazingly 🥰

[@AI5G]

this Answers to most of geopolitical questions . 🙏

[@shaswatvikramgupta]

When you started speaking in hindi I just thought you r going to say a shayari 😀😀😀...your hindi is like shayrana andaaz 😘...nicely earranged explanation 👏👏👏

[@yamdewsahu2668]

आपका बताने का तरीका और विषय बहुत अच्छा लगता है. धन्यवाद इसी तरह आप वीडियो बनाते रहे.

[@jacknimble7950]

Wow 😵 What a cluster f&*$. Thank You very much for the breakdown.

[@abdulhadisafi4250]

I am from Afghanistan 100% right what your saying in my opinion sir thank you so much for your amazing work

[@anubhavsrivastava6840]

Sir ap ko hi miss kr rha tha and apki video ka notification a gya have a long life sir 🙏🙏

[@jemros98]

Well done, very clear information,, unlike mainstream media just talk nd talk of nonsense talk

[@prajwal9348]

Excellent Video💖👏

[@abdurrahmanwakeel3923]

Afghan Defense Forces indeed fought bitterly with Taliban for decades drawing around 70 000 deaths, this is undeniable fact

[@saketnathmishra5008]

Finally the much needed video is out now.....🙏 Always kudos and hats off to your way of explanation 🙏

[@RAKESHPANDEY-wo1ot]

Thank you so much many doubts clear.

[@johnnguyen6859]

I'm neither pros nor cons the Taliban. However, it's time for Afghanistan to have a new government. Let's wait and see to the future of the new Afghanistan administration. May Allah almighty bless the people of the new Afghanistan.

[@dennisroland5654]

Outstandingly informative presentation. Thank you. I'm going back to the beginning and listening a second time in order to solidify my understanding.

[@Frontliner8210]

AFGHANISTA CHOOSE TO BE A BATTLEGROUND RATHER THAN TO BE A PROGRESSIVE NATION LIKE DUBIA ....No nation could ever make AFGHANISTAN peace&loving Country

[@LK-cq4qq]

someone had oil and someone had foreign involvement Inshort USSR ,Russia,,USA(+West) fucked everything up

[@vinoth29408689]

Great you answered all of our questions 😀

[@ankitnautiyal2568]

Thanks for the the fault lines in the Afghan Army was explained very well. But who are the people who are running away from Afhanistan. Hoardes of poor people are waiting in border of Pakistan. What is their ethnicity and why are they running?

[@kushaalxain9607]

This has got to be one of the complex video explained in the simplest & exceptionally intelligent form

[@keval3095]

Pashtun are divided by 4 major tribes that is Sarbani, bettani, ghurghast, karlani & further into sub- tribes. 1) Sarbani :- (western Afghanistan herat to khandhar to balochistan) Durrani, Barakzai, popalzai, mohammadzai, achekzai, Zirak, Sadozai, Ishaqzais, alikozais.... Etc (Northern Pakistan- eastern sarbani northern pak) :- Yosufzai(notorious tribe) , Shinwari, Safi, Swati, Momands (notorious tribe) , Daudzai..... Etc 2) Bettani (central afghanistan tribe kabul to FATA):- Ghalji (khilji - one of the most prominent and largest tribe), Nasir, Hotaki (16 century great hotak empire), Jaji, Naizis, Lodi, Sur, Suleiman khel,Ali khel, Amadzai.... Etc 3) Ghurghust ( south western Pakistan- balochistan) Kakar(notorious tribe), Luni, Panris, Musa khel, Spintarinis, Gaduns... Etc 4) Karlani (Hill tribe in FATA) :- Afridi, Orakzai, Mangal (notorious tribe) , Wazir, Mehsood, zardan, turis, Khattak( notorious tribe), Bangash, Uthman khel, zazi , Dawars, Wardaks..... Etc

[@unpredictablewarrior1431]

Not fully accurate

[@keval3095]

@@unpredictablewarrior1431I apologize for any mistake and further would like to know about the mistakes I've made Thank you

[@explorer_103]

@@keval3095 what do you mean by notorious tribe

[@keval3095]

@@explorer_103 Notorious tribe means which fight with other tribes and force them to relocate( in history or past) . Which raided most of the time to others territory for loot.

[@hardcoresalafist4189]

Where is Rabbani ashuri daphtali gadun

[@aadeshtiwari3159]

As I always say nobody explains better than Amit Sengupta!!

[@freedomofhazaristan6248]

Afghanistan and forces spend 2 billion dollars . not trillion

[@randomfighter2249]

USA spend trillion dollars

[@16-owaisrashid61]

India: Pakistan made Taliban America who gave stinger missile to taliban:Apne Baap ko credit dena bhool gaya

[@shersharajputh8660]

@ Amit sirji- I wish to learn about great karkota dynasty explained by you.The great cholas, Great karkota,Great ahom dynasty was totally buried in dust by our scholars.NCERT never speaks about those dynasty existed many centuries even more than Mughals which discussed most.Most of indians unaware about our cultural heroes.See Mughals are not indians they came to India captured and ruled.The sad thing about Indian culture is that Even great ashoka king was confirmed as indian very late in 1920s.Before that we were uaware of it.So kindly speak about those dynasty which make indians know about their power.The cholas had great Navy power which Mughals have least.Karkota dynasty extends from Kolkata to great Black sea.Even these known facts make us proud about our culture.Your videos are so good and iam your big follower.Jaihind ❤️🔥🙏

[@ronymooney6175]

I found it very interesting information. Can you do for Malaysia's ethnic or politics in Malaysia?

[@joe111360]

So Afghanistan is always going to be hell on earth.

[@t.4999]

Pretty much. They will need to sort themselves either by one group replacing all others or civilizing themselves to co-exist or better divide the nation on ethnic lines

[@BizNiti-India]

Literally you made it interesting 🔥

[@mahendra8004]

A lot of thanks Sir......Finally Taliban Mysterious is over.

[@sadhguru-mylife2752]

Your topics are masterpiece !! 🔥

[@thelegendSSR]

in the last leg of Prelims ,try some similar stuff for polity kzbin.info/www/bejne/eInLmol6pLKlkLM

[@EILF7842]

love your voice 🔥🔥🔥

[@Learnwithfaizan24]

Superpowers are raised to dust in Afghanistan. 1. USSR 2. AMERICA MORE TO COME

[@SHADDY_CLICKS]

Truth is, Afghan army lately realized the consequences of collaborating with occupational forces, hence didn't retaliated when they got opportunity to fight with Taliban independently.

[@dhruboroy9784]

No it was ummah

[@bandygamy5898]

@@dhruboroy9784 Ummah my ass, that's idealism

[@mathslegacy12]

Afghan army just surrendered they are not enlightened people