An Unexpected Call with Andrew Perry- Was it Real? The Hills Rewatch Podcast

[@davidmcmahonjr1990]

Okay, I have watched and listened to all 3 episodes. Here is my feedback: 1. Frankie needs to stop talking about his club days and being excluded... 2. Audrina needs to take the lead on the earlier episodes 3. They need to show/ play actual clips from the shop and re-act to them and then give their thoughts on 'Was it real' and things we might not know 4. They need to stop jumping around on timelines. Talk about Season 1 and these episodes!! However, I did like Andrew Pery this episode giving more behind-the-scenes info.

[@alexislupman3590]

Yes!!!

[@hjet5604]

I wonder if they read these comments! Everyone is saying the same thing!!

[@iliana9190]

I agree. I don’t care what their fave movies are.

[@user-ef5id9km3p]

totally agree. also think that aside from reacting to each Hills episode , they can do these one off bonus podcast episodes with special guest appearance eg. Andrew, Jason etc.

[@LaurN423]

This! It feels like Frankie has some stuff to work out. He’s very upset about not being a main cast member and this podcast isn’t going to change it. Be more of a support here to the people the show was about.

[@leslierivera7059]

Totally get why they would cut Frankie out of the first few seasons - he doesn't let anyone else talk. Audrina is THE HILLS - Brody and Frankie need to kick back.

[@KalasStage]

Shew, I’m trying so hard, but the getting off topic constantly is giving me whiplash. I want this podcast to do well, please take our constructive feedback. We want to support you!

[@CourageousDreamerAllon4journey]

Please talk about the actual show and episodes here more. Love you all!

[@audrawinningham]

Hoping you start talking about the episodes soon since at this point we are 3 for 3 on Frankie's explanation of owning a club.

[@B4andafterbeauty12]

😂

[@kristab6981]

Frankie is exhausting. This podcast has potential but allow audrina and Brody to speak.

[@jennifermorgan1887]

Yes, Frankie’s big ole ego is still so bruised about not being shown in the episodes, as he thought he “deserved”! It’s really awkward & uncomfortable to watch! It’s like he forgets the show is not called “Frankie: The Hill’s”! Like Andrew said 😂 But every single episode I’ve watched, it’s all about him being in such & such scene w/LC or whoever, but they didn’t show him or that scene on TV. Or it’s about his B-Day episode that got highest ratings. Sorry & HBD, but that’s not why it got the highest ratings. Oh & how Brian didn’t invite to the Premiere after everything he’s done for them. 🙄 And agree, Frankie needs to let people talk & let them finish their thought. It’s disappointing & I feel bad saying this, bc I liked him & I appreciate how hard he’s worked when he moved here. But Narcissism is for real!.. Rant over!

[@Rachel-0]

Whitney and Timmy deserve a shout out for starting this “trend” 2 years ago lol

[@AbiCroCro]

And for doing it soooo well, giving us the whole episode with live reactions… chef’s kiss

[@Deep_Divah]

i love them, i also suggest kirstin and stephen for laguna beach

[@DeannaS]

I love listening to Audrina because she was a main cast member since the 1st season. The boys need to stop cutting her off while she speaks! There were many cringe AF moments with Andrew when Frankie would cut Audrina off & change topics. I love BTS but the convos were hard to follow.

[@joycebenavides8943]

I’m trying to watch these because I’m truly interested in the whole concept of “was it real?” However you all are barely talking about the episodes and what was real or not and it’s very hard to follow and keep my interest. I love that you brought a producer as that brings a lot of insight in regards to behind the scenes and what’s real or not. But there is a lot of off topic conversation goes on which is fine but it’s very rarely brought back to topic. It also seems like you don’t even watch the episode, you’re just going based on memory? It would be nice to talk scene by scene. Back to the beach with Kristin and Steven is a perfect example of how these rewatching pods should be! It’s ok to go off topic here and there but bring it back and have an outline of what you’re going to talk about. Otherwise it’s all over the place and very sloppy. I’m sorry if this is harsh but if you want this to go anywhere I would maybe take some of this feedback and consider it. We’re all fans and that’s why we’re here! But give us the right content please 😊

[@hjet5604]

Exactly my thoughts! And no wonder back to the beach is getting so many more views and so did Whitney’s re-watch!

[@ileanaaa]

Yes . The layout is very unorganized.

[@nancyw1357]

Yes...totally...they arent going through the episodes at all. Just chit chat...BORING!!!

[@Hai_Lello]

I agree with you. It’s really slow and it seems like they’re not even comfortable talking to each other. There’s a sense of awkwardness with the pauses and the conversation. I don’t know if it’s nerves or bashfulness but it looks like when no one in the group did their part for the project so they’re in front of the class, looking at each other and trying to figure out who is gonna say what. Even in the Jason episodes there was like a quiet, lost feel. Whereas in Kristen and Stephen’s, they were both very confident and very much in control of their conversation. I’m really interested in this podcast, too, and I wish it was more…well, just more!

[@MissPatty818]

I totally agree! This show should have been called The Hills: BTS - btw which is Whitney and Tims behind the scenes facts bit.

[@moreadventure3627]

Lauren, Heidi, Audrina and Whitney would made more sense doing this type of podcast

[@ashleyyllovee]

I know frankee seems like he’s joking when giving the producers shit for not putting him in the show more but it really seems like it was something that lingered on and he can’t let go of. He kept bringing it up and making comments to Andrew and it was very cringe lol like what do you want him to say? IT WAS BUSINESS .

[@ChloRuiz0720]

Do you guys actually watch the episodes or just read a synopsis of what the show was about?

[@laurend8140]

It doesn't seem like they did, at least Audrina, which just gives off a vibe that they don't really care and just want the money

[@ChloRuiz0720]

@@laurend8140 I wish they would do Whit & Tim style where we could see them react & watch the episode. That goes for Stephen & Kristin for Back to the Beach but at least they are kinda going scene by scene

[@blairstoriemusic]

Agreed. It would be better if they actually watch the episode so they know what happened and can discuss it vs guessing and not being sure what actually happened in the episode.

[@Rachel-0]

@@ChloRuiz0720 agree but that would be straight up copying them.

[@ChloRuiz0720]

@@Rachel-0 yes but alot of people do reaction videos that way. I would enjoy other people perspective because I really loved that show

[@pretty9083]

Frankie talks about himself too much and his club promotion so much resentment

[@mxscape]

Andrew was great. It’s annoying how frankie talks so much, even worst siding with Heidi and Spencer. It’s sounding like they were very calculated to be the villain or star of the show. You could see Lauren cared and Heidi was already orchestrating their Fake role.

[@user-ef5id9km3p]

I felt for Andrew in this interview. These guys were all over the place. Audrina is the most focused, but can also get dragged into the off topic nonsense and cringe Frankie jokes. They need a strong moderator, someone other than the three of them. Maybe Andrew. Also Frankie, please please stop talking about yourself all the time. C'mon dude, this podcast could be great.

[@kristinamccardle2539]

I’m really trying to get into this show. But there’s no substance. It’s quiet annoying that they only bring up Heidi and Spencer that is everyone’s favorite. Like really? I keep watching this but every time I’m just annoyed. Just watched Kristin and Steven and that’s even more entertaining talking about laguna beach. I’m going to give whit and Timmy a shout out. Love love their videos.

[@MissPatty818]

Andrew Perry is the best! I can hear him for hours. They should have let him speak more not cut him off so much. Also this show is incorrectly named, shouldn’t be rewatch should be The Hills: our behind the scenes look. Would be nice if they actually watched the episodes and spoke about them, meaning we want to hear Audrina for now.

[@ch_mo_1051]

So far we’ve learned nothing new. This has all been covered in interviews before. Are they going to admit that most of the Speidi storylines were fabricated, repetitive and dull? Are they going to admit that Speidi honestly were assholes for a while, that they 100% created the rumour and that Spencer honestly lost his mind at the end? Are Audrina and Brody going to admit that they hooked up or continue the ‘good friends’ storyline. Will Audrina be honest about her relationship with Justin? I’m doubting all of this

[@brian4878]

Audrina is still so bad ass

[@coolcooldude1631]

Audrina is the only one we care about

[@PNNYLN]

Frankly really isn’t over not being one of the main characters in the original hills, hey? Get over it, everyone loves you

[@jenniebabi2]

let Andrew talk!! He kept getting cut off, I was so interested in what he had to say

[@livpotter3637]

I want a reaction video where you react to the videos. Like Whitney’s.

[@chickcallednic7098]

Whitney and Timmy said over and over Heidi’s job wasn’t real. I think it’s nice to get different opinions on this as there was sooooo many people involved… I do wish these guys stayed a bit more on topic tho

[@user-ef5id9km3p]

I think because Tim was a producer on The City he has the skills to produce and structure their reaction videos, which is great, but these three have no idea. You can really see it in this episode because Andrew is so succinct and professional (when they eventually let him speak), where as these three are all over the place.

[@jennifermorgan1887]

@@chickcallednic7098 but they don’t know for a fact. That’s just his opinion going off doing The City.

[@marla-singer]

Damn! Brody spitting facts as to why the new Hills got canceled 😂 Brody, needs to do this podcast with Kristen. They both don’t hold back.

[@trishk7846]

Audrina-please talk about that slime ball guy you went to dinner with who claimed he was a model, and got a voicemail from his "agent" while you were on the date. Then you told Heidi on the phone the food was "greasy."

[@Adriescene]

Great behind the scenes insights. These episodes need to be longer tho! It’s just scratching the surface and leave us wanting more ❤

[@alimcgarel247]

…why wouldn’t you watch the episode before a podcast where you’re supposed to be talking about the episode? I think Brody mentioned he did, but Audrina kept being like “I don’t remember.” She couldn’t watch the episode beforehand? What’s the point if they’re just guessing? I’m a huge Hills fan here, it’s my favorite show. This podcast so far seems disappointing. Please actually watch the episodes prior and comment on what happened.

[@steevenhyde3505]

They need to let the guest speak. Is Frankie okay? He seems to whine a lot lately...

[@hjet5604]

Doesn’t seem like they talk about the episode at all! They go into tangents all the time. I still watch just cos I’m a fan of the show and the insights are cool but would like to hear about the episodes!

[@MsLibby76]

I wish you would show more scenes from the episodes you are talking about.

[@darcyblinch2318]

A few episodes in and I find it hard to connect, unfortunately The episodes so far have rarely actually been about the episode itself, it's just more random inside jokes and stories that one of your audience care about. Secondly, the chemistry and cohesion with you 3 feels awkward. Some parts all of you are trying to talk and it gets hard to listen to Please let Audrina talk more - she's the only cast member here that was actually there for all of it Frankie keeps cutting people off while they are talking and seemingly diverts topics back to him Whitney and Timmy so far, have done it better. They actually went through scene by scene and provided wonderful context This just feels like a Frankie bro sesh

[@marisamcneece5639]

Are y’all ever going to actually talk about the show? This is kinda ridiculous.

[@ashleyyllovee]

Please watch the show and talk about it with us . Timmy and whit did it and it was so insightful we’d like to get your side too !

[@Ciara-tt5sy]

First love you guys! 😍 I wish you guys could watch the episodes with us and talk more about what really happened and more BTS of the episodes that would be epic! 👏🙌

[@snb_angels]

Andrew Perry is awesome 🤩

[@colleentross7883]

I see why they casted Audrina. She’s the perfect/chill friend to hang with. They truly showed her authenticity. #hugefan

[@cocoandchinos]

Really loved watching this, it's so insightful to how the show was filmed and put together. I think we all loved watching it and couldn't wait for the next episode, we all miss it! Thank you for doing this podcast, I'll be tuning in to watch and listen to them all.

[@CherishAnn]

I was excited for this but it’s not organized at all . They go off topic . I loved Frankie on the show but he chimes in and talks about things that are not super important or drags it on. Like that he worked in the same building as Heidi and he knows she actually worked like ok cool I guess but not interesting . I hope they watch the episodes and alter the new episodes to be more organized .

[@Alwayslurkinsomewhere]

How is this a rewatch podcast? Majority of the time brody, audrina and frankie talk more about other episodes or times then the actual episode that's titled. Stop talking about brody and audrina "talking". Brody wasn't even on the show at this point 🤦🏼‍♀️. Take some notes from whitney and Tim or laguna biotch aka nostalgia and now. She actually covered the episodes.

[@VNam89]

I reaaaaaalllllly want to like and support this podcast, but it’s all over the place talking about the last episode and Kim K’s appearance which wasn’t till at least the second season. Please talk about the actual episode.

[@Fore_Runner]

Feedback: Don’t read so much. Be organic with it. We get it, Frankie knows people. Use it when appropriate in the conversation. Please get Spencer on here as a host it will make your show because of the chemistry he has with Brody. Don’t interrupt guests. Let them say their point of view. I like this show. I like the topics. It has so much potential. I subscribed. Thank you. ❤

[@alexxa8273]

Can you guys touch on the accusations against Adam? I feel like it would beneficial and it’s important!

[@valeriaissavi9259]

Someone tell me why Spencer isn't on this? I would love to see Brody and Spencer do something together. Their chemistry is amazing.

[@melissaw1813]

I remember when i first saw laguna beach i was like is this real life or a tv show . It took me quite awhile to figure out what i was watching but i was hooked!

[@moreadventure3627]

Heidi was a natural and would’ve gone far in life successfully

[@betty7522]

it’s hard to stay interested when they go off topic and the amount of ads 😳😣

[@Deep_Divah]

i have watched your commentary for the first 2 episode and the only good outcome of spending that hour watching frankie (that i honestly don't even remember ever seeing on the show, but well a lot of time passed by) talk about his personal stuff, was that people in the comments let me discover whitney's podcast. i will give it a try for few more episodes but i can't like this.

[@davidmcmahonjr1990]

This needs Heidi and Whitney!!!

[@karalamb4842]

The new show could have done with a lot more in depth of the story lines I felt like you guys all had good story lines but it was to surface I would have liked to see more in depth and honesty it’s disappointing it was cancelled

[@ch_mo_1051]

Is Frankie really going to steal that Karate Kid opinion from How I Met Your Mother and try to play it off as his own?

[@SAGEWOLF]

So why wasn’t Frankie running a club reason enough for the crew to go to his spot? Could feel the tension & no offense but director guy needs to stop crushing on Audrina, own up to they should have had Frankie on the show. Brody & Audrina here for all of your happiness! Many blessings to all of you ✨ thank you guys for coming back out. much love xoxo

[@mayafrode7794]

These comments 🤣 lol. I like watching anything from you guys!

[@deemonroe]

It’s just blatantly clear that Heidi and Jen were opportunistic and 2 faced.

[@pistachiosandpopcorn7146]

Brody knows what's up. Spencer was truly the best character..hands down. I don't know how anyone can argue that. Spencer and Brody are smart dudes. And Heidi was a great character too Audrina...possibly second best.

[@colleentross7883]

So, MTV tells you when and where you’re filming but not who with. They also, manipulate things and over dramatize scenes. This we knew as an audience but I appreciate the cast/crew being honest that reality tv is not exactly reality.

[@afzr5085]

What the heck is up with frankie. He’s the most uptight person on this podcast

[@B4andafterbeauty12]

The more shots he took, the more “uptight” he became. 🍹😬

[@MJ-sz6ys]

I am from Costa Rica! Where did you stay? Is there an episode about this trip? (I'm watching the Hills for the 1st time on Paramount

[@shane8493]

Audrina wearing a Harley shirt, so cool

[@harper8432]

Audrina is orange..

[@sharonm.t.2492]

40:09 omg! Frankie's face. I never caught the jokes when I first watched these videos. He's like y'all did me dirty and he's looking at producer like, I should kick your ass right here!

[@sharonm.t.2492]

I'm still laughing omg 😂

[@carlaa52]

Oof! Really trying to get into this, but it’s not happening. Audrina is an awesome host. She has great composure and really hears out the guest.

[@tl5672]

Frankie doesn't seem well.... It really is a messy podcast.. I wish they would have some more structure.

[@Georgiaas9]

Been listening to the Laguna beach podcast with Kristin and Stephen and absolutely love it. Trying to get into this one and I just can’t… sorry Frankie, but it’s so cringe listening to you make it about yourself all the time. Going off topic WAY too much - I’m bored! Barely talked about the juicy stuff

[@iliana9190]

Stick to the episodes and what was “real”.. not just reminiscing about the club life. (Frankie)

[@deena8929]

Are we all just gunna ignore the subliminal hints that frankie just told us about brody and audrina hooking "up 2wice a row" and audrina comming to their room in Costa rica/hawaii .. and then they akwardly pause,blush/smile/ and go to Andrew to change the subject... NEW IT!!😹

[@111matt]

This is kind of boring.. just make a new show with Audrina, that's all anyone wants anymore.. if ur not gonna keep going with new beginnings

[@farahv_]

@Whitney Port needs to be a guest cos she started the rewatch!

[@amandabooth2336]

I just feel like audrina is delusional about how fake everything on the show was. I don’t know if it’s bc of her book (which I read) where she basically talked about her time on the hills as everything was real so she won’t admit to how staged her scenes were or what. I am so invested in the hills, I truly hope they add Spencer bc his “the spills” tiktok series is truly amazing and all we want to know is how fake everything was

[@mostwantedck]

I'm sorry but Frankie is so childish let someone else talk. Can we focus on the hills more

[@jennifermorgan1887]

Ok Audrina!!! 😄 Hey there, my fellow NKOTB Blockhead Sister!

[@karalamb4842]

Brody if you like 90 day fiancé then you need to watch Stacey and Darcey that show is heccas 😂😂

[@user-xv1kp6qf7h]

These episodes are very disorganized, it seems like they did not watch the episodes or prepare at all for this podcast. There is a lot of jumping around and it is hard to follow. A lot of the behind the scenes “is it real” answers are vague and superficial. Give us more tea! Love Audrina & loved the hills, laguna beach etc. Whitney & Timmy definitely have done this better. Add more clips please! & please prepare :)

[@taramorales1807]

Pivot! This format isn’t working!

[@autumgreen7721]

What’s with the reading cue cards 🤣😂🤣😂 another cringe moment. As their first guest Audrina could have tried to memorize some of his resume.

[@emrainbow]

I liked the backstories. Looking forward to seeing how you all evolve this. TBH Audrina and Brody were as secretive as Justin Bobby.

[@tricktaylor]

How about Audrina takes 5 minutes before the show begins to at least read the script and look like she knows something without reading it cold off a teleprompter. Its gotten better w age but she has the dead eyes that seem to broadcast that theres nothing going on behind them...

[@precious4641]

I dont even know what I'm listening too. Are they even talking about the show!???

[@ssbb8481]

Frankie still a lackey 😂

[@nemoneon]

I’m with Brody on the movie…I Love count of monte christo

[@andreica]

this need to be more scripted and well planned before filming.

[@brittanymarks5342]

100% agreed with Frankie!! About Audrey and Brody

[@jasminebranch3007]

Why are vulnerable people with psychological/ life problems paying for podcast sponsorships? Better Help is everywhere. That’s wrong

[@Glowingfieldsphotography]

You guys need to find a better editor. There have been quite a few awkward/unexplainable moments, that just don’t make sense or lack of context. Like the whole Miranda part. If you can’t make it make sense, then just don’t include it. It’s pretty annoying on top of the lack of structure these have.

[@arlenes.4392]

Does Frankie mean Samantha?

[@SandyGaliano]

If you had to assign comparisons then Lauren:Carrie Heidi: Samantha Whitney: Charlotte Audrina: Miranda

[@pistachiosandpopcorn7146]

No. Heidi is Charlotte. All she wanted to do was get married and have kids (in the future..not right off).

[@hrwcalifornia3961]

The script reading is painful 😂

[@cicelywarrington5836]

Frankie is not a great conversationalist. Adrian and Brody should take the lead and follow along with the episode.

[@sogiki]

This show is a mess. There’s no leader, no set questions, and the content is disorganized. Brody has the most potential oddly enough. The rhythm is completely off. You can’t just stick three people in a room and make good radio. It’s frankly lazy. Do the work.

[@sergioivan1944]

Why bring the hills producer if you end up changing topics and talking about other shows, and not asking the right questions?

[@selita90]

Nobody in jersey shore was italian, thanks.

[@pistachiosandpopcorn7146]

The only one that was not...was Snooki. The rest were definitely Italian.

[@CourageousDreamerAllon4journey]

@@pistachiosandpopcorn7146 snooki and j-woww.

[@rosamg8145]

Is it just me or does Brody and Frankie look like their on a sick one 😬😳

[@lacali2346]

Whitney and Tim did it better

[@elysia..]

brodes likes 90 daysss????? das whats up!!!!

[@Godiswith_HER]

Why do they read off scripts ! Makes it seem not genuine.

[@user-AG123]

Frankie is horrible ! Omg these are so hard to watch

[@lbrando18]

Frankie just is not meant to be a podcaster

[@velvetbrown850]

Zero chemistry with anyone here

[@Goghvanjosey]

Is anyone else cringing hard/ vert uncomfortable that Frankie is like… being too crass and inappropriately acting like he should know about Audrina sex life it’s super uncomfortable,reminds me of HS boys who would say they had sex with girls and “slut shame” them…. Just get off th podcast he’s so much older than the cast and it’s embarrassing he’s still clubbing while everyone else has grown up

[@en6278]

The Lauren loonies are so confused. They accuse the show of copying Whitneys show but are also in the comments complaining that theyre not talking about the show enough. Its like they just watch to complain.