Apple Magic Mouse 2 Review: The Best & Worst Mouse for Mac OS

[@MarceloRafael00]

This mouse is probably the result of a project where an Apple engineer bet with his colleague that he could create the worst mouse ever, and even so, Apple fans would continue buying and defending it. I cannot believe this is a serious project.

[@adamtalkstech]

Ha it's the best and worst.

[@randomunderwebdweller]

Design is bad but functionality is good. So I will still defend it when used with MacOS. The gestures and smooth scrolling is top notch.

[@MarceloRafael00]

@@randomunderwebdweller there are a lot of mouses that can do more than the Magic Mouse. I really use the Mission Control, however I also use the switching between windows for same apps (control+down), and the Magic Mouse is the only one that doesn’t allow the user to configure this custom shortcut.

[@randomunderwebdweller]

@@MarceloRafael00 even so, do you know of any mouse able to make use of MacOS smooth scrolling? For me at least, that is the main value of this mouse and the gesture support. Not being able to customize is not a big deal. A lot of people don’t bother to customize anyway. It’s just up to preference. It does not make the mouse bad. So I stand by what I said, functionality is good.

[@MarceloRafael00]

@@randomunderwebdweller it’s not a matter of opinion. It’s not ergonomic, nor customisable, you cannot use it while it’s charging, and like any apple device, you are only able to do what Apple allows. Smooth scrolling definitely is not a big deal compared to all shortcomings you have in this mouse. I have this mouse that my company gave me, and I swear, I’ve really tried to use it a lot of times. You definitely need to make a big effort to ignore all shortcomings of this mouse

[@WrenchingWolf92]

I'm brand new to the Mac scene. Got myself a Macbook Air M2, and found an old 2013 Mac Pro on eBay. Got a new Apple mouse to go with it all. I can't use this mouse for more than a few minutes without my arm cramping up! Horrible ergonomic design that I'm amazed Apple approved. Great way to turn away converts like myself from buying the accessories, since I'm afraid to dump the $130 on a keyboard now.

[@RH-nk7eo]

I forced myself to use it for a year but it is just terrible through and through. Bought a logitech and was instantly relieved.

[@WorkFromHype]

I too have a love / hate relationship with this mouse... nice video man!

[@adamtalkstech]

Thanks so much for the comment man. Big fan of your channel.

[@markmoran7748]

Nice job Adam. I enjoyed the video. It was concise, on topic, clear and well spoken. Thanks

[@adamtalkstech]

I appreciate that!

[@EmadSaedi]

Man I really like your channel. Great content. Keep it up!

[@adamtalkstech]

I really appreciate that! Welcome to channel!

[@slob5041]

If you consider it as a one button mouse, it becomes closer to a finger on iOS. Probably the intention because Steve fought heavily against multiple input mice.

[@adamtalkstech]

Interesting point. I never thought of that.

[@vpntrends2566]

I’ve been using magic mouse for a few years, then I bought mx master 3s for mac been using it too 1y or more. Here are a few things you missed to mention but may be very important to some. Magic mouse very easy to clean it never gets dirty, battery life seems to last a lot longer than 3S, and 3S gets very dirty fast and almost impossible to clean. Rubber material of 3S is very bad in my opinion. Also 3S is very big many people wont feel comfortable with it, try and you will see what im saying. As for the features 3S I think has more, but most of the things you daily do both mouses will support, and with touch scroll on magic mouse you can precisely move where you want. Also 3S clicks are silent first few weeks then it start to make noise on every 2nd or 3rd click very annoying. I am personally returning to magic mouse soon just to get the black version :)

[@adamtalkstech]

Yeah I see what you're saying. I still prefer the 3S even after years of using the magic mouse. The comfort has been great for me. I haven't had issues with the worn out rubber yet but I don't eat at the computer either so not sure if that has anything to do with it.

[@vpntrends2566]

@@adamtalkstech I don't eat above the 3S or at computer either, this mouse simply gets dirty quickly from normal usage and there are many complaints about this from other people, in order to clean it you would have to open the mouse. On the other hand one swipe over magic mouse surface and its clean. In my opinion I would replace it just because of this even if it had better comfort and more features, but everyone can decide for themself what they think is more important..

[@valentinomc]

How does the scrolling experience compare with S3?

[@IAmMrAcid]

@@valentinomc Really bad if using on Mac. Even if you tried to turn on Smart wheel

[@RayHoth]

I know this is an older video but from my experience, I can use my magic mouse and magic keyboard throughout my devices. I have two M1 Macbook Pros and an iPad Pro. How am I doing this, I will tell you how I am doing this. They all use the same Apple ID.

[@adamtalkstech]

That is when they are on same network using continuity.

[@TrevorDennis100]

I have a Magic Mouse that I've used with an iPad Pro, but I have my first ever Macbook Pro (M2 Pro) on its way - I have used Windows since 3.1 - so was pleased to realise that the Magic Mouse would work with the MBP. The thing is, I just thought it was an iPad mouse, and I knew nothing about gestures, so it's all very exciting. I was going to get a Master 3S for the MBP as I have used MX series mice since forever, and have used a Master 3S with my Windows 11 desktop for several years. But after watching this, I cancelled the Master 3S for the MBP, and will give the Magic Mouse a proper try. So thanks for putting me straight. One thing I am wondering about, is that I've watched another review which complained about the Master 3S low poling rate of just 90hz. My Windows one seems to work smoothly enough, but the reviewer said his was jerky with his MBP. I guess I can try my current 3S using the dongle, and decide after that.

[@randomunderwebdweller]

Even with the downsides, I am still getting this mouse because it’s the only one I know that is capable of smooth scrolling. I read a lot of web novels/comics and the smooth scrolling in MacOS is the best way to enjoy it.

[@mamood2007]

Hello Adam: This is my FIRST encounter with YOUR channel. I found your video production and its content were useful. It was a GREAT idea to present BOTH the Positives & Negatives of Mac OS Mouse in comparison to Logitec Mouse that YOU have used. Mah-M🙂🙂d Sultan

[@adamtalkstech]

Welcome aboard! Thanks for watching :)

[@330glass]

I couldn’t imagine going to a coffee shop with my laptop and working with that huge mouse lol I think the Magic Mouse was made to be easily portable and look good in environments that aren’t necessarily an office.

[@adamtalkstech]

Yup Magic Mouse lives in my backpack for when I’m on the go working

[@BlackBruceLeeTheGreatDekuTree]

I mean but you’re already pulling out a laptop which is a device a lot larger than a cellphone in a coffee shop so why would the mouse matter?

[@SamSam-Cat]

Thanks for the review. Ordered mine for 50% off!

[@valentinomc]

I just got a Logit mouse, which is definitely better, but scrolling up and down, I believe the Magic Mouse is better. I dont know if anyone have both of them let me know if you see any diferent.

[@axel_logan]

I switch on the ergonomic logitec after 16 years of magic mouse, yep returned it and i'm back on the magic mouse, the scrolling is unnegociable

[@stephanhekkert8892]

I have a older Magic Mouse but I can’t scroll with it on my iPad

[@sjarvis3860]

I just purchased a magic mouse and just tried using it on a standard mouse pad, but its very unresponsive. I noticed on a lot of surfaces, the mouse lens is barely picking them up and only works on a flat hard surface. Does this mouse work on standard mouse pads for you?

[@oliviadoutreband3916]

I find that I don't even need to use a mouse pad, but when i do it still is effective, perhaps see if you can try a new one / get a replacement or someone to look at it.

[@Domakla]

You can also change the sensibility of the mouse in the settings; maybe that will do the job.

[@brycemorgan6708]

Check the laser eye minehead, just a single piece of hair and it caused the mouse not to track. Make sure your surface is completely clean also

[@kosta1605]

I do like the mouse just wish it tracked better. Sensor on it feels like its from the 90's.

[@phillippereira6468]

Really? I started using computers and mice on pcs from 1990 and I disagree, they were much better. This is just complete rubbish.

[@adamtalkstech]

Works great for me

[@adamtalkstech]

Check the comments. This mouse is polarizing lol

[@user-0909qwerty]

is the magic mouse worth it if it’s half the price off? 😥

[@adamtalkstech]

Absolutely

[@ShotgunTherapy]

Yeah there are better mice out there and yes it’s an ergonomic nightmare but the features it offers are non replaceable and you won’t get them on any other mouse on the market. I don’t work for long hours on my computer it’s more of a word processing, email and KZbin computer. The Magic Mouse is perfect for what I need it for and I have zero regrets buying one in 2024.

[@spzi_]

my biggest gripe with the mouse is the sensor being super inaccurate and high latency, which is funny because on windows the latency issues are gone, except the innacuracy gets worse, but as soon as you install the magic mosue drivers for the touch scrolling the latency comes back, and the weirdest part is how the latency gets 40% worse while holding the mouse button down, goes from 90hz to like 60hz for no reason the only other thing is how heavy is in relation to the size, makes the sharp corners dig into my hands a lot more than it should... seriously who thought putting sharp corners on a mouse was a good idea

[@orangeofmars2835]

I have the original that I try to use with the original Mac Mini M1. Annoying that it is hard to connect.

[@adamtalkstech]

Yeah the originals are annoying for sure

[@shivammandal2484]

Thank mate! So its gonna be a nice optionfor me.

[@adamtalkstech]

Good choice!

[@krexar5717]

The cons were enough, the pros do not safe it. Thank you. Im happy i never switched back to this brand.

[@adamtalkstech]

All depends who you ask. I’m still rocking Logitech for my daily drivers.

[@ericlucero4152]

The fact that's apple is the sole reason it isnt being called out more for how horrible it is.

[@adamtalkstech]

It’s not that bad.

[@shriefallam8866]

Amazing lighting, amazing sound quality, amazing studio background, but no hands? XD

[@Treborray]

great review !

[@adamtalkstech]

Thank you! Cheers!

[@MrsLangue]

I just got my first MacBook and was seduced by the design of the magic mouse. Scrolling up and down is really great, but I need a big surface to glide to the corners of the screen and it also does not glide smoothly. I hate that so much. My cheapest mouse for 20 bucks is better than my 100$ apple mouse regarding gliding. I will use it a few days more and then probably return it and get Logitech.

[@Blyad12345]

Wait ok, want to discuss your con, about the paring process. Paring it with de Ipad is just how you pare almost every mouse. Logitechs MX Master 3s is a special mouse because it has the function to connect with multiple devices at once. That said paring another bluetooth mouse (if it doesnt have a dongle) you do it the same way. I understand you in some ways, but it is a normal way of paring.

[@adamtalkstech]

That’s a good point. I have a few brands of mouses that use the Logitech way of pairing so I guess I just got used to that and considered it to be “normal”

[@Blyad12345]

@@adamtalkstech good response and video, now following

[@marvellousadesanya8480]

I think the biggest issue for me with the Apple mouse is not able to charge while using. Could be a serious issue when not using a laptop. However, I expected Logitech to have a better competitive price. So, I just purchased the Apple mouse. I also really love the touch feature.

[@lesleycooomer9073]

I now have had 2 unused Magic Mouses. I sold te 1st one and the other is in my draw. If I am working all day in Indesign i find it too heavy. I now use a very cheap small Microsoft mouse!!

[@adamtalkstech]

Why not the Magic Mouse?

[@colin6711]

Which one would you suggest buying. Mx master/anywhere 3s or Magic Mouse to use with m1 MacBook Pro? I don’t have an external display at home by the way.

[@adamtalkstech]

MX Master 3S is my favorite overall for long term use. Magic mouse is my favorite for casual use. I have a couple direct head to head videos in this playlist: kzbin.info/www/bejne/faimoYp8lrKFrtk&pp=gAQBiAQB

[@Warp3326]

Can you right click with it?

[@adamtalkstech]

Yup! Just needs enabled in the system preferences

[@Warp3326]

ok@@adamtalkstech

[@tech-no-logictech9743]

For the ergonomics part I just bought the Solumics Case which makes it feel in the hand like a normal mouse.

[@adamtalkstech]

Nice! I have heard of that one but had seen some mixed reviews. should I grab it and test it?

[@tech-no-logictech9743]

@@adamtalkstech I've literally ordered it yesterday and only used it for the last 20minutes. The MX (am used to it) feels better right now, but like with every mouse this "new" magic mouse needs some time. Haven't used mine in a while and those gestures are really nice. My side scrolling in Final Cut stops working every now and then which led to me giving up on this function and with the MM it's a breeze again. 😊

[@heckinbasedandinkpilledoct7459]

I love the features of the Magic Mouse, but the ergonomic quality does suck. I wish they would just build the body of the mouse properly

[@nevinsunny1515]

are you getting any issues in mac with logitec MX 3. Lots of people are experiencing lags apparently

[@adamtalkstech]

No. I use it all day every day

[@AyushiGaur-mg5vs]

well, we can use the mouse with both ipad and mac simultaneously. No need to connect magic mouse again and again.

[@adamtalkstech]

Only with continuity on same WiFi network.

[@visionlandmusic]

How about the fact that it doesn’t wok with 99% of mouse pads!

[@cfrontron]

Who uses a mouse pad anymore. Its not 1987 anymore lady

[@migueltoledo1884]

If Apple could keep the functionality of the Magic Mouse, but add the ergonomics of say - a Logitech MX Master 3 - it would be the best mouse for Mac.

[@adamtalkstech]

I agree completely.

[@Jack_McCourt01]

so you need to turn it off and then on again to pair it to another device, that's so stupid.

[@TomTheDon_]

Thank you !

[@adamtalkstech]

You're welcome!

[@rashiagrawal2505]

It work on macbook

[@الإسكندر-س3ش]

I am not understand why we have not right click with 2fingers as in track pad on magic mouse. This is most stupid in this mouse

[@adamtalkstech]

You just have to change the setting

[@JJbike]

Just got the new Imac. The magic mouse doesnt have the right click function like the one on my 2015 imac. Apparently you have to hit control and tap to cut, paste, spell, search etc. I called Apple ,and thats what they told me. Any fixes for that?

[@adamtalkstech]

Go into the settings and change secondary click on it to right side

[@JJbike]

@@adamtalkstech thanks. Apple Care didnt even know that. I cpuld not believe that you actually had to use a key and the mouse. Didnt sound innovative.

[@adamtalkstech]

@@JJbike that’s crazy. I think I actually have a video on how to turn right click on the Apple mouse

[@mub9341]

Great job on the review, I don't get it, how can anyone like it? This mouse is absolutely horrible! limited on features, ergonomics suck, and that stupid bottom charge port! I bought the Logitech MX Master 3s. It is superior in every way. Comfortable to use, great design, loaded with programmable buttons for the same price! And no I don't work for Logitech, I am not an apple fan boy and always try to buy products that make sense, the Magic Mouse makes no sense. Garbage product.

[@adamtalkstech]

Thanks for watching! I really think it’s just about the amazing touch scrolling

[@slob5041]

It's the only apple product I genuinely can't use. It's too behind in terms of dpi. It has nothing that really makes it win over any traditional mouse other than the gesture input which is intentionally gimped compared to trackpad.

[@timmlinar7065]

The design of Logitech mx master is not even comperable with magic mouse because logitech design sucks as much as it can. I will buy the magic mouse after watching this video ofc

[@mub9341]

Hmmm, so I'm curious why you prefer the Magic Mouse? So many of us think the ergonomics & design are horrible, and it's extremely limited on features for the price. I have a friend who is a manager at a local Apple Store, even he says most people hate it, including him. The Logitech MX master 3s may not have premium build quality but it is loaded with features, better ergonomics and is a way better option for the money. Heck just for the programmable buttons & keyboard shortcuts alone, makes the Logitech a win.@@timmlinar7065

[@macdal6877]

recently purchased an apple mouse and keyboard to go with my mac mini m2 / LG 24'' 24MD4KLB-B IPS . Ive purchased the LG and samsung drive based on your recoommendations- so thanks.. I'm looking for a second monitor (24 inches) that I can position in portrait mode (vertical) my budget is from around 100- 250ish. It has to vesa mountable and have good viewing angles.Is there anything that comes to mind? I'm open to both a 1080p /1440p I'd be just using it to wach an occasional video or have messenger apps up on it- nothing major. Ive researched it a bit but no monitor is really jumping out at me. Appreciate any input give. Do ppl generally go with the same size monitor as their primary or would going with a 27 inch 2nd monitor be strange. Thanks.

[@r4gn4r0k69]

This thing’s design is a war crime

[@adamtalkstech]

The comments on this video always entertain me. Some people love it, some hate it.

[@phillippereira6468]

Hate the damn thing, and already had to repair it under warranty, I wish they gave my money back to be honest. I have been using computers for 34 years, this was the first mouse that has failed and is basically rubbish

[@adamtalkstech]

Wild. Never heard that happen to anyone.

[@moe5347]

it works fine for me except precision, let's say I wanna highlight the very beginning of your comment here, takes longer than the trackpad

[@TodaysArtClass]

I think Air.0 Mouse has more magic than this… 🤔

[@adamtalkstech]

I haven’t heard of that one

[@neek_yt8]

disadvantage: bad for gaming

[@leosheppard8517]

It’s just shit. It’s slippery and not very ergonomic!

[@Youtuber-lv6eh]

This video should be: You cant charge while using it hurts my hand and wrist. 0/10. The apple fanboyism is insane.

[@adamtalkstech]

Looks like I've got a new career as an Apple fanboy.

[@beauburton_08]

🤖 ah

[@adamtalkstech]

Yes I am.

[@jannieschluter9670]

Well, all the cons are irrelevant... 😂

[@adamtalkstech]

True.

[@sadiqarie5872]

First time i see this stupid product how this charging it 😂😂

[@adamtalkstech]

Yesss it’s so dumb