[Blind Reaction] MLP:FiM S07E23 - Secrets and Pies

Blind reaction and commentary on My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Season 7 Episode 23 - Secrets and Pies.
Commentary background music: www.bensound.com
COPYRIGHTS: FAIR USE, Title 17, US Code (Sections 107-118 of the copyright law): All media in this video is used for purpose of review & commentary under terms of fair use. All footage, music & images used belong to their respective companies.

[@liamatkins452]

For those who say Rainbow Dash deserves the Element of Honesty, here is why she is more suited for Loyalty than Honesty.

[@ReligiousPrime]

Um, who says that Dash deserves Honesty?

[@gatchakittyowo3671]

Religious Prime loads of people cuz she tells the truth ALOT more out of place and AJ is loyal to her family so she should of got loyalty, hope that cleared it up 4 u

[@redrosereindeer]

@@ReligiousPrime some people

[@rainbow4516]

Well at times she CAN be honest

[@mocameek]

@@ReligiousPrime Alot of people

[@zhanejackson5062]

What I truly love about this episode is that when Pinkie doesn't jump to conclusions in the beginning. Especially from season 2. Even if she is a little off, at least she actually made an attempt to figure it out this time. I'm glad she learned that lesson in the "Mmmmystery" episode.

[@iicliz2350]

Courtney TD I was making sure she doesn't. For continuity reasons.

[@zhanejackson5062]

julie martinez and that's what I am saying

[@laszlozsurka8991]

I guess Pinkie is the only pie Rainbow Dash loves :D Also, who else expected Pinkamena to show up in this episode?

[@jetenime]

aww

[@mikistenbeck6517]

there were several moments i thought "she" was gonna show, 15:42 is one of them,

[@laszlozsurka8991]

This episode could've been a great chance for her to make an appearance.

[@mikistenbeck6517]

yes, but "Party of one" was more then enough for me, i don't really like seeing Pinkie in her "Pinkamena" state,

[@sunshinehp1542]

I really wanna see pinkamena again.

[@elana1463]

Hm, maybe we can figure out how many Pies Rainbow got. The Wonderbolts got monthly pie donations, so that are 12 There is a birthday pie half birthday pie opposite day pie not your birthday but I made you a pie anyway day so 16 regular pies every year...and then there are also the pies for irregular reasons, and the pies she gets served when someone else has a birthday So I would guess at least 24 pies every year

[@rockyc6480]

:0 good job

[@ImaginationGamer25]

20:51 The abject horror on his face at the sight of that pie... XD

[@feqbrony8989]

Who else expected Pinkie’s mane to go straight throughout the episode?

[@Spelllboundmiyuki]

Meh

[@malachi9690]

22:58 Pinkie is actually chocking Dash. She hasn't completely forgiven her.

[@SpacialRend7]

Getting on Pinkie’s bad side is the last thing you ever want to do because things get beyond weird and downright freaky!

[@imanishraf6215]

SpacialRend7 I don't wanna know her bad side, she already full of unexplainable and non logical things in her good side.

[@GabrielaTorres-ow4lt]

Pie. Mmm

[@IsaacAllison]

amalie Torres Cupcakes!

[@BlueflagAlpha]

she will become party of one

[@gachagirl3948]

Yeah you can prove that in “The last roundup”

[@seraineity]

"Wheres soarin when you need him?" He's busy eating applejack's pies xD

[@oncepinkatryn_]

Xd

[@princesslightningstrike4592]

I want Soarin too.

[@miss_irine5423]

Wow, huge fan

[@Shritistrang]

Why was Applejack in this episode? Well, to deliver those apples to Pinkie, of course. Also, her accidentally landing in Pinkie's party planning cave was hilarious.

[@oliwermattsson1478]

i dont judge her being in this episode i just enjoyed rainbow dashs and pnkies hug

[@Omega-eu7kb]

The amazing thing about this episode is that it's based on the fact that we never saw Rainbow dash eat one pie in the entire show

[@Edward256]

Makes me wonder how she got through The Sisterhooves Social race...

[@iicliz2350]

Yukomatsu Cotton_Ash I wonder if she ever lied to Applejack about her apple pies.

[@Omega-eu7kb]

MLP Legend well Pinkie is the one who bakes pie for the group AJ probably sell the one she cooks or if she cooks for the mane6 the attention isn't entirely on RD so she can just not eat the pie.

[@Diovolol]

@@Edward256 I'm guessing she made it past it by not actually eating the pie but by slamming her face into the pie like a woodpecker

[@princessdreamixbeautix4637]

What about season 2 episode 24?

[@Kelaiah01]

Did you notice that when Pinkie asked the WonderBolts if they'd be able to pick the pies out of a line-up, that Soarin was the only one who smiled when he nodded? ;) Of COURSE he'd smile, he LOVES pie! XD

[@sajida227]

Wait if that wasent rainbow dash then who was that

[@princesslightningstrike4592]

I love Soarin.

[@iceblacktempestrv6426]

14:32 They do have trees in Cloudsdale.

[@demonicangel3191]

Oh we’re the wonderbolts and we fly super fast and we’re from Cloudsdale which is a part of equestria! We’re like fast and we fly super fast and we also really like that it has nice TREEEES! (Haven’t heard this in a while so I probably got it wrong. XD)

[@iceblacktempestrv6426]

Neutral Person Hilarious.

[@bsky91]

14:55 I had to laugh so HARD when she got taken away like that. Almost like she was being taken to the Asylum.

[@felidaeunplugged8316]

I know you probably won't see this Applegeek but I'm going to say it anyway.When I first discovered your channel,I was going through a difficult period.Your over the top,honest reactions and commentary made me smile and watch the show again.Thank you.

[@applegeek2597]

Thank you so much for sharing that. It's been a while since I've been monitoring comments, largely because of spoilers, but a friend shared this one with me. I'm so happy that I have been able to bring a smile to your face!

[@supergracelps8067]

TOO MUCH PINKIE DASH SHIPPING! I'm about to scream! -takes in a big breath-..............yay......(that's a fluttershy scream)

[@obviouslyzara9406]

*I'm kind of a "Flutterdash" shipper but sonic rainboom callback*

[@annieis_a_legendary_female9919]

Super Gracelps There can never be too much Pinkiedash! It is best ship in my opinion after all.

[@sukisu9961]

Super Gracelps so your saying that you ship them of lesbians? Eh sorry I normally ship boys with girls like fluttercord that’s who I ship the most😉😉

[@KaityKat117]

@@sukisu9961 Imagine being that homophobic. o3o

[@princessdreamixbeautix4637]

@@obviouslyzara9406 Flutterdash seriously? You don't remember how awful Rainbow treats Fluttershy sometimes? This would never work. I also don't like how in season 9 they turned Rainbow into a lesbian. This is so stereotypical that girl who likes male sporty things is a lesbian. I don't like it.

[@JinxProductions]

Just realized, when Tank ate the pie, he also ate the container. That can’t be good for him

[@joshblackwell8632]

So what do you guys think of the episodes Josh Hamilton has written so far??? ("Parental Glideance", "Triple Threat" and "Secrets and Pies") Are you looking forward to the next episode he rights???

[@RubberyCat]

I'll answer like this: It was some time since i saw Pinkie Pie done entirely correct (when a writer left, i'm bad at names), but finally i see that at least one of the new ones knows how she ticks. Essentially, he's _really_ good, or even Great! at describing ALL the characters i've seen him touch thus far.

[@7Seraphem7]

In order. Pure, freaking WIN! Not bad, but has issues. Pure hilarity! he does great character stuff... but does seem to have issues making the morals fit in naturally with what's going on and getting them out in a way that feels natural and works well.

[@applejoy4411]

I don't have much to say on any of the episodes except that they were okay.

[@CanterlotCrusader]

I really like them. Maybe he made Dash's parents a little too exaggerated, but you could tell there was a lot of fun making these episodes. This one is one of the funniest episodes in a long time where the whole thing front to back was jokes.

[@demonicangel3191]

1. I’m glad to see rainbow’s parents. The episode does have its moments and I didn’t hate this episode, but I thought that episode was just really mediocre. I felt like it just could’ve been better. 2. I honestly don’t have that much to say about this episode. It was kind of a boring episode tbh. Saw where it was going from a mile a way. 3. Kind of the same thing like the second one, except that it was a small and fun episode. So far he’s doing ok in my book.

[@Gokuvstheworld]

A First World Problem: When you want soda to drink but you only have clean water to drink. A Pinkie Pie World Problem: When Pinkie Pie makes you very tasty pies that she want you to eat, but you don't have a taste for them

[@psychick7]

I think Applejack's in the episode as a joke. Being that the lesson is you can always tell me the truth, and if she'd had a better idea of what was going on the whole issue would probably have been resolved years ago. Basically applejack is here to mock all episodes like this one where everything gets blown way out of proportion when there's a simple solution. And frankly that's funniest joke of the episode to me.

[@titanhades4331]

The Rainbow Pie shippers are happy. At least Rainbow likes the most important pie. 😊

[@mayeastudio2194]

Nightmare Dash is such a good idea of name for her vilain self though,nice job

[@penguinmaster7]

"it's worth all the trouble just to see her happy" now that's friendship :3

[@pragyaabha]

Doctor: Perhaps it’s a Pie Pandemic! Me watching in 2020: *GASP* SHE KNEW

[@catherinecalmerin1825]

This

[@veemonfan8102]

A Pie Pandemic sounds better than a Coronavirus pandemic right about now.

[@aegirfairy2124]

She hates Applejack's Pies too.

[@rockyc6480]

I swore she ate a apple jack one a earler season

[@juneterrago9795]

Pinkie: "I DON'T WANNA HEAR IT!!!" Applegeek: "Well, that was far more public than it needed to be." No kidding!!!!

[@funcoolfunfun]

This is one of the funniest episodes of the season. And while it's not among my top 8, it IS close.

[@arumikahaven]

I wonder if Pinkie's daydream about Rainbow shooting lasers is a nod to Derpy Wants Muffins. It's about the Cakes being out of muffins, and Derpy goes crazy, shooting laser eyes after Bulk eats the last muffin, its an great piece of fan animation XD

[@TailsFan369no2]

The actual title is epic rage time incredible derp

[@avientalley3495]

Applegeek: "Well, that was far more public than it needed to be." Me: Yeah, it happens to everyone.

[@jasontilford3397]

The look on your face when Pinkie says "Now EAT UP!" is just as funny as Best Pony's! XD 20:53 Another priceless expression.

[@ashlynwolff]

18:38 - It's obviously because... I have Amnesia! ..... - I was Brainwashed! ...... - It's ... Opposite Day? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I guess RD just don't like eating sweetness like candy, corn, pies.. 20:56 jeez I couldn't not respect Dash for That

[@autumbreeze1129]

17:22 well, Dash did get that Rainbow Power from the Tree of Harmony, so it giving her access to something like the Speed Force isn't too outrageous an idea, when you think about it

[@RpGfreak901]

16:27 She is going into full Pinkamina mode!!!!

[@kellingc]

"Your hugs are toi tight" "No, they're not." Why do I get the feeling that she's kind of getting back at Rainbow with the tight hugs?

[@princeedmirovillar8044]

She had enough of Rainbow's shit

[@LoneWhiteMage]

I love me a good Pinkie Pie episode.

[@MrSeyker]

Oh, wow. I hadn't realized when I watched the episode that Dash accessed the speed force. She broke physics just to not eat pie.

[@TheSmokingSkull]

Not usually one to poke fun at this, but Pinkie did just say "my pies are her favorite!" when talking about Rainbow Dash, and "seeing you eat my pie makes me happy". One only needs to know their Urban Dictionary to get what I'm saying. FiM has had a bunch of dialogue/visual moments like this, even from the very first season up till now.

[@shadowx8145]

The Smoking Skull get your mind out of the gutter XD

[@TheSmokingSkull]

darcel francis ;D

[@7Seraphem7]

Oh, the writers had to know what they were doing.

[@Ojunix]

Innuendo! in a show about Pastel Color Ponies. :D

[@MLPDethDealr32]

Yes she did XD This is one reason i stopped thinking it was just for kids. Especially when we've had gags like this.

[@DanielDiCenso]

Having AJ and Twilight.....Well, they do tend to be the most rational (USUALLY) out of the girls and when you're dealing with a nut like Pinkie.....

[@kmpgos4158]

6:09 I find it funny and ironic that, considering party planning cave is a reference to Batman, Pinkie's character is like a mix between batman and joker in this episode. (She's investigating and sneaking around, which is what Batman often do, but also have a lot of crazy moments). Long story short. Pinkie-Joker with Party Planning Cave is the funniest Batman.

[@scootaloofromponyville1708]

Fun fact, Pinkie licking her eyeballs to free them of fluids, instead of blinking is ACTUALLY something reptiles like lizards or some amphibians like geckos do since THEY don't have eye lids

[@orchid3795]

9:35 Well, technically humans are animals too, and a lot of other animals can't eat "people food" :)

[@dannysylvain3723]

I like this episode but i would love an RD episode that doesn't involve her having to learn a lesson or apologize . make it an episode where she teaches somepony else a lesson

[@titanhades4331]

Problem is, its very hard to think of any lesson she could teach another pony that is not already covered by the others.

[@dannysylvain3723]

it doesn't have to be a lesson. it could be showing guidance to a pony ,in a task that RD is skilled in. or situation she's been through/in

[@titanhades4331]

The only pony I can think of her teaching anything to is Scotaloo. I could have sworn we've seen her do that. Or have we yet to see that?

[@titanhades4331]

Wait, I got it? How about that one in season 4, Rainbow Falls ? And Wonderbolts Acedemy from Season 3. Or Griffin the Brush off from Season 1. Top Bolt and Stranger Than Fan Fiction in season 6.

[@dannysylvain3723]

well i guess she has had a lot good guidance moments in the past seasons But i would like some more RD and Scootaloo episodes next season

[@malachi9690]

31:18 It's one of her flaws, yes she can be blunt some times but sometimes she doesn't want to hurt her friends feelings. The most blunt we have seen her is in the earlier seasons. So she has changed considerably.

[@kaylagaymon4873]

This episode was freaking hilarious. Pinkie Pie's crazy facial expressions always make me laugh. Rainbow Dash didn't want to hurt Pinkie Pie's feelings 🥧🥧🥧🤪🤪🤪🤣🤣🤣

[@TimeturnerJ]

There'll be so much fanart of Pinkie's Nightmare!Dash. xD

[@sajida227]

Is she was dreaming or what because dash says she dident remember her self doing that so hm

[@srikanthramprasad565]

I am glad that after the events of MMMystery on Friendship Express which was 5 seasons ago Pinkie finally is a real detective as she managed to get all the facts straight.

[@christinadust126]

Throughout the whole episode I was wondering why Dash didn't tell her the truth until the end with the big hug it made me think. Would Pinkie deny that Dash hates pies?

[@titanhades4331]

Pies are one things. Hugs are an entirely different matter. 😊

[@RubberyCat]

I suspect that she goes by "Love hurts .... a little". ^_^

[@7Seraphem7]

Pinkie is an expert hugger, she know she hugs are just right. It's not her hugs that are too tight, it's everypony elses hugs are to loose.

[@Doomsday-yo7lh]

Well, in a follow up comic, Pinkie spends a whole day trying to get Dash to try pies but then she learns the lesson that everyone has different tastes and she stops being a Pinkie Pie and becomes chill.

[@stardustpie967]

16:22 Pinkie's version of tardy mode

[@1989JROG]

@ 15:47-15:48 why do i get the feeling that Pinkie’s face is going to have a meme and/or gif? 😂

[@twinpony]

15:46 pinkie pie: now EAT UP! LOL

[@twinpony]

16:40 pinkie licks her own eyes to keep them moisturize like a chameleon.

[@twinpony]

also Andrea libman sure did an amazing job of voicing pinkie. lol

[@twinpony]

also at 15:04: that was a stupid and silly plan pinkie come up with. I mean she didn't even think that rainbow would fly up to grab her and put her on the ground instead of eating the pie mountain.

[@twinpony]

plus applegeek reaction to her manic expression is hilarious and surprised. LOL

[@noctisalucis3462]

Thank u from saving me from the pies so have a pie😌😇 👿NOW EAT UP

[@twinpony]

16:40 chameleon like it's eyes to stay moisture. also she takes after gummy. lol XD 😂.

[@gianlucasevastamula8630]

You mean geckos right ?

[@twinpony]

@@gianlucasevastamula8630 yep.

[@ScarletFury]

Ah good ol' technology... it not working and raging at it, you do something normal that you normally do with it afterwards and suddenly it works and you just sit there like... What the hay?!?... you gotta love our love hate relationship with it! xD

[@comicbookmoviegamer2122]

This was good episode. Pinkie pie is really scary when she is mad. Also I hope to see fan art of evil Rainbow Dash.

[@DanknDerpyGamer]

"How about this, your hugs are too tight." "Hahahaha, hahaha, no they're not." 😂 🤣 😂 🤣 😂 🤣 😂 🤣

[@arcanezira]

Has anyone seen the new movie? Did you notice we actually never see Tempest's cutie mark? We don't see it either in the comic book they pre-released as an introduction to the new characters. Could it be she doesn't have one because her horn was broken!?! She's so frantic about her quest because her destiny was taken away from her!

[@socgraffiti]

Applegeek, the Wonderbolts get monthly pie donations. Soaring then eats said pies! Lol

[@RubberyCat]

This was a GREAT episode. It is a back to the roots-like thing, meaning (like season 1 - 2) having a simple but highly entertaining story. ^_^

[@SnugglyDashie]

CAD SARN IT YOU ARE TOO GOOD XD seriously though you need to be a detective. Like you realize everything early on in these reactions. And while i love that, i do kinda sorta want one or two to slip over your head for part of it to ensure a nive red bull imduced reaction at the reveal. 💙 much love to you

[@brynncollins2513]

Here are some things I thought were funny: Pinkie Pie: Chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga Choo-Choo! “You really added that sparkle to that pressure diamond drop.” She sounds a lot like Rainbow Shimmer. RAINBOW DASH LIES!!!! Fauna “Pie Pandemic!” COVID-19. Applejack: I could’ve told her that.

[@kaneaquino8295]

Epic Rage Time (From Alligator in Tub Production) had Derpy shoot lasers from her eyes when she didn't get her muffins.

[@delta6884]

i honestly love how much you laugh when reacting to mlp episodes

[@jadacrossgrove7045]

His face when he saw the gross pie 😂

[@peachypeachessss]

I love watching your reactions!!!! I’m so glad you enjoyed this episode! Can’t wait to watch more reactions 💜

[@kariannrodriguez4996]

'Pink me too

[@Narrator007]

1:44 "Derpy!!" Talking to White Lightning, for some reason.

[@ChipmunkRaccoon3]

I'm surprised Pinkie didn't say, "I can't believe I forgot she can fly!" after being saved from her "pie pyramid".

[@ljp878]

I had thought that this one would go along the route of Pinkie being obsessed with finding the truth and exposing Dash's lies would cause her to care more about that goal than trying to reconcile with her friend or anything else. Even though it went on a slightly different path, I was overall pleased with the episode. =3 Plus your reactions are priceless! XD Fun stuff. ^^

[@jetenime]

I love this episode because not too long ago I started shipping Pinkie and Rainbow Dash, because they're the one ship that I actually see happening. The fact that they both went through trouble to do something just to see each other happy because it made them happy was just so sweet and made me ship them more! Edit: Oh, I also love the reference to "Party of One" Always great to see references like that, especially all the way back to season 1, and one of the best episodes at that.

[@brianclroblox4604]

20:50 The moment everyone felt sick.

[@NagelTubeHD]

11:48 Pinkie Pie, you have a weird way of imagination! What is this dream based on?! 🤣🤣🤣 14:47 @Applegeek, that doesn’t make any sense! 🤣🤣🤣 15:00 Pinkie Pie, how did you do that?! I swear, she’s a living cartoon! 🤣🤣🤣 20:50 OMG, @Applegeek! Did Rainbow Dash just do that?! (Oh thank God!) That face killed me! 🤣🤣🤣 21:27 I don’t know why, but I find that funny! 🤣🤣🤣 23:06 why is your laugh so funny? 🤣

[@twinpony]

that episode is so hilarious! lol XD 😂

[@princesslightningstrike4592]

Yes. I love it

[@alicewilloughby4318]

9:16 - Pie pan-demic. No big reaction. I am too stunned.

[@5evelid7]

"Its not even my birthday"

[@jonasfletcher9926]

Rainbow has been donating pies to the wonderbolts. Some of then would've been eaten by Soarin.

[@spiritmeister8579]

8:39 ABOUT A WEEK AGO!!!!!

[@Enter_the_Toshiverse_1996]

Its the Leaning Tower of Pies! Better break out the whipped cream cause its coming down!

[@brony4life1982]

I agree, I would have spared Pinkie Pie's feelings and long going stuff and just told her from the start, I don't like Pies. Even myself I don't like some pies.

[@ninjagregshow9423]

I'm suddenly reminded of those vines of that guy singing "why you always lyin?"

[@twinpony]

nightmare dash stole superman's heat vision/cyclop's optic blast.

[@DanielDiCenso]

1st thing when I saw Dash's "pie." Did she ask Discord to go to Nurgle's realm to get it?? And the truth....Dash.....Ya can't cook for spit!

[@Emoinvadernixie]

also I honestly think in my opinion this is like a RainbowPie episode to me ^^~ (Rainbow Dash x Pinkie Pie)

[@jetenime]

It definitely is, those are some of my favorite episodes ^-^

[@Edward256]

I too found this to be a PinkieDash moment... I'm starting to think Pinkie may actually have a crush, and Rainbow is not fond of that.

[@peachypeachessss]

Edward256 I think the same way!!! Besides Rarijack, I think it’s a possible ship..? Because I do think they’re really close to each other

[@jetenime]

I think Rarijack is an adorable ship, but for some reason I just can't seem to see it happening. I don't why lol.

[@jetenime]

Edward256 I really hope that's the case, but I don't know if it's something Hasbro can do : ( I really want them too though, it would be nice.

[@connorthompson8376]

I think you're right that it harkens back to the kid level lessons of the earlier seasons. This reminded me of 'The Cart Before The Ponies,' but here they got the formula right.

[@SnugglyDashie]

SO SORRY IM LATE! Im on vacation currently on fall break. Ill make sure to be as early as possible this week. Great episode overall. My personal favorite part was when they confirmed that Tank is not dead :D

[@LunaHorizon]

Gummy is best voice of reason, Pinkie take off your tin foil hat.

[@PoniiAndii]

The thing I like about episode leaks is that reactions tend to be released way earlier.

[@elderscrollsswimmer4833]

Hah. The one person who could have REALLY told Pinkie about RD and what sort of food she likes is RD's mother. She didn't get interviewed here... Looks like there is one Pie RD likes (but not to eat) and that's Pinkie Pie... you just don't eat your friends, right? That nastiness? Mud Pie? We made that sort of things as children but never ate them. (If RD did, well...)

[@alicewilloughby4318]

5:53 - Seeing Gummy here reminds me; I recently learned that for a short time there was a comic book called "Royal Roy" (another comic company's answer to Richie Rich) in which Prince Roy had a pet alligator - quite a bit larger than Pinkie's - named... *Gummy!*

[@nicolasvillasecaali7662]

re-watching this and i just now realise the timing at 10:38 XDDD

[@paris4k]

pinkie pie is the only pony who can defiy the laws of phisics

[@Aprion]

This was fun. A nice lighthearted episode full of silliness.

[@Kickassreaction]

I'd say 22 24 and the finale are then this but it's still a good episode. Your reaction to the finale is gonna be fucking insane

[@amethyst_dawn]

Dayum, Ponka Po be Scary

[@guardian08527]

Nightmare Dash is the spitting image of a Deviant Art OC. Right down to the badly rendered outlines!

[@lheybell28]

20:52 dat face XD 😂

[@georgeharvey4226]

I honestly wasn't sure what to expect from this one. Here are my highlights: 1:41-1:45 Hi Berry Punch. Also I missed seeing Derpy. 1:50-1:53 Pinkie claims "pie baking is more art than science." 1:55-2:02 Twilight and Applegeek have the same thought. 2:03-2:14 You've got to hand...umm...hoof it to her. She's devoted to detail. 2:06-2:08 Yep, very obvious reasons. 2:09-2:19 I know right. Can you really have a pie with 73 different flavours at once? Then again, it is Pinkie we're talking about here. 2:15-2:28 Wow. How was Twilight able to catch all that? I'm glad you managed to Applegeek - I didn't. 2:38-2:41 Her saying this reminded me of Coco Puffs for some reason. And don't even eat them. 2:51-2:57 Translation: Sugar Rush. 2:51-3:09 Classic funny Pinkie Pie - even Twilight agrees. 3:50 Hi Spitfire, Soarin, Fleetfoot, Sky Stinger, Vapour Trail and Rainbow Dash. 3:52-3:57 I noticed that too. 3:57 Pinkie using balloons to stay on top of the clouds. Nice attention to detail there, Josh Hamilton. 4:03-4:07 We know, Dash. Applegeek and Twilight said the same thing a couple of minutes ago. 4:10-4:15 I didn't know that. So is the show referencing itself? 4:10-4:18 That's understandable. But the question remains: what will she do for her 100th training session? 4:18 It does look appetising. And I don't even eat pie. 4:28-4:31 Was that necessary? 4:40-4:50 How are the pie and plate not falling through the clouds? That's some poor attention to detail there, animators. 4:57 Hi again Sky and Vapour. 5:07 Oh, I see, I guess it was necessary. Also, wouldn't it have been better not to show the pie in the trash until after it passed Pinkie? The payoff would've felt stronger. 5:20 Pinkie loses a ballon. 5:24 Pinkie rummaging through the trash. 5:25-5:29 Good question. They can't just dump it towards the ground, can they? 5:35-5:46 Pinkie freaking out. 5:43 "Like trash, in the trash, with other trash." 5:50 I didn't notice that was done Batman style. 5:51 Party Planning Cave - I guess this is Batman. 5:52-5:57 I guess chocolate could do that to you. 6:06-6:09 Pinkie laughing hysterically. 6:10-6:16 I don't think that's it, Pinkie. 6:17-6:22 Evil queen? Who are you talking about? Chrysalis? 6:22 Pinkie watching Gummy's tongue. 6:25-6:29 Two fun facts: you can protect yourself from brainwashing by acting stubborn; and Rainbow Dash is unhygienic. 6:38 What actually are poison berries? They're not really poisonous are they? Otherwise people wouldn't eat them. 6:50 Flashback to Rainbow Dash's Birthaversary. Also, hi Derpy's backside. 6:50-7:35 Rainbow, how could you! 7:08 That pony also has a rainbow Cutie Mark. 7:15-7:18 "It's not your Birthday but here's a Pie anyway Day". 7:24-7:27 But it is "Here's a Pie anyway Day". 7:40-7:46 Pinkie answers her own question. 7:48 'MMMystery in the Friendship Express' callback. 7:50-7:54 Applegeek stumbles on his words. 7:59-8:03 Who does Spitfire think she is, the Terminator? 8:02 Pinkie's eye. 8:26-8:29 Pinkie going full-on cop. Also, what line-up? How does this situation call for a line-up? 8:29 Hi Dr. Fauna. 8:32-8:41 You worked it out, Applegeek. 8:46 Nice diagram of Winola there - I doubt I spelt her name right. 8:49 "Thanks for lending me your jacket Peach Pie." 8:53-8:58 Pinkie Pie, the preciously-positive, pink party-planning pony, ponders that the pieces of the puzzle are plopping into place and the picture isn't pretty - try saying that five times real fast. 8:59-9:03 My thoughts exactly. 9:04 Funny X-ray. 9:07-9:10 No, because she's a vet. Not a forensic scientist. 9:18-9:24 Dr. Fauna suspects a "Pie Pandemic"; Pinkie thinks she knows "Pony Patient Zero." (I think that's that's enough alliterations for one episode.) 9:28-9:40 An important, yet confusing lesson. 9:35 Nice picture of Celestia in the background. 9:38 I noticed it first, Applegeek. 9:40-9:58 You said it for me, Applegeek 10:07 And there's the classic investigation chart. 10:14-10:17 Gummy: "I can't answer, I'm just a quiet alligator." 10:29-10:43 Pinkie Pie finally deduces the truth. 10:49 Hi Applejack. 10:56-10:58 Whoops. 10:59-11:01 Nice catch. 11:38-11:42 I've been getting them for a while now, too. Although it tend to associate craziness with 'Lesson Zero'. 11:40-12:26 Pinkie goes overboard with her imagination. 11:49-12:26 Demon Rainbow Dash. 11:52-11:56 Applegeek's face. 12:10-12:26 Laser eyes. 12:43-12:47 Why did I think briefly that Pinkie Pie was going to poison Rainbow Dash? 12:55-12:57 "Operation: Pie of Lies". 13:02 Bye Pinkie. 13:04-13:06 How did you get out the last time? Go up the slide? 13:09-13:12 That would freak anyone out. 13:11-13:57 Rainbow with a frizzy mane. 13:12-13:14 "Unofficial wake your Friends up Day." 13:18-13:21 So true, so very true. 13:20 That face. 13:27-13:31 Funny. 13:37 That face, too. 13:40-13:42 The biggest problem with sneezing: you have to close your eyes. 13:42-13:50 That secret hole and pipe system. 14:03 Pinkie's eye twitching. 14:06 Pinkie losses all her balloons. How is she going to get down now? 14:25-14:29 Wow, the one time she actually means it. 14:38-14:57 Pinkie Pie strapped down. 14:55-14:57 Wait, where is he taking her? Isn't that the end of the runway? 14:58 Agreed. 15:03-15:10 She's really going bonkers with these ideas, isn't she? 15:10-15:16 How will eating the pies save you exactly? 15:18-15:23 Pinkie forgets that Rainbow Dash is a Pegasus. 15:28-15:30 Angry Pinkie. 15:30 Pie avalanche. 15:35-15:38 I was thinking the same thing. I guess it's just not the way her mind works. 15:39-15:43 Pinkie getting crazier. 15:46-15:49 Those faces - from Applegeek and Pinkie Pie both. 15:51-15:59 Rainbow Dash always has a plan. 16:04-16:07 It's funny you should say that. Keep watching. 16:06-16:08 Those faces. 16:10 Hi Bon-Bon. 16:14-16:17 That's an understatement. 16:22 Does it look like she's okay? 16:27-16:31 Those faces. 16:33-16:40 Pinkie would be good at facing the Weeping Angles. 16:40 That's disgusting. 16:46-17:10 Rainbow Dash: the queen of staling. 16:51-16:54 Those faces. 16:52-16:55 That's actually a really good question. 16:59-17:02 Those faces. 17:04 That face, too. 17:07-17:09 Milk does go great with pie - so I've been told. 17:10-17:12 Those faces. 17:13-17:23 Slow motion - with a lighting-quick Rainbow Dash. 17:31 That face. 17:41-17:41 Finally. This is what you should have done from the start. 17:46 Don't deny it Dash, we've all seen it. 18:01-18:08 To her credit, she really makes it sound like she genuinely doesn't understand. I'd believe her if I hadn't seen things with my own eyes. 18:13 Good point. 18:21-18:23 You took the words right out of my mouth, Applegeek. 18:24-18:47 Rainbow Dash: the queen of excuses. 18:41/18:43 Pinkies eyes. 18:52-19:01 Trust me Dash, you don't want to know. 19:12-19:14 Dash upset. 19:14-19:25 Applegeek and Twilight have a point, Rainbow Dash. 19:35 It's been a while since we've seen one of those from Applejack. 19:43-19:52 Exactly. 19:56-19:59 Or just admitted you didn't like them - Applegeek agrees with me. 20:08-20:12 What are you implying Pinkie? 20:18 I see what's behind her and I'm worried - I thought this show did well to avoid gross-out humour. 20:29-20:33 I guess she has a point. I don't think anypony needs that many pies. 20:37-20:39 "Pieling System." 20:49-20:51 Where did you even find the ingredients to make that monstrosity?! The sewer? 20:51-21:00 Applegeek's face and reaction. 20:53-20:55 ARE YOU TRYING TO COMMIT SUICIDE?! 21:05-21:12 There are better ways to apologise than torturing yourself, Rainbow Dash. 21:10-21:12 Even Pinkie is horrified. 21:17-21:20 Applegeek's face. 21:18 Gross. 21:23-21:26 I don't think that's how stairs work. 21:26-21:31 I thought you said you made it, Dash? 21:43 Hi Derpy's backside, again. 22:14-22:17 That face. 22:45-22:49 Also, I know you hate washing, Dash, but you seriously need a bath. 22:49-23:01 Lots of characters have needed honesty lessons lately haven't they? Rainbow Dash, Twilight, Shinning Armour, Iron Will - you need to step up a little more AJ. 22:56 Rainbow Dash's face. 23:01-23:17 Applegeek laughing at Pinkie's denial. 23:08 And a Pie to close. All in all, I wouldn't call this episode a homerun, but it's definitely been one my favourites in a while. The last few stories were good, but something about them just didn't seem to click for me. Here, however, I was entertained throughout. The story was simple, the moral was relatable and Pinkie Pie's antics - well, they were just as funny as ever. We only have one story left before the big finale. Let's see what they have in store for us.

[@chaosblur]

I had pretty much the same exact reaction to that ... pie? (it looks like some kind of unholy abomination who has only heard of the concept of pie, but has no earthly or otherworldly idea what a pie actually is, a twisted reflection, a horrific perversion of everything that pie stands for, a steaming moldy tin of death and decay masquerading as a pie)

[@sassytygrysica9623]

I help or not?

[@dakotadoyle7573]

13:09 I was thinking this episode needed some more cowbell Also how is Pinkie standing in RD's house without her balloons?

[@autumbreeze1129]

10:15 Sci-twi would be proud😋

[@socialanimeranger86]

Hey Apple Geek, I know you like collecting stuffed ponies so I have a deal for you! Build-A-Bear online is having a sale on MLP the Movie Plushies. If you really liked the movie and wanted a Tempest or Songbird Serenade then they have those as well. They also have Twilight, Pinkie Pie, Fluttershy, Luna, Big Mac, Rarity, Rainbow Dash, Starlight, and Trixie. It's a buy two for price of one along with accessories and other add on's for the characters. Tempest Shadow looks really good and I just bought her and her Storm King armor outfit along with Trixie and her outfit all less than $50. The ponies without any add on or accessories is only $17 each if you buy two. Just figure I give you the heads up and anyone else reading this comment.