Ascension and Coronation in the Islamic World | Al Muqaddimah

Don't forget to like, comment, share and subscribe.
Video of the coronation of Mehmed VI: • Crowning of Mehmed VI ...
Find Al Muqaddimah Elsewhere: linktr.ee/AlMuqaddimahYT
Help Al Muqaddimah Financially: linktr.ee/PayMyRent
Disclaimer: The maps and flags in the video are not 100% accurate. Some maps and flags are difficult to find and so, are estimations.
Be sure to check out my Patreon Page. Even if you can't pledge, still visit it and check out the content I'll post there.
Music by epidemicsound.com
If you had a problem with the video, or found something to be incorrect, please send me a message, rather than being a jerk and reporting it.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Al Muqaddimah is, sadly, still demonetized. Please consider pledging a dollar or more at the following link to help Al Muqaddimah produce these videos. Thank you! www.patreon.com/AlMuqaddimahYT

[@makisekurisu4674]

Please make video on the ottoman empire!

[@hadtrio6629]

Why didn't you cover the Moroccan baia?

[@theculturedjinni]

Well to be honest, it is not really coronation when it comes to the caliphs as they are not supposed to be kings, but rather implementers of the will of God chosen through shuura or majlis, and even later during the umayyad and abbasid periods, you still had process of accepting heirs to the throne. Early caliphates were not absolutist monarchies, but rather some sort of elective oligarchic dictatorship based upon religious foundations. Maybe process of ascension to power would have been a better description of this entire process rather than coronation, on order to emphasize the difference between Caliphate and kingship? Though the nuances of the titles would have been hard to fit then, so I understand kind of why you added coronation to the video title too and why you kind of did skip through it rather quickly in the video. Yet, it should be said that you mentioned many things adjacent to this with the bay3a 👍& I think you did a very good job with it!

[@beepboop204]

demonetized?

[@mastergame3984]

End of time and Qiyamah signs, Imam Al-Mahdi will come from the east! Recently a man named Muhammad Qasim and his divine dreams about the rise of Islam are getting famous on social media. Many people are claiming that he is the Mahdi. Muhammad Qasim, the man with blessed dreams for Islam and Pakistan. His followers present him as Imam Mahdi. What is the message in his dreams ? In Islam true dreams have influenced the course of history. "Allah will not help Muslims until they eradicate Shirk at the state level", This is the claim of a man named Muhammad Qasim from Pakistan. He is also claiming to have Divine Dreams about the end of Time and the rise of his country.

[@thepubgguy595]

The "Animator" talked about at the start of the video is Al Muqaddimah himself 😅

[@HammadKhan-tl6bb]

How do you knoe

[@thepubgguy595]

@@HammadKhan-tl6bb read the description of the useful chart video

[@Despotic_Waffle]

Ah, Maqaddimah was doing the obama awarding a medal to himself meme

[@filhanislamictv8712]

I was about to write, your animation is great tol😅

[@piyush93688]

@@Despotic_Waffle It's like Modi getting a photo of himself as a gesture in a stadium named after himself.

[@Ozgur72]

The Ottoman ceremony video has tavern music as background. It is like watching Charles III's coronation with Spice Girls songs :)

[@dilanmukidisi4lanz986]

Lol

[@mh-tw4kx]

Yeah a bit of blasphemy

[@HistoryOfRevolutions]

“For those who practise tyranny and deprive others of their rights, I will be harsh and stern, but for those who follow the law, I will be most soft and tender.” - Umar ibn Al Khattab (2nd Caliph)

[@wizardmongol4868]

proceeds to whip his own son to death for breaking laws.

[@tarantula51]

Pretty hypocritical considering the caliphate is a dictactor

[@good__person]

@@tarantula51 what do you mean? dont you know that caliphs often take advice from their friend aka their supporters?

[@tarantula51]

@@good__person 😅 historically. no. on paper, yes. practically? no. no matter how much you try to mental gymnastic it, the caliphate is a tyrant. and the worse kind. take a good look at north korea. thats what the caliphate look like for 1300+years of its existent. up until it was abolish by gigachad ataturk.

[@jamieammar6131]

@@good__person Well, dictators take advice from their friends too. Caliphate is pretty much a dictatorship. But more like a benevolent autocracy, not a tyrannical one. The Rashidun caliphate anyway. A job of an autocrat is to keep the people happy who keep him/her in power. In the case of Rashidun, it was the military, specially the Syrian army and the house of Umayya.

[@fahdchmanti7632]

there is one modern example of the bayea. In morocco the king is called amir al muminin and when he becomes king the country officials take the bayea . and then every year they gather and renew their bayea

[@Hi5Ripon]

Its ironic as to how Moroccan King proclaim himself as Amir ul Muminin, yet look at his people full filled with materialistic and hedonistic people and their women walk around half-naked

[@fahdchmanti7632]

@@Hi5Ripon DFK

[@fahdchmanti7632]

@@Hi5Ripon DFK is a shortcut for the phrase diha f karek , which literally means mind your ass , which means its none of your business what moroccan women wear

[@mauratlantean3002]

​@@Hi5RiponMorocco has always been carrying the muslim world and will always be. God save our king Amir al Muminin. Keep hating

[@strasbourgeois1]

As a Christian I like Muslim tradition, and specifically their traditions like these. Peace be upon you all.

[@imimran924]

because we have similarities

[@VladVlad-ul1io]

Convert to ISLAM! WHAT AR EYOU WAITING FOR??? Don''t disbelieve because you will burn in hell

[@strasbourgeois1]

@@VladVlad-ul1io No. 😂 I have respect, but will never believe. We are similar but I am still staying to the religion I was born as and will NEVER switch. God forbid if I do, I hope I meet the worst punishment.

[@fawadahmedshaikh9893]

​@@VladVlad-ul1io it's his choice if h revert r not .we can only guide

[@kingkarna7168]

​@@strasbourgeois1 amen

[@tehaisikattepi9393]

Fun facts : World Oldest SURVIVING Sultanate are here in Malaysia . It is Malay sultanate of Kedah , from the same family since 1153 .

[@thedeadwarrior1828]

Interesting video, I would like to add that wali Al'ahd still had to collect bay'ah when they rose to power, also very interestingly in Morocco we have a tradition of writing down the bay'ah, a tradition that is almost 800 years old or even older, it was even once used against a moroccan sultan, where the army claimed that the new taxes he imposed on them was not in the bay'ah they had, so they rebelled supporting one of his brothers It us also worth noting that there existed a tradition of "bay'at al mawt" where an army would swear an oath to their emir to fight tell death, most famous was during the Abd allah ibn alzubair's defence of the kaaba from alhajjaj Last thing i would add is, interestingly, bay'at alhudaibya mentioned in the quran was a literal exchange, as those who swore the oath were given a right to the booty of the war on the jewish forts outside of Yatherib, even those who died before the battle had their families collect their portion of the booty, in a way it was a literal contract

[@Stoneworks]

This was a fascinating video, thank you for making it!

[@alexanderthegreat913]

Stoneworks? As in Minecraft server guy? Nice

[@AncientAmericas]

Really interesting topic! Well done!

[@Stoneworks]

I know you, you son of a gun

[@briansmith9439]

I was just reading, yesterday in fact, that Ka'b ibn Lu'ay, a direct ancestor of the Prophet (PBUH), began the practice of delivering a sermon on Friday during the 4th century CE as part of the Ibrahimic practices which became the basis for the Khutbah. The article I was reading mentioned many other practices now typically associated with Islam actually predated it, e.g. Abd al-Muttalib instituted the practice of giving one-fifth of any booty going to the poor and needy and that the Kaabah is to be circumambulated 7 times. Perhaps examining how Islam, rather than being a religion that sprang anew and fully-formed actually maintained many pre-Islamic traditions that people were already familiar with more-or-less. This work maintained that the things that carried forward into Islam did so only from the pre-Islamic monotheistic Ibrahimic religious practices but I wonder if that was the only source. The footage of the 1918 installation of Mehmet VI is - wow - what a visual record to have.

[@Narutnax]

Yes, there were remnants of Hanif religion, which was an Ibrahimic religion that had many customs and rituals from Ibrahim (pbuh). Contrary to popular belief that Islam took many rituals of pagan Arabs, actually it took Hanif rituals that was also mixed into pagans rituals. If I'm not mistaken there was Abu Amir (who himself was hanif), he accused prophet Muhammad (pbuh) of adding additional things to Hanif religion, to which Muhammad replied that he brought Hanif religion pure and white. Thus, we can conclude that Islam was not a new religion, it was a continuation of the religion of previous prophets. (also , can you give me the link of the article you had read?)

[@ubaidurrehman2167]

Thank you for another video ❤️

[@daarussalaam.]

Alhamdulillah thanks, this video about bay'ah is a great framework of thinking about how you could receive power rightfully & receiving the right of exercising power to the subjects by the consensus of both parties (the subjects and you as the will-be-governor of them)

[@alvarobaenahuerta7506]

Another great video!!!

[@kmmmsyr9883]

Thankfully, we have lots of information about Ottoman coronations. I really recommend reading about them and some other ceremonies like circumcision feasts of princes.

[@imiikhan]

really insightful ❤

[@masahibbhatti4088]

Love the videos game. Keep em coming

[@justvidanes2471]

Thank you for getting into detail about the ba’Ah. I have an affinity for secular thought and this bridges my understanding of the old ways of covenants and I had known when i talked to the Prophet in a dream. Thank you.

[@Mo_Mudabber]

Ok💀

[@kaysmith8992]

This makes me wonder, what about the 'faraway Islamic worlds' like Sub-Saharan Africa and Indonesia? What was their equivalent for the Sultan's 'coronation'? These regions seem starkly different from the Arab/Turkic/Persian worlds, I'm less familiar with sub-Saharan Africa but Indonesia seems to have preserved a huge amount of unusual pre-Islamic rituals so i wonder if likewise their 'coronation' equivalent had more pre-Islamic relics.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

There's a lot of interesting stuff to be found in India and Morocco (as the comments have enlightened me, Malaysia as well) but this video was focused on the "Caliphates" only or it would be a much longer video. I might talk about those other places when William comes to the throne. Maybe.

[@ummfaizal]

You can search video on KZbin about coronation of Sultan Ibrahim of Johor, Malaysia in 2015. It's resembled British coronation, but before the coronation, Ottoman flag was raised in front of Grand Palace because the current Johor dynasty got their Sultan title from Ottoman Caliph in 1880s during Maharaja Abu Bakar of Johor visit to Istanbul to meet Sultan Abdel Aziz.

[@meninsilau]

Little i know in Indonesia... After choosen by democratic means, they'll make an oath with their respectative holy book overhead.

[@ummfaizal]

@@meninsilau Current Javanese kingdoms (Sultanate of Yogyakarta, Sunanate of Surakarta and Dukedom of Mangkunegara & Paku Alam) also have the girding ceremony but not sword but with dagger of Keris. Then gamelan ensemble music start with melody of frog after rain (Kodok Ngorek) invoking blessing from sky.

[@smavi4133]

@@ummfaizal the Ottoman flag is raised? I don’t know, I might be biased here but that’s beautiful. It shows that there is, even on regal level, some traces of a classical caliphate. Although spending the majority of my spare time on reading about Islamic history, I hear this for the first time. Thank you for this information!

[@CooperDianeBob]

I recently went looking for books and articles about this and court life in the Muslim world there's some interesting stuff

[@Merle1987]

I been waiting forever... For your videos... Siyawish.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

I will be posting more regularly now, hopefully.

[@Artur_M.]

Very interesting!

[@aliburakgunduz4040]

The tradition of the Ottomans taking the throne by swearing on their ancestors' sword actually comes from an old nomadic tradition. The Romans write that the Huns similarly took the throne by swearing on the sword.

[@MustardAndFries]

Is there anyway you could include sources for the topics discussed?

[@SaszaDerRoyt]

15:41 what is rhe source of this map? It looks similar to the work of a particular post-medieval cartographer but I can't tell for sure

[@seneca983]

I found almost the same map on Getty Images with the caption: "Old engraving depicting map of Constantinopolis (Istanbul), the capital of the Byzantine and the Ottoman empires. Printed in 1572 by Braun and Hogenberg in Civitates Orbis Terrarum. Photo by N. Staykov (2007)".

[@micahistory]

interesting, never gave this a thought before

[@mfaizsyahmi]

Today I learned that the khutbahs was a tool in asserting fielty. I always thought that the prayers read for the Sultan and heir's health read in khutbahs here where I live is standard practice, not knowing it possibly used to pray for the Caliph before the tragic dissolution of the institution. Also fun seeing the King of Malaysia, Defender of Faith in such Malaysian states and territories without a Sultan and thus prayed for in khutbahs in such places, cameod in the coronation video right at the anointing part.

[@ummfaizal]

Khutbah used for political power already happened during Banu Umayyah reign when they delivered khutbah to curse Ali. Ali retaliated by using azan and qunut to condemn Muayiwah for becoming rebels (as he declared he is Caliph in Syria) against his caliphate in every prayer . That's why every Shiah's azan will have the declaration of Ali as Waliyullah and every salah they'll have qunut

[@ummfaizal]

We are not sure if before Ottoman dissolution, our ancestors here prayed for the Ottomans or not in khutbah. Because Ottoman Caliphate legality was in question. According to Ahlul Hadis (Shafi'i and Hanbali madhab) only Quraisy clan can claimed to Caliphate. The Bendahara dynasty of Johor claim to be from Ba'alawi of Aydarus of Yemen and used title of Khalifah and Zillullah fil Allam. The Johor Sultanate have high prestige among Malays because they're successor to Malacca Sultanate. Plus they have Nobat troupe that claimed from prophet Ibrahim and Alexander the Great, the music played during installation of Yang Di-Pertuan Agong. We don't have coronation but installation of King. Except for Johor, Selangor, Terengganu and Kelantan that have their own crowns.

[@pamtam1]

Fundamentally, Khutbah is NOT a tool for anything except it is a mandatory part of Salaah and that it (Khutbah) should consist of the Aqwaal of ALLAH SWT (meaning the words of the Quran) and the Prophet (PBUH) meaning Hadees. Apart from these fundamentals, one can make dua, essentially for Muslims and everyone else. But because there is a minimum requirement of Khutbah but NOT an upper limitation of what CANNOT be said about praising or making Dua of a supposed Caliph or prime minister or head of state of President or Army leader etc, one can use the Khutbah as a “Tool”. At the end of it all, one has to realize and remember that Khutbah of Friday is part of Salaah (specifically in lieu of the first two Rakats (cycles) of prayer) and the essential/Mandatory parts are the Aqwaal (words) of ALLAH SWT meaning the words of Quran and that of the Prophet (PBUH).

[@pamtam1]

The rulers and the people of the Muslim world, due to lack of freedom of expression about political views have time and again, blatantly appropriated this sacred part of Friday Khutbah and have tried to convert the Khutbah as a “Tool” and extension to make up for their lack of communication with the people by way of honest administration/governance, primarily the peaceful transfer of power. Had Islam been a creation of the Muslims, the Muslims would have decimated every aspect of Islam right in the beginning.

[@ummfaizal]

@@pamtam1 in my country Malaysia, the mandatory part are delivered in Arabic (praises to Allah, salawat, 2 verses of Quran and du'a, per Shafi'i madhab) while the rest of khutbah delivered in Malay language. The second khutbah mostly contain lengthy of du'a, this du'a contain prayers for our sultan as head of Islam (an adoption of English constitution for king as head of Church of England 😊). In my state of Kelantan, the sultan always late for Friday prayer, the khutbah cannot delivered until the sultan, the head of Islam came, he's always late that 2.30pm or 3pm only can start the khutbah. The zohor time 1.15pm😢

[@16tonw8]

In your video, you mention that "quite a few" Sunnis believe that the Prophet chose Ali to be his successor. Could you make a video expanding on this?

[@Buurba_Jolof]

Thanks

[@griveouswithhislightsabers3665]

Hey man could you suggest me some series.

[@niltomperimneto]

Can you share the bibliography about this topic that you used?

[@abdolrahmanhamed2821]

Hey Syawish i'm a Muslim and i really like the Islamic content that you produce ,But i want to know one thing if may i ask what do you think of the famous Imam Abu Hamid al-Ghazali and Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah and i respectfully want you to respond.

[@Husayn0318]

8:26 No reputable Sunni scholar has ever said that the Prophet ﷺ nominated Ali as his spiritual/political successor!

[@UniViews]

Firstly the other videos you made I learned a lot from them so thank you sir. But this is an important point @Anon0118 brings. When you say that reputable Sunni's have said this you need give an example with sources to substantiate the claim. We wouldn't want to spread misinformation.

[@tazbeedsharafuddin1316]

Please make a video on Bengal Sultanate.

[@nopurposeposting1548]

im not too sure if secular is the correct term for some stuff on the video because it indicates separation from religion while probably it wasnt really understood as such, but i get your point.

[@kennethlau8990]

People made Bay'ah to Imam 'Ali (AS) at Ghadir Khumm right after the Prophet (SAWA) chose him; even the most prominent Sahaba made Bay'ah to Imam 'Ali (AS).

[@AhmedMohamed-vq5le]

So sad that you didn't mention the Moroccan Bayha which is still going between Moroccans and The Alaouite Dynasty.

[@AdamAzzr]

3adi. Lpakistaniyn kaymoto 3la l3otmaniyn dakchi 3lach

[@magma9000]

Love from Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@understandingislam9176]

جزاک اللہ

[@idrissadiq3310]

I would like to add, the Bait ur Ridhwan was a pledge made at the tree of Ridhwan regarding Uthman (Ra). The Muslims had halted at Hudaybiyah. They were wearing their Ihram and had the intention of performing Umrah (the prophet had a dream of visiting Kabaa). Uthman was sent to Makkah to negotiate with the them so that the Muslims could perform Umrah. The Muslims waited for a while and they got no response back from Uthman. A rumor broke out he was killed. The prophet and his companies then swore to avenge Uthman if he was killed (a pledge ,bayyah, was made) . However Uthman returned after some time proving the rumor false.

[@davidblair9877]

19:25: power has derived from guns, gold, and bodies for a long time. There’s a reason the Ghulam and Mameluke soldier classes rose from slave to ruler; them as got the weapons tend to get the rest eventually.

[@lerneanlion]

So until the last two Sultans, no non-Muslims have ever been invited to join the coronation of the new Ottoman Sultan like at all? If that is the case, then it means no meeting ambassadors and dignitaries of the other nations during the dinner or something like that too, right?

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Coronation is different from Sword-Girding. They weren't invited to Sword-Girding. They were to the whole coronation ceremony.

[@lerneanlion]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT Thanks for the clarification!

[@noushadansari68]

Name of the background music ?

[@mustfaaboassd]

ولي العهد means the next in oath Also wrong on no baya for Ali Its was taken from everyone that day according to shia sources and some sunnie sources

[@History_Matters]

Indeed

[@HamzaBhatti54]

what happened to socials?

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Deleted them. Feel free to text me on Whatsapp.

[@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273]

​@@AlMuqaddimahYT Good decision I only have WhatsApp and KZbin

[@fnansjy456]

Al Muqqidimah we shoud do Baya too

[@tiggerchen3]

Javanesse muslim kings coronation is also interesting

[@ummfaizal]

Ya, I watched the video, they have gamelan ensemble with music of Kodok Ngorek, the gamelan music sound like frogs after rain, invoking blessing from god to the King. I also knew about current Mangkunegara king need to convert from Christianity into Islam because only muslim can become the Javanese kings. But I don't know why the Mangkunegaran family got embraced other religions as well, maybe because of mixed marriage?

[@HuntingTheEnd]

8:27 "This is the position held by Shias and quite a few Sunni's as well" In what context do you mean the Sunnis agree with that statement as well? Do you mean that just in the context that Ali was the fourth caliph, or in a different way?

[@lapis722]

please make a video on african muslim empires (west and east africa)

[@golgumbazguide...4113]

Explore Golgumbaz with Guide Jahangir, South India 🇮🇳

[@gergelyszilagyi4694]

What is the third reason about people not giving baya to Ali?

[@felineboy1586]

Civil war

[@History_Matters]

Either they were forced to give Bay'ah to another one , or they were hypocrites No other reason

[@abdolrahmanhamed2821]

@@History_Matters Right biased shiite (Shia) dude

[@History_Matters]

@@A_I_N_P 🚨🚨The Companions sent Takfir upon each other, and none of them believed in the Sunni notion of justice of all the Companions.🚨🚨 Rather, they were human beings, among them were the hypocrites and among them were the believers. And I will give you evidence from the words of your scholars Here the well known Sunni scholar : Al-Dhahabi in the introduction of his book Al-Ruwat Al-Thikat 📕 Page 23 saying : *_Some Sahaba sent Takfir upon each other with some sort of Ta'weel_* ..وما زال يمر بي الرجل الثبت وفيه مقال من لا يعبأ به ، ولو فتحنا هذا الباب على نفوسنا لدخل فيه عدة من الصحابة والتابعين والأئمة ، فبعض الصحابة كـــفـَّـــر بعضــهم بتــأويــل مــا ، والله يرضى عن الكل ويغفر لهم ، فمــا هم بمعصومين ، وما اختلافهم ومحاربتهم بالتي تليـّنـهم عندنــا أصـــلاً الرواة الثقات المتكلم فيهم بما لا يوجب ردهم 📕 | الحافظ الذهبي | المقدمة | ص ٢٣ 📃 His student Al-Subki also mentioned it in his book , and said that he agreed with it ونقله عنه تلميذه السبكي في ترجمته للذهبي (١٣٠٦) في كتابه "طبقات الشافعية الكبرى" 📕 | ج 9 📚 | 111 📃 However if we check the sahih Sunni hadiths , we will find that Prophet Muhammad said : *_Whoever calls another man a Kafir , then one of them is surely a Kafir_* Narrator : Abdullah bin Omar | Scholar : Al-Bukhari | Source: Sahih Al-Bukhari | Page or number: 6104 | Grade : [Sahih] Authentic Also Narrated by Muslim with a slight difference *_أَيُّما رَجُلٍ قالَ لأخِيهِ: يا كافِرُ، فقَدْ باءَ بها أحَدُهُما_* الراوي : عبدالله بن عمر | المحدث : البخاري | المصدر : صحيح البخاري الصفحة أو الرقم: 6104 | خلاصة حكم المحدث : [صحيح] التخريج : أخرجه مسلم (60) باختلاف يسير Thus surely some of the Sahaba were Kafir according to your own books

[@azmainnisak5977]

Wow the baya system sounds incredible and interesting! Sounds a bit like democracy... the ruler has the right to rule because of the social contract between the ruler and the people and the ruler is a servant of the people. The ruler and the person giving baya are equal persons and the ruler-to-be even gives speeches to collect bayas. I suppose the difference is that the ruler will rule in accordance with the laws of Islam and not approve of a law that goes against that...

[@awebb4868]

Could you share the third reason you did not want to go into, please

[@Espingol]

What about the coronation of Mohammad Reza Pahlavi in 1967?

[@Quran_and_Ahlulbeit]

He wasn't a religious figure He was a secular Shah Ayatollah Khomeini was the one whom we (Twelver Shia) gave Islamic political pledge of allegiance , and then Ayatollah Khamenei after him till this day

[@criminalsyst9389]

Can u do islamic laws econemic shariah and banks buying and runing business

[@yasserharakat2882]

Where did you read that Saladin said that he wished he had mentioned the Calif's name during khoutbah ? There is NO source that says that

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

It comes from Ibn Abi Tayy (a Shia, so there was no love lost between him and Saladin). However, I'm quoting it from Saladin by John Man.

[@haslemdacarter2055]

But you ARE the animator 😂😂

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Charity begins at home, man. If you don't appreciate your work, no one will either.

[@ivstev70th]

What is the difference between Sultan and Malik (King)?

[@caniblmolstr452]

Hey i heard Roger II of Sicily had an Islamic coronation.. Is that true? That it was part of why the Pope called him a half Heathen

[@smavi4133]

16:48 wow.

[@Yanzdorloph]

Idk thou, in Morocco they still do the Bai'a to this day the same way the did hundreds of eyars ago, and still the leaders of the tribes still come from all regions to do the pledge, the tribe leaders don't have really that much power anymore nowadays but they did not long ago, just in the generation of our parents and before (speaking as 90s kid), IMO the biggest change that happened in Morocco after it's independence is how the power and autonomy of tribes got diluted (althou some tribes still have the right to have their own tribal laws, own judges and courts, amogst these are the jews too who did and still to this day have their own court ).

[@Rikard_A]

How does nobility work in an arabic culture and within Islam?

[@thecorporatefinanceguy]

"baay-yaah" not "bye-yah".... Nevertheless, alhamdulilah... Nice video.

[@ElderKarcha]

You forgot the WORDS said by Umar to congratulate Ali at Ghadeer Khum according to Sunni sources. In Shia sources, even Aisha and other women pledged allegiance to Ali by putting their hands along with Ali in a water basin. #Mawlaya #Caliph #Sultan #King #Prince

[@csx3180]

Expected more about morocco from a channel named after a moroccan book, especially since the Ba'ya system has been almost unbroken in morocco for the better part of the past 12 centuries

[@fromriverstotheseapalestin7030]

In Shaa Allah, Each day, Every day, From rivers to the sea palastine will be free.

[@raihanrusli2720]

I know this youtube channel only discuss islamic history in secular pov, but I am just curious, is the narrator muslim himself ? Note : I am just asking this simple question, no need to discuss other things, alll I need is yes or no. Whatever it is, I like the channel

[@chronikhiles]

Yes, he's a Punjabi Muslim.

[@raihanrusli2720]

@@chronikhiles thanks

[@nuhashahmed7692]

Please share the source of Mu'awiyah praying in the holy sepulchure during his coronation.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

It's from the Maronite Chronicle. AG 971. You can find it on Wikipedia as well but if you wanna read more, check out Robert Hoyland's Seeing Islam as Others Saw It. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maronite_Chronicle

[@nuhashahmed7692]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT Is the christian source the only one that states that he is prayed at the Holy sepulchre?

[@vaktus3380]

This page is Middle East centric, Morocco has retained a continuous written bayah system, even in every khutbah the legitimacy of the king is reinforced

[@Rus_and_NATO_Slayer]

Sounds like your going to cry

[@ummfaizal]

Yup, I noticed it already, maybe this KZbin channel owner not interested to outside of Middle East. The 'facts'about Islamization of Malaysia and Indonesia also not so correct he just read it from whiteman books about generalization of Islam. He don't know what kind of Islam practiced here, it's Shafi'i madhab, we got Islam from Egypt during Ayyubiyah and Mamluk Sultanates, it's nothing to do with China. Chinese live in Malaysia and Indonesia are not muslims.

[@vaktus3380]

@@Rus_and_NATO_Slayer Childish afghan, you have bigger concerns

[@vaktus3380]

@@ummfaizal Thanks for the information, is there a good video i can watch about islamic history in Malaysia and Indonesia?

[@ummfaizal]

@@vaktus3380 I watch several videos on KZbin about why Malaysia and Indonesia Indonesia became Muslims. No video gave the correct answer. It's true we got Islam from Arabian traders. But the trade route through the sea already established way long before Islam. In fact there is one Malay word existed in Quran, in Surah Al-Insan, the word كافورا (camphore) is a pure Malay word. It's shows connection between Malay archipelago to Middle East since ancient time. Precise facts about the Islamization here only can be get through local studies not through European/Orientalist. Got a video from Knowlegia channel but this video also not provide details. The first Islamic sultanate here was Perlak Sultanate of Ismaili Shiah which have connection to Fatimids of Egypt. After Ayyubids toppled down the Fatimids, the Perlak was destroyed by Pasai Sultanate of Sunni Shafi'i sect. From this point Shafi'i sect become the dominant creed to spread to all South East Asia. Because it was sponsored by Ayyubids and later Mamluk Sultanates. All of videos I watched said local kings helping the spread of Islam, this was not true, because Islamization here became slower because of local kings resisted not to convert into Islam, only after Sufi Saints perform miracles in front of king then only they converted, that was in late 1400s just few years before arrival of Portuguese.

[@gabrielleordane4241]

What is the third way you don’t want to get into??😮

[@dermaroc2008]

Did you ignore Morocco on purpose?

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

I was mainly focused on those who called themselves caliphs, I might do a separate video on the Moroccans and the Indians.

[@vaktus3380]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT Don’t act like you know there were Moroccans that claimed caliph during the almohad period and the bayah system being continuous until today

[@alirazasoomro9677]

Please show respect to the Prophet and his companions. say peace be upon him and may Allah be please with them after the name of Prophet Muhammad SAW and their companions respectively.

[@History_Matters]

🚨🚨The Companions sent Takfir upon each other, and none of them believed in the Sunni notion of justice of all the Companions.🚨🚨 Rather, they were human beings, among them were the hypocrites and among them were the believers. And I will give you evidence from the words of your scholars Here the well known Sunni scholar : Al-Dhahabi in the introduction of his book Al-Ruwat Al-Thikat 📕 Page 23 saying : *_Some Sahaba sent Takfir upon each other with some sort of Ta'weel_* ..وما زال يمر بي الرجل الثبت وفيه مقال من لا يعبأ به ، ولو فتحنا هذا الباب على نفوسنا لدخل فيه عدة من الصحابة والتابعين والأئمة ، فبعض الصحابة كـــفـَّـــر بعضــهم بتــأويــل مــا ، والله يرضى عن الكل ويغفر لهم ، فمــا هم بمعصومين ، وما اختلافهم ومحاربتهم بالتي تليـّنـهم عندنــا أصـــلاً الرواة الثقات المتكلم فيهم بما لا يوجب ردهم 📕 | الحافظ الذهبي | المقدمة | ص ٢٣ 📃 His student Al-Subki also mentioned it in his book , and said that he agreed with it ونقله عنه تلميذه السبكي في ترجمته للذهبي (١٣٠٦) في كتابه "طبقات الشافعية الكبرى" 📕 | ج 9 📚 | 111 📃 However if we check the sahih Sunni hadiths , we will find that Prophet Muhammad said : *_Whoever calls another man a Kafir , then one of them is surely a Kafir_* Narrator : Abdullah bin Omar | Scholar : Al-Bukhari | Source: Sahih Al-Bukhari | Page or number: 6104 | Grade : [Sahih] Authentic Also Narrated by Muslim with a slight difference *_أَيُّما رَجُلٍ قالَ لأخِيهِ: يا كافِرُ، فقَدْ باءَ بها أحَدُهُما_* الراوي : عبدالله بن عمر | المحدث : البخاري | المصدر : صحيح البخاري الصفحة أو الرقم: 6104 | خلاصة حكم المحدث : [صحيح] التخريج : أخرجه مسلم (60) باختلاف يسير Thus surely some of the Sahaba were Kafir according to your own books

[@alirazasoomro9677]

@@History_Matters I agree that some of the people during the period of Prophet Muhammad PBUH were hypocrites and kafirs. But that does not mean that we call well-known Sahabas, companions, and Caliphs of the Holy Prophet in that way without any respect.

[@History_Matters]

@@alirazasoomro9677 If I prove to you a companion slurred Imam Ali ? The Prophet said in Sahih Sunni Hadith that whoever slurrs Ali , in turn would've slurred the Prophet and whoever slurred the prophet slurred God A Sahaba named Al-Mughira Ibn Shu'ba in a Sahih Sunni hadith slurred Imam Ali What do you say about Al-Mughira ? I say he was a kafir

[@alirazasoomro9677]

@@History_Matters dear you did not understand what I said. I said to the person who recorded the video that you should say the complete names of Prophet Muhammad Pbuh and his companions. It means he should add peace be upon him and may Allah be pleased with them (companions), just because of respect. But you turned the discussion another way. Yes, I agree there are lots of Hadiths in which many companions were slurred including Hazrat Ali may Allah be pleased with him. Whoever slurs Moula Ali A.S and other beloved Sahabas certainly commits wrongdoing.

[@History_Matters]

@@alirazasoomro9677 God bless you

[@gadyariv2456]

Wasn't Hussein bin Ali, the Emir of Mecca, the last Caliph after the abolition of the Ottoman monarchy...pity you didn't even mention what his assentation entaild.

[@kingdomofprussia5846]

I have a question, since most of the Islamic World is Sunni, why was the Fatimid Caliphate for a time, unchallenged by Sunni Rivals or further extension, recognized as a Caliphate? Sorry if my question has already been answered in a previous video or I worded it wrong, the Fatimids always have been an interest to me.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

It wasn't unchallenged by any means. It was constantly attacked both militarily and through propaganda. Not only Sunnis but the Shia Buyids were against the Fatimids as well. They weren't recognized as Caliphs by anyone but those in Egypt (especially Shias).

[@ummfaizal]

​​@@AlMuqaddimahYT do you have evidence that Fatimids Caliphate were not recognized outside of Egypt? In fact, the Holy Cities of Mecca and Madinah also under their control. They're also have extensive trade and da'wah mission to India and South-East Asia. The first islamic sultanate in Indonesia name Perlak Sultanates were of Ismaili Shiah sect. During Ayubids toppled down the Fatimids, a war broken in northern Sumatra between Pasai Sultanate (Sunni) against Perlak (Ismaili Shiah) and won by Pasai. Then Pasai spread Islam to Malacca, Kedah and Patani. From this onwards that is why South-East Asia is Sunni of Shafi'i fiqh. Islam came here from trade network starting from Egypt to Hejaz, Yemen, Malabar coast of India then to Malaysia and Indonesia. The dakwah very active at that time. Even the famous Shafi'i jurist Sheikhul Islam Ibn Hajar Al-Haithami from Egypt even travelled to Malabar coast of India in 1526 to meet his student Sheikh Zainudin Al-Malibari, author of Fathul Muin kitab in Shafi'i fiqh that are still used in Malay archipelago madrasah today.

[@tavishnundoo6002]

For the algorithm

[@History_Matters]

*_Sahih sunni hadith of Twelve Imams_* 📚 Jaber bin Samra said: I went with my father to the Prophet, may God bless him and grant him peace, and I heard him [the prophet] say: This authority of Islam doesn't end *_unless 12 Khalifas have passed_* . Then he spoke words I couldn't hear . I asked my dad : What did he say ? He told me , the prophet said : All of them are from Quraish" Narrated by Al-Bukhari (No. / 7222) and Muslim, and the wording is that of the latter (No. / 1821).

[@sarahkareem1251]

Facts!

[@History_Matters]

@@sarahkareem1251 thanks sister Alhamdulillah we are upon the path of Ahlulbeit

[@sarahkareem1251]

@@History_Matters You're welcome brother. Yes indeed and what a blessed path that is!

[@novaprime5976]

Baiat? That's how we call it in Indonesian language

[@emperorkaido8539]

the rashidun caliph is not a king unlike what te ummayads and the abbasids did which was wrong if you know what i mean

[@Morso8]

In Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦 we still make bay'ah for every new king

[@nuhashahmed7692]

Yup.Unforntunately people don't know how big Bani Saud is or about the Bay'ah ceremony.

[@Morso8]

@@FirdousAhmedLone yes, our kings aren't immortal, when the king dies someone replaces him

[@nuhashahmed7692]

@@johnroe4160 Peaceful protests has never been a thing in Islam. There are rules to what you can and can't do regarding the ruler of an Islamic state in Islam. And those things you mentioned doesn't make one a monarchy. A monarchy is someone who inhertits power and can rule until he dies or abdicates it. Giving allegiance is not meaningless; You see the Saudi monarchy isn't like your typical western monarchy. The father isn't just handing over power to his son. If enough members of the Bani Saud don't give ba'yah, the father's choice is irrelevant. The Bani Saud represents most of Saudi Arabia. Its a massive family with relations to pretty much every region and tribe in the country.

[@seneca983]

@@nuhashahmed7692 "A monarchy is someone who inhertits power" Not necessarily. There have also been elective monarchies, e.g. the Holy Roman Empire, though I don't know whether there have been any Muslim elective monarchies.

[@nuhashahmed7692]

@@seneca983 Quite frankly I don't see much difference in how the Holy Roman Empire practiced elective monarchy and what the Saudis practice in terms of monarchy.

[@rehaniqbal7986]

Rashidun caliphate is the only caliphate i accept because after that the heir was chosen before the King died and on the day of judgement what these dogs of banu umayya did Ahl Al-Byat Allah will punish them severly. The Prophet Muhammed (PBUH) said on many occations that don't harm Ahl Al-Byat but still what they did on the land of Karbala.

[@beepboop204]

😀😀😀

[@ummfaizal]

That Ottoman video was not showing the girding sword ceremony 😂.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Oh, yeah, the footage is more than 100 years old and not all of it survived or has been restored. Still I found it pretty interesting.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

@@ummfaizal The credit is in the description. It has been since I uploaded the video. The name of the channel appears in the video clip that is in the video as well. Please watch the video or check the description before you comment.

[@ummfaizal]

​@@AlMuqaddimahYT do you get permission from the owner of the video to re-publish the video? If not then it's same as stealing it. That's why earlier I question your level of education. Just simply put the link without permission to reuse it, it's same as stealing

[@ailediablo79]

Abad Alhamed didn't do genocid as it was in 1912 and he was out by 1908. If he ruild they wouldn't joined ww1.

[@sairadha674]

Can you pls provide sources. It would help in reading further on the topic.

[@CAAnmoldeepsingh]

baaya gets a whole other meaning in south delhi or bombay. 😂😂

[@Rus_and_NATO_Slayer]

I only read about the coranarion of Crimean khans so they would read a prayer and drop a white cloth over the new khans head

[@AhmedMahmoud-tv9vw]

6:34 it should be Mu'awiyah ibn Abi Sufyan and not Mu'awiyah ibn Abu Sufyan.

[@madianantar7842]

15:06 crowns are for scrubs

[@Shimra8888]

Isn’t the Ummah and Caliphates technically not monarchies? All Muslims are equal surely? What title did Muhammad have, king, chief, emperor??

[@emperorkaido8539]

only the rashidun caliphs were not kings the ummayad and abbasid caliphs were kings which to me is wrong and a break from the prophets tradition

[@kamakiller1145]

Muhammad had the title of Prophet

[@user-es2bq2bf1b]

@@kamakiller1145 and messanger

[@History_Matters]

The prophet is also an Imam , an infallible political and spiritual leader After him came 12 Imams , also infallible , who transmitted the teachings of the Prophet

[@Shimra8888]

@@History_Matters Shiite heretic

[@Rikard_A]

But as I understand it is that the choosen heir of the Chaliph was suppose to be respected. And would not that mean that the Bay'ah was suppose to be symbolic, just like an oath of alliegence? Because alot of states has collaspped because of infigthing. Look at the Roman empire ( I mean the Easten Roman Empire that is called Byzantium) that collappsed becaused emperors were usurperd and usurpers used other peoples like the bulghars and Turks to usurp power from the ruling emperor. I would not call the change of Bay*ah any empty gesture - but a changed gesture.

[@ballerspakistan]

Sultan Abdulhamid didn't kill his brothers.

[@ElderKarcha]

4:52 ~> not exactly A militarized resistance was inflicted on the Tax Resistants after the cruel suppression of the opposition led by the Prophet’s Household and their loyalists.

[@kuroazrem5376]

Please do a video about the Mughal coronation.

[@JohnnyLodge2]

As non muslim seems obvious to me that Ali was the chosen successor

[@aalhashmi90]

Not really, there where many occasions where the Prophet (pbuh) appointment Abu Baker, especially in his last days. People didn'tjust choose Abu Baker for his politicalinfluenc, it was because they saw him as the Prophet's right hand man..

[@JohnnyLodge2]

@@aalhashmi90 def says Ali whereas Abu Bakr was right hand man because he gave him his favorite underaged wife.

[@zulfiqarawan3407]

Why using secular word for prophet and abu bakr (ra). Whereas right word should be political

[@tahmeed94]

Why do you use inappropriate images or paintings of Prophet and companions

[@qamarhassan936]

16:57: ceremonial killing of brothers 😂😂

[@papazataklaattiranimam]

Être fort comme un Turc (‘to be strong like a turk’): This expression originates in the 15th century when the Turks had a reputation for being strong, almost unbeatable warriors due to their numerous victories. At the time, the Ottoman Empire ruled large parts of south-east Europe, north Africa and western Asia. It is said that François I, King of France, was gifted Turkish armour by Suleiman the Magnificent (the tenth and most famous sultan of the Ottoman Empire) during their alliance. When he wore it, he is said to have exclaimed: “Here I am now, strong as a Turk!”.

[@sabrinashahab795]

The first four caliphs were ok , rest were not

[@abdullahcomam]

Fear Allah, the 5th Khalifa was Al Hassan ibn Ali (RA).

[@faisalalsanea4025]

Ottoman can’t be caliphs but they are emperors and kings nothing more, just Umayyad and Abbasid can claim it or who who have a common ancestor with the prophet