Remembrance Episode 9- Breaking Point

[@AuraNova-AshleyH]

Before you comment: I know that this episode took a long time. Things happened that were just unavoidable and I had to start over from scratch when my computer deleted my files. I get that "Oh this took a year to make" jokes are fun and all but please don't comment things like that. They are getting really aggressive and have gotten to the point of belittling me for taking so long to finish. It's very rude to the cast as well. I apologize none the less though and can assure you that ep10 and ep11 will not take as long.

[@AuraNova-AshleyH]

@@crinja404 There will be two part series finale. With everything I build up, I need two episodes to resolve everything without it being rushed.

[@Cuaedria]

Ashley H Quality work takes a long time. No rush; I’m eager to see the individual songs from this episode! Eager, but equally willing to wait. 😁

[@MBV169]

You are a very good writer this ep 9 Is rilly good is there going to de a finaly.

[@thefreerepublicofadmiralpr2935]

Ashley H Hey Ashley, do you know the name of that pony talking to Nightmare Star at the beginning?

[@17keelh14]

There is no rush.

[@iceluvndiva21]

Calling it now: Twilight has to rediscover the elements inside her own heart, the love inside cadence, the friendship in flurry and galaxy, the selflessness in Luna, the joy in discord. All things that they can use to free celestia. And this series is basically the grieving cycle in extremes and the various ways people experience it. Same steps but in different orders, lengths, and expressions

[@helenaschreibman9035]

very true

[@Blaze_The_Wolf9]

Yeah

[@17keelh14]

You are so right, if only they can get over the grieving they might realise that the answer is right in front of them they just need to be able to find it.

[@17keelh14]

@FoxSlasher Foxy you are probably right.

[@iceluvndiva21]

FoxSlasher Foxy Good point. And maybe forgive her parents (if she’s still mad at them obviously)

[@raydashietwitwi3955]

Well this thumbnail definitely takes "a picture is worth a thousand words" into account...... Poor Discord

[@erroremma4679]

I did my best with the feels :D

[@vxzkkkk]

I read this as the picture showed up XD

[@caltoonfangirl7109]

I was literally crying when Discord read Fluttershy’s letter.

[@iceluvndiva21]

CallieFan Megamind Same

[@cherish_dreamer6472]

Same

[@Mars._.Bars3533]

Me too

[@nahlacook5573]

Same

[@imanishraf6215]

My heart break at the moment Fluttershy started to appear on her chair.

[@warriorofdramaclan8107]

I nearly cried when Discord was reading Fluttershy's letter and when Twilight and Cadence were talking about the past and... well... y'know. But what REALLY got me was when Flurry overheard. :'( Also Nightmare Star's song at the end, dude, man.

[@itsnothanss]

Right back at ya- (Meaning i agree)

[@mondoshusband6473]

Me: *goes through subscriptions* Also me: *sees this* Me again: I think im gonna die

[@karlhnedkovsky5214]

I already did!

[@karlhnedkovsky5214]

@Eri Chan **malevolent smile**

[@kylemarston2573]

I think twilight will be the next pony to die if she uses that spell bring back her friends. powerful spells always come with a price. 😟😟😟😟

[@karlhnedkovsky5214]

@@kylemarston2573 I hope not! 😢

[@JustChill0927]

@@kylemarston2573 Hopefully not. She's used powerful spells and been fine before so maybe she can bring back her friends and be fine here too.

[@HaileyA110]

Five seconds in I’m already crying Jesus Ashley

[@JustChill0927]

Same here

[@enriqueuy8101]

5 seconds...that's fast

[@JustChill0927]

@@enriqueuy8101 Yeah

[@SRoop23]

This audio drama was the first spark in my friendship with my best friend. We bonded over Remembrance for little over a year now, ever since episode 8 came out. And I can tell you that when we watch it together, we're gonna have an amazing time, and probably cry too. I'm dedicating this day and this episode, as well as this comment to my bestest friend in the whole world. Happy (very late) friendaversary, Auri

[@hm7201]

That's so sweet. :3

[@archeishere1]

Tell her that i said Hi! Happy Late BestFriendaversary.

[@SRoop23]

@@archeishere1 Aww thank you

[@archeishere1]

@@SRoop23 My pleasure, also have you and your best friend watched DOD and BOD?

[@SRoop23]

@@archeishere1 I have! My friend hasn't tho, I'm still trying to get her to watch it XD

[@autumnrose9655]

Who else cried during Discord’s song?😢

[@caveman0745]

I did too

[@brennathelunalastar7013]

Autumn Rose I did.

[@autumnrose9655]

Mohini Stalker same😭

[@bloodmoon8130]

Me

[@radianthope8502]

Me,,

[@dawddawid9075]

This thumbnail, geez i feel so bad for discord

[@lilywilson9163]

Me too

[@Cart00nist101]

Poor discord😞😞😞😞

[@stephaniereid8632]

Ikr

[@lilywilson9163]

I really feel bad for Discord

[@tazzhardy1025]

Poor discord I feel so bad for her 😟😟😟

[@littlewishy6432]

Just one word: wow. Now as of those who commented hate on this episode (I know who you are from the premiere chat. You can’t change it now.), why are you here to begin with then? If you don’t like it, find something ELSE that suits your satisfaction and don’t come back! To people that discourteously rushed Ashley for the production of this episode, *ENOUGH*. You pretty much deserve to get a 1-month delay of the next episodes. To @Ashley H: Don’t listen to these ungrateful, closed-minded morons. You owe no respect to people that have the audacity to push you around or leave destructive criticism. Thank you for dedicating your time to release a new episode that was well worth the wait.

[@dragb9284]

Jonah Chang in A442 wait what happened?

[@josecarrilloii4036]

@@dragb9284 I have no idea.

[@littlewishy6432]

48:15 48:25 Look at the premiere chat

[@17keelh14]

You tell them.

[@lilytiger8746]

Who else cried during Discord's part? Come on, it CAN'T just be me

[@minionfanatic987]

😭😭😭😭

[@radianthope8502]

Me

[@sound_wave16]

Me.

[@MatulaJesus]

Me 😭

[@yu-gi-ohmasterchef8130]

Discord’s part was a really emotional Discord really cared for Flutershy and I think that Discord loved her so that’s why Discord looked ready to cry looking a Fluttershy’s chair at the map then the song had me crying there rest of the way through the video

[@breedarling4859]

Discord seen where he cant admit, flusttershy is gone. Got me in tears.. it couldn't stop following.😭 God what episode! ❤

[@christygalaxy4458]

When zecora's descendent(I'm so sorry I forgot her name) was talking about the ponies who used resurrection spell I didn't think she was talking about Luna and celestia's PARENTS! Well done Ashley....ALL HAIL THE DORITO QUEEN!!!

[@looneymicrophone6431]

The daughter name is zaliea

[@christygalaxy4458]

bugs bunny omg thank you! I been wondering what her name was all day...thanks

[@MrGabeanator]

zillia

[@kylinbilderain5370]

I wonder what the lullaby was maybe it could bring Celesta back?

[@MrGabeanator]

@@kylinbilderain5370 maybe

[@TheCommenterDragon]

Yes, episode 9 is finally here, this episode was so epic and or definitely worth the wait, al the art and the songs were just true masterpieces, major kudos to all the talented artists and singers who made this episode possible.

[@iceluvndiva21]

The Commenter Dragon That villain song at the end got a good chuckle outta me. It’s like she threw a lamp us saying “lighten up or I’ll light you up!”.

[@JustChill0927]

@@iceluvndiva21 Same

[@JustChill0927]

Yeah this episode was absolutely amazing

[@fridaeriksson9014]

@@JustChill0927 do you know when part 10-11 of remembrance comning out ???

[@JustChill0927]

@@fridaeriksson9014 yea!!

[@EverlastingSky23]

After coming back to rewatch this series, the concept of Alicorns being immortal reminded me of a favorite book I read in middle school. It’s called Tuck Everlasting, and it’s basically about this girl named Winnie who leaves the comfort of her fenced in yard to explore the woods she was warned to stay away from. When she explores the woods she’s comes across a family “The Tucks” A mother and father and their sons and it turns out they are immortal after drinking from a spring they found. While the mother and the youngest son loved the idea of being immortal and living their lives care free. The father and oldest son talk to Winnie about how they hated being immortal and how they wished they could perish like people they meet eventually do. Mr. Tuck and Miles (the oldest son) talk how it is a curse, they tell Winnie that’s she’s lucky and tell her not to drink from the spring. Miles eventually loses his wife and daughter when the started to age and they realized that he couldn’t because he was immortal. He watched them leave him, and he eventually saw his wife pass on and he watched how his daughter grew into an old lady and she perished too. Long story short, it’s an amazing book and I can talk about it for hours, but this series reminded me of that book.

[@SpacialRend7]

Well, things are really boiling over here in this episode. It’s sad to think that Flurry was fearing that she was turning into her frozen-hearted mother, trying to isolate herself from others and all. It’s a good thing that Galaxy is there to remind her to be strong. It’s about time that Discord admitted his feelings over the loss of Fluttershy. His song had me going, that and the scene when he read Flutters’ letter to him. I liked the scene when Twilight was having a conversation with Cadance, something I’ve been waiting to see all this time. The two of them reminiscing on the good times was a heartwarming scene. I hope Cadance has a heart to heart talk with Flurry after the misunderstanding she heard during that conversation. Then there’s the scene with Luna’s information about the resurrection spell that her parents used to bring back the loved ones they lost and payed the ultimate price in doing so. I wonder if Twilight is going to go through with that spell after hearing what Luna had to say. She’d better think hard or things will go down to the South Pole in the worst way. Things are already looking bleak with Nightmare Star and the other Nightmares building their army. All being said, I really enjoyed this latest episode of Remembrance, and as always, I’m looking forward to the next one! Excellent job to all of you (Ashley, cast, artists, etc.)!

[@thewatcher2928]

Obviously, she will use the spell The "remembrance" animation shows that

[@forbidden_curry_kira]

@@thewatcher2928 Actually you can't say that-not in this timeframe. If you actually watched the sfm, it shows that Celestia was there and in this case she isn't because well she is the villain arc. It might turn out if Celestia reforms later on but we'll have to wait to find out.

[@thewatcher2928]

That's what I am expecting will happen eventually. Celestia reforms, the nightmare leaves, and the rest we will know

[@celestiafanforever]

I have a lot to talk about this episode with my friend when she calls me back about this. Also during Discord's song I kept screaming at him to say Fluttershy's name and that I would say my dead grandma's name as well knowing the fact that she's gone and isn't coming back.

[@mintyfresh2357]

CelestiaFan Forever i’m on the verge of tears after reading the comments I’m sorry for your loss.

[@meggamiauw4266]

I'm sorry for your loss...

[@fanofthematrix7939]

CelestiaFan Forever I’m sorry for your loss and I hope your grandma is happy

[@hatercityshutdown5041]

I’m sorry for your loss ):

[@celestiafanforever]

@@mintyfresh2357 sorry didn't mean to make you cry.

[@Platinum_Band]

Wait a two part series finale that leads into Argo's Remembrance video? This is going to be really interesting. Ashley thank you to you and everyone who is a part of this project. Even though there are large gaps between episodes the story is wonderful and a beautiful piece of work. The artists giving us wonderful art to look at while we listen to the story unfold. The voice actors doing what they do best and being amazing at it. Thank you Ashley for your dedication to this project and to the community who has come to love the project as well. I hope that even after the series where it leads into Argo's video we return and have a chance to see Nightmare Star's fall and see the story unfold a little more before the true end of them. Thank you again so much and keep at it we all support you and look forward to the next installation of this project.

[@candicefaithv]

thank you!

[@lunaris2078]

This is going to be great! but I still feel bad for Discord though. and Ashley H, thank you for making this truly wonderful! All your videos put a smile to our faces, your singing voice is amazing and for all the people that work hard to make this come true. Thank you!

[@musescript4215]

This episode was absolutely amazing from the artwork, to the songs, and to the voice acting. I seriously love your writing choices in this series and there were a lot of things I didn't expect in this episode. All of the characters need to have therapy sessions, though it will probably never happen lol. My reaction will probably show up on the 27th where the majority of the time, I wanted to give them all hugs. ^^

[@littlewishy6432]

MuseScript Can’t wait for that!

[@candicefaithv]

You're amazing Muse :) can't wait!

[@princess-kitsune-tsu4381]

Alright everyone here comes the feels grab your tissues like 40 packs of them some popcorn something to drink sit back relax and prepare for some feels!!~

[@AnotherSimplYElla]

K

[@meredithburgess7034]

I agree

[@sugarcrystals5649]

The hush now quiet now that played during discords reading of Fluttershy's letter got me.

[@voidedNYX]

I literally cry when Galaxy confront Discord about Fluttershy and when he reads the letter. This episode is so Good! Now i know why it takes months to make this.

[@archeishere1]

The curse of immortality watching everything you love rot away in due time.

[@moonyart50]

Who ever voiced discord has such amazing voice

[@hotdogzandcheese2466]

True that

[@BeesMeliss]

It's MJ Smuv.

[@robertwho50]

@@BeesMeliss who please

[@amandagerow4690]

I think Discord's song is one of my favorites his voice actor did an impressive job.

[@CodyDragonMight9560]

@Ashley H I still miss the show, I feel heartbroken

[@mondoshusband6473]

Like I always say... the show maybe over.. but the fandom will never die

[@pancakemaxx4377]

First My Pride episode 3 now this,ITS MA LUCKY DAY

[@darkrose7774]

I noticed that Galaxy's mom had no hair. Does that mean what I think it means? Omg, Ash, stop! Thank you. A tear-jerker for sure!

[@sunsetluna9259]

I loved that they changed up the song "all eyes on me" It's just so Ahh! I love it!

[@princesstt9778]

Ikr? It was a wonderful surprise.

[@giantwarchicken1577]

Time stamp please?

[@MoricsVV]

Maybe Ashley know Batim too :>

[@sunsetluna9259]

mAyBe

[@mxchamii6708]

@@giantwarchicken1577 kzbin.info/www/bejne/bpKWqWWGbqiCaqs

[@yoshifan3077]

Oh wow Time for heartbreakings episode can't wait 😢

[@SpectrumSwordtails]

I really hope that the drama between flurry and cadence has a happy ending soon. Cause I don't know how much more of this my heart can take.

[@christinemurphy120]

Awesome episode. The Discord and Fluttershy part got me I was crying like crazy I'm a Fluttercord fan. And I loved the Nightmare Star and the Nightmares sang it was awesome. I'm looking forward to the Finale good luck and stay safe Ashley.

[@TheHappyGunner007]

We're in the endgame now

[@lovelypink_2005]

24:30 "Lost in thoughts, all alone" You are the ocean's gray waves... Destined to seek, Life beyond the shore, just out of reach... Yet the waters ever change... flowing like time, your path is yours to climb... In the White light... A hand reaches through... A double-edged blade cuts your heart in two. Waking dreams, fade away... Embrace the brand new day! Sing with me - a song... Of birthrights and love... The light scatters to... The sky above! Down breaks through the gloom, White as a bone, Lost in thoughts, All alone... Sing with me - a song... Of silence and blood... The rain falls, but can't wash away the mud... With my ancient heart dwells... Madness and pride... Can no one... hear my cry...?

[@slendertubbiegamerpo6139]

I can't find this song I went to the exact time but there's nobody singing it

[@lovelypink_2005]

@@slendertubbiegamerpo6139 it's a lyrics from the song's cover made by Aphmau! She made a cover to this song, and those are the lyrics on the cover

[@slendertubbiegamerpo6139]

@@lovelypink_2005 wheres the cover in the video cause I watched this 5 times and not once saw it in the video I'll look it up though I looked it up still can't find it

[@ShibaInu102]

I’m assuming this series is officially over then? Understandable. It probably creates a lot of pressure & anxiety. Maybe one day it’ll finish at least. ❤

[@itsnothanss]

When cadence and twilight talked about shining I- I loved this episode, worth the wait definitely F in the chat for everybody [Mane 6, the dead citizens and shining]

[@alexiswagner5388]

F

[@alexiswagner5388]

I never do that lol but it's for mlp

[@simple_slight]

F

[@101wolfanime]

Please excuse me while I crawl into a ball and cry my eyes out. This episode was well worth the wait. As always, beautiful work to everyone that worked on this project. Stay safe everyone.

[@phenioxflameanimations6433]

I’m so excited to see the new episode! I’ve been waiting so long for this and I knew AshlyH would never let us down. She always knows how to put a smile on our face and hearts alike. She is our inspiration. “ May your heart be your guiding key!!!”

[@crystalpayne_entertains9903]

This was completely worth the wait!!!! Absolutely amazing, beautiful, spectacular! "Her Name" has me in tears! Great work to you Ashley and the whole cast of VA's and artist. You all did a wonderful job bringing this together

[@candicefaithv]

Thank you!

[@Mor1moo]

Ima just head back into the fandom for this

[@kaitlyn3491]

Holy mother of Equestria! That was amazing Ashley! You and all the artists/VAs did a phenomenal job. My goes to Discord in this episode and I’m so happy to se some Galheart in here. I’m glad that everything that’s happened this year did not stand in the way of your creating. I can’t wait for the rest of this amazing series!

[@candicefaithv]

Thank you!

[@TheJohnLytleShow]

Worth the wait. Cried through the last half and still crying as I type this.

[@myjarofuwus942]

Video: 7:04 Me: That sounds really familiar-- *Galaxy starts singing* Me: OMFG ITS THE MELODY FROM BUTTERFLY BY BTS!

[@aisyhusry__]

I thought it was just me who knows the song😂

[@myjarofuwus942]

@@aisyhusry__ I was literally looking in the comments who also realized but couldn't find a single one.

[@zeldamarkedlink]

In the first few minutes in, I am tearing up....My feels. I have had Tears in my eyes the whole time. THAT FIRE EMBLEM MUSIC IS SO PERFECT😭😭😭

[@ARMSonicCL15]

Im going to say it for the first time: ALL HAIL DORITO QUEEN!!!

[@ultrasonic736]

This is one of, if not the best fan made MLP project ever. The writing is amazing, the characters are great, and it's so emotional! Sometimes I enjoy Remembrance more than the actual show, and that's saying a lot because MLP is my favorite show! I found this series recently, and I wish i'd found it sooner because it's so amazing! Thank you so much for making such a great piece of art for the MLP community! I'm so excited for the next one!

[@delphoxhoopa7289]

Hello Amazon? I'm gonna need one thousand tissues.😢😭

[@amberdolphin1210]

Will you be able to receive them with this pandemic? You may need to use handkerchiefs.

[@m.m5004]

Your criying aren You. Like me

[@izolda6521]

You just HAD to include discord into this, thanks a lot, now I can’t stop crying and I’m gonna be obsessed with this until I’ve watched it all ... discord makes everything better, but that also means I’m gonna be crying the whole time with empathy for discord rifigjropssocjjfriieid but seriously, thank you for having discord in this series it makes it from a 12/10 fanfic to a 1111112/10 and also the saddest thing ever

[@codyholste6142]

Damn onion ninjas get outta here I started crying when discord started singing dammit

[@mintyrose4413]

21:31 I don't know why or what but I couldn't hold back my tears😭😭🤧 you really out done your self thank you for an amazing video💖💙

[@baliyae]

Awwww, Discord, I wanted to hug him as he sang about Fluttershy! I especially wanted to hug him after he read what she wrote to him in her journal! Right in the Fluttercord feels!

[@richiebankich]

YASSSSS! Mama needs her Remembrance! 😊

[@justafan7072]

Okay, I know I’m late. But WOW I am amazed with every single song. I love this episode because it’s putting the events on pause, and seeing everyponies emotions and character development. Ashley you are amazing, and don’t forget that, and the cast who sung, were on point❤️

[@savvy3tv632]

I just finished the episode and I just have to say it was AMAZING!!! Definitely worth the wait. Will Cadence mend her relationship with Flurry? Will Twilight use the spell? Will Galheart become cannon!! And I was BAWLING during Discord’s song. It was so heartbreaking that he lives without her. Wonderful job.

[@thefreerepublicofadmiralpr2935]

Savvy3tv I desperately hope that Twilight uses the spell. Especially after watching Disney Pixar’s Onward where such a thing was used. I want to see how Ashley would pull it off.

[@chokingonflowers3582]

Honestly there's something so beautiful about that letter that Fluttershy wrote to Discord, shipping wise or not, it's the bittersweetness of remembering someone you hold dear to you and who feels the same way towards you.

[@Max541000]

This moment when Discord discovered and read Fluttershy's letter (while hearing the "Hush now" lullaby music) almost made me cry...but I resisted...and then I saw the feather...WOW

[@pepperimps01]

I'm super late, but I thought I'd share a little comment showing my appreciation for this series. From the artwork, the writing, the voice acting, the songs---it's absolutely incredible and I'm proud to call it my favorite audio series. It's complex and beautiful. 💗💞I know this is technically the end, and I am beyond sorry that people have harassed you and the crew over the work you've produced. Much love ❤️

[@BigSis111]

I cried like 5 times! The voices and the pictures are so beautiful! And songs really touched me

[@shannonm0317]

* Looks in sees this * EEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[@TheGimpGrind]

This series has been a mountain of feels so far! I'm sorry you've received so much crap about it.. Fandoms can be really toxic(ironic for a fandom of a series about friendship). Crappy fandom behavior aside, I'm really glad you addressed how Discord is handling losing Fluttershy! That song and journal sequence was heart wrenching! I don't remember an example in the show canon where Discord dropped that "I don't care" façade. Aside from his initial revelation that he really did value and want Fluttershy's friendship. It was nice to see that side of him for more than a split second. The whole plot thread with Cadence and the death of Shining also caught me off guard. I hope you're feeling better about the whole thing, and rediscovering your love for what you've created! Don't let toxic fandom behavior ruin your passion. Hope you're well! :)

[@Elenamoon6688]

I love this but poor Discord I cried when he sang his song but also poor Flurry and Cadence I cried when Flurry overheard Cadence I hope they fix there relationship but I always cry with these episodes also great job this is amazing

[@daizeeofficial1763]

Holy the thumbnail is well done- props to the artist

[@erroremma4679]

Thank you! x3

[@daizeeofficial1763]

@@erroremma4679 you're welcome ^^

[@demonicange1_]

When discord read fluttershy’s letter and held the feather from her wing i cried about the dead friend i never had

[@LaissezFairyWriter]

Wow, Flurry’s struggle is so real. The fear of becoming your parents is such a terrifying thing, and even more so here, because all of her family members have turned into empty shells living for centuries in despair. Poor girl, glad Gal is here to help her through this. Beautiful episode! I teared up a few times.

[@yourfavoritejazzlover]

AAAAAHHHHH I HAVE WAITED TWO YEARS FOR THIS WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY THOOOOOO

[@candicefaithv]

It's been an honour and a privilege getting to play Twilight & Luna for you, Ash! I recorded my reaction, will upload sometime ;)

[@imanishraf6215]

Me : Time to watch Remembrance episode 9. I'm ready. (See the thumbnail for this video) Me : Before that, I need tissue to be 100% ready.

[@FandarelPandrylaes]

Dear Ashley H I got around to watching this at last after seeing you video about status of the channel and this series. Why I can understand and see the criticisms of this episode and perhaps how it was ended. I saw this as set up episode and I had alot of fun watch this. I enjoyed how deep you got with the bottle up feeling of alot of characters that simplely do not get to used this way on the show canon. The solidarity that flurry was shown by Galaxy was heartwarming. What you did with discord was refreshing and I felt you used him very well to release some feelings and see a side of him that we don't get to see too much. The backstory you came up with Luna and Celestia and their parents was interesting. And you tied in with the plot and I enjoyed that. I enjoyed the music. I just had fun! Yeah fan animations and projects are always going to be the best. But I support you and I'll gladly wait until you're ready to make the next episode. Thank you for your hard work on this. I understand. The amount of work I put into helping the brony musician community and horse music herald. I truly understand what goes into the process of creating something. Over at Bronies Against MS. Agent Fluffy, MC-Arch, Cynifree, LuckRock and Melody Brony are bringing the comic dub that Witchy Specrai and myself wrote. and it's taking time to create so I get it and understand. And I will openly say that I encourage you to Branch out and enjoy making other things. I will support you! I hope this helped.

[@FandarelPandrylaes]

P.S the scene of discord reading flutters journal And that music of fluttershy's lullaby was so tear jerking satisfying. I loved seeing discord this way

[@echoturan613]

I think I've watched this Episode four or five times now and I still cry at Discord's song about Fluttershy ugh right in my feels Ashley H

[@DemonHunter-yk6xh]

I'll watch it later, or tommorow, and see if it's any good I watch these when it's not just a Livestream. Cross your finger's I hope this episode is as amazing as it is promising

[@Pedrosilva-bk3rm]

The song when lord discord singing about lady fluttershy is... just... so strong and powerful... I cried so much nonstop that... it’s prove of how much he love her...... lord discord,lady fluttershy...😭😭😭😫😫😫

[@MoonQuill_SqueeSqueeSquee]

Me when “All Eyes On Me” comes on: A long long time ago- Wait hold up.

[@NyxGachaCC324777]

OH MY GAWD!!!! I INSTANTLY REALIZED THAT THE SONG IS THE SAME TUNE AS “BTS Butterfly”!!!! OMG! IM AN ARMY AND IM FREAKING OUT SINCE MY FAVOURITE SERIES HAS AN AUDIO SIMILAR TO BTS, MY FAVOURITE PEOPLE IN THE WORLD!!!😱😱😱😭😭😭💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@kalenah.4248]

Oh my god I can’t believe this! I’m so happy! I missed the live chat and I’m so sad about but at least I get to see this most beautiful masterpiece that was created by the gods!💖💖💖 Edit 1: oh my god an Avenger endgame reference at 12:48 I’m so happy! I love it! 😆 Edit 2: that was an amazing episode! I absolutely love it so much I cried during discord’s solo about fluttershy! 😭 why Ashley! Why did you make this so sad! 😭 I also loved the duet from flurry heart and galaxy! I love those two so much that I shop them together so hard it’s so cute! 🥰 also the part where Luna talked about their parents is really interesting about how they used the resurrection spell to bring back their loved ones. That part I really loved I was really interested in that part! AHHH!😆 I loved it Ashley, all of the art work and music is just amazing, you guys did a fantastic job! Thank you so so much! I can’t wait till episode 10!!

[@charlieiguess7890]

I just... I had just had some kind of scenario in my head: When we go to that animated Remembrance we see that Twilight brings back her friends. And since this is based on it, I think Twilight will use that spell. But what if, after she used the spell and brought her friends back, they all go and enjoy the next years with their loved ones and best friends. I imagine Fluttershy going to See Discord, but being unable to find him. The last time someone saw him, was Galaxie at Fluttershys stair. So what if Discord couldn‘t handle being without Futtershy anymore, especially after that Journal, so he somehow found a way to destroy himself and go to that... afterlife, where he hoped to find her. But she wasn‘t there. And now he has to wait another Pony-lifetime to see her again. But when she and her friends arrive, the loneliness has driven him completely mad. It would take forever to bring him back. I sometimes hate me for being able to imagine those things in my had. Help

[@artsyamethyst9239]

This truly rekindled my love for the MLP fandom, truly thank you! Last year in April I was a senior in highschool and got so caught up in life and other crazy stuff. I have my notifications on for your channel when the finale episode remembrance comes out. This episode made me absolutely sob but also strangely gave me comfort thank you truly.

[@Troublethegremlin]

Life happens! You guys shouldn’t be demeaned for something like that! That’s ridiculous! Don’t let them get ya down! Most of us really love how much effort and passion you all put into these shows! You the animators the cast everyone! Your true fans will be here! Also you guys outdid yourselves with this amazing work!! Pretty sure discord’s song still makes me cry every time I see it. Have to rewatch it when I need a good crying session, especially when I get stuff in my eyes and I can’t cry when I need to. Discord’s song does it easily. The passion and emotion in this video HURTS the feels DANG are LEGIT. It’s so relatable, so much it hurts. AMAZING WORK all of you! 🤗

[@hollyjulianna4920]

Wow, I didn’t realize how long this comment had gotten. Ashley, if you’re reading this, it’s not about how long this episode took or anything like that. It’s just a bunch of text about how wonderfully outstanding this episode was! Your dedication to this project is admirable. The fact that you pushed though everything that happened and went through all of that writing, directing, and all of that editing is truly astonishing. After the premiere, I sat for 10 minutes just thinking about how wonderful this episode was, and even teared up at how amazing of a viewing experience I had. And 50 minutes? Wow! The feels in this episode were just next-level as well. How Do I and Her Name were just beautiful, and I sung along to Just Not Today the entire song. I already had it all memorized heh! The shipping fuel was too much for me to handle! And oh my gosh, I loved I Am The Queen, it is such a bop. I could listen to that on repeat for hours. The writing in this episode is just wow. You always know how to trigger my emotions. The scene right before Just Not Today was so well written. That dialogue exchange alone made me cry. And I for one think that the backstory with Tia and Luna’s parents was such a good choice. The fact that their parents were the ones that used the Resurrection Spell makes so much sense. Speaking of sense, sometimes I get confused about what’s going on in an audio drama. Not here! Everything was so well written that I could show this to one of my friends and given a little backstory about the audio drama, they could follow along without me pausing and explaining everything. That is how good this writing is. Don’t even get me started with the whole “Discord sad boi times” thing. I was trying to stay strong throughout the song but when Discord got to Fluttershy’s journal I couldn’t hold my tears. The parts with Nightmare Star were excellent as well! I know I may seem a bit flat in a way with using different vocabulary words to describe this, but I am trying my best to really explain how I feel about this! I’m sure that you know that this is amazing and I’m not trying to make it seem like it needs to be forced upon you. I’m saying all of this because this episode is so wonderful. To wrap this ridiculously long comment up, I just want to thank Ashley, if she’s reading this. You are what keeps this fandom alive. I was feeling pretty down with everything going on at the moment, but this episode lifted me right up. Thank you for pouring your time and heart into Remembrance. Such a project like this will always be left in my memory. :>

[@Lillyhoves]

I’m so sad I can’t watch it live because it is midnight

[@BitesforNugget]

Sooo, are we gonna talk about how Gal finally said she loves Flurry? Okay, jokes aside, this is an amazing episode, and I can't wait for the end! Twi and her friends are definitely gonna win, I kinda want the nightmare too..anyways, like I said, great episode, keep up the work Ashley and Staff.

[@Mom-pz3ms]

Kyella Forever yA sHe GaY

[@BitesforNugget]

@@Mom-pz3ms yEsHhHh #Gaysquad (I'm bi.)

[@whoeveriam789]

Just because someone says they love someone to the same gender doesn't mean their necessarily gay.

[@BitesforNugget]

@@whoeveriam789 I know that, I just like the idea of these two dating. I think they'd be really cute together.

[@FeligamiAdrizoeSworaDooplivian]

@@BitesforNuggetAgreed. But my question is? Are they both Bi? Both lesbian? Or is one of them bi and the other a lesbian?

[@melissacr4760]

Ashley h u did an amazing job on this can't wait for the final episode

[@looneymicrophone6431]

Episodes still have 10 and 11

[@Mor1moo]

ITS CANON YESS MY GAY SELF IS STILL FREAKING OUT AHHHHH I’m talking about flurry and gal if you can’t guess...

[@liladuvendack9931]

Let’s just appreciate that this was uploaded on Lesbian Day of Visibility too Probably not intentional but still

[@Mor1moo]

Lila Duvendack yess!!! I didn’t realise that!!

[@Aszhley]

YES AGREED

[@discontinuedchannel2392]

I KNOOOOOOOWWWW, my little gay heart is singing!

[@clownemoji5395]

*LETS GO LESBIANS LETS GO*

[@guineapig5858]

It's so good! I cried and then the last song sang was too catchy, I can't believe I'm a week late! It's deffinetly great in this difficult time, I am proud of you to have kept going despite the computer damage, (I know that all well due to my laptop deleting an essay I spent ages on, and it's very frustrating) the voices were amazing, the art was amazing, the editing was amazing. Personally I think it couldn't have come at a better time, sadly a lot of people are struggling with grief right now. This is like a god send. I mean you don't gain any money for this, this is a free thing on KZbin. And despite some snarky remarks and terrible technology, you still keep going along with the rest of the team. You have really come far!

[@KittyCatMeowMeowTime]

Oh my goodness! I don't know how, but I missed this! What a treat! Thank you for all your hard work Ashley H.

[@MellowOptimist]

At the start of the episode, I was already slowly breaking down to tears as the story progressed - I was crying all the way up to discord's song, my tears hit hardest at this point. You all did a beautiful job on this, keep up with the amazing work. I look foreward to future episodes. 😂

[@PeytonWalsh]

This episode made me cry because I enjoy this episode so much. I love the Discord and Fluttershy part because that made me ball like a baby. I also love Flurry and Galaxy's relationship growing too.

[@17keelh14]

Finally can't wait to watch it.

[@amanda-mf2uk]

Please tell me I’m not the only one who see’s something more than a friendship between Galaxy and Flurry, and this was really worth the wait well done to everyone who has worked on this it’s absolutely beautiful ☺️

[@michellemich5783]

I loved this! Exited for ep.10! Stay safe Ashley!

[@Gresekjr122]

Just Finished & I only have this to say. Oh my goddesses this was worth the Waite. I really enjoyed the songs. Everyone did a fabulous job. Keep up the good work Ashley H. Take your time posting the next part of this wonderful project. Have a wonderful day.

[@BeesMeliss]

Flurry seems to have Mommy Issues.

[@itsnothanss]

You got me 😂

[@autumbreeze1129]

... so, was Fluttershy's spirit in the throne, because that's what it looked like to. You've made one fatal mistake, Nightmare Star, you let Luna get away. She's given Twilight reason to hesitate on using the resurrection spell. Stepping away from it will awaken loyalty. In a word, Nightmare, you're screwed

[@ReecesCrushedToPieces]

43:30 I-... The songs around here seem legit hand-picked... But really, I love the fact that you used a lot of these well known songs, "All eyes on me", "Believer", "Again", and "Smoke and Mirrors". I love how I can either recognize the tune or the song itself. GJ!! ^^

[@melissacr4760]

I can't wait for mlp remembrance ep 9 breaking point

[@looneymicrophone6431]

I seen it already no spoilers just say grab tissue

[@meredithburgess7034]

The tears are real. You did a great job with this Ashley H good job to the others that helped with this you all worked very hard on this I bet

[@Jade01134]

I just want to say thank you so freaking much for all the hard work you and the cast and all the artists and music producers put into this beautiful series. I've been following this channel for years and I just wanted to write a comment about how much I appreciate all that you and everyone does.

[@tristentopiacraft]

Discord’s song almost made me cry. I could feel the tears coming. I know twilight can help everyone. She just needs to realize that the elements of harmony are within her as well as the spirits of her friends. They have never truly left her. I know she can do this.

[@omegamimikyu996]

My brother: I won't cry Me: you'll eat those words (During discord's song) My brother: *crying like crazy* Me: Told you dude..... I told you *crying even more*