What Happens If You Disarm All The Legendary Gunslingers And Willy Curlls - Red Dead Redemption 2

#rdr2 #reddeadredemption #arthurmorgan
Arthur Meets All The Legendary Gunslingers

[@ashokakash1992]

I remember accidentally discovering Emmet’s house even before starting the gunslinger mission. I killed him and fed him to the pigs. But after activating the mission he respawned again.

[@anonymousstill9276]

That can't be possible, since Emma only spawns once the mission starts. Before that it's only a random rancher that spawns, with three hats that you save in your inventory

[@Kiabblanctorche]

@@anonymousstill9276 if you kill him before working, he respawns

[@filipbitala2624]

Happens with many others, like micah or the guy that give you tb, not that i tried or anything

[@luriddream]

​@@Kiabblanctorche ok mind showing us how you kill someone who did not yet spawn?

[@levipolacek6938]

@@luriddream didnt happen spent well over 500 hours playing the game only time you see these people are in the missons

[@HESHRocketWarhead]

There's something just so fucking disrespectful about walking up and slapping Flaco when he gets his shotgun out.

[@Evanflame-rk9xu]

"You put that back where you got it, partner. You done lost already"

[@Mangaka_Library]

​@Evanflame-rk9xu *Slaps away Shotgun off hand* *Continues to Beat down with just fists*

[@PreposterousPineapplePerson]

"CQC it is then"

[@damienthetexasian6827]

Emmet does it. Sadie does it. Charles does it. Why Can't I Quickdraw a throwing knife !

[@SolusFather]

Because you don’t bring a knife to a gunfight

[@insightfulno]

@@SolusFather YESSS

[@jamespeech9141]

Because Arthur's hands ain't gifted with the hands of a Brit

[@littleaqua32]

@@jamespeech9141 he's been referenced by Bill in Chapter 2 during the Social Call mission as being pretty good with throwing knives though, but maybe he meant Arthur was good at killing people with knives.

[@cheese3764]

They all can throw NORMAL knife, why we can't?

[@SergStrzelecki]

Calloway can’t be disarmed. Even shot in leg will instantly kill him

[@ankhangnguyenoan9205]

Nah everywhere on his body

[@szdxw]

Well, that confirm he isn’t a gunslinger.

[@ankhangnguyenoan9205]

Yeah Black Belle says he's a coward while they fight

[@Lineproof]

@@szdxw of course he is, he’s like the 2nd-3rd fastest draw in the entirety of rdr (maybe, ofc it’s just speculation)

[@falsetitle6940]

@@Lineproof Arthur and John have 1st and 2nd covered.

[@chorizojoe8282]

The only ones I enjoyed encountering were Black Belle and Flaco Hernández. My wife showed me that if I antagonized Flaco’s men, they’d respect me, and I love how they minded their own business after my standoff with him. On the other hand, teaming up with black belle was such a fun mission, too. Arthur’s journal entry about her was the final touch to it

[@awad5579]

Seriously if I antagonise then they don't give a shit?

[@shinobiloko4672]

​@@awad5579 yes

[@chorizojoe8282]

@@awad5579 yeah. I tried to defuse and got lit up😂

[@hylianro]

I just threatened instead of antagonizing and it works the same

[@cuntress9000]

you're telling me i could've just antagonized them and avoided the guilt of having to kill all of them? this game really surprises me sometimes lmao

[@ShasOSwoll]

I like how Billy Midnight is inspired by Robert Ford, an unassuming, unheroic character who killed someone in his sleep (instead of in the back), and despite becoming famous, is now overrun with guilt

[@RogerCharlamange]

Jesse James didn't die in his sleep, he was shot in the back of the head while dusting a photo, likely accepting his fate. "On April 3, 1882, after eating breakfast, the Fords' and James' went into the living room before travelling to Platte City. By reading the daily newspaper, James had just learned of gang member Liddil's confession for participating in Hite's murder and grew increasingly suspicious of the Fords for never reporting this matter to him. According to Robert Ford, it became clear to him that James had realized they were there to betray him. However, instead of scolding the Fords, James walked across the living room to lay his revolvers on a sofa. He turned around and noticed a dusty picture above the mantel, and stood on a chair in order to clean it. Robert Ford drew his weapon and shot James in the back of the head before running out of the house while yelling to Zerelda that "it was an accident"

[@ShasOSwoll]

@@_Zephster No I'm talking about Billy Midnight

[@squeaky206]

Robert Ford killed the guy while he was dusting off something, so it was in the back or the head.

[@SpinAttackLink]

@@ShasOSwollyup when you’re chasing him he’ll say “I didn’t shoot him in his sleep” or something like that

[@he1senberg79]

fun fact about calloway he tries to blind you with his belt buckle when you duel him

[@thegamingkirby8696]

Never noticed it at all TBH, I'm just that oblivious

[@-INSERT_FUNNY_HERE-]

Doesn’t surprise me.

[@theunfunnyjokester]

Too bad for him he didn’t know that Arthur Morgan views the world in third person

[@carodar34]

thats some small awesome detail right there god damn it didnt even noticed

[@error4v0r47]

It would’ve been so cool if Arthur just said his name and we could’ve heard Jack say it in the epilogue. Because in the epilogue, if you complete this side quest, you can hear Abigail and John arguing about the book Theodore wrote.

[@-_J_-]

Imagine the shock on John's face when he reads the last few pages of the book because it says "Apart from Black Belle, every one of them died by the gun of Arthur Morgan"

[@TheMarianadealmeida]

⁠​⁠@@-_J_-i dont mean to be a dick but Theodore never knew the name of arthur since arthur never told him

[@TheMegacooldude69]

@@TheMarianadealmeida I believe his comment was in response to the theoretical where Arther gave Theodore his name, not in reference to what happened in game

[@rocketpigrecords3719]

​@@-_J_-*Tacitus Kilgore

[@pedroaltamirano8265]

Arthur should been on a cigarette card like the main character from the remastered mafia

[@pepenger_in_the_bushes]

Imagine cigarette card with Arthur in remake of first RDR but on that he is named as "Tacitus Killgore".

[@EasternOutlaw09]

Yeah, it would’ve been cool to see a description of Arthur in his prime. If he looked like he how did in game it wouldn’t make sense. But it makes sense in Mafia because it spans 8 years.

[@donttreadonme123]

@@pepenger_in_the_bushes 💀

[@unclebuns5286]

@@pepenger_in_the_bushesor “Fenton”

[@hylianro]

​@@pepenger_in_the_busheshis picture is in the art gallery during that one mission with the guy drawing lewd pictures of people's relatives I'm surprised there was never a card referencing Arthur

[@TruthbtoldMD]

Tried so hard to disarm midnight twice

[@David_Quinn_Photography]

I don't think its doable I wanted to keep him from offing him self and I restarted the mission over and over and no cigar after about an hour.

[@Monkey62403]

​@@David_Quinn_Photography he hit the second gun. You just can't disarm him again.

[@here9087]

Midnight is too hard, when I'm going to disarm him he just crouches. And he does it way too fast for me to react.

[@zmx363]

I tried to disarm him a second time too and ends up somehow killing him even if I hit his gun

[@carodar34]

midnight can only be disarmed once, the second one is just a straight kill sadly

[@gothxm]

Arthur would be a movie star if he was real. its hilarious seeing him doubt himself or act like a fool when the man just oozes charisma

[@Aedlmonrl]

It's probably because he's an outlaw and that he's killed innocents too. He's a humble down to earth guy knowing what he truly is after all

[@kinggamer4618]

You have to kill them in order to continue the mission whether they do themselves or they kill you. Mission dialog won't process until its done

[@ragergamer3111]

Not true, you can knock out Flaco and still take his pic without killing him. Idk about Granger but I did it with Flaco

[@platinumblast8610]

@@ragergamer3111 you can do it with granger as well

[@pascalg16]

​@@ragergamer3111Maybe they die from the punches.

[@hylianro]

​@@pascalg16yeah I think the game considers knock outs as killing them, the little X icon appears on the minimap (which if u hover over it, it reads "corpse") and you lose honor

[@ArrowThrills]

​@@hylianrodamn

[@squaredanimator]

I remember I accidentally disarmed granger. I thought I got the good result and I would be able to take an alive picture. But no, I was caught offguard and got stabbed.

[@Admiralkirk95]

I guess Calloway can't be disarmed. I played it and noticed he seems to flash his belt at you. Wonder if you can do quick draws in first person and it's blinding you slightly. Underhanded until the very end.

[@Goosecaboose47231]

Calloway may be underhanded but he still has a pretty good draw so I’d think that some of his renown might have at least a tiny bit of validity

[@-INSERT_FUNNY_HERE-]

Look closer during the duel. He tries to blind Arthur with his belt buckle. I think that lost him any validity he may have had

[@Bithe_Get]

Calloway's not even that fast you can see his draw is like normal speed on the cutscene

[@nickdegugs7190]

I REALLY tried to disarm Midnight but darn it he’s still a hell of quick draw, I thought it was impossible

[@AshwinY]

Yup he's fast lol

[@nickdegugs7190]

@@AshwinYI was able to spare Grainger on my second time around. Unfortunately I was trying to get minimal honor so I shot him anyway.

[@rtgedits1865]

If arthur can kill all of those legendary gunslinger, then why isn't he a legendary gunslinger himself? Edit: seriously i was only just asking why arthur is not known as a legendary gunslinger in the game when he could easily kill the legendary gunslingers and you guys started an argument because of it.

[@tianrunzhang6557]

He is. When Midnight is disarmed: "Don't miss." When Arthur is disarmed: "Put the gun down! Alright, lemme see em palms. You're coming with me!"

[@zookazeroALT]

He is but when he was asked what his name was to be recognized he said I'm nobody

[@corporatecat230]

He is because that's how real life works, you don't get an achievement bar over your head in real life whenever you accomplish something. Dude, come out of your room for at least 10 minutes

[@notyourdaddude1957]

Because Arthur was traveling places to places all the time, always changed his identity where he goes faking his name so no one would recognize him. This people aren't know for being famous outlaws but for being skilled with their guns when somebody challenges them, plus most of this gunslingers are either retired or on the run from the law like Black Belle. I'm sure if Arthur would have reached a much older age, he would be very well known too.

[@geometrydash8834]

he is, hes 'The gunslinger with no name', it's actually a reference to Clint Eastwood the 'no named gunslinger'

[@keecko8169]

wish the revolver midnight used to shoot himself wasnt just a cattleman. Itd be sick to get an extra revolver that you could show off to all your homies (also wish that characters in game acknowledged rare weapons like calloway's or flaco's revolvers. If they're legendary for their gun skills then their guns should also be legendary and recognizable, so itd be cool if atleast 3 or 4 npcs would acknowledge how rare the guns were)

[@mattybutler1985]

The only one with a weapon that's notable is Midnight, his pistol is a Mauser, which is not only probably the best sidearm in the game but you can get it as early as Chapter 2, WAY before you're normally supposed to. I make a point of doing this quest in Chapter 2 because of that. Well, Calloway's revolver has the motto from Bully on it which is cool too.

[@TriCop]

@@mattybutler1985Might be my preference but the shofield revolvers are the best sidearms mausers do too little damage and are too inaccurate unless you like cheating with dead eye

[@mattybutler1985]

The main benefit of the Mauser is having a magazine, it carries more bullets than any other sidearm and reloads much quicker. It's great for a single sidearm. Revolvers are good for dual wielding as they circumvent the capacity disadvantage.

[@TriCop]

@@mattybutler1985 Ok but when using dead eye it automatically reloads for you so having an extra 4-8 bullets doesn’t matter much to me at least

[@TriCop]

@@mattybutler1985 I will agree it reloads quicker but to me it just doesn’t matter if dead eye does it for you yknow?

[@Rn-rk7qb]

5:15 "I SAID DRAW" "no-" "YES"

[@sunnyyy1437]

"COME ON, DRAW!" "Why?!" "I SAID DRAW, GOD DAMN IT!" "No." *_"YES!!!"_*

[@LlFE]

I love how Black Belle rides off like the Wicked Witch of the West

[@nonenone2173]

That also sounds like a female gunslinger name

[@11Reaper9]

I love and respect Billy Midnight end. “You come for me?!? So come on!!” Sadly I have to put you down. But tits my favorite line in the game.

[@sharpsupressorgaming5682]

Tits 💀

[@racist2708]

tits

[@riyadhussain2027]

Tits

[@hayk3000]

Tits are my favourite in the game too

[@frostansalt6536]

Tits !!?

[@BigFatJuicyMonkies]

I had to watch the Calloway scene several times because it was just such great voice acting.

[@wingsofblackedbrandy4798]

Arthur:No… lmfao idk why that was so funny to me

[@RBCharger]

How did you get Black Belle to pose like that? Did you just delay until she changed poses?

[@AshwinY]

There's option.. Change pose

[@ghostwhencodghosts9114]

Did you even play the game

[@RBCharger]

@@ghostwhencodghosts9114 Are you trying to be mean for some reason? Yeah, I played. 8 times with 100% completions. I just didn't spend a lot of time taking pictures.

[@-INSERT_FUNNY_HERE-]

@@RBChargeralright but even still. The option was right there at the side of the screen, and after completing the game 8 times you’d think you would’ve seen it by then

[@RBCharger]

@@-INSERT_FUNNY_HERE- I actually did know that at one time. In my photo file, I have pictures of Black Belle in different poses. The good thing about going senile is that I can play games over and over. I just play them over and over until I get good at them then take long breaks. The only way I know how many times I played the game is that there is one photo in Blackwater that is mission related and you only get one shot at it.

[@catrawiner]

Love that you just b*tch-slapped Flaco’s gun out of his hand

[@ion_force]

Some of them you didn't seem to try disarming.

[@bibby659]

Doesn't look like disarms to me, least not all of them. And even the ones you do end up typically ending themselves. Only one actually bothers just letting their picture get taken.

[@dr.hugog.hackenbush9443]

Even if you shoot his gun/hand?

[@ankhangnguyenoan9205]

Same like Micah

[@AshwinY]

Yes

[@ErichKartmann]

And sheriff Malloy

[@WoRLDs_CoLLiDiNG]

perfect editing I watched every second and will again

[@kevinboy2758]

Bro i swear i coudnt disarm anyone. Idk how but i just coudnt

[@AshwinY]

Shoot at hand

[@notyourdaddude1957]

What you mean? you played the part when Arthur must save Mary's brother from the cult right? in that scene you shoot to disarm him, the same thing you do in every duel. You just shoot their hands, the hand that holds the gun of course.

[@fortniteawesome7]

@@notyourdaddude1957 he could have done the gunslinger missions before then, and also you dont have to do the mission for mary's brother. I'm still playing as arthur and i accidentally skipped it because i took too long in the cutscene so she got pissed

[@notyourdaddude1957]

@@fortniteawesome7 Well you don't have to do it but it's a pretty important side mission that you usually don't want to skip. That basically is the start of building up the enstrained relationship between Mary and Arthur, so it's a pretty important mission that connects with the main story.

[@kevinboy2758]

@@notyourdaddude1957 i played that too i disarmed him but not on the first try

[@gladlawson61]

One of the fun missions in rdr2.

[@imcrow6674]

shit i remember trying to disarm them my first time playing rdr2 (like how you can in rdr1) but every damn time id just hit their gun and get shot so i never thought you could disarm them

[@MiguelOhara187]

It does seem instinctively to throw Calloway into the river 😂

[@joshuagrahambrown]

After all these years, I’d never seen the “Keep Your Dreams Simple” until now

[@dennndennnn]

The jingle that plays after every gunslinger dies goes so hard.

[@kadbenson7540]

Midnight has the coolest looking unique weapon in my opinion

[@Dovah_Slayer]

Remember, dont forget to pick up their guns. You will never ever see them again

[@ajsalcove1762]

I shot Billy Midnight’s hand right when he pulled out the gun to unliven himself and he died. It was so disappointing, like, don’t give me a chance like that if it’s not allowed Rockstar

[@TheRipVanWinkle1899]

Calloways revolver and Otis Millers revolver is an awesome combo

[@zeenathismail8054]

The controller has been ordered now I wait for money

[@blengdiabloed7335]

You can actually hogtie Emmet though. Like he is gonna charge you with a knife, but I just hogtied him and you can get his mugshot while he's tied. Same for Flaco. Like I shot his gun, went to him to hogtie him, and he's just down there cursing you lmao. At the very least, they're not dead. They are a bit slower compare to Jim Calloway. Jim, however cannot be disarmed and he's friggin fast too.

[@MegaTsab]

What hat is that you wearing? I’m thinking it’s the rodeo hat but modded to be smaller but hoping I’m wrong and it’s in the vanilla game and I missed it since I’m on console lol

[@nee_suhh]

I've never seen that carved in the ice like that

[@quintenj21]

I loke how what evers writing in the ice he like showed but didnt show what it said so we could discover it by ourselves

[@Miltypooh2001]

I remember trying to disarm billy midnight but he was just too quick it took me a couple of tries until i finally did it then he pulled out another gun and shot himself

[@TheRamblingSoul]

Do you need to shoot them on their hand, arm or gun to disarm them?

[@Watermelon_cat87328]

Black Belle:"just the way it is"

[@Gilber1606]

Didnt knew disarmig folks was an option

[@cdtv3602]

0:22 *"i don't have a name!"* ~arthur morgan 1899

[@BlackLung36]

Does Anyone Know What You Get Once You Kill All Gunslingers Except Black Belle (Not The Guns) Like Do You Get Any Special Clothing Or Outfits?

[@piercehubbard4086]

6:09 can you call this man to draw? I don’t know if I ever came across him, I do like to go into bars and start hell on people talking crap though.

[@StefKebab]

Fun fact bcus not everyone knows this, id you antagonize Flaco's boys, they actually just let you in to talk, and when yoy kill Flaco they run away lol

[@alvarosoares3530]

calloways last mission was so fun lol

[@MoeruGoRound]

I like how KZbin allows you to show a man shooting himself without censoring but not saying the word kill.

[@amyspahr849]

Sadly I can't do any because my current save is glitched bc right when I draw I die instantly always

[@JonnesTT]

Arthur be running around, doing legendary gunslinger deeds and using one of the gangs letter aliases. There ain't no need for a rat, if that name is used to pickup letters. All you oughta do is ask around post offices where letters to that name are being sent to and you'll know where the gang is. Then you only have to look around good spots to camp and you'll have them. Hell, with 5.000 dollars the pinkertons could've stationed people at most lucrative targets in the area and caught the gangs riders one by one.

[@Notion752]

Ok?

[@MiiNiPaa]

> where letters to that name are being sent to Nowhere. Once a boy went in and took the letters. That boy lives here. He tells that when he played at the edge of the town a man came and asked if he could get letters from the post office for him. He paod a quarter for that. Mentioned that he got into a drunk fight with a postmaster and doesn't want to interact with him. He did that and that was the last he saw him. This is how it usually works.

[@empdisaster10]

They dont use the same name all of the time. Killgore is just the current one. If they suspected the name to be compromised they'd change it. They also never had it delivered to the same post office, usually they'd get it sent to a post office they werent at and then would travel to go get it

[@glenmarkgregorio8167]

0:22 The Dollars Trilogy reference🤠👌

[@buddythecowboy]

I disarmed Flaco once and then he pulled out another gun and then shot me and then I had to redo it and then I accidentally killed him instead of disarm him

[@joe.142]

didnt even know you could disarm them 💀

[@EnoYaka]

U didnt even disarm them all u shot that dude right in the chest

[@GENTLEBEAR_FOREVER]

He can'tbe disarmed

[@qwerty.44]

I couldn’t disarm Emmet or Flaco, Midnight was a little easier though.

[@Epinardscaramel]

I didn't even know you could disarm people in duels!

[@-INSERT_FUNNY_HERE-]

Well then have you played the mission with Jamie? Mary’s little brother? Because you’re required to disarm him in that mission to keep him from killing himself

[@lasonris8934]

I shot the first guy in the hand, (the one you have to chase) Apparently I hit an artery or something because a hand shot killed him

[@sdavid__]

i dissrmed granger so fast he dropped two knives and no guns

[@barnousauresrex2662]

After i killed billy midnight my horse decided to run into the train like and idiot

[@johannesseyfried7933]

Midnight was the only one who I felt a bit bad for (except for Black Belle maybe, she was cool too). All other gunslingers you meet on the quest are assholes, but Billy Midnight was just paranoid. He didn't have to die. At least not because of something as simple as a misunderstanding.

[@TheHQZombie]

Do you have to kill/knockout Flaco? What about hogtie?

[@LeShawnDeWalrus]

I kinda wish brontes mauser was unique too, 2 unique mausers.

[@chrishamilton7516]

“No” “YEEEESSSSSSSS”

[@sahilhossain8204]

Lore of What Happens If You Disarm All The Legendary Gunslingers And Willy Curlls - Red Dead Redemption 2 momentum 100

[@mujtabamalikzada5177]

Can we kill them as john marston or just arthur ????

[@glenmarkgregorio8167]

1:37 "Death before dishonor" though🤷

[@dasPanthertier123]

Arthur being better at dueling than all those famous gunslingers is equivalent to random buskers often being better at their instruments than ultra famous musicians

[@BelethorsGeneralGoodsStore]

Something I find interesting is that Belle is the only woman AND survivor of the legendary gunslinger missions.

[@Birbboy.]

I mean, Arthur does write on his journal they would be killing people together if she was younger, and writes "Black Belle - What a woman"

[@luisosvaldogarza5377]

Black belle hearing about the others gunslingers: - Men ☕

[@ianmoriarty2199]

Was disappointed when I successfully shot at Midnight's second pistol, but the game just ignored me.

[@entrypoint7834]

There’s a bug when you disarm Calloway

[@gigantor6519]

4:43 The shooting, and the victim's death pose afterward. I've seen something like it before in RDR2. (No spoilers for those who haven't played the game, but IYKYK)

[@bobsburgers2071]

there all past there prime

[@bbbenson9508]

I full drew on midnight and knocked out gringer

[@Thelonelydrifterman]

5:17 no YES

[@glenmarkgregorio8167]

4:36 Arthur: Girls with guns, alway hot. Wait what-😳

[@grimreaper6060]

I thought I was the only one that threw Calloway's body off the cliff...

[@chickennugget9004]

I thought I was the only one that did that 😂

[@grimreaper6060]

@@chickennugget9004 I bet everyone does that... At least the first time they play.

[@marinaheizmann9580]

4:40 whats the name of this gunslinger?

[@HvttFuyf-dz8jr]

Why was billy midnight so real

[@diaperfang5293]

Always pissed me off how we gun down all the dudes and not Black Belle.

[@The_Great_Idiot]

Can you do this after the ending

[@AshwinY]

Yes

[@BigOlRub]

You can actually shoot the black belle while she rides away. Stole her gun and her horse.

[@Bithe_Get]

She has a gun?? Its unique?

[@TuPapishamp00]

bro did not disarm jim boy calloway

[@chicotheworld9763]

i forgot all about these. can you do them as john?

[@AshwinY]

Yes

[@idonthavethefoggiestidea7187]

5:16 “no”

[@StellaNBellaOfficial]

5:52 i did this the same thing after i killed calloway.

[@TheGaza93]

Never knew she did another pose…

[@USS_Grey_Ghost]

I wander if there is a way to disarm without them having to die

[@hylianro]

I think I have a mod that does that. The mission simply doesn't progress, you have to kill them for anything to happen

[@olivergarcia6144]

Who’s faster Landon Rickets or Jim boy calloway

[@AshwinY]

Willy curlls

[@SonnyDraxler]

Clint Eastwood

[@AxenfonKlatismrek]

Lucky Luke

[@Synpathetix]

Jayden Mcleen

[@thesenate4630]

Walter White

[@turtlecb1]

Good thing you censored "Kills himself". I was really close to becoming aware that the character in question might kill himself, and therefore suffer the resulting mental strain of imagining that gruesome event -- at least for the additional 2.3 seconds before he actually did blow the better part of his face off, followed by a lengthy examination of his ruined body. But man, if I had to see that letter "i", I don't know what I would've done. Probably would've never recovered 🙁

[@jameshubert6103]

So you can’t kill the woman?

[@AshwinY]

Nah..

[@SomeCanine]

Well, you can kill a copy of Black Belle by instigating a crime in the vicinity of the quest and pulling her out of the window, but I don't think that's what you're after.

[@filmesmoon240]

she didn't attack arthur like the men, why would he kill her?

[@jayglover4818]

No there no way in the game that lets you kill her cause she didn't attack you

[@pepenger_in_the_bushes]

@@filmesmoon240 Guns. Her rifle in particular. Let them who is without sin of obtaining unique weapons in games by killing innocent NPCs cast the first stone

[@Kiritsun]

That's a sad mission, all this deads for nothing...

[@maximodiaz802]

Flaco Hernández is in online?

[@tommyzdoesstuff342]

"shit indeed"