Did JWST Debunk The Big Bang?

[@reinster8746]

NASA should really hire you for a news broadcaster

[@TheNoiseySpectator]

Oh, another foreigner coming to our Country to take jobs away from Americans. : < Besides, Australia needs him more. 😂 Update; I was being sarcastic about him being a foreigner coming to take jobs away from Americans. I realize that may not be clear because so many people out there these days _really do_ feel that way. 🙊

[@Turkey1a1aGames]

Fr

[@TheMrNugget]

@@TheNoiseySpectator ?

[@rowdyproductionsarstudios5662]

People make the same comment on every video

[@TheMrNugget]

@@rowdyproductionsarstudios5662 because NASA should

[@HeisenbergFam]

"science was wrong all along" Imagine someone proving Earth is flat or shaped like a donut

[@Iamaplanet]

Its a square believe me i would know

[@Syrius9]

​@@Iamaplanet no its a tesseract

[@ilikecheese4518]

its a dinosaur

[@idkausernamelol_]

​@@ilikecheese4518 its an stair

[@Iamaplanet]

​@@Syrius9 how would u know

[@diogoconstantino9803]

Sooo not exactly, the major problem is the time for this galaxy's to form. These galaxy's that we found are simply too massive to form in that 350 million years, so if they are formed the same way galaxy's are today they started their creation before the big bang. But it doesn't need to break our theory of the big bang (yet) because another theory about the way galaxy's form is being studied. It's quite complex but you can search it up it's really interesting

[@hsbdkdndn]

Science prides itself with the ability to be wrong and claims to welcome it. But in practice it's dogmatic and authoritative like religion. We should be excited to find out our previous theories were wrong!

[@Templarfreak]

there's one particular idea ive heard about how strange star-like bodies could have formed in a primordial universe only millions of years after it had started to form, called Quasi-Stars. the idea is not proven and is still totally theoretical, but: in the primordial universe, things like modern stars could not form so easily due to some factors that i dont have a perfect explanation for, but from my understanding they just would not be able to hold themselves together the material would constantly get carried away. however, what could have been possible was for blackholes to form this early. the thing is, though, they wouldnt be able to become very big, unless they became the center of a Quasi-Star. the black hole creates a strong enough gravity well to become the center of a quasi-star, so the material doesnt get blown away. but, because of the nature of the primordial universe, there's particles "stealing" from its mass all the time, kind of like a naturally-formed blackhole dyson sphere. this keeps the blackhole in a state of equilibrium, unable to swallow up all the mass that makes up the qausi-star, but still being a strong enough gravity well to hold the material in place. eventually, as the primordial universe cooled down, these blackholes won the battle and became the supermassive blackholes that are the centers of galaxies today.

[@Jake-li7ih]

Seems they need the Big Bang to fit their anti religion narrative not realizing that despite popular belief they actually can go hand n hand

[@alanfran]

@@hsbdkdndn Who? i mean, Science is not one thing but a large diverse group of people that comprise it, those who do not give up their theories despite evidence that suggests it is wrong, aren't doing science, and thus aren't doing their job

[@Stjcb_7]

Maybe the galaxies did form in the amount of time required, or maybe the universe is older than we thought? I think there are many possibilities, even primordial galaxies. What is the relationship or ratio between space and time? Maybe time warps in some way when there is less space, skewing our calculations somehow. Maybe these galaxies seem further away than they are because of light refraction or black hole lensing? we just don’t know 😅 personally I feel spiritually is there to help us deal with that grief, science and religion are not necessarily opposites

[@MrFERCHO321]

It’s simple. AstroKobi drops a video, I watch.

[@dollynawaka7733]

Correction:- we all watch 😊

[@dinamo7485]

Why would you need to comment lol

[@weevil5]

bot comment

[@tamigoX]

i was partially inspired to subscribe to him because of this comment. just wanted you to know

[@aaronbeardsley3261]

​@birb5964 you fuckin nailed it my guy. It's hidden in plain sight. Been around big time since YT shorts. Dude most likely went and paid for a certain amount of generated comments/likes. Pretty sad.

[@TheSlothYt]

The queen remembered this

[@elitecereal]

she doesn't anymore

[@Zer0cip]

lol

[@mspaint93]

Lizzie's in a box

[@DatuIskandar215]

​@@elitecereal 💀

[@EnclaveComsOfficer]

​@@elitecereal facts

[@alaster1403]

Bro really said "just 350 million years" 💀💀

[@diecast_tuur]

fr

[@Ahmad_Stn]

If you were to put Earth’s history on a clock, compared to dinosaurs, humans would have been around earth at 11:59pm (i explained that horribly but you get the gist)

[@Shibu-069]

Bro, compared to other galaxies, these are like the oldest and closest to the age of formation of universe. Hence, 350 million years is really less

[@St8Genesis]

Compared to 13.7 billion years like he said in the video literally SECONDS before 350 million years, God y’all just comment whatever without thinking 🤡🤡🤡

[@diecast_tuur]

@@St8Genesis Ow I'm sry, I was wrong, I watched it again.

[@Dstryrr]

We haven't even left spawn and we are trying to figure out the end game build

[@BondrewdAiriDarke]

I love this channel so much, I’m infatuated. Also you should do voice over content for books, ect. Your voice is very captivating.

[@freebird117]

🚨INTRUDER ALERT, A RED SPY IS IN THE BASE🚨

[@chocolaticepeen4489]

​@@freebird117a red spy is in the base?

[@LOKESH_866]

He should be hired as Inter_ galactic space news reporter by all aliens and humans civilizations in the universe.

[@sethmaginnipig1801]

I love the ammount of content you’re releasing AstroKobi ! Please don’t stop

[@daikicipolloni3151]

Science is never wrong. Science just draws new conclusions from new information. Simply put, science learned more.

[@k_slyons7346]

Very well put, basically what I just commented 😊

[@TheCommentCreator]

I read it as science is wrong

[@cully7927]

Science is always wrong until proven right, and always right until proven wrong.

[@bigedslobotomy]

Whenever I see click bait titles like “This disproves the Big Bang” I just keep on scrolling. Ain’t nobody got time for that!

[@DarthVaderfr]

Sensationalistic youtubers are such a waste of human capabilities

[@yousifalkilabi]

I like the theory’s and music on this channel.

[@firooziehsan]

Can you imagine the tech those aliens must have. 13 billion years of advancements. I cant even comprehend.

[@Ari-ft3lm]

It's not debunked big bang, but Galaxies should take billion year to formed. So they have to recalculate, change all of the previous work. and it strengthens the theory that big bang is not the beginning but continuity of many big bang. Sorry I'm not really good with science but that it's what i van take from Michio Kaku interview

[@Mike-xi4zt]

@Ari-ft3/m the Big bang is based on running redshift Doppler observation in reverse. There are more than one things that can cause the stretching of light which is what redshift is. Moving away is not the only cause of redshift stretching of light waves.

[@tempestive1]

Every single time "science was wrong", it's been corrected by more and better science. Someone saying "science debunked the Big Bang" just showcases how little that person knows about scientific methods.

[@Deplayo]

Actually there is a theory behind this phenomenal where it explains why these galaxies were made sooner than we thought, its called the black hole star, Kuzgezert talked about this in this video! Its like some sort of a star that has a blackhole inside of it which makes the black hole consuming the star while pushing it away because of radiation at the same time, causing the star to grow even larger , shorly after the star gets to the point where it's not stabilized and blows up, causing the fragments to rotate around the black hole, and creating a galaxy! Such fascinating world we live in!

[@Zachary-]

Any new discovery about the big bang will not prove science is wrong. It will just show that there's always more to learn.

[@user-dn1oz6td5r]

It's also called the Big Bang THEORY for a reason. It's not a fact. It's just a theory

[@annanowak9620]

So science was right because they proved it was wrong 😂

[@euphoriaashoor7348]

Do a longer video with more details please

[@dewsada]

Ur content is insane, keep it up bro!!!

[@titasghosh9729]

We can see the big bang as the cmb

[@yakman31]

We never know when it started if we dont know where it ended.

[@alexandrosandreou8585]

Light has entered the chat

[@AlanRobinsonArun]

​@@alexandrosandreou8585energy

[@vanshasvani9210]

Thanks bro for making my intrest towards space more now I have knowledge of space which I wouldn't be having if I didnt saw ur videos really inspiring

[@dannyvegito6357]

😂didn't get anything out of this one Kobi

[@Bogey84]

The controversy surrounding this discovery is that the galaxies in question are more developed than previously observed in the universe. This is why theres now speculation around the big bang. Its not that they cant exist at this stage of the universes expansion, but that theyre more developed than they “should” be for how young they are from our perspective-which suggests they may possibly have formed prior to 13.8b years ago.

[@freddywizowski8605]

This wouldn't disprove the big bang either way. It would merely mean we miscalculated the age of the universe.

[@JB-yc1lk]

Love the stache on you

[@Mr_Astro-Vera]

My theory is multiple big bangs where after a Long Long time all the energy loses & gravity pulls everything again & when finally all the attoms arrive not necessarily all of them BOOOM

[@TsoiIzAlive]

Damn you should teach Physics at Harvard

[@Conqueror25]

It's one of the three theories.Big bang, constant existence of universe and then this. That the big crunch and the big bang are looped in a helical structure. Big bang happens. Uni expands, then at some point, it reverses, then big crunch, then another big bang

[@DarthVaderfr]

More like an hypothesis

[@Mr_Astro-Vera]

@@TsoiIzAlive Thank You Brother

[@Mr_Astro-Vera]

@@DarthVaderfr yeah what ever

[@KoolBreeze420]

ChatAi already told me the theory can't be broken but needs to be tweaked. I asked it a few days ago.

[@shlaugen]

God let's us see what we're ready to see

[@user-dn1oz6td5r]

Huh? What are you even saying

[@InAeternumRomaMater]

Still waiting for the reason why that's not the case...

[@InAeternumRomaMater]

@Sk6 That's not the entire reason actually. There was the argument that it had to take much more time for a galaxy to form after the Big Bang than just 350 million you absolut buffoon

[@DarthVaderfr]

​@Sk6 how does that need further explanation

[@DarthVaderfr]

@Sk6 yeah i mean the video and the comment of aeternum, how does the video needs further explanation 😂😂😂

[@hsbdkdndn]

Science prides itself with the ability to be wrong and claims to welcome it. But in practice it's dogmatic and authoritative like religion. We should be excited to find out our previous theories were wrong!

[@DarthVaderfr]

@@hsbdkdndn science is xactly like this you simply don't take part in it but you yearn to have an opinion that guarantees that you will have an higher moral standards in comparison with the actual system to which you obviously don't understand nothing about it and formed the opinion among youtube videos You didn't even listened to this short who literally explained why this particular datas didn't disprove the big bang theory and you still commented in this way? Is English your third language? you simply don't understand that once something had been tested thousands of times, is simply irrefutable, that doesn't mean science is dogmatic, that simply means that if i tried something a million times you can't just wander around and say the opposite of what we tested and pretending that your ideas has the same validity as my facts, cause nature it's not democratic, you simply are illusioned by this common misconception and think that science is dogmatic cause it refutes your unsustained claims that you copy pasted from ignorants on youtube

[@flh_]

i love ur content sm

[@Mr_Astro-Vera]

He reuploads some of his videos thinking We’re stupid?

[@flh_]

@@Mr_Astro-Vera he just posts the same video on different platforms to reach a bigger audience

[@Blackhole-TON618]

​@@Mr_Astro-Vera bro took it personally

[@captain76580]

Just 350milloon years 💀💀💀☠️☠️☠️

[@ariamh823]

How the hell do they give age to some random lights(that look like dots in a 144p image) in uncomprehensable number of years that are too goddamn far from us?

[@Ed.strell]

I don’t know maybe do some research and see

[@Dogthedeadly]

Stars are aged by calculating the amount of redshift, which gives distance. Since we know the speed of light, we can determine how old the light reaching us is based off of its distance from us.

[@vivekrai4559]

The way u explain is top notch😊

[@TungstenCarbide-hj9nl]

God truly has blessed us

[@user-dn1oz6td5r]

Yes, god really blessed us by creating galaxies that we will never go to or have anything to do with ever.😂

[@TungstenCarbide-hj9nl]

@@user-dn1oz6td5r yup, he went above and beyond, just like always

[@RealmsSMPStudios]

Another thing to take into account is that the heat back then was I think around 10 trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion! Degrees Fahrenheit or something like that, so almost no matter could form, but that doesn’t mean that galaxies couldn’t have already be taking shape from the Protons and Neutrons and Electrons that were flying around…

[@officialhackse]

Yeah man 350m years is Soo soon💀

[@stanhxz5039]

What is the song/music called on the background of this video?

[@Mahi-ni2fm]

Solas by Jamie Duffy

[@stanhxz5039]

@@Mahi-ni2fm Thx!

[@Askebo]

I heard you like space, there's a cool space exploration game called outer wilds you may enjoy, made everyone I know (including me) cry, it's a very beautiful game

[@Gordon_Freeman484]

Outer wilds fans when they travel to the galaxy thats older than the universe but instead of finding a quantum forest, they find a regular galaxy

[@evrenthaman2049]

I saw a super nova of a star that was on top of the moon it was super bright in austrailia

[@Leostorch819]

that one galaxy that is 0.1 second older than milky way be like am almost like you bro

[@kylieshaye6562]

I love this haircut so much

[@bungogoldbungo8285]

Australians call it a mullet

[@DarthVaderfr]

My boy is rizzing through a screen

[@user-nz5cl1qg8q]

How can nothing come from nothing and what started the big bang what started it all

[@user-lw2hh9fk2l]

Nothing started everthing🤫🤫🤫 Joke btw

[@weeelums5963]

People are rapidly forgetting what science IS. If we prove ourselves wrong about a theory, science didn’t fail us, it worked as intended. We should always be trying to prove ourselves wrong in order to get closer to the truths of the universe. Finding out that some galaxies are much older than we thought is great news because it helps us refine our theory of the Big Bang. That’s all science is, discovering, correcting, and refining our understandings to get closer to the grand mysteries of the universe.

[@FoxtrotsGame]

Outer Wilds moment lol

[@Y2sin15]

The thing is i only hear space news from you because your way of telling it is really special it makes me always interested in hearing more and more. Like sometimes i just go into your channel and just watch a bunch of your shorts for the 10th time and i still really enjoy them❤

[@bobaman5426]

This is crazy

[@Dovahki1n]

As someone once said “Let there be light”

[@stevelaw3886]

Yes, a bronze age goat herder

[@Dovahki1n]

@@stevelaw3886 look up “if Jesus resurrection was a hoax” great skit. You might see how retarded that statement was and could at least come up with something better seeing as you clearly never even touched a Bible let alone read that sacred ancient book.

[@wanmohdazwanwanazman7688]

May you guys success in conquering the first sky, I wish you all good luck.🙂

[@tomatotomoto]

I feel as though there are very few things in life we know for certain. There is much left to discover. One day we could indeed prove some of our most resilient theories wrong. We always need to humble our human minds just a little to realize we know very little compared to the knowledge left in the universe.

[@DarthVaderfr]

Absolute certainty comes just from math theorem and your knowledge of being conscious, everything else could just be a simulation, but you have to be at least a brain in a vat or something

[@matt.nguyen0]

what song is this?

[@bonelessduck8986]

piano

[@xepherart2153]

Solas-jamie duffy

[@matt.nguyen0]

@@xepherart2153 Thank you so much!!!

[@xepherart2153]

@@matt.nguyen0 no problem mate

[@turnip1055]

Hey Astro kobi me and my mate love your videos we sit and talk about space for hours and our main topic is always Astro kobi ❤

[@RainedOnParade]

Science cannot be wrong because it is base knowledge humans have some access to. SCIENTISTS can be wrong because they are people trying to see that base knowledge through a third party we call experimentation. The problem with the way it was phrased is that it easily becomes “the science is settled, the sun orbits the earth” or some modern equivalent.

[@weebmaster9591]

I would’ve expected it to be hot for them to form still

[@slardarfingers]

You’re my hero Kobi

[@Mine_Gamerz_INDIA]

Finally found someone saying that JWST didn't broke BIG BANG

[@TheTrueYonko]

I mean it was pretty obvious but people will do anything to sound right 🤷

[@majorfails5512]

Exactly. Its like finding Jurassic dinosaur bones older than we thought and saying that the Jurassic era never existed.

[@Umarlikeshellcat]

350 million ye sooo soon

[@Dark_Ninja77]

Meanwhile Methuselah star chilling in the corner

[@michaelstapelberg7751]

thank you!!!

[@DissatisfiedDissapointment]

Bro fr!?

[@ukwt_imsayin]

Why he had to rhyme at last? "Science was wrong all along" Man rapped harder than Eminem!!!..

[@kirk1902]

@astrokobi, is your mustache coming in darker or is it just me!?

[@ZahidAli-wi1lh]

Maybe the cosmologist need to rewrite about the evolution of the early galaxies .

[@OGfromNG]

Just keep looking further, and it will debunk it very soon when u see the big man sat on his throne

[@Blackhole-TON618]

No

[@Conqueror25]

​@@Blackhole-TON618 lmaoo

[@Blackhole-TON618]

@@Conqueror25 he literally has no proof

[@DarthVaderfr]

That will be just how god was 13.8 billions of years ago😊😊 Jokes aside, the big bang is the theory of how the universe expanded, not of his creation, the universe was once smaller and denser and you can run backwards that down to a billionth of a second experimentally, that is undebunkable

[@OGfromNG]

@@DarthVaderfr that’s if the scientific religion is correct science is not facts I hope u understand. But I know what u are saying

[@TomfooleryVA]

How would they even know how old those galaxies even are

[@r4ko]

Where do people find their news, in the town bar ?!

[@DarthVaderfr]

Yes.

[@Trevor-gu8un]

God does amazing things. ❤

[@Ruanabdey]

Nah he didn't do shit

[@Trevor-gu8un]

That's what you believe, but me, I think otherwise

[@seal9390]

​@@RuanabdeySo you believe in scientific impossibility that nothing created everything?

[@Ruanabdey]

@@seal9390 but you believe in a book written a few thousand years ago by some idiots saying that there was a massive idiot who created earth in seven days bullshit

[@DarthVaderfr]

@@seal9390 how is scientifically possible that nothing created god? Why you don't apply the same reasoning to your god Besides nobody knows if the universe come from nothing, we don't know shit about that, stop pretending thst we do becaude sky daddy loves us

[@professionalmola3852]

Just 350 million years after. He says it like that’s not a long time 😂

[@eugeneeugene3704]

The problem is that this was too fast for a galaxy to be formed.

[@thebbsfly5019]

Dude thank you so much for debunking this all my friends wouldn’t believe me 😂

[@TRXX394]

The camera man 😶‍🌫️🫥💀💀💀💀💀

[@dwagon_lover]

we found a star that a while "pre dates the bigbang" but we don`t truly know how old the universe it`s just a mystery

[@_Lightyy]

"JUST 350 million years before the big bang"

[@matt24fc]

Glad you made this one. So sick of misinformation...or to clarify, non professional, unscientific, nonproven hype claims blowing up in social media, misleading millions of people.

[@pokeluke2532]

Can’t wait to tell my science teacher.

[@chris.l4195]

When humans starts to excavate Nemo waters we're in for a treat.

[@malaki1344is]

Lol 😂 oh kobe ,u seem to be the only one on this train.

[@loyalsreview6362]

That means those galaxies are older than ours meaning that there’s a chance life may be in them😮

[@SamudrarajOfficial]

I wonder if we could see the big bang itself

[@stevelaw3886]

No, sadly. The oldest we can see is the Cosmic Microwave Background radiation. Have a quick Google of it - it's fascinating

[@goodboi7517]

bro we boutta find the eye of the universe out here 😭

[@mik0005]

Bro said "Just 350 Million Years" 💀

[@bananazncookies6837]

I still can’t believe that the people that are the biggest experts in science and arguably the smartest people on the planet think that nothing and nothing collided and made everything 🤦‍♂️.

[@ewest4817]

No one thinks that

[@bananazncookies6837]

@@ewest4817 enlighten me on what they do think, because as the name suggests, there was literally a big bang and everything we know today just existed.

[@bananazncookies6837]

Makes absolutely no sense

[@ewest4817]

@@bananazncookies6837 we know the Big Bang happened. We don’t know why it happened

[@nattythepanda4692]

​@@bananazncookies6837The thing that you're getting tripped up on is not that there was nothing, there were things. Let me make an image for you, imagine that there's a bunch of energy just packed together in a single spot, we wouldn't be able to see it, but it's still there.

[@izaizabela8426]

My bro just said '' 350 million years just after the big bang '' Lol ITS 350 MILLION YEARS 😭

[@dingus14]

first time actually seeing a typo in a video title

[@tassochristopoulos2046]

Millions and billions of years ... let me see 2024 first

[@existingperson]

All these “scientists” forgot that the Big Bang was caused by Professor P. who was sent back in time with a a bomb

[@dynamicvibe4248]

The James Webb Space Telescope just rewrite the Book of Astronomy.

[@vee1267]

What’s the music playing in the background? It’s so pretty

[@valentinlorincz6769]

I'll never understand the whole concept of space and time. What was the big bang? What blew up? What created the things that blew up? Infinite regression. This whole thing is just too much to comprehend. Why does everything exist, how did everything/reality came to be?

[@KaseyZINC]

How can we perfectly see galaxies that are billions of lightyears away, but i still have problems with my internet

[@IzrealYT]

Astrokobi did you know saturn has 62 new moons surpassing jupiter Saturn moons: 145 Jupiter moons:95 Jupiter in tears rn

[@potatowestandforukraine5574]

yo Astrokobi I’ve been curious what exploded to make the Big Bang? like was it a super massive star the size of like 40 billion light years wide to cause such explosion to make the observable universe massive?

[@fishdrip54]

We don't know.

[@potatowestandforukraine5574]

@@fishdrip54 WE DO

[@theblueskyisstolensunlight]

Bro, you look like Eric Sloane from "Kickboxer"

[@patrickmartin2689]

We don't know SHYT!!! 😫😫😭😭😤😤👀👀🤬🤬😝😝😁😁✌✌

[@frostkiller]

In the beginning there was the word, and the word was with go.

[@keysersoze7919]

If only I get a dollar Everytime this mf shakes his head

[@supernovatluthelightoftheu3221]

I've been thinking about this, couldn't it be that in the Early universe everything was quite dense, so could time be way slower, and what we percieve as hundreds of millions of years may have been billions instead?

[@timmontour]

So how back do we go ? We looking at a time when we didn't even was step on earth 🤯💯🇨🇦👍🏾