Luke Skywalkers FINAL LESSON to REY on AHCH TO | Rise Of Skywalker

[@ATATChat]

Enjoy todays video! This was fun to think about. Why is Luke so blue? Please LIKE, SHARE, and SUBSCRIBE if you are new to the channel! Cheers! ATAT

[@aadilhafejee9122]

Enjoyed the video, also r u starting to like tros a bit more?

[@ATATChat]

@@aadilhafejee9122 oh yessss

[@MeanMrMustard1]

Maybe Harmy can fix blue Luke.

[@BabysitterSky]

Pulling a lightsaber from behind your back and shrugging is the destiny of a Jedi.

[@ATATChat]

Agree

[@micheledeetlefs6041]

While wearing a Holey Good Boy Sweater. The sweater definitely matters.

[@gingin4920]

I loved that scene. So good.

[@holygramatha4978]

It’s hilarious but it’s also really deep when you think about it (Han in ROTJ)

[@mammon_is_god]

It's the destiny of a Solo to shrug.

[@jknetwork6211]

I’ll admit while the film is flawed, that part where Luke raises the ship from the ocean does put a smile on my face.

[@SamaritanPrime]

I thought to myself "I remember a time when Luke couldn't do that. Look how far we have come."

[@SimoneCalloni]

@@SamaritanPrime Also, Yoda in Ep. V knew that Luke already had the power to lift the X-Wing, but he failed due to his lack of faith in himself and the Force. Now he is totally one with the Force. The scene it's great and someway completes Luke's growth.

[@byallaccounts563]

When I find myself in times of trouble, master Luke comes to me, speaking words of wisdom: "confronting fear is the destiny of a jedi."

[@DaleESkywalker]

"This is your fight", (not Ben's). Rey did have to call on the Jedi of the past for power but she had to face that fear herself.

[@DartagnanMagic]

Yep, you nailed it about it reinforcing Luke's arc. when people say it retconned TLJ, I think...Bro, do you even watch?

[@chagis100]

"LeT tHe PaSt DiE"

[@jacksonmustian2945]

chagis100 said by kylo Ren. The villain

[@Ncholasbloom]

@@jacksonmustian2945 not by ben solo

[@davidv4018]

I don't think it reinforces it, it simplifies it. But it is not a contradiction

[@DartagnanMagic]

@@davidv4018 Luke's arc completed in TLJ. Then delivering that to Rey reinforces what was already learned in TLJ.

[@auntvesuvi3872]

Thanks, Nick! ♛ I also see it in real-world terms... how confronting fear is *all* *of* *our* destinies... the courage and grace we do it with can make us as close to a "Jedi" as a human can be.

[@angelahevenshuntress585]

This is great I love your take on it and how each Jedi has to face their own fears and need to conquer them to truly be a Jedi, btw I agree with you on Luke’s haircut as a force ghost but I loved that scene especially when he lifts his old x-wing I got chills and started tearing up 😅😂

[@amorg319]

"What are you doing?" Mark Hamil sold that line. "Ow" and "Give it to me" are my other favorites from TROS.

[@melaniehenderson7353]

I love this channel. I love the attention you give to small details, you catch things I always miss. It's so cool to hear your analysis!

[@islamicthought206]

Rey never saw Luke in his younger and cleaner version so this makes sense.

[@StuartLugsden]

Many though that the deleted “pirate attack” on the caretakers village was the final lesson but Rian said it wasn’t and that Rey left before it could happen. I probably wouldn’t have guessed this was that final lesson.

[@ATATChat]

Yea I figured JJ thought this was his opportunity to tell a lesson using Luke due to the deleted scene. (which I love)

[@WhiteWolf496]

The caretaker village sequence is the third lesson. But it was removed from the film for pacing reasons. Its still in the novelisation though.

[@DaleESkywalker]

True, although it seems the general (what's the word I'm looking for?) theme? of his lessons were to discourage Rey from learning from him and to make her own decisions (allow herself to be guided by the Force) because he was influenced by Sno..errr, Sidious, (yet all he could really sense was his failure and hubris). What Rey and Yoda did was make him realize he was, and that is (partially) why he projected himself on Crait. 1. He knows he's still vulnerable to influence. 2. He doesn't have time to raise the ship and fly there. Rey technically doesn't even get there in time to save them but she does rescue them. 3. He avoids all influence to harm Ben, (and Ben/Kylo can't harm him).

[@WhiteWolf496]

@@DaleESkywalker the point of his lessons were to tell Rey why the Jedi needed to end. So yeah you're pretty close

[@Ncholasbloom]

@@WhiteWolf496 thats good its still canon then

[@TheFellCloud]

Mark's hair stylist did him dirty. He looks like an old hippy lol

[@codekhalil6437]

The Luke Lebowski

[@PopRevision]

Lmao

[@micheledeetlefs6041]

The Saber Dude.

[@MeanMrMustard1]

A dirty hippy.

[@jacobberg373]

Aren't Jedi hippies without the drugs and sex

[@rjkzbkfy9665]

I glad that I'm not the only one who was bothered by Luke's haircut in TROS. I hope Force ghost have some kinda shapeshifting power.

[@TimeandMonotony]

I just recently discovered your channel and I love how positive it is! I had a lot of problems with TROS, but I still love the sequel trilogy and it's nice to see someone pointing out the things this trilogy got right. *edit* Yeah, Luke's hair is terrible in this. Maybe the only hairstylist who became a Force Ghost was the person who decided padawans should have rat tails? And therefore obviously has no taste when it comes to hair.

[@ATATChat]

Haha!

[@Dogspark841]

this guy has such a refreshing perspective and positive attitude can't get enough

[@micheledeetlefs6041]

When Anakin goes to Yoda about his fear of losing Padme, Yoda does not tell him to confront his fear but to let it go, to accept what he fears may come to pass and to stop resisting it. That's basically an avoidance technique, to say what you're afraid of is going to happen so there's no sense in wasting energy to stop it. It doesn't, as a point in fact, address the fear itself at all, just avoids talking about it or acting against it, or even constructively accepting it. Luke's advice is much healthier. You are afraid. Face it. Just because you fear it, doesn't mean it will defeat you. He is suggesting she fight. A much better option than to passively accept her fate. One wonders how much better off the Galaxy would have been had Luke given his sister the same advice. If he'd told Leia to face her fears that her baby would die if she completed her training. Ironically, had she done that, it never would have come about. She would have become a Jedi not a Senator, would have been Ben's master as well as his mother. Without the weight of Senate responsibilities (and the need to avoid Ben at some level out of fear of losing him someday), Leia would have been free to make him a priority. Ben wouldn't have felt cast aside. Snoke/Palpatine would not have found a toehold into his heart. The Lightsaber Nightlight Incident wouldn't have happened. Ben wouldn't have fled or fallen. Maybe being dead does give the Jedi insight. Still not sure about Kenobi and his certain point of view crap, though.

[@TerraStone]

As there are issues with TROS, there are also things done very well with it. I thought TROS wrapped up the sequel trilogy really nicely, but it could of been better at wrapping up the saga

[@ATATChat]

That's my main beef. The saga. It's a nice cherry on top of the st tho

[@TerraStone]

@@ATATChat I really wish the Luke force ghost looked like the Yoda one from TLJ. This one doesn't work well imo, way too much blue

[@henryvdl3692]

one thing that really annoys me is that when talking about Luke in TLJ, people completely ignore his ark in the third act. The only TLJ Luke they know is the one that threw his lightsaber away, not the one that sacrificed his life for the last hope of the galaxy

[@knightatyourservice7512]

I'm sorry it isn't about the subject of the video, but you mentioned the episode called "The Gathering" and I really need to tell that: the concept of the episode could make a great Star Wars horror story.

[@ATATChat]

That's actually a rad concept!

[@AirbenderHawk]

YAS, fam!!! :)). Seeing Luke giving her a final lesson in this moment brings me back to return of the Jedi, where Obi wan told Luke to face his destiny a second time, and now, this is a role reversal as Luke as a master here told her to face her fears head on, and that she did. It rhymes, like poetry.

[@mimcris8481]

Luke's appearance was one of the best things in the movie! The lesson mirrors one of Luke's last decisions. I really liked it

[@Harrison1875]

I was thinking... do you think Ben died still hating Luke? I've got a feeling we'll get an answer in the novelization but I think it's an interesting question.

[@micheledeetlefs6041]

I don't think he ever hated Luke. He was terrified of the man and terribly, terribly hurt. His anger came from this grief and fear, not hate. Hate burns cold. Kylo was blazing.

[@lukerope1906]

I'm pretty sure some of those Rey/Luke scenes were reshoots. Ewan in ATOC had the same thing happen to him, terrible hair and beard in all the reshot stuff.

[@o_manam]

His hair was absolutely awesome in TFA, such an awesome reveal. It was still pretty amazing in TLJ. But this one is like... what

[@jacobberg373]

I didn't notice anything wrong with it, but I don't really focus on hair that much when watching a movie

[@o_manam]

@@jacobberg373 every movie is about the hair bud

[@jacobberg373]

@@o_manam Never know it was so important

[@rjkzbkfy9665]

1:47 - Man, TCW did wonders to Anakin character arc and REALLY REALLY improved the viewing of the prequels.

[@ATATChat]

Amen

[@bluepearl_22]

And yet, people still claim ROS retcons TLJ *smh*

[@StuartLugsden]

It definitely did a little but not for the most part.

[@davidv4018]

It did retcon a lot, and much of it wasn't for the best. But it doesn't break the message imo.

[@davidv4018]

@Geralt of Trivia The original trilogy is filled with retcons. They are not necessarily a bad thing, they may work better for the story. "i am your father" is a retcon "i told the truth from a certain point of view" is a retcon.

[@bluepearl_22]

@Geralt of Trivia It didn't. Most people just have a double standard when evaluating the new movies and the OT since they aren't able to watch the old ones from an objective point of view due to their emotional connection to them. That's not a crime but it does cloud their judgement imo.

[@tonoormusic]

blue_pearl_22 I often get the feeling that those people don’t even watch the OT that much, cause if they would do that, they’ll be able to see the same issues in different movies

[@hexortime]

I like this line so much . Confronting fear its the destiny of a Jedi

[@Mantorok12]

"I've seen this raw strength only once before. It didn't scare me enough then. It does now." So I guess that was about Palpatine and Rey, not Kylo, in hindsight. Makes a lot more sense that Luke would be terrified of Rey reminding him of Sidious. Makes sense why he would refuse to train her, and help her only when she passed the final test: she threw away her lightsaber just as he did on the death star, before she fell to the dark side

[@ATATChat]

Luke wasn't in touch with the force at that time so he wouldn't have an idea of who she was until the moment he reconnected trying to sense Leia. I'm pretty sure I remember Mark and Ryan discussing that line because of its ambiguity but then the comic / novel said "in my nephew". With that said, I think beyond ancillary material, that explanation does work!

[@blackeyedlily]

I do love that line. It is one of those iconic lines that does resonate with the main themes of Star Wars. And I like how you point out that it reflects back to Luke’s journey in The Last Jedi. I’m always going to treasure Luke’s story in TLJ. Unfortunately I have so many other problems with this scene between Luke and Rey that I have a hard time focusing on that one solid point. I absolutely hate how they have Luke telling Rey that he and Leia both knew she was a Palpatine. I dislike that for many reasons, but especially because of how upset Luke was at Obi Wan and Yodi withholding the truth of his parentage from him. And don’t get me started on the whole Leia trained to be a Jedi. Not only does that contradict so much of her new canon story arc, but it really bothers me in relation to what she could have done for her own son if she had that background. Oh well, I guess I’m just ranting now. But yeah, I have a lot of feelings about this scene.

[@4leafclover395]

Great video and the ending made me laugh out loud!! Maybe “Hobo” Luke in lysol blue is the way he wanted to be remembered! 🌈💖😃

[@kespos2100]

I love your analysis! Your vids really add to my enjoyment of Star Wars

[@markm3416]

wonderful interpretation. I also like to think the 3rd lesson in TLJ was Luke's to learn about failure from master Yoda. love the channel. keep up the great work.

[@Rey20171]

You weren’t kidding about the Lysol comparisons

[@Thedreamlandfire]

Beautiful video ! And I loved that line , it always gave me chills when I heard it in the trailer . And ahaha I also noticed how both Han and Luke looked really scruffy 😂

[@JGPRIME25]

"Lost Ben Solo you did. Lose Rey, we must not."

[@rogueguardian]

Ok that makes a lot more sense now, thanks Nick.

[@elizabeth7sj222]

I really appreciate this point of view. I’m loving sequels Luke more and more.

[@ryansutter9434]

Loved every moment in Ahch To! Had my problems with the movie but theres also a lot I really liked.

[@ioanevans6763]

I liked the scene with force ghost luke. But I do admit....I hate his hair

[@batgiant3535]

Excellent video thank you

[@cases3394]

Thanks for the video! Great coverage as per usual and yes, WTF were they thinking with Luke's hair?! You cannot tell me Mark didn't have something to say about that?

[@deliagabrielaion3060]

Great video, AT-AT! I need these injections of positivity to soothe my aching disappointment in the finale.

[@olgak.1139]

Even as a Force Ghost, Luke has the privilege to grow older as time passes by.Hmm...Impressive... most impressive.

[@holygramatha4978]

Luke’s haircut was weird asf but I really thought he was (story-wise) beautiful. I really loved TROS and I’d even go as far to say it’s just as good as the OT.

[@Jooglesberry]

I can't get over how blue Luke is. I think they did it to distinguish Han from a force ghost, for normies.

[@ATATChat]

hahahah

[@Tbonejones5900]

Even tho the paceing might be werid I loved 9 I felt it was a nice ending to my childhood mtfbwy all

[@codekhalil6437]

The Luke Lebowski. I'm sure force ghosts can (should) probably be able to go back to any time frame of their life and take up that form. Kind of like young Anakin at the end of Return of the Jedi. But I may be opening a whole new bag of doritos here

[@nathonalexavier1505]

Thank you for mentioning the hairstyle.

[@davidv4018]

Question for you who knows a lot about editing (from someone who doesn't know the first thing). Do you think that this movie was reshaped (a lot or not) from its original intent through editing? Like, it seems that some shoots weren't intended for the scenes they got to be into (like for example Finn screaming "noo" when chewbacca seemingly died, it looked like he was reacting to another thing less dramatic; or so many scenes were characters are doing voices in off)? Maybe this happens in all movies, but i am just looking to much into them. Great video as always!

[@ATATChat]

I think the entire intro was reshaped for sure

[@davidv4018]

@@ATATChat Thanks for the reply! I remember now that you talked about it in the review, to me it was as weird as the battle with palpatine, and ach-to. But i liked the "I was wrong!" for someone who didn't get to the final act of episode viii.

[@rango3780]

the grand master Jedi haircut as I like to call it;)

[@WeirwoodNet]

Great scene

[@vittoriacolona]

Interesting take on the mirror cave scene. I took it as Rey seeking personal validation of who she is as a human being through finding out who her parents were. So when she asks the mirror to 'show her her parents'. The mirror does exactly that. It shows her herself. Because Rey did in fact 'parentes' herself. She did so from the age of 5 (or 7) when she was dropped on Jakku and was forced to survive and take care of herself. She's a self-made woman and can take pride and satisfaction in that. So TROS in no way retcons out TLJ. Rey might have inherited her supernatural powers from her family, but everything else, her resilience, intelligence, ingenuity and character. Are all things she built on her own. She did not inherit that- and that is what made her successful. Not grandpa. Even if Rey is from a family with supernatural powers. It does not mean that the force isn't open to everyone. Since Broom Boy in TLJ and Finn--two nobodies- are force sensitive.

[@Ncholasbloom]

woah so jj stayed true to what tlj was showing after all i like connection rey and luke had now i give tlj even more credit rey failed once by not being able to turn ben and she nearly failed again by doing what luke did

[@Rey20171]

OK I am just going to make this comment for the hell of it because why fudge not it's about time and I already left this comment on another channel so here it goes..... If you ever want to sum up all three movies in the sequel trilogy here's a fun way to break it down... -The Force Awakens was like spending a day at an epic theme park that was so dope it made you feel like a child again and you want to do it all over again the next day. -The Last Jedi is a night at the art house with art displays that at first you can't wrap your head around what they are supposed to mean but at the same time you can't get your mind off of it because for some reason there's something about it that's so fascinating. It's not perfect but that's OK because you want to keep visiting it. -The Rise of Skywalker is equivalent to putting down a book that had so much going on and you can not wrap your head around what you just read it's left you feeling perplexed, conflicted, very emotional, slightly unsettled and confused. But somehow at the same time despite your conflicted sort of on-the-fence, middle of the road thoughts you want to read it all over again to understand it more and maybe you might like it there are things you might like or you feel even more conflicted and you're reminded why. You just find yourself thinking about this book a lot and you want to give yourself more reasons to talk about it every chance you get. All that while you're sitting comfortably in your lazy chair sipping your tea or coffee in front of a fire with a note book in your hand because you're getting inspired. So what is more of your style? Feel free to weigh in everyone.

[@bagginsofbagend]

Your videos are awesome.

[@austinjensen5143]

You rock that mop Luke

[@DONNY2SAVAGE]

My question is when did Luke realize Palpatine was alive? Seems like it would shock him the most since he was the only one to actually witness Palps death. Did Luke just hear those radio broadcasts and figure oh well, Palpy’s back, go get em Rey? Woulda liked to see a reaction shot like Hans death.

[@WhiteWolf496]

I never saw it as Leia creating the image of Han. I saw it as the audience seeing the world through Ben's eyes (not literally) and seeing his conjured memory of his father. I like that Rey's hood is kinda like she's coming to terms with her ancestral background. Emperor Palpatine loved a good hood. But like you said, RIP Luke's hair. #LukesHairDeservedBetter

[@evrint]

3:55 What a hairable fate.

[@ATATChat]

😂

[@landrya9938]

That’s easily my favorite moment of the movie and I loved a lot of it. I think my biggest problem was how Ben didn’t show up as a force ghost at the end. That would have not only wrapped up Ben’s arc perfectly, it would have wrapped up Luke’s as well. It would have shown that they reconciled. It just felt incomplete. Maybe a deleted scene or possible extended cut, fingers crossed.

[@BaRoBG]

Luke's mop is TOP hahaha

[@PlaywiththePlays]

If kylo ren were alive, the movie would be SO MUCH better. He deserved to live along with rey and grow a new generation of Jedi.

[@BabysitterSky]

He helped murder what I can only assume are billions of people.... I think he had to die.

[@gregz.4842]

@@BabysitterSky no he didn't. It was not his decision to destroy the Hosnian system.

[@PlaywiththePlays]

@@BabysitterSky vader has also killed thousands of innocents. I think kylo should have ended palpatine if not live. Would have made his death way better

[@BabysitterSky]

@@gregz.4842 Lol dude was party of the group that did though.

[@BabysitterSky]

@@PlaywiththePlays Oh I know. Vader helped kill his millions too.

[@horrorfan1697]

why was lukes hair so long now that hes dead? now thats a msyetry that needs solving lol

[@ATATChat]

Haha

[@raiden_c1]

A really spotty wig

[@SimoneCalloni]

He should have had the same look of Force-projection Luke, in my opinion.

[@micheledeetlefs6041]

There are no combs or conditioner in The Jedi Netherworld, obviously. One does hope there are extra robes, or all of Ghost Ben's visits to Rey will be rather blue, and not just cause he's a Force Ghost.

[@Rey20171]

OK been more serious now this is probably one of the more poignant scenes going of this movie I could clearly see it echoing what Yoda was trying to teach Luke in the last Jedi about failure but now it’s about confronting your fear and not letting your lineage for whatever define who you are Because of one member of your family being pure evil. This movie is trilogy was about one meeting their destiny and I would say that there was no other scene that says it more clearly than this one or lease this is just a few examples of that lesson. It’s no different than every other lead protagonist that had a moment like this and other stories out there Harry Potter being one of them frodo from Lord of the rings being another Katniss everdeen from the hunger games being another, It’s a classic moment of every hero and heroine is journey towards the middle and the end. You have a young lady being told from a wise old man the same one who didn’t want to help her initially in the last movie, she helped changed his perspective and wake up and go back to being the hero he was always meant to be until the end and as a payback he helps her continue her journey on defeating the greater evil. I never realized this till now and I’m glad this video got to make me look at it in a deeper context.

[@MeanMrMustard1]

I can't believe they didn't match the shorter wigs from TFA and TLJ. That hairstylist is gonna be doing Uber soon.

[@ATATChat]

Haha

[@postmastergaming]

How did Luke’s hair grow so much when he became a force ghost??

[@ATATChat]

No barbers in the afterlife

[@4leafclover395]

AT-AT Chat Hey, that’s my line! LOL 😂

[@deliagabrielaion3060]

It's just another freak Jedi ghost power: Luke can summon length of hair 😜! Or maybe we could come up with wild poetic theories that hair which never ceases to grow marks the passage of time in the afterlife, suggesting that the Jedi get to live twice and consequently die a second time, as ghosts, possibly after fulfilling some new, reality-shattering tasks in the ethereal realm. Disney could make at least another movie about all the ghosts (throw Han in for good measure too) and their interweaving with Rey's solid world. I'd like that. But let the ghost movie be told from Ben's point of view 😍. And they shouldn't recast Leia, but use her absence as proof of a threat to both the ghost and the physical realms. She could be the first ghost to be devoured by the threat and the rest of them must discover, understand and work with the living to stop the threat (which ISN'T ghost Palpatine 😉, but a more sinister, far more powerful entity that I'd choose to have never been emodied at all. We could make it the illspring, or the source of the dark side).

[@GabiBrooks]

3:56 lmao🤣

[@homiefoxpgn4497]

Although The Rise of Skywalker was certainly flawed, I feel like it did a lot of good too. It gave amazing closure to Ben's character arc, gave us some fun action sequences, and some really memorable quotes. Overall 7/10, great ideas but the overall film felt rushed, some of the ideas still were executed well though even with the rush of the film.

[@ultratankie]

My perspective is that the specifics of TROS feel almost too bizarre to be part of a real, bona fide Star Wars film, and the execution doesn't do much to help those ideas settle. That said, it ultimately does serve a place in the arc of the saga. Putting all nine movies together and watching them chronologically, you come away with a story about first romanticizing the past (the Rebellion and Luke fight to restore the Republic/the Jedi), and then de-romanticizing it (the Republic/the Jedi are shown to have never truly embodied what we were fighting for), and finally re-romanticizing it (Rey and the Resistance choose to embrace the myth of the Republic/the Jedi anyway, in the hopes that they will achieve that ideal in the future). TROS is incredibly nostalgic and reliant on familiar icons, but is that so bad when the ending of TLJ affirms that, yes, we *should* be inspired by those myths?

[@TheSixthDoctor]

The mop got worse inbetween TLJ and TROS. He actually looked good as a grizzled hermit, but in TROS, it was an obvious wig.

[@giglefreakz]

This scene could have been so much better. Both in special effects and dialogue, as while the lesson itself doesn't retcon The Last Jedi, I thought the dialogue lacked something that TLJ did have. It's just the way it was written and also the delivery of the lines from Mark, something felt off.

[@ATATChat]

Yea, I'd agree. I think I now understand more fully why Luke was absent on TFA. JJ doesn't know what to do with him.

[@rjkzbkfy9665]

Wait, didn't Luke encounter Vader in the previous Star Wars-Marvel run?

[@a_fine_edition2746]

Yes, but it probably stings much more in the new one because he had trained and was absolutely positive that he was ready, whereas before, he likely wasn’t as confident.

[@That_Guy3604]

F for Luke's hair

[@Wumbo_Mumbo]

Ayy, Knight of Ren, baby! Wait. . . did I actually spell my name PYSchotic instead of PSYchotic on Patreon, again!?

[@ATATChat]

Oh snap! I'll check that

[@o...o4144]

Soon people will start given the love that this trylogi loves... Well, the did that with the prequels, they will do that with everything...

[@ATATChat]

It's funny, every little kid I know (because I have two myself) said this trilogy is amazing to them. At the end of the day, if it amazes young children in the same way we were, then it did its job.

[@o...o4144]

@@ATATChat really? Man, that's so cool! Wonderful, the mind of a child is...

[@deliagabrielaion3060]

It's just another freak Jedi ghost power: Luke can summon length of hair 😜! Or maybe we could come up with wild poetic theories that hair which never ceases to grow marks the passage of time in the afterlife, suggesting that the Jedi get to live twice and consequently die a second time, as ghosts, possibly after fulfilling some new, reality-shattering tasks in the ethereal realm. Disney could make at least another movie about all the ghosts (throw Han in for good measure too) and their interweaving with Rey's solid world. I'd like that. But let the ghost movie be told from Ben's point of view 😍. And they shouldn't recast Leia, but use her absence as proof of a threat to both the ghost and the physical realms. She could be the first ghost to be devoured by the threat and the rest of them must discover, understand and work with the living to stop the threat (which ISN'T ghost Palpatine 😉, but a more sinister, far more powerful entity that I'd choose to have never been emodied at all. We could make it the illspring, or the source of the dark side).

[@marcelochong4342]

A Jedis weapon deserve more respect... What are you doing .... I was wrong... It was fear that kept me here What are you most afraid of Because you are a Palpatine Leia know it too Because she saw your spirit Your heart Rey, some things are stronger than blood Confronting fear is the destiny of a Jedi Your destiny... If you dont face Palpatine, it will be the end of the JEDI And the war will be lost... Theres something my sister would want you to have... It was the last day of her training... Leia told me she sense the death of his son at the end of her jedi path... She sorrender her saber to me and said that one day, it would be picked up again by someone who will finish her journy... A thousend generations live in you now... But this is your fight... You will take both sabers to Exegol You have everything you need...

[@Ncholasbloom]

so she predicted rey was the one to pick up her saber?

[@skywalkerlad2907]

Great again mate and yeah wtf is with his hair bro

[@molliethomas2585]

Really liked this breakdown AT-AT 👍 Another home run. On another note, it looks like the idea of Ben's return is getting more mainstream. Here is an article by ScreenRant that talks specifically about how he can be resurrected after TROS. www.google.com/amp/s/screenrant.com/star-wars-10-theory-ben-solo-resurrection/amp/ Go check it out.

[@ATATChat]

Thanks!

[@alexfelix5533]

Rey: Did JJ like the last Jedi Luke: if he did then why did he use this film to retcon most of it

[@ATATChat]

The only real retcon is the xwing story wise. Rey's heritage was expanded upon. Same parents. It's like Luke and the audience finding out "the other jedi" in ROTJ was Leia, who also turned out to be Luke's twin sister at the 11th hour. 🤟

[@alexfelix5533]

AT-AT Chat 👍

[@davidv4018]

I don't think he was "retconing" it to try to negate what happened before, but it was "retconing" it to tell the story he wanted to tell. Rey descends from the dark, but is light, and feels the pull to the dark; Ren descends from the light, but is dark, and feels the pull to the light. Rey is having this idea that maybe it was for the best that she was left alone in jakku.

[@MrDavidSalamon]

I agree on the lousy haircut length on Luke-- terrible...lol

[@Ncholasbloom]

why help a plapatine though the bloodline that caused your family so much pain

[@marcelochong4342]

Why you Change the pic

[@ATATChat]

Couldn't stand it haha

[@ramonbetzler7786]

I think those scenes are re-shoots and the hair is fake

[@marcelochong4342]

Yeah his haircut is terrible

[@haitolawrence5986]

ROS is a vain attempt to polish a turd. Playing familiar John Williams cues and recreating actual emotional moments from the original films instead of creating new ones with real meaning is pure desperation. You know it's bad when 'fans' are actually adding their own explanation of events because the plot of the movie was incapable of doing it in the first place.

[@ATATChat]

I loved that you liked your own comment. The reason I know this is because I saw the time receipt at 37 seconds after you posted this, lmao. You ok boss?

[@DaleESkywalker]

What's a potato cam?

[@ATATChat]

It's what I call a crappy cam recording haha

[@DaleESkywalker]

@@ATATChat I've recorded footage off my computer screen on my phone. That's a true definition of milky-potato-watered-down footage.

[@StuartLugsden]

It’s an internet slang for when people film screens with there poor quality phones or video cameras.

[@DaleESkywalker]

@@StuartLugsden it always sux no matter how good your camera is. :D

[@StuartLugsden]

Yeah. When you see it on your phone after recording it doesn’t look too bad. If it makes the news then you see just how bad it is.

[@deniseallisonstout1901]

Are you twins...because some of your videos sound deeper than others...anyway this trilogy requires too many KZbin videos to explain everything

[@jmgmarcus808]

The worst writing of SW movie.

[@ATATChat]

I would say that AOTC wins that