Atheist Asks Muslim To Explain Why God Allows Suffering! Muhammed Ali

[@TheMuslimLantern]

Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah! Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern Book A Private Session: muslimlantern.org/

[@Mafia_マフィア]

✨ ‏*‪1:05‬‏* " The atheist chooses this world to be his paradise, and the believer chooses the afterlife to be his paradise." "Atheists hold on to this argument, in fact proof of the existence of heaven."

[@yahyakam7498]

Brother why do you put your camera to the side and he is facing the camera?

[@riddikulus1432]

Its his style and many people do not watch the camera instead watch the monitor, ​@@yahyakam7498

[@Topdawah]

@@yahyakam7498everyone has a good side 😊

[@hannawurst6064]

*What your imams don't tell you* Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity! *this is a mistake in the Qur'an!*

[@ulrisse8066]

Hey i am the guys in that video, thank you so much for your time, i really appreciated this conversation ! i had a lot of trouble explaining my thoughts (especially when we talked about the contingency argument) but i still managed to understand you and left with better understanding of islam. After this i talked to an imam because i had more questions, some were answered, some were not but i will keep trying to find answers, thanks again !

[@MeneerWu]

May Allah guide you to the straight path 🤲🏻

[@jasonthemuslim652]

I may be able to answer some of your questions In Sha’Allah. If you want my contact information just ask or if you’d rather you can just respond to my comment with questions.

[@jawadzarshoi3920]

When u said BIG BANG brother MOHAMMAD Ali was like... 😂

[@ulrisse8066]

@@jasonthemuslim652 I appreciate but that won't be necessary, i talk with a french imam every week and he answer almost every questions i ask (and usually if he cannot provide answers to my questions when i ask them he always has an answer the next week)

[@bardamoszecronstarog9499]

​@@ulrisse8066not gonna lie brother I like your hair lol. Anyways it's really awesome you're actively researching for the truth. Also you're very well mannered as well. You've got a really nice way of conversing so it was nice watching this video. Continue on your search and may you be blessed with the straight path.

[@hinato3024]

This guy is very well mannered and seems very nice. May Allah guide him

[@agoesac2]

Aamiin

[@FluyStone]

Yes. Inshallah he will find a good muslim french who can answer his questions so that he may revert to Islam !

[@AbuBilal-nf4jw]

Allaahuma Aaamiin.

[@cadnanb602]

Ameen

[@ryan6140]

Ameen

[@trapster1483]

I learned today in a chemistry class that if the PH of your blood changes by a maximum of 0.1, it would become toxic and you would die. Subhanallah "Then which of your Lord’s favours will you ˹humans and jinn˺ both deny?"

[@Sal_A]

SubhanAllah. To put it, anything that is specified needs a Specifier because the threshold could be any number amongst an infinite of numbers, colors, shapes, mass, speed, etc

[@alhomsiyyah]

When you study the exact physiological mechanism by which the blood is buffered, it leaves you in absolute awe at the power and intelligence of Allah. No human being, no created being, no random collision of molecules or uncoordinated evolution could create a system like that which exists in our bodies. وفي أنفسكم أفلا تبصرون "And within yourselves [are signs]. So do you not see?" (51:21)

[@abz7800]

bro im muslim aswell but its fact that allah just wants to hide his existence from us for whatever reason.you can give 10000 facts about science but it doesnt change that fact because the lack of knowledge of something like how our existence came to be doesn't immediately mean it proves god existence . allah is supernatural and therefore a supernatural existence requires supernatural evidence not natural evidence like science facts . allah knows this very well thats why he gave the prophets supernatural miracles like sea splitting moon splitting staff turning into snake etc. for the rest of us he just doesn't want to do that and so we are left in the dark . moses himself ask allah prove to me you exist and allah again showed him a miracles . if moses had doubts even though allah spoke to him directly and he was a prophet then who are are we to never have a shadow of a doubt

[@randomness8819]

Muslim Lantern's smile is Dr. Zakir Naik's, "Brother/sister asked a very good question." Lol

[@SaZanJaveddKhan786]

Good one bruv 😂😂😂

[@Munirs1998]

I speak French/Arabic and would happily help out. I feel Ulrysse was genuine. Baraka Allah feek, Muhammad.

[@Lonewold.]

Ya Rabb, Guide brother Ulrisse and every sincere person and continue to Guide and Bless all of Us Aameen Ya Rabbul Alameen

[@agoesac2]

Aamiin

[@publicpm8809]

Ameen

[@aungheinphyo31]

Ameen

[@bukor0su368]

you can tell that he's just started his journey by looking at the arguments he has presented. He seems sincere and open to the truth. May Allah guide him and keep us firm upon the truth.

[@taufiqrl]

He seems really sincere, may Allah ﷻ guide him to the straight path

[@mozydiaz8296]

Generally, young French people are sincere in their questions and have no ulterior motives, unlike the old ones. It also depends on what background they come from; the French bourgeoisie and patriots have a bad view of Arabs and Muslims.

[@Pray-Serendipity]

Its just scary how much Power Allah has. Who knows how many dimensions he control and how many species he created.

[@purplecadence7390]

one thing that always stuck with me. Allah will continuously create in jannah so we dont get bored. imagine that. hell create things that we literally and factually can not imagine.

[@ami.o3574]

@@purplecadence7390is there a source for this?

[@RedaReda-vl9ff]

Islam is indeed the path of the winners in this life and in the hereafter

[@E11KMA]

Muslim Lantern just dropped a new video 🥳🎉

[@kazialam7768]

I learned so much about Islam and other religions from this channel. Thank you for doing such a great work.

[@ruby5136]

This was a very enjoyable conversation to watch he was sincere and calm instead of trying to argue and mock, thank you for the video muhammed we learn a lot from it :)

[@a7madx7]

A good listener is always a good man. I wish Allah Almighty turns his heart and give him Hedaya. he seems worthy of it and ofc Allah knows best.

[@EmadGGs]

Alhamdulillah another video 🙌🙌 Like, Comment, & Subscribe to The Muslim Lantern to help support the Dawah

[@elvarpasic2090]

Alhamdulillahi Rabbil Alameen. I have seen this one live aswell but always nice to wat ch in in Video format. Barak Allahu Feek Muhammad!

[@Iraniansunnimuslim]

This life is a test, that has easy and difficult questions, we must pass the test so we can achieve the ultimate reward. A place that has no śuffring. Alhamdulillah for truth that stayed obvious!

[@SueNa01]

I see a video from MA and I click immediately. God bless you MA. You never fail to teach us ❤

[@Blood-pack]

Al’Hamdulillah, another video another discussion… I’m excited to watch and learn insha’Allah… Barak’Allahu’Feek…

[@homtanks7259]

JazakAllah'u khairan brother

[@faisalsediqi6120]

جزاکم الله خیرا اخی محمد ❤

[@saadibneharun9327]

Respect from Bangladesh

[@riddikulus1432]

Bangladesh er Bangla version of Muslim lantern banabo naki? Channel dub

[@Death4Horseman]

Banaw ​@@riddikulus1432

[@mohammadtanvirislam1464]

এইটা মাস্ট লাগবে,ভাই।

[@MdSohanurRahman-vv1eb]

We want Muslim Lantern Bangla dub.. Love form Bangladesh..

[@riddikulus1432]

​@@mohammadtanvirislam1464u telling me this? Or to sadd ibne harun

[@sadiafortune4064]

Brother Muhammad Ali TRUE GEM to the UMMAH ALHAMDULLILAH AMEEN May ALLAH SWT PROTECT BROTHER MUHAMMAD ALI and all thee other brothers in ISLAM conveying DAWAH so profoundly and proffesionally knowledgeable respectfully ALHAMDULLILAH AMEEN

[@hatajusic3568]

Ameen 🤲🏼

[@Raakanroll2110]

MLs reaction at 21:59 was gold .. (when the guy started talking about BIG BANG) 😂❤

[@sadiafortune4064]

MASHA ALLAH respectful conversation from this French gentleman

[@najmanishmael]

May Allah accept to us all.... Allahummah ameen

[@maruf2050]

Alhamdulillah very nice conversation.

[@m_shakes]

Jazzak Allahu Khair brother.

[@themeanzone7571]

Well mannered guy wish him the best

[@hatajusic3568]

May Allah guide this young man. Thank you brother Mohammed, may Allah bless you 🤲🏼

[@Soroush.73]

Masha'Allah TabarakAllah. May Allah guide the sincere. Ameen

[@annoraboketto523]

Nice respectful interaction! May Allah grant this French guy and all of us guidance and happiness!

[@Come2islamm]

🌹اللَّهُم صَلِّ عَلَى مُحَمدٍ وَعَلَى آل محمد🌹

[@Lokation101]

ﷺ

[@Studyhard-c3j]

❤

[@samiaaouimri-sq1jb]

اللهم صل وسلم على سيدنا محمد

[@معاذ.ذ]

Jazak Allah khyrain

[@angelosaleh8344]

Allah is first. ❤☝🏻

[@Ahra-Su]

*Anyone who asks this kind of question should definitely watch "Jeffrey Lang's The Purpose of Life" video. He also attributes his atheist life from his teenage years to his professorship to this subject. However, all the deep thoughts and analyses he made on the Quran led him to become a muslim. He explains this process in this video.*

[@obayedrakib71]

Love from Bangladesh brother...

[@ayanokojisenpaionce3092]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@YEAGERlST]

If you read this; Say "SubhanAllah" 33x Say "Alhamdulillah" 33x Say "Allahu akbar" 34x May Allah reward you.

[@osama-canaan-ihu]

جزاك الله خيراً يا محمد

[@idrissbenabbes1284]

May Allah grant you and us the highest degrees in paradise! Amen.

[@hassanzayed1981]

جزاك الله كل خير

[@tempacc9589]

The question really stems from the Christian belief that everyone goes to heaven instead of life being a test. If everyone goes to heaven then suffering makes no sense.

[@Hprs9]

Don’t u believe life is only a test for mostly ppl born Muslim (Since that’s most of Muslim population)

[@JosephfollowsJesus]

Yeah, Amen ✝️

[@Dizoliot]

Yes, many people today have christian trauma and baggage that have no explanations to anything, the amount of people who leave comments on muslims channels claim they're christians and completely don't understand the angle/paradigm and I feel really bad for them. Alhamdulilah for islam.

[@Dizoliot]

@ what a joker, he wasn't saying anything positive about your belief. Seek help.

[@halim997]

​@@JosephfollowsJesusread his comment again 😅

[@Just_a_man_309]

He is a nice, bright young man who seems sincere in his quest. May Allah guide him to the straight path.

[@sea5586]

May Allah reward you with goodness

[@maddystrange]

❤from kashmir brother.

[@MdSohanurRahman-vv1eb]

The respectful speaking manner of the this brother deserve praise. May Allah Guide Him To The Truth.

[@nullunullu7990]

This guy is well mannered ❤❤ I gave you my heart for that, may Allah guide you men✌️

[@muramasa565]

The brother seems sincere

[@muhammadfajarprimajuniansy3416]

Jazaakallaahu khayran

[@altafwali24]

When Muslim lanterns smiles while the non Muslim makes claims I understand instantly that it's definitely over for that guy😂❤

[@akmamjadhussain6465]

Alhamdulillah. Respect also from my side.From Bangladesh.

[@aa-ff9ul]

May Allah guide the young man

[@Sher245]

7:24, just a slight error there in the language brother, you meant to say "Fighting".

[@Gary-v8]

Masha Allah. A well-mannered man. May Allah guide him.

[@biased6463]

I have a nice example for relative suffering i thought of myself :P. Rich person angry because his fridge is missing his favourite beverage vs Poor person who has an empty fridge but is happy his fridge is at least working I also thought of an extreme example haha: Person who made his first accident with a car being in shock and sad vs Person who makes car accidents every minute his/her whole life, but the current accident was the softest of them all.

[@bwddanieldacosta4818]

I speak French alhamdoulillah. If need, let me know inshaAllah

[@freeman7983]

baraka ALLAHU fik

[@mohammedaly79]

In shaa llah Allah will guide him to the right path

[@deanawad8618]

Oh Allah please guide us all to the straight path and keep us firm

[@GuidancetowardsTruth]

Respect from Pakistan

[@juliankelley6253]

Alhamdullilah! So happy you touched on the “All loving” vs “Most loving”. All loving is a more neo Christian concept that we Muslims don’t believe. But secular people try to impose this on every religion. May Allah bless you ML and guide Ulrisse, amin.

[@StückaEsser]

Fun fact, there's no proof that hummus have unalived non combatants. The only error ists there are issteal

[@OumarSL]

Muslim lantern new video, like first then watch.

[@riddikulus1432]

May Allah guide this confuse man into Islam, Amin.

[@Sal_A]

Winning a billion dollars may be the greatest calamity ever to happen to me if it takes me away from God-my ultimate purpose. On the other hand, losing my job, all my wealth, and even falling ill, may in fact be the greatest blessing ever given to me if it brings me closer to God-my ultimate purpose.

[@felreizmeshinca7459]

His Muslim friends that speaks French will help him understand the points better. InshaAllah.

[@arep1030]

Ive watched soooo many muslim content on youtube and i can safely say muslim lantern is the best to introduce to non muslims who wants to start learning Islam easily. Just so they'll have the basic ideas. There are some videos that i don't necessarily agree the way he explains some things, but most of his answers are so so so good. May Allah bless him and all of us

[@Shabs2456]

What I find fascinating is, there are billions of us humans, every single one of us has a different face, even identical twins have slight differences. Amazing. SubhanAllah

[@notyourusualfriendo3031]

What amazed me the most about the creation of the universe that we live in is how the law of gravity works,how can something come from an accident/random manage to dictate how the law works?if it was random how can we don't see planet shape in square or triangle?

[@hotcheese3553]

Yes, Brother, In my opinion **Math** is the one of the biggest evidence for design of the Universe. i.e You can calculate the diameter , shape of an object that is Billions of light years away. Truly Tells you that Allah is Al - Musawwir (The shaper or The Fashinor).

[@Hanan.T.K]

The existence of these laws to begin with is what blows my mind! How can they exist like that in a vacuum (if there was no God)? What made them exist? What made them work? It's so weird!

[@samiaaouimri-sq1jb]

لا إله إلا الله محمد رسول الله ☝️🇵🇸

[@Mohamed--Aden]

The main question is what would he accept as proof for God? What evidence would make him believe? A lot of people don’t have a criteria. Therefore they would deny or sidestep any evidence.

[@kamilabdulaziz7846]

My English is not so good but i still can understand what MA mentioned...its not the language, its the arrogance?

[@mintomehr4330]

Finally the goat is back🎉

[@fatimaibrahim5360]

احبك في الله يا اخي❤

[@yumarromero5144]

Assalamualaikum my brother keep up the good work may Allah reward you for all that you do for the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam how can you even question your creator you're sustained or your maker if you only knew was coming for you you would not even how can you even questioned why the universe so big cuz he feels like doing it cuz he can

[@emad2212]

هداه الله

[@darayoubi3182]

May Allah guide brother Ulrisse

[@leolionroarrrrrrr5509]

Most suffering is caused by people, and their free will. Free will. He knows once the animal is through suffering, they will be home at peace. He knows the end.

[@AyhamSpaceE]

Inside of the Quran, there id is always an answer for a question a human will have in his life. Allah is indeed all knowing and the Quran is perfect!❤

[@jaketwigg1065]

There’s a Quranic response to the Simulation question: Indeed, it is We who bring the dead to life and record what they have put forth and what they left behind, and all things We have enumerated in a clear register. 36:12 The Universe is a simulation, and Allah is the programmer ☝️

[@أحمدإيهاب-ب6ف]

Alhmdu llah❤

[@naeemulhoque1777]

I missed this stream 😭

[@Z1578S]

May allah azzawajal guide him, brother seems very sincere

[@aesfroliew2830]

May Jesus Christ the Son of God guide you to Christianity.

[@9W9W9W]

I don't what in his hart but I know that God will guide who ever looking for the truth sincerely May Allah guide him and help him to find the truth easley,

[@ruzaidiabduljalil2550]

ماشاءالله تبا رك الله

[@AnfaalShaheen]

May Allah guide us

[@syeera1234]

Alhamdulillah 🤲🏻

[@Truthbetold367]

Evil is the absence of good with good, evil has to exist for this life to be a test.

[@smooth2477]

Islam is the truth. Everyone come out from the darkness and to the light

[@ihdinamohamed4972]

Ulrisse bonjour mon poto si tu désire continuer tes questionnement je me propose de répondre à tes interrogation ! J'espère que tout va bien pour toi. J'ai aimé ton respect et ta curiosité

[@ulrisse8066]

merci beaucoup mais je parle à un imam toute les semaines pour les questions que j'ai concernant l'islam, je trouve que c'est plus pertinent qu'une conversation par message, mais merci quand même pour la proposition !

[@Salma.Louhichi]

@@ulrisse8066 J'espère vraiment que tu discutes avec un bon imam, quelqu'un qui possède des connaissances scientifiques et qui présente les points islamiques de manière logique. La première étape que j'ai suivie a été de comprendre logiquement ce qu'est Dieu, ce qui fait de Dieu un Dieu, et comment notre univers prouve l'existence d'un Dieu. Après cela, j'ai entrepris une quête pour découvrir la vérité sur les religions, et Alhamdoulillah, c'était l'Islam. J'ai principalement regardé les vidéos de Mohammad Ali, car il utilise la logique dans presque tout et cela m'a aussi aidé à mieux comprendre les autres religions. J'espère donc sincèrement que tu regarderas plus de ses vidéos et InshaAllah le CC pourra t'aider. BTW Allah, c'est juste la traduction de 'Dieu' en arabe. ^^ Que nous soyons tous guidés vers la vérité

[@FortisFortunaAdiuvat-97]

MassyaAllah Allahuakbar

[@JohnTronto]

27:10 Is Dr. Khalil still active? He is a Moroccan who speaks French very well & hes very good with atheists.

[@insanityfreedom2953]

Why is it so hard for him to realise knowledge is really important to start the universe? Being all powerful means can do anything and can destroy anything. Doesn’t mean things that being done and being destroyed will have any wisdom within it

[@insanityfreedom2953]

We need oxygen to breathe and live. This is knowledge and the wisdom of the creation of oxygen. All powerful only, means human just live without needed to breathe. But the fact that we have lung and it needed oxygen is where knowledge is being applied.

[@ulrisse8066]

Hey i am the atheist in the video, i had a lot of trouble explaining what i was thinking during our talk about the contigency argument so i will try to explain it better here. My first problem is that, as presented in my talk with muslim lantern, the contigency argument start with "can something come from nothing ?". Even if the answer seems to be no, i actually think that we don't really know. We have never had any experience with pure nothingness. Even in the vacuum of space, in the absence of any matter there is still some radiations and forces at play, so we cannot even look into space to see what "nothing" is like. But even if we accept that nothing can come from nothing, and we go back to the cause of all causes, we cannot say anything about it. I think that we can say only one thing about the cause of all causes (call it God if you will) and it's that it caused the universe, nothing more, nothing less. We cannot know if it's bound by time, we cannot know if it has a will, we cannot know if it's all powerful, we cannot know if it's even able to interact with the universe it created. And even if some arguments can be made to say that the cause of all causes is all powerful, all knowing, has a free will and is not bound by time, we cannot say that the cause of all causes is not evil. I still feel like i can't explain fully my view on this argument, but I hope I cleared some things.

[@google-mughal]

@@ulrisse8066 " L'homme ne voit-il pas que Nous l'avons créé d'une goutte de sperme? Et le voilà [devenu] un adversaire déclaré!" Coran 36:77 "Ont-ils été créé à partir de rien ou sont-ils eux les créateurs?" 52:35 "Et [rappelez-vous] lorsque vous dites: «O Moïse, nous ne te croirons qu'après avoir vu Allah clairement»!"2:55 "Pensiez-vous que Nous vous avions créés sans but, et que vous ne seriez pas ramenés vers Nous?» "23:115 "Si Allah s'en prenait aux gens pour leurs méfaits, Il ne laisserait sur cette terre aucun être vivant. Mais Il les renvoie jusqu'à un terme fixé. Puis, quand leur terme vient, ils ne peuvent ni le retarder d'une heure ni l'avancer." [16: 61] Please Read Quran, You will find answers to most of your Questions; Inshallah

[@tehnoobclone]

​@@ulrisse8066we cannot know in a sense that we cannot prove it mathematically or test it scientifically, sure but that is the limitation of maths and science. However, rationale and logic are valid to infer such an entity, because without which, you will always eventually fall back to something coming from nothing. But this is also why Revelation from that something is necessary to further our understanding. Allah Himself describes what is God: Say God is One (Indivisible, Absolute), God The Independent and Depended upon, never begets nor begotten, and never is anything unto Him comparable. [Al-Quran surah 112] You will find this concept of God completely rationally consistent for any reality. And how do we know the Quran is revealed from that Entity? We test the Quran by elimination, could it have come from anything else? With absolute certainty if you study it sincerely and hollistically, no.

[@insanityfreedom2953]

@@ulrisse8066 Muhammad Ali had presented an argument for you in the stream why the one that started everything need to be powerful, all knowing, has a will and doesn’t bound by time and space. So I don’t have to repeat that again. It’s necessary to have this attribute on whatever that thing is to start this universe. This is proof by argument, you can’t see the proof with eyes but use your intellect. I give you easy examples. Have you seen your own brain with your eyes to know that you have brain? Not from a computer monitor, not a doctor telling you so, not a study like “all human has brain”, but your own eyes seeing your own brain? I don’t think so, but you use your intellect and then you believe your brain is there in the skull. You believe you have brain based on argument proof.

[@TawhedDawah]

MashAllah

[@shabnumbhat5139]

May Allah guide you to the right path.

[@Anonymous_56789]

Our Prophet ﷺ said “Whoever recites Ayatul Kursi immediately after each prescribed prayer, there will be nothing standing between him and his entering Paradise except death." Dont forget to recite Ayatul kursi before sleep Our Prophet ﷺ said, When you go to your bed, recite Ayatul Kursi and you will be protected by Allah, and no devil will come near you until morning (5010) Narrated by al-Bukhari Take screenshot and share to earn reward (it allows you to copy and paste easily), and spread this message to also earn rewards by directing others towards good In’Sha’Allah, maybe Allah could make this a means to grant us Jannaht Ul Firdaus Ameen

[@aakhtab8403]

The Lantern is super lit.

[@ahmedadawy1238]

May Allah bless you brother Muhammad Ali