Attack on Titan 4x11 REACTION! | "Deceiver”

[@totallyrealname7002]

The parallels between Mikasa, Louise, & Kaya are such good writing in my opinion. After being saved by Mikasa Louise admired the strength and bravery she showed and took to heart that you have to fight to protect what you hold dear. Contrast this to Kaya who was saved by Sasha and consequently admired her compassion to help a stranger in need. This mirrors the different views both the audience and the characters in the show have regarding using the Rumbling versus attempting diplomacy or any other more hopeful solution. The struggle between what way of thinking is right runs through so many scenes in this season. Mikasa herself isn’t blind to how Louise’s admiration of her is akin to the way she has always idolized Eren and her cold treatment of her is because of how uncomfortable that feeling is, it’s no coincidence that she flashes back to her meeting with Eren right after speaking with her. Whenever Mikasa has previously looked back on that scene it’s been with warmth and love because she’s associated it with the beauty of the moment Eren wrapped his scarf around her. But this time the flashback is eerie and focuses more on the viciousness of the moment and how scared she was watching it. Perfectly exemplifying Mikasa's whole character theme from season one that the world is both cruel and beautiful, Mikasa has always seen the beauty in Eren but now she's being forced to recognize the brutality in him as well. On another note, you guys brought up the Floch’s shift from resenting Eren over Erwin’s death last season to being one of his most avid supports now, but it adds up when you analyze Floch’s reason for wanting to bring Erwin back. Floch believed that Erwin was a demon capable of making the cold decision’s and sacrifices necessary to bring them victory against hopeless odds, and now he sees the same thing in Eren who put even the people he cares about most in serious danger to enact whatever plan he has to fight back against Marley.

[@LycanFerret]

The part with Mikasa and Louise had its meaning clearer in the manga. That Mikasa was being forced to see herself in third person, through outside eyes. Understanding what other's thought of her previously. It's quite a profound scene. And integral to Mikasa's character growth, alongside Levi injuring himself against Annie in S1.

[@daniaaal]

To add on from Floch’s perception of Erwin, Floch actually hated Erwin because he led the recruits to hell (season 3 part 2). But he wanted Erwin to be alive because he believed humanity within the walls needed a devil, regardless of how much he feels about the devil on a personal level. In a way, Floch is in someway, both villanous in his scheme, but also a manifestation of one of Erwin’s qualities as a commander: ruthlessness in getting the job done. Even if it means siding with Eren whom he disagreed with in the previous season. He’s another well-written character in AOT in my opinion, even if I disagree with him and don’t like him

[@GreySunday17]

Perfect way to put it IMO. Bravo.

[@saswatapaul4184]

That is so well said bro

[@lovinganother1546]

Bro thanks for this, I honestly didnt realise that, so understanding it now just make this whole thing even better for me. That's crazy when you realise it, mikasa being the same as that girl to eren and now honestly seeing his crazy side back when he saved her.

[@nom__sain2239]

The armband scene is so tough. Gabi's mind is so poisoned by the propaganda that she's unwilling to remove her armband, a symbol of Marleyean oppression, because in her mind it makes her better than the Paradis Eldians. She'd rather get caught and killed then remove an armband that labels her as a hated minority.

[@Jimins__Pookie]

@لأمير مادرا Such an underrated but based opinion! W Gabi, she's my daughter

[@GewalfofWivia]

As you said, she believed the armband marked her as better than the Islanders. Also she's a hated minority with or without the armband.

[@antoinebrg6299]

Reminds me of people today that want to be part of an "oppressed" minority so much to get a bigger piece of the shitcake...

[@charleysimmons427]

@@GewalfofWivia the armband is so they can tell who is eldian the same way hitler did to the jews not everyone is easy to tell as a minority esp. between same skin color races hence the armband as a marker so you aren't mistaken

[@MondliNgwenya.]

Falco's so understanding because he sat in on Eren and Reiner's conversation. That's exactly why Eren made him stay and listen to it

[@iCyberDev]

My observation only but IF this were to be the same horse, it's possible Gabi's hair had some resemblance to someone it knew. Then again we've seen horses try to bit off scout head bands in season 1. We've also seen horses fly too. Horses are loose units.

[@CarlieAndAnge]

Very true

[@DrProfNoNo]

Pretty sure Shallot was killed together with Ness by the female titan

[@juansosa1670]

Could it be Shallot? Ness's horse? The one that liked eating hair? She wasn't killed. She probably kept wandering inside Wall Maria until she was found

[@fayechronicles]

The flying horses part sent me rolling on the floor lmfao

[@currentlyaliveanddead6733]

@@juansosa1670 Charlotte(the horse) is probably dead as its shown standing beside Ness among the fallen comrades.

[@tzimiable]

The realization of who that girl is, and who is taking care of her, and the potential stuff that will happen down the road hit me like a mountainload of bricks all at once. Absolutely insanely good writing.

[@YorksLancsTransportHub]

I noticed it as soon as I saw her.

[@karakarma8061]

Fun fact that titan that killed Kaya's mother was Connie's dad

[@shinsou_simp81]

Wait, for real?

[@karakarma8061]

@@shinsou_simp81 yeah it is

[@shinsou_simp81]

@@karakarma8061 whoa😮

[@lul6658]

Shit.. Damn Isayama.

[@springdeerling7866]

Don't we also see his siblings as titans? They're play fighting w each other and I think one rips the others ear off

[@rashad0026]

The conversation with Kaya was the first time her worldview has been challenged! Gabi sounded less and less confident with every rebuttal by Kaya. Tremendous voice acting in this series.

[@kzvnq]

she just like reiner

[@Degenerick]

Jean is Ruthless

[@CarlieAndAnge]

😂

[@DynamicShantanu50]

I see what you did there 😂😂😂😂lol

[@bxllisticbeats]

I don’t think Floch was against Eren before. He was against using the syringe being used on a random soldier and not the Commander.

[@nicjuancarlospe1866]

hence he was against eren's desires

[@由花子-p8n]

Floch wanted Levi to use the syringe for the Devil (this time it was Ervin) who he thought that could save the world. He has been very angry that Levi used the syringe not for the Devil with personal feelings. From that time he lost all of his colleagues by Ervin’s order, he has believed in the Devil (now it’s Eren).

[@bxllisticbeats]

@@由花子-p8n ^^^

[@alfaking8480]

Yo anyone that is gonna say Armin is not a random soldier to us he isn’t to flock he is love my nigga Armin tho

[@Anonymous-vl8ez]

Floch was pro Erwin because floch saw in Erwin a devil that keeps moving forward. Now, as Eren has changed quite obviously, Floch likes Eren.

[@polygon2745]

Comparing Gabi and Falco isn't really fair to either of them. For one, people are just different (children included). Falco is just more mature than Gabi. Second, since his uncle (the Grice from Grisha's That Day flashback) was apprehended as a Restorationist he and Colt had to step up and become Warriors to save their family from being sent to Paradis so he has a unique perspective that Gabi doesn't have. Falco was also present during the conversation between Reiner and Eren, so he also understands THEIR perspectives as well. Gabi on the other hand is emotionally charged, passionate, traumatized, and hotheaded. She HAS to buy into the indoctrination to justify everything she's done up until now for Marley.

[@KeangoDLuke]

Exactly this. Very importantly as well, she comes from a military family where all her life she's seen the benefits that being a good soldier, or good eldian has brought to her family.

[@SoulExpansion1111]

What I've noticed how similar Gabi and Falco are to Eren and Mikasa, Falco always looking out for Gabi, his focus is always taking care of Gabi, chasing after her, while Gabis strong will to pursure her mission at no costs and not really taking in account anything else, just continuing to move forward.Very similar to Eren and Mikasas relationship.

[@tofferooni4972]

@@SoulExpansion1111 Gabi is VERY much a 'suicidal maniac' as everyone called Eren during the last three seasons

[@MagicAlex15xxx]

Not to disagree with your points, but your whole comment is a comparison between Gabi and Falco. What was the unfairness you were against again?

[@SoulExpansion1111]

@@tofferooni4972 I just also found out that Mikasa and Falco have the same birthday too haha

[@someguy6469]

"they would meet nichollo and he would help gabi understand-" No, I'll stop there.😂

[@blahblahblah3716]

​@@jimmycorbett4611why people are so in disbelief if a reactor on to something by guess... U guys roast reactors badly if they are wrong and blame them as fake reactors if they made some good predictions... Accept some people are good at attention to details, interconnecting and making theories.

[@remqls]

​@@blahblahblah3716 omg exactly, we were all a lil bit confused and wrong abt our theory when we first watched it

[@mutanthybrid3466]

Remember, some little boys pull hair and throw rocks to try to get attention. The farmer liked Historia when he was a little boy, but did not know how to show it. Now that he is adult, he knows what it was all about. It wasn't that he was bad, just that he was too young to understand how to express his feelings.

[@franktaku9121]

Gabi has spent her whole life training and fighting for what she believes is right. All of her thoughts and actions are justified in her mind because she is a "good eldian." Asking her to accept that not all the people on the island are evil is essentially asking her to reconsider her entire identity. Things for Gabi are black and white. Good and evil. The moment something challenges her world view she needs to revert to broad generalizations about the people of paradis. This is the only way she can justify her ideology because if she begins to look at the people of the island as individuals, then everything is no longer black and white. It's different shades of grey. Gabi has killed people for the sake of what she believes.. She NEEDS to be able to justify herself.

[@ilsrzz135]

you phrased it so well

[@jassuyt6357]

Unpopular opinion but I think shes a terrible character and I feel like the whole "shes just like Eren" is just lazy writing in a near perfect show

[@ilsrzz135]

@@jassuyt6357 but she's not "just like" eren

[@dog_chasing_cars7576]

how many people did eren kill in previous series?

[@currentlyaliveanddead6733]

@@dog_chasing_cars7576 less than 10 before this season?

[@mrfool3545]

The horse theory blew my mind out.

[@haroko_chanotaku7234]

Polluting Gabi mind from the stories and sayings that were from her family and from the Marley about the islanders being demons as before and unchanged, so I never blamed her for her behavior because Isayama is very realistic about her👑👑👏. The dialogue that took place between Gabi and Kaya summed up the cycle of hatred in this wonderful work that is supposed to be taught in universities from the depth of this political dialogue.👑👑👑👑👑👑

[@Bunnybry]

That scene with the small girl that idolizes Mikasa caught me off guard at first. I don't think that Mikasa is trying to be rude, I think she was trying to protect her by telling her to stop talking about her allegiance to Eren so she would get out of prison. Also, I think that it was painful for her to hear someone that idolizes her condone Erens actions when Mikasa doesn't. As for the headaches, she has had them since she was little in season 1.

[@juansosa1670]

Some people think that she doesn't like seeing herself in that girl, so attached, so devoted

[@Ice_barrage]

@@juansosa1670 Mikasa is doubting Eren at this point, thats why

[@juansosa1670]

@@Ice_barrage Yes, that's true. I kinda fast forwarded to her future actions and said that conclusion

[@Ice_barrage]

@@juansosa1670 oh i havent seen this season yet haha, more than these 11 episodes on this channel i mean

[@juansosa1670]

@@Ice_barrage I see. Then you will see if it sounds reasonable or not what I said (which is something that one reactor said, I've only been pissed at Mikasa's attitude)

[@571danu]

You need to understand that 12 years of brainwashing doesn't go away in couple of days. Also Falco never saw his friends die but Gabi did, she saw more carnage than falco, and falco had the chance to hear erens story and form a connection BEFORE he attacked. Falcos uncle was also against marley, grice, so he has a different upbringing to Gabi. She was priased to be a warrior candidate and praised for killing her enemies.

[@psy_99]

The horse was kind of a throwback to shallot, the horse that would chew hair back in season 1

[@Degenerick]

did you guys notice that this ep’s budget all went to the scenery and the backgrounds like the river and forest? it’s almost movie quality 👌

[@idk-gz3kw]

and horse

[@daniaaal]

@@idk-gz3kw you know the budget is high when horses move in this show

[@soredtome]

I’m glad you’re trying to understand Gabi, even if it’s frustrating. To add to your considerations, especially regarding her different approach with respect to Falco, I’d like to point out not just Falco witnessing Eren-Reiner chat, but also the difference in backgrounds, because this is something I think you half-missed during the Marley episodes (because too many info): you caught immediately that Falco is related to Restorationist, so even if they publicly repented and offered the kids as Warriors, the Grice family probably does not buy into the propaganda; the difference with Reiner and Gabi’s family, the way they consider being a Warrior “an honor” and Karina Braun’s rather concerning way of parenting and delusions… that’s another world completely. The only good thing is that Gabi is bright, possibly more than Reiner was at her age (12).

[@scythe9734]

Couldn't have said it better myself.

[@KeangoDLuke]

Yep. Very important distinction between the two

[@IvyHilts]

Karina Braun is a terrible mother...

[@scythe9734]

@@IvyHilts True, BUT she is also a victim too, because she is a direct descendent of the first Eldians that were left behind by that Motherfu**er King Fritz.

[@Mitsu2040]

Very nice way of putting that

[@prideofjustice994]

As someone that had grew up on a farm, I can confirm this is normal horse behavior. Every time 7-year old me turned my back to them, there was always 1 that would lean over and try to lick my hair. I eventually started wearing hats, but then they would grab my hat & run away. Thanks for another great react & discuss. 🙂

[@daniaaal]

Louise reminds Mikasa of her own "blind" loyalty towards Eren. Looking at Louise made Mikasa realise that what she's been doing for Eren isn't far off for what Louise is doing for Mikasa and Eren, but for the wrong reasons. It made her question her own feelings for Eren, whether it was genuinely love or blind devotion, especially given how Eren has become so cold-hearted so far this season.

[@nullx2368]

Gabi struggle is simple to me, the moment she accepts these eldians are the same, the way marley threated them makes no sense and shows that she was treated very poorly by those who "love her" including her family.Its not just about accepting the other side but also seeing her side.

[@1997uday]

What exactly is her side here? That she chooses to be completely blind rather than face the facts? That's why she was so willing to be a slave to Marley and someone like eren or grisha won't be

[@1997uday]

@لأمير مادرا that's the best you got? Anyone would be a cry baby seeing what he has seen since the first episode Maybe you are built differently tough guy

[@TechnoArpan]

@@1997uday i mean, kind of. She's definitely not rational. Her entire sense of self worth is tied to being a "good eldian" so if she doesn't think that the paradis people are "devils" then her entire life and it's meaning collapses. She's basically in denial. If you hate Gabi, go ahead, no one's stopping you. However, she is a well written character

[@1997uday]

@@TechnoArpan yeah I do hate her character, and I do that because if I place myself in her shoes I won't be dedicating my entire life to prove that I'm "good" to people who will still spit and shit on me regardless of what happens, she must have clearly seen the other Eldians being sent to their Paradise over the smallest of crimes, yet she never gets any rage against marleyans And yes I accept she's a well written character, and a required character for this season to illustrate how this brainwashing happens and what prompted Reiner, Annie and bertolt to attack

[@nullx2368]

@@1997uday she loved her home, the guards that died for her, you could see how torn she was when Eren and others invaded. From a child perspective it all made sense that these people are definitely just devils. It's not like she's completely wrong, Eren himself says so and he's clearly doesn't have humanity best intentions.

[@kiid_frenzy4505]

13:36 "Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it"

[@Sashangle1]

This is one of my favorite episodes, I was happy to see Kaya The interaction between the younger generation was also very interesting to see

[@christopherabiuso3723]

I think the discussion about Gabi and how she sees good Eldians and yet hates them all and wants to destroy them regardless is a nice parallel to Eldians who view the world at large in a similar way. As viewers I think we can be considered to have an Eldians perspective…we’ve seen good people who inhabit the world, and yet too many of us seem to be inclined to reach for the nuclear option and kill them all.

[@riastradh]

What can I say? They gotta go

[@riastradh]

@@ulysses5439 idk man Jaegerists kinda wildin. They right but they wildin. In Liberio they were deliberately aiming at civilians

[@AliElBaba]

@@riastradh What should they done else ? If they wouldnt have be that harsh, they probably would have lost. Comapred to marleyans, our people atleast felt bad for killing civillians. Marley people didnt give a fuck…

[@alexmoult7725]

Okay, I genuinely laughed at "she's going to show them kindness and then Gabi's going to kill her family...... and all the horses as well" EDIT: and I also laughed at "oh, isn't that sasha's dad" "yeah I was going to say that too" "..." "oh that's awkward" "oh no"

[@TimothyGod]

Well, the hanger scene with sannes in the jail cell, it wasnt her replacing erwin. It was her replacing sannes, his role was to ensure certain information isn't revealed to the public and to kill anybody as necessary. As soon as he got stuck in the cell and hanji took over he's basically saying you're going to be in my boot soon. Which is where she is now having to hide information which is what her and the scouts have been trying to do the opposite for for so long. So now she's realizing that she really is just stuck in that position hiding information

[@mcdcrss43]

Floch is DEVOTED to Eren because, REMEMBER what Floch said about Erwin Smith??? "The ONLY way we can BEAT the devils, is a DEVIL!"

[@turulob3792]

Now Eren is that devil 😈

[@nate8930]

Falco is an underrated character. Like the first generation to understand all the hate and murder in the world is wrong. I hope he gets a real glow up next year.

[@tris273]

An awesome example of an Episode that introduces offensive circular storytelling. As Ange mentioned in 14:00 there are lots of parrallels that dedicate the plot and that are made from the opposite sides. Circular Storytelling is hard stuff to master as an artist and its declared of the golden discipline in literature. Aot mastered that to another level :D, literally every scene tells another story. And the more you get into s4 the more parrallels are revealed.

[@jerviealbay2991]

Love Carlie’s Prediction with Nikolo. Can’t wait for the next episodes.

[@joaniewwh3502]

as much as i can, i try to watch your reactions as quickly as it drops but i've been entertaining colleagues on a biz trip these past couple of nights and i just go home to pass out for like 3 hours and work again. anyway, i'm late but just dropping by to comment for algorithms and say thank you! much love to you both! 💜

[@MOTHforLife]

I'm excited to see tge guitar intro for the next opening. Ange should have a time with it

[@mcdcrss43]

DIFFERENCE between Falco & Gabi is that Falco HEARD EVERYTHING from the conversations between Eren & Reiner. Compared to the HORRIFIC DEATHS of Udo & Zofia that Gabi WITNESSED! Falco feels SORRY, Gabi feels ANGRY!!! Sad & tragic circumstances.

[@music79075]

I think Falcos emotions are more of profound disillusionment and confusion.

[@mcdcrss43]

@@music79075 absolutely! They're JUST kids at the end of the day.

[@TechnoArpan]

There's also the fact that since Falco's uncle was part of the restorationists, his family in general just isn't as indoctrinated as the others.

[@mrsuperselenio5694]

Hmm I don't think its just cause Falco heard Everything, even if Gabi had been in Falco's place at the basement, she would still react emotionally to her home and her people getting killed. Since we first saw her, she has always been a character that thinks high of herself and her sole purpose in life is to try to impress others while Falco first interaction has been to protect and help even if it is the enemy. Falco sees people at the end of the day, Gabi sees her people and Devils

[@xdrago1051]

You're making it seem like if you swapped their situations falco wouldve turned out like gabi and gabi like falco. If gabi was in falcos situation the first thing she'd do is yell atrocities at Eren then brainlessly attack Eren and get herself and reiner killed. If falco saw what gabi saw he wouldve been alot more empty and likely not as nice but he wouldn't take out his anger on innocent people, blind to what's right in his face. Qnd more importantly he'd still have his humanity. Bad comparison.

[@diegomagana9938]

Is not that she has been brainwashed, that is exactly how racism works, they plant all the hate in the childhood and unfortunately it lasts for life, that was also what Isayama was planning to show on this part of the series

[@RyzenShanks]

Yeah! I agree! It would be nice if Gabi will be able to talk to Nicolo, someone can help her understand! And also talking to Eren, it would be nice if Gabi can talk to Eren! I'm so excited for Gabi to passionately yell to Eren!

[@hollowbastion9372]

I think the horse that attacked Gabi's head is the same regiment horse from S1 that liked to eat hair, Shallot.

[@ThePointlessBox_]

the people who you are expecting Gabi to forgive less than a day ago slaughtered her hometown in front of her, especially with Zofia and Udo dying like they did. Falco was with Reiner and wasnt there.

[@goldenboy_808]

I always understand Gabi If I were in her situation, and I literally saw these people kill my closest friends and family it would take a lot of time for me to come around. Plus she wasn’t there for that conversation that Reiner and Eren had, whereas Falco was. Sure Falco had told her what they said but seeing is believing lol and the only thing she saw were the dead bodies of her friends. Plus she’s been brainwashed and indoctrinated, which is so easily shaken off

[@gurjeet_jim2151]

I can't believe how u were so fine with gabi killing that soldier, I was about to explode when I saw that

[@wakuwaku3190]

ikr. but i guess they couldnt be angry to her knowing a lot of apologist in the comment section.

[@ART3MIS_1904]

That soldier is alive.

[@22I22]

15:08 Oh yeah Niccolo will definitely help her understand.

[@RickeyRitesh]

Nice one👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍× thousand.

[@rinner_senpai]

One of the best episode discussions from you guys, keep it up! ♥️

[@scythe9734]

It's funny how people say "Why is it so hard for Gabi to understand the truth!?"..... does the truth actually matters? Does it REALLY make any difference after what she saw in Marley? She saw Island "Devils" killing her people and friends, it is as simple as that. People put too much importance on truths and lies, when in reality people accepts only the truths that benefits them and suits their situations. To be honest, if Isayama made Gabi stop being Gabi in this episode I would have been disappointed. It would have been bad writing. Also, loved how you noticed how Gabi's speeches felt scripted, because it is like she is quoting from a book. BUT everything she said was true and the Eldian Empire were Tyrants who raped and made the rest of the world second citizens (just like what is being done to the Eldians in Marley and the rest of the World) for 2000 years until a 100 years ago. But guess what? people probably won't accept this truth because, just like I said before, they only accept the truths that suits their situations and benefit them.

[@blackdynamite3288]

No matter what the Eldians did in the past nothing justifies killing innocents. Especially innocents ignorant of what they’re being killed for. That’s the point Isayama is making. Hate just breeds more hate.

[@haroko_chanotaku7234]

Your words are really wonderful👏👏👑. Since Isayama is very realistic in the character of Gabi, and the story is so realistic that the characters develop, it is not just a superficial development for the sake of events, like the rest of the silly anime stories, so the audience believes that Isayama will change Gabi by only one situation is to feed her food, and this is a matter Quite ridiculous, since she has been brought up from her childhood to despise the people of the island, so it makes sense to see her development and many situations until the character changes make more sense than farce. So, congratulations to Isayama on such an amazing character🤝🏆🏆🏆🏆

[@marcoinibur3257]

Gabi is one of my favorite carachters, she is made to show the ipocrisy of the Watchers and she does it perfect

[@scythe9734]

@@blackdynamite3288 Very true, but what does that have to do with what I said? I didn't say it is right or wrong to punish people for their ancestors actions. What I clearly meant is that Gabi didn't do anything frustratingly unrealistic or exaggerated. From her perspective she is doing what I would have done if I lived her life and was in her situation. Regardless of all of this, I still think that the World and Marley treated Eldians in a depressingly realistic way. A 2000 years long crime was committed and the guilty part (The Eldian Royal Family) wasn't punished. What did Fritz expect the world to do? Just go on with their life in harmony with the Eldians that he left behind while he and his circle of Eldians live happily ever after on an island like nothing happened!? Yea, sure.

[@harshitpurohit2416]

@@blackdynamite3288 I am not defending Gabi when I say this, but she is 10. She is in 5th standard killing people and she is being taught this version of history. How much of a fault is hers, is very hard to quantify. And I will contradict myself to say this but there is fault but who would be like Falco when your friends, the people you meet everyday, the house you live in and the everything is being destroyed by another section of population who are being taught to be devils and you are just 10 years old. To be a judge of that, that would be a monumental task in itself.

[@Bunnybry]

That thumbnail! 🤣🤣🤣

[@CarlieAndAnge]

😆

[@jaimecouto9450]

That Horse Scene made me laugh so hard 🤣 and it still does!

[@AthanaSus]

Does Gabi have a brick nearby? That'll do! 😂 love that reaction

[@PogMcDog]

This discussion makes the next few episodes really hype to watch from our third person audience perspective.

[@william8478]

“Gonna show her kindness, then Gabi’s gonna killer her family.” lol she’s wayyy ahead of ya

[@rna6079]

here's my two cents: if you can't understand Gabi, can you understand Eren? Eren took a long time to understand that there are good and bad people in both sides, even when he got the memories of his dad with all the knowledge. Gabi is still in shock and angry, she needs time to see things.

[@nachgeben]

Love that you have Jean as the thumbnail though.

[@usurper3497]

We are this near to episode 12 Jesus!!

[@AliAli-23]

cannot wait for 4x19+ 20 + 21

[@killia404]

Carlie has a third eye haha she has guessed so much! Nice reaction guys, already waiting for the next one

[@azureira]

I don’t know if you noticed but the reason the horse bit Gabi is because she looks a lot like Sasha in terms of face and hair color, so the horse mistaken her for Sasha and tried to bite her, because Sasha used to take care of those horses.

[@badinfluence3510]

Finally! Thanks for including Angelo's guitar shredding on the start of reaction timestamp

[@Sp1neEdits]

i just remembered you guys are the only ones who dont know about the jean horse meme S1-S3 everyone who watched the show kept saying jean looks like a horse so someone switched a horses face with jeans and made it longer and he really does look like a horse i rememberd this when i saw the horses or as i call them ""God Horses" like they live threw everything

[@avinash9526]

We are Moving toward THAT ep 👀

[@TukaihaHithlec]

Quite enjoyed this video

[@goldenboy_808]

SO CLOSE TO EPISODE 13. Enjoy the peace while it lasts cause shit is about it get fucking crazy

[@meticulousCheese]

I have genuinely never heard or considered the horse continuity - well played carlie

[@foxxberry2752]

Day 12 of asking Carlie and Ange to watch Erased😁: Next anime I would recommend for you guys is Erased, it's Sci-Fi Drama, and a touch of mystery. It's so intense at times, but also so lighthearted I bet you guys will love it

[@hammertime1015]

Lol anyone notice at 6:19 the kid on the far left looks just like Connie. Funny how Sasha's brother(adoptive?) looks liker her best friend. :)

[@shubhamsen3999]

I am glad to have your videos back to back on aot 😋 thank you..!

[@rinzzler366]

It's not as talked about but back in season 2 episode 2 sasha's father is talking about leaving the forest to Sasha and tells her the government is paying people for raising horses, so go figure her family gets into the business of running a stable. And caring for horses and they started an orphanage on the side probably because of Kaya and the events of season 2.

[@grapehool]

the eldians tortured the world for 2000 years, marley tortured eldians for 100 years. We can never know who is right or wrong its all gray

[@ZoiYoichi]

Damn Ange saying “that’ll do” at the thought of Gabi bludgeoning the girl to death with a rock is kinda crazy🤣

[@hishouha]

I understand Gabi and her character is great, but damn she pissed me off a lot in these first episodes 😂

[@allisongao6791]

magic horse lol, the most insane theory

[@artbarge713]

I think it would've been cooler if Gabi was the one in the basement, so she was somewhat deradicalized, and Falco was radicalized due to Udo and Zophia. It'd show more consequences of Erens actions more; an incredibly sweet, kind boy being corrupted into an instrument of war and hate.

[@oyamampendu9467]

Yeah but her reaction to him would've been way more volatile.

[@artbarge713]

@@oyamampendu9467 What do you mean?

[@farial9599]

I don't think it'd work tho 😂 to deradicalized Gabi, ones would need a long week of debate with so many shouting and cursing due to her hotheaded personality (there's no way she'd just believe whatever eren said at that moment). The basement scene only worked cause Falco sat down and obediently listened to them and frozen in shocked. If Gabi was the one there, I'm pretty sure she'd go berserk the moment Willy shouting "Eren Yeager" 😂

[@jlilley73]

@@farial9599 Careful man, I don't think Carlie and Ange have watched that far ahead.

[@farial9599]

​@@jlilley73 oh my bad. hope they don't read it yet

[@bryanolivera7818]

I have noticed that many who saw Mikasa's dialogue with Lousie try to justify Mikasa's attitude, saying that she felt uncomfortable with Louise's comment. but this is not a good explanation, (it would be a bad justification) since mikasa did not have to act like this with Louise, who only wanted to be like her, no, it would have been difficult for mikasa to be more understanding and tell her something "better" that simply telling him to "shut up", I think eren also has something to do with it. I think what Isayama wanted to show is: how Mikasa is obsessed with Eren and wouldn't "stand" if someone told her that she should let Eren "be free" (which at that point would mean that Eren would walk away from her to take carry out their plans). Mikasa cannot tolerate that Eren distances himself from her, as he considers it "his only reason for living from her" from her. we know that emotional dependency is not healthy. and what the author wants us to understand is that the best thing mikasa can do is "free" herself from Eren and not depend on anyone to live happily.

[@LeviAckermann1]

you totally missed who that girl that gave the salute was and it was such an emotional moment... Hopefully you catch it during editing

[@tyronetalam8488]

My interpretation is Gabi's finding really difficult to absorb the idea that the Paradis Eldians are good because it completely shatters not only what she's been taught but also what she went through as an Eldian in Marley. "What discrimination and hurt did I have to go through for then?" or something among those lines. I think Falco understood and processed it better not only bc he's calmer and more empathetic than Gabi, but also bc he watched the interaction between Reiner and Eren prior to Eren and Paradis attacking, at that point i think he probably started to understand smth fundamental about Eldians and their "sins"

[@cjjackson2423]

16:11 nah Sasha was already on that horse she rode it into town after she split from the group. That horse actually left them for dead 😭😭😭

[@sylg1733]

Like everyone, i was sad to see Sasha to die only on her second episode of season 4. But what i like about this season, they are still showing references about her, like even after her death, she still have a role. Plus, we got some flashbacks where they are showing her. So we feel like that she did not died. 😊 My favorite part of the video: Ange: Historia is pregnant with the farmer. I like to think that the farmer is a nice dude... Carlie: He's not! Another great AOT reactions video! Continue your great work while watching that season 4!! 🤗

[@thecommentatorguy4429]

Eren Yeager is the best written character in AOT..

[@mranime97]

5:39 Araki = Jojo's killing dogs Isayama = AOT killing Horses 😂

[@1997uday]

Finally a reactor who applies enough brains and does not go into the blind mindset of "eren and Gabi are same" 🥴

[@Grionlam]

the horse is that bite Mia head probably one of the Jaegerist

[@Omega_Star_]

9:06 now i don't know the name exactly but that Horse had that bald dude with the headband bite his head the same way in season 1, that horse lived all the way up until now lol, it was intended lol

[@AV-ik5mm]

I really thought Jean was on thumbnail 😂

[@kevint4673]

Finally someone who says it: Gabi and Eren have similarities in the way they are given MC treatment, but they are so much more different.

[@cal4254]

When you reach the 17th you should react to the opening and ending. The op title Rumbling was also no 1 in the us hardrock charts.

[@zoltanschultz8986]

5:39 okay carlie😱. no more internet for you today 🤣.

[@samuelwallace9060]

Gabi in this episode is the definition of an idealog

[@pablo7137]

Like commies

[@emmyjr1231]

love the thumbnail

[@novAviator01]

Thank you for the video

[@Sashangle1]

Exactly! Lots of differences between Eren and Gabi! Not the primary aggressor and he sought out the truth

[@matheusfranco3903]

Actually when sasha went to save that girl, the horse run away. That's why she had to let the girl go and stop to fight the titan and buy some time for the girl.

[@acfacf4657]

The horse is actually Jean. Now you know why they've called him horse face so many times. Eren told Jean through the powers of the founding titan to take revenge for Sasha. Tatake.

[@nahte-]

It’s my head canon that the horse that tried to bite Gabi’s head off is Sasha reincarnated.

[@lecameleon2500]

That's crazy about the horse, now, I remember, his name is Shallot if I'm right and the horse acted already like he did with Gabi back then. It was with a guy who died by Annie, sys something like that ?

[@t.y.163]

It sounds like weird though, but this is the most favorite episode for me among entire series. Even better than Hero or Midnight Sun.

[@jlilley73]

I prefer Ep 4x13, but regardless, I do love the Gabi/Falco storyline!

[@kodyross8222]

I suppose it’s always easier to keep believing what you always have than to accept that everything you thought was wrong. Even in the face of the truth.

[@モア-s9n]

馬をサムネに持ってきたセンスw

[@mojohey7408]

Love your opinions!!

[@Luky.73]

To underestand Gabi, just think than if she acept that the "devils in the island" are just normal people, its means than she have to acept that all she thinks, all she believes, all she is, is false. And even in the real world, for the majority of the people, accept that the other (the person who believes or likes different things or was born in a different place) is not bad and you are not the good Another thing to point out, that in the manga it was but in the anime it wasn't, when Gabi asks Falco if he's not mad at Zeke for betraying them, he thinks something like: "I still haven't told him that I helped the enemy and that it's my fault that Udo and Zofia died"

[@astroteddy5120]

Carlie's horse theory 😂

[@themetronomian7239]

Floch's simp arc begins

[@LoneWolf-xq4bs]

There is nothing wrong with appreciating such a well-written character, why do you have to insult or belittle those who adore Floch every time?

[@ART3MIS_1904]

Yeah, be careful, Floch stans are coming I hate him, he's the worst.

[@LoneWolf-xq4bs]

@@ART3MIS_1904 The world hates and discriminates against the Eldians and what do you do? You hate and discriminate the Floch fans unfortunately this work has not taught you anything 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@themetronomian7239]

@@LoneWolf-xq4bs i agree, but nothing wrong about an opinion

[@ds90seph]

*Oh* *my* *god* It's the *same* *freaking* *horse* Horsevengeance!!!!!!