ATTACK ON TITAN 4X20 REACTION ''Memories from the future'' Shingeki No Kyojin

[@al_alemania]

Grisha's voice actor went crazy, he did a fantastic job 🔥

[@kenethernandez6246]

Facts

[@haswindaaderahmadien9908]

true, it makes me feel emotional, such an amazing voice acting

[@tyrionlannister1628]

The scene where he was breaking down in the Forrest gave me chills..

[@markuman01]

He doing crazy good since Zeke's back story, the yelling the emotion was perfect.

[@noda7004]

Yeah i got goosebumps

[@chrisinigo6113]

The Attack Titan's ability is to receive the memories of its future heirs. This was hinted at when Kruger mentioned Mikasa and Armin towards the end of S3. In fact, Eren saw his future when he touched Historia's hand. Note that they can only see these memories, but cannot interact with them. So how could Eren meddle in the past? Well, he had 3 perfect conditions: 1. ⁠⁠ he Had Attack Titan ability 2. ⁠⁠ Founder Titan ability with access to coordinate 3. ⁠⁠ he was also in contact with someone with royal blood, too known as Zeke. After Zeke touched Eren's head, they were able to see Grisha's past memories with Eren using the power of coordinates. They could freely see the past. Now if Eren had another Titan other than the Attack Titan, he could just watch. But since the Attack Titan can see forward in time, Grisha can use this to see Eren's memories of the same event he is currently experiencing in real time. So, this means that every time Grisha can see or hear Eren, he is actually receiving a brief future memory from Eren's point of view where he can see with his eyes and hear his words. That means he is seeing himself from a third perspective. Then if he responds, his response is simply part of the memory that Eren/Zeke are seeing, allowing for two-way communication through time. Also note that whenever Grisha sees Zeke, Eren is always behind his father. So whenever Grisha sees Zeke, he is actually due to the memories of Eren's point of view.

[@vitor_oliveira]

im loving this

[@diegogonzalezvazq]

i think its more eren showing grisha his own memories but other than that this is a perfect explanation

[@maelpsng]

u need to comment this to all of the reactors

[@gil828]

This is such a great explanation.

[@misaelrey382]

Perfect! Every time Eren received new memories he was devasted, I wonder if he saw himself doing these bad things and went "WTF?!", only by the end of S3 he could understand what his titan was really capable of and is when the shit started to happened.

[@CertifiedSunset]

No wonder why Eren had the sudden mood change after making contact with Historia, he saw the future and he knew there was no way to avoid it. Having both the founder and attack titan (the past and future) basically makes him omnipotent. Eren is the closest thing to a god in the series so far.

[@DBT1007]

Only God for the Eldians. And still dangerous for noneldians since he can control titans. BUT! As long as the titans still there tho.

[@bruhmingo]

When Eren kissed historia’s hand he only saw the memories he showed his father. He saw some of the future, but not all of it.

[@Nicc2609]

@@bruhmingo he saw everything

[@PurplePainting]

@@Nicc2609 actually a big misunderstanding of Eren's powers that causes a lot of plot holes if you go into it assuming Eren is able to see everything. Eren's knowledge of the future is limited to Grisha's knowledge of the future.

[@Nicc2609]

@@PurplePainting probably he couldn't see everything in details, but he saw what will happen and how, I don't know if you have read the manga, you will understand everything then

[@checkmate9099]

"I saw Eren's memories of what comes next. But i never imagined it would be so terrible" The foreshadowing of this is so terrifying.

[@Tupadre97]

he's talking about the ending lol

[@tiagonogueira2567]

He is speaking about dove eren

[@jamrah8713]

@@tiagonogueira2567 oh man. for the last time eren never turned into a bird. its just symbolism for freedom.

[@MaytrixMan]

The shot they show here of Eren kissing Historia’s hand (at the end of season 3) is to show the audience that THIS is what Eren saw rather than the shortened version we saw back then. Eren has known how things were going to play out since that moment. You can see how much his character shifted even in those final episodes of the third season.

[@Nukerunin]

Yeah, it was almost like he became a whole new person on the exterior. He was a lot more dead in the eyes. Also that intense look of terror he had when he kissed her hand was nuts. It definitely rocked him in that moment.

[@tyrionlannister1628]

This is where I wanted Game of Thrones to take Brann Stark’s story line… so happy seeing it here… it’s perfection..

[@ahmadiskandarzulkarnain5833]

This episode kinda remind me hold the door episode

[@Robert_H.]

For some, Final Season Part 3 (Yes, there is still a Part 3 coming, many do not even know yet) is already Game of Thrones Season 8, if Mappa doesn't change a little bit of the ending. So you have even more parallels, if you like 😂.

[@ahmadiskandarzulkarnain5833]

@@Robert_H. Nah you're just overreacting. Watch invanderzz video, he's already explain pretty well

[@tyrionlannister1628]

To further clarify- In Game of Thrones we see Brandon Stark use his power, can’t even remember what it was .. to see past events, in one of these he calls out to his father “Sean bean” and for a instance Eddard Stark turned around, this was our first indication Brann could influence the past. The second was with Hodor, he literally changed Hodor’s life before he was born. Towards the final episodes of GoT I was expecting a massive reveal, probably within the last minutes of the show, us seeing Brandon Stark crowned, then through a flashback style revelation being shown how he went back throughout time, again and again trying to put the pieces in place, first telling the mad king “burn them all” then going further back to make his great, great, great grandfather “Brann the Builder” build the wall, then one last time back to the first men, trying to persuade the children of the forest Not to create the white walkers, in turn being captured by them and turned into the Knight King, trapped in the past a few thousand years before he was born. Present day Brann was literally fighting against his past selfs mistakes traveling through time… I don’t know… something along those lines… P.s Brann would have also been responsible for the Crows that led to him being pushed out the tower window in the first place.. P.s.s … Burn Them All… Build The Wall…. Hold The Door…

[@Tupadre97]

@@ahmadiskandarzulkarnain5833 nah

[@PressEnter42]

"even if you die. Even after death" that line gave me chills

[@DouglasR1B]

In fact, what some people don't realize is that the Attack Titan in itself is nothing special. But what allowed the manipulation of history to become as we know it was that at some point in the future something happened: - A carrier of Attack Titan + Founding along with a person of real blood entered the Paths together. Zeke making it possible to enter the memories made Eren able to influence the past and all the Attack Titan holders, who could only see the future because Eren was in the Paths showing them. Therefore, the only really special Attack Titan is the last one. The one from the future. It is a time loop and a paradox. The past only happened because someone in the future wanted it to. And that was Eren, the will of the Attack Titan who in all ages has always fought for freedom.

[@TheEmperor393]

Good explanation to the final piece I need to put into this puzzle. Something is lacking for me in your explanation tho: If it's only Eren interacting with the memories because Zeke took him there, why could Kruger "saw" the "save Mikasa and Armin" line said by Grisha when passing his powers to Eren? Your view is the most complete I've read until now, but I still am not 100% sure of why Eren was able to affect previous memories except for the ability of the attack titan to see memories of future holders (that's the reason Grisha can "see" Zeke). So I tend to think there is -in the end - some special ability of the attack titan to see future memories, but dunno what memories and when. According to Grisha is Eren who is choosing what to show him but still doesnt make complete sense to me. Thanks for sharing!

[@izrael820]

It's only because there's one user sending memories. Eren saw his dad's memories of him seeing 19yro Eren telling him to kill kids and that the attack titan can see the future. Through zeke making it possible for Eren to directly see his dad's memories Eren can tell his father what to do in real time while Grisha see "present" Erens memories of that instant. The attack titan is special since no other titan could influence the previous holder through their currem memories.

[@tridentdruid2449]

If eren is the last inheritor of the attack titan then how does Falco get memories that aren't his

[@markuman01]

Is it because..... Spoiler. . . . . . . . . He the last Attack Titan inheritors?

[@DouglasR1B]

@@TheEmperor393I'm glad you like my comment. I'll try to explain your last doubt but it might a little confusing: Eren influenced Kruger in the same way he influenced Grisha, and this can be seen in internal monologues that Eren will have while reflecting on memories of everything that happened in the past. He will say "Even if everything was set in stone from the beginning, I wished for this.... Everything, everything that has happened." When Kruger gave the Attack Titan to Grisha and talked about Mikasa and Armin, Eren influenced him to say that. It's a paradox too. - Kruger said it because Eren made him say it. - But Eren made him say it by showing the memories. - Eren only had the memories because Grisha said it to Eren. - and Grisha only said it because Krueger said it (influenced by Eren). Eren prepared his own path, just as he influenced Kruger to tell Grisha to form a new family on the Walls. This way, he could be born and be who he is. With this in mind the phrases "I was born into this world" and "I am who I am since I was born" take on a much fuller meaning.

[@Syam_kun]

Zeke before this episode: We gotta undo Grisha's brainwashing on you Eren Zeke after this episode: SHIT! I gotta undo your brainwashing on Grisha!

[@joemama7134]

When young Grisha feels Zeke’s presence for the first time, both Zeke and EREN himself seem suprised. Which means Eren didn’t know he could play with his father’s past memories until Zeke took him there. When Eren kissed Historia’s hand, he saw his future memories, but maybe he didn’t see them all, and he improvised along the way

[@luisben101233]

That could be why Eren is sometimes surprised by things that happen around him. He might know the end result and certain key events, but he might not know the path that leads to them. He knew he was gonna touch Zeke and activate the founding, but maybe he didn't know it was going to be his head that touched Zeke's hand

[@Lakross101]

Might explain why Eren blurted out to stop Zeke from screaming. He wasn't seeing things line up the way he expected and panicked. Broke character in other words.

[@yeager1234]

@@luisben101233 yes exactly

[@tommyn3522]

@@Lakross101 I thought it was also because of Falco - he was present at the restaurant when Falco drank the wine and has known about it since it happened. It’s easy to forget that Eren didn’t become heartless, he just got the glimpse into the future that told him everything was set. I think he didn’t feel the scream was necessary (the same as your reasoning) and also realized falco would get caught up.

[@DGame1234]

That's a good point! he didn't know he could do that because, he only saw his father's memories but never been in this paths mind space as a third person.

[@viriatox9782]

Great reaction. One detail to note: when Grisha first discovered the Reiss's hideout, he was fortunate not to choose that moment to take the Founding Titan (not only for the fact of not wanting to become a murderer, but also to continue living with his new family), because its possessor then was not the young and inexperienced Frieda Reiss, but her experienced Uncle, Uri Reiss. If he had fought against Uri, Grisha would probably have lost to him.

[@yeager1234]

Probably not. As Uri also was bound by the vow of renouncing war.

[@oreo3087]

@@yeager1234 i think he meant combat experience with titan

[@yeager1234]

@@oreo3087 still wouldn't matter. Cause uri won't fight really seriously as he is stuck by the king fritz ideology. Only reason he came later was because grisha wanted to spend more time with his family

[@viriatox9782]

@@oreo3087 Exactly. The vow didn't stop Uri from defeating Kenny so easily, and it wouldn't have stopped him if he wanted to smash him with his titan hand. The vow limits the power of the founding titan, but does not prevent it from defending him/herself or his/her combat experience.

[@joaoassumpcao3347]

@@yeager1234 You misunderstand the vow renouncing war. The vow avoids the royal blooded founding titan user to use the Founder's power to retaliate against the world. In other words, it convinces them to keep humanity in the walls. The "war" in the vow is referencing specifically a war against the rest of the world, not ANY war. Which is why Frieda fought Grisha, she only lost. It's actually the opposite of what you said. BECAUSE of the vow renouncing war, Uri would have no choice but to fight Grisha, because otherwise he would be allowing the loss of the Founder and the possibility of external war.

[@Vanessa-sd6dc]

zeke was SO determined to convince eren that he had been manipulated by his father but in the end we found out that The manipulator has always been eren, bro....... he is one of the best protagonists ( antagonist too?? lol ) than me I've seen it in an anime, I feel very happy to exist at the same time as this work of art. I love your reactions

[@danieltan5991]

You and many other viewers may have misunderstood the term antagonist. The protagonist isn't the good guy nor the antagonist is the bad guy, rather the protagonist is the main character of the show while the antagonist is the one who tries to go against the protagonist or his plan. Eren has always been the protagonist of the show, its just that after we see everyone's POV in Season 4 and Eren sees his future memories, he starts looking more like a villain than a hero to us, the viewers.

[@callmeweeb4350]

Eren has always been the protag, even now, just turned anti-hero

[@bfedezl2018]

@@danieltan5991 He does lose the role of protagonist from a point in the story by which regardless of Moral standing it is not longer Eren the protagonist but other characters. Aka after 123 he no longer is the protagonist

[@kaen4299]

@@bfedezl2018 You make no sense

[@Felnal]

@@bfedezl2018 Uh, no. Eren shifting his moral ground doesn't change his status as the lead character (aka his status as the protagonist). What changes is him going from being a hero protagonist to being a villain protagonist.

[@thomasdevlin5825]

This is the episode I was waiting for, this might be the craziest point in the entire series, and they somehow found a way to make it even better in the anime

[@ranitsarkar472]

There you have it. The main character, the side character, the protagonist, the antagonist, the love interest, the true author of AOT Eren Jaegar.

[@DrewDragoon]

hey now, the love interest is clearly Pieck

[@warkunitale]

Attack on titan is pieck fiction . I have no shame

[@12NiBer12]

@@warkunitale Get out.

[@THEONEDBZ4ever]

It gets crazier, for all you anime only fans. Manga readers know what I'm talking about!

[@charoddr92]

Grisha was talking directly to grown Eren when he mentioned the key to the basement btw. Thats why he had that expression on his face when he walked away.

[@thesyndrome43]

I love the subtle shots, like when young Eren says "then the lives of all who've died will be for nothing!" and it zooms in on Grisha's eye; when we heard that line in episode 1 it didn't mean much, but knowing what we know that line probably hit Grisha like a ton of bricks and he started flashing back to his sister, wife and all the other Eldian patriots who died, and it reaffirmed his resolve to go take the founding titan

[@handa_panda]

Zeke: “Eren, I will save you from Grisha’s manipulation.” Eren: “You thought I was manipulated but actually IT WAS ME, EREN who’s manipulating.

[@apatheticdeity6030]

It is truly ironic... that Eren was the son that Grisha wanted while he was in Eldia, while Zeke was the son he wanted in Paradise, but he only realized how horrifying a person like Eren would be after experiencing it.

[@HaloProNerd]

we first saw grisha’s memory of him taking the founding titan when Eren kissed historias hand back in season 3. That’s why they showed that scene again after grisha stabs his hand. It shows a timeline to when we last saw this event, but it also establishes that this was when Eren found out about all of this and how he ended up knowing it was him who needed to push his father to do it

[@Gabe-cv4yr]

Mirror within mirror. Finite and infinite. The paradox that is reality. A closed loop, repeating infinitely and yet finite in its outcomes and story. Freewill and pre-determined destiny altogether. We live in it.

[@ahmadiskandarzulkarnain5833]

12:56 It is when Eren kiss Historia hand in season 3 episode 20, It is when Eren saw grisha memories and knowing he in the future would do that thing, basically Eren just watching anime this episode

[@tyrionlannister1628]

In Assassins Bullet, after Gabi had shot Sasha, Eren asked Connie if Sasha had any last words, in which Connie replied “Meat” Eren to everyone’s surprise started laughing .. Eren laughed because he knew at that moment he was on the right path.. she died exactly how he knew she would and her last words were exactly what he saw before it happened.. it was just confirmation at that point..

[@NeuralexLive]

Crazy because that episode was released exactly one year ago today (yesterday)

[@tyrionlannister1628]

@@NeuralexLive 😲 “Twilight Zone Music Plays”

[@tyrionlannister1628]

@@NeuralexLive From what I’ve read, the scene where Eren throws the wood into the wood crate at home in the first episode and when Zeke and Eren watch it through their memories was 9 years apart, both in the anime and in reality.

[@DrewDragoon]

When Grisha is hugging Zeke and he finally begins to tear up, the word he says in Japanese is closer to Dad or Daddy, not the formal Father he has been referring to him as up until now. A lot of subs miss this tiny detail. That hit me deep man.

[@theorenmiyamoto1023]

So in order to avoid any confusion regarding the time travel mechanics, I will break down what type of Time travel we're dealing with here. AOT operates by a particular type of time travel where it's almost impossible to change the past even if you somehow go back in time. And any change that you tried to cause was always meant to happen in the overall timeline. Here time is a fixed circle, not a stream. We may see Eren meddle in the past but that was always meant to happen. This calls into the question of the existence of free will in the world of Attack of Titan. The Attack Titan's ability is to receive the memories of its future inheritors. This was hinted when Kruger mentioned Mikasa and Armin towards the end of S3. Keep in mind, they can only view these memories but can't interact with them. So how was Eren able to meddle in the past? Well, he had 3 perfect conditions: 1) He had the ability of the Attack Titan 2) The ability of the Founding Titan 3) He was also in contact with someone with royal blood AKA Zeke. After Zeke tapped Eren's head, they were able to view Grisha's past memories with Eren using the power of the coordinate. They were freely able to view the past as if it were through a one way mirror. Now if Eren had any other Titan other than the Attack Titan, he would only be able to look. But since Attack Titan can see forward in time, Grisha can use this to see Eren's recollection of the same event that he's currently experiencing in real time. So this mean that whenever Grisha can see or hear Eren, he's actually recieving a brief future memory from Eren's POV where he can see out of his eyes and hear his words. That means he is seeing himself from a 3rd perspective. Then if he responds, his response is simply part of the memory that Eren/Zeke are viewing, allowing for a two way communication through time. Also Note that everytime, Grisha sees Zeke, Eren is always standing behind his dad. So whenever Grisha sees Zeke, it is from actually due to the memories from Eren's POV

[@nathanielblanchard7975]

Nice copy paste

[@kenethernandez6246]

Damn this even helped me out lol. Good to know.

[@TheEmperor393]

Yes to everything. Only thing for me is: if is Grisha who is using the attack titan power to see the future memories of Eren, why can he see only that one or just the ones "Eren wants to show him" instead of everything. Is never metioned how the AT ability works for the holders to access future holders memories, at the beggining it was supposed to be a random event.

[@ablasttv]

Why is everyone spoiling this shit on every video. Quit. You're not cool for knowing. Let people watch and figure it out themselves.

[@tearlach47]

@@ablasttv It's not a spoiler, and these comments will not be removed.

[@zrubskev]

More than “seeing the future” is the power to “send memories to past users”. Similar but not the same haha

[@zrubskev]

I think Eren knows as much as Grish knows. Think of this, someone who has seen the future wouldn’t be surprised of things that’s gonna happen and Eren still gets surprise of certain things.

[@saverio_6990]

@@zrubskev he hasnt seen it all. He has only seen the memories he sent his father

[@mitchhamstrung1679]

You’re so right about how crazy this time travel thing is, I love the paradox of it all. Also, it’s mind boggling to think about how this show has gone from like a post-apocalyptic survival story, to a political intrigue mystery, to straight up war, and now to this. Loving this show and loving your reactions as always 👍🏻

[@cris7131]

"Is there even a bad guy?" That summs up Aot perfectly.

[@sabinakoka7967]

Fun fact of zeke He always called grisha "ano chichi" that father but in japanese chichi il only used for calling other persons father's This episode for the first time zeke called grisha otosan that in japanese is like "my dad"

[@Kraven240]

Alex, your reaction and analisis is so brilliant. We love you for it. Thank you.

[@sevimslife]

Just wanna mention in case nobody else commented it. This was NOT time travel 😅 it was a look into Grisha’s past memories. Grisha, as the Attack Titan, sees memories of Eren from the future (hence the title of the episode). Grisha sees himself from Eren’s point of view as Eren stands above him telling him to take the Founding Titan. Grisha does NOT see Eren himself. He sees everything through Eren’s eyes, and is led to do what he did. That’s why he also saw Zeke in his study room because Eren was behind him and his view was towards Zeke. Grisha sees Zeke through Eren’s eyes who is standing behind him.

[@shanestafford6605]

Wild, the Founder is bound by the past ; the Attack is bound by the future...crazy concept

[@resolutelament]

I'm sure another comment here has explained it, but Grisha is seeing Zeke through Eren's eyes and memories that's happening at that point in time in the paths. Anytime Grisha is seeing Zeke, Eren is standing behind both of them and is looking directly at Zeke. I've waited so long for people to lose their minds over this episode and it's amazing to finally see haha

[@まる-c5p4c]

From the first episode, the story is written on the premise that "Attack Titan" is looking at the future. In other words, the author was watching the ending of the final episode and was guided by that memory to write the story.

[@warkunitale]

that's crazy , Aot gets better and even better each time I don't expect it to

[@camsaturn]

Great reaction… love the sprinkle of French… from a fellow Canadian in north eastern Ontario 😘

[@NeuralexLive]

Ohhhh fellow Canadian 😃😃😃

[@RedNightron]

Awesome reaction, but the line "Duh your Ex ate Carla" killed me.

[@MacRain]

Basically Eren is a manga reader so he already knows the future 😂 Edit: also, remember the title of the very first episode.

[@denjipochita3398]

Eren pretty much told Isayama to write Attack on Titan. Eren played Zeke and his own father since birth through time and space. “Memories of the Future” is one of the best, if not, the greatest twist in fiction.

[@xceptionz6360]

Last episode was a 10/10. This deserves more than 10/10. As a manga reader,they did this more than justice. Just some tips for anyone still 1confused. I don’t think these are spoilers,but I give a warning anyway…. Grisha, Kruger and every attack Titan holder before that have been working according to the memories sent by the future chad Eren. Eren sent his memories back in time to create the perfect environment for him to steal the founding titans power in the future and destroy the world. Remember,out of all the 9 titans,the attack Titan had always been in search of freedom,free from the founding titans control. Why do you think that is? Eren had been influencing them all. About Grish seeing Zeke at only certain times….. Grisha actually doesn’t see Eren or Zeke in HIS real time. No,Grisha sees them through the memories Eren sent him. In this case,the memory of Zeke and Eren traveling through Grishas memories, is the exact memory Eren had sent him. Notice that every time Grisha sees Zeke,Eren is standing right behind Grisha? In other words,Grish I seeing it through Erens perspective. And also when Eren told Grisha to slaughter the kids…he didn’t hear it in real-time. He has been given the memory where Chad Eren whispers that to Grisha. Aka,Grishas hearing a memory of Eren coaxing him to kill the kids. That in turn affect him in HIS real time. AND when Grisha shows the key to chad Eren ,he really doesn’t see him,but he has a general idea of where Eren is standing in the room,because of the memories he’d been given from the future(which are from Erens perspective). That’s why he doesn’t speak about how much Eren had grown,because he literally can’t see him. Only see himself through future Erens perspective,aka memories. Just GENIUS writing

[@sadiedavis1051]

Eren saw his future memories through Grisha's memories when he kissed Historia's hand and that's why he was depressed and dead inside eversince because he already knows what's about to happen and what he should do to save his people on the island from the enemies.

[@pablovargas302]

Keep this in mind. When Grisha kills the Reiss family, there's no "first time", it's just that we did not see the full scene before, but as this is something like a "time loop", there's little to nothing you can really change. Grisha was always going to do it, though he hesitated and tried to "change" the future that was already decided for him, but Eren gave him that little push to do what he had to do, in order for the "loop" to continue as it always has. Sorry for the long text lmao

[@Loner_Mike98]

Exactly 💯

[@davidhdz7688]

Always been a time travel story, and you can see that from S1 episode 1 name "To you, 2000 years from now", and the next week episode it's called "From you, 2000 years ago"

[@小野妹子-p7r]

・ The lifespan of the successors of the nine giants is 13 years. ・The 145th King Fritz built a wall on Paradis Island. ・ It has been 107 years since the wall was built. Calculating these, the date from the birth of the giant's ancestor Ymir-Fritz to the present is 1992. If you add the remaining life of Ellen, 8 years, to that, it will be 2000 years. That's what it means.

[@小野妹子-p7r]

Hope the translator is working

[@shanestafford6605]

Think about it like this, the attack titan is unlike any other being, let alone any other of the 9 titans. We as people are influenced by our past/past experiences because that’s all we know, similar to the other 8 titans. The other 8 “remember” and are influenced by their past users. BUT, The attack titan sees both its past AND future users’ memories(though only select future memories), and is influenced in a timeline backwards to what we know as normal causality for us. Because what is more influential on your actions, a memory? Or a call to fulfill your duty in a predetermined role?? One destined by your son, in years to come… Another example of the Attack titan difference: Ymir memories go to Galliard then to Falco(forward) BUT Eren Yeager memories (sometimes) go to Grisha Yeager then (sometimes) to Eren Kruger(backward) as well as forwards It’s just tough for us watching the show to grasp the concept that season 1 Grisha was influenced by an Eren that we, at the time, didn’t know yet. All in order to, later on, allow Eren to get to the point where he influences Grisha in the past. Yes its a loop, but its def a closed/fixed loop

[@pockglockusp7]

They can't really see the future, the future users are sending memories in the paste, same as Eren which is sending memeroies to Griesha into the past, from the future

[@Astral0muffiN]

I'm still not convinced that it is a closed causal loop, it all depends on what effect Erens ability to influence the past has on the founder Ymir, what the origin of the vow of the King really is among other things. Introducing disorder to an otherwise static loop making it adhere to the second law of thermodynamics breaks the paradox. In his struggle to break free of the loop he will probably have to give up his freedom to let others determine the outcome.

[@shanestafford6605]

​@@Astral0muffiN I think youre thinking to linearly. Eren doesnt influence the past, he HAS influenced the past. He always has, thats why the past has led him to this moment, where he can continue his influence.I think the confusing thing is that the attack titan is bound by its future, not its past. It acts according to the future/the "end". AKA Eren. therefore has ALREADY given up his freedom, to his future and final self.

[@Astral0muffiN]

@@shanestafford6605 Self-causing events have infinite entry points that do not result in paradoxes and closed loops are no exeption. So I'm just wondererng which Isayama is going for and prefer to wait and see if we get further clarification on what type of loop this is and how he handles it in the narrative. I found the second person perspective in Grishas reunion with Zeke quite interesting in regards to non-paradoxical loops that allows for entropy. Letting them influence each other through Erens memory of the event, implying the willful addition of novelty and disorder to the system. If the loop extends as far back as Ymir that would allow for plenty more fuckery so you might be right, I just need more info to be convinced.

[@unknownstormtrooper5735]

Grisha literally despises Marley with an iron passion and for him to tell Zeke to stop Eren's plan for Marley is beyond haunting. *Opening plays in the distance

[@jL-rk2sc]

Man!Grisha's VA really amazing,he deserves an award!

[@marc5681]

This is a masterpiece of an episode

[@yuutousakaki]

my brain is exploded after this episode. This is SOMETHING beyond grandfather paradox and butterfly effect (@_@!)

[@itristen1990]

I am seriously so happy to be on this journey with you man! Great vid 👍👍 Can’t wait for next week!!! 🔥🔥🔥

[@iamshiro]

初めて見つけましたが着眼点が好きです。 また来週のリアクションを楽しみにしてます！

[@yeagerist1107]

Eren our king, our lord, our emperor, our God. We keep moving forward until our enemy are destroyed...!!!

[@sacrebleu7422]

the next episode will clarify a lot, for its name is (from you 2000 years ago). And if u remember the name of the episode where eren woke up crying, while dreaming under the tree is called (to you in 2000 years). so yeah that anime has a time travel storyline implemented... funny fact here is that the next episode is gonna be the 80th and number 8 itself looks pretty similar to an infinity symbol, while the 0 has the shape of a circle. so its kinda like a loop

[@pancakecookies50]

His future memories started to flow since Eren kissed Historia's hand. He saw every sceneries of the future of him thru Grisha's memory. Eren knew he can't change the future when Sasha was dead.

[@r19870411]

Remenber Grisha's voice actor, Tsuchida Hiroshi, performance the most plot tension sence in this show.

[@carleto35476]

It has been a time travel all along literally the first scene in attack on titan was a dream that Eren had about the colossal titan attacking in the future which ends up happening.

[@inflatedgoosemcgee7801]

Eren the villain confirmed. I was always confused when I watched S3 reactions to why Grisha would pass his titan powers to Eren since he seemed like a good parent in Paradis.

[@deonx262]

*Anyone confused with how the Eren manipulated Grisha can check it out :-* The Attack Titan has the ability to look into the future. This means that Grisha saw Eren viewing his memories in the future with Zeke. By that logic, Grisha saw himself through Eren’s eyes. This means that when Grisha actually went to retake the Founding Titan, he already saw these certain scenes through Eren.

[@gingerlemon865]

You can see "Future Eren" watching Eren, Mikasa, and Armin from afar in his hoodie in S1 when they're at the shelter. Eren throws his bread and yells at Armin and stuff. Future Eren is just watching from afar.

[@NeuralexLive]

I knooooow I went back and watched that episode 🤯🤯🤯

[@not_toxik_-8107]

Your videos are so cool. I'm french and I love your reactions. Ialso love your debriefing at the end of your videos so continue like this, that's cool !!

[@daryll3493]

I bet you were more mind blown the 2nd time you watched this, as you edit your videos Alex 🤣

[@tialla8745]

Hajime Isayama started painting & maked story at the age of 22

[@anupriye5109]

Isayama: Hmm.. not sure about this part of the plot, it is the right direction? Eren: Keep moving Forward! Isayama: Yes my lord...

[@maiki8099]

cet episode a retourné mon cerveau c etait d'une intensitée

[@syafiqmarzuki1697]

Did you guys remember the special ending scene for season 3 episode 12? That was the biggest hint of The Attack Titan's ability.

[@callmelafey1842]

Amazing analysis and observing!!

[@21mochammadsulton22]

When i was bored and also want to improve my listening skill. I watched your videos ✨

[@thedangler7002]

These episodes are so consistently great

[@voltgaming2213]

Mappa did a good job making this at least better than previous episodes

[@tylerrader9945]

When i read the manga chapter of this when it came out I ran around my house screaming. Glad to see the world is where I was at all that time ago :)

[@svilleda237]

Grisha my favorite characther ❤️ I waited for these to be animated And the acting was so touching and lunatic 💯👌

[@murcianwolfreacts5135]

Just when we thought last week´s revelations were the pinnacle, we get this!!!! Who do we root for!!!???

[@lisemzarate4029]

It suddenly dawned on me, the O.P, is a mix of classical and modern music, fitting for the episodes, 🤔🤯

[@Shizar7]

12:56 that scene is from season 3 ep 21 or 22, just after that kiss Eren sees that same memory where he manipulates his father.. You can can say that's the moment we lost Eren

[@williambeaulieu3668]

C'est tellement triste de se dire qu'il y a pleins de gens qui ne connaisse ou regardes pas attack on titan, c'est un masterpiece et pleins de gens vont passer a coter de ca dans leur vie.

[@freezefire8206]

"Has it been all along?" is the perfect definition of Attact on titan

[@killua1418]

DEMON SLAYER AND AOT WITH CRAZY EPISODES. THE ANIME THIS YEAR HAS BEEN OFF THE CHARTS LETS GOOOOO. Your reactions make it 10x better too. Look forward to every single one.

[@NeuralexLive]

#animesundays are beyond intense 🤯🤯🤯

[@piyushkabadi3543]

masterpiece straight masterpiece

[@DBT1007]

The 12:55 means.. The show want to tell you about... THAT MOMENT IS WHAT EREN SAW WHEN HE TOUCH HISTORIA. (young) Eren even got the same expression as Grisha in that moment. Shocked and forced. And from that point, his personality completely changed. From a cheerful boy that talk about the outside world with Armin before they got the medal, but after that historia touch moment thing, eren became like.. depressed. And u can even see more about that when they reached the sea. And also.... This is the FIRST EMOTIONAL MOMENT OF MAPPA. I almost cried in that Grisha moment when he regretted doing that and like... "are you happy now, Eren!?"

[@kapitanjisun]

Eren din't exactly saw the future. The Attack Titan's ability is to send memories from a previous inheritor from a future one. But the loop hole is that you can't send memories to your past self, which Eren expoilted. He saw his future self when he unlocked Grisha's memories of a Future Eren. When Grisha is "seeing" Grisha, it's eren's memories watching him so it was Grisha watching himself in 3rd person pov (eren's pov). It's kinda crazy to think

[@kolba1a]

thanks god i found one more great person to watch his reactions.all of the people im watching u are 2nd place.keep it up this great content.(nvm my bad english)

[@Hendysmd98]

5:38 I'm glad you noticed that they wandered for years in Grisha's memories, that's crazy! And, to know that Grisha killed the Reiss family because he was persuaded by Eren is even more twisting me.

[@yuar7926]

Yes it's very intence ) Thank for your reaction!

[@tadjman4059]

Ceux qui ont pas tout capté concentrez vous: Grisha voit le futur d'Eren grâce à l'assaillant et Eren voit les souvenirs de Grisha qu’il a hérité en le mangeant. Donc Eren, en embrassant la main d'Historia, a vu son propre futur à travers Grisha: c'est à dire tout ce qu'il va entreprendre dans le futur --> Manipuler son père, être celui qui décide tout et plein d'autre trucs. Eren s'est crée tout seul, y'a pas de début pas de fin ! --> C'est en se voyant faire qu'il a su quoi faire, et il a fait ce qu'il a fait car il savait qu'il devait le faire ! C'est une dinguerie monumentale. Le futur influence le passé ! (Et Grisha obéit à Eren pcq il est désesperé, il lui reste moins de 3 ans à vivre et il sait qu'Eren va faire qql chose d'atroce mais Eren refuse de tout lui montrer, il est obligé de faire confiance aveuglément, car s'il ne fait rien ça sera fini pour Eldia de toute façon. Au fond de lui il aimerait que Sieg empêche Eren d'accomplir son destin, mais le futur peut-il être changé ?) (Si Grisha voit Sieg c'est à travers les visions qu'Eren decide de lui montrer. Eren est un grand manipulateur.)

[@diegocorvalan7988]

Really nice reaction video, I react in the same way with the Op jajajaja. Regards from Chile

[@jamiepetereit7828]

this was one of my favorite parts in the manga

[@June44555]

Grisha was actually looking at himself through eren’s eyes 👀

[@ChristGS]

Even Frieda does want to help Grisha, she felt his pain, but because she's bound by the "Vow Renouncing War", and she owns the Founding Titan, if u look closely suddenly her eyes turned into those bright one that signifies the Founding Titan eye, that very moment her attitude changed, with her face straight up she said the dooms day has come for Eldians, etc, it's because of the First King ideology, Vow Renouncing War, I hope I tells this clear.

[@jaroslavmihok740]

great reaction Alex

[@lecameleon2500]

Cet épisode est juste incroyable !

[@raymondbruce178]

That's why Mr. Kruger told Grisha to protect Mikasa and Armin before giving him the attack titan. Foreshadowing at it's bestttt😭

[@DavidTorres-bz2oj]

I love your videos bro, regards from Chile!!!

[@thecrimsondragon2379]

I swear to god this episode almost made me cry

[@Bunnies987]

Zeke: Grisha must brainwash you a lot, Eren Eren: nah, i brainwashed him all

[@AnibalAlvarez]

Jeeezzz... I'll be the whole week watching reactions for the most insane plost twist in TV history xD And next week will be the same, knowing what's gonna happen... LOL

[@pochinankurunaisa4558]

It's interesting to look up the lyrics of the song

[@haruikichi]

I love seeing these KZbinrs making theories lol, like the old days ya feel me manga readers

[@思考停止-h3p]

Alex, 🤗you always show me a lot of fun.Thank you very much.🙏❤️ I've been watching Alex's videos over and over again.🤣 It's fun.🎵🎵🎵🎵

[@1984-z8f]

12:40 All the important things occurred by Grisha’s RIGHT hand. And now he blame his right hand and stab with other hand. And I think it’s not only his will. Sick as always!

[@LeviAckerman-jk3nt]

The Best Reaction on KZbin !!!

[@viroz6562]

Read the rest, emotional rollercoaster continues.

[@trannhat1332]

11:00 the ability of the Attack Titan is to Know the Future not see it, so Eren only see the result not the way lead to it

[@noda7004]

That ep made me feel so weird Like feeling fear and amazed Happy and sad I can’t describe exactly what happened to me in this ep But it was amazing