WHICH LUXURY SUV IS BETTER? BMW X5 vs GENESIS GV80 // ENGINEER'S FULL REVIEW

[@kkadkhoda]

Great video as always and learned a lot while I enjoyed it!!, Thx🙏👌👍

[@brianpackard9954]

Thanks for your review.

[@PopsRacer61]

...And the only problem I have with German cars is they have the best driving dynamics, are built like tanks and usually have slightly thicker gauge metal panels/thicker paint and more sound deadening material, superb sound systems..and drive flawlessly when new! Buuuuut, unless you're more than a 6 figure earner and do not care what the maintenance and parts cost, and money is not an issue... those cars will break the bank after 4 - 6 yrs of ownership. Still great cars though!

[@zhila5958]

New ones aren’t built like a tank. Not a single BMW could last in the shithole i reside in. Nor a single American or korean car for that matter either. The japanese are leagues and bounds more durable than others, it’s not even worth making any comparisons.

[@PopsRacer61]

@@dgdave2673 ..that's my POINT!

[@themaskedsingercucucachu8225]

@@zhila5958 False, simply false. they are far less durable on torture roads... they use CHEAP materials that are cheap to replace.... if that id your definition of durable, so be it. The Japanese don't build tanks.

[@burningknuckle26]

@@zhila5958 fax

[@truoli131]

Absolutely wonderful video as usual! Could you look into comparing luxury SUV coupes?

[@jsfbay1]

David, how did you find the dual screens in the BMW with regards to reflection/glare? I like the Genesis because the gauge cluster has (traditional) cowling around it, whereas the BMW's has zero cowling. Thanks very much for another great video!

[@strykerballcrush4650]

Not a big fan of this trend where manufacturers put basic functionality like temperature control in the infotainment panel instead of having physical controls in the console.

[@syedshahram]

Never had an engineer’s perspective. Good to see that. What was the first review did with those gap measurements? Also you should try out the 2025 GV80 too. Waiting for that review.

[@elizabethwhite4606]

David, thank you for another great detailed and road driving review. Going with the Genesis for the incredible interior and smooth ride. After my personal experience with BMW, I would choose the reliability of the Genesis.

[@mig3872]

I'm thinking about GV80 myself

[@AdvantagersRS]

Looked at both 6 months ago and bought the GV80. no regrets and i still love it.

[@mig3872]

@@AdvantagersRSthank you. This is helping me make my decision.

[@Genie98997]

I'm a fan of BMW but many friends have had many EXPENSIVE repairs with BMW after the warranty expires, despite keeping up with maintenance at the dealership. I don't need the size of the GV80 so test drove a Genesis GV70 (base model) and was blown away. I'll likely be trading up my Mazda CX-5 for my first Genny. I might wait for year 2 of GV70 Hybrid, which should be reaching the shores within the next couple of years...

[@musicultra571]

Greatest review format on KZbin. This guy actually cares about engineering quality and build qualyunlike some pthers that ramble about "steering feel"

[@dariangordon-rk5sm]

GREAT comparison review. Thanks for going to the effort of doing this review, with your engineering background.

[@AutomotivePress]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@Tully3674]

Good video - Thank you.

[@danielrogers4072]

I like the “Auto” climate setting on BMW HVAC and seats, works much like the same feature on my Land Cruiser 200!

[@stevenlucero3371]

David, will you comment on the thinking behind a function such as adjusting the HVAC controls within the monitor what was the engineering that designed this feature?

[@bryandsouza9905]

You forgot one thing about the BMW is that when you are driving you can voice command it to lower or increase temperature, you don’t need to fumble with the screen

[@patbomar1375]

Very nice review.

[@Pawpatrol119]

Great show David 👏👏👏

[@ChungKyuParkCK]

Just concise, informative and real excellent comments in terms of reliability and easiness to understand. About to decide which SUV to buy after return my company car due to my recent retirement. Genesis GV 80 Coupe( with 48w electric motor; mild hybrid ) facelift model 3.5 Twin Turbo vs. BMW X5 Hybrid( which has been my favorite SUV all the time). Dear David, plaese make some clips regarding the new Genesis GV80 Coupe mild hybrid, which heard to be come to USA in a month or so. Thanks and kust Two Thumbs Up!!!

[@jollyp1605]

Great review as always from David.

[@mso8190]

Thank you, David San. Can I request you measure the paint on the front bumper as thats usually where most stone chips occur. Also could you possibly get a sound meter to measure the interior decibels?

[@jimmyamico4713]

Hi David, No doubt in my mind the genesis GV 80… like I have said before many many times, German cars are not reliable and dependable in my opinion… The GV is much more capable as a better fit and finish on the inside and outside and has an overall better ride… In my opinion❤

[@patsman6737]

Great review. How would you rate the Mercedes GLE450 as compared to the GV80 / X5?

[@gwenwright9865]

Thank you for the comparison.

[@scottwong-ur6vl]

Genesis drives me bananas. They make gorgeous cars then expect mb and bmw owners to go buy their cars from hyundai sales reps in a new polo and service their cars with hyundai service. I think it might be the most horrendous dealership experience(s) i’ve ever had.

[@scooter5940]

You see similar comments all over.

[@gerritayers7822]

I bought my Genesis GV 80’from Larry Miller In Peoria, AZ and was beyond pleased with the sales experience and the vehicle.

[@meysamarasharbastan8426]

I live in Calgary, Canada, and recently, they opened a new building for Genesis. Everything separated from Hyundai, very classy and luxury.

[@your_royal_highness]

Walking into a cheesy Hyundai dealership to check out a Genesis was borderline humiliating. I’m glad they are opening more standalone’s.

[@Imcarlosolivas]

I have a BMW X5 and I love it. I do like the look of the GV80 but worry about losing my sporty aggressive characteristics of the Bimmer. Plus, I’ve been in BMW and Mercedes products so long, is a Hyundai right for me? IDK? More for my money, but I’m hearing bad things. Decisions decisions…

[@whatdoufeel]

Always great reviews.

[@stea2494]

I traded my 2020 rx for a 22 x5 and i have no regrets such an improvement overall, better ride, better tech, top notch quality and overall better pride of ownership. My first BMW and probably not my last

[@fairenough4970]

great job - but I had too many problems with X3

[@Genie98997]

The BMW color is not bad, but that Genesis semi-gloss paint is gorgeous. The Genesis does look like a $200k vehicle (yes, because it was designed by former Bentley designers) and is one of the best looking vehicles on the road imo. Definitely need those 22" rims to fill out the wheel wells. Great review

[@shane6115]

I’m European 🇪🇺 and have to say that the best vehicle come out of Asia.

[@Lions_Gate]

The cheapest cars come out of Asia

[@scooter5940]

I could not get past the ugly and staid sterling wheel on the GV 80 - it’s awful- so I went with the X5 40i which delivered in December. Genesis finally fixed that on the 2025. Both good looking inside and out, I just slightly preferred the BMW, which also has the better engine. Also, Genesis and its dealers are not proven as a luxury brand, so I’d expect to see some sort of financial break from buying one, but there isn’t one. This is such a competitive segment with a lot of great choices. Love the X5 so far.

[@rcalbuquerque1]

Been watching your videos….getting ready to buy a new vehicle…Lexus TX 550H+ of BMW X5 x drive 50e both around the same money what would you buy?

[@AutomotivePress]

The BMW is more fun to drive but the TX is more reliable... it depends on how long you want to keep the cars

[@Fezzent]

Your mic gain is way too high on headphones it crackles

[@jaywho476]

So you're saying the Genesis drives really well over perfectly smooth roads😂

[@rightlanehog3151]

David, When will Lexus offer a RWD CUV to compete with these? 🤔

[@philhenderson3516]

Probably never lol! They're too miserly to do it.

[@europec2082]

the matte paint looks nicer

[@Genie98997]

Agree, having the HVAC buried in a screen is an immediate dealbreaker for me in ANY vehicle. Genesis just "gets it" when it comes to ergonomic design and ease of use. Very intuitive.

[@nonyabusiness6048]

The Genesis is superior merely for the fact that both the maintenance and repair is remarkably cheap then a German car/suv...

[@bwrecks]

You win. BMW kill you with maintenance. Never again

[@Lions_Gate]

When you are on a tight budget, you buy a cheaper car.

[@your_royal_highness]

I can afford it and am not willing to drive a more boring car. Not yet anyway. I have said I will consider going back to something like Lexus when I am in my 80’s. At that point a PHEV or even full electric would make sense since I will generally only be driving to the grocery store and doctor’s office. Meanwhile, BMW, Audi and Porsche are what I crave. I got a great deal on a ‘25 X5 40i Silver anniversary edition with 900 miles on it, by virtue of the fact I did not get it from a BMW dealer. I saved around $15-$20k in terms of cost and trade in value (vs buying from a BMW dealer) and still retained all but three months of the warranty. That savings will pay for some maintenance! I traded in my ‘23 SQ5, which was a marvelous car, but I wanted something with more room. Next one will likely either be another X5 (especially if they dump the run-flats which I understand is going to happen) or a certified Cayenne. Possibly a Q8 which is a nice looking car, but the BMW is a lot cheaper. The X5 50e is enticing.

[@andik2329]

As a German I always thought that the German cars are over engineered but they have a much better ride quality than any Japanese car. However the Asian cars have a higher quality in terms of longevity. As an example. The 3.0 l 6 cylinder in the Audi Q7 has 3 turbochargers. 2 normal and 1 electric, which uses 48 volts and can spin from 0 to 170000 rpm in 0.2 sec. They get a 3 mpg better gas milage than Toyota. Guess what brakes first. Toyota puts in a 4.0 l six or eight cylinder that is normally aspirated and uses regular gasoline. It has less horsepower and the gas mileage is worse but the engine lasts forever.

[@themaskedsingercucucachu8225]

mechanical quality, materials and fit and finish for the suspension, frame, brakes, everything... is clearly superior on the BMW.

[@Stixenterprise]

Paint comparison is not apples to apples!

[@malcombhardy]

Good, quality perspective on these vehicles. I love the BMW motor and driving feel however question reliability and maintenance; especially since I usually purchase pre owned. That is my only hesitation with purchasing a bmw. The Genesis in my opinion is a bit more luxurious and I have less anxiety purchasing than the X5.

[@your_royal_highness]

How about the Audi Q8? Compared to the X5 and GV80

[@fmint63extraordinaire81]

I will say Genisis is still fairly new and they have Damn near caught up and surpassed the Germans in a Short period of time, camera based turn signals, digital rear view camera, reclining second row seats, heated and ventilation so the overall package is better and less expensive then the BMW those are the facts.

[@amigatommy7]

Always preferred the nob to touchscreen.

[@Rockofaz]

The X5 can be controlled through voice control in addition or instead of the touch pad.

[@Genie98997]

On a 4 year lease: BMW Long-term purchase >5 years ownership: Genesis

[@ThatGuy-kv1kw]

rotary gear selector is a mistake

[@femiogunsola5436]

For me, as a consumer, the GV80 looks and drive better. The X5 is good though

[@Threxx]

BMW X5 is not all new for 2024. Current gen came out in 2018 for 2019 model year.

[@BigNoseDog]

The 2025 GV80 will use a large screen similar to what’s in the X5.

[@burningknuckle26]

in this price range... the Genesis is awesome

[@phaseglobalradiocom9677]

BMW is not made in Germany. It’s made in the USA and it will fall apart after the warranty period.

[@zhila5958]

You mean during the warranty? the X7 were notorious for falling part during the warranty according to some folks

[@emmanuelmorris6672]

111 q​@@zhila5958

[@user-g968h93r]

Like all fords, chevys, dodges? Sit down goofy

[@Lions_Gate]

You must be a racer driver. Rag any car out and it has problems.

[@lendledavegarcia7024]

With same price range i would go for BMW interior and exterior

[@Alrounderrrr]

Seriously why they have these big screens which look ridiculous and make things more complicated

[@your_royal_highness]

One thing to hate on the BMW (and other makes) is EVERYTHING is on the damn screens; makes for a collision waiting to happen

[@JohnnyLocke]

💪

[@michaeldichael9978]

BMW, all day long. No contest.

[@bwrecks]

No savings either

[@KunalBalani]

Anyone who is impressed with GV80 should visit their service department. Hyundai service is the worst.

[@dvdkaranja14]

Have a 2022 GV80 2.5 and I wouldn’t trade it for the BMW.You can’t beat the Genesis 100k mile warranty

[@vincedemo2752]

Why not get the 3.5? Was it price difference that made you go 2.5?

[@jpsmith8523]

100k warranty is worthless, the worse cars made will go 100k... not a buying point

[@Shabnation]

German car or Korean car ? As a mechanic please people never buy Korean cars please the powertrains are junk .

[@ramgamery]

What exactly is the problem with Korean power trains? Can you please elaborate?

[@shane6115]

@@ramgameryhe can’t.

[@Shabnation]

@@shane6115 for one . The pistons rings do not last more then 50k miles without the car burning and wasting through tons of oil , number 2 they have timing chains issues especially with the gv70 number 3 the oil pump assembly’s come damaged from factory because of faulty electronics which causes it to overheat . Number 5 the esc controller the idle / stop tend to fail . Number 6 the brake boosters from factory sometimes come stripped ? How is this possible? Number 7 they have faulty connected rod bearings that seize up the motor , I mean should I keep going or?

[@Shabnation]

@@shane6115 should I list you more issues ?

[@Shabnation]

@@shane6115 maybe I should thank Hyundai for bringing me so much service 🤣 shall I list the problems with the Hyundai ionic too?

[@majideshaqzai766]

German car is best

[@bigdogpete43]

Drove them both. BMW is the king of this market. You can measure all you want, but it outruns, out handles, and outclasses everything else in this class, esp a freaking Hyundai which only puts lipstick on a pig. The B58 engine is a legend. BMW is, and always has been, built for drivers. Genesis is built for riders.

[@bwrecks]

If send my kids to college than use that money servicing a bmw

[@SME5724]

X5 no doubt

[@johnhall3683]

But why would you compare it with a BMW?, instead of a Infiniti, Lexus even the cheesy Cadillac.the BMW really has too much quality and class to be that copycat company! So please stop it!

[@cobra1026]

Genesis GV80 is much better than BMW

[@Lions_Gate]

No, it’s just cheaper…..for a reason.

[@donaldbanner2185]

................................... Both are Un-Dependable and LOSS of money Depreciation 3 years 40 to 50K ...NIGHTMARES